IN RE: Cuisinart Food Processor Antitrust Litigation

JPML FORM 1A |
DOCKET ENTRIES
JUDICIAL PANFL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
DOCKET NG. 447 -- In re Cuisinart Food Processor Antitrust Litigation
RE 1 oe te | i :wT ret. | PloneLr EooT Description I TT I I TI Im II I IIe
| |
80/10/21 1 MOTION, BRIEF, SCHEDULE, AND EXHIBITS A THROUGH R w/cert.
svc. for Cuisinarts, Inc. (ds)
Suggested Transferee District: District of Connecticut
80/10/31 — IRA B. ROSE, ESQ. for Frances Nathan and Fred Cohn;: JERRY S. COHEN, ESQ. for Marc A. Busman, et al.; STEVEN M.
i KIPPERMAN, ESQ. for Tille Lee Louie and Basic Living Products,
| Inc.; ERBERXXRE J. THOMAS HANNAN, ESQ. for Robert Reynolds,
: | et al.; O. MERRITT BURRUS, II, ESQ. for Belle Linda Gayer,
| | et al.; EDWARD F. HABER, ESQ. for Renee Logan; ARTHUR M.
| HANDLER, ESQ. for Cuisinarts, Inc., Carl G. Sontheimer, Shirley
M. Sontheimer; STEVEN D. MCCORMICK, ESQ. FOR Def, Marshall
Field & Co., Inc. XKHXX MICHAEL J. FREED, ESQ. for Crate &
| Barrel, Inc., AARON M. GREENBERG, ESQ. for James D. Mah
| Associates; Don T. Hibner, Esq. for Deft. J.W. Robinson Co. (cds)|{
80/11/3 | | appraRANCES: Myron M. Cherry, Esq. for Gloria Ehrlich, et al. and| i Janet Bebber Bahr, et al.; H. Laddie Montague, Jr., Esq. for
| Frederick Blum; Richard A. Dinnebier, Esq. for Hardwick
| | Townsend, Inc. (cds)80/11/03 2 | REQUEST FOR EXTENSION OF TIME -- Pltfs. Bahr and Ehrlich —-
| ! GRANTED TO ALL TO AND INCLUDING NOV. 12, 1980 --
| Notification mailed to all counsel. (rew)	"80/11/03 3 | REQUESTFOR EXTENSION OF TIME -- Deft. Crate & Barrell, Inc.
i GRANTED TO ALL TO AND INCLUDING NOV. 12, 1980 —-
| | Notification mailed to all counsel (rew)80/11/04} 4 | RESPONSE -- Plfts. Louie and Basic Living Products, Inc. --
! ! w/Exhibit and cert. of svc. (emh)
|
80/11/45 HEARING ORDER -- Setting motion of Cuisinarts, Inc. for
! transfer of A-1 through A-10. Hearing set for West Palm
i ] Beach, Fla. on Dec. 9, 1980. Notified counsel, clerks
| and judges. (rew)
80/11/09 5 RESPONSE/BRIEF -- All Pltfs. Reynolds, et al. --
| w/Exhibit and cert. of svc. (emh)
80/11/05 6 | RESPONSE -- P1ltf. Belle Linda Gayer -- w/cert. of svc. (emh)
80/11/06 7 . RESPONSE/BRIEF -- Pltf. Blum -- w/cert. of svc. (emh)
80/11/07 8 : LETTER OBJECTING TO REQUEST FOR EXTENSION OF TIME --
: ; Counsel for Cuisinarts, Inc. (signed by Mr. Handler (emh)
80/11/19 9 : RESPONSE -- Renee Logan -- w/cert. of svc. (emh)
80/11/10 10 | RESPONSE/BRIEF -- Deft. J.W. Robinson -- w/cert. of
: | of service (emh)
| |
Co|
|
CoLL

PML FORM 1A
DOCKET = I'RI £ 5
JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULT IDISTRICT LITIGATION
CRE MCa mm
i en SOU ts ol AotW inactSoba eC SSE EE LT 8 EETS ee
; Pltf. Bahr and P1ltf. Ehrlich
80/11/12 11 RESPONSE/BRIEF -- PALAL/ SAHA WebeA/ —— w/Exhibits and
f . h
80/11/12] 12 reSSGTaE OF S¥Ter . (FREY Cohn and Frances Nathan --
| w/cert. of svc. (emh)	80/11/13] 13 | JOINT RESPONSE/BRIEF -- Marshall Field & Co. and Crate &
| | Barrel, Inc. -- w/Affadivits and cert. of svc. (emh)
|80/11/14]	14 | RESPONSE -- Pltfs. Busman and Sacarob -- w/cert. of svc.
| (emh)80/11/17 AMENDED CERT. OF SVC. (Pleading No. 13) -- Marshall Field &
Co. and Crate & Barrell, Inc. (emh)
80/11/17 15 RESPONSE -- Deft. James D. Mah - w/cert. of svc. (emh)i
80/11/19 16 REPLY/BRIEF -- Cuisinarts, Inc. - w/cert. of svc. (emh)
80/11/19 17 ! AMENDED MOTION to add two additional actions --
! | Cuisinarts, Inc. -- w/Exhibits and cert. of svc. (emh)80/12/1} 18 LETTER -- pltf. Reynolds -- dated 11/25/80 —-—
f re developments in action service indicated. (ds)
80/12/01 19 LETTER -- pltfs. Louie and Basic -- recent developments --
oo no service (cds) i
80/12/03 20 { RESPONSE TO SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION -- Pltf. Eisenberger --
i | w/Exhibits A - E and cert. of serv. (cds)80/12/05| | WAIVER OF ORAL ARGUMENT ~-- BELLE LINDA GAYER, ETC., (0G&X
i ! ROBERT REYNOLDS, ET AL., MARSHALL FIELD & CO., TOWNSEND/
HARDWICK, JAMES D. MAH ASSOCIATES,	and FRED COHN, ET AL. (cds)
80/12/05| HEARING APPEARANCES: ARTHUR HANDLER, ESQ. FOR Cuisinarts, Inc.,
| Carl Sontheimer and Shirley Sontheimer; H. LADDIE MONTAGUE,	. Po 0 JR., ESQ. FOR Plaintiff Blum; JERRY COHEN, ESQ. FOR Marc
co Busman, et al. and Joan Sacarob, et al.; EDWARD HABER, ESQ.
FOR Renee Logan; MYRON M. CHERRY, ESQ. FOR Gloria Ehrlich and
; Janet Weber Bahr; MICHAEL J. FREED, ESQ. FOR Crate and
Barrel, Inc.; and STEVEN M. KIPPERMAN, ESQ. FOR Tillie Lee
ouie and i iyi t
80/12/08 21 | redPdkRend B3TiE MATE BRON tT Mit ehusetts. w/cert. of sve. (ds)
80/12/12; 22 { LETTER - Basic & Louie re recent developments in Basic-
; stayed - Louie - remanded to State Court and Reynolds -
i Co remanded to State Court w/Northern California Order. (ds)
80/12/12} 23 LETTER - Cuisinarts re recent development Louie - remanded
| Cd to State Court and Gayer (S. Cal.) - remand motion
80/12/09 24 | (PEERS Bsen (@80rt) Copy of Defendant Cruisinarts, Inc.
| ANSWER TO COMPLAINT filed in E.D. Virginia. Re: A-3. (ds)	i .
| /

JPML FORM 1A P.3
DOCKET ENTRIES
JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
DOCKET NO. 447 —— In re Cuisinart Food Processor Antitrust Litigation
Date Pleading Description
81/01/16 CONSENT OF TRANSFEREE COURT for assignment of litigation to
the Honorable Jose A. Cabranes. (emh)
81/01/16 OPINION AND ORDER transferring A-4, A-7 thru A-10 to the
District of Connecticut for coordinated or consolidated
pretrial proceedings. (emh)
81/02/23 ONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDERS FILED TODAY.
A-11 Eisenberger v. Cuisinarts, Inc., N.Y.,S., 80-6130
A-12 Mass. v. Cuisinarts, Inc., Mass, 80-2430-K
B-13 Harwood v. Federated, N.Y.,S., 80-6622
B-14 Archer v. Federated, N.Y.,S. 80-6740
Notified counsel, involved judges. (rew)
81/03/11 | CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDERS FINAL TODAY --—
A-11 Eisenberger v. Cuisinarts, S.D.M.Y., 80-Civ.6130(MJL
A-12 Commonwealth of Mass., et al. v. Cuisinarts, D.Mass.
80-2430-K
B-13 Harwood, etc. v. Federated Dept. Stores, Inc.,
S.D.N.Y., 80-Civ.6622
B-14 Archer v. Federated Dept. Stores, Inc., et al.
S.D.N.Y., 80-Civ.6740
Notified involved clerks and judges. (ea)
81/04/03 CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDER FILED TODAY -- B-15 Schenk wv.
Sontheimer, et al., 5.D. New York, C.A. No. 81-CIV-6151
(ML). Notified involved counsel & judges. (ds)
81/04/09 CORRECTION ORDER -- Correct 1g civil action number in B-15	from 81 Civ 6151 to 81 Civ 1651. Notified involved
counsel and judges. (ds)
81/04/21 CONDITIONAL TRANSFER ORDER FINAL TODAY -- B-15 Schenk v.
Sontheimer, et al., S.D.N.Y., 81-CIV-1651(ML) -- NOTIFIED
INVOLVED JUDGES AND CLERKS (cds)

JPML Form 1
® t
Revised: 8/78
DOCKET NO. 447 -— JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
CAPTION: _In re Cuisinart Food Processor Antitrust Litigation
SUMMARY OF LITIGATION
12/9/80 Dates Filed Type Citation District Name of Judge Assigned From
. 1/16/81 D&O 306 F5pp. 651P- Connecticut Jose A. Cabranes
Special Transferee Information
Vs
“4, Thanol_ Fhe . DATE CLOSED:yy / lr val)
(Corre ALLE 2
TAA-RL G2

D ACTIONS 7
JPMI, FORM 1 LISTING OF INVOLVE (0) - ga _
DOCKET NO. 447 -- _In re Cuisinart Food Processor An Us gation aa @,
Intra” District] Civi Tans feredpate of Se
Office and Action ransfer| Docket [Dismissal =
Number Caption IJudge Number Date Number [or Remand Misc.
A-1 |Fred Cohn, et al., etc. v. Cuisinarts,D.Conn. | B80-444 TA 1C/RY, § 37
Inc. Lay : . 2 2
10/34/83
A~2 Frederick Blum v. Cuisinarts, Inc. YA 880-610 yi / :	- C pORA NE
oan S acon Te) D Cp BOEw re _— /y1/51DA-3 OF Emi B rch, T4/ Ve Cuisinarts, # J): 17) Soo-0054 "TA ¢ // § . ifief3Inc. pists SI-AS5
’
’ A) py A tf, A &rng ™~y
A-4 V Basic Living Products, Inc., etc. v. [N.D.Cal. csn-3781-ac3AN 1 6 B® gi1042 | Fg lo
Cuisinarts, Inc. ollenberg
~ ~ Sour Ey 1 Al ,
A-5 Tillie Lee Louie, etc. v. Cuisinarts, N.D.CalC80-3929«RPA/ ~ : I 7 y a a pee
Inc. Aguilar 7 :
A-6" Robert Reynolds d/b/a Douglas Gardens, :D.Cal.|C80-3030-SW— : IRE SE EE 1/
etc., et al. v. Cuisinarts, Inc. _ illiams| ~~ ) Lor te Peto
“0/2 /630A-7 Belle Linda Gayer, etc. v. Cuisinarts,S.D.Cal.|[80-1675-GT(M}AN 1 © gai H- §/ je) fInc. ompson i
Sess b)A-8/ Janet Webber Bahr, etc. v. Marshall .D.I11 | 80C5227 JAN 1 ¢ 1981 H§/-2 7 8/64
Field & Co., Inc. Flaum
- A=-9/ Gloria Ehrlich, etc. v. Crate & Barrel|,N.D.I1ll|80C5228 JAN 1 6 ogy #61 278 $ fg)s10Inc. Bua
A-10 Renee Logan v. Cuisinarts, Inc. Mass. 80-2257-5] N 1 8 198 H-§1-¢9 iff ; NSkinner |

Cc Document 1 Filed 05/18/15 Page 6 of9
seus FORM 1 -CEEAhld	Le Listing of Involved Actions -- p.2
DOCKET No. 447 -- In re Cuisinart Food Processor Antitrust Litigation
Intra- District Civil : Date of
Office and Action TransferflransfereePismissal
Number! Caption Judge Number Date pocket No.pr Remand Misc.
A-11 Agnes Eisen ergex v. Cuisinarts, Inc. S.D.N.Y 80 Civ ERY J VIIa dears :	Nz IS Lowe AR 1981
A-12 ommonwealth of Rar A et al. vj. D.Mass Ma FT 1 1 1581 /780-172 je foy/53 1 Pd	uisinarts, Inc. 4&5 § Keeton Vif ;
B-13 | Robert I. Harwood, etc. v. Federated §.D.N.Y.|80 Civ 6622 3’ y oe - L953
Department Stores, Inc. 2 3/5 4 annella MAR 11 db 1751 /7 Zz /
B-14 yvonne S. Archer v,., Federated Dept. 5.D.N.Y.{80 Civ S140 11 i984 HIT 10/39/35 D
Department Stores, ay * al. agliard LAN iB-15 | Audrey Schenk v. Cafl Sontheimer, S.D.N.Y.| 81-Civ- . NEL H 8-295 A
et al. <f 3/57 Lowe 1651 co
Co ea PE uid 2 i 2) J ge
PY Ve <s <> D0 XY. 5 “7	AA Puy J	i rd > o ‘
ye o53 ; . J
J EN LV OFre
XyZ-16 State of New Jersey, et al. v. D. ConnJ 81-170 121832
Cuisinarts, Inc., et al. . /] Y/,
4 /; ’ ” V4 CZ
| | | : |

JPML Form 4 . ~.
ATTORNEY SERVICE LIST
JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
DOCKET NO. 447 -- _ IN RE CUISINART FOOD PROCESSOR ANTITRUST LITIGATION
FRED COHN, ET AL. (A-1) JANET WEBBER BAHR, ETC. (A-8)
Ira B. Rose, Esq. GLORIA EHRLICH, ETC. (A-9 :
Phillips, Nizer, Benjamin, Krim,
& Ballon Myron M. Cherry, Esq.
40 West 57th Street Cherry & Flynn
New York, New York 10019 One IBM Plaza, Suite 4501 :
Chicago, Illinois 60611
FREDERICK BLUM (A=2)
H. Laddie Montague, Jr., Esq. : RENEE LOGAN (A-10)
: Berger & Montague, P.C. Edward F. Haber, Esq.
1622 Locust Street 33 Broad Street
ilad ia, 191
Philadelphia, PA 03 Boston, Mass. 02109
DONAID A. SACAROB (A-3) CUISINARTS, INC.
Jerry S. Cohen, Esq. CARL G. SONTHEIMER
Kohn, Milstein & Cohen SHIRLEY M. SONTHEIMER Cat
‘1776	K Street, N.W. Arthur M. Handler, Esg. ~~
washington, D. C. 20006 Golenbock and Barell
, EE OE SSS v	- : 645 Fifth Avenue
mesa meee = Dt eee New York, New York 10022
BASIC LIVING PRODUCTS, INC. (A-4)
Steven M. Kipperman, Esquire MARSHALL FIELD & CO., INC.
407 Sansome St., Suite 400 } Steven D. McCormick, Esq.
| San Francisco, Calif. 94111 Kirkland & Ellis
| 200 East Randolph Drive
| Chicago, Illinois 60601
| a
| Michael J. Freed, Esq.
135 South LaSalle Street
Chicaga, Illinois 60603
JAMES D. MAH ASSOCIATES
3 Aaron M. Greenberg, Esq.
i ST i Phillips, Cohn & Greenberg
BELLE LINDA GAYER, ETC, (A-7 One Maritime Plaza, Suite 725
O. Merritt Burrus, II, Esq. San Francisco, Calif. 94111
1200 Third Avenue
Suite 1100
San Diego, Calif. 92101

JPML FORM 4A -- Continuation
Panel Attorney Service List -- p. 2
DOCKET NO. 447 —_— IN RE CUISINART FOOD PROCESSOR ANTITRUST LITIGATION
Don T. Hibner, Jr., Esq. 1218 sixteenth Street, N.W.
Sheppard, Mullin, Richter & Hampton Washington, D. C. 20036
333 South Hope Street - 48th Floor
| Los Angeles, Calif. 90071 Beverly C. Mdore, Jr., Esquire
4420 Connecticut Ave., N W.
HARDWICK TOWNSEND, INC. Suite 228
Richard A. Dinnebier, Esd. washington, D. C. 20008
888 North Main Street .
suite 904 FEDERATED DEPARTMENT STORES
Santa Ana, California 92701 (Deft. B-13 & B-14)
Daniel H. Margolis, Esquire
| Bergson, Borkland, Margolis &
| Adler
a | 11 pupont Circle	washington, D. C. 20036
AGNES	EISENBERGER	(A-11)
Robert N. Kaplan, Esquire AUDREY SCHENK (B-15)
Kaplan, Kilsheimer & Foley Ira Jay Sands, Esquire
122 East 42nd Street 515 Madison Avenue
New York, New York 10168 New York, New York 10022
| COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS, Jer Lash
ET AL. (A-12) Sales Manager of Cuisinarts, Inc.
| Alan L. Kovacs, Esquire 411 West Putnam Avenue
| One Ashburton Place, Room 1902 Greenwich, Connecticut
Boston, Massachusetts 02108
ROBERT I, HARWOOD (B-13)
Kass, Goodkind, Wechsler &
Labaton
122 East 42nd Street
New York, New York 10168
YVONNE S. ARCHER (B=14)
James Finch, Esquire
Kirkwood, Kaplan, Russin
& Vecchi
Gulf & Western Bldg.,
6th Flocr
15 Columbus Circle
New York, New York 10023

JPML FORM 3 )
p. ££
COMMON PARTY CHECKLIST -- JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
DOCKET NO. 447 -- In re Cuisinart Food Processor Antitrust Litigation
Named as Party in Following Actions
_ 4 2 9-5 SL tf {J — oy ~/d.
——" ——	ry"
77 -
Crate & Barrel,: Inc. i
Al A-rs
Carl G. Sontheimer a
a;
shirley M. Sontheimer |
Ae
| zz]
J. W. Robinson, Inc. |
44 7
Federated Dept. Stores [CL	HHS]
B73
Jerry Lash