RlNAT AKHMETSHIN v. William Browder

�nit£h- �tat£s @nurt nf J\pp£als
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT
Argued September 22, 2020 Decided April 13, 2021
No. 19-7129
RlNAT AKHMETSHIN,
APPELLANT
V.
WILLIAM BROWDER,
APPELLEE
On Petition for Panel Rehearing
Michael Tremonte argued the cause for appellant. With
him on the briefs was Alexandra G. Elenowitz-Hess.
Michael J. Gottlieb argued the cause and filed the brief for
appellee. With him on the briefs was Stephanie L. Miner.
Before: TATEL and KATSAS, Circuit Judges, and
EDWARDS, Senior Circuit Judge.
Opinion for the Court filed by Senior Circuit Judge
EDWARDS.

-- 1 of 86 --

2
TABLE OF CONTENTS
OPINION ACCOMPANYING CERTIFICATION OF
QUESTIONS TO THE D.C. COURT OF APPEALS.................. 3
ORIGINAL PANEL OPINION AND DISSENTING OPINION ........ 14
DEFENDANT-APPELLEE' S PETITION FOR PANEL
REHEARINGORREHEARINGENBANC............................ 37
PLAINTIFF-APPELLANT'S RESPONSE TO THE PETITION
FOR PANEL REHEARING AND REHEARING EN BANC............ 61

-- 2 of 86 --

-- 3 of 86 --

-- 4 of 86 --

-- 5 of 86 --

-- 6 of 86 --

-- 7 of 86 --

-- 8 of 86 --

-- 9 of 86 --

-- 10 of 86 --

-- 11 of 86 --

-- 12 of 86 --

-- 13 of 86 --

-- 14 of 86 --

-- 15 of 86 --

-- 16 of 86 --

-- 17 of 86 --

-- 18 of 86 --

-- 19 of 86 --

-- 20 of 86 --

-- 21 of 86 --

-- 22 of 86 --

-- 23 of 86 --

-- 24 of 86 --

-- 25 of 86 --

-- 26 of 86 --

-- 27 of 86 --

-- 28 of 86 --

-- 29 of 86 --

-- 30 of 86 --

-- 31 of 86 --

-- 32 of 86 --

-- 33 of 86 --

-- 34 of 86 --

-- 35 of 86 --

-- 36 of 86 --

-- 37 of 86 --

-- 38 of 86 --

-- 39 of 86 --

-- 40 of 86 --

-- 41 of 86 --

-- 42 of 86 --

-- 43 of 86 --

-- 44 of 86 --

-- 45 of 86 --

-- 46 of 86 --

-- 47 of 86 --

-- 48 of 86 --

-- 49 of 86 --

-- 50 of 86 --

-- 51 of 86 --

-- 52 of 86 --

-- 53 of 86 --

-- 54 of 86 --

-- 55 of 86 --

-- 56 of 86 --

-- 57 of 86 --

-- 58 of 86 --

-- 59 of 86 --

-- 60 of 86 --

-- 61 of 86 --

-- 62 of 86 --

-- 63 of 86 --

-- 64 of 86 --

-- 65 of 86 --

-- 66 of 86 --

-- 67 of 86 --

-- 68 of 86 --

-- 69 of 86 --

-- 70 of 86 --

-- 71 of 86 --

-- 72 of 86 --

-- 73 of 86 --

-- 74 of 86 --

-- 75 of 86 --

-- 76 of 86 --

-- 77 of 86 --

-- 78 of 86 --

-- 79 of 86 --

-- 80 of 86 --

-- 81 of 86 --

-- 82 of 86 --

-- 83 of 86 --

-- 84 of 86 --

-- 85 of 86 --

-- 86 of 86 --