IN RE EX PARTE APPLICATION OF TYLOR GROUP LLC FOR AN ORDER UNDER 28 U.S.C. 1782

2:25-cv-16183Njd20 janv. 2026

Texte intégral

Case 2:25-cv-16183-WJM-MAH Document 19 Filed 01/20/26 Page 1 of 5 PageID:
<pageID>
Case 2:25-cv-16183-WJM-MAH Document 19 Filed 01/20/26 Page 2 of 5 PageID:
<pageID>
Case 2:25-cv-16183-WJM-MAH Document 19 Filed 01/20/26 Page 3 of 5 PageID:
<pageID>
Case 2:25-cv-16183-WJM-MAH Document 19 Filed 01/20/26 Page 4 of 5 PageID:
<pageID>
Case 2:25-cv-16183-WJM-MAH Document 19 Filed 01/20/26 Page 5 of 5 PageID:
<pageID>

OCR transcription for search; preserved printed pages are authoritative

Case 2:25-cv-16183-WJM-MAH Document19_ Filed 01/20/26 Page 1 of 5 PagelD:
<pagelD>

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF NEW JERSEY

IN RE EX PARTE APPLICATION OF TYLOR No. 25-cv-16183-WJM-MAH
GROUP LLC FOR AN ORDER UNDER 28
U.S.C. § 1782 OPINION

WILLIAM J. MARTINY, U.S.D.J.:

This matter comes before the Court on Respondent Jonathan Choon Kim’s
(“Respondent”) Motion to Vacate the Court’s Order granting Applicant Tylor Group
LLC’s (““Applicant” or “Tylor Group”) application for discovery pursuant to 28 U.S.C.
§ 1782. ECF No. 13 (“Motion”). The Motion is fully briefed, and the Court decides the
Motion without oral argument. Fed. R. Civ. P. 78(b). As discussed below, the Motion is
DENIED, Applicant’s request for leave to file a sur-reply is GRANTED, and the parties
are ORDERED to meet and confer to narrow the scope the discovery requests.

I BACKGROUND

This dispute arises out of litigation in the Republic of Korea. A decade ago, Respondent
was the co-CEO of Redbadge Pacific, Inc., (“RBP”), and currently, he is Managing Partner
and a member of its Board. ECF No. 16-1 (“Lee Decl.”), 9 11; ECF No. 13-2 (Resp.
Decl.”), 993, 10. Respondent’s former co-CEO is the owner of the Tylor Group, after
having previously left RBP and initiating several legal actions against it via the Tylor
Group and another legal entity, Resp. Decl. (9 11, 14-19; Lee Decl. 9 8. In 2016, RBP
allegedly issued a transfer of a million shares to the Tylor Group, which is now the subject
of a dispute before the Seoul Central District Court (the “Korean Action”), ECF No. 1-4,
at 2; Mot. 6-7; Lee Decl. ¥ 8; Resp. Decl. 9 19. The Tylor Group alleges it is the true owner
of the disputed shares, yet RBP has failed to list it as on its registry of shares. ECF No. 1-
4, at 6-7; Resp. Decl. § 19. Respondent is not a party to the Korean Action. ECF No. 17
(“Reply”), at 1; ECF No, 18 (“Sur-Reply”), at 2.

Ten days after filing the Korean Action, on September 29, 2025, Applicant moved
under 28 U.S.C. § 1782 for an order authorizing it to take discovery from Respondent.
ECF No. 1 (“Application”), The Application seeks two forms of discovery: (1) a
deposition of Respondent, ECF No. 1-5 (Deposition Subpoena”); and (2) production of
various documents relating to the share transfer, ranging from November 18, 2015, to the
present, ECF No. 1-6 (“Document Subpoena”), at 5-6. The Court granted the ex parte
application on October 16, 2025. ECF No. 4. This Motion followed.

Il, LEGAL STANDARD

Section 1782 grants district courts the authority to order discovery “for use in a
proceeding in a foreign or international tribunal.” Intel Corp. vy. Adv. Micro Devices, Inc.,

Case 2:25-cv-16183-WJM-MAH Document19_ Filed 01/20/26 Page 2 of 5 PagelD:
<pagelD>

542 U.S. 241, 246 (2004) (quoting 28 U.S.C. § 1782(a)). The statute has several threshold
requirements: (1) the respondent resides in this district; (2) the applicant seeks either
testimony or the production of a “document or other thing”; (3) the discovery “for use in
proceedings before a foreign or international tribunal”; and (4) the applicant is either the
foreign or international tribunal itself, or an interested party. Jn re O’Keeffe, 646 F. App’x
263, 265 0.4 (3d Cir. 2016) (quoting 28 U.S.C. § 1782). If those requirements are met, the
Court must balance several discretionary factors: (1) whether the respondent is a participant
in the foreign proceeding; (2) the nature of the foreign tribunal, the character of the foreign
proceedings, and the receptivity of the foreign court to federal judicial assistance; (3)
whether the request is an attempt to circumvent foreign proof-gathering restrictions; and
(4) whether the request is unduly intrusive or burdensome. Intel, 542 U.S. at 264-65; SPS
Corp I, Fundo de Investimento em Direitos Creditérios NGo Padronizados v. Gen. Motors
Co., 110 F.4th 586, 592 (3d Cir. 2024),

On a motion to vacate, the Respondent bears the burden of persuasion. Sauren Fonds-
Select SICAV vy. Pramerica Real Estate Investors, No, 16-cv-00133, 2016 WL 630443 8, at
*2 (D.N.J. Oct. 26, 2016); see In re Bayer AG, 146 F.3d 188, 195 Gd Cir, 1998), as
amended (July 23, 1998) (“[D]istrict courts should treat relevant discovery materials
sought pursuant to § 1782 as discoverable unless the party opposing the application can
demonstrate facts sufficient to justify the denial of the application.”). The district court’s
analysis must not be “cursory and conclusory.” In re Biomet Orthopaedics Switzerland
GmBh, 742 PF. App’x 690, 696 (3d Cir, 2018). District courts have jurisdiction under 28
U.S.C. §§ 1331 and 1782, Jd. at 694,

III. DISCUSSION!

As it must, the Court centers its discussion around the disputed Jntel factors because
the statutory requirements are uncontested. ECF No. 16 (“Opposition”), at 5.

A, Factor 1: Jurisdictional Reach

Briefly, Respondent appears to improperly contest the first Jnfe/ factor, the
“jurisdictional reach factor,” for the first time on reply. Reply 7; see In re Alpine Partners
(BYD) L.P., No. 24-cv-00337, 2024 WL 4336824, at *7 (D.N.J. Sept. 27, 2024) (noting that
the Court may disregard arguments initially raised on reply), As a result, Applicant sought
leave to file a sur-reply brief, which the Court GRANTS, Applicant argues that the
Respondent is not a party to the Korean Action and is outside the jurisdiction of Korean
courts, which together satisfy the first factor. Sur-Reply 2; see In re Chevron Corp., 633
F.3d 153, 162 (3d Cir. 2011) (holding that the first Znte? factor favors the applicant when
the respondent is not a party to the foreign action and therefore is not subject to the
jurisdiction of the foreign tribunal). Respondent’s contention that all possible documents
within his possession would also be in the possession of RBP is conclusory and fails to

' Courts differ as to whether motions to vacate § 1782 applications are dispositive.
Republic of Turkey v. Cicek, No. 19-cv-20107, 2020 WL 8073613, at *2 (D.N.J. June 4,
2020). Regardless, this Court elects to handle the Motion in the first instance.

Case 2:25-cv-16183-WJM-MAH Document19_ Filed 01/20/26 Page 3 of 5 PagelD:
<pagelD>

rebut Applicant’s showing that Respondent is outside the jurisdictional reach of Korean
courts, See Reply 7. Therefore, the first Jnte/ factor points in Applicant’s favor?

B. Factor 2: Receptivity

Next, the parties contest the second Intel factor, the “receptivity factor,” which involves
“the nature of the foreign tribunal, the character of the proceedings underway abroad, and
the receptivity of the foreign government or the court or agency abroad to U.S. federal-
court judicial assistance.” Jntel, 542 U.S. at 244; accord Inre O'Keeffe, 646 F. App’x at
266. ‘The movant must “present adequate evidence to support” the foreign court’s hostility
to § 1782 discovery. In re Chevron Corp., 633 F.3d at 162. The Court may “consider any
materials, typically statutes or case law from the foreign jurisdiction, that may be presented
by the parties.” Jn re Bayer AG, 146 F.3d 188, 195 (3d Cir. 1998), as amended (July 23,
1998). The Court focuses on the receptivity of the foreign country to federal judicial
assistance, not admissibility. In re O'Keeffe, 646 F. App’x at 267.

Here, the parties present conflicting declarations as to Korean courts’ receptivity to
§ 1782 discovery. Contrast ECF No. 13-3, at {5-15 (concluding that Korean procedure
requires an application to the Korean court for discovery, noting that litigants customarily
do so, and reasoning that evidence obtained outside of those procedures may be
inadmissible), and ECF No. 17-1, at {4 16 (arguing that a deposition may not be admissible
in Korea), with Lee Decl. 9941-74 (concluding that Korean courts have liberal
admissibility practices and rarely exclude evidence not obtained through application to the
Korean courts). Without delving into Korean law, the Court concludes that Respondent’s
declarations do not provide sufficient proof that Korean courts would reject § 1782
discovery, See In re O’Keeffe, 646 F. App’x 267-68 (discouraging district courts ftom
weighing conflicting interpretations of foreign law and recognizing that the receptivity
factor can be met where granting the discovery request would facilitate litigation in the
foreign tribunal). Indeed, courts across the country have found that Korean courts are
receptive to § 1782 discovery. See, e.g., Amgen, Inc. v. Celltrion USA, Inc., No. 24-cv-
09052, 2024 WL 5182022, at *8 (D.N.J. Dec. 20, 2024), appeal dismissed sub nom. In re
Amgen Inc., 139 F.4th 265 Gd Cir. 2025) (crediting evidence that Korean courts are
receptive to § 1782 discovery); In re Youngpoong Corp., No. 25-mc-00194, 2025 WL
3228034, at *4 (S.D.N.Y. Nov. 19, 2025) (“Respondents have not provided any
authoritative proof that the Seoul Central District Court would reject evidence obtained
with the aid of Section 1782.”); In re NanoPyxis Co., Ltd., No. 17-mc-80151, 2018 WL
1156838, at *3 (N.D. Cal. Mar. 5, 2018) (same and collecting cases), Because Respondent
has failed to mect his burden, the second Jnte/ factor favors Applicant.

* The Court declines to consider whether Respondent’s declarant, Mr. Sang Yun Park, can
properly opine on Korean law. See Sur-Reply 2 (asserting that Mr. Park cannot provide
legal advice in Korea). However, legal advice is different from legal explanation, just as
law professors can teach law without offering legal advice to their students.

Case 2:25-cv-16183-WJM-MAH Document19 Filed 01/20/26 Page 4 of 5 PagelD:
<pagelD>

Cc, Factor 3: Circumvention

While “[cflosely related to the receptivity factor,” SPS Corp. I, 110 F.4th at 593, the
third Jntel factor, the “circumvention factor,” requires examination of the motives behind
the discovery request: “whether the § 1782(a) request conceals an attempt to circumvent
foreign proof-gathering restrictions or other policies of a foreign country or the United
States.” Intel, 542 U.S. at 264-65. Indeed, “a litigant may not willfully circumvent foreign
discovery restrictions.” Kulzer v. Esschem, Inc., 390 F, App’x 88, 92 (3d Cir. 2010). An
adverse ruling by a foreign court, though “not necessarily fatal for § 1782 applicants,” may
demonstrate circumvention. SPS Corp I 110 F Ath at 594,

On the one hand, Applicant has not attempted to pursue Korean discovery procedures.
Mot. 9; see In re Application for Discovery for Use in Foreign Proceeding Pursuant to 28
USC. § 1782, No. 17-cv-04269, 2019 WL 168828, at *11 (D.NJ. Jan. 10, 2019) CTA]
party’s failure to invoke local discovery procedures remains significant, and may be
considered.”); In re Application of Gilead Pharmasset LLC, No, 14-mc-00243, 2015 WL
1903957, at *5 (D. Del. Apr. 14, 2015) (finding circumvention given the applicant’s “lack
of interest in pursuing any discovery under the [foreign] laws”). On the other hand,
Applicant is not required to do so, See Intel, 542 U.S. at 261 (holding that § 1782 does not
require foreign discoverability because “{a] foreign nation may limit discovery within its
domain for reasons peculiar to its own legal practices, culture, or traditions.”), On balance,
the parties’ competing evidence regarding Korean procedure underscores that Applicant’s
tactical decision to proceed first via § 1782 application does not imply circumvention
absent additional evidence that Korean courts would disapprove of Applicant’s choice. See
In re RH2 Participaes Societrias LTDA, No. 23-cv-04025, 2024 WL 3598379, at *7
(D.N.J. July 31, 2024) (declining to infer bad faith where the petitioner did not first try to
utilize the foreign jurisdiction’s procedures), Given that other federal courts have granted
§ 1782 applications where the applicant did not first proceed in Korea, see supra subpart
IN(B), the Court concludes that Respondent has failed to meet his burden as to the
circumvention factor.

D. Factor 4; Unduly Intrusive or Burdensome

Finally, the parties focus most on the fourth Jnte/ factor: whether the request is “unduly
intrusive or burdensome” and therefore should “be rejected or trimmed.” Jntel, 542 U.S.
at 265. The Court’s analysis of the fourth factor is “virtually identical” to the “overly
burdensome” analysis of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. Inre Ex Parte Glob. Energy
Horizons Corp., 647 F. App’x 83, 86 3d Cir. 2016). Discovery must be “reasonably
calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence,” balancing the “undue burden
or expense” to the respondent. Jd. (quoting Fed. R. Civ. P. 26, 45).

As to the Document Subpoena, Respondent correctly complains about its breadth, The
Document Subpoena’s requests “for production of ‘all documents’ or ‘all communications’
of a certain type” over a decade-long period are “not narrowly tailored requests,” even if
they may be “certainly relevant.” See In re Selman, No. 23-cv-00895 , 2024 WL 1092025,
at *9 (D. Del. Mar, 13, 2024) (requiring the parties to reduce the scope of the document

Case 2:25-cv-16183-WJM-MAH Document19_ Filed 01/20/26 Page 5 of 5 PagelD:
<pagelD>

requests). Indeed, Applicant concedes that “the same breadth of discovery is not available
in Korean proceedings,” Opp’n 12, militating against the fourth Jnte/ factor.

Additionally, the Court is troubled by the potential that Respondent may use the
Document Subpoena as a fishing expedition, either for the Korean Action or other pending
litigations involving RBP. While the parties may move for a protective order, Fed. R. Civ.
P, 26(c), the existence of other actions further supports Respondent’s concern that
Applicant may inappropriately use the expansive discovery it seeks here for other
litigations. See In re Watkins, No. 24-mc-00023, 2024 WL 4264900, at *12 (S.D.N.Y. July
26, 2024), report and recommendation adopted sub nom. Watkins v. Ellesse LIC, No. 24-
MC-23, 2024 WL 4582755 (S.D.N.Y. Oct, 25, 2024) (permitting a § 1782 application to
proceed contingent on the entry of a protective order preventing discovery from being used
in other litigations).

Similarly, as to the Deposition Subpoena, the Court must weigh the burden imposed on
Respondent, a senior executive of RBP, and the routine nature of a deposition. Contrast
In re Alpine Partners (BVI) L.P., No. 24-cv-00337, 2024 WL 4336824, at *7 (D.N.J. Sept.
27, 2024) (noting that sitting for a deposition where the respondent resides does not present
“any undue burden, cost, or expense”), with LAE Techs, Hong Kong Ltd. v. Demuren, No.
23-cv-02314, 2024 WL 863464, at *7 (D.N.J, Feb, 29, 2024) (referencing apex doctrine
and denying a deposition request levied against a senior executive who was not shown to
have unique personal knowledge). Here, Applicant has shown that Respondent, the co-
CEO during the relevant timeframe, possesses personal knowledge, and he remains
involved with RBP. While depositions are routine under the Federal Rules of Civil
Procedure, Opp’n 19, Respondent’s deposition may not be essential to Applicant’s case in
the Korean Action.

Accordingly, at this juncture, the Court declines to determine the appropriate scope of
discovery from Respondent. The Court simply concludes that the fourth Jnte/ factor has
been met as to both subpoenas.

IV. CONCLUSION

Because the first three Jnte/ factors counsel in favor of allowing some form of § 1782
discovery from Respondent, the Court DENIES the Motion. However, because
Respondent has satisfied his burden as to the fourth Jnfe/ factor, the Court ORDERS the
parties to meet and confer and attempt to natrow the scope of the two subpoenas to
encompass only information relevant to and likely to be admissible in the Korean Action.
see In re Selman, 2024 WL 1092025, at *9 (directing the parties to meet and confer).
Additionally, the Court GRANTS Applicant’s request for leave to file a sur-reply brief.
An appropriate order follows.

DATE: J anuary®, 2026

J. MARTINI, U.S.D.J.

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.