SCHAFER v. CONOPCO, INC.

2:23-cv-00348Njd4 mars 2026

Texte intégral

NOT FOR PUBLICATION
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
DISTRICT OF NEW JERSEY
HOLLY SCHAFER,
Plaintiff,
v.
CONOPCO, INC., d/b/a UNILEVER
HOME & PERSONAL CARE USA,
Defendant.
Civil Action No. 23-348
OPINION
March 4, 2026
SEMPER, District Judge.
THIS MATTER comes before the Court on Defendant Conopco, Inc. d/b/a Unilver Home
& Personal Care USA’s (“Defendant”) motion to preclude Plaintiff Holly Schafer’s (“Plaintiff”)
expert from testifying at trial (ECF 41, “Daubert Mot.”) and Defendant’s motion for summary
judgment (ECF 43, “SJM”). Plaintiff opposed both motions (ECF 45, “Daubert Opp.”; ECF 46,
“SJM Opp.”) Defendant filed reply briefs. (ECF 49, “Daubert Reply”; ECF 47, “SJM Reply”.)
The Court reviewed the submissions made in support of and in opposition to the motions and
decided the motions without oral argument pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 78 and
Local Civil Rule 78.1. For the reasons stated below, Defendant’s motions are GRANTED.
I. 	MOTION TO PRECLUDE
Defendant has filed a motion to preclude the testimony of Dr. Marc Serota, an expert
retained by Plaintiff, “pursuant to Rule 702 of the Federal Rules of Evidence and Daubert v.
Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals, Inc., 509 U.S. 579 (1993).” (Daubert Mot. at 1.) In her Complaint,
Plaintiff alleges that she experienced an allergic reaction to a preservative called DMDM
Case 2:23-cv-00348-JKS-MAH Document 66 Filed 03/04/26 Page 1 of 13 PageID:
<pageID>
2
hydantoin in TRESemmé shampoo manufactured by Defendant Unilever, and that such a reaction
caused her to temporarily lose hair. (Id.) Plaintiff hired an expert, Dr. Marc Serota, who prepared
an expert report and was deposed in the course of this and other related litigation. (See ECF 55-1,
55-4.) Defendant has included the depositions of Plaintiff and Plaintiff’s treating physician, Dr.
Donna Gavarone, as exhibits for this Court’s consideration. (See ECF 55-2, ECF 55-3.)
A. Legal Standard
Federal Rule of Evidence 702 provides:
A witness who is qualified as an expert by knowledge, skill, experience, training, or
education may testify in the form of an opinion or otherwise if the proponent
demonstrates to the court that it is more likely than not that:
(a) the expert’s scientific, technical, or other specialized knowledge will help the
trier of fact to understand the evidence or to determine a fact in issue;
(b) the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data;
(c) the testimony is the product of reliable principles and methods; and
(d) the expert’s opinion reflects a reliable application of the principles and methods
to the facts of the case.
Fed. R. Evid. 702. In Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals, Inc, the Supreme Court held that
district courts must act as gatekeepers to ensure proffered expert scientific testimony meets the
requirements of Rule 702. See 509 U.S. 579, 589 (1993). And in Kumho Tire Co. v. Carmichael,
the Court held that “this basic gatekeeping obligation” “applies to all expert testimony,” not just
“scientific” testimony. 526 U.S. 137, 147 (1999).
“Rule 702 embodies three distinct substantive restrictions on the admission of expert
testimony: qualifications, reliability, and fit.” Elcock v. Kmart Corp., 233 F.3d 734, 741 (3d Cir.
2000). 	First, the proffered witness must be a qualified expert, meaning that the witness must
possess specialized expertise. Feit v. Great-West Life & Annuity Ins. Co., 460 F. Supp. 2d 632,
Case 2:23-cv-00348-JKS-MAH Document 66 Filed 03/04/26 Page 2 of 13 PageID:
<pageID>
3
636 (D.N.J. 2006). Second, the testimony must be reliable. This requirement has been interpreted
to mean that an “expert’s opinion must be based on the ‘methods and procedures of science’ rather
than on ‘subjective belief or unsupported speculation;’ the expert must have ‘good grounds' for his
or her belief.” 	Id. (citing In re Paoli Railroad Yard PCB Litigation, 35 F.3d 717, 742 (3d Cir.
1994), cert. denied, 513 U.S. 1190 (1995)). Thus, “[c]ourts need not admit bare conclusions or
mere assumptions proffered under the guise of ‘expert opinions [,]’” id. at 637, and “nothing in
either Daubert or the Federal Rules of Evidence requires a district court to admit opinion evidence
that is connected to existing data only by the ipse dixit of the expert.” Gen. Elec. Co. v. Joiner,
522 U.S. 136, 146, (1997). Third, the expert’s testimony must “fit,” meaning that the testimony
“‘must be relevant for the purposes of the case and must assist the trier of fact.’” 	Calhoun v.
Yamaha Motor Corp., U.S.A., 350 F.3d 316, 321 (3d Cir. 2003) (quoting Schneider v. Fried, 320
F.3d 396, 405 (3d Cir. 2003)).
An expert who renders an opinion based on factual assumptions not present in the case
“cannot be said to ‘assist the trier of fact,’ as Rule 702 requires.” Elcock, 233 F.3d at 756 n. 13.
Consequently, “[t]his type of an opinion misleads the fact-finder and arguably does not comply
with the ‘fit’ requirement” of Rule 702. Id. “A court ‘must examine the expert’s conclusions in
order to determine whether they could reliably flow from the facts known to the expert and the
methodology used.’” 	McGarrigle v. Mercury Marine, 838 F. Supp. 2d 282, 293 (D.N.J. 2011)
(citing Oddi v. Ford Motor Co., 234 F.3d 136, 145 (3d Cir. 2000).
The proponent of expert testimony must establish the admissibility of the expert’s opinion
by a preponderance of the evidence. In re Paoli, 35 F.3d at 744.
Case 2:23-cv-00348-JKS-MAH Document 66 Filed 03/04/26 Page 3 of 13 PageID:
<pageID>
4
B. Discussion
Defendant argues that Plaintiff cannot meet her burden of establishing that Dr. Serota’s
opinion is reliable. (Daubert Mot. at 21.) Specifically, Defendant points to Dr. Serota’s deposition
testimony where he admitted that his opinion was wrong and that he “could not even speculate as
to how TRESemmé could have possibly caused Plaintiff’s alleged hair loss” was speculative. (Id.
at 23.) Defendant also argues that even if Dr. Serota had not conceded his opinion was wrong, it
would still be inadmissible for Dr. Serota’s failure to conduct requisite procedures and diagnostic
techniques, like the administration of a patch test or a physical examination of Plaintiff. (Id. at 23-
30.) 	Plaintiff counters that Dr. Serota employed reliable diagnostic techniques to opine that
TRESemmé caused Plaintiff’s hair loss, namely “the close temporal relationship between the onset
of Ms. Schafer’s hair loss and her use of TRESemmé.” 	(Daubert Opp. at 23.) 	Plaintiff also
contends that Defendant’s arguments go to the weight, rather than admissibility, of the expert
testimony here. (Id. at 26.)
The opinion offered by Dr. Serota’s expert report fails to meet the requirements set forth
in Rule 702 as well as the standard for the admissibility of expert opinions established by Daubert.
Dr. Serota’s own sworn testimony at his deposition contradicts the findings of his expert report.
In his expert report, Dr. Serota opines, based on his experience as practicing dermatologist, that
DMDM hydantoin in TRESemmé products commonly causes contact dermatitis, and that contact
dermatitis of the scalp can cause hair loss. (Id. at 22) (citing ECF 55-1, “Serota Rep.” ¶¶ 10-14,
18-22, 24-25.) 	Dr. Serota then opines beyond a reasonable degree of medical certainty that
TRESemmé caused Ms. Schafer’s hair loss, based on the strong temporal connection between her
Case 2:23-cv-00348-JKS-MAH Document 66 Filed 03/04/26 Page 4 of 13 PageID:
<pageID>
5
exposure to TRESemmé, her scalp reactions, and hair loss.1 	(Id. at 26.) 	However, during Dr.
Serota’s deposition, when presented with Plaintiff’s sworn testimony that she never experienced
dermatitis, Dr. Serota responded: “I don’t know if that was clear to me. . . I would need to see what
you are referring to.” 	(ECF 55-4, “Serota Dep.”, 124:19-124:4.) 	After being read Plaintiff’s
testimony that she never experienced or noticed “any rashes, irritation, scaling, or bleeding in [her]
scalp” (id., 125:6-17), Dr. Serota invoked Plaintiff’s testimony about a “tingling” sensation she
felt after using TRESemmé products, which “would be a sign of a reaction[.]”2 (Id., 128:6-22.)
But, after reviewing Plaintiff’s testimony that such tingling lasted for only a few seconds, Dr.
Serota conceded that a tingling reaction due to contact dermatitis “would be present for somewhere
between 24 and 72 hours” and thus would last “longer than a few seconds[.]”3 (Id., 136:19-137:2.)
Dr. Serota then testified that Plaintiff’s reported experience of tingling was “not a typical
history for allergic contact dermatitis” and that he had never seen or diagnosed any patient with
dermatitis when the only symptom was tingling. (Id., 137:8-9, 137:11-16.) He also conceded that
he could not identify any authority or literature that would support a diagnosis under those
circumstances. (Id., 137:18-138:13.) After this discussion, Dr. Serota was asked if he could opine
1 Plaintiff reported that she began using TRESemmé shampoos and conditioners starting in early
2021, which caused her to experience “tingling” on her scalp. (ECF 55-2, “Pl. Dep.”, 70:12-71:6,
51:1-53:4.) Plaintiff reported hair loss beginning in March or April 2021, increasing in severity
after using TRESemmé shampoo and conditioner. (Id., 75:10-76:9.) After Plaintiff stopped using
TRESemmé, she experienced hair loss for about five months, and it took about “a year and some
change” to return and regrow. (Id., 106:9-25, 107:25-108:11.)
2 In her opposition brief, Plaintiff also cites the tingling sensation reported by Plaintiff as evidence
of contact dermatitis. 	(See Daubert Opp. at 2) (“However, ‘tingling’ is a common symptom of
contact dermatitis.”)
3 Dr. Serota later testified that he had no “objective evidence in this case that [Plaintiff] suffered
visible signs of dermatitis” and “objectively, I don’t see any signs of dermatitis that were presented
on this case.” (Serota Dep., 148:3-7, 151:2-5.)
Case 2:23-cv-00348-JKS-MAH Document 66 Filed 03/04/26 Page 5 of 13 PageID:
<pageID>
6
to a reasonable degree of medical certainty whether TRESemmé substantially contributed to
Plaintiff’s hair loss, as alleged in his expert report, and he responded only that Plaintiff’s hair loss
“seems to correlate” with her use of TRESemmé products. (Id., 148:9-24; see also id., 164:8-21
(“I think what I could say to a reasonable degree of medical certainty is that exposure to the
TRESemmé product correlates with her symptoms”); id., 166:24 (“the symptomatology correlates
with her exposure to the product”); id., 175:6 (“it seems to correlate”).)
Dr. Serota admitted that “the mechanism of [plaintiff’s hair loss] being allergic contact
dermatitis may not be correct” (id., 148:24-149:2) and that he could not “state to a reasonable
degree of medical certainty from a scientific perspective what that mechanism was.” (Id., 153:22-
25.) In fact, he repeatedly stated that he did not “have enough information to be able to speculate
on the underlying mechanism” that caused Plaintiff’s hair loss.4 	(Id., 166:8-20.) 	Thus, Dr.
Serota’s testimony did not just undermine, it completely invalidated his theory of causation, and
he was unable to offer an alternate theory without speculation.
The expert testimony here does not meet the reliability or fit requirements of Rule 702. As
part of the reliability assessment, “the expert must have ‘good grounds’ for his or her belief.” In
re Paoli, 35 F.3d at 742 (quoting Daubert, 509 U.S. at 590). Dr. Serota’s testimony demonstrates
he does not have good grounds for his belief that TRESemmé caused Plaintiff’s hair loss. (See
Serota Dep., 164:17-21) (“Whether the mechanism is allergic contact or a different mechanism, I
don’t think, in this particular case, I can opine with a reasonable degree of medical certainty.”)
4 See also id., 154:3-6 (“Q. What type of mechanism could it be? A. I don’t think I can speculate
on that.”); id., 154:21-23 (“I don’t have enough information to speculate on a mechanism.”); id.,
154:25-155:5 (“Q. What other mechanisms could it be? MR. FEARON: Objection. A. Again, it
would be me speculating.”); id., 164:17-21 (“Whether the mechanism is allergic contact or a
different mechanism, I don’t think, in this particular case, I can opine with a reasonable degree of
medical certainty.”)
Case 2:23-cv-00348-JKS-MAH Document 66 Filed 03/04/26 Page 6 of 13 PageID:
<pageID>
7
During his deposition, his expert opinion shifted from causation to correlation. 	Therefore, Dr.
Serota cannot be allowed to testify to the original causation theory proffered in his expert report.
“In addition to reliability, Rule 702 requires that the expert’s testimony must assist the trier
of fact” which means “the requirement of reliability, or ‘good grounds,’ extends to each step in an
expert’s analysis all the way through the step that connects the work of the expert to the particular
case.” In re Paoli, 35 F.3d at 743. “The opinion must be sufficiently tied to the facts of the case
that it will aid the jury in resolving a factual dispute.” Travelers Prop. Cas. Co. of Am. v. Hallam
Eng’g & Const. Corp., No. 08-0444, 2013 WL 30174, at *6 (D.N.J. Jan. 2, 2013) (cleaned up).
When an expert’s theory of causation is not supported by the underlying facts, it flunks the “fit”
requirement and must be rejected. See, e.g., State Farm Fire & Cas. Co. v. Holmes Prods., 165 F.
App’x 182, 186 (3d Cir. 2006) (“the Court here did not err in excluding Gray’s testimony because
he was only able to state how the fire started in terms of mere possibilities, and this causal
supposition was not sufficiently supported by evidence in the record”). 	Because Dr. Serota
admitted that his theory of causation was not supported by the underlying facts of Plaintiff’s case,
it fails the fit requirement.
In opposition, Plaintiff argues that Dr. Serota’s opinions “are relevant, flow from the facts,
and will aid the jury in determining general and specific causation issues.” (Daubert Opp. at 26.)
But Dr. Serota’s opinion, as offered in his expert report, improperly relies on Plaintiff’s own self-
reporting of her symptoms. The Third Circuit advised that “a physician who evaluates a patient in
preparation for litigation should seek more than a patient’s self-report of symptoms or illness and
hence should either examine the patient or review the patient’s medical records[.]” In re Paoli, 35
F.3d at 762. Plaintiff contends that Plaintiff “gave detailed and sworn chronology of the onset and
nature of her symptoms in her interrogatory responses and during her deposition” that more
Case 2:23-cv-00348-JKS-MAH Document 66 Filed 03/04/26 Page 7 of 13 PageID:
<pageID>
8
accurately reflect “‘the usual inducement to candor—with a physician’ in medical records rather
than a post-litigation symptom ‘checklist’ or similar document provided by a medical expert to a
plaintiff during a lawsuit.” 	(Daubert Opp. at 27) (quoting In re Paoili, 35 F.3d at 761.) 	This
argument, and Plaintiff’s use of selective quotations from Paoli, is unavailing. “While courts allow
reliance on patient statements, they are based upon a personal history corroborated by medical
records, a physical examination and medical tests.” In re Paoili, 35 F.3d at 762. Dr. Serota did
not perform a physical examination or any medical tests on Plaintiff (see Daubert Opp. at 15), and
while Plaintiff is correct that this is not fatal itself, Plaintiff’s medical records do not corroborate
her self-report of symptoms.5 Indeed, Dr. Serota admitted in his deposition that Plaintiff’s medical
records “do not document any sign of dermatitis” and that Plaintiff’s treating physician “saw no
signs of dermatitis on [Plaintiff]’s scalp[.]” (Serota Dep., 144:6-17.)
For the foregoing reasons, the expert testimony here does not meet the standard for
admissibility under Rule 702 or Daubert and must be excluded. The Court need not conduct an
evidentiary hearing to make this determination. See Oddi, 234 F.3d at 154-55 (affirming a district
court’s denial of an evidentiary hearing where the depositions and affidavits of plaintiff’s expert
sufficiently explained the basis for his conclusions); Feit, 271 F. App’x at 250 (finding no error
with District Court’s conclusion that no hearing was necessary because the record included an
5 In July 2021, Plaintiff visited her personal physician Dr. Donna Gavarone to discuss her alleged
hair loss and told Dr. Gavarone that she believed she was losing hair because of COVID. 	(Pl.
Dep., 129:6-14.) During her deposition, Dr. Gavarone confirmed she never observed any signs of
dermatitis on Plaintiff. (ECF 55-3, Gavarone Dep., 38:7-39:5, 41:24-42:6, 45:25-46:19, 47:7-49:8,
50:10-51:6, 52:12-53:3.) Dr. Gavarone testified that she never observed any noticeable signs of
hair loss on Plaintiff either, contrary to Plaintiff’s claims in this case. (Id.) Dr. Gavarone told
Plaintiff that whatever hair loss she may have experienced was likely hereditary because her
mother, who Dr. Gavarone also treated, had thinning hair. (Id., 66:19-22, 68:1-12.)
Case 2:23-cv-00348-JKS-MAH Document 66 Filed 03/04/26 Page 8 of 13 PageID:
<pageID>
9
“expert report, deposition, and letter brief”). 	Defendant’s motion to preclude is therefore
GRANTED.
II. 	MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Defendant has simultaneously filed a motion for summary judgment, asking this Court to
dismiss all counts of Plaintiff’s Complaint.6 (SJM Mot. at 1.) Defendant argues that because Dr.
Serota’s opinion “flunks basic admissibility standards,” Plaintiff’s sole causation cannot be
admitted at trial, and thus her Complaint must be dismissed because Plaintiff cannot meet her
burden to establish causation. 	(Id. at 1-2.) 	Plaintiff maintains that she “has established that
TRESemmé Keratin Smooth shampoo and conditioner containing DMDM, MCI, and MI can cause
contact dermatitis and that contact dermatitis can, in turn, cause hair loss (general causation)”
based on Dr. Serota’s “reliabl[e] opin[ion.]” (SJM Opp. at 15.)
A. Legal Standard
Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 56(a) provides that summary judgment should be granted
if the movant shows that “there is no genuine issue as to any material fact [and] the moving party
is entitled to a judgment as a matter of law.” Kreschollek v. S. Stevedoring Co., 223 F.3d 202, 204
(3d Cir. 2000); see also Anderson v. Liberty Lobby, Inc., 477 U.S. 242, 248 (1986). In deciding a
motion for summary judgment, a court must construe all facts and inferences in the light most
favorable to the nonmoving party. See Boyle v. Cnty. of Allegheny Pa., 139 F.3d 386, 393 (3d Cir.
1998) (citing Peters v. Del. River Port Auth. of Pa. & N.J., 16 F.3d 1346, 1349 (3d Cir. 1994)).
The moving party bears the burden of establishing that no genuine issue of material fact
6 Plaintiff asserts four causes of action in her Complaint, including three product liability claims
(manufacturing defect, design defect, and failure to warn) and one negligence claim. (See ECF 1
¶¶ 46-79.) In Plaintiff’s opposition brief, she withdraws her manufacturing-defect and negligence
causes of action. 	(See SJM Opp. at 3 n.2) (“[Plaintiff] voluntarily dismisses her manufacturing
defect and negligence claims (Counts I and IV of the Complaint).”)
Case 2:23-cv-00348-JKS-MAH Document 66 Filed 03/04/26 Page 9 of 13 PageID:
<pageID>
10
remains. See Celotex Corp. v. Catrett, 477 U.S. 317, 322-23 (1986). “[W]ith respect to an issue on
which the nonmoving party bears the burden of proof . . . the burden on the moving party may be
discharged by ‘showing’ — that is, pointing out to the district court — that there is an absence of
evidence to support the nonmoving party’s case.” Id. at 325.
Once the moving party has met that threshold burden, the non-moving party “must do more
than simply show that there is some metaphysical doubt as to the material facts.” Matsushita Elec.
Indus. Co., Ltd. v. Zenith Radio Corp., 475 U.S. 574, 586 (1986). A fact is only “material” for
purposes of a summary judgment motion if a dispute over that fact “might affect the outcome of
the suit under the governing law.” Anderson, 477 U.S. at 248. A dispute about a material fact is
“genuine” if “the evidence is such that a reasonable jury could return a verdict for the nonmoving
party.” 	Id. 	Unsupported allegations, subjective beliefs, or argument alone, however, cannot
forestall 	summary 	judgment. 	See Lujan 	v. 	Nat’l 	Wildlife 	Fed’n, 	497 	U.S. 	871, 	888
(1988) (nonmoving party may not successfully oppose summary judgment motion by simply
replacing “conclusory allegations of the complaint or answer with conclusory allegations of an
affidavit.”). Thus, if the nonmoving party fails “to make a showing sufficient to establish the
existence of an element essential to that party’s case, and on which that party will bear the burden
of proof at trial . . . there can be ‘no genuine issue of material fact,’ since a complete failure of
proof concerning an essential element of the nonmoving party’s case necessarily renders all other
facts immaterial.” Katz v. Aetna Cas. & Sur. Co., 972 F.2d 53, 55 (3d Cir. 1992) (quoting Celotex,
477 U.S. at 322-23). Moreover, the “mere existence of some alleged factual dispute between the
parties will not defeat an otherwise properly supported motion for summary judgment; the
requirement is that there be no genuine issue of material fact.” Anderson, 477 U.S. at 247-48.
Case 2:23-cv-00348-JKS-MAH Document 66 Filed 03/04/26 Page 10 of 13 PageID:
<pageID>
11
B. Discussion
The Court agrees with Defendant that Plaintiff’s claims fail as a matter of law because
Plaintiff cannot establish the element of causation. Under Pennsylvania law, “[p]roof of causation
is a necessary element in a products liability action. Absent a causal relationship between the
defendant’s product and the plaintiff’s injury the defendant cannot be held liable on a theory of
negligence, strict liability, or misrepresentation.” Riad v. Porsche Cars N. Am., Inc., No. 18-5175,
2024 WL 3606315, at *2 (E.D. Pa. July 30, 2024) (cleaned up). “[T]o meet her causation burden,
plaintiff must first establish that the product is capable of causing the alleged injury (general
causation). She must then establish that, in her particular case, the product did in fact cause her
alleged injury (specific causation).” Ream v. Ethicon, Inc., No. 20-00922, 2020 WL 6889238, at
*4 (M.D. Pa. Nov. 24, 2020) (cleaned up).7 “Further, a plaintiff must establish causation through
admissible expert testimony.” Ream, 2020 WL 6889238, at *4 (citation omitted); see Bailey v. B.S.
Quarries, Inc., No. 13-3006, 2017 WL 4366987, at *3 (M.D. Pa. Sept. 29, 2017) (“a product
liability claim must be supported by expert witness testimony”).8
Defendant argues that without Plaintiff’s expert’s opinion on the causation of her hair loss,
Plaintiff cannot prove the essential element of her claims, and Defendant is entitled to judgment
7 Plaintiff is a citizen of Pennsylvania, and Defendant “assumes for the purposes of this motion
that Pennsylvania law governs the substantive elements of Plaintiff’s product-liability claims.”
(SJM Mot. at 5.) The law is no different in New Jersey. See Coffman v. Keene Corp., 133 N.J.
581, 594 (1993) (“causation is a fundamental requisite for establishing any product-liability
action”); Martin v. Blaser Swisslube, Inc., No. 03-6116, 2005 WL 3454291, at *2 (D.N.J. Dec. 16,
2005) (“Two types of causation must be established to prevail in a products liability action:
product-defect causation, and medical causation.”) (citing Coffman).
8 New Jersey courts have reached similar results, concluding that questions of “medical causation”
are “plainly outside the common knowledge of the average juror.” 	Quail v. Shop-Rite
Supermarkets, Inc., 455 N.J. Super. 118, 135 (App. Div. 2018); see Feit, 271 F. App’x at 252
(“Generally, expert testimony is needed to prove causation of a medical condition.”) (applying
New Jersey law).
Case 2:23-cv-00348-JKS-MAH Document 66 Filed 03/04/26 Page 11 of 13 PageID:
<pageID>
12
as a matter of law. (SJM Mot. at 9) (citing Fabrizi v. Rexall Sundown, Inc., No. 01-289, 2004 WL
1202984, at *12 (W.D. Pa. June 2, 2004) (report and recommendation adopted June 24, 2004)
(“Where a plaintiff fails to present admissible expert testimony regarding causation, courts
routinely have granted summary judgment in favor of the defendant.”) (citing Heller v. Shaw
Indus., Inc., 167 F.3d 146, 165 (3d Cir. 1999)).)9
Plaintiff does not respond to Defendant’s argument. (See SJM Reply at 2) (“Plaintiff does
not dispute that if her expert is precluded from testifying at trial, the Court must enter summary
judgment in favor of Unilever on all of her claims.”) 	“It is well-settled that failure to meet an
opponent’s arguments operates as a concession.” Gillham v. Virgin Islands Supreme Court, No.
22-00044, 2023 WL 4865072, at *3 (D.V.I. July 28, 2023), aff’d sub nom. Gillham v. Supreme
Court of Virgin Islands, No. 23-2478, 2025 WL 227687 (3d Cir. Jan. 17, 2025) (citing In re
Bestwall LLC, 47 F.4th 233, 244 (3d Cir. 2022) (finding that a court may “treat the failure of a
party to respond to its opponent’s arguments as a concession” that the assertions are true) (cleaned
up)). Plaintiff thus concedes that without expert testimony, her claims fail as a matter of law. See
Woodell v. Coach, No. 22-2222, 2022 WL 17486262, at *3 (D.N.J. Dec. 7, 2022) (“As [plaintiff]
does not address these arguments in his opposition brief, any arguments in opposition are deemed
waived.”).
Because this Court has found that Plaintiff’s expert is precluded from testifying, Plaintiff
cannot prove causation, which is an element necessary to establish her product liability claims.
9 See also Murray v. Consol. Rail Corp., No. A-0664-21, 2023 WL 2193825, at *6 (N.J. Super.
Ct. App. Div. Feb. 24, 2023) (“Having affirmed the motion judge’s order excluding Dr. Levin’s
report and testimony, we also affirm his order granting defendant’s summary-judgment motion.”);
Rice v. Gold Medal Env’t of NJ, Inc., No. A-0768-22, 2024 WL 1316076, at *5 (N.J. Super. Ct.
App. Div. Mar. 28, 2024) (same); Olson v. Sunoco, Inc., No. A-4769-12T1, 2014 WL 7671579,
*2 (N.J. Super. Ct. App. Div. Jan. 26, 2015) (same); Schweiger v. Standard Tile Supply, Co., No.
A-1322-18T2, 2019 WL 5783478, *4 (N.J. Super. Ct. App. Div. Nov. 6, 2019) (same).
Case 2:23-cv-00348-JKS-MAH Document 66 Filed 03/04/26 Page 12 of 13 PageID:
<pageID>
13
Therefore, the Court will enter summary judgment in Defendant’s favor and dismiss Plaintiff’s
remaining design-defect and failure to warn claims. See Oddi v. Ford Motor Co., 234 F.3d 136,
159 (3d Cir. 2000) (“Inasmuch as Oddi’s ‘defect expert’ does not survive Daubert scrutiny, the
district court properly granted summary judgment to Ford and Grumman on Oddi’s negligent
failure to test claim.”)
III. 	CONCLUSION
For the reasons stated above, Defendant’s motions to preclude (ECF 41) and for summary
judgment (ECF 43) are GRANTED. 	Plaintiff’s Complaint (ECF 1) is DISMISSED with
prejudice. An appropriate order follows.
/s/ Jamel K. Semper 	.
H ON. JAMEL K. S EMPER
United States District Judge
Orig: 	Clerk
cc: 	Michael A. Hammer, U.S.M.J.
Parties
Case 2:23-cv-00348-JKS-MAH Document 66 Filed 03/04/26 Page 13 of 13 PageID:
<pageID>

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.