COOK v. BELL

2:26-cv-01188Njd13 févr. 2026

Texte intégral

UNITED 	STATES 	DISTRICT 	COURT
DISTRICT OF NEW JERSEY
ISAIAH 	COOK,
No. 	26-cv-01188 (MEF) (AME)
Plaintiff,
OPINION and ORDER
v.
MICHEAL 	H. 	BELL,
Defendant.
* 	* 	*
The 	Plaintiff 1 	seeks 	to 	bring 	this 	action 	in 	forma 	pauperis, 	so
he 	"must 	establish 	that 	he 	is 	unable 	to 	pay 	the 	costs 	of 	his
suit." 	Walker 	v. 	People 	Exp. 	Airlines, 	Inc., 	886 	F.2d 	598, 	601
(3d 	Cir. 	1989).
The 	Plaintiff 	has 	done 	so.
He 	indicates 	that 	he 	does 	not 	work, 	see 	Application 	to 	Proceed
in 	District 	Court 	Without 	Prepaying 	Fees 	or 	Costs 	(ECF 	1-2) 	at
1-2, 	and 	relies 	exclusively 	on 	periodic 	disability 	payments 	to
cover 	his 	monthly 	expenses. 	See 	id. 	at 	2. 	In 	addition, 	the
Plaintiff 	states 	that 	he 	has 	minimal 	savings, 	see 	id., 	no 	major
assets, 	see 	id. 	at 	3, 	and 	no 	stable 	place 	to 	live. 	See 	id. 	at
5.
The 	Plaintiff's 	application 	to 	proceed 	in 	forma 	pauperis 	is
accordingly 	granted.
Given 	that 	conclusion, 	the 	governing 	statute 	requires 	the 	Court
to 	screen 	the 	Plaintiff's 	complaint 	under 	28 	U.S.C.
§ 	1915 (e) (2) (B).
1 	Isaiah 	Cook.
Case 2:26-cv-01188-MEF-AME Document 3 Filed 02/13/26 Page 1 of 3 PageID:
<pageID>
Among 	other 	things, 	the 	statute 	requires 	a 	district 	court 	to
"dismiss 	the 	case" 	if 	the 	complaint 	"fails 	to 	state 	a 	claim on
which 	relief may be 	granted." 	Id. 	§ 	1915 (e) (2) (B) (ii).
"The 	legal 	standard 	for 	dismissing 	a 	complaint 	for 	failure 	to
state 	a 	claim pursuant 	to 	28 	U.S.C. 	§ 	1915(e) (2) (B) (ii) 	is 	the
same 	as 	that 	for 	dismissing 	a 	complaint 	pursuant 	to 	Federal 	Rule
of 	Civil 	Procedure 	12(b) (6) ." 	Schreane 	v. 	Seana, 	506 	F. 	App'x
120, 	122 	(3d 	Cir. 	2012).
The 	Plaintiff 	appears 	to 	allege 	that 	the 	Defendant 	submitted 	a
false 	claim to 	the 	government 	when 	he 	sought 	"Medicare 	and/or
Medicaid" 	reimbursements, 	engaged 	in 	"healthcare 	fraud," 	and
"falsif[ied] 	medical 	records." 	Complaint 	for 	a 	Civil 	Case
("Complaint") 	(ECF 	1) 	at 	4. 	And 	the 	Plaintiff 	seeks 	damages 	for
"improper 	care, 	ethics 	violations, 	misrepresentations, 	and
negligence/fraud." 	Id. 	at 	5. 2
But 	this 	does 	not 	clear 	the 	plausible-claim bar 	that 	it 	needs
to. 	See 	generally Ashcroft 	v. 	Iqbal, 	556 	U.S. 	662, 	678 	(2009).
The 	complaint 	contains 	no 	sufficient 	factual 	allegations 	from
which 	the 	court 	could 	"draw 	the 	reasonable 	inference 	that 	the
defendant 	is 	liable 	for 	the 	misconduct 	alleged." 	Id. 	(cleaned
up).
Specifically, 	the 	complaint 	does 	not 	provide 	meaningful
information 	as 	to 	any 	of 	the 	who-what-when-where-and-how
questions 	that 	factual 	allegations 	must 	speak 	to. 	What 	claim
was 	submitted 	to 	the 	government? 	What 	made 	it 	false? 	What 	did
the 	medical 	records 	say? 	What 	care 	did 	the 	Plaintiff 	receive?
What 	was 	wrong 	with 	it? 	When 	and 	where 	did 	any 	of 	this 	happen?
Instead, 	the 	Plaintiff 	has 	only 	come 	forward 	with 	"an 	unadorned,
the-defendant-unlawfully-harmed-me 	accusation." 	Id.
That 	is 	not 	enough. 	See 	Devine 	v. 	Pa. 	Dep't 	of 	Corr., 	2025 	WL
3162335, 	at 	*3 	(E.D. 	Pa. 	Nov. 	12, 	2025) 	(dismissing 	complaint
that 	"provid[ed] 	no 	specific 	facts 	at 	all" 	under 	Section
1915(e) (2) (B) (ii)); 	Mickell 	v. 	Police 	Dep't 	of 	Scranton, 	2017 	WL
4532160, 	at 	*4-5 	(M.D. 	Pa. 	Mar. 	10, 	2017), 	report 	and
recommendation 	adopted, 	2017 	WL 	4516748 	(M.D. 	Pa. 	Oct. 	10, 	2017)
(similar); 	Williams 	v. 	Marriott/Hilton-Davidson 	Hosp., 	2026 	WL
212676, 	at 	*1-2 	(E.D. 	Pa. 	Jan. 	27, 	2026) 	(similar); 	Green 	v.
2 	The 	complaint 	invokes 	the 	False 	Claims 	Act, 	see 	31 	U.S.C.
§ 	3729 	et 	seq., 	and 	the 	federal 	question 	statute, 	see 	28 	U.S.C.
§ 	1331, 	as 	the 	basis 	for 	jurisdiction. 	See 	Complaint 	at 	3.
2
Case 2:26-cv-01188-MEF-AME Document 3 Filed 02/13/26 Page 2 of 3 PageID:
<pageID>
Scripps 	Corp. 	Headquarters/Scripps 	Ctr., 	2022 	WL 	179616, 	at 	*2-3
(S.D. 	Ohio 	Jan. 	20, 	2022), 	report 	and 	recommendation 	adopted,
2022 	WL 	615042 	(S.D. 	Ohio 	Mar. 	2, 	2022) 	(similar); 	Ibn-Duriya 	v.
Curry, 	2007 	WL 	1191715, 	at 	*2 	(W.D. 	Ky. 	Apr. 	18, 	2007)
(similar); 	Schmitz 	v. 	Schaffer, 	2013 	WL 	627080, 	at 	*3-4 	(D.
Minn. 	Jan. 	18, 	2013), 	report 	and 	recommendation 	adopted, 	2013 	WL
627118 	(D. 	Minn. 	Feb. 	20, 	2013) 	(similar).
The 	complaint 	is 	dismissed.
It 	is 	on 	this 	13th 	day 	of 	February, 	2026 	SO ORDERED.
/Michael 	E. 	Farbiarz, 	U.S.D.J.
3
Case 2:26-cv-01188-MEF-AME Document 3 Filed 02/13/26 Page 3 of 3 PageID:
<pageID>

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.