TAMBURRINO, M.D. et al v. UNITEDHEALTH GROUP INC. et al

2:21-cv-12766Njd28 janv. 2026

Texte intégral

1
NOT FOR PUBLICATION
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF NEW JERSEY
JOSEPH F. TAMBURRINO, M.D., as an
assignee and authorized representative of
his 	patient 	L.K., 	and 	BARBARA
WILLIAMS, on behalf of themselves and
on behalf of all others similarly situated,
Plaintiffs,
v.
UNITED HEALTHCARE INSURANCE
COMPANY,
Defendant.
Civil Action No. 21-12766 (SDW) (LDW)
OPINION
January 28, 2026
WIGENTON, District Judge.
Before 	this 	Court 	is 	Plaintiff 	Barbara 	Williams’s 	(“Plaintiff”) 	Motion 	for 	Class
Certification (D.E. 119 (“Mot.”)) pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure (“Rule”) 23.
Jurisdiction is proper pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1331 and 29 U.S.C. § 1132(e). 	Venue is proper
pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1391(b) and 29 U.S.C. § 1132(e). 	This opinion is issued without oral
argument pursuant to Rule 78 and Local Civil Rule 78.1. For the reasons stated herein, Plaintiff’s
Motion is DENIED.
I. 	FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND1
1 This Court also incorporates the background sections from its opinions dated April 25, 2022, and January 26, 2023.
(D.E. 35 at 1–3 (“April 25 Opinion”); D.E. 51 at 1–2 (“January 26 Opinion”)).
Case 2:21-cv-12766-SDW-LDW Document 140 Filed 01/28/26 Page 1 of 11 PageID:
<pageID>
2
Plaintiff’s Motion arises out of her claim that Defendant denied coverage to herself and all
of the putative class members because of its application of a denial policy that relies on
inapplicable Medicare billing and coding guidelines. 	Specifically, Plaintiff contends that
Defendant relied on Medicare billing and coding guidelines, rather than using HCPCS S2068, the
billing code created for DIEP flap microsurgery.
Plaintiff is enrolled in a health insurance plan governed by the Employee Retirement
Income Security Act (“ERISA”) and allegedly administered by Defendant. 	On September 24,
2018, Drs. Taylor Theunissen and Alireza Sadeghi performed, as co-surgeons, a post-mastectomy
delayed bilateral breast reconstruction with deep inferior epigastric perforator (“DIEP”) flap
microsurgery on Plaintiff. (D.E. 37 ¶ 51.) After the surgery, Drs. Theunissen billed Defendant for
the services he rendered. (Id. ¶¶ 52-53.) Defendant denied reimbursement for services performed
by Drs. Theunissen and Sadeghi because they operated as co-surgeons. (Id.) Dr. Theunissen
appealed Defendant’s decision, but Defendant upheld the denial. (Id. ¶¶ 54-57.)
On June 21, 2021, then-named Plaintiffs2, Dr. Joseph Tamburrino and Dr. Theunissen,
instituted this putative class action challenging then-named Defendants alleged “uniform claim
processing and reimbursement policy that denies coverage to United members whose plastic
surgeons perform DIEP flap microsurgery as either assistant surgeons or as co-surgeons.”3 (D.E.
1 ¶ 6.) 	Defendants moved to dismiss the original complaint. 	(D.E. 11.) In response, Plaintiffs
2 The original Complaint and First Amended Complaint (“FAC”) named as plaintiffs Drs. Joseph Tamburrino and
Taylor Theunissen. (D.E. 1, 28.) The named plaintiffs in the Second Amended Complaint were Dr. Tamburrino and
Barbara Williams. (D.E. 37.)
3 The original Complaint and FAC named as defendants the following six entities: United Healthcare Insurance
Company, UnitedHealth Group Inc., United Healthcare Services, Inc., United Healthcare Service LLC, Oxford Health
Plans, LLC, and Oxford Health Insurance, Inc. 	(D.E. 1, 28.) The sole defendant named in the SAC is United
Healthcare Insurance Company. (D.E. 37.)
Case 2:21-cv-12766-SDW-LDW Document 140 Filed 01/28/26 Page 2 of 11 PageID:
<pageID>
3
opposed Defendants’ motion and cross-moved for leave to file an amended complaint, (D.E. 25),
which this Court granted, (D.E. 26).
On October 11, 2021, the same Plaintiffs filed a three-count First Amended Class Action
Complaint (“FAC”) alleging wrongful denial of benefits under 29 U.S.C. § 1132(a)(1)(B) (Count
I), a claim for equitable relief under 29 U.S.C. § 1132(a)(3)(A) (Count II), and a claim for equitable
relief under 29 U.S.C. § 1132(a)(3)(B) (Count III).4 (See generally D.E. 28.) On November 10,
2021, the same then-named Defendants again moved to dismiss all of Dr. Theunissen’s claims, all
claims against UnitedHealth Group Inc., United Healthcare Services, Inc., United Healthcare
Service LLC, Oxford Health Plans, LLC, and Oxford Health Insurance, Inc., and Counts II and
III. (D.E. 31.) On April 25, 2022, this Court granted Defendants’ motion to dismiss and specifically
provided Plaintiffs with “one final opportunity to amend the complaint” to cure the deficiencies
therein. (D.E. 35 at 12.)
On May 25, 2022, Plaintiffs Dr. Tamburrino and Barbara Williams filed the Second
Amended Complaint (“SAC”), in which they allege the same three counts as in the FAC against
only Defendant United Healthcare Insurance Company. (D.E. 37.) On June 22, 2022, Defendant
moved to partially dismiss the SAC because Plaintiffs failed to adequately plead a breach of
fiduciary duty by Defendant or any other theory of liability that would warrant additional equitable
relief under Section 502(a)(3) (Counts II and III). 	(D.E. 42.) 	On January 26, 2023, this Court
issued an Opinion granting Defendant’s partial motion to dismiss and dismissed Counts II and III
with prejudice. 	(D.E. 51.) 	On November 14, 2024, Dr. Tamburrino voluntarily dismissed his
claims against Defendant, leaving Plaintiff Williams as the sole plaintiff and proposed class
representative. (D.E. 103.) On July 1, 2025, Plaintiff filed the instant Motion to certify this case
4 Hereinafter, 29 U.S.C. § 1132(a) will be referred to as ERISA § 502(a).
Case 2:21-cv-12766-SDW-LDW Document 140 Filed 01/28/26 Page 3 of 11 PageID:
<pageID>
4
to proceed as a class action pursuant to Rule 23(b)(1) or (2). (See D.E. 119 and D.E. 120.) Plaintiff
seeks to certify the following class:
All people in the United States who were a member of a health
benefit plan governed by ERISA (a) whose request for coverage for
DIEP Flap surgery was denied by UHIC on or after June 21, 2015;
where (b) such denial was based on UHIC’s Co-Surgeons/Team
Surgeon Policy, Assistants-at-Surgery Policy, or UHIC’s Breast
Reconstruction Policy; and (c) such denial was not reversed on
administrative appeal.
The parties timely completed briefing.
II. 	LEGAL STANDARD
A 	“party 	proposing 	class-action 	certification 	bears 	the 	burden 	of 	affirmatively
demonstrating by a preponderance of the evidence ... compliance with the requirements of Rule
23.” Byrd v. Aaron's Inc., 784 F.3d 154, 163 (3d Cir. 2015), as amended (Apr. 28, 2015) (citing
Comcast Corp. v. Behrend, 569 U.S. 27, 33 (2013)). 	Specifically, “every putative class action
must satisfy the four requirements of Rule 23(a) and the requirements of either Rule 23(b)(1), (2),
or (3).” Marcus v. BMW of N. Am., LLC, 687 F.3d 583, 590 (3d Cir. 2012). Under Rule 23(a), a
class may be certified only if:
(1) the class is so numerous that joinder of all members is
impracticable; (2) there are questions of law or fact common to the
class; (3) the claims or defenses of the representative parties are
typical 	of 	the 	claims 	or 	defenses 	of 	the 	class; 	and 	(4) 	the
representative parties will fairly and adequately protect the interests
of the class.
Fed. R. Civ. P 23(a)(1)–(4). These requirements are, respectively, referred to as the numerosity,
commonality, typicality, and adequacy requirements. 	See, e.g., Marcus, 687 F.3d at 590–91.
Under Rule 23(b)(2), a class action may be maintained if “the party opposing the class has acted
or refused to act on grounds that apply generally to the class, so that final injunctive relief or
Case 2:21-cv-12766-SDW-LDW Document 140 Filed 01/28/26 Page 4 of 11 PageID:
<pageID>
5
corresponding declaratory relief is appropriate respecting the class as a whole.” Fed. R. Civ. P.
23(b)(2). Additionally, under Rule 23(b)(2), a plaintiff must show the class claims are cohesive
among the class members. See Gates v. Rohm & Haas Co., 665 F.3d 255, 263-64 (3d Cir. 2011).
III. 	DISCUSSION
A. Numerosity
A party seeking class certification must show that “the class is so numerous that joinder of
all members is impracticable.” Fed. R. Civ. P. 23(a)(1). 	“No minimum number of plaintiffs is
required to maintain a suit as a class action, but generally if the named plaintiff demonstrates that
the potential number of plaintiffs exceeds 40, the first prong of Rule 23(a) has been met.” Stewart
v. Abraham, 275 F.3d 220, 226–27 (3d Cir. 2001). Plaintiff alleges the numerosity requirement is
satisfied because discovery revealed thousands of claims that were denied due to Defendant’s
reimbursement policy at issue. (D.E. 120 (“Mov. Br.”) at 32.) Defendant does not dispute whether
Plaintiff satisfies the numerosity requirement. 	Accordingly, the numerosity requirement is
satisfied because the claims data produced by Defendant demonstrates a sufficient number of
potential plaintiffs.
B. Commonality
Plaintiff states that several questions of law and fact are common to all class members.
Specifically, Plaintiff alleges common issues are: (1) whether Defendant maintained uniform
surgical team policies that resulted in systemic denials of covered claims; (2) whether Defendant’s
policy violates ERISA; and (3) whether Defendant’s denial of coverage for assistants-at-surgery
and co-surgeons violates the terms of the plans at issue. (Mov. Br. at 34.) In response, Defendant
asserts that Plaintiff fails to satisfy the commonality requirement because the alleged class-wide
injury cannot be resolved without individualized inquiries because of variations in plan language.
Case 2:21-cv-12766-SDW-LDW Document 140 Filed 01/28/26 Page 5 of 11 PageID:
<pageID>
6
(D.E. 123 (“Opp. Br.”) at 30.) Plaintiff counters that the variations in plan language are immaterial
because the class members suffered the same injury and were deprived of the coverage promised
in their plan documents. (D.E. 126 (“Reply Br.”) at 5, 16.)
Rule 23(a) requires that Plaintiff identify “questions of law or fact common to the class.”
Fed. R. Civ. P. 23(a)(2). 	The commonality requirement is met “if the named plaintiffs share at
least one question of fact or law with the grievances of the prospective class.” 	In re Schering
Plough Corp. ERISA Litig., 589 F.3d 585, 596–97 (3d Cir. 2009) (citing Baby Neal v. Casey, 43
F.3d 48, 56 (3d Cir. 1994)). 	However, the claims of the class members “ ‘must depend upon a
common contention ... [which] must be of such a nature that it is capable of class-wide resolution
– which means that determination of its truth or falsity will resolve an issue that is central to the
validity of each one of the claims in one stroke.’ ” Mielo v. Steak ‘n Shake Operations, Inc., 897
F.3d 467, 489 (3d Cir. 2018) (quoting Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. v. Dukes, 564 U.S. 338, 349-50
(2011)) (emphasis added).
Here, importantly, Plaintiff seeks class certification to pursue her claims for benefits under
ERISA § 502(a)(1)(B). 	To assert a claim under ERISA § 502(a)(1)(B), a plan participant must
demonstrate that “he or she ... ha[s] a right to benefits that is legally enforceable against the plan,”
and that the plan administrator improperly denied those benefits. 	Fleisher v. Standard Ins. Co.,
679 F.3d 116, 120 (3d Cir. 2012). The Supreme Court has held that “a denial of benefits challenged
under [ERISA] is to be reviewed under a de novo standard unless the benefit plan gives the
administrator or fiduciary discretionary authority to determine eligibility for benefits or to construe
the terms of the plan.” Firestone Tire & Rubber Co. v. Bruch, 489 U.S. 101, 115 (1989). If the
plan gives the administrator or fiduciary discretionary authority to make eligibility determinations,
a court reviews its decisions under an abuse-of-discretion (or arbitrary and capricious) standard.
Case 2:21-cv-12766-SDW-LDW Document 140 Filed 01/28/26 Page 6 of 11 PageID:
<pageID>
7
Viera v. Life Ins. Co. of N. Am., 642 F.3d 407, 413 (3d Cir. 2011) (citing Metro. Life Ins. Co. v.
Glenn, 554 U.S. 105, 111 (2008)). “Whether a plan administrator's exercise of power is mandatory
or discretionary depends upon the terms of the plan.” 	Luby v. Teamsters Health, Welfare, &
Pension Trust Funds, 944 F.2d 1176, 1180 (3d Cir. 1991). Therefore, to determine whether the
plan administrator improperly denied benefits, a court must determine the applicable standard of
review.
This Court agrees with Defendant that the question of which standard of review applies to
the members’ plan cannot be resolved on a class-wide basis and as such, Plaintiff fails to satisfy
the commonality requirement. 	Courts in this district have found that a proposed class fails to
satisfy the commonality requirement when a court is required to engage in individualized inquiries
to resolve the class members’ claims. See e.g., Lipstein v. UnitedHealth Grp., 296 F.R.D. 279, 288
(D.N.J. 2013) (finding that no single common answer could possibly answer the class members'
claims because the court would need to make individual determinations after analyzing each plan's
language and potentially other evidence relevant to each claim); see also Wragg v. Ortiz, 462 F.
Supp. 3d 476, 515 (D.N.J. 2020) (stating that plaintiffs failed to satisfy the commonality
requirement because the court would be required to engage in an intensive, multi-step,
individualized inquiry as to whether each prisoner met criteria for conditional release). Here, this
Court cannot determine which plans reserve discretion without reviewing the plan language of
each members’ plan, and Plaintiff offers no method of identifying plans that reserve discretion on
a class-wide basis. As such, determining which standard of review applies to each plan would
require an individualized, fact-specific inquiry, as this Court would have to review each individual
plan to ascertain which plans reserve discretion and how far that discretion extends.
Case 2:21-cv-12766-SDW-LDW Document 140 Filed 01/28/26 Page 7 of 11 PageID:
<pageID>
8
Although Plaintiff contends that the variations in plan language are immaterial, the
difference in whether this Court should apply a de novo, arbitrary and capricious, or a more
deferential standard of review could materially impact the outcomes of each class member’s claim.
Accordingly, the claims of the class members cannot be resolved in a single stroke and Plaintiff
fails to establish the Rule 23(a) prerequisite of commonality. 	See Mielo v. Steak ‘n Shake
Operations, Inc., 897 F.3d 467, 489 (3d Cir. 2018) (stating that class members' claims must
“depend upon a common contention” that “is capable of class wide resolution ... in one stroke)
(internal citation omitted). 	Therefore, Plaintiff’s Motion for Class Certification is denied. 	See
Marcus v. BMW of N. Am., LLC, 687 F.3d 583, 590 (3d Cir. 2012) (“[E]very putative class action
must satisfy the four requirements of Rule 23(a) . . .”). 	Notwithstanding, this Court shall address
the remaining factors.
C. Typicality
Typicality requires that “the claims or defenses of the representative parties are typical of
the claims or defenses of the class.” Fed. R. Civ. P. 23(a)(3). This requirement “ensur[es] that the
class representatives are sufficiently similar to the rest of the class—in terms of their legal claims,
factual circumstances, and stake in the litigation—so that certifying those individuals to represent
the class will be fair to the rest of the proposed class.” In re Schering Plough Corp. ERISA Litig.,
589 F.3d 585, 598 (3d Cir. 2009) (citations omitted). In determining whether the typicality
requirement for class certification is satisfied, courts must address three concerns:
(1) the claims of the class representative must be generally the same
as those of the class in terms of both (a) the legal theory advanced
and (b) the factual circumstances underlying that theory; (2) the
class representative must not be subject to a defense that is both
inapplicable to many members of the class and likely to become a
major focus of the litigation; and (3) the interests and incentives of
the representative must be sufficiently aligned with those of the
class.
Case 2:21-cv-12766-SDW-LDW Document 140 Filed 01/28/26 Page 8 of 11 PageID:
<pageID>
9
Marcus v. BMW of N. Am., LLC, 687 F.3d 583, 598 (3d Cir. 2012) (citing Schering Plough, 589
F.3d at 597-99). “It is well-established that a proposed class representative is not ‘typical’ under
Rule 23(a)(3) if ‘the representative is subject to a unique defense that is likely to become a major
focus of the litigation.’ ” Schering Plough, 589 F.3d at 598 (quoting Beck v. Maximus, Inc., 457
F.3d 291, 301 (3d Cir. 2006)).
Plaintiff asserts that she satisfies the Rule 23(a)(3) typicality requirement because Plaintiff
makes the same legal argument and alleges the same unlawful conduct as putative class members.
(Mov. Br. at 30.) 	Defendant contends that Plaintiff fails to satisfy Rule 23(a)(3)’s typicality
requirement because there are defenses applicable to the class that may not be applicable to
Plaintiff. 	(Opp. Br. at 29-32.) 	Specifically, Defendant highlights that the variety of limitation
periods in members’ plans demonstrate that some class members’ claim may be untimely. (Id.)
Here, Plaintiff seeks to certify a class dating back to June 21, 2015. 	However, as
demonstrated by the sample claims5, there is a wide variety of limitation periods amongst the
members’ plans, ranging from a three-year limitation period to a one-year limitation period.
Consequently, several class members’ claims would be time barred. 	Despite the time-barred
claims, Plaintiff argues that statute of limitation issues do not defeat typicality. However, the Third
Circuit has highlighted that statute of limitation issues overlap with certain Rule 23 requirements;
and may preclude a finding of typicality where the proposed class includes numerous class
members with untimely claims, thereby rendering the named plaintiff’s timely claims atypical.
See In re Cmty. Bank of N. Virginia, 622 F.3d 275, 293 (3d Cir. 2010). Based on the sample claims
5 In response to Plaintiff’s claims, Defendant produced claims data for the time period of January 2018 to July 2023
that contained claims for ERISA plans whose members submitted claims for DIEP flap microsurgery under the HCPCS
S2068 code with co-surgeon or assistant surgeon modifiers. From the produced claims data, the parties agreed upon
a sample of 30 DIEP flap microsurgery claim denials, including Plaintiff, as the “Member Sample.”
Case 2:21-cv-12766-SDW-LDW Document 140 Filed 01/28/26 Page 9 of 11 PageID:
<pageID>
10
and thousands of putative class members, it is likely that the numerous class members with
untimely claims could render Plaintiff’s timely claims atypical. Regardless, this Court need not
render a decision on this element because certification is denied on other dispositive grounds.
D. Adequacy
To show adequacy, the named plaintiffs must show that they will “fairly and adequately
protect the interests of the class.” Fed. R. Civ. P. 23(a)(4). 	This inquiry is twofold. 	First, “the
named plaintiffs’ interests must be sufficiently aligned with the interests of the absentees.” Beneli
v. BCA Fin. Servs., Inc., 324 F.R.D. 89, 98 (D.N.J. 2018) (citing In re General Motors, 55 F.3d
768, 800 (3d Cir. 1995)). Second, “the plaintiff's counsel must be qualified to represent the class.”
Id. 	“The party challenging representation bears the burden of proving the representation is not
adequate.” In re Prudential Ins. Co. of Am. Sales Practices Litig., 962 F. Supp. 450, 519 (D.N.J.
1997).
Here, Defendant raises significant concerns regarding Plaintiff’s ability to serve as class
representative. 	First, Defendant highlights that the relief sought by Plaintiff, reprocessing of
claims, may be harmful to some class members as they could be worse off financially while
providers may be better off financially. (Opp. Br. at 41.) Second, Defendant points to Plaintiff’s
sworn deposition testimony where Plaintiff expressed doubts or an unwillingness to serve as a
class representative. (Id. at 43.) Plaintiff counters that Defendant’s arguments are speculative and
mischaracterizes Plaintiff’s testimony. (Reply Br. at 18.) While there may be issues concerning
Plaintiff’s ability to adequately protect the interests of the class, this Court need not reach a
decision at this time, as certification is denied on other grounds.
E. Rule 23(b) Requirements
Case 2:21-cv-12766-SDW-LDW Document 140 Filed 01/28/26 Page 10 of 11 PageID:
<pageID>
11
This Court need not address whether Plaintiff has met the requirements of Rule 23(b),
because Plaintiff has not met the prerequisite requirements of Rule 23(a).
IV. 	CONCLUSION
For the reasons stated above, Plaintiff’s Motion for Class Certification is DENIED. An
appropriate order follows.
/s/ Susan D. Wigenton
SUSAN D. WIGENTON, U.S.D.J.
Orig: 	Clerk
cc: 	Parties
Leda D. Wettre, U.S.M.J.
Case 2:21-cv-12766-SDW-LDW Document 140 Filed 01/28/26 Page 11 of 11 PageID:
<pageID>

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.