Pacific Resources Associates LLC v. Suzy Cleaners et al

3:20-cv-00234Casd2 déc. 2025

Texte intégral

1
20-cv-0234-RBM-DEB
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
PACIFIC RESOURCES ASSOCIATES
LLC, a Delaware limited liability
company, et al.,
Plaintiffs,
v.
SUZY CLEANERS, an organization,
et al.,
Defendants,
AND RELATED CROSS-CLAIMS.
Case No.: 20-cv-0234-RBM-DEB
Consolidated: 22-cv-1892-RBM-DEB
ORDER GRANTING THE
HORTMANS’ MOTION TO
ENFORCE PROTECTIVE ORDER
AND FOR SANCTIONS
[DKT. NO. 308]
I. 	INTRODUCTION
Before the Court is the Hortman Parties’ Motion to Enforce Protective Order and for
Sanctions (“Motion for Sanctions”). Dkt. No. 308. For the reasons discussed below, the
Court GRANTS the Hortmans’ Motion for Sanctions and awards sanctions against the
Kims’ counsel. See Dkt. No. 308.1
1 The “Hortmans” are Kim Buhler, the court appointed administrator and executor of the
Estate of Barbara Hortman and co-trustee, and/or Norman Alton Hortman, III, co-trustee
of the Norman Alton Hortman and Barbara Hortman Revocable Trust No. 1 Dated July 2,
Case 3:20-cv-00234-RBM-DEB Document 334 Filed 12/02/25 PageID.<pageID>
Page 1 of 8
2
20-cv-0234-RBM-DEB
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
II. 	PROCEDURAL AND FACTUAL BACKGROUND
This case arises out of alleged soil contamination at the Valley Plaza shopping center
in Escondido, California. The remaining claims are between current and former property
owners and owners/operators of dry-cleaning businesses allegedly responsible for the
contamination.
One disputed issue is whether the Hortmans fraudulently transferred Trust assets to
avoid financial responsibility for the Valley Plaza investigation and remediation. The
Hortmans produced financial information in response to discovery requests. The Hortmans
designated their financial information as “Confidential” and subject to the Court’s
Protective Order, 	which 	requires 	that 	“[a]ll 	confidential 	information 	designated 	as
‘CONFIDENTIAL’ must not be disclosed by the receiving party . . . and, in any event,
must not be used for any purpose other than in connection with this litigation[.]”
Dkt. No. 276 ¶ 7.
In a separate administrative proceeding, the San Diego Regional Water Quality
Control Board (“Water Board”) issued a final Cleanup and Abatement Order (“CAO”) for
Valley Plaza. The Water Board named the Kims, but not the Hortmans, as responsible
parties. Dkt. No. 283 at 30–34. The Kims, through their counsel, filed a Petition for Review
with the State Water Resources Control Board challenging the Hortmans’ omission from
the CAO. See Dkt. No. 306-2 (“Water Board Petition”). The Kims’ Petition alleges the
Hortmans fraudulently transferred Trust assets to themselves and described certain of those
assets. Id. at 12–13, 17, 19.
The Kims also filed a complaint against the Hortmans in the San Diego County
Superior Court (“Superior Court Complaint”).2 The Kims’ Superior Court Complaint
similarly alleges the Hortmans fraudulently conveyed Trust assets to avoid liability for the
1985 (the “Trust”). The “Kims” are third-party Plaintiffs Guhn Y. Kim, Yun Soon Kim,
and the Kim Family Trust of 2017.
2 Guhn, et al. v. Buhler, et al., No. 25-CU-10275-C (Cal. Sup. Ct. Feb. 7, 2025).
Case 3:20-cv-00234-RBM-DEB Document 334 Filed 12/02/25 PageID.<pageID>
Page 2 of 8
3
20-cv-0234-RBM-DEB
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
alleged soil contamination at Valley Plaza. Dkt. No. 306-3. The Superior Court Complaint
also describes the Hortmans’ assets. Id. ¶¶ 12, 14, 22.
The Hortmans seek sanctions against the Kims and their attorney, alleging they
violated the Court’s Protective Order by disclosing the Hortmans’ confidential financial
information in the Water Board Petition and Superior Court Complaint. Dkt. No. 306-1
at 5–6. The Hortmans’ Supplemental Brief seeks additional sanctions for a third violation
of the Protective Order that allegedly occurred when the Kims’ counsel filed a new lawsuit
against the Hortmans (and others), George Landt, et al. v. M&E Brothers, LLC, et al.,
United States District Court, Southern District of California, Case No. 3:25-cv-01364-
RBM-DEB (“Landt Action”). Dkt. No. 328.
The Court held a hearing on the Motion for Sanctions. Dkt. No. 326; see also Dkt.
No. 330 (Sealed Hr’g Tr.). The Court now finds counsel for the Kims violated the Court’s
Protective Order and imposes sanctions.
III. 	LEGAL STANDARD
Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 37 grants courts authority to impose sanctions for
protective order violations. Westinghouse Elec. Corp. v. Newman & Holtzinger, P.C., 992
F.2d 932, 934–35 (9th Cir. 1993); see also Apple, Inc. v. Samsung Elecs. Co., No. 5:11-cv-
01846-LHK-PSG, 2014 WL 12596470, *5 (N.D. Cal. 2014) (“[T]he Ninth Circuit has
repeatedly 	held 	that 	Rule 	37 	‘provide[s] 	comprehensively 	for 	enforcement 	of 	all
[discovery] 	orders, 	including 	Rule 	26(c) 	protective 	orders.’” 	(citing 	Westinghouse,
992 F.2d at 934–35)). “Sanctions are permissible under Rule 37 when a party fails to
comply with a court order, regardless of the reasons.” Life Techs. Corp. v. Biosearch
Techs., 	Inc., 	No. 	12-cv-0852-WHA-JCS, 	2012 	WL 	1600393, 	at 	*8 	(N.D. 	Cal.
May 7, 2012).
The Court has “discretion whether to issue sanctions under Rule 37(b), and if so,
what types of sanctions to issue.” Cabrales v. BAE Sys. San Diego Ship Repair, Inc., No.
21-cv-2122-AJB-DDL, 2023 WL 5985517, at *1 (S.D. Cal. Sept. 13, 2023) (citing Von
Brimer v. Whirlpool Corp., 536 F.2d 838, 844 (9th Cir. 1976)). The sanctions, however,
Case 3:20-cv-00234-RBM-DEB Document 334 Filed 12/02/25 PageID.<pageID>
Page 3 of 8
4
20-cv-0234-RBM-DEB
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
“must be just” and “specifically relate to the particular claim at issue in the discovery
order.” Navalier v. Sletten, 262 F.3d 923, 947 (9th Cir. 2001) (citing Ins. Corp. of Ireland,
Ltd. v. Compagnie des Bauxites de Guinee, 456 U.S. 694, 707 (1982)). Unless the violation
was “substantially justified or other circumstances make an award of expenses unjust[,]”
the Court “must” order the disobedient party, its attorney, or both, to pay for reasonable
expenses caused by the noncompliance. Fed. R. Civ. P. 37(b)(2)(C).
IV. 	DISCUSSION
For the reasons discussed below, the Court finds: (A) the Hortmans designated their
financial information as “Confidential” and subject to the Protective Order; (B) the
Hortmans’ designations were proper; (C) the Kims disclosed the Hortmans’ confidential
financial information in their Water Board Petition and Superior Court Complaint; and
(D) sanctions are warranted.
A. 	The Hortmans Designated Their Financial Information as Confidential and
Subject to the Protective Order
In January 2025, the Hortmans produced financial documents in response to
discovery requests. Dkt. No. 308-6. The documents included Trust records, tax returns, and
personal bank statements. Id.; see also Dkt. No. 306-5. The Hortmans also answered
interrogatories about Trust assets and distributions. See, e.g., Dkt. No. 306-7 at 6. The
Hortmans designated these discovery responses as “Confidential” and subject to the
Protective Order. See Dkt. No. 308-6.
The Hortmans also gave deposition testimony about their finances and designated
this testimony as “Confidential” and subject to the Protective Order. Dkt. No. 306-8
at 4–5 (Hortman Dep.); Dkt. No. 306-9 at 5–6 (Buhler Dep.); Dkt. No. 308-3 ¶¶ 9–10, 12
(McMillan Decl.); Dkt. No. 308-7 (attorney e-mails).
B. 	The Hortmans’ Designations Were Proper
The Kims’ Opposition argues the Hortmans improperly designated their financial
information as confidential and subject to the Protective Order. These arguments include:
(1) the Hortmans are not “parties” entitled to designate discovery as subject to the
Case 3:20-cv-00234-RBM-DEB Document 334 Filed 12/02/25 PageID.<pageID>
Page 4 of 8
5
20-cv-0234-RBM-DEB
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Protective Order; (2) their financial information is not protectable because the Hortman
matriarch is deceased; (3) they did not timely designate their deposition testimony as
subject to the Protective Order; and (4) their financial information is publicly available.
The Protective Order, however, contains a procedure for a party to challenge the
propriety of designating discovery as “Confidential” and subject to the Protective Order:
the objecting party must notify the designating party of the objection, “promptly meet and
confer,” and bring any unresolved disputes to the Court. Dkt. No. 276 ¶ 24. The objecting
party “must” treat the materials at issue as confidential “until the Court has ruled on the
objection” or the issue is otherwise resolved. Id.
The Kims did not invoke this procedure for the discovery at issue. Instead, the Kims
publicly 	disclosed 	the 	discovery 	at 	issue 	and 	now 	make 	after-the-fact 	arguments
challenging the designations. This is impermissible. See, e.g., DS Advanced Enterps., Ltd.
v. Lowe’s Home Ctrs., LLC, No. 23-cv-1335-CAB-JLB, 2025 WL 586030, at *1 (S.D. Cal.
Feb. 24, 2025) (“[C]ounsel could not unilaterally decide to ignore the designation because
he thought it improperly designated.”); Brady v. Grendene USA, Inc., No. 12-cv-0604-
GPC-KSC, 2015 WL 3554968, at *3 (S.D. Cal. June 5, 2015) (“whether something should
be designated confidential is irrelevant to [a party’s] obligation to comply with the
Protective Order”); Brocade Communs. Sys. v. A10 Networks, Inc., No. 10-cv-3428-LHK,
2011 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 99932, at *14 (N.D. Cal. Sep. 6, 2011) (“It is not up to the party
filing a document containing information designated as confidential […] to make a
subjective decision about whether the designation is accurate. That decision is for the court
to make.”).
The Kims’ arguments also fail on the merits. As counsel for the Kims acknowledged
at the hearing on this Motion, Kim Buhler and Norman Hortman are parties in their capacity
as trustees, they are living beneficiaries of the Hortman Trust, and they designated the
financial information provided in their discovery responses as confidential and subject to
the Protective Order. Dkt. No. 330 at 31. Confirming this, the discovery at issue was
Case 3:20-cv-00234-RBM-DEB Document 334 Filed 12/02/25 PageID.<pageID>
Page 5 of 8
6
20-cv-0234-RBM-DEB
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
requested and produced pursuant to Federal Rules of Civil Procedure 30, 33, and 34, which
are not available to obtain discovery from non-parties.
The Court also finds the Hortmans timely designated their deposition testimony as
subject to the Protective Order. At the outset of the depositions, and anticipating the
questioning would seek financial information, the Hortmans’ counsel designated the
depositions as subject to the Protective Order. Dkt. No. 306-8 at 4; Dkt. No. 306-9 at 5–6.
Counsel for the Kims did not object. Id. Once the transcripts were prepared, the Hortmans’
counsel narrowed the designations by identifying the specific pages and lines of testimony
subject to the Protective Order. Dkt. No. 308-7 at 1, 3. The Court finds this two-step
procedure is reasonable and proper, especially in the absence of a contemporaneous
objection.
The Kims’ argument that the Hortmans’ financial information is publicly available
is based on internet searches the Kims’ counsel conducted in preparation for the Motion
hearing. Dkt. No. 330 at 19. Thus, the internet searches were not the source of the
information 	disclosed. 	Moreover, 	the 	searches 	were 	informed 	by 	the 	confidential
information the Hortmans produced in discovery. Id. at 18–19. The Court, therefore, finds
after-the-fact internet searches irrelevant to the analysis.
C. 	The Kims Disclosed the Hortmans’ Confidential Financial Information in the
Water Board Petition and Superior Court Complaint
The Kims disclosed the Hortmans’ confidential financial information in their Water
Board Petition. The Petition describes the type, quantity, and value of the Hortman Trust
assets and specifically references this litigation. Dkt. No. 306-2 at 17, 19. The Petition also
identifies the Hortman parties by name. Id. at 15.
The Kims also disclosed the Hortmans’ confidential financial information in their
Superior Court Complaint. The complaint describes Trust distributions and specific asset
types and values. Dkt. No. 306-3 at 4–8.
At the May 2025 hearing, counsel for the Kims acknowledged the discovery subject
to the Protective Order was the source of at least some of the information in the Water
Case 3:20-cv-00234-RBM-DEB Document 334 Filed 12/02/25 PageID.<pageID>
Page 6 of 8
7
20-cv-0234-RBM-DEB
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Board Petition and Superior Court Complaint. Dkt. No. 330 at 18–19, 23–25. The Court,
therefore, finds the Kims violated the Protective Order by disclosing the Hortmans’
confidential financial information outside of this litigation.
D. 	Sanctions are Warranted
The Court finds compensatory sanctions under Rule 37(b)(2)(C) are warranted to
redress the Kims’ violations of the Protective Order. For the reasons discussed above, the
Kims’ violations of the Protective Order were not substantially justified, and no other
circumstances make sanctions unjust.
Counsel for the Hortmans notified counsel for the Kims of the violations, but counsel
for the Kims initially refused to take any action to mitigate the improper disclosures.
Dkt. No. 308-10; Dkt. No. 308-11. The Hortmans, therefore, filed this Motion to vindicate
their rights under the Protective Order. The Court finds sanctions compensating the
Hortmans for the attorney’s fees incurred in enforcing the Protective Order are appropriate,
just, and specifically relate to the Kims’ violations. Cf. Juul Labs, Inc. v. Chou, No. 21-cv-
3056-DSF-PDx, 2022 WL 2161063, at *9 (C.D. Cal. May 6, 2022) (finding attorney’s fees
sanction unjust in part because counsel “generally cooperat[ed] . . . in attempting to work
through logistical issues and resolve problems” prior to raising issue with the court).
The Hortmans seek $15,645 in fees associated with bringing this (and related)
Motions (21.7 hours at $350/hour, and 32.2 hours at $250/hour). See Dkt. No. 308-16. The
Kims’ Opposition does not dispute the reasonableness of the fees claimed.
The Court has reviewed counsels’ time entries and finds the work and rates
reasonable, with two adjustments. 	The Court excludes 0.10 hour (at the $350 rate) on
April 3, 2025 concerning a minute order not included on the docket in this case, and
excludes 0.20 hour (at the $250 rate) on the same date, regarding unspecified expert
discovery. See Dkt. No. 308-16 at 4; see also Fed. R. Civ. P. 37(b)(2)(C) (permitting award
of “reasonable expenses . . . caused by the failure [to comply]”). The Court, therefore,
awards $15,560 in compensatory sanctions (21.6 hours at $350 ($7560.00), plus 32 hours
at $250 ($8000.00)). The Court finds this amount adequate to both compensate the
Case 3:20-cv-00234-RBM-DEB Document 334 Filed 12/02/25 PageID.<pageID>
Page 7 of 8
8
20-cv-0234-RBM-DEB
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Hortmans for the fees incurred enforcing the Protective Order and deter further violations.
The Court finds this compensatory sanction sufficiently addresses any additional disclosure
in 	the 	related 	Landt 	litigation 	discussed 	in 	the 	Hortmans’ 	Supplemental 	Brief
(Dkt. No. 328).
The record establishes counsel for the Kims is responsible for violating the
Protective Order, rather than the Kims themselves. See Dkt. No. 308-4 (Water Board
Petition filed by counsel); Dkt. No. 306-3 at 2 (Superior Court Complaint filed by counsel);
Dkt. No. 330 at 40, 42 (counsel for the Kims’ acknowledgement of fault). The Court,
therefore, imposes this sanction on counsel only. Cahill v. Nike, Inc., No. 18-cv-1477-JR,
2024 WL 3963809, at *6 (D. Or. Aug. 26, 2024) (imposing attorney’s fees sanctions on
counsel instead of client, “as the party itself played no role in the disclosure.”).
V. 	CONCLUSION
The Court GRANTS the Hortmans’ Motion for Sanctions and ORDERS counsel
for the Kims to reimburse the Hortmans for costs and fees incurred litigating this motion
in the amount of $15,560.00. Counsel must make this payment to Hortmans’ counsel within
thirty days of this Order.
IT IS SO ORDERED.
Dated: December 2, 2025
Case 3:20-cv-00234-RBM-DEB Document 334 Filed 12/02/25 PageID.<pageID>
Page 8 of 8

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.