USA v. MCIVER

2:25-cr-00388Njd13 nov. 2025

Texte intégral

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
DISTRICT OF NEW JERSEY
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
Plaintiff,
v.
LAMONICA MCIVER,
Defendant.
Crim. No. 25-388
OPINION
November 13, 2025
SEMPER, District Judge.
THIS MATTER comes before the Court on Defendant LaMonica McIver’s (“Defendant”)
motions to dismiss the indictment against her for legislative immunity under the Speech or Debate
Clause (ECF 19) and for selective enforcement and prosecution, as well as vindictive prosecution.
(ECF 20.) Defendant’s latter motion includes a discovery request for its selective enforcement,
selective prosecution, and vindictive prosecution claims if the Court concludes that dismissal is
not yet warranted. (Id. at 28.) The Court held oral argument on October 21, 2025. (ECF 37.) For
the reasons stated below, Defendant’s motion for selective enforcement and vindictive prosecution
(ECF 20) is DENIED, Defendant’s motion for legislative immunity (ECF 19) on Counts One and
Three is DENIED, and the Court will reserve ruling on Count Two of the indictment.
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 1 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
2
I. 	FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND1
Defendant represents New Jersey’s 10 th Congressional District in the United States House
of Representatives, where she serves on the Committee on Homeland Security.2 	Since joining
Congress in 2024, Defendant has focused on executive immigration action in New Jersey.3 On
May 9, 2025, Defendant and two House Representatives more senior to her (“Representative-1”
and 	“Representative-2”; 	collectively, 	the 	“Representatives”) 	conducted 	an 	unannounced
congressional oversight inspection of Delaney Hall, a Newark, New Jersey immigration detention
facility 	under 	the 	authority 	of 	the 	Department 	of 	Homeland 	Security 	(“DHS”). 	The
Representatives 	and 	Defendant 	were 	statutorily 	permitted 	to 	conduct 	the 	unannounced
congressional oversight visit at Delaney Hall, pursuant to the Further Consolidated Appropriations
1 The facts and procedural history are drawn from the indictment (ECF 12, “Ind.”), Defendant’s
briefs in support of her motions to dismiss (ECF 19-1, “Mot. I”; ECF 20-1, “Mot. II”), the
Government’s brief in opposition (ECF 27, “Opp.”), Defendant’s reply briefs (ECF 30, “Reply I”;
ECF 32, “Reply II”), as well as the exhibits attached to the respective parties’ papers, including
video surveillance of the subject incident. (ECF 19-3—19-12, “Def. Ex. A” – “Def. Ex. J”.)
2 House Rules state that members of the Committee on Homeland Security “shall review and study
on a primary and continuing basis all Government activities, programs and organizations related
to homeland security that fall within its primary legislative jurisdiction”— including “homeland
security policy” and “administration.” Rules of the House of Representatives, 119th Cong. Rule
X, cl. 1(j), 3(g)(2) (2025).
3 In February 2025, Defendant conducted an inspection visit of an Immigration and Customs
Enforcement (“ICE”) detention center in Elizabeth, New Jersey with Representative-1 and
Representative-2. 	(Mot. I at 6.) 	She met with ICE officials in Newark on March 28, 2025 to
discuss oversight of the facilities. (Id.) Defendant has also written letters to DHS Secretary Kristi
Noem to express concern over ICE’s operation in New Jersey including its treatment of detainees
in private detention centers. (Id.)
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 2 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
3
Act (“FCAA”).4 See Pub. L. No. 118-47, 138 Stat. 360 (1994).5 Upon arriving at Delaney Hall,
Defendant and the Representatives entered through the front security gate (“Security Gate”) and
were directed to the administrative office, where they waited for over an hour to conduct their
inspection. (Def. Ex. B, 00:00:06-1:05:15.) As Defendant and the Representatives waited in the
administrative office, a guard opened the Security Gate and allowed the Mayor of Newark
(“Mayor”) and his security detail to enter the secure premises of Delaney Hall. (Def. Ex. E, 00:28.)
Approximately forty protestors, spectators, and media members amassed outside the
Security Gate a few feet from where the Mayor and his security detail stood waiting for Defendant
and the Representatives. (Ind., Count 1¶ 6; Def. Ex. E, 00:29-00:40.) As the Mayor stood within
the secured area, DHS officials and Immigration and Customs Enforcement (“ICE”) agents,
including the Special Agent in Charge in New Jersey (“V-1”),6 arrived at Delaney Hall. (Opp. at
2.) V-1 and approximately fifteen ICE and DHS officials approached the Mayor and his security
detail on foot. (Def. Ex. F, 02:33.) V-1 advised the Mayor he was not authorized on the premises
and that he would be arrested if he did not leave. (Id., 3:50-4:05.)
4 The Government concedes that Defendant and the Representatives had statutory authority to
access Delaney Hall and “conduct an unscheduled inspection tour of the facility in conjunction
with [their] Congressional oversight responsibilities.” 	(Opp. at 1) (see also id. at 18, 57)
(Transcript, “Tr.” at 9:18-20) (“THE COURT: . . . as far as I can tell from the government’s brief
this defendant had a statutory right to be there. [GOVERNMENT]: Correct, Judge.”).
5 Section 527 of the FCAA specifically prohibits DHS from using funds “to prevent” a Member
of Congress or their designated employee “from entering, for the purpose of conducting oversight,
any facility operated by or for the Department of Homeland Security used to detain or otherwise
house aliens, or to make any temporary modification at any such facility that in any way alters
what is observed by a visiting Member of Congress[.]” 138 Stat. 360 § 527(a). The FCAA also
states that Members of Congress are not required “to provide prior notice of intent to enter a facility
described in subsection (a) for the purpose of conducting oversight.” Id. § 527(b).
6 As identified in Indictment Crim. No. 25-388. (See generally Ind.)
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 3 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
4
As this conversation ensued, Defendant and the Representatives exited the administrative
office and walked approximately 100 feet toward the Security Gate to join the discussion between
the Mayor and V-1. 	(Def. Ex. B, 1:08:15; Def. Ex. F, 04:33.) 	V-1 informed the group that
“members of Congress had lawful authority to be in the secured area of Delaney Hall, but that [the
Mayor] did not.” (Ind., Count 1 ¶ 9; Def. Ex. G, 3:00-3:15.) Defendant and the Representatives
advised V-1 that they had been waiting for over an hour to exercise their congressional oversight,
and that they believed DHS officials had delayed their inspection. 	(Def. Ex. F, 4:49-5:55.)
Moments later, V-1 asked the Mayor to put his hands behind his back to which Defendant stated,
“You’re not arresting him. . . hell no . . . hell no.”7 (Def. Ex. G, 3:07-3:35; Def. Ex. F, 7:22-8:28;
Ind., Count 1 ¶ 10.) The Mayor and his detail were directed outside the Security Gate and remained
in the public parking lot among the protestors, while Defendant and Representative-2 walked
toward the administrative office with several DHS agents. (Id. ¶ 11; Def. Ex. F, 8:35-9:30.) While
still at the Security Gate, Representative-1 told the Mayor that “we will be your eyes and your
ears.” (Def. Ex. F, 9:20-9:25.)
Moments later, V-1 gathered a group of DHS agents near the Security Gate, informed them
that the Deputy Attorney General had authorized the Mayor’s arrest, and instructed the agents to
switch on their body worn cameras. (Def. Ex. B, 1:17:05-1:17:30; Opp. at 3.) As V-1 and DHS
agents exited the secured premises through the Security Gate, Defendant and the Representatives
reversed their course from the administrative office back toward the unsecured public parking lot
where the Mayor stood among the protestors, walked alongside V-1, and immediately approached
the Mayor and his security detail. (Def. Ex. B, 1:17:52; Def. Ex. A, 1:26:36-1:27:03.) After an
7 During this discussion, some of the nearby amassed protestors were yelling expletives at V-1,
including one person who said, “you let him in you piece of s--t.” (Def. Ex. G, 3:05-3:15.)
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 4 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
5
unidentified male in the crowd yelled out, “circle the Mayor,” the Defendant, the Representatives,
and some protestors encircled the Mayor as V-1 and the agents pushed their way through the crowd
to apprehend the Mayor. (Def. Ex. I, 00:46-00:50; Def. Ex. A, 1:26:56-1:27:02.) Defendant placed
herself between V-1 and the Mayor, and as V-1 attempted to effectuate the Mayor’s arrest,
Defendant told the surrounding agents, “you’re touching a federal official,” and repeatedly stated
“don’t touch us.” 	(Def. Ex. I, 0:59-1:30.) 	As V-1 was attempting the arrest, Representative-1
briefly stood near the Mayor’s right shoulder, and Defendant wedged herself between V-1 and the
Mayor’s left shoulder. (Id., 1:12-1:21.) During this exchange, Defendant and V-1 had physical
contact that is the basis for Counts One and Three. The Government alleges Defendant faced the
Mayor and “placed her arms around him in an effort to prevent HSI from completing the arrest[,]”
and that during “her attempt to thwart the arrest” she “slammed her forearm into the body” of V-
1. (Ind., Count 1 ¶¶ 12, 13.) The indictment further alleges that Defendant “reached out and tried
to restrain V-1 by forcibly grabbing him.” (Id. ¶ 13.) Defendant alleges that V-1 and the agents
engaged in “disproportionate” escalation which created “chaos and a serious scuffle involving a
great deal of physical contact.” (Mot. II at 11.)
Following the brief physical contact with Defendant, V-1 handcuffed the Mayor and led
him toward the Security Gate through the compressed group of protestors who had surrounded
him moments earlier. 	(Def. Ex. A, 01:28:03.) 	The situation became dynamic as DHS agents
forced their way to the Security Gate by pushing away hostile protestors.8 	During the scuffle,
Representative-2 told agents, “You cannot push me,” while walking back toward the Security Gate
with Defendant. 	(Def. Ex. I, 1:45-1:54.) 	As this occurred, two DHS agents surrounded
8 Protestors in the public parking lot were captured on body worn camera referring to DHS agents
“F-----g Nazis,” “Fascists,” and “New Jersey’s Gestapo” following the Mayor’s arrest. (Def. Ex.
I, 3:02-3:15; Def. Ex. H, 2:20-2:39.)
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 5 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
6
Representaitve-1 to shield her from the shoving of the crowd. (Def. Ex. A, 1:28:03-1:28:41.) After
V-1 brought the handcuffed Mayor through the Security Gate into the secured area outside the
facility, Defendant and Representative-2 attempted to reenter the Security Gate. 	(Def. Ex. A,
1:28:05-1:28:25.) 	Several protestors pushed agents who surrounded the Security Gate. 	(Id.,
1:28:08-1:28:18.) 	The Government alleges that Defendant “pushed past” an ICE Deportation
Officer (“V-2”)9 “as she returned inside the secured area of Delaney Hall.” (Ind., Count 2 ¶ 3.)
Surveillance video shows that as Defendant and Representative-2 tried to reenter the facility
through the Security Gate, V-2 blocked Defendant from entering by forcibly pushing her back into
the public parking lot, and Defendant responded by pushing V-2 in return. 	(Id., 1:28:08-21.)
Defendant was only able to reenter the facility when Representative-2 wrapped his arms around
her and pulled her through the Security Gate. (Id., 1:28:15-24.) Defendant and the Representatives
were subsequently allowed to conduct their congressional oversight inspection of Delaney Hall
later that day.10 (Mot. I at 11.) The Mayor was charged with trespassing in violation of 18 U.S.C.
§ 13 and N.J. Stat. Ann. § 2C:18-3. (Opp. at 4.) On May 21, 2025, the U.S. Attorney’s Office
dropped the charges against the Mayor. (Id.)
On May 19, 2025, a federal Complaint charged Defendant with three counts of assaulting,
resisting, impeding, and interfering with a federal officer, in violation 18 U.S.C. § 111(a)(1). (See
ECF 1.) On June 10, 2025, a federal grand jury returned an indictment charging Defendant with
the same. (See Ind.) On August 15, 2025, Defendant filed two motions to dismiss the indictment,
9 As identified in Count Two of the indictment. (Ind., Count 2 ¶ 3.)
10 During oral argument on October 21, 2025, the Defense asserted it had not yet received and
reviewed all the surveillance video depicting Defendant’s oversight inspection following the
alleged criminal conduct. (Tr. at 20:1-14.) 	The factual record of the oversight inspection is
incomplete.
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 6 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
7
for legislative immunity under the Speech or Debate Clause (see Mot. I) and for selective
enforcement, selective prosecution, and vindictive prosecution. (See Mot II.) On September 15,
2025, the Government filed a consolidated opposition. 	(See Opp.) 	On September 25, 2025,
Defendants filed two reply briefs, addressing each motion to dismiss respectively. (See Reply I;
Reply II.) The Court held oral argument on October 21, 2025. (See ECF 37.)
II. 	LEGISLATIVE IMMUNITY
Defendant asks this Court to dismiss the indictment against her because all counts require
the presentation of evidence that is protected by the Speech or Debate Clause.11 (Mot. I at 11.)
Defendant first argues that her oversight visit to Delaney Hall was a manifestly legislative act
because she “unquestionably had congressional authority” to inspect the facility. 	(Id. at 16.)
Defendant then argues that even if this Court were to conclude that her activities at Delaney Hall
were ambiguously legislative, the content, form, and purpose of her visit confirm that “her
predominant purpose was legislative.” (Id. at 14.) She argues that “the indictment’s charges are
inextricably connected” to her legislative acts and must be dismissed. (Id. at n.8.)
The Government maintains that the non-legislative act of interfering and impeding with
the arrest of the Mayor does not entitle Defendant to Speech or Debate immunity. (Opp. at 57.)
The Government concedes that Defendant’s inspection of Delaney Hall was “a legislative act” and
that “‘as a general matter, legislative fact-finding is entitled to the protection of legislative
immunity,’ to include informal trips in pursuit of that goal.” (Id.) (quoting United States v. James,
888 F.2d 42, 47 n.6 (3d Cir. 2018)). But, the Government argues, “the legislative activities that
11 The Court’s decision regarding Defendant’s immunity under the Speech Clause is subject to
immediate appeal under the collateral order doctrine. See Helstoski v. Meanor, 442 U.S. 500, 506–
08 (1979). 	See also United States v. McDade, 28 F.3d 283, 288 (3d Cir. 1994) (“[W]e have
jurisdiction to entertain the defendant’s claim that the Speech or Debate Clause requires dismissal
of the entire indictment or particular charges contained in the indictment.”).
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 7 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
8
brought her to Delaney Hall to inspect the facility, although protected,” are “separate and distinct
from the conduct [that] gave rise to the charges in the indictment.” (Id.)
A. Speech or Debate Clause
The Speech or Debate Clause provides that “for any Speech or Debate in either House”
Members of Congress “shall not be questioned in any other place.” U.S. Const. art. I, § 6, cl. 1.12
The Supreme Court has repeatedly recognized that the purpose of the Speech or Debate Clause is
to “prevent intimidation by the executive and accountability before a possibly hostile judiciary.”
United States v. Johnson, 383 U.S. 169, 181 (1966); see also Eastland v. U.S. Servicemen’s Fund,
421 U.S. 491, 502 (1975) (“The purpose of the Clause is to insure that the legislative function the
Constitution allocates to Congress may be performed independently.”); United States v. Helstoski,
442 U.S. 477, 491 (1979) (“This Court has reiterated the central importance of the Clause for
preventing intrusion by Executive and Judiciary into the legislative sphere.”). In Johnson, the
Supreme Court wrote:
There is little doubt that the instigation of criminal charges against critical or
disfavored legislators by the executive in a judicial forum was the chief fear
prompting the long struggle for parliamentary privilege in England and, in the
context of the American system of separation of powers, is the predominate thrust
of the Speech or Debate Clause.
12 Article 1, Section 6, Clause 1 of the Constitution reads that Senators and Representatives:
shall in all Cases, except Treason, Felony and Breach of the Peace, be privileged
from Arrest during their Attendance at the Session of their respective Houses, and
in going to and returning from the same; and for any Speech or Debate in either
House, they shall not be questioned in any other Place.
U.S. Const. art. I, § 6, cl. 1.
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 8 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
9
383 U.S. at 182.13 But the Clause was “not written into the Constitution simply for the personal
or private benefit of Members of Congress, but to protect the integrity of the legislative process by
insuring the independence of individual legislators.” United States v. Brewster, 408 U.S. 501, 507
(1972); see also Tenney v. Brandhove, 341 U.S. 367, 377 (1951) (“Legislators are immune from
deterrents to the uninhibited discharge of their legislative duty, not for their private indulgence but
for the public good”). Indeed, the Speech or Debate Clause was not intended “to make Members
of Congress super-citizens, immune from criminal responsibility.” Brewster, 408 U.S. at 516.
Supreme Court jurisprudence instructs that the Clause must be read “broadly” to guarantee
Members of Congress immunity from criminal or civil liability based on their legislative acts,
Gravel v. United States, 408 U.S. 606, 615 (1972), and to create a privilege against the use of
“evidence of a legislative act” in a prosecution or before a grand jury. Helstoski, 442 U.S. at 487.
Because the privilege “was designed to preserve legislative independence, not supremacy,”
invocations of it that go “beyond what is needed to protect legislative independence” must be
“closely scrutinized.” Hutchinson v. Proxmire, 443 U.S. 111, 126–27 (1979).
To that end, the Speech or Debate Clause “prohibits inquiry only into those things generally
said or done in the House or the Senate in the performance of official duties and into the motivation
13 The Supreme Court reaffirmed that the Clause’s “purpose was to preserve the constitutional
structure of separate, coequal, and independent branches of government” a decade after Johnson.
United States v. Helstoski, 442 U.S. 477, 491 (1979). There, the Supreme Court similarly wrote:
The English and American history of the privilege suggests that any lesser standard
would risk intrusion by the Executive and the Judiciary into the sphere of protected
legislative activities. The importance of the principle was recognized as early as
1808 in Coffin v. Coffin, 4 Mass. 1, 27, where the court said that the purpose of the
principle was to secure to every member “exemption from prosecution, for every
thing said or done by him, as a representative, in the exercise of the functions of
that office.”
Id.
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 9 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
10
for those acts.” 	Brewster, 408 U.S. at 512. 	However, the “Speech or Debate Clause does not
immunize every official act performed by a member of Congress.” McDade, 28 F.3d at 295; see
also Brewster, 408 U.S. at 515 (“In no case has this Court ever treated the Clause as protecting all
conduct relating to the legislative process.”). Rather, it protects only acts that are “an integral part
of the deliberative and communicative processes by which Members participate in committee and
House proceedings with respect to the consideration and passage or rejection of proposed
legislation or with respect to other matters which the Constitution places within the jurisdiction of
either House.” Gravel, 408 U.S. at 625.
The privilege applies to legislative conduct beyond the House or Senate floor. 	See
Hutchinson, 443 U.S. at 127 (“[T]he courts have extended the privilege to matters beyond pure
speech or debate in either House, but ‘only when necessary to prevent indirect impairment of such
deliberations.’”) (quoting Gravel, 408 U.S. at 625). But it does not extend to “political activities”
like constituent services and efforts to win reelection. Youngblood v. DeWeese, 352 F.3d 836, 840
(3d Cir. 2003), as amended (Feb. 11, 2004). 	The Supreme Court has distinguished protected
legislative activity from the “entirely legitimate activities” of Members of Congress that the
Speech or Debate Clause does not protect, which include “a wide range of legitimate ‘errands’
performed for constituents, the making of appointments with Government agencies, assistance in
securing Government contracts, preparing so-called ‘news letters’ to constituents, news releases,
and speeches delivered outside the Congress.”14 	Brewster, 408 U.S. at 512. 	These acts “are
political in nature rather than legislative,” and thus do not enjoy Speech or Debate protection. Id.
14 “The range of these related activities has grown over the years. They are performed in part
because they have come to be expected by constituents, and because they are a means of
developing continuing support for future elections.” Brewster, 408 U.S. at 512.
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 10 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
11
B. Legal Standard
In practice, the Speech or Debate privilege affords protection from indictment only for
“legislative activities.” 	Id. 	Any “references to past legislative acts of a Member cannot be
admitted without undermining the values protected by the Clause.” Helstoski, 442 U.S. at 487-88
(“Indeed, the Speech or Debate Clause was designed to preclude prosecution of Members for
legislative acts.”). 	The Supreme Court has left “no doubt that evidence of a legislative act of a
Member may not be introduced by the Government in a prosecution”—indeed, the Government’s
evidence may not even “mention [] a legislative act.” Id. at 487, 490. But a prosecution that “does
not draw in question the legislative acts of the defendant member of Congress or his motives for
performing them” does not offend the Speech or Debate Clause. Brewster, 408 U.S. at 510, 512
(“[A] Member of Congress may be prosecuted under a criminal statute provided that the
Government’s case does not rely on legislative acts or the motivation for legislative acts.”)
The Third Circuit in United States v. Menendez, 831 F.3d 155 (3d Cir. 2016) laid out a
two-step framework for identifying legislative acts that are protected by the Speech or Debate
Clause, which it reaffirmed two years later in United States v. James, 888 F.3d 42 (3d Cir. 2018).
First, courts must “look to the form of the act to determine whether it is inherently legislative or
non-legislative. Some acts are ‘so clearly legislative in nature that no further examination has to
be made to determine their appropriate status.’” Menendez, 831 F.3d at 166 (quoting Gov’t of V.I.
v. Lee, 775 F.2d 514, 522 (3d Cir. 1985)). 	“Examples of ‘manifestly legislative acts’ include
introducing and voting on proposed resolutions and legislation, introducing evidence and
interrogating witnesses during committee hearings, subpoenaing records for committee hearings,
inserting material into the Congressional Record, and delivering a speech in Congress.” Id. The
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 11 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
12
legislator’s intent or motive is irrelevant to this analysis. See id. (“‘[A]n unworthy purpose’ does
not eliminate Speech or Debate protection.”) (quoting Johnson, 383 U.S. at 749).
Some acts are “so clearly non-legislative that no inquiry into their content or underlying
motivation or purpose is needed to classify them.” Menendez, 831 F.3d at 166. Examples include
the type of “legitimate constituent services” identified by the Supreme Court in Brewster, such as
securing Government contracts, preparing newsletters for constituents, delivering speeches outside
Congress, in addition to “illegitimate activities such as accepting bribes in exchange for taking
official action.” Id.; see also Brewster, 408 U.S. at 512, 526. “Even if these non-legislative acts
involve policy or relate to protected legislative activity, they are not protected.” Menendez, 831
F.3d at 166.
If an act is neither manifestly legislative nor clearly non-legislative, then it is “ambiguously
legislative,” and the court must proceed to the second step of the Speech or Debate analysis.
Id. “Ambiguously legislative acts—including trips by legislators and informal contacts with the
Executive Branch—will be protected or unprotected based on their particular circumstances.” Id.
The second step requires the court to “consider the content, purpose, and motive of the act to assess
its legislative or non-legislative character.” Id. (citing Lee, 775 F.2d at 522-24). Acts where the
legislator’s “primary purpose” is “to gather information in support of future legislation or to
engage in policy-based oversight” are protected by the Speech or Debate privilege. Id. at 173.
Indeed, the Speech or Debate Clause provides legislators with immunity when they are
engaging in “fact-finding, information gathering, and investigative activities[.]” Lee, 775 F.2d at
521. 	The Third Circuit explained this is because “fact-finding occupies a position of sufficient
importance in the legislative process to justify the protection afforded by legislative immunity.”
Id. 	Speech or Debate Clause immunity also applies when legislators are engaging in true
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 12 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
13
legislative oversight. McDade, 28 F.3d at 302 (Scirica, J., concurring). But “claims of ‘oversight’
do not automatically result in Speech or Debate protection.”15 Menendez, 831 F.3d at 168. “Like
all acts by Members, oversight activities exist along a spectrum: the Speech or Debate protection
is obvious at the edges where they are manifestly legislative or clearly non-legislative, but it is not
obvious in the middle ground where they are ambiguously legislative and consideration of their
content, purpose, and motive is necessary.” Id.
“[I]nformal efforts to influence the Executive Branch are ambiguously legislative in
nature” and similarly require examination of their content, purpose, and motive. 	Id. (quoting
Gravel, 408 U.S. at 625.) 	In general, efforts by legislators to “cajole” and “exhort” Executive
Branch officials “with respect to the administration of a federal statute” are not protected by the
Speech or Debate Clause. Gravel, 408 U.S. at 625. This includes “efforts to intervene in decisions
pending before the Executive Branch that would mainly affect one particular party.” Id. (citing
McDade, 28 F.3d at 300). 	However, informal attempts to influence the Executive Branch “on
policy, for actual legislative purposes, may qualify as true legislative oversight and merit Speech
or Debate immunity.” Id. (quoting McDade, 28 F.3d at 304 (Scirica, J., concurring)).
On a motion to dismiss an indictment under the Speech or Debate Clause, the district court
must examine the indictment to determine whether its charges are predicated upon evidence of
legislative acts. United States v. Menendez, 132 F. Supp. 3d 610, 620-621 (D.N.J. 2015), aff’d,
831 F.3d 155 (3d Cir. 2016); see also Brewster, 408 U.S. at 525 (examining the face of the
indictment to determine whether “inquiry into legislative acts or motivation for legislative acts is
15 Oversight activity like participation in committee hearings is “clearly protected” by the Speech
or Debate Clause. McDade, 28 F.3d at 300 (majority opinion) (citing Eastland, 421 U.S. at 504–
06). Activities on the other end of the spectrum, “such as routine casework for constituents, are
just as clearly not protected.” Id. The McDade court determined “whether the Speech or Debate
Clause shields forms of ‘oversight’ falling between these extremes . . . is less clear.” Id.
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 13 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
14
necessary for the Government to make out a prima facie case”). The court must analyze the record
evidence before it to make this determination. See Menendez, 132 F. Supp. at 620. If a charge
cannot be proven without evidence of a legislative act, it must be dismissed. 	Id. at 621. 	If,
however, a charge can be proven without evidence of a legislative act, the charge survives and trial
must be “wholly purged of elements offensive to the Speech or Debate Clause.” 	Johnson, 383
U.S. at 185. A party asserting the legislative privilege, as Defendant does here, bears the burden
of establishing the applicability of legislative immunity by a preponderance of the evidence. See
Lee, 775 F.2d at 524.
C. Discussion
To assess the legislative nature of the challenged acts, the Court must examine the record
evidence before it. 	See In re Grand Jury Investigation, 608 F. App’x 99, 101 (3d Cir. 2015)
(requiring district court to conduct a “careful analysis of the record evidence . . . to decide whether
the evidence shows that it was a legislative act.”). The record evidence before the Court includes
video of the incident attached to Defendant’s motion to dismiss in the form of surveillance and
body worn camera footage. 	(See Def. Exs. A-J.) 	Consistent with the Third Circuit’s two-step
approach to the Speech or Debate Clause, the Court must first determine whether Defendant’s acts
were “manifestly legislative” or “so clearly non-legislative that no inquiry into their content or
underlying motivation or purpose is needed to classify them.” Menendez, 831 F.3d at 166. The
Court finds that Defendant’s conduct as alleged in the indictment is neither; rather it is
ambiguously legislative, requiring the Court to consider its content, purpose and motive to assess
the legislative nature of the acts at issue. See id. at 168.
Ambiguously legislative acts include “trips by legislators” and “informal contacts with the
Executive 	Branch” 	which 	“will 	be 	protected 	or 	unprotected 	based 	on 	their 	particular
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 14 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
15
circumstances.” Id. at 166. As the Government concedes, Defendant’s inspection of Delaney Hall
was a legislative act,16 and “as a general matter, legislative fact-finding is entitled to the protection
of legislative immunity[.]”17 Lee, 775 F.2d at 517. The alleged criminal conduct did not occur
during Defendant’s inspection of Delany Hall, instead it occurred during an inexplicable delay of
Defendant’s oversight inspection. 	Although Defendant bears no fault in the delay, her alleged
intervention into the Mayor’s questionable arrest had no cognizable connection to any legislative
function protected by the Speech or Debate Clause. Defendant briefly left the facility she came to
inspect to engage in the alleged conduct that was not in furtherance of congressional “fact-finding”
or “information gathering” as set forth in Lee. 775 F.2d at 521. Defendant’s active participation
in the alleged conduct removes her acts from the safe harbor of mere oversight. 	Lawfully or
unlawfully, Defendant actively engaged in conduct unrelated to her oversight responsibilities and
congressional duties. 	Accordingly, Defendant’s argument that her “inspection of Delaney Hall
was manifestly legislative” is misleading and does not account for Defendant’s conduct before the
inspection commenced. (Mot. I at 16) (emphasis added). The Government has charged Defendant
for conduct that took place during a brief time frame before the oversight inspection began, not on
16 See Opp. at 57 (“As a preliminary matter, the Government does not take issue with McIver’s
characterization of the inspection of Delaney Hall with her fellow Members as a ‘legislative act.’”).
Moreover, Defendant was statutorily authorized to enter and inspect the facility to conduct
oversight. See 138 Stat. 360 § 527.
17 “The power to investigate and to do so through compulsory process plainly falls within the
sphere of legitimate legislative activity.” Lee, 775 F.2d at 521. In Eastland, the Supreme Court
wrote that “this Court has often noted that the power to investigate is inherent in the power to make
laws because a legislative body cannot legislate wisely or effectively in the absence of information
respecting the conditions which the legislation is intended to affect or change” and that “[t]o
conclude that the power of inquiry is other than an integral part of the legislative process would be
a miserly reading of the Speech or Debate Clause in derogation of the integrity of the legislative
process.” 421 U.S. at 504-05 (cleaned up).
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 15 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
16
the facility’s premises but in the public parking lot outside the Security Gate. The Court cannot
find that the charged conduct was manifestly legislative.18
Defendant further contends that her exercise of congressional authority “comfortably
shows that her presence at Delaney Hall was ‘manifestly legislative activity.’” 	(Mot. I at 17)
(emphasis added). 	The case law does not support Defendant’s broad interpretation. 	The Third
Circuit’s holding in Lee is instructive, where the court declined to find that the entirety of a
legislator’s fact-finding trip was protected by the Speech or Debate Clause. See 775 F.2d at 522.
There, a legislator from the Virgin Islands argued that the conversations and meetings that took
place during a trip he took to New York and Washington, D.C. were entitled to immunity because
the purpose of his trip was for legislative fact-finding.19 See id. The Court disagreed. In rejecting
his argument as too broad, it found that for “conversations to trigger the protection of legislative
immunity, they must have involved legislative fact-finding.” 	Id. 	The Court wrote that “it is
Senator Lee’s purpose or motive that will determine in part whether the trip was a legislative act
18 Cases where legislative immunity has been triggered for “manifestly legislative acts” involve
activity “so clearly legislative in nature that no further examination had to be made to determine
their appropriate status.” Lee, 775 F.2d at 522. “While such manifestly legislative acts may have
been pursued and accomplished for illegitimate purposes, such as personal gain, the acts
themselves were obviously legislative in nature.” 	Id.; see, e.g., Helstoski, 442 U.S. 477
(introducing proposed legislation); Eastland, 421 U.S. 491 (subpoenaing records for committee
hearing); Doe v. McMillan, 412 U.S. 306 (1973) (inserting material in the Congressional Record);
Gravel, 408 U.S. 606 (introducing evidence during committee hearings); Johnson, 383 U.S. 169
(1966) (delivering a speech on the floor of the House); Tenney v. Brandhove, 341 U.S. 367 (1951)
(interrogating witnesses during committee hearings); Kilbourn v. Thompson, 103 U.S. 168 (1881)
(voting on resolutions).
19 The defendant in Lee had received approval from the President of the Virgin Islands legislature
for a legislative fact-finding trip to New York and Washington, D.C. to conduct meetings and
discuss such official legislative business as consumer affairs, interior matters and issues involving
transportation. See 775 F.2d at 517. An investigation by law enforcement later revealed that many
of the meetings with government officials he claimed took place did not in fact happen. See id.
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 16 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
17
at all” and ordered the district court to examine “which acts were proper legislative acts and which
were personal and non-legislative acts.” Id. at 522, 524.
The Court must proceed to the second step of Menendez,20 where it will consider the
predominant purpose of Defendant’s actions to determine if any of her acts “qualify as ‘true
legislative oversight’ and merit Speech or Debate immunity.” 831 F.3d at 169 (quoting McDade,
28 F.2d at 304) (Scirica, J., concurring).
1. 	Counts One and Three
Count One of the indictment alleges that when ICE agents were attempting to handcuff the
Mayor, Defendant “placed her arms around him in an effort to prevent HSI from completing the
arrest” and that during that attempt to prevent his arrest, Defendant “slammed her forearm into the
body of V-1” and “reached out and tried to restrain V-1 by forcibly grabbing him.” (Ind., Count
1 ¶¶ 12, 13.) The indictment further alleges that though Defendant “initially remained inside the
secured area of Delaney Hall[,]” once DHS agents escorted the Mayor to the unsecured area
outside the Security Gate and attempted to effectuate his arrest, Defendant “hurried outside
towards the agents and attempted to thwart” the arrest. (Id. ¶¶ 11, 12.) The Court must evaluate
the predominant purpose of these actions, and it relies on the video evidence attached to
Defendant’s motion when considering “the content, purpose, and motive of the act to assess its
legislative or non-legislative character.” Menendez, 831 F.3d at 166.
20 Defendant argues that “Supreme Court precedent applying the Speech or Debate Clause makes
clear that the Third Circuit’s two-step test has ‘one step too many.’” (Mot. I. at 20) (quoting N.Y.
State Rifle & Pistol Ass’n, Inc. v. Bruen, 597 U.S. 1, 19 (2022)). But the Supreme Court in Bruen
did not apply the Speech or Debate Clause, nor did it even reference the Clause in its opinion.
Rather, the Bruen court rejected the “two-step” framework that circuit courts had established for
analyzing Second Amendment challenges. Bruen, 597 U.S. at 17 (“[T]he Courts of Appeals have
coalesced around a ‘two-step’ framework for analyzing Second Amendment challenges that
combines history with means-end scrutiny.”).
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 17 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
18
Defendant argues that “her sole purpose on May 9 was exercising her congressional
prerogative to see for herself how ICE was treating the people it was paying a private company to
incarcerate.” (Mot. I at 17.) While Defendant acknowledges that she “followed ICE out of the
gates of Delaney Hall,” she maintains that she did so “to continue her oversight.” (Reply I at 4.)
Defendant argues this act was “not a deviation from her oversight agenda; it was doubling down
on it[,]” and that her congressional jurisdiction was “in no way limited to facility premises
themselves, and undoubtedly includes conducting oversight of ICE’s unlawful and irresponsible
behavior.” 	(Id. at 4, 5) (emphasis in original.) 	The Government responds that Defendant is
attempting “to blur the distinction between the clearly legislative act of conducting an inspection
of Delaney Hall and the non-legislative act of interfering and impeding with the arrest of the
Mayor.” (Opp. at 61.)
Here, the predominant purpose of Defendant’s acts alleged in Count One was not to engage
in fact-finding in connection with oversight of the facility. After DHS officials announced they
were arresting the Mayor, Defendant left the secured area of the facility and opposed the arrest
outside of the facility. Defendant’s opposition to the Mayor’s arrest went further than the Mayor’s
security detail,21 who watched as Defendant wedged herself between the Mayor and V-1. (Def.
Ex. I, 1:28-1:39.) 	Defendant was not acting pursuant to her congressional oversight authority
when she exited the Security Gate and made herself an active participant in a “scrum. . . in a public
parking lot.” (Mot. I at 3.) As Defendant objected to the Mayor’s arrest, the incident deteriorated
into “a serious scuffle involving a great deal of physical contact.” (Mot. II at 11.) 	Defendant’s
21 During the Mayor’s arrest, two members of his security detail watched as the Mayor was taken
into custody. (Def. Ex. I, 1:30-1:56.) One of the members of his security detail (“Detective”) told
a DHS agent who was making a perimeter around the Mayor, “I’m a cop relax, bro. I’m not doing
anything. Relax.” (Id., 1:30-1:41.)
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 18 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
19
strong opposition to the Mayor’s arrest is akin to “lobbying on behalf of a particular party” which
remains “outside the constitutional safe harbor” of the Speech or Debate Clause. Menendez, 831
F.3d at 169. Indeed, Defendant’s conduct is analogous to “efforts to intervene in decisions pending
before the Executive Branch that would mainly affect one particular party,” which are beyond the
scope of Speech or Debate protection. Id. at 168. Impeding an arrest, whether lawful or unlawful,
goes beyond any reasonable definition of oversight and, accordingly, exceeds the safe harbor of
legislative immunity.
The Court therefore rejects Defendant’s argument that “the indictment’s charges are
inextricably connected to her legislative acts.” (Mot. I at 14 n.8.) Defendant’s actions in Count
One are wholly disconnected from the oversight she and the Representatives later conducted when
touring the facility, where they engaged in protected fact-finding related to federal immigration
policy. Defendant’s presence at Delaney Hall does not grant constitutional protection for every
act performed in connection to that visit. 	See Lee, 775 F.2d at 522; Brewster, 408 U.S. at 528
(“The Speech or Debate Clause does not prohibit inquiry into illegal conduct simply because it has
some nexus to legislative functions.”) 	Similarly unavailing is Defendant’s argument that her
oversight jurisdiction is not “limited to facility premises themselves” and “undoubtedly includes
conducting oversight of ICE’s unlawful and irresponsible behavior.” (Reply I at 5.) Defendant’s
oversight authority to inspect immigration detention facilities cannot reasonably include a “scrum.
. . in a public parking lot” that has no nexus to oversight or legislative activity. (Mot I. at 3.)
Defendant further argues that “the indictment and evidence produced in discovery make
clear that neither a court nor a jury could evaluate the evidence in this case without referring to
and analyzing [her] legislative acts, placing those acts squarely at issue.” (Id. at 12.) Specifically,
Defendant contends that the “jury would necessarily hear about her focus on immigration policy,
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 19 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
20
and her history of congressional oversight in the area,” including “her February 2025 visit to
another immigration detention facility in Elizabeth, and her meeting the following month” with
ICE regional officials. (Id. at 3.) The Government insists that it has no intention to introduce any
of these matters into evidence because “those details do not tend to make it more likely that she
committed the charged offenses.”22 (Opp. at 59) (citing Fed. R. Evid. 401(b).) In order to prove
that Defendant violated 18 U.S.C. § 111(a)(1), the Government maintains it only needs to
introduce evidence that “she used her forearms to forcibly strike a federal Agent who was
attempting to arrest someone outside the gate to Delaney Hall, and she used her hands to forcibly
grab and pull at that agent’s jacket” and that “[n]othing about that touches on oversight activities.”
(Opp. at 58.)
The Third Circuit has recognized that Supreme Court jurisprudence (as well as its own)
“clearly establishes that the Speech or Debate Clause permits proof of a defendant’s status as a
member of Congress.” McDade, 28 F.3d at 290. The McDade Court wrote that “it follows that
the Speech or Debate Clause also permits proof of a defendant’s status as a member of a
congressional committee or as the holder of a committee leadership position.” 	Id. 	While the
Speech or Debate Clause “prevents the use of legislative acts against a Member[,]” it does not
prevent a legislator “from offering such acts in his own defense, even though he thereby subjects
himself to cross-examination.” Id. at 295 (citing United States v. Myers, 635 F.2d 932, 942 (2d
Cir.), cert denied, 449 U.S. 956 (1980)). Therefore, Defendant may offer evidence of her visits to
22 The Government also contends that “the jury will not be asked to evaluate her motives and
purposes in conducting the inspection on May 9, 2025, because those motives are irrelevant to
whether she violated § 111 when she interfered with and impeded the arrest of the Mayor.” (Opp.
at 59.)
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 20 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
21
other immigration facilities in New Jersey and meetings with federal immigration officials at trial
without offending the privilege established by the Speech or Debate Clause.
To prove Count One, the Government need not—and may not—inquire into or introduce
evidence of her legislative act of conducting an oversight inspection of the facility, which includes
eliciting any details from the fact-finding she or the other Representatives engaged in during their
tour, or any conclusions drawn from the same.23 	“Where an act has both legislative and non-
legislative components, a court should attempt to separate the legislative components from the
non-legislative components.” Menendez, 132 F. Supp. 3d at 620. If the Court determines that “a
particular meeting or event constitutes a legislative act, i.e., that it contained a significant
legislative component, then legislative immunity attaches and that particular activity is not
admissible in the prosecution, unless [Defendant] himself seeks to introduce it.” Lee, 775 F.2d at
525 (internal citation omitted).
Finally, Defendant suggests that inquiry into Defendant’s motives “would raise significant
separation-of-powers concerns considering Trump’s holding that courts evaluating claims of
presidential immunity emphatically ‘may not inquire into the President’s motives.’” (Mot. I. at
20) (emphasis in original) (quoting Trump v. United States, 603 U.S. 593, 618 (2024)). Defendant
asks this Court to extend the Supreme Court’s ruling on presidential immunity to the area of
legislative immunity. But these are two separate immunities applicable to two separate branches
of government, scrutinized under two separate legal standards. Article I of the Constitution confers
23 The Supreme Court “in Helstoski expressly held that, even where a conversation includes a
discussion of both legislative acts and non-legislative acts, the conversation can be examined and
the immunized aspects of the conversation deleted.” 	Lee, 775 F.2d at 523. 	In Helstoski, the
Supreme 	Court 	wrote 	that 	“[n]othing 	in 	our 	opinion, 	by 	any 	conceivable 	reading,
prohibits excising references to legislative acts, so that the remainder of the evidence would be
admissible.” 442 U.S. at 488 n.7.
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 21 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
22
legislative immunity for speech or debate, which the courts have interpreted and developed
through case law, while the presidential immunity doctrine is a court-created doctrine derived from
the executive’s Article II powers. 	See Youngstown Sheet & Tube Co. v. Sawyer, 343 U.S. 579
(1952); see also Nixon v. Fitzgerald, 457 U.S. 731 (1982). Moreover, the question of whether the
President engages in “official action” is a distinct inquiry from whether a Member of Congress
was engaging in a legislative act. Trump, 603 U.S. at 617.
Determining whether a criminal prosecution relies on legislative acts is a fact-specific
inquiry that requires close examination of the conduct at issue to ensure legislative independence,
without making “Members of Congress super-citizens, immune from criminal responsibility.”
Brewster, 408 U.S. at 516. Critically, the Speech or Debate Clause “does not prohibit inquiry into
activities that are casually or incidentally related to legislative affairs but not a part of the
legislative process itself.” Id. at 528. Here, the Court finds that the conduct charged in Count One
is only incidentally related to Defendant’s legislative oversight. The Government is not prohibited
from introducing evidence of those non-legislative acts at trial.
Count Three does not contain any additional factual allegations, but instead it incorporates
the “allegations set forth in paragraphs 1 through 12 of Count One” of the indictment. (Ind., Count
3 ¶ 1.) Count Three similarly alleges that Defendant violated 18 U.S.C. § 111(a)(1) and 18 U.S.C.
§ 2 by forcibly assaulting, resisting, opposing, impeding, intimidating, and interfering with “HSI
Special Agents and ICE Deportation Officers while said Special Agents and Officers were engaged
in and on account of the performance of their official duties.”24 (Id. ¶ 2.) 	Therefore, the same
facts and law apply with equal force to this charge, and the outcome must be the same.
24 Count One, alternatively, identifies Victim-1 as the subject of her alleged criminal conduct. (Ind.
Count 1 ¶ 1(d).)
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 22 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
23
Defendant has not met her burden of establishing that her predominant purpose in
physically opposing the Mayor’s arrest was to conduct oversight or gather information for a
legislative purpose. No genuine legislative purpose was advanced by Defendant’s alleged conduct.
Therefore, Defendant’s motion to dismiss Counts One and Three of the indictment is DENIED.
2. 	Count Two
The Court must similarly examine the predominant purpose of the acts alleged in Count
Two. 	After the Mayor was arrested and brought back inside the secured area, Defendant and
Representative-2 were among the crowd that was moving towards the Security Gate. (Def. Ex. A,
1:28:02.) V-2, one of the ICE agents standing guard at the Security Gate, was attempting to prevent
protestors in the crowd from entering the Security Gate. (Id.) As Defendant attempted to reenter
the facility through the Security Gate, V-2 forcibly pushed Defendant back into the public parking
lot before Defendant pushed V-2 in response.25 (Id., 1:28:10-1:28:20.) 	The indictment alleges
Defendant “pushed past V-2 while using each of her forearms to forcibly strike V-2 as she returned
inside of the secured area of Delaney Hall.” (Ind., Count 2 ¶ 3.) Defendant successfully reentered
the facility after Representative-2 wrapped his arms around her and pulled her through the Security
Gate, as the agents kept protestors from entering the Security Gate. (Def. Ex. A, 1:28:20-1:28:25.)
Following her reentry into the secured area of Delaney Hall, Defendant and the Representatives
were allowed to conduct their inspection of the facility. (Mot. I. at 11.)
25 Surveillance video reveals a dynamic situation where V-2 struggled through a crowd of hostile
protestors before encountering Defendant at the Security Gate. (See generally Def. Ex. I.) 	The
Court makes no finding on V-2’s intent when he forcibly pushed Defendant as she lawfully tried
to reenter the Security Gate. 	While the inchoate record does not allow for a determination of
Defendant’s predominate purpose upon reentry into the Security Gate, it is axiomatic that
Defendant’s statutory right to enter and inspect the facility could not be infringed, even if
mistakenly, by V-2. Upon completion of the record, Count Two will be subjected to scrutiny.
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 23 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
24
Menendez requires this Court to assess Defendant’s predominant purpose to determine the
applicability of Speech or Debate protection. As of the date of oral argument, the factual record
is still being developed. 	Discovery is ongoing, and the parties are in process of reviewing two
hours of complete video from the inspection.26 The facts surrounding that inspection are relevant
to Defendant’s motive in reentering the facility in Count Two, and whether her intent was related
to her oversight duties.27 Defendant’s predominant purpose can only be established by facts that
the parties have not yet put before the Court. 	Accordingly, the factual record is not ripe to
determine the applicability of the Speech or Debate Clause for Count Two. Therefore, the Court
will reserve on this matter until the factual record is developed further.
III. 	SELECTIVE ENFORCEMENT AND VINDICTIVE PROSECUTION
Defendant also moves to dismiss the indictment for selective enforcement and prosecution
in violation of her constitutional rights under the First and Fifth Amendments. (Mot. II at 14.) She
argues that she is being prosecuted for the content or viewpoint of her speech and for her partisan
affiliation. (Id. at 20.) In addition, Defendant alleges that she was vindictively prosecuted, and
that the indictment should be dismissed on this basis28 as well. 	(Id. at 27.) 	In the alternative,
Defendant asks this Court, if it determines the existing factual record does not provide clear
26 The Government is in the process of turning over the complete set of surveillance footage from
the Members’ tour, which took place after the subject incident. (See Tr. at 20:1-14.)
27 A Member of Congress may only “be prosecuted under a criminal statute provided that the
Government’s case does not rely on legislative acts or the motivation for legislative acts.”
Helstoski, 442 U.S. at 487-88.
28 A claim of vindictive or selective prosecution is not immediately appealable under the collateral
order doctrine. See United States v. Biden, No. 24-1703, 2024 WL 4541448, at *2 (3d Cir. May
9, 2024) (holding criminal defendants raising selective and vindictive prosecution claims “cannot
appeal before final judgment.”).
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 24 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
25
evidence of her claims, to grant additional discovery and hold evidentiary hearings on her claims
of selective enforcement and prosecution as well as vindictive prosecution. (Id. at 28.)
A. Legal Standard
The Executive Branch, led by the President, is vested with the exclusive authority to
prosecute cases. See United States v. Nixon, 418 U.S. 683, 693 (1974). “In our criminal justice
system, the Government retains ‘broad discretion’ as to whom to prosecute.” 	Wayte v. United
States, 470 U.S. 598, 607 (1985) (quoting United States v. Goodwin, 457 U.S. 368, 380 n.11,
(1982)). If probable cause exists, the decision of whether to prosecute or to present charges to a
grand jury is generally committed entirely to the prosecutor’s discretion. 	See Bordenkircher v.
Hayes, 434 U.S. 357, 364 (1978). This “broad discretion rests largely on the recognition that the
decision to prosecute is particularly ill-suited to judicial review.”29 Wayte, 470 U.S. at 607.
Prosecutorial discretion, however, is not “unfettered.” 	United States v. Batchelder, 442
U.S. 114, 124-125 (1979). The charging decision must not run afoul of the rights and protections
afforded by the Constitution. See id. at 125 (“Selectivity in the enforcement of criminal laws is,
of course, subject to constitutional constraints.”). 	A claim of selective prosecution is “an
independent assertion that the prosecutor has brought the charge for reasons forbidden by the
Constitution.” United States v. Armstrong, 517 U.S. 456, 463 (1996). Such a claim is founded on
principles of equal protection.30 Id. at 465. In particular, the decision to prosecute may not be
29 The Supreme Court in Wayte held that “[e]xamining the basis of a prosecution delays the
criminal proceeding, threatens to chill law enforcement by subjecting the prosecutor’s motives and
decisionmaking to outside inquiry, and may undermine prosecutorial effectiveness by revealing
the Government’s enforcement policy.” 470 U.S. at 607. 	These are “substantial concerns” that
“make the courts properly hesitant to examine the decision whether to prosecute.” Id. at 607-08.
30 Selective prosecution claims, therefore, are analyzed according to equal protection standards.
See Wayte, 470 U.S. at 608. 	Although the Fifth Amendment, unlike the Fourteenth, does not
contain an equal protection clause, it does contain an equal protection component, and the Supreme
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 25 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
26
“deliberately based upon an unjustifiable standard such as race, religion, or other arbitrary
classification, including the exercise of protected statutory and constitutional rights.” Wayte, 470
U.S. at 608 (internal citations and quotations omitted). An improper basis for selective prosecution
includes the exercise of First Amendment rights. 	See id. at 604 (denying selective prosecution
claim alleged by “vocal” opponents of a registration program claiming to have been impermissibly
targeted for prosecution “on the basis of their exercise of First Amendment rights”). Prosecutorial
decisions, therefore, “cannot turn on the exercise of free speech rights.”31 	Frederick Douglass
Found., Inc. v. District of Columbia, 82 F.4th 1122, 1141 (D.C. Cir. 2023).
To demonstrate selective prosecution, a defendant must show that the prosecution was
“motivated by a discriminatory purpose” and had a “discriminatory effect.” Armstrong, 517 U.S.
at 465. To satisfy the discriminatory effect element, the defendant bears the burden of showing
that “persons similarly situated have not been prosecuted” for the same offense. United States v.
Schoolcraft, 879 F.2d 64, 68 (3d Cir. 1989). 	To determine whether individuals are similarly
situated, courts assess a variety of factors, including “the strength of the case, the prosecution’s
general deterrence value, the Government’s enforcement priorities, and the case’s relationship to
the Government’s overall enforcement plan.” 	Wayte, 470 U.S. at 607. 	To satisfy the
“discriminatory purpose” element, the defendant must also show that “the decision to prosecute
was made on the basis of an unjustifiable standard, such as race, religion, or some other arbitrary
Court’s “approach to Fifth Amendment equal protection claims has[. . . ]been precisely the same
as to equal protection claims under the Fourteenth Amendment.” Id. n.9 (citing Weinberger v.
Wiesenfeld, 420 U.S. 636, 638, n. 2 (1975)).
31 “Specifically, selective enforcement of a neutral and facially constitutional law may run afoul
of the First Amendment if the government’s prosecutorial choices turn on the content or viewpoint
of speech.” Frederick Douglass Found., Inc. v. District of Columbia, 82 F.4th 1122, 1141 (D.C.
Cir. 2023).
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 26 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
27
factor, or that the prosecution was intended to prevent his exercise of a fundamental right.”
Schoolcraft, 879 F.2d at 68. Each of these elements must be shown with “clear evidence sufficient
to overcome the presumption of regularity that attaches to decisions to prosecute.” United States
v. Taylor, 686 F.3d 182, 197 (3d Cir. 2012) (cleaned up). 	This standard is “a demanding one.”
Armstrong, 517 U.S. at 463.
Selective prosecution and selective enforcement claims “are generally evaluated under the
same two-part test, which is derived from a line of seminal Supreme Court cases about the collision
between equal protection principles and the criminal justice system.” United States v. Washington,
869 F.3d 193, 214 (3d Cir. 2017). “Meeting this standard generally requires evidence that similarly
situated individuals of a difference race or classification were not prosecuted, arrested, or
otherwise investigated.” 	Id. 	Though “selective prosecution” and “selective enforcement” have
been used interchangeably, the Third Circuit has clarified that these are separate claims, noting
that “‘[p]rosecution’ refers to the actions of prosecutors (in their capacity as prosecutors) and
‘enforcement’ to the actions of law enforcement and those affiliated with law-enforcement
personnel.” Id. 	Nevertheless, a “defendant challenging a criminal prosecution at either the law
enforcement or prosecution inflection points must provide ‘clear evidence’ of discriminatory effect
and discriminatory intent” or purpose. Id.
One form of selective prosecution is vindictive prosecution, which derives from the
principle that “an individual certainly may be penalized for violating the law, [but] he just as
certainly may not be punished for exercising a protected statutory or constitutional right.”
Goodwin, 457 U.S. at 372; see also Bordenkircher, 434 U.S. at 363 (“To punish a person because
he has done what the law plainly allows him to do is a due process violation of the most basic
sort[.]”). 	There are two ways in which a defendant may demonstrate vindictive prosecution.
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 27 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
28
“First, a defendant may use evidence of a prosecutor’s retaliatory motive to prove actual
vindictiveness. Second, in certain circumstances, a defendant may show facts sufficient to give
rise to a presumption of vindictiveness.” United States v. Paramo, 998 F.2d 1212, 1220 (3d Cir.
1993) (internal citations omitted). A presumption of vindictiveness only attaches where there is a
“realistic likelihood of vindictiveness.” Id. “The inquiry here is not whether there is a possibility
that the defendant might be deterred from exercising a legal right, but whether the situation
presents a reasonable likelihood of a danger that the State might be retaliating against the accused
for lawfully exercising a right.” United States v. Esposito, 968 F.2d 300, 303 (3d Cir. 1992). As
the Third Circuit has warned, “courts must be cautious in adopting” such a presumption. Id.
1. 	Discovery in Support of Defendant’s Claims
Not only is the standard for showing selective prosecution a “rigorous” one, but so is the
standard for obtaining discovery in support of such a claim. 	Armstrong, 517 U.S. at 468 (“The
justifications for a rigorous standard for the elements of a selective-prosecution claim thus require
a correspondingly rigorous standard for discovery in aid of such a claim.”). Six years after
Armstrong, the Supreme Court again reiterated the significant burden facing a defendant,
explaining 	that 	defendant 	must 	show 	“some evidence of 	both 	discriminatory 	effect 	and
discriminatory intent” even to obtain discovery in support of a selective prosecution claim. United
States v. Bass, 536 U.S. 862, 863 (2002) (emphasis added). The Third Circuit recently explained
the nuanced differences between the standard to obtain discovery and the standard to prevail on
the merits of a selective prosecution claim:
A criminal defendant, however, will not often have access to the information,
statistical or otherwise, that might satisfy a “clear evidence” burden. Thus, the two
component cases that make up the Armstrong/Bass test – United States v.
Armstrong and United States v. Bass, both of which arose from selective
prosecution challenges – propounded a facially less rigorous standard for criminal
defendants seeking discovery on an anticipated selective prosecution claim. Instead
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 28 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
29
of “clear evidence,” a successful discovery motion can rest on “some evidence.”
“Some evidence” must still include a showing that similarly situated persons were
not prosecuted. Furthermore, under Armstrong/Bass, the defendant’s showing must
be “credible” and cannot generally be satisfied with nationwide statistics.
Washington, 869 F.3d at 214-15 (emphasis in original) (footnotes omitted). In Washington, the
Third Circuit joined the Seventh in holding that “motions for discovery seeking information on
putative claims of unconstitutional selective enforcement are not governed by strict application of
the Armstrong/Bass framework.” Id. at 220. Therefore, on a pretrial discovery request that alleges
both selective prosecution and selective enforcement, “the standard guiding the district court’s
discretion is different” for claims of selective enforcement. 	Id. 	Thus, “[d]istinct from what is
required under Armstrong/Bass, a defendant need not, at the initial stage, provide ‘some evidence’
of discriminatory intent, or show that (on the effect prong) similarly situated persons of a different
race or equal protection classification were not arrested or investigated by law enforcement.” Id.
at 221. However, “the proffer must be strong enough to support a reasonable inference of
discriminatory intent and non-enforcement.” 	Id. 	In so holding, the Third Circuit declined “to
mandate a precise system or order that a district court must follow” but rather left it to the “broad
discretion of the district court” that is routinely exercised in “matters of docket control and
discovery[.]” Id. at 220.
“Although the Third Circuit has not squarely addressed the standard to obtain discovery
for a vindictive-prosecution claim, it appears to be the same as for selective prosecution.” United
States v. Biden, 729 F. Supp. 3d 410, 418 (D. Del. 2024), appeal dismissed, No. 24-1703, 2024
WL 4541448 (3d Cir. May 9, 2024) (citing United States v. Sanders, 211 F.3d 711, 717 (2d Cir.
2000) (“We see no reason to apply a different standard to obtain discovery on a claim of vindictive
prosecution.”)). “Thus, a defendant may fail to demonstrate dismissal is warranted for selective
or vindictive prosecution, but discovery may nevertheless be appropriate if the defendant comes
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 29 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
30
forward with some evidence of the essential elements of the underlying” vindictive prosecution
claim. Biden, 729 F. Supp. 3d at 418.
B. Discussion
To establish the discriminatory effect prong of her selective enforcement and prosecution
claims, Defendant identifies the individuals prosecuted under 18 U.S.C. § 111(a) in connection
with the attack on the Capitol on January 6, 2021 (“the January 6 defendants”)32 as a similarly
situated group of individuals who were not prosecuted for the same offense on account of their
viewpoint and partisan affiliation. (Mot. II at 17.) Defendant maintains that that her “case stands
in remarkable contrast to those January 6 cases dismissed by the government” because her conduct
was “manifestly less egregious” and did not result in any injuries or physical harm to officers, thus
“there is no conduct-based justification for dismissing the January 6 cases, while continuing to
prosecute her.” (Id. at 19, 20.) The Government responds that the January 6 defendants cannot be
considered similarly situated to Defendant because they were pardoned, and thus “on their face do
not meet the[] basic criteria” of individuals who “‘could have been prosecuted for the offenses for
which [the defendant was] charged, but were not prosecuted.’” (Opp. at 15) (citing United States
v. Hedaithy, 392 F.3d 580, 607 (3d Cir. 2004)).
Defendant further argues that the differential treatment between her and the January 6
defendants “turned on a constitutionally impermissible consideration—namely, the content or
viewpoint of speech, or partisan affiliation” which establishes the discriminatory intent prong of
32 Defendant states that she “does not rely on defendants who received pardons or commutations
and thus does not implicate any issues associated with the President’s constitutional authority to
‘grant Reprieves and Pardons for Offences against the United States.’” (Mot. II at 6 n. 12) (citing
U.S. Const. art. II, § 2, cl. 1.) Instead, Defendant relies on the January 6 defendants who had been
charged with assaulting federal officers in violation of 18 U.S.C § 111(a) and whose cases were
pending at the time of the presidential proclamation but “have now been dismissed[.]” (Id. at 17.)
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 30 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
31
her selective enforcement claim. 	(Mot. II at 20) (internal citations and quotations omitted).
Defendant contends that the failure of the U.S. Attorney’s Office to follow internal consultation
guidelines before filing charges against her, the timing of the charges, as well as statements made
by the Interim U.S. Attorney, President Trump, and DHS all demonstrate the discriminatory
purpose behind the government’s prosecution and enforcement action against her. (Id. at 22-26.)
1. 	Discriminatory Effect
To establish her claims for selective enforcement and prosecution, Defendant must provide
clear evidence that “similarly situated individuals of a difference race or classification were not
prosecuted, arrested, or otherwise investigated.” 	Washington, 869 F.3d at 214. 	Defendant has
identified the January 6 defendants as the similarly situated group against whom enforcement and
prosecutorial action was not taken. 	The Court will evaluate Defendant’s selective enforcement
and prosecution claims separately.
The January 6 defendants are not a similarly situated class of individuals against whom no
enforcement or investigative action was taken. 	It is undisputed that the Department of Justice
(“DOJ”) launched a large-scale investigation of the January 6 defendants and dedicated
considerable financial and employee resources to that effort. In her brief, Defendant cites an NPR
article describing DOJ efforts in the wake of January 6, 2021 as “the largest criminal investigation
in U.S. history.”33 (See Mot. II. at 19 n.30.) The Government’s brief cites a press release issued
by the former Attorney General Merrick Garland on the fourth anniversary of January 6, 2021,
stating that “[o]ver the past four years, our prosecutors, FBI agents, investigators, and analysts
have conducted one of the most complex, and most resource-intensive investigations in the Justice
33 The Jan. 6 Attack: The Cases Behind the Biggest Criminal Investigation in U.S. History, NPR
(Mar. 14, 2025, at 17:26 ET), https://www.npr.org/2021/02/09/965472049/the-capitol-siegethe-
arrested-and-their-stories.
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 31 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
32
Department’s history.”34 	The Court agrees with the Government’s argument that “the massive
investigatory action brought against the January 6 Defendants entirely undermines any claim that
the January 6 Defendants can be said to be similarly situated for enforcement purposes,”
particularly compared to the “limited” enforcement action DHS took against Defendant here.35
(Opp. at 24, 23.) Accordingly, Defendant’s selective enforcement claim fails.
Defendant’s selective prosecution claim suffers from a similar “threshold, insurmountable
defect” (Opp. at 14) because the January 6 defendants were in fact prosecuted by DOJ before
receiving pardons for their crimes.36 On January 20, 2025, President Trump issued a Proclamation
granting a blanket pardon “for certain offenses relating to the events at or near the United States
Capitol on January 6, 2021” and directing “the Attorney General to pursue dismissal with prejudice
to the government of all pending indictments against individuals for their conduct related to the
events at or near the United States Capitol on January 6, 2021.”37 DOJ had no discretion when
dismissing the January 6 defendants’ criminal cases—the Presidential pardon required their
34 Press Release, U.S. DEP ’T OF J UST., Attorney General Merrick B. Garland Statement on the
Fourth Anniversary of the January 6 Attack on the Capitol (Feb. 6, 2025), available at
https://www.justice.gov/archives/opa/pr/attorney-general-merrick-bgarland-statement-fourth
anniversary-january-6-attack-capitol.
35 The Government describes its enforcement action against Defendant as consisting “largely of
downloading the video footage of the body-worn cameras of ICE officers who assisted in the arrest
of the Mayor as well as obtaining surveillance footage from Delaney Hall’s cameras near the gate
to the facility and subsequently reviewing that video” which was “then provided to members of
the U.S. Attorney’s Office for review.” (Opp. at 24.)
36 The same NPR article that Defendant cites in her brief states that 1,575 people were charged
with federal crimes as part of the January 6 investigation, 1,030 defendants pleaded guilty, 261
went to trial, and 1,126 were sentenced by a federal judge. See supra note 34.
37 Granting Pardons and Commutation of Sentences for Certain Offenses Relating to the Events at
or Near the United States Capitol on January 6, 2021, Proclamation No. 10887, 90 Fed. Reg. 8331
(Jan. 29, 2025), https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2025-01-29/pdf/2025-01950.pdf.
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 32 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
33
dismissal. 	The Government’s brief attests that the “Office of the Pardon Attorney further
confirmed that the January 6 Defendants whose cases were pending as of the issuance date of the
Pardon are included in the universe of defendants who received pardons as a result, and the Pardon
Office has issued certificates of pardon to those defendants upon request.”38 (Opp. at 16.) The
Government attaches to its brief twenty-four certificates of pardon that were requested and
received by defendants whose cases were still pending at the time of the pardon. (See ECF 27-5,
Gov. Ex. B.)
Moreover, courts dismissing the remaining January 6 cases have acknowledged that the
President had pardoned the defendant appearing before them. See e.g., United States v. Banuelos,
763 F. Supp. 3d 1, at *1-2 (D.D.C. 2025) (“The Court does not discern…any defect in either the
legal merits of, or the factual basis for, the Government’s case” that “the President, in addition to
pardoning the Defendant, has ordered the Attorney General to do so.”); United States v.
Warnagiris, No. 21-0382, 2025 WL 341990, at *4 (D.D.C. Jan. 30, 2025) (“On January 20, 2025,
President Trump issued a sweeping proclamation pardoning individuals charged for their conduct
at the Capitol on January 6, 2021”)39 (emphasis added). The January 6 defendants, therefore, are
not similarly situated because they were in fact prosecuted and subsequently pardoned.
Irrespective of the pardon, the January 6 defendants are not similarly situated to Defendant
because the facts and circumstances surrounding their criminal cases are unambiguously distinct.
38 The Government’s brief further avers that on September 2, 2025, the Deputy Pardon Attorney
from the Office of the Pardon Attorney informed the U.S. Attorney’s Office that “(i) the January
6 Defendants with then-pending cases received pardons under the Pardon and were eligible to
receive certificates of pardon, and (ii) that any January 6 Defendant was still considered pardoned
even if a certificate of pardon was not requested.” (Opp. at 7 n.10.)
39 The defendant in Warnagiris requested and received a certificate of pardon. 	(See ECF 27-1,
Gov. Ex. A, at 2.)
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 33 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
34
Several circuits have adopted the Fourth Circuit’s holding that individuals “are similarly situated
when their circumstances present no distinguishable legitimate prosecutorial factors that might
justify making different prosecutorial decisions with respect to them.” United States v. Olvis, 97
F.3d 739, 744 (4th Cir. 1996); see e.g., Frederick Douglass, 82 F.4th at 1137; United States v.
Lewis, 517 F.3d 20, 27 (1st Cir. 2008); United States v. Deberry, 430 F.3d 1294, 1301 (10th Cir.
2005); McDonald v. Vill. of Winnetka, 371 F.3d 992, 1006 (7th Cir. 2004). Defendant concedes
that while she and the January 6 defendants were prosecuted under the same statute, “the similarity
ends there.” 	(Mot. II. at 1.) 	Defendant explicitly differentiates herself from the January 6
defendants, noting that many of those defendants had “serious criminal records,” while she has no
criminal history. (Id. at 19.) Defendant also labels her conduct as “manifestly less egregious than
storming the Capitol, throwing explosives, beating officers with bats and riot shields, and spraying
them with pepper spray.” (Id. at 20.) In contrast, Defendant points out that there is no suggestion
in this case that any of the alleged victims were hurt. (Id.)
The Court is further persuaded by the District Court’s opinion in United States v. Judd
denying a January 6 defendant’s motion to dismiss for selective prosecution and enforcement, cited
in the Government’s brief. 579 F. Supp. 3d 1 (D.D.C. 2021); see Opp. at 20. The defendant in
Judd argued he had been selectively prosecuted for assaulting law enforcement officers outside
the Capitol while rioters in Portland against whom the government had dropped charges had
committed similar or more severe assaultive conduct. 	579 F. Supp. 3d at 7. 	The court there
acknowledged that the “unique context of January 6 render few defendants similarly situated” and
ultimately found the two groups of protestors were not similarly situated because the “action in
Portland, though destructive and ominous, caused no similar threat to civilians.” Id. at 8. If the
January 6 defendants can be distinguished from another group of civilian protestors, Defendant, a
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 34 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
35
Congresswoman with statutory authority to be present at Delaney Hall, is certainly not similarly
situated to the individuals prosecuted in connection with January 6.
2. 	Discriminatory Purpose
Because Defendant has not demonstrated that similarly situated individuals were not
prosecuted, arrested, or otherwise investigated, her selective enforcement and prosecution claims
fail, and the Court need not address Defendant’s arguments about the discriminatory intent prong
required to prove her claims.40 See Biden, 729 F. Supp. 3d at 422 (“Because Defendant has failed
to come forward with ‘clear evidence’ that he has been prosecuted where others similarly situated
were not, he is unable to show discriminatory effect, one of the two necessary elements of a
selective-prosecution claim . . . his motion to dismiss the indictment on that basis must be
denied.”). 	Defendant has failed to offer clear evidence that the charges in this case had a
discriminatory effect, thus her claims of selective enforcement and prosecution must fail.
3. 	Vindictive Prosecution
To prove her vindictive prosecution claim, Defendant must offer evidence of actual
vindictiveness—direct evidence that the prosecutor harbored personal animus towards her—or by
showing “a reasonable likelihood of a danger” that the government is retaliating against her for
lawfully exercising a right that gives rise to a presumption of vindictiveness. Esposito, 968 F.2d
at 303. Defendant argues that DHS statements and actions beginning on May 9 “provide strong
40 Defendant’s principal argument that the charges in this case were motivated by a discriminatory
purpose is that the government “cannot pursue charges against her because she is a Democrat who
conducts oversight of Executive Branch immigration policy, while dismissing charges brought
under the same statute against those whose views they share and who engaged in conduct far more
egregious.” (Mot. II at 4.) Defendant asserts that this difference in viewpoint is “the sole credible
explanation for that difference in treatment.” (Id.) This argument is belied by the fact that two
more senior members of her political party were present on May 9 conducting oversight of
executive immigration policy who also surrounded the Mayor and objected to his arrest but were
not criminally charged.
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 35 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
36
evidence that the goal of this prosecution is to deter” Defendant’s legitimate exercise of her
statutorily protected oversight responsibilities. (Mot. II. at 27.) Defendant further argues that the
prosecution’s retaliatory animus is demonstrated by the “deliberate and reckless steps” that
executive branch officials took to “drive the [Representatives’] visit into chaos” and “has insisted
on criminal prosecution as retribution” for Defendant’s participation in those events. (Id. at 28.)
To begin, Defendant has not demonstrated that her prosecution is a result of personal
animus harbored by the prosecution. Defendant identifies public statements made in April 2025
by the Interim U.S. Attorney in an interview that “we could turn New Jersey red”41 as well as a
statement from the President after Defendant had been charged that the “days of woke are over.”42
(Id. at 23-24.) None of these statements are particularized to Defendant herself. In fact, during
President Trump’s full exchange with a reporter where he stated the “days of woke are over,” when
asked if he directed the prosecution of Defendant, the President stated “No. I didn’t. The days of
woke are over. That woman, I don’t, I have no idea who she is.”43 These broad statements are
not specific to this Defendant or responsive to her policy positions on immigration, and are
therefore not personalized in a way that the requested relief contemplates. Defendant also points
to DHS statements criticizing Democratic lawmakers and referring to their oversight visit as
41 HUMAN EVENTS D AILY WITH J ACK P OSOBIEC , Newly Appointed New Jersey DA Alina Habba-
Live From the White House, at 4:47-49, (Apple Podcasts Mar. 27, 2025), available at available at
https://podcasts.apple.com/ca/podcast/newly-appointed-new-jersey-da-alinahabba-live-
from/id1585243541?i=1000701160 703 at 4:47-49.
42 Andrew Solender, Trump Defends McIver Charges: “The Days of that Crap Are Over”, AXIOS
(May 20, 2025), https://www.axios.com/2025/05/20/trump-lamonica-mciver-doj-charges-ice.
43 “Trump on McIver Charges: The Days of Woke Are Over”, WASH. P OST (May 20, 2025, at
11:51 ET), www.washingtonpost.com/video/politics/trump-onmciver-charges-the-days-of-woke-
are-over/2025/05/20/68660a86-b6e2-4ac7-9641-17bf5289e5f1_video.html.
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 36 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
37
“political stunts” that “endanger the safety” of ICE personnel. 	(See id. at 27.)44 	But DHS
statements and actions are irrelevant to Defendant’s instant vindictive prosecution claim. 	The
Court agrees with the Government that this evidence “does not involve anyone making
prosecutorial decisions and is thus not a proper consideration for a vindictive prosecution motion.”
(Opp. at 41.) Defendant, therefore, has not presented clear evidence of personal animus.
Next, the Court must determine if a presumption of vindictiveness has attached. 	The
Supreme Court has cast doubt on the applicability of the presumption in pretrial settings.45 See
generally Goodwin, 457 U.S. at 372-84 (discussing the propriety of the presumption in cases where
a defendant successfully challenges a conviction and faces enhanced punishment upon retrial, but
declining to apply the presumption in the pretrial context where the defendant faced additional
charges and enhanced punishment after refusing to plead guilty as demanded by the prosecutor).
The district court in Biden wrote in 2024 that “[t]his Court has found no cases from within the
Third Circuit where a presumption of vindictiveness was applied in the pretrial context.” 729 F.
Supp. 3d at 424 n.7 (declining to apply the presumption of vindictiveness in pretrial motion to
dismiss). This Court has identified no such cases from within the Third Circuit since. Moreover,
44 Citing Press Release, DHS, ICE Employee Attacked by Rioters After Congressman Doxes Him
to Mob at California Marijuana Facility (July 14, 2025), https://perma.cc/3GNL-PWE6.
45 The Supreme Court in Goodwin explained that “[t]here is good reason to be cautious before
adopting an inflexible presumption of prosecutorial vindictiveness in a pretrial setting” because
“[a]t this stage of the proceedings, the prosecutor’s assessment of the proper extent of prosecution
may not have crystallized” but once a trial begins “and certainly by the time a conviction has been
obtained – it is much more likely that the State has discovered and assessed all of the information
against an accused and has made a determination, on the basis of that information, of the extent to
which he should be prosecuted.” 457 U.S. at 381. “Thus, a change in the charging decision made
after an initial trial is completed is much more likely to be improperly motivated than is a pretrial
decision.” Id.
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 37 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
38
the Third Circuit has warned that “courts must be cautious in adopting” a presumption of
vindictiveness. Esposito, 968 F.2d at 303.
Defendant maintains that the government is retaliating against her for “for lawful oversight
activity.” 	(Reply II. at 11.) 	Defendant argues that “the prosecution here rests on a retaliatory
animus” because “the Executive Branch does not like scrutiny of its immigration policies and
practices.” 	(Mot. II. at 27-28.) 	This argument is undermined by the absence of charges filed
against the Representatives who were also present on May 9 conducting oversight of the
administration’s 	immigration 	policies. 	Video 	evidence 	shows 	that 	Representative-1 	and
Representative-2 were also in close proximity to the Mayor and also advocated on his behalf, but
did not physically contest his arrest. 	(See Def. Ex. A, 1:27:10.) 	Similarly unavailing is
Defendant’s argument that the government’s circumvention of DOJ’s mandatory approval
procedure to charge a Member of Congress is evidence of retaliatory motive. (See id. at 27.) In
early May, before Defendant was charged, DOJ suspended the requirement that federal prosecutors
seek approval from the Public Integrity Unit before bringing charges against public officials. (See
Opp. at 26-27.)46 Thus, even if a presumption of vindictiveness could be invoked in the pretrial
context, Defendant has failed to demonstrate that such a presumption is appropriate here.
Defendant has failed to show that her prosecution is vindictive.
46 Citing Sarah N. Lynch et al., How Trump Defanged the Justice Department’s Political
Corruption 	Watchdogs, 	R EUTERS 	(June 	9, 	2025) 	(emphasis 	added),
https://www.reuters.com/investigations/how-trump-defanged-justice-departmentspolitical-
corruption-watchdogs-2025-06-09/.
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 38 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
39
4. 	Defendant’s Request for Discovery and an Evidentiary Hearing
Defendant seeks discovery for her claims of selective and vindictive prosecution in the
event the Court concludes that dismissal is not yet warranted. (See Mot. II at 28.) Defendant has
submitted discovery requests which ask for communications over a six-month period referring to
the incident in question or discussing the Defendant, the Mayor, or the Representatives’ oversight
visit. (See ECF 26-1.) Defendant seeks these communications between “the prosecution team”
which she defines as including but not limited to the Attorney General, the Deputy Attorney
General, the Assistant Attorney General for the Criminal Division, the Interim or Acting U.S.
Attorney for the District of New Jersey, the DHS Secretary, Deputy Secretary, General Counsel,
and their staff, in addition to all members of ICE leadership and members of their staff. (Id. at 2.)
Defendant is correct that the standard to obtain discovery is different than the standard to
prevail on a motion to dismiss the indictment for selective or vindictive prosecution. 	While
Defendant needs to show “clear evidence” that her prosecution was selective or vindictive to obtain
dismissal, but she only needs to come forward with “some evidence” to obtain discovery.
Washington, 869 F.3d at 214; see also Bass, 536 U.S. at 863 (requiring “some evidence of both
discriminatory effect and discriminatory intent” for a selective prosecution claim). Even with that
clarification, the Court is mindful that both standards are considered “rigorous.” Armstrong, 517
U.S. at 468. Indeed, the standard is so rigorous that as of 2017, the Third Circuit had yet to find
“sufficient evidence to permit discovery of a prosecutor’s decision-making policies and practices.”
Washington, 869 F.3d at 215; see also Biden,729 F. Supp. 3d at 427 n.10 (“This Court has been
unable to locate Third Circuit cases since 2017 permitting such discovery.”).
This is not the rare case where discovery of a prosecutor’s decision-making practices will
be permitted. To obtain discovery, Defendant “must still include a showing that similarly situated
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 39 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
40
persons were not prosecuted.” Washington, 869 F.2d at 215. Defendant’s motion falls short. For
the reasons discussed supra, Defendant has not offered “credible” evidence that similarly situated
individuals were not prosecuted, because the January 6 defendants were all pardoned without the
opportunity for prosecutorial discretion. Id. Defendant has not offered “some evidence” of her
vindictive prosecution claim either. She provides the Court with statements made by the Interim
U.S. Attorney and President that are not particularized to her or her policy positions on
immigration. To provide discovery based on statements made by executive branch officials related
only to her partisan affiliation would render the discovery standard hollow because it would be
universally applicable. 	Accordingly, Defendant is not entitled to discovery for her selective or
vindictive prosecution claims.
The standard for discovery on a selective enforcement claim is even less rigorous and
subject to the district court’s discretion, although the Third Circuit advised that “the district court
must be mindful that the end ‘goal’ of such a discovery motion is a valid claim of selective
enforcement under the heightened substantive standards,” which its decision in Washington did
not “diminish or distinguish.” 869 F.2d at 221. Guided by these principles, the Court cannot find
that Defendant’s broad request for communications among top DOJ, DHS, and ICE officials
beginning on January 20, 2025 is warranted for her selective enforcement claim. As discussed,
Defendant has failed to provide evidence that the January 6 defendants were similarly situated
individuals who were not investigated or arrested on account of the vast resources and manpower
devoted to investigating those individuals.
Defendant has thus failed to offer the minimal required evidence of discriminatory effect.
That failure is itself enough to deny Defendant’s request for discovery and an evidentiary hearing.
See Bass, 536 U.S. at 864 (“[B]ecause respondent failed to submit relevant evidence that similarly
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 40 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>
41
situated persons were treated differently, he was not entitled to discovery.”); Hedaithy, 392 F.3d
at 607 (denying discovery where defendant “did not present sufficient credible evidence of
discriminatory effect”).
IV. 	CONCLUSION
For the foregoing reasons, Defendant’s motions to dismiss the indictment for selective
enforcement, selective prosecution, and vindictive prosecution, and for discovery and an
evidentiary hearing (ECF 20) regarding the same are DENIED. Defendant’s motion to dismiss
the indictment for legislative immunity (ECF 19) is DENIED, and the Court will reserve on the
question of whether Defendant is immune from prosecution for Count Two under the Speech or
Debate Clause. An appropriate order follows.
/s/ Jamel K. Semper 	.
H ON. JAMEL K. S EMPER
United States District Judge
Orig: 	Clerk
cc: 	Parties
Case 2:25-cr-00388-JKS Document 44 Filed 11/13/25 Page 41 of 41 PageID:
<pageID>

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.