IN RE: Ecological Sciences Corporation Litigation

rd
Zi
0
3
oo
0 +
RB
Date | s
| San Francisco alifornia
10/6/71 | |sSHOW CAUSE AND HEARING ORDER amended to add B-1 through B-4, Oct. 29, 19
LC Sanfrancisco, Calif. Notified counsel involved judge
0 J AMEND SCO & HEARING ORDER to include C-1 - Klafter v. cological
[| S.D. Fla., No. 71-1466-Civ-JLK.
10 Ll.| PLTF. ROSENFIELD to Order to Show Cause.& brief.
10/13/71 Plaintiffs in Arnold Dutchen, et eno. to SCO.
10/13/71 PLTF. LESTER C. WEINBERG response to SCO.
g-+14 | AMEND SCO & HEARING ORDER to include D-1 - Richman v, Ecological, E.D.
| ii 0. 71-C=500
10/14/71 § 4. IHASKINS & SELLS REPONSE to SCO. (and supporting brief). de
10/15/71
0/18 ¢	| Response	© ologica ience and Koenig to 0
0/18 | 7 | AUERBACH (defenda Response to SCO (1 cpy received
10/26/71 —— PLT. ROSENFIELD (supplement to pleading NG.	10 8 plaintiffs WASYLOW and HNIDKO response to OSC w/certificate of service
0/238 9 loroec ROGOVIN, PEARSON, GOLDFARB & WEISBERG —- Response to Show Cause Order.
11/8/71 i 10 orida Plaintiffs response to order to show cause.
24/71 Mi Mark Auerbach memo regarding further developments w.cert of service.o IE Judge Lasker from Roger W. Van Deusen attorney for Ecological
} |"J "Science stating disposition of Penna. case 1301 w/cpy of order.
! | Roger W andusen (Ecological Science) encl. Judge Lasker's
— [ ® 0/71 re: transfer of N actions to S.D. Fla,
[| JORDER - and NOTICE OF HEARING, Washington, D. C. Jan. 28, 1972
FC] o show cause what effect the filing of SECURITIES EXCHANGE COMMISSION
[ . BCOLOGICAL SCIENCE CORP., S.D.N.Y. 71 Civ. 5016, or any other event
[ subsequent to the 10/29/71 hearing on this matter should have on the
nn guestion of transfer of the actions listed on the HXKKAXKEAXREKXHXKHE
] itigation A-1 through D-1.
1/3/72 S.E.C. V. ECOLOGICAL SCIENCE CORP, S.D.N.Y. 71 Civ. 5016, or any other
|] event subsequent to 10/29/71 hearing -~ response from several of
[ the defendants (including Ecological Science)
1/6/72 S.E.C. V. ECOLOGICAL SCIENCE, S.D.N.Y. 71 Civ. 5016,
Ie Response of Haskin and Sells to Order of 12/22/71
1/17/72 |J ORDER entered - vacating the Show Cause Order entered 9/29/71 and
| Hearing order entered 12/22/71. Notified counsel, transferor |
LC clerks, involved judges.
1/21/72 Response of Plaintiffs Rogovin, Pearson, Goldfarb and Weisberg to
[ the Panel's Show Cause Order.
1 | ORDER - denying ansfer o he itigation acating how 3 e
] order without prejudice to the right of any ps3 Q MOVE
CC] he panel O onsolidation © 1a0 QO 8 §14Q0
| [|]
|
| [|
[|] _
yr
I
]
|
[| :

) DOCKET NO. _ 86
DOCKET -- JUDICIAL PANEL oN MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
® Description of Litigation %	A
IN RE ECOLOGICAL SCIENCES CORPORATION LITIGATION
DISTRICT & TRANSFER
NO. CAPTION D.C. NUMBER} JUDGE DATE MISC.
/. | FLA	A-1 Arnold Dutchen & Seena Haimowitz v. S.D. NF, SCO 9/29
Ecological Science Corp., et al. >I 2Y59 or (*)
J 7/1726C14
A-2 Lester C. Weinberg v. Harold P. Koenig, |.S.D. d=¥.F4] . ket al. 209-8] OK eR (*)sco 9/29
} ne 7/7927 —&M
A-3 . J John Wasylow, et Ql. v. Harold P. Sn S5.0.0.Y L : oCKoeniq, et al. 7, susie ied put net 1 Cy 15 “k*)sco 97/29
Sas imitied ver’) ’ He 2515)
ve A. Harry Skydell v. Harold Koenig, S.D. ¥¥-fAha.et al. 71 Civ. 264 *)sco 9/29
7/7722£
A-5 Leon G. Seyranian, etc. v. Ecological, _|N.B-—€alif. ~
Science, Inc., et al. (&2 Fha. 2/775 AYox Ke SCO 9/29	“a, # 5,
VA-6 David M. Rosenfield v. Ecological EET a. (Kk) F1738-7C	Sicence Corp., et al. 71-I801D roderifk SCO 9/29
Va-7 Joel Goldfarb v. Harold P. Koenig, S.D. Fla.
et al. 71-1242-CiviTC xx) (2004)
Capot SCO 9/29
/A-8 William I. Weisberg v. Harold P. Koenig, |S.D. Fla.
et al. 71-1244-Civ}TC Cabot xx) (2046)
i sco 9/29
SB-1 Bertrude Kaplan, et al. wv. Ecological ~.} S.D. Fla. Aen ltadl
Science Corp., et al. {71-1257-Civ-TC Cabo S00 sda
o_o Seymour Regovin v. Harold P. Koenig S.D. Fla. (17170© et al. , 1-1127~-CivHTC Cabo Clo L0/E. Pa
v B-3 Daniel J. Monaco v. Ecologieal Science S.D. Fla.	; : so
Corp., et al. 1-1352~CivHrC Caba cco /0 Z
/B-4 Dr. Carl M. Pearson v. Ecological S.D. Fla.Science Corp., et al. 1-1058-CivHI'C Cabag Laren iianl
(*) Consolidated for all purposes - 9/3/11
® (**) Transferred from S.D. New York - 8/2471Co (**%) Transferred	to S.D. Fla. - 10/15/71

DOCKET NO. 86
DOCKET -~- JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
-
	_—
@ Description of LitigationIN RE ECOLOGICAL SCIENCE CORPORATION LITIGATION
DISTRICT & TRANSFER
NO. CAPTION D.C. NUMBER} JUDGE DATE MISC.
C-1 Melvin L. Klafter, et al. v. Ecological S.D. Fla. AmerikaScience Corporation, et al. ~ ~Ci
p ' 71-1466-Civ}JLK Sco-re/ /
-1 Alvin Richman, etc. v. Ecological E.D. Wisc. Roser len
Science Corp., et al. A7ad. FA . 71-C=500 ordon deo -/904/s

) . DOCKET NO. 86
ATTORNEY LIST -- JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
es
% DESCRIPTION OF LITIGATION	IN RE ECOLOGICAL SCIENCES CORPORATION LITIGATION
ee
A-1 Dermot G. Foley, Esquire N id Ecological Sciences C orp.Kaplan, Kilsheimer & Foley | <“T Harold ®. Koenig R
o 122 East 42nd Street : aN Murrdy.	A. Gordon, Esquire	New York, New York 10017 401 Brdadway
New York,-New York 10013
A-2 Irving Steinman, Esquire Same as A-1 above (Gordon)
11 Park Place
New York, New York 10007 \
A-3 Samuel P. Sporn, Esquire Same\ as A-1 above (Gordon); also for
Schoengold & Sporn 30 defendants	217 Broadway “g Norman J. Davidson =~
New York, New York 10007 =~ Sornchs G. Fabian, Jr.:
Robert"J. Grosh
“Jack H.“-Vollbrecht
“SRobert Bi Carter
Richard J.Silvestrini ~
. Charles A. "Macaluso
lak V4 (odolee or J. Peter Martin h	} A-4 | , Esquire KE
Kass, Goodkind, Wechsler & Gerstein Sameas A-1 above (Gordon)
122 East 42nd Street
New York, New York 10017 _=
A-5 Hal F. Seibert, Esquire -
o Laub, Seyranian & Mackay :	605 Central Building
436 14th Street
Oakland, California 94612
A-6 | Moxheit & Rosenfield, Esquire alhen Pikes : anaging pRriner)
12I1\S. roa{ Stree Suite 1718 Wolf, Blwck, Schorr\& Solis-Cohen
Philkdelphia, Pa. 9107 PacMhard B\ildin
2 Philagelphiy, Pa.\ 19X02 \
Harold Ne, Koh Esquire
1700 Market Street Ecodogic ON “\O12th Flodqr, IVB Ruildikg Mogxgan\ Lewis Boc Nx	Philadelphia, Pa.\ 1910 210X The\Fideli Bldy.
® : EX ia, Pa. Hhi Aaron M. Fine, Esquire ;
1214 IVB Building g Robert C. Dean, Jr.1700 Market Street Marshall, Simonds, Esquire
. . Proctor & Hoar
Philadelphia, Pa- 19103 28 State Street
Boston, Mass. 02109

No. Defendant
A-7 Rosenthal & Gurkin HASKINS & SELLS
19 West 44th Street Michael A. Cooper, Esquire
New York, New York 10036 Sullivan & Cromwell
48 Wall Street
A-8 Mordecai Rosenfeld, Esquire New York, New York 10005
233 Broadway
New York, New York 10007
“~
Mr. Magk Auerbach
520 E. h Street
New Ts York
Mr. Cesare De Franceschino ~
Vice President . CBoologicalgeience Corporation
20215 N. W. qd AvenueMiami, Florida™33169
Mr. Rennsselaer W. Bartram TIT “
: 1122 North~Qcean Boulevard
Gulf Stream, “Delray Beach, Florida
r. George V. R. Mulligan N|
Director, Egological Science Corp.
20215 N. W. 2nd Avenue
Miami, Florida 33169
Mr. Arthur Cantor
234 West 44th Street ~
New York, New York
Mr. Norman Prusinski J
Ecological\Science Corporation
20215 N. W. 2nd Avenue	Miami, Florida 33169
Me, Jerome S. Wagshal, EL
Sominedii.. @20235-NWr2Na Avene ~~,
TEE TI AS peI EE Sd YU Rese	yg
} Mr. C. E. Woolen
Ecological Science Corporation
20215 .N. W. 2nd Avenue
§ Miami, Florida 33169

DOCKET NO. 86
ATTORNEY LIST -- JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
nse eee ES SS
A DESCRIPTION OF LITIGATION	IN RE ECOLOGICAL SCIENCES CORPORATION LITIGATION
ee
B-1] H. J. Frazier, Esquire
0 Suite 701, Kenann Building3101 No. Federal Highway
Ft. Lauderdale, Fla. 33306
B-2{ Stanley L. Kaufman, Esquire Same as A-1 above (Gordon)
Kaufman, Taylor, Kimmel & Miller
41 East 42nd Street
New York, New York 10017
ECOLOGICAL SCIENCE CORPORATION
B-3| Joseph W. Cotchett, Esquire HAROLD P. KOENIG
Colson & Hicks NORMAN J. DAVIDSON ~
2d Floor, Concord Bldg. FRANCIS G. FABIAN, JR. eC
66 West Flagler Street ROBERT J. GROSH TD
Miami, Fla. 33130 JACK H. VOLLBRECHT Sm mil
ROBERT B. CARTER IT
B-4] Kelly, Black, Black & Kenny RICHARD J. SILVERSTRINI O°
a 1409 Alfred I. duPont Building CHARLES A. MACALUSO
+] Miami, Florida ~— §J. PETER MARTIN
2 CESARE D. FRANCESCHINO
: . : . RENNSSELAER W. BARTRAM, III
C-1}F MeIxin LN lafte BBRORGE V. R. MULLIGAN
39 Soy Gee oe t ARTHUR CANTOR	Chicago,~Illimqis 60803 NORMAN PRUSINSKI
Roger W. Van Deusen, Esquire
C B. F. Paty, Jr., Esquire Metzenbaum, Gaines, Finley &
Paty, Downey, Lewis & acon 2 So Stern Co., E.P.A.	486—Royel-—Ralm-Way AO. Box 23¢s £ 1700 Investment Plaza
Palm Beach, Florida 33480 = 1801 East 9th Street
Cleveland, Ohio 44114
D-1 George E. Shoup, Jr., Esquire
Hersh, Stupar, Stepke, Gollin & SchultzMARK AUERBACH >
Suite 1810, 633 W. Wisconsin Avenue Stuart A. Summit, Esquire «
Milwaukee, Wisconsin 53203 Miller & Summit LE
90 Broad Street ——
> New York, New York 10004 == =~

No. Defendant
ECOLOGICAL SCIENCE CORPORATION
HAROLD P. KOENIG
NO N J. DAVIDSON
RENNSSELAER W. BERTRAM
FRANCIS,	C. FABIAN, JR.
DR. RICRARD J. GROSH	JACK H. VQLL_RECHT
: ROBERT B. ‘CARTER
GEORGE V. MULL IGAN
MARK AUERBA!
CESARE DE F CESCHINO
Gergorg M. Hyrvey, Esq.
Morgan, Lewis\& Bockius
123 South Broad Street CPhiladelphia, Pa. 19109

Pp. 1
JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION
DOCKET NO. 86 -- IN RE ECOLOGICAL SCIENCES CORPORATION LITIGATION
>NY
: COMMON PARTY CHECKLIST ’
NAME OF PARTY NAMED AS PARTY IN FOLLOWING ACTIONS
A-/A-2, 8-3 A=	'A-5'8-4.8-7,A-8'0	= 16-2 15-3,8-4
Ecological Science o-V:p-y ~~ sr rr 7 rr J 7
Corporation A
le
A—/A-218~2,8-%	RSA \H-/,0-3 .D—[, P~2.8-5,45-4]
Harold P. Koenig Jd-\,p-y) ZF JF 7 r= Fr ST
I.
® eee]
~ A-3 As RN-GJC-1'D-/
Norman J. Davidson AE	A.
a
EE
2-%.A-s:822
| zz	r-
Robert c. Dean, Jr. | ~~	~~
rr]
~ EN EEN Ev AI ry
-
| Francis G6. Fabian, Jy —— — — —— — —— ~~ ~~
-_
re __]
4-2A-sS,-/D=-) ooo]
N iRobert J. Grosh
~ B-3,pS ALD]	| -
C Jack H. Vollbrecht __	a
—	-—
a-12,4%5,8-6¢~-/ OOOO]
~J MAA
fRark Auerbach ee
|]
N A-2,A-spnbt2-'D-) oo]
Robert B. Carter AAA
_
® yCesare DeFranceshini "="	~~ ~~ |

Pe
0-3 |y
Norman Prusinski
; ————— d	Richard J. Silvestrini -—
x-%___________ oo]
Rensselaer W. Bartram 111 [97	“BEI
) A-3 8-5. &-L0-7 OOOO]
George V. R. Mulligan HE	A
is	OOOO]
~ ee]
~ =
J. Peter Martin 1
x]
a| 7 oHaskin & Sells, a ee]
N rs. OOOO]
Haskin & Sells, a yr]
artnershi ee]
F SUP —
ee \, . SN. AA	Leg	ay” Half, LVFAT	managing partndr of : Ne Ll, 5 2
\ oA of	Arthur Cantor A 54