JOHNSON v. COMODO GROUP, INC.

2:16-cv-04469Njd4 févr. 2026

Texte intégral

1
NOT FOR PUBLICATION
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
DISTRICT OF NEW JERSEY
MICHAEL JOHNSON, on behalf of himself and
others similarly situated,
Plaintiff,
v.
COMODO GROUP, Inc.,
Defendant.
Civil Action No. 16-4469
OPINION
February 4, 2026
SEMPER, District Judge.
The matter comes before the Court on Plaintiff Michael Johnson’s (“Plaintiff”) unopposed
motion for final approval of class action settlement (ECF 354, “Settl. Mot.”) and motion for
attorney’s fees, expenses, and an incentive award (ECF 351, “Fees Mot.”). Defendant Comodo
Group, Inc. (“CGI”) does not oppose either motion. The Court reviewed the submissions made in
support of the motions and held a final approval hearing on November 4, 2025. (ECF 357.) 	For
the reasons stated below, Plaintiff’s motions are GRANTED.
I. 	BACKGROUND AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY
This settlement represents the culmination of several years of hard-fought and complex
litigation. Plaintiff initiated this class action lawsuit in 2016, alleging that Defendant violated the
Telephone Consumer Protection Act (“TCPA”), 47 U.S.C. § 227(b)(1)(A)(iii), by making
automated telemarketing calls to sell encrypted software to class members’ cell phones without
their consent. (ECF 1 ¶¶ 1, 4.) The TCPA prohibits auto dialed or pre-recorded marketing calls to
cellular telephones without the called party’s prior express written consent. 	47 U.S.C. §
Case 2:16-cv-04469-JKS-LDW Document 358 Filed 02/04/26 Page 1 of 19 PageID:
<pageID>
2
227(b)(1)(A)(iii). As set forth in the Third Amended Complaint (“TAC”), the operative pleading,
Plaintiff alleges CGI engaged in a sophisticated sales practice to identify sales targets, call them
using a prerecorded message, and did so without any consent; express, implied, written or
otherwise. (ECF 243, TAC, ¶¶ 14–48.) 	Plaintiff sought $500 in statutory damages for each of
CGI’s violations of the TCPA with trebling of up to $1,500 for willful violations. (Id. ¶¶ 70, 78.)
This Court certified a class of (1) all persons in the United States (2) to whose cellular
telephone number Comodo made a telemarketing call (3) using a prerecorded voice (4) within four
years of the filing of the complaint. (See ECF 256; ECF 257.) Motion practice has been “extensive
and contentious.” (Settl. Mot at 5.) The Court granted Plaintiff’s motion for class certification,
denied Defendant’s motion for summary judgment, denied Defendant’s multiple motions to strike
the testimony of Plaintiff’s expert, and denied Defendant’s motion to decertify the class. (See ECF
221, 321, 322.) 	In addition, Defendant sought interlocutory review of this Court’s class
certification and summary judgment rulings, which was denied by the Third Circuit. See Johnson
v. Comodo Grp. Inc., 20-2113, 2021 WL 10312101 (3d Cir. Sept. 7, 2021). Document production
throughout this litigation included emails, contracts, system manuals, slideshows, audio recordings
and call records. (Settl. Mot. at 4-5.) The parties also engaged in multiple settlement conferences
and mediations. (Id. at 5.)
The parties have agreed to a class-wide settlement where Defendant will pay $1,625,000
to settle the case, with average recovery of approximately $596. (Id. at 2.) Class members will
receive a cash award weighted by the number of allegedly unlawful calls sent to them. (Id.) Each
class member who submitted a valid claim form shall receive a pro rata share of the net-settlement
fund (the Settlement Fund minus administrative costs, the Fee and Costs Award and the Incentive
Award) weighted by the number of calls that used a prerecorded voice to the corresponding phone
Case 2:16-cv-04469-JKS-LDW Document 358 Filed 02/04/26 Page 2 of 19 PageID:
<pageID>
3
number as reflected in the call data. (ECF 349-3, “Settlement Agr.” Art III ¶ 1(d).)كThe claimed
call amount will be capped at $1,500 per call which is the maximum available damages. (Id.) If
money remains in the Settlement Fund from un-cashed benefit checks (checks sent to claiming
class members which the members do not cash or deposit), the settlement administrator shall make
a second distribution of the settlement fund to those who did cash their checks,كprovided that the
total amount paid to any class member from the first and second distributions combined shall not
exceed the $1,500 cap per claimed call. (Id, Art III, ¶ 1(h).) If any amounts remain in the fund, the
remaining amounts will go to a cy pres recipient. (Id., Art III, ¶ 1(i).) No amount of the settlement
fund will revert to the Defendant. (Id.)
In exchange for the benefits of the Settlement, Plaintiff has agreed to dismiss this litigation
with prejudice as to himself and all class members. (Id., Art V ¶ 1(a).) Plaintiff and all class
members who do not timely opt out will release Defendant from all claims “pertaining to the
telephone calls made and/or calling practices utilized by or on behalf of CGI between July 22,
2012, and the date of entry of the Preliminary Approval Order to Class Members.” (Id.)
On June 17, 2025, this Court preliminarily approved the settlement agreement. (ECF 350.)
Pursuant to that preliminary approval order, notice was sent to class members by email and
postcard with the terms of the settlement and inviting members to submit claims.1 (ECF 354-5,
“Cordova Decl.”, ¶¶ 4-10.) 	Verita, the class administrator, established a settlement website,
www.ComodoTCPA.com, to provide potential class members with access to the Long Form
Notice, Claim Form and other settlement-related documents. (Id. ¶ 11). Verita also established a
1 Pursuant to the Class Action Fairness Act, 28 U.S.C. §1715(b), on May 5, 2025, Verita, the class
administrator, sent CAFA Notice identifying the required documents to (a) the Attorney General
of the United States, (b) the fifty-five (55) state and territorial Attorneys General, identified in the
service list for the CAFA Notice. (Cordova Decl. ¶¶ 2-3).
Case 2:16-cv-04469-JKS-LDW Document 358 Filed 02/04/26 Page 3 of 19 PageID:
<pageID>
4
toll-free hotline for class members to call and obtain information about the settlement, request a
notice packet, and seek assistance from a live operator during regular business hours. (Id. ¶ 12.)
Of the 12,757 class members identified there have been 1,266 valid claims, which represents a
10.2% claim rate. (Id. ¶ 13.) Those 1,266 valid claims are associated with 4,631 separate calls,
with the average number of calls per valid claim of 3.66. (Id.) The objection, exclusion, and claim
deadline was September 15, 2025. (Id.) There were no objections or requests for exclusion. (Id.
¶¶ 14-15.) Verita’s costs to complete class administration are $88,377.08. (Id. ¶ 16.)
II. 	Final Settlement Approval
a. 	Rule 23
Under Rule 23(e)(2) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, the Court may approve a
proposed settlement of a class action after a hearing if the settlement “is fair, reasonable and
adequate.” Fed. R. Civ. P. 23(e)(2). The law encourages and favors settlement of civil actions in
federal courts, particularly in complex class actions. In re General Motors Corp. Pick–Up Truck
Fuel Tank Products Liability Litigation, 55 F.3d 768, 784 (3d Cir. 1995). As a result, when a
settlement is reached on terms agreeable to all parties, it is to be encouraged. Bell Atl. Corp. v.
Bolger, 2 F.3d 1304, 1314 & n.16 (3d Cir. 1993).
The four factors set out in Rule 23(e)(2) include: (A) whether the class representatives and
class counsel have adequately represented the class;ك(B) whether the proposed settlement was
negotiated at arm’s length; (C) whether the relief provided for the class is adequate, taking into
account:ك(i) the costs, risks, and delay of trial and appeal; (ii) the effectiveness of any proposed
method of distributing relief to the class, including the method of processing class member claims;
(iii) the terms of any proposed award of attorneys’ fees, including timing of payment; and (iv) any
Case 2:16-cv-04469-JKS-LDW Document 358 Filed 02/04/26 Page 4 of 19 PageID:
<pageID>
5
agreement required to be identified under Rule 23(e)(3); and (D) whether the proposal treats class
members equitably relative to each other. Fed. R. Civ. P. 23(e)(2).
b. 	Girsch Factors
In determining the reasonableness, fairness, and adequacy of a proposed settlement for the
purposes of Rule 23(e), courts consider the following factors, known as the Girsch factors: (1) the
complexity, expense and likely duration of the litigation; (2) the reaction of the class to the
settlement; (3) the stage of the proceedings and the amount of discovery completed; (4) the risks
of establishing liability; (5) the risks of establishing damages; (6) the risks of maintaining the class
action through the trial; (7) the ability of the defendants to withstand a greater judgment; (8) the
range of reasonableness of the settlement fund in light of the best possible recovery; and (9) the
range of reasonableness of the settlement fund in light of all the attendant risks of litigation. In re
Nat’l Football League, 821 F.3d at 437 (citing Girsh v. Jepson, 521 F.2d 153, 157 (3d Cir. 1975)).
The settling parties bear the burden of establishing that the Girsh factors weigh in favor of
approval. But the ultimate decision of whether to approve a proposed settlement “is left to the
sound discretion of the district court.” Girsh, 521 F.2d at 157.
i. 	Adequate Representation and Arms-Length Negotiation
Rule 23(e)(2)(A) and (B) look “to the conduct of the litigation” and “the negotiations
leading up to the proposed settlement” to determine whether the class representative and class
counsel have adequately represented the class and whether the proposed settlement was negotiated
at arm’s length. Advisory Committee Notes to 2018 Amendments (324 F.R.D. 904, 919).
This litigation has already spanned ten years and has been exhaustively litigated. 	See
Castro v. Sanofi Pasteur Inc., 11-7178, 2017 WL 4776626, at *3 (D.N.J. Oct. 23, 2017) (approving
class action settlement where litigation spanned six years). 	Class counsel underwent extensive
Case 2:16-cv-04469-JKS-LDW Document 358 Filed 02/04/26 Page 5 of 19 PageID:
<pageID>
6
discovery in this matter, won class certification, defeated summary judgment, defeated two
attempts to strike Plaintiff’s expert’s testimony and to decertify the class. (See Settl. Mot. at 14.)
Class counsel also has extensive experience in class action litigation.2 	(Id.) 	The settlement
agreement is a result of an arm’s length negotiation3 because neither Plaintiff nor Plaintiff’s
counsel are affiliated with CGI; moreover, the parties have been adverse for years and were unable
to reach an agreement early in litigation. (Id. 15-16.)
ii. 	Adequacy of the Relief
Rule 23(e)(2)(C)(i) overlaps significant with the Girsch factors. Both sets of factors advise
the Court to consider the adequacy of the settlement relief given the costs, risks, and delay that
trial and appeal would inevitably impose. Compare Fed. R. Civ. P. 23(e)(2)(C)(i), with Girsh, 521
F.2d at 157. The relief here is distinctly favorable compared to other TCPA cases. The average
recovery per claiming member, $596.17, is far above the average recovery for TCPA class
settlements. See, e.g., Desouza v. Aerocare Holdings LLC, 2024 WL 1252384, at *3 (M.D. Fla.
Mar. 25, 2024) (“$160 per class member . . . exceeds that of similar approved TCPA settlements
and is substantial”); Vu v. I Care Credit, LLC, 2022 WL 22871480, at *10 (C.D. Cal. Nov. 4, 2022)
(noting that an award of $18.57 per claimant “is within the range of other class action settlements
2 See, e.g., Sanchez et al. v. Kia Motors Am., Inc., No. 20-01604, 2024 WL 4730654 (C.D. Cal.
Nov. 7, 2024) (contested class certification; certifying 10 state classes of more than 100,000
automobile purchasers and lessees bringing consumer protection and breach of warranty claims
arising out of alleged windshield defect); Guthrie et al. v. Mazda Motor of America, Inc., No. 22-
01055,� 2024 WL 5369372 (C.D. Cal. Oct. 8, 2024) (settlement class counsel representing
nationwide class of approximately 86,000 vehicle purchasers and lessees bringing breach of
warranty and consumer protection claims arising from alleged oil consumption defect); Munday v.
Navy Federal Credit Union, No. 15-01629, 2016 WL 7655807 (C.D. Cal., Sept. 15, 2016) (final
approval of class settlement of $2.75MM in TCPA action).
3 Black’s Law Dictionary (10th ed.2014) defines “arm’s length transaction” as follows: “1. A
transaction between two unrelated and unaffiliated parties. 2. A transaction between two parties,
however closely related they may be, conducted as if the parties were strangers, so that no conflict
of interest arises.”
Case 2:16-cv-04469-JKS-LDW Document 358 Filed 02/04/26 Page 6 of 19 PageID:
<pageID>
7
under the TCPA that courts have approved”); Couser v. Comenity Bank, 125 F. Supp. 3d 1034,
1044 (S.D. Cal. 2015) (approving a TCPA class settlement where each of the 308,026 approved
claim members (or a 7.7% claims rate) received $13.75); In re Cap. One Tel. Consumer Prot. Act
Litig., 80 F. Supp. 3d 781, 787 (N.D. Ill. 2015) (approving class settlement providing about $34
per claimant).
The seventh, eighth, and ninth Girsh factors—the ability of the Defendant to withstand a
greater judgment, and the range of reasonableness of the settlement given the best possible
recovery and considering all the attendant risks of litigation—each support final approval of the
settlement. The significant recovery for each claiming member of the class demonstrates that the
settlement falls well within the range of what is fair, reasonable, and adequate, and clearly merits
approval.
iii. 	Class Reaction to the Settlement
The second Girsh factor “gauge[s] whether members of the class support the settlement.”
In re Prudential Ins. Co. America Sales Practice Litigation Agent Actions, 148 F.3d 283, 318 (3d
Cir. 1998). 	As such, courts look at the “number and vociferousness of the objectors.... [and]
generally assume[ ] that silence constitutes tacit consent to the agreement.” 	In re Gen. Motors
Corp. Pick-Up Truck Fuel Tank Prods. Liab. Litig., 55 F.3d 768, 812 (3d Cir. 1995) (quoting Bell
Atl. Corp., 2 F.3d at 1313 & n.15).
The class reaction here has been undeniably positive. 	To date, there have been no
objections to the settlement by any class member. The high claims rate and absence of opt-outs
or objections support final approval of this settlement. See In re Cendant Corp. Litig., 264 F.3d
201, 234-35 (3d Cir. 2001) (affirming district court’s conclusion that the class’s reaction was
“extremely favorable” where 478,000 notices were sent, 4 objections were made, and 234 class
Case 2:16-cv-04469-JKS-LDW Document 358 Filed 02/04/26 Page 7 of 19 PageID:
<pageID>
8
members opted out). Moreover, the strong response rate, 10.2%, is far above the median.ككSee Fed.
Trade Comm’n, Consumers and Class Actions: A Retrospective and Analysis of Settlement
Campaigns, 11 (2019) (“Across all cases in our sample requiring a claims process, the median
calculated claims rate was 9%, and the weighted mean (i.e., cases weighted by the number of notice
recipients) was 4%.”).
iv. 	Stage of Proceedings
The relevant inquiry under the third Girsh factor is “whether Plaintiffs had an ‘adequate
appreciation of the merits of the case before negotiating’ settlement.” In re Wilmington Tr. Sec.
Litig., No. 10-0990, 2018 WL 6046452, at *5 (D. Del. Nov. 19, 2018) (In re Prudential, 148 F.3d
at 319.). 	The purpose of this factor is to determine “the degree of case development that class
counsel have accomplished prior to settlement.” In re Cendant Corp. Litig., 264 F.3d at 235. Here,
the parties engaged in significant motion practice and discovery, through which Plaintiff was
adequately informed of the relative strengths and weaknesses of the case against CGI such that
Plaintiff and counsel were able to intelligently evaluate settlement. 	See, e.g., In re Genta Sec.
Litig., No. 04–2123, 2008 WL 2229843, at *6 (D.N.J. May 28, 2008). This factor also weighs in
favor of approving the settlement.
v. 	Risks of Establishing Liability and Damages
The fourth, fifth, and sixth Girsh factors—the risks of establishing liability, establishing
damages, and maintaining the class action through the trial—also support approval of this
settlement. See Lazy Oil, Co. v. Witco Corp., 95 F. Supp. 2d 290, 337 (W.D. Pa. 1997) (noting
that “[h]ere, as in every case, Plaintiffs face the general risk that they may lose at trial, since no
one can predict the way in which a jury will resolve disputed issues”), aff’d, 166 F.3d 581 (3d Cir.
1999). 	The purpose of these factors is to “balance the likelihood of success and the potential
Case 2:16-cv-04469-JKS-LDW Document 358 Filed 02/04/26 Page 8 of 19 PageID:
<pageID>
9
damage award if the case were taken to trial against the benefits of an immediate settlement.” In
re Prudential, 148 F.3d at 319. “By evaluating the risks of establishing liability, the district court
can examine what the potential rewards (or downside) of litigation might have been had class
counsel elected to litigate the claims rather than settle them.” In re Gen. Motors, 55 F.3d at 814.
Where there is a prospect of long, contentious, and uncertain litigation, these factors weigh in favor
of approval. See In re Cendant Corp. Litig., 264 F.3d at 238.
vi. 	Effectiveness of “proposed method of distributing relief” and “the method
of processing class-member claims.”
Under this factor, the Court “scrutinize[s] the method of claims processing to ensure that
it facilitates filing legitimate claims” and “should be alert to whether the claims process is unduly
demanding.” 324 F.R.D. 904, 920. 	This factor is satisfied because individualized notice was
provided to identifiable class members and the notice clearly described the process for Class
Members to object or exclude themselves or to submit claims. See Hall v. Accolade, Inc., No. 17-
3423, 2019 WL 3996621, at *5 (E.D. Pa. Aug. 23, 2019); see also Cordova Decl. ¶¶ 5-11 (class
members received a copy of the notice via direct mail or email with all relevant documents
available on the class settlement website). 	The high response rate, 10.2%, reflects that class
members were able to submit claims without issue.ك
vii. 	Rule 23(e)(2)(C)(iii) – The terms and timing of any proposed attorney’s
fee award.
This factor recognizes that “[e]xamination of the attorney-fee provisions may also be
valuable in assessing the fairness of the proposed settlement.” 324 F.R.D. 904, 919. Class counsel
filed a motion for an award of attorneys’ fees, expenses and an incentive Award on August 15,
2025, thirty days before the expiration of the objection period which concluded on September 15,
2025. (See Fees Mot.) 	The motion was promptly posted on the settlement website once it was
Case 2:16-cv-04469-JKS-LDW Document 358 Filed 02/04/26 Page 9 of 19 PageID:
<pageID>
10
filed. (Settl. Mot. at 22.) As set forth below, the attorneys’ fees, expenses, and inventive award
are reasonable in this case. See infra Section III.
viii. 	Rule 23(e)(2)(C)(iv) – Any agreement required to be identified under Rule
23(e)(3)
Rule 23(e)(3) requires settling parties to “file a statement identifying any agreement made
in connection with the proposal.” 	There are no other agreements other than the settlement
agreement that concern the relief provided and what is released. (Settl. Mot. at 22.) The Parties
have executed a stipulation following conferrals with the representatives of the state attorneys
general offices. (See ECF 354-3, “Ex. A”.)
ix. 	Rule 23(e)(2)(D) – Whether the settlement treats class members equitably
relative to each other
This factor seeks to prevent the “inequitable treatment of some class members vis-a-vis
others.” 324 F.R.D. 904, 920. This factor is satisfied here because class member awards are
weighed by the number of allegedly unlawful calls each received. 	Thus, while some class
members will recover more than others, that is solely a function of the difference in their injuries
and is therefore equitable.
III. 	Attorneys’ Fees, Expenses & Incentive Award
Plaintiff’s counsel also makes a motion for attorneys’ fees in the amount of $650,000 (40%
of the settlement fund), reimbursement of $92,283.46 in expenses, and an incentive award of
$40,000 to the class representative. 	(Fees Mot. at 1.) 	The Federal Rules of Civil Procedure
expressly authorize that “the court may award reasonable attorney’s fees and nontaxable costs that
are authorized by law or by the parties’ agreement.” Fed. R. Civ. P. 23(h). Courts apply one of
two methodologies in awarding fees: (1) the lodestar method or (2) the percentage-of-recovery
method in which Class Counsel is awarded a percentage of the settlement amount. See Holden v.
Guardian Analytics, Inc., No. 23-2115, 2024 WL 2845392, at *10 (D.N.J. June 5, 2024) (citing In
Case 2:16-cv-04469-JKS-LDW Document 358 Filed 02/04/26 Page 10 of 19 PageID:
<pageID>
11
re AT&T Corp., Sec. Litig., 455 F.3d 160, 164 (3d Cir. 2006)). 	Where fees and class recovery
come from a fund agreed for class recovery, the percentage-of-recovery method is used. Id. (citing
Dewy v. Volkswagen AG, 558 F. App’x 191, 197 (3d Cir. 2014)). 	The percentage-of-recovery
method is preferred in common fund cases because it “rewards counsel for success and penalizes
it for failure.” In re Rite Aid Corp. Sec. Litig., 396 F.3d 294, 300 (3d Cir. 2005).
In such common fund cases, “the fees typically awarded to class counsel generally range
between 19% to 45% of the Settlement Fund.” Beltran v. Sos Ltd., No. 21-7454 2023 WL 319895,
at *8 (D.N.J. Jan. 3, 2023) (citing In re General Motors, 55 F.3d at 822), report and
recommendation adopted, 2023كWL 316294 (D.N.J. Jan. 19, 2023); see also McGowan v. CFG
Health Network, LLC, No. 22-02770, 2024 WL 1340329, at *14 (D.N.J. Mar. 28, 2024) (approving
33% fee award).
a. 	Gunter Factors
The Third Circuit has identified a list of factors (the Gunter factors) to determine the
reasonableness of a fee award. Gunter v. Ridgewood Energy Corp., 223 F.3d 190, 195 n.1 (3d Cir.
2000); see also Holden, 2024 WL 2845392 at * 11 (applying the factors). The Gunter factors are
(1) the size of the fund created and the number of persons benefitted; (2) the presence or absence
of substantial objections by members of the class to the settlement terms and/or fees requested by
counsel; (3) the skill and efficiency of the attorneys involved; (4) the complexity and duration of
the litigation; (5) the risk of nonpayment; (6) the amount of time devoted to the case by plaintiff’s
counsel; and (7) the awards in similar cases. Id.
As discussed, Plaintiff’s counsel seeks a fee award of forty percent of the settlement fund.
Here, because the Gunter factors substantially overlap with the Girsch factors, the Court will refer
to its earlier findings when reviewing the fee application. An analysis of these factors supports
the requested fees award.
Case 2:16-cv-04469-JKS-LDW Document 358 Filed 02/04/26 Page 11 of 19 PageID:
<pageID>
12
i. 	Size of the Fund and Number of Persons Benefitted
For this factor, courts “consider the fee request in comparison to the size of the fund created
and the number of class members to be benefitted.” Yedlowski v. Roka Bioscience, Inc., 14-8020,
2016 WL 6661336, at *20 (D.N.J. Nov. 10, 2016) (quoting Rowe v. E.I. DuPont de Nemours &
Co., Nos. 06–1810 & 06–3080, 2011 WL 3837106, at *18 (D.N.J. Aug. 26, 2011)). The amount
of the settlement fund is $1,625.000. 	As discussed supra, for the 12,757 class members, 1,266
valid claims are associated with 4,631 separate calls, and the average recovery in this case is
$596.17 per claiming member, which is significantly greater than the average recovery in TCPA
cases. 	The settlement amount and average recovery per claiming class member is thus
considerable, as is the number of persons who will benefit from recovery of the cash funds.
ii. 	Objections to the Fee Request
The class notice included details of the request for attorneys’ fees, expenses, and the
incentive award. 	There have been no objections. 	This factor weighs in favor of approving
Plaintiff’s fee request.
iii. 	Skill and Efficacy of the Attorneys
“Lead Counsel’s skill and efficiency is ‘measured by the quality of the result achieved, the
difficulties faced, the speed and efficiency of the recovery, the standing, experience and expertise
of the counsel, the skill and professionalism with which counsel prosecuted the case and the
performance and quality of opposing counsel.’” Yedlowski, 2016 WL 6661336, at *20 (quoting
Hall v. AT&T Mobility LLC, No. 07–5325, 2010 WL 4053547, at *19 (D.N.J. Oct. 13, 2010)). In
addition, “[t]he quality and vigor of opposing counsel” is relevant when evaluating the quality of
services rendered by Lead Counsel. Id. at *21.
Case 2:16-cv-04469-JKS-LDW Document 358 Filed 02/04/26 Page 12 of 19 PageID:
<pageID>
13
As discussed supra, class counsel are experienced class action litigators. 	Defendant is
represented by Kelley Drye, a large national firm that vigorously defended this action. This case
was litigated over the course of ten years, with extensive discovery, motion practice, mediation
attempts, and appellate review. That class counsel was able to achieve this settlement in light of
Defendant’s defense of this action supports the reasonableness of the requested fee award. 	See
Granillo v. FCA US LLC, No. 16-153, 2019 WL 4052432, at *10 (D.N.J. Aug. 27, 2019)ك(“the fact
that Class Counsel achieved this Settlement for the Class in the face of formidable legal opposition
further evidences the quality of their work, which weighs in favor of approval of the attorneys’ fee
award.”).
iv. 	Complexity and Duration of the Litigation
This ten-year litigation was complex and long. 	There was voluminous briefing on class
certification, summary judgment, experts, appeals and class notice. This was all after extensive
and contentious discovery. This settlement was not quickly or easily arrived at, which supports
the forty percent fee award. See, e.g., Holden, 2024 WL 2845392 at *1 (awarding a third of the
fund after only several months of litigation).
v. 	Risk of Nonpayment
“Courts across the country have consistently recognized that the risk of receiving little or
no recovery is a major factor in considering an award of attorneys' fees.” Yedlowski, 2016 WL
6661336, at *21. To bring a national class action on a contingency fee basis requires a law firm’s
commitment of time and resources in the face of significant risks of loss and delay. See In re
Schering-Plough Corp. Enhance ERISA Litig., No. 08–1432, 2012 WL 1964451, at *7 (D.N.J.
May 31, 2012) (“Courts routinely recognize that the risk created by undertaking an action on a
contingency fee basis militates in favor of approval.”). Plaintiff’s counsel certainly accepted the
Case 2:16-cv-04469-JKS-LDW Document 358 Filed 02/04/26 Page 13 of 19 PageID:
<pageID>
14
real risk of little or no payment when it undertook the case on a contingency fee basis. This risk
is heightened for a small law firm like class counsel. Firms of small size face even greater risks
in litigating large class actions with no guarantee of payment. Boyd v. Bank of Am. Corp., No. 13–
0561, 2014 WL 6473804, at *10 (C.D. Cal. Nov. 18, 2014) (finding heightened risk of small firm
representation should be rewarded with larger percentage fee for good result). This factor weighs
in favor of approving the fee request.
vi. 	Amount of Time Devoted to the Case
As discussed supra, class counsel has invested significant time and effort over the past
decade litigating this class action, arriving at a settlement, and will continue to devote time by
monitoring claims processing and the distribution of settlement payments by the settlement
administrator. These efforts, taken with the risk of no recovery to counsel, demonstrate that the
fee requested is reasonable.
vii. 	Awards in Similar Cases
A forty-percent fee award is within the range of what is approved in percentage-of-recovery
cases in the Third Circuit in complex litigation. In re Suboxone (Buprenorphine Hydrochloride &
Naloxone) Antitrust Litig., No. 13-2445, 2024 WL 815503, at *16 (E.D. Pa. Feb. 27, 2024) (“the
Third Circuit has noted that reasonable fee awards in percentage-of-recovery cases generally range
from nineteen to forty-five percent of the common fund.”) (collecting cases). Forty percent falls
on the higher end of this general range, but it is supported by the above-average results achieved
by counsel here on behalf of the class for a TCPA case. Here, the total and individual recovery
will be higher than a normal TCPA suit, and no amount of the settlement fund will revert back to
CGI, which supports the requested fee award.
Case 2:16-cv-04469-JKS-LDW Document 358 Filed 02/04/26 Page 14 of 19 PageID:
<pageID>
15
b. 	Prudential Factors
In addition to the Gunter factors, courts in the Third Circuit consider the factors articulated
by the Third Circuit in In re Prudential Ins. Co. of Am. Sales Practice Litig., 148 F.3d 283 (3d Cir.
1998). These factors are (1) whether the benefits accruing to the class are attributable to the efforts
of class counsel or other groups, such as government agencies; (2) whether the fee is comparable
to the fee that would have been negotiated had the case been subject to a contingent fee agreement;
and (3) whether the settlement agreement contains innovative terms and conditions. In re AT & T
Corp., 455 F.3d 160, 165 (3d Cir. 2006) (citing In re Prudential, 148 F.3d at 338-40).ك
With respect to the first Prudential factor – whether the benefits are attributable to class
counsel or the other groups – the settlement results here are solely the result of class counsel’s
efforts. In Prudential, the Third Circuit singled this factor out for important consideration by
district courts. See 148 F.3d at 338. There, the appeals court remanded the trial court’s fee award
for wrongly “credit[ing] class counsel with creating the entire value of the settlement” and
overlooking the considerable contributions of a multi-state life insurance task force. 	Id. 	Here,
there was no such assistance by any state or federal body. Thus, this Court finds that “class counsel
was not aided by the efforts of any governmental group, and the entire value of the benefits
accruing to class members is properly attributable to the efforts of class counsel.” In re AT&T
Corp., 455 F.3d at 173. This factor weighs in favor of the proposed fee.
The second Prudential factor – comparison of the requested fee to a negotiated contingent
fee agreement –weighs in favor of the requested award. A forty percent contingent fee is routinely
negotiated in the open market. 	In re Mercedes-Benz Emissions Litig., No. 16-881, 2021 WL
7833193, at *15 (D.N.J. Aug. 2, 2021) (“In individual cases, the customary contingent fee would
likely range between 30 and 40 percent of the recovery”) (quoting Dartell v. Tibet Pharm., Inc.,
Case 2:16-cv-04469-JKS-LDW Document 358 Filed 02/04/26 Page 15 of 19 PageID:
<pageID>
16
No. 14-3620, 2017 WL 2815073, at *11 (D.N.J. June 29, 2017)); Evanoff v. Marsh USA, LLC, No.
23-3417, 2024 WL 3330571, at *2 (E.D. Pa. July 8, 2024) (“Plaintiff's counsel’s contingency rate
is forty percent. . . This is within the range normally accepted in these matters”); In re Ikon Off.
Sols., Inc., Sec. Litig., 194 F.R.D. 166, 194 (E.D. Pa. 2000) (“[I]n private contingency fee cases,
particularly in tort matters, plaintiffs’ counsel routinely negotiate agreements providing for
between thirty and forty percent of any recovery”).
This settlement includes standard terms, and thus the third Prudential factor assessing
whether the agreement contains innovative terms is neutral. See McDonough v. Toys “R” Us, Inc.,
834 F. Supp. 2d 329, 345 (E.D. Pa. 2011) (“In the absence of any innovative terms, this factor
neither weighs in favor or against the proposed fee request.”); see also Castro, 2017 WL 4776626,
at *9 (approving attorneys’ fees request where class action settlement includes standard terms
when other Prudential factors support settlement).
c. 	Lodestar Cross-Check Method
The Third Circuit has “suggested that district courts cross-check the percentage award at
which they arrive against the ‘lodestar’ award method.” Gunter, 223 F.3d at 195 n.1. “The lodestar
award is calculated by multiplying the number of hours reasonably worked on a client’s case by a
reasonable hourly billing rate for such services based on the given geographical area, the nature of
the services provided, and the experience of the attorneys.” In re Prudential, 148 F.3d at 305. The
purpose of a cross-check is to “ensure that the proposed fee award [under the percentage-of-
recovery method] does not result in counsel being paid a rate vastly in excess of what any lawyer
could reasonably charge per hour, thus avoiding a ‘windfall’ to lead counsel.” In re Cendant Corp.
Litig., 264 F.3d at 285.
Case 2:16-cv-04469-JKS-LDW Document 358 Filed 02/04/26 Page 16 of 19 PageID:
<pageID>
17
There is no risk of windfall here. Using blended hourly rates to reflect change in rates over
the last ten years, class counsel’s lodestar is $1,333,210. (ECF 351-3, Lemberg Decl., ¶ 14). The
lodestar does not include additional work associated with final approval and class counsel’s
oversight of the claim process. (Id. ¶ 13.) Thus, class counsel seeks substantially less ($650,000)
than the lodestar, which supports the reasonableness of the fee award. In re Wawa, Inc. Data Sec.
Litig., 141 F.4th 456, 476 (3d Cir. 2025) (approving award where lodestar cross-check resulted in
a negative multiplier, “meaning that counsel was compensated for fewer hours than they labored.”)
d. 	Reimbursement of Expenses
“Counsel in common fund cases is entitled to reimbursement of expenses that were
adequately documented and reasonably and appropriately incurred in the prosecution of the case.”
In re Cendant Corp., 232 F. Supp. 2d 327, 343 (D.N.J. 2002). 	The Court approves Plaintiff’s
request for reimbursement of $92,283.46 in out-of-pocket litigation expenses. (See Lemberg Decl.
¶ 18-21.) The expenses include filing fees, expert fees, mediator fees, deposition transcript fees,
consultation fees, and postage. (Id.) These expenses were reasonably necessary to prosecute this
case, were borne by counsel and are appropriately reimbursed from the fund. In re Wawa, Inc.
Data Sec. Litig., No. 19-6019, 2024 WLك1557366, at *22 (E.D. Pa. Apr. 9, 2024), aff'd, 141 F.4th
456 (3d Cir. 2025) (“Class counsel’s litigation expenses include their filing fees, service of process
fees, expert and professional services fees, mediation fees . . . These types of expenses are approved
by courts in this Circuit with regularity.”); c.f. Castro, 2017 WL 4776626, at *10 (D.N.J. Oct. 23,
2017) (approving out-of-pocket expenses of $7,199,310.00 as reasonable).
e. 	Incentive Award
Class representatives are eligible to receive incentive awards. In re Schering–Plough Corp.
Enhance Securities Litig., No. 08–397, 2013 WL 5505744, at *56 (D.N.J. Oct. 1, 2013). 	An
Case 2:16-cv-04469-JKS-LDW Document 358 Filed 02/04/26 Page 17 of 19 PageID:
<pageID>
18
incentive award to the class representative for bringing and litigating a case on behalf of the class
promotes 	a 	public 	policy 	of 	encouraging 	individuals 	to 	undertake 	the 	responsibility 	of
representative lawsuits. Manual for Complex Litigation, § 21.62 n.971 (4th ed. 2004). “‘Courts
routinely approve incentive awards to compensate named plaintiffs for the services they provided
and the risks they incurred during the course of the class action litigation.’” Cullen v. Whitman
Med. Corp., 197 F.R.D. 136, 145 (E.D. Pa. 2000) (quoting In re So. Ohio Corr. Facility, 175 F.R.D.
270, 272 (S.D. Ohio 1997)).
Plaintiff seeks an incentive award in the amount of $40,000. 	Mr. Johnson, the class
representative, has represented the class for nearly a decade, keeping in regular contact with
counsel during this time, actively participating in the case, answering discovery requests, being
deposed, and traveling to New Jersey from his home in Washington State twice. 	(ECF 351-5,
Taylor Decl., ¶¶ 8, 9.) 	Mr. Johnson withstood CGI’s attempts to settle with him individually,
including offers higher than $40,000, which he rejected. (Id. ¶ 10.)
No class members have objected to this incentive award. The Court finds that given the
significant role Mr. Johnson played throughout this litigation, the incentive award is warranted.
See McDermid v. Inovio Pharms., Inc., 2023 WL 227355, at *13 (E.D. Pa. Jan. 18, 2023)
(approving two incentive awards to class representatives of over $75,000).
IV. 	CONCLUSION
The settlement agreement is the result of arm’s-length negotiations by experienced and
knowledgeable counsel which provides above-average relief to the class for disputed claims under
the TCPA. For the reasons stated above and at the final approval hearing held on November 4,
2025, Plaintiff’s motion for approval of the settlement is GRANTED. 	In addition, Plaintiff’s
motion for an award of attorneys’ fees, reimbursement of expenses, and an incentive award to the
Case 2:16-cv-04469-JKS-LDW Document 358 Filed 02/04/26 Page 18 of 19 PageID:
<pageID>
19
class representative is GRANTED. Appropriate Orders accompany this Opinion, one addressing
the settlement and the other concerning the fee, expenses, and award application.
/s/ Jamel K. Semper 	.
H ON. JAMEL K. S EMPER
United States District Judge
Orig: 	Clerk
cc: 	Leda D. Wettre, U.S.M.J.
Parties
Case 2:16-cv-04469-JKS-LDW Document 358 Filed 02/04/26 Page 19 of 19 PageID:
<pageID>

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.