PATEL v. VMWARE, INC.

1:22-cv-05731Njd4 févr. 2026

Texte intégral

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
DISTRICT OF NEW JERSEY
DEVRAJ PATEL,
Plaintiff,
v.
VMWARE, INC.,
Defendant.
Case No. 22–cv–05731–ESK–AMD
OPINION
KIEL, U.S.D.J.
IN THIS MATTER plaintiff Devraj Patel claims that defendant VMware,
Inc. failed to pay the full commission it owed him from a substantial sale when
it unilaterally changed the terms of his compensation agreement in the midst of
the process to close the sale. 	There are no material factual disputes. 	VMware
provided notice of yearly changes to the commission structure, Patel agreed to
those changes, and VMware exercised its express right to cap commissions for
“Exceptional 	Transactions,” 	which 	the 	sale 	at 	issue 	undisputably 	was.
Accordingly, summary judgment in favor of VMware will be entered.
I. 	BACKGROUND
Patel was employed at VMware as a client executive beginning in 2019.
(ECF No. 66–2 (Pl.’s SOMF) ¶ 1; ECF No. 68–5 (Def.’s SOMF ¶ 4.)) 	VMware is
an 	information 	technology 	company. 1 	(Def.’s 	SOMF 	¶ 1.) 	Patel 	sold
VMware’s products and services to state and local education clients in New
Jersey and New York. 	(Id. ¶ 4.)
1 VMware was acquired by Broadcom, Inc. in 2023 and is now known as VMware,
LLC. 	(Def.’s SOMF ¶ 2.)
Case 1:22-cv-05731-ESK-AMD Document 73 Filed 02/04/26 Page 1 of 12 PageID:
<pageID>
2
A. 	Patel’s Compensation Structure
Patel 	received 	a 	base 	salary 	of 	$155,000 	and 	received 	commission
payments based on 	performance. 	(Pl.’s 	SOMF ¶ 3; Def.’s SOMF ¶¶ 5–9.)
Performance was measured against goal sheets presented to employees twice a
year. 	(Pl.’s SOMF ¶¶ 3, 7.) 	Goal sheets set forth “differing commission rates
and 	commission 	tiers 	based 	on 	quota 	achievement, 	all 	tied 	to 	differing
compensation targets.” 	(Def.’s SOMF ¶ 14.) 	Once a new goal sheet is issued,
the prior goal sheet is voided. 	(Pl.’s SOMF ¶11.)
Each goal sheet included uniform terms and conditions applicable to all
employees 	eligible 	for 	commission 	compensation. 	(Def.’s 	SOMF 	¶ 15.)
Commissions would be paid only if the employee accepted the new goal sheet
and its terms and conditions. 	(Pl.’s SOMF ¶ 11.) 	For each fiscal year, 2 Patel
was emailed his goal sheets, which he electronically signed by clicking an
electronic “accept” button. 	(Def.’s SOMF ¶¶ 16–18.) 	Patel, however, argues
that he never read the goal sheet’s terms and conditions because VMware
provided insufficient time to do so. 	(ECF No.70–1 (Pl.’s Resp. to Def.’s SOMF)
¶ 18.)
The terms and conditions govern VMware’s commission payments to its
commission-eligible employees. 	(ECF No. 68–3 (Farkhrisaralan Decl.) ¶ 6.)
The terms and conditions call commission-eligible employees “participants” and
commissions “variable compensation.” 	(Id. ¶ 6.) 	VMware updated the terms
and conditions each fiscal year. 	(Pl.’s SOMF ¶¶ 5–8.) 	Section 1 of each fiscal
year’s terms and conditions contained a provision indicating that it superseded
and replaced the prior fiscal year’s terms and conditions. 	(ECF No. 66–3 pp.
117, 158, 188.)
2 VMware’s fiscal year begins in early February. 	(ECF No. 66–3 pp. 117, 158,
188.) 	Thus, fiscal year 2020 began on February 2, 2019, and ended on January 31,
2020. 	(Id. p. 117.)
Case 1:22-cv-05731-ESK-AMD Document 73 Filed 02/04/26 Page 2 of 12 PageID:
<pageID>
3
Section 10 of the 2020 terms and conditions titled “Company Right to
Modify” provided:
Exceptional Transaction
In addition to the Company’s right to modify plans pursuant to
Section 14.1, there are exceptional transactions that may not be
treated in accordance with the typical Plan terms and rules, i.e.
“Exceptional Transactions”, and the Company reserves the right and
sole discretion to make commission and crediting adjustments for
such transactions. 	For such deals, credit is not guaranteed, and no
draws will be paid against these designated transactions.
The Company designates as “Exceptional” any deal considered an
unanticipated or extraordinarily large credit event above planned
performance expectations (quota) or those which generate abnormal
expense burden. 	Illustrative Exceptional Transactions subject to
review include but are not limited to the examples below:
• Disproportionate Quota Attainment: Any single transaction
value which exceeds more than 100% of the Participant’s assigned
Quota and/or was not carried in the Participant’s assigned Quota
• Large Single Deals: Any single opportunity with a bookings value
greater than or equal to $10,000,000 USD
* * * * *
Exceptional Transaction Designation and Approval
VMware reserves the right to exclude credit for associates or teams
without deal involvement and final treatment will be considered by
sales role. Sales, Sales Operations, and Finance leadership will
identify Exceptional Transactions as early as possible in the sales
process for review and designation and will communicate any hold
order/payment status to the affected Participant(s) during the review
process.
Final 	designated 	transactions 	and 	recommendations 	will 	be
presented 	to 	the 	Sales 	Compensation 	Committee, 	for 	Level 	1
approval, on a monthly, with credit and payment updates executed
in the next feasible pay cycle post-approval.
(Def.’s SOMF ¶ 27.) 	Pursuant to the 2020 terms and conditions, VMware’s
“[s]ales, 	[s]ales 	[o]perations, 	and 	[f]inance 	leadership 	[would] 	identify
Exceptional Transactions as early as possible in the sales process for review
Case 1:22-cv-05731-ESK-AMD Document 73 Filed 02/04/26 Page 3 of 12 PageID:
<pageID>
4
and designation and will communicate any hold order/payment status to the
affected Participant(s) during the review process.” 	(Id.) 	The parties dispute
the meaning of the term “sales process.” 	Patel asserts that the “sales process
begins when the salesperson first makes contact with a potential customer, if
not earlier” and “ends when the salesperson receives a purchase order from the
customer or the customer has signed an agreement to finance the purchase.”
(ECF No. 66–2 (Pl.’s Br.) p. 11.) 	VMware asserts the “sales process” begins
when a customer sends a purchase order or signs an agreement. 3 	(ECF No.
69–1 (Def.’s Resp. to Pl.’s SOMF) ¶ 20–21; ECF No. 68–1 (Def.’s Br.) p. 14.)
While the relevant terms and conditions stayed substantially the same for
the relevant fiscal years, the underlined language below was added to the 2022
terms and conditions:
Final 	designated 	transactions 	and 	recommendations 	will 	be
presented 	to 	the 	Sales 	Compensation 	Committee 	for 	Level 	1
approval, on a monthly basis, with Credit and payment updates
executed in the next feasible pay cycle post-approval. 	The Sales
Compensation 	Committee 	may 	make 	Crediting 	and 	payment
Adjustments 	for 	such 	transactions. 	Generally, 	for 	Exceptional
Transactions, the maximum Credit for a single deal (which could
include multiple orders to the same customer) is limited to 300%
attainment for each metric in the Plan. 	Credit will not be granted
for a value greater than the eligible Credit for the role.
(ECF No. 66–3 p. 199.) 4 	Although the 2020 terms and conditions did not
include the underlined language, VMware argues that it was permitted to
modify 	commissions 	for 	“Exceptional 	Transactions.” 	(Def.’s 	SOMF 	¶ 58.)
3 “Sales process” is not a defined term in the terms and conditions.
4 For fiscal year 2021, the additional line reads: “The Sales Compensation
Committee may make crediting and payment Adjustments for such transactions.
Generally, for Exceptional Transactions, the maximum Credit for a single deal (which
could include multiple orders to the same customer) is limited to 300% plan
attainment.” 	(ECF No. 66–3 p. 170.)
Case 1:22-cv-05731-ESK-AMD Document 73 Filed 02/04/26 Page 4 of 12 PageID:
<pageID>
5
VMware claims it had been applying a 300% cap to Exceptional Transactions
“for several years.” 	(Def.’s SOMF ¶ 59, Pl.’s Resp. to Def.’s SOMF ¶ 59.) 5
All relevant years’ terms and conditions state that commissions are
“earned” after three conditions are met: (a) the employee accepted the goal sheet
and terms and conditions; (b) the employee has “eligible Quota Achievement”;
and (c) VMware completed its reconciliation of the transaction, which can
include a review of “Exception[al] Transactions.” 6 	(Def.’s SOMF ¶ 26.) 7 	A
credit event for a given transaction does not occur until a purchase order or
5 Although admitting this fact, Patel states that VMware “apparently has been
imposing a 300% cap on commissions arising from [E]xceptional [T]ransactions for
several years. 	However, there is no basis to do so under the [fiscal year 2020) Plan.”
(Pl.’s Resp. to Def.’s SOMF ¶ 59.)
6 Section 6.1 of the Terms and Conditions provides:
Variable Compensation payments are “Earned” by Participants only
after all of the following have occurred:
• The Participant Accepted his or her Goal Sheet.
• The Participant has (1) eligible Quota Achievement for quota-
retiring transactions; or (2) for non-quota retiring earning opportunities
(for 	example, 	incremental 	incentives, 	SPIFs), 	all 	criteria 	for 	the
opportunity have been met.
• A Plan Reconciliation, including but not limited to the review of any
transactions deemed to be Exception Transactions, splits, and other
Adjustments, 	has 	been 	completed 	by 	VMware, 	analyzing 	all
commissionable events, draws, Commissions paid, and factors affecting
Variable Compensation. 	Plan Reconciliation occurs after the end of the
Plan Period. 	As a result, to the extent VMware makes any payments for
Variable Compensation before this Plan Reconciliation has been completed,
such payments are preliminary advances for Variable Compensation that
has not yet been earned and are subject to Adjustments until Plan
Reconciliation.
(ECF No. 66–3 p. 124.)
7 Although 	the 	term 	“Exception 	Transactions” 	appear 	in 	the 	terms 	and
conditions, VMware, without explanation, assumes this was intended to mean
“Exceptional Transactions.” 	(Def.’s Br. p. 7.) 	Patel does not address this irregularity.
Case 1:22-cv-05731-ESK-AMD Document 73 Filed 02/04/26 Page 5 of 12 PageID:
<pageID>
6
binding agreement for the purchase of VMware’s products and/or services is
signed. 	(Id. ¶ 45.)
B. 	The Sale
Patel began working as the lead salesperson on a large potential sale to
the New York City Department of Education (“DOE”) around September 2019.
(Pl.’s SOMF ¶¶ 27–28.) 	Since Patel spent a substantial portion of his time
working on this deal, he closed fewer sales in fiscal years 2020 and 2021. 	(ECF
No. 66–1 (Pl.’s Br.) p. 13.) 	One part of the sale to the DOE closed in August
2021 and the other closed in November or December 2021. 	(Pl.’s SOMF ¶¶ 30,
36.) 	The combined value of the sale was approximately $20,000,000. 	(Id.
¶ 29.)
C. 	After Closing
In late October of 2021, VMware placed Patel’s commissions from the first
part of the sale on hold. 	(Pl.’s SOMF ¶ 31; Def.’s Resp. to Pl.’s SOMF ¶ 31.)
Through 	October 	and 	November, 	Patel 	exchanged 	emails 	with 	several
coworkers regarding the commissions from the DOE sale. 	(Pl.’s SOMF ¶ 32–
35.) 	On December 8, 2021, VMware notified Patel that it determined the
August 2021 sale to be an Exceptional Transaction. 	(Id. ¶ 37.) 	Thereafter,
VMware applied the 300% cap to both parts of the sale, reducing Patel’s credit
by $4,100,000 for the first part and $4,500,000 to the second. 	(ECF No. 70–2
p. 233.) 	Patel received $539,685 in commissions but would have received
$1,052,212 had VMware not applied the cap. 	(Pl.’s SOMF ¶¶ 40–41.)
D. 	Procedural History
On August 19, 2022, Patel commenced this action in the Superior Court of
New Jersey. 	(ECF No. 1 ¶ 1.) 	Patel asserts three counts against VMware:
violations of the New Jersey Wage Payment Law (Count I), breach of contract
(Count II), and breach of covenant of good faith and fair dealing (Count III).
Case 1:22-cv-05731-ESK-AMD Document 73 Filed 02/04/26 Page 6 of 12 PageID:
<pageID>
7
(Id. pp. 15, 16.) 	VMware removed the action on September 27, 2022, asserting
diversity jurisdiction. 	(ECF No. 1.)
On 	April 	18, 	2025, 	Patel 	and 	VMware 	filed 	motions 	for 	summary
judgment. 	(ECF 	No. 	66; 	ECF 	No. 	68.) 	The 	parties 	filed 	responses 	in
opposition to the opposing parties’ motion. 	(ECF No. 69; ECF No. 70.) 	The
parties also filed reply briefs. 	(ECF No. 71; ECF No. 72.)
II. 	LEGAL STANDARD
Under Rule 56(c), summary judgment is appropriate if the moving party
demonstrates there are no genuine issues of material fact, and the materials in
the record establish the movant is entitled to judgment as a matter of law.
Celotex Corp. v. Catrett, 477 U.S. 317, 322–23 (1986); see also Fed. R. Civ. P.
56(c)(1)(A) 	(providing 	that 	“materials 	in 	the 	record” 	include 	depositions,
documents, 	electronically 	stored 	information, 	affidavits 	or 	declarations,
admissions, interrogatory answers, or “other” materials). 	A factual dispute is
“genuine” if a reasonable trier of fact could find in favor of the non-moving
party. 	Anderson v. Liberty Lobby, Inc., 477 U.S. 242, 248 (1986). 	A fact is
“material” if a dispute over that fact “might affect the outcome of the suit under
the governing law.” 	Id.
III. 	DISCUSSION
A. 	Count I: NJWPL
The New Jersey Wage Payment Law (NJWPL) is a “remedial statute” that
“governs the time and mode of payment of wages due to employees.” 	Musker
v. Suuchi, Inc., 331 A.3d 900, 905 (N.J. 2025) (quoting Maia v. IEW Constr.
Grp., 313 A.3d 887, 895 (N.J. 2024)). 	The NJWPL has humanitarian purposes,
and should be liberally construed. 	Hargrove v. Sleepy’s, LLC, 106 A.3d 449,
457 (N.J. 2015); Kas Oriental Rugs, Inc. v. Ellman, 972 A.2d 413, 429 (N.J.
Super. 2009). 	“If an employer violates the NJWPL, an employee may seek
damages in a private cause of action.” 	Musker, 331 A.3d at 905.
Case 1:22-cv-05731-ESK-AMD Document 73 Filed 02/04/26 Page 7 of 12 PageID:
<pageID>
8
The NJWPL defines “wages” to include amounts “determined” on a
“commission basis.” 	N.J.S.A. § 34:11-4.1(c); see also Musker, 331 A.3d at 906.
Though the NJWPL does not define commissions, it is “a fee paid to an agent or
employee 	for 	transacting 	a 	piece 	of 	business 	or 	performing 	a 	service;
esp[ecially]: a percentage of the money received from a total paid to the agent
responsible for the business.” 	Musker, 331 A.3d at 906. 	Supplementary
incentives, or “compensation that motivates employees to do something above
and beyond their ‘labor or services’” are excluded from wages and not protected
by the NJWPL. 	Id.
The NJWPL requires employers to notify “employees of any changes in the
pay rates or pay days prior to the time of such changes.” 	N.J.S.A. § 34:11-
4.6(b). 	While employers may change commission calculations, these changes
can only be made “prospectively,” “giving advance notice to any employee paid
on a commission basis.” 	Winslow v. Corp. Exp., Inc., 834 A.2d 1037, 1044 (N.J.
Super. Ct. App. Div. 2003); Hargrove, 106 A.3d at 457 (internal citations
omitted).
Here, VMware did what the NJWPL requires. 	At the start of each fiscal
year, VMware notified all “participants” of the commission structure that would
be applied to “earned” commissions for the fiscal year. 	Each new goal sheet
and terms and conditions expressly notified participants that the prior fiscal
year’s terms and conditions were “superseded and replaced.” 	Accordingly,
VMware did not retroactively change the rate of commissions that Patel was
entitled to receive.
Patel 	argues 	that 	VMware 	violated 	the 	NJWPL 	by 	“changing 	the
commission formula applicable to the sales [ ] Patel closed with the [ ] DOE over
two years after he began working on the sale, and four months after he closed
the sale.” 	(Pl.’s Br. pp. 7, 18.) 	When Patel began working on the potential
DOE sale is, however, irrelevant because his commission is based on the
Case 1:22-cv-05731-ESK-AMD Document 73 Filed 02/04/26 Page 8 of 12 PageID:
<pageID>
9
formula 	in 	effect 	at 	the 	time 	the 	commission 	is 	“earned.” 	Under 	the
unambiguous 	terms 	of 	each 	fiscal 	year’s 	terms 	and 	conditions, 	Patel’s
commissions were earned only after a “Plan Reconciliation,” which occurred at
the end of each fiscal year.
Although Patel began working on the DOE sale in September 2019,
during fiscal year 2020, the sales did not close until fiscal year 2022. 	Thus,
the 	terms 	and 	conditions 	for 	fiscal 	year 	2022 	were 	in 	effect 	when 	the
commissions for the DOE sale were “earned.” 	Those terms and conditions
contained a cap of “300% attainment.” 	Fair notices of the implementation of
the cap were provided with the fiscal year 2021 and 2022 terms and conditions.
Patel agreed to those terms and conditions.
Accordingly, summary judgment will be entered in favor of VMware on
Count I.
B. 	Count II: Breach of Contract
A breach of contract claim requires that: (1) the parties entered into a
contract containing certain terms; (2) the plaintiff performed as required while
the defendant did not; and (3) the defendant’s breach caused a loss for the
plaintiff. 	Goldfarb v. Solimine, 245 A.3d 570, 577 (N.J. 2021). 	Compensation
plans agreed to by the parties are enforceable contracts under New Jersey law.
Nolan, 579 A.2d at 1257.
Patel points to VMware’s obligation to “identify Exceptional Transactions
as early as possible in the sales process for review and designation.” 	Patel
argues that VMware breached the terms and conditions by failing to timely
advise him—i.e. “as soon as possible”—that the potential sale to the DOE might
be considered an Exceptional Transaction. 	(Pl.’s Br. p. 21.) 	But VMware was
not required to again notify Patel that a large, potential sale would be
considered an Exceptional Transaction. 	Section 10 of each of the terms and
conditions for fiscal years 2020, 2021, and 2022 notify participants that “[a]ny
Case 1:22-cv-05731-ESK-AMD Document 73 Filed 02/04/26 Page 9 of 12 PageID:
<pageID>
10
single transaction with a booking value greater than or equal to $10,000,000”
would be treated as an Exceptional Transaction. 	(ECF No. 66–3 pp. 129, 170,
199.) 	Each fiscal year’s terms and conditions also notified participants that
“[a]ny 	single 	transaction 	value 	which 	exceeds 	more 	than 	100% 	of 	the
[p]articipant’s assigned Quota and/or was not carried in the [p]articipant’s
assigned Quota would be treated as an Exceptional Transaction.” 	(Id.) 	No
dispute exists that the sale to the DOE exceeded 100% of Patel’s quota and the
sale to the DOE was anticipated to be over $10,000,000. 	Accordingly, Patel
was already on notice, through each year’s terms and conditions, that the
potential sale to the DOE would be an Exceptional Transaction. 	VMware’s not
further notifying Patel during the “sales process” is of no moment.
Accordingly, summary judgment will be entered in favor of VMware on
Count II.
C. 	Count 	III: 	Breach 	of 	the 	Implied
Covenant of Good Faith and Fair Dealing
“The implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing is a ‘component of
every contract that requires both parties to a contract act in good faith[,]’ that
is, 	they 	must 	‘adher[e] 	to 	community 	standards 	of 	decency, 	fairness, 	or
reasonableness.’ ” 	Marshall v. Verde Energy USA. Inc., No. 18-1344, 2019 WL
1254562, at *5 (D.N.J. Mar. 19, 2019) (alterations in original) (quoting Iliadis
v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., 922 A.2d 710, 722 (N.J. 2007)).
“However, ‘[t]he implied duty of good faith and fair dealing does not
operate to alter the clear terms of an agreement and may not be invoked to
preclude a party from exercising its express rights under such an agreement.’”
Axletree Solutions, Inc. v. IntellectEU, Inc., No. 24–11431, 2025 WL 583271, at
* 6 (D.N.J. Feb. 24, 2025) (quoting Fleming Cos., Inc. v. Thriftway Medford
Lakes, Inc., 913 F. Supp. 837, 846 (D.N.J. 1995)). 	“Where the terms of a
contract are not specific, the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing may
Case 1:22-cv-05731-ESK-AMD Document 73 Filed 02/04/26 Page 10 of 12 PageID:
<pageID>
11
fill in the gaps where necessary to give efficacy to the contract as written.” 	Id.
“But where the terms of the parties’ contract are clear, the implied covenant of
good faith and fair dealing will not override the contract’s express language.”
Id. (quoting Fields v. Thompson Printing Co., 363 F.3d 259, 272 (3d Cir. 2004)).
Patel argues that VMware’s reliance on the terms and conditions to
reduce Patel’s commissions violates the covenant of good faith and fair dealing.
(Pl.’s Br. p. 25.) 	Patel cites to Nolan v. Control Data Corp., where the Court
found a sales plan likely did not confer “the absolute, unfettered discretion to
amend its compensation scheme retroactively at any time and for any reason
whatsoever.” 	579 A.2d 1252, 1258 (N.J. Super. App. Div. 1990)). 	In Nolan,
the employee’s quota was changed five different times over the course of one
year. 	Id. at 1255. 	The facts of Nolan differ from the facts here. 	The terms
and conditions which Patel agreed to each fiscal year expressly provided
VMware with the right to designate Exceptional Transactions and to cap
commissions 	for 	such 	transactions. 	And 	they 	explicitly 	stated 	that 	a
transaction exceeding 100% of Patel’s quota would be treated as an Exceptional
Transaction. 	The 	same 	terms 	and 	conditions 	contained 	a 	cap 	of 	“300%
attainment.”
VMware acted within the scope of its express rights. 	Patel’s implied
covenant 	claim 	cannot 	survive. 	Accordingly, 	summary 	judgment 	will 	be
entered in favor of VMware on Count III.
Case 1:22-cv-05731-ESK-AMD Document 73 Filed 02/04/26 Page 11 of 12 PageID:
<pageID>
12
IV. 	CONCLUSION
For 	the 	foregoing 	reasons, 	VMware’s 	motion 	(ECF 	No. 	68) 	will 	be
GRANTED. 	Patel’s motion (ECF No. 66) will be DENIED. 	An appropriate
order and judgment accompanies this opinion.
/s/ Edward S. Kiel
E DWARD S. K IEL
UNITED S TATES DISTRICT JUDGE
Dated: 	February 4, 2026
Case 1:22-cv-05731-ESK-AMD Document 73 Filed 02/04/26 Page 12 of 12 PageID:
<pageID>

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.