CourtListener 9532073•Ramirez v. Golden Queen Mining Co.
Texte intégral
Filed 5/15/24; modified and certified for publication 6/11/24 (order attached)
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIFTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
CARLOS RAMIREZ,
F086371
Plaintiff and Respondent,
(Super. Ct. No. BCV-22-102808)
v.
GOLDEN QUEEN MINING COMPANY, LLC, OPINION
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Kern County. David R. Zulfa,
Judge.
Belden Blaine Raytis, T. Scott Belden, Kaleb L. Judy and Tyler D. Anthony for
Defendant and Appellant.
Bibiyan Law Group, David D. Bibiyan and Henry G. Glitz for Plaintiff and
Respondent.
-ooOoo-
Carlos Ramirez filed a class action lawsuit against his former employer alleging
various violations of the Labor Code and unfair competition. The employer moved to
compel arbitration. The trial court denied the motion on the ground that the employer
failed to demonstrate the existence of an executed arbitration agreement. The employer
appealed, contending it carried the initial burden of making a prima facie showing that a
written arbitration agreement existed. The employer also contended Ramirez’s
statements that he did not recall being presented with or signing an arbitration agreement
were insufficient to rebut its initial showing and create a factual dispute about the
authenticity of a handwritten signature.
There is a split of authority among the Courts of Appeal as to what constitutes
sufficient evidence to create a factual dispute about the authenticity of a handwritten
signature on a document agreeing to arbitration. (Cf. Iyere v. Wise Auto Group (2023)
87 Cal.App.5th 747, 757–758 (Iyere) with Gamboa v. Northeast Community Clinic
(2021) 72 Cal.App.5th 158, 164–165 (Gamboa).) We join Iyere in concluding that an
individual is capable of recognizing his or her handwritten signature and if that individual
does not deny a handwritten signature is his or her own, that person’s failure to remember
signing the document does not create a factual dispute about the signature’s authenticity.
(Iyere, supra, at p. 757.)
Here, Ramirez’s declaration asserts he does not recall ever being presented with or
signing an arbitration agreement. The declaration, however, omits several significant
facts. First, the declaration fails to state whether Ramirez even reviewed the arbitration
agreement, the related handbook acknowledgement, or any other documents purportedly
signed by him and included in the employer’s moving papers. A review of those
documents, the handwritten signatures, and the handwritten initials might have improved
Ramirez’s recollection. Second, the declaration does not address whether Ramirez
recalled signing the handbook acknowledgement, which is the document relied upon by
the employer to show his consent to arbitration. The acknowledgement included a
bolded, underlined sentence stating he agreed to the terms of the arbitration agreement in
the employee handbook. Third, Ramirez’s declaration does not state, one way or the
other, whether the handwritten signature on the handbook acknowledgement is his.
2.
Based on these omissions, we conclude Ramirez did not rebut the employer’s initial
showing that an arbitration agreement existed.
We therefore reverse the order denying the motion to compel arbitration and
remand for further proceedings to address Ramirez’s unconscionability defense.
FACTS
Appellant Golden Queen Mining Company, LLC (Queen Mining) is a California
limited liability company that operates the Soledad Mountain gold and silver mine in
Mojave, California. The open-pit mine operates 24 hours per day, 365 days per year.
Queen Mining’s operations use equipment, explosives and chemicals obtained from
sources outside California. All the gold and silver recovered from the crushed ore is sold
to a refinery outside of California. Based on its purchases and sales, Queen Mining
contends its business operations involve interstate commerce and, therefore, the Federal
Arbitration Act (FAA; 9 U.S.C. § 1 et seq.) governs its arbitration agreements.
In March 2019, Ramirez was hired by Queen Mining as a nonexempt hourly
employee to perform electrical work. Ramirez’s employment ended in August 2022. As
part of Queen Mining’s onboarding process, new employees are provided with many
documents including an employee handbook containing an arbitration agreement. The
documents allegedly provided to Ramirez are described below.
PROCEEDINGS
In October 2022, Ramirez filed a class action complaint against Queen Mining
alleging causes of action for failure to pay overtime wages, pay minimum wages, provide
meal periods, provide rest periods, pay all wages due upon termination, provide accurate
wage statements, indemnify employees for expenses incurred in performing their jobs,
and pay for vested, unused vacation time upon termination.
Motion to Compel
In April 2023, Queen Mining filed a motion to compel arbitration and supporting
declarations. The declaration of Latasha Marshall, Queen Mining’s human resources
3.
manager, asserted Ramirez “signed an ‘Arbitration Agreement’ on or about March 28,
2019.” Marshall attached as exhibits to her declaration copies of (1) a two-page
arbitration agreement, (2) a handbook acknowledgement purportedly signed by Ramirez
and dated March 28, 2019, and (3) six other documents purportedly signed by Ramirez
and dated March 28, 2019.
Opposition
Ramirez opposed the motion, contending that Queen Mining could not prove the
existence of an arbitration agreement between the parties because (1) Queen Mining had
failed to authenticate the proffered arbitration agreement and (2) even if authentic, a
signature on an employee handbook acknowledgement did not constitute valid assent to
arbitration. Alternatively, Ramirez argued any such agreement was unenforceable
because it was procedurally and substantively unconscionable.
Ramirez’s declaration in support of his opposition to the motion to compel is
relatively short and, therefore, to accurately describe his evidence, we quote the
declaration’s last six numbered paragraphs:
“3. In or around March 2019, I was hired by [Queen Mining] to work as a
non-exempt hourly employee. My duties included electrical work.
“4. I do not recall ever being presented with an arbitration agreement,
either in person or electronically.
“5. I do not recall ever signing an arbitration agreement for [Queen
Mining], either on paper or electronically.
“6. Nobody ever informed me about an arbitration agreement, a desire for
me to sign an arbitration agreement, or explained to me what an arbitration
agreement is.
“7. Until my counsel explained it to me, I did not know what arbitration
was. If someone had explained to me what an arbitration agreement was, I
would not sign it.
4.
“8. As I do not recall ever being provided with or signing an arbitration
agreement, I do not believe the Court should consider any such claim or
document offered by [Queen Mining] to be genuine.”
Ramirez’s opposition papers also included evidentiary objections to the statement
in Marshall’s declaration that he “signed an ‘Arbitration Agreement’ on or about
March 28, 2019.” Ramirez argued (1) the assertion lacked foundation and was not
supported by required preliminary facts; (2) Marshall lacked personal knowledge and had
made an improper factual conclusion; and (3) the assertion was an improper legal
conclusion in that Ramirez never signed an arbitration agreement and only purportedly
signed an acknowledgement of the employee handbook.
Reply
Queen Mining’s reply papers argued Ramirez’s employment as an electrical
worker, which involved keeping the mine’s electrical power distribution systems
connected to the electrical grid, involved or affected interstate commerce and, thus, the
FAA applied. Queen Mining asserted that because Ramirez did not deny signing the
“HANDBOOK ACKNOWLEDGEMENT,” which contains a bolded, underlined
sentence stating he agreed to the terms of the arbitration agreement, the burden did not
shift back to it to authenticate his signature. Queen Mining’s reply was supported with
Marshall’s supplemental declaration, which included a complete copy of Queen Mining’s
“Employee Information & Handbook” as an attachment. The arbitration agreement is set
forth on pages 30 and 31 of the handbook. Queen Mining argued Ramirez’s signature on
the handbook acknowledgement was sufficient to establish his assent to the arbitration
agreement contained in the handbook. Addressing Ramirez’s defense to enforcement,
Queen Mining asserted the arbitration agreement was neither procedurally nor
substantively unconscionable.
Hearing and Decision
In May 2023, the trial court heard the motion to compel arbitration. At the
beginning of the hearing, the court announced its tentative decision to deny the motion
5.
based on a finding that Queen Mining failed to demonstrate the existence of an executed
arbitration agreement. Counsel for Queen Mining argued Iyere, supra, 87 Cal.App.5th
747, was directly on point and established Ramirez’s statement that he did not recall
signing the arbitration agreement was insufficient to rebut Queen Mining’s initial
showing. Counsel for Ramirez argued that nothing in Iyere should cause the court to
reverse its tentative. After hearing from counsel, the trial court took the matter under
submission and stated it would reread Iyere.
The trial court’s subsequent written ruling denied the motion, repeating the
tentative decision’s finding that Queen Mining “has failed to demonstrate the existence of
an executed arbitration agreement.” The ruling stated the court believed the separate
arbitration agreement at issue in Iyere was distinguishable from the arbitration provision
included in Queen Mining’s more comprehensive employee handbook and, thus, the
court viewed Esparza v. Sand & Sea, Inc. (2016) 2 Cal.App.5th 781 as more persuasive. 1
The court also sustained Ramirez’s evidentiary objections to Marshall’s factual assertion
that Ramirez “signed an ‘Arbitration Agreement’ on or about March 28, 2019.”
Counsel for Ramirez prepared a proposed order denying the motion to compel
arbitration. On May 26, 2023, the trial court signed and filed the order.
Appeal
In June 2023, Queen Mining filed an appeal. About two weeks later, Queen
Mining’s attorney filed a mandatory Judicial Council form APP-004, Civil Case
Information Statement. (See Cal. Rules of Court, rule 8.100(g) [appellant must serve and
file a completed form APP-004].) Form APP-004, Part II, item 2 contains a box followed
by “This appeal is entitled to calendar preference/priority on appeal (cite authority):”
This item was left blank by Queen Mining’s attorney. In a properly completed form, the
1 Unlike this case, the acknowledgement signed in Esparza did not mention the
arbitration agreement contained in the employee handbook. (Esparza, supra, at p. 785.)
6.
box would have been marked and Code of Civil Procedure section 1291.2 would have
been cited. That section provides that hearings in all proceedings brought under the
California Arbitration Act (Code Civ. Proc., § 1280 et seq.) shall have preference over all
other civil proceedings so that the arbitration “proceedings shall be quickly heard and
determined.” (See Woolls v. Superior Court (2005) 127 Cal.App.4th 197, 204, fn. 4
[“Arbitration proceedings are entitled to calendar preference in all courts”]; Hedges v.
Carrigan (2004) 117 Cal.App.4th 578, 582.) The attorney’s misstatement of law was
repeated in October 2023 when he filed an application for extension of time to file the
appellant’s opening brief that stated: “(6) This case is not entitled to priority.” (See
Bus. & Prof. Code, § 6068, subd. (d); Rules Prof. Conduct, rule 3.3(a)(1).)
DISCUSSION
I. ESTABLISHING THE EXISTENCE OF AN ARBITRATION AGREEMENT
When presented with a motion or petition to compel arbitration, a trial court must
determine whether an “agreement to arbitrate the controversy exists.” (Code Civ. Proc.,
§ 1281.2; Iyere, supra, 87 Cal.App.5th at p. 754.) The court makes this determination in
a “summary proceeding” (Code Civ. Proc., § 1290.2), sitting “as a trier of fact, weighing
all the affidavits, declarations, and other documentary evidence, as well as oral testimony
received at the court’s discretion, to reach a final determination.” (Engalla v. Permanente
Medical Group, Inc. (1997) 15 Cal.4th 951, 972.)
The party seeking arbitration has the burden of proving the existence of an
arbitration agreement by a preponderance of the evidence. (Nielsen Contracting, Inc. v.
Applied Underwriters, Inc. (2018) 22 Cal.App.5th 1096, 1106.) The agreement must be
in writing to be valid and enforceable. (Code Civ. Proc., § 1281.) 2 The party opposing
2 A written arbitration agreement does not necessarily need to be signed because “a
party’s acceptance may be implied in fact [citation] or be effectuated by delegated
consent [citation].” (Pinnacle Museum Tower Assn. v. Pinnacle Market Development
(US), LLC (2012) 55 Cal.4th 223, 236 (Pinnacle); see Craig v. Brown & Root, Inc. (2000)
84 Cal.App.4th 416, 422 [employee of 12 years impliedly agreed to arbitration by
7.
arbitration bears the burden of proving by a preponderance of the evidence any defense to
the agreement’s enforcement. (Nielsen, supra, at p. 1106.) Whether the arbitration
agreement is a legally enforceable contract is determined by applying general principles
of California contract law. (Ibid.)
Although the party seeking arbitration bears the ultimate burden of proof as to the
existence of an arbitration agreement, the burden of producing evidence on the issue may
shift pursuant to a three-step process recognized by California courts. (Iyere, supra,
87 Cal.App.5th at p. 755; Gamboa, supra, 72 Cal.App.5th at pp. 164–165.) The first step
requires the party seeking arbitration to carry the initial burden of presenting prima facie
evidence of a written agreement to arbitrate the controversy. (Rosenthal v. Great Western
Fin. Securities Corp. (1996) 14 Cal.4th 394, 413 (Rosenthal); Gamboa, supra, at p. 165.)
If that initial burden is met, the second step requires the party opposing arbitration to
carry the burden of producing evidence to challenge the authenticity of the agreement.
(Gamboa, supra, at p. 165.) If the opposing party meets the burden of producing
sufficient evidence, the third step requires the party seeking arbitration to prove by a
preponderance of the evidence that the parties formed a valid contract to arbitrate their
dispute. (Id. at pp. 165–166.)
continuing to work after employer announced arbitration of employee disputes would be
mandatory].) Also, a signature manifesting assent to arbitration need not be on the
arbitration agreement itself. (See 24 Hour Fitness, Inc. v. Superior Court (1998) 66
Cal.App.4th 1199, 1205, 1212 [when hired, plaintiff signed a certificate acknowledging
receipt of a personnel handbook stating she had read and agreed to submit disputes
arising out of her employment as described in the arbitration section of the handbook;
appellate court concluded the agreement was enforceable].)
8.
A. Step One: Initial Showing
1. Basic Principles
How a party seeking arbitration makes the initial prima facie showing that an
arbitration agreement exists is addressed in California Rules of Court, rule 3.1330 (Rule
3.1330):
“A petition to compel arbitration or to stay proceedings pursuant to Code of
Civil Procedure sections 1281.2 and 1281.4 must state, in addition to other
required allegations, the provisions of the written agreement and the
paragraph that provides for arbitration. The provisions must be stated
verbatim or a copy must be physically or electronically attached to the
petition and incorporated by reference.”
Thus, a party seeking arbitration can carry its initial burden “ ‘by attaching a copy
of the arbitration agreement purportedly bearing the opposing party’s signature.’ ” (Iyere,
supra, 87 Cal.App.5th at p. 755, quoting Espejo v. Southern California Permanente
Medical Group (2016) 246 Cal.App.4th 1047, 1060 (Espejo).) The party seeking
arbitration “need not ‘follow the normal procedures of document authentication’ and need
only ‘allege the existence of an agreement and support the allegation as provided in rule
[3.1330].’ ” (Iyere, supra, at p. 755, quoting Condee v. Longwood Management Corp.
(2001) 88 Cal.App.4th 215, 218.)
2. The Evidence Produced
Queen Mining’s motion to compel arbitration alleged Ramirez signed an
acknowledgement of an arbitration agreement on or about March 28, 2019. The motion
was supported with Marshall’s declaration, which asserted (1) Ramirez was employed by
Queen Mining from approximately 2019 to August 2021; (2) she was a custodian of
records for Queen Mining; (3) Queen Mining keeps personnel files that contain
documents made in the regular course of its business, such as employee applications,
write-ups, and documents noting the dates an employee is hired or terminated; (4) Queen
Mining kept a personnel file for Ramirez; (5) Ramirez signed an arbitration agreement on
or about March 28, 2019; and (6) true and correct copies of the arbitration agreement, the
9.
acknowledgement of the arbitration agreement signed by Ramirez, and other documents
signed by Ramirez were attached as exhibits to the declaration.
The arbitration agreement stated that, “[i]n the event of any dispute arising under
or involving any provision of this Agreement … or any dispute regarding employee’s
employment, … employee and Company agree to submit any such dispute to binding
arbitration pursuant to the provisions of the Federal Arbitration Act[.]” The two-page
arbitration agreement attached to Marshall’s declaration did not contain a signature block
and was not signed or initialed. The “HANDBOOK ACKNOWLEDGEMENT” attached
to Marshall’s declaration included the following:
“My signature also acknowledges and certifies that I understand and
voluntarily agree to terms of the Company Arbitration Agreement.
“Furthermore, I understand that, because the Company cannot anticipate
every issue that may arise during my employment, if I have any questions
regarding the contents of the Handbook, I should consult Human
Resources.
“I have carefully read this Acknowledgement.”
Immediately below these three paragraphs were blank lines for an employee
number, position, name, signature, and date. The first three blanks were completed by
hand in blue ink with “452,” “Electrical II,” and “Carlos Ramirez.” The signature line
appears to contain a signature for “Carlos Ramirez” in cursive handwriting and the date
line contains a handwritten “3-28-19.”
Another document attached to Marshall’s declaration was a “NEW HIRE
ORIENTATION CHECKLIST.” The checklist’s left-hand column contains 19 items
under a heading stating “I have filled out and returned the following to HR.” The initials
“CR” are handwritten in blue ink next to 18 of the items, including “Arbitration
Agreement” and “Handbook Acknowledgement.” The checklist’s right-hand column
contains 14 items under a heading stating “I acknowledge receipt of the following.” All
14 items have the handwritten initials “CR” next to them. The items include “Arbitration
10.
Agreement,” “Corporate Governance,” and “Employee Handbook.” The employee
signature line at the bottom of the checklist appears to contain Ramirez’s handwritten
signature and is dated “3-28-19.”
The attachments to Marshall’s declaration also include five other documents
appearing to contain Ramirez’s handwritten signature along with the “3-28-19” date.
These entries are handwritten in blue ink that appears to match the ink used for the
signature on the handbook acknowledgement and the signature and initials on the
checklist.
3. The Prima Facie Showing Was Made
We conclude as a matter of law that Queen Mining carried its initial burden and
made a prima facie showing of the existence of a written arbitration agreement. Queen
Mining alleged the existence of an agreement and supported that allegation by complying
with Rule 3.1330. (Iyere, supra, 87 Cal.App.5th at p. 755.) As a result, the burden of
producing evidence shifted to Ramirez.
B. Step Two: Rebutting the Initial Showing
When the burden has shifted to the party opposing arbitration, that party must
“identify a factual dispute as to the agreement’s existence” and must present admissible
evidence to support the existence of that factual dispute. (Iyere, supra, 87 Cal.App.5th at
p. 755.) For example, if a party disputes the authenticity of his or her signatures, the
party “must offer admissible evidence creating a factual dispute as to the authenticity of
the[] signatures. The opponent need not prove that his or her purported signature is not
authentic, but must submit sufficient evidence to create a factual dispute and shift the
burden back to the arbitration proponent, who retains the ultimate burden of proving, by a
preponderance of the evidence, the authenticity of the signature.” (Ibid., first italics in
original, second italics added.) We next describe the split of authority among the Courts
11.
of Appeal on the question of what constitutes sufficient evidence to create a factual
dispute about the authenticity of handwritten signatures.
1. The Split in Authority
In Gamboa, an employee injured her hand at work and was terminated after she
requested a medical accommodation. The employee sued her former employer for
discrimination, retaliation, and failure to provide reasonable accommodation. (Gamboa,
supra, 72 Cal.App.5th at p. 163.) The employer filed a motion to compel arbitration that
alleged the employee had signed an arbitration agreement as part of her required
onboarding documents. (Ibid.) The employee’s opposition to the motion included her
declaration, which stated (1) she had reviewed the arbitration agreement included in the
employer’s moving papers, (2) she did “ ‘not remember these documents at all,’ ” (3) no
one had ever told her about an arbitration agreement or explained it until after her lawsuit
began, and (4) “ ‘[h]ad I been made aware of the existence of an arbitration agreement,
and been explained its provisions, I would not have signed any such documents.’ ” (Id. at
pp. 163, 167.) The trial court denied the motion to compel arbitration. (Id. at p. 164.)
The Second District, Division Seven, affirmed. (Id. at p. 171.) The court addressed
whether the employee’s evidence was sufficient to satisfy her burden at step two by
stating: “[W]e need not decide whether Gamboa challenged the authenticity of her
purported signature on the arbitration agreement. It was enough that she challenged the
authenticity of the agreement by saying under penalty of perjury that she did not
remember it.” (Id. at p. 168.)
In Iyere, three employees who had been terminated by their employer filed a joint
complaint alleging many employment-related causes of action. (Iyere, supra,
87 Cal.App.5th at p. 752.) The employer filed a motion to sever the complaints and
compel each plaintiff to submit his claims to individual arbitration. (Ibid.) The trial court
denied the motion, concluding the employer failed to prove the authenticity of the
12.
plaintiffs’ signatures on the arbitration agreements and the agreements were procedurally
and substantively unconscionable. (Id. at p. 754.) The First District, Division Four,
reversed and remanded the matter with directions to grant the employer’s motion. (Id. at
pp. 761–762.)
The First District addressed whether the “plaintiffs’ evidence was sufficient to
create a factual dispute shifting the burden of production back to” the employer. (Iyere,
supra, 87 Cal.App.5th at p. 756.) The court stated the question was one of law and
subject to de novo review. (Id. at p. 755.) The employer’s moving papers included
copies of arbitration agreements bearing the plaintiffs’ apparent handwritten signatures.
The plaintiffs’ opposition papers included each plaintiff’s declaration stating that, on the
first day of work, he (1) was given a stack of documents, (2) was told to quickly sign the
documents so he could get to work, and (3) signed the stack of documents immediately
and returned them. (Id. at p. 756.) Each declaration also stated: “ ‘I do not recall ever
reading or signing any document entitled Binding Arbitration Agreement …. I do not
know how my signature was placed on [the document].’ ” Each plaintiff further stated
that if he had understood that the agreement waived his right to sue the employer, he
would not have signed it. (Ibid.)
The First District concluded the declarations did not create a factual dispute as to
whether the plaintiffs signed the agreements, stating:
“The declarations explicitly acknowledge that plaintiffs signed a ‘stack of
documents’ and do not deny that the stack included the agreement.
Although plaintiffs state they do not recall signing the agreement, there is
no conflict between their having signed a document on which their
handwritten signature appears and, two years later, being unable to recall
doing so. In the absence of any evidence that their purported signatures
were not their own, there was no evidence that plaintiffs did not in fact sign
the agreement.” (Iyere, supra, 87 Cal.App.5th at p. 756.)
The First District distinguished cases involving a plaintiff’s statement that he or
she did not recall electronically signing an arbitration agreement because “the
13.
individual’s inability to recall signing electronically may reasonably be regarded as
evidence that the person did not do so. However, an individual is capable of recognizing
his or her own personal signature. If the individual does not deny that the handwritten
personal signature is his or her own, that person’s failure to remember signing is of little
or no significance.” (Iyere, supra, 87 Cal.App.5th at p. 757.)
The First District acknowledged that the court in Gamboa had reached a different
conclusion about the inability to remember signing an agreement by hand and disagreed
with Gamboa’s conclusion. (Iyere, supra, 87 Cal.App.5th at p. 758.) The First District
addressed the rationale in Gamboa that treated electronic signatures and handwritten
signatures “as ‘a distinction without a legal difference’ because ‘electronic and
handwritten signatures have the same legal effect and are equally enforceable.’
[Citations.]” (Iyere, supra, at p. 758.) The First District rejected that reasoning because
“there is a considerable difference between the evidence needed to authenticate the two.”
(Ibid.)
Consequently, in Iyere, the First District concluded that, if a plaintiff presented
with a handwritten signature on an arbitration agreement is unable to allege the signature
is inauthentic or forged, the plaintiff’s failure to recall signing the agreement “neither
creates a factual dispute as to the signature’s authenticity nor affords an independent basis
to find that a contract was not formed.” (Iyere, supra, 87 Cal.App.5th at p. 758.) We
agree with this conclusion and the underlying rationale. Thus, we join the federal district
court in Prostek v. Lincare Inc. (E.D. Cal. 2023) 662 F.Supp.3d 1100 in following Iyere
and rejecting Gamboa. (Prostek, supra, at p. 1114.)
2. Ramirez’s Evidence Did Not Carry His Burden
Having chosen which principles of law should govern the evidence needed to
carry the second step of the burden-shifting framework, we next consider how those
principles apply to the evidence presented in this case. Stated in broad terms, the issue
14.
presented is whether Ramirez produced sufficient evidence to create a factual dispute
about the existence of an enforceable arbitration agreement and, as a result, shifted the
burden of production back to Queen Mining. (See Iyere, supra, 87 Cal.App.5th at
p. 756.) Stated in more specific terms, the issue is whether Ramirez’s evidence created a
factual dispute as to the authenticity of the signature on the “HANDBOOK
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT,” which included a bolded, underlined sentence stating he
agreed to the terms of the arbitration agreement. If the answer to that question is “no,”
then the question becomes whether Ramirez’s evidence created a factual dispute on an
alternate ground that would lead to the conclusion the parties did not form a contract to
arbitrate their disputes. (See generally, Civ. Code, §§ 1550 [essential elements of contract
formation], 1565 [essentials of consent to a contract].)
Because Ramirez had the burden of producing evidence, we describe some
seemingly obvious points that are omitted from his declaration. First, unlike Gamboa’s
declaration in support of her opposition, Ramirez’s declaration did not state he reviewed
the arbitration agreement and other documents attached to Marshall’s declaration. The
idea that a witness’s inspection of a writing may refresh the witness’s memory is long
established. (See Evid. Code, § 771 [production of writing used to refresh memory].)
Here, Ramirez’s evidence does not allow this court to discern whether he took the
fundamental step of inspecting the arbitration agreement included in Queen Mining’s
moving papers. It follows that his evidence leaves us wondering whether such an
inspection would have improved his ability to recall being presented with the arbitration
agreement and related acknowledgement.
Second, Ramirez’s declaration did not state he examined any of the seven
handwritten signatures on the documents that Queen Mining contended he purportedly
signed. Similarly, he did not state whether he examined the 32 sets of the initials “CR”
that were handwritten on the checklist included in Queen Mining’s moving papers. As a
15.
result, Ramirez’s declaration did not address whether the signatures or initials were
inauthentic or forged.
Third, Ramirez’s declaration did not state he did not recall signing the
“HANDBOOK ACKNOWLEDGEMENT,” which is the specific document relied upon
by Queen Mining to manifest Ramirez’s assent to arbitration. The distinction between a
signed arbitration agreement and a signed acknowledgement is significant in the context
of this case because Ramirez’s opposition papers explicitly raised that distinction. For
instance, one of the grounds asserted in his objection to the statement in Marshall’s
declaration asserting he “signed an ‘Arbitration Agreement’ on or about March 28, 2019,”
was that Ramirez never signed an arbitration agreement and only purportedly signed an
acknowledgement of the employee handbook. Thus, the wording of Ramirez’s
declaration leaves open the possibility that he does recall signing the acknowledgement.
Having identified some of Ramirez’s omissions, we next consider the evidence
Ramirez actually presented to carry his second-step burden of producing evidence.
Ramirez’s declaration stated (1) he did “not recall ever being presented with an
arbitration agreement,” 3 (2) he did “not recall ever signing an arbitration agreement,”
(3) no one informed him about an arbitration agreement, informed him of a desire that he
sign an arbitration agreement, or explained to him what an arbitration agreement was, and
(4) if someone had explained to him what an arbitration agreement was, he would not
sign it.
Our evaluation of Ramirez’s evidence begins with whether he offered sufficient
evidence to create a factual dispute about the authenticity of his signature on the
3 Read literally, Ramirez’s broad representation that he does not recall ever being
presented with an arbitration agreement implies either that his attorney did not have
Ramirez review the arbitration agreement in Queen Mining’s moving papers before
signing the declaration or that Ramirez did review the arbitration agreement but, due to a
poor memory or some other reason, he could not recall it by the time he signed the
declaration.
16.
“HANDBOOK ACKNOWLEDGEMENT.” His declaration does not assert the signature
on that document is not his and, furthermore, does not even state that he cannot recall
signing that particular document. Consequently, we conclude Ramirez, like the plaintiffs
in Iyere, has offered no admissible evidence creating a dispute as to the authenticity of the
handwritten signature on the acknowledgement. (See Iyere, 87 Cal.App.5th at pp. 756–
757.)
We next evaluate whether the evidence offered by Ramirez creates a factual
dispute about whether the parties formed an enforceable contract to arbitrate their
employment-related disputes. As concluded by the First District, the inability to recall
signing a document does not “afford[] an independent basis to find that a contract was not
formed.” (Iyere, supra, 87 Cal.App.5th at p. 758.)
Consequently, the burden of producing evidence never shifted back to Queen
Mining. Based on Ramirez’s failure to carry his second step burden, the trial court
should never have reached the third step in the burden-shifting framework. After
concluding an arbitration agreement existed, the trial court should have addressed
whether Ramirez had proven by a preponderance of the evidence that the agreement was
unconscionable and, thus, not enforceable. (See Nielsen Contracting, Inc. v. Applied
Underwriters, Inc., supra, 22 Cal.App.5th at p. 1106 [party opposing arbitration bears the
burden of proving by a preponderance of the evidence any defense to the agreement’s
enforcement].)
II. REMAND FOR FURTHER PROCEEDINGS
Ordinarily, a trial court is required to rule on the gateway issues of whether an
arbitration agreement is enforceable, which includes claims of unconscionability.
(Balandran v. Labor Ready, Inc. (2004) 124 Cal.App.4th 1522, 1530.) Here, the trial
court did not reach Ramirez’s unconscionability defense and, therefore, it is appropriate
to remand for further proceedings addressing that defense. (Ibid.)
17.
DISPOSITION
The order denying the motion to compel arbitration is reversed. The matter is
remanded to the trial court for further proceedings not inconsistent with this opinion.
In the interests of justice, the parties shall bear their own costs on appeal. (Cal.
Rules of Court, rule 8.278(a)(5); see Cal. Rules of Court, rule 8.100(g).)
FRANSON, J.
WE CONCUR:
LEVY, Acting P. J.
POOCHIGIAN, J.
18.
Fsiled 6/11/24
CERTIFIED FOR PUBLICATION
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIFTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
CARLOS RAMIREZ,
F086371
Plaintiff and Respondent,
(Super. Ct. No. BCV-22-102808)
v.
ORDER MODIFYING OPINION
GOLDEN QUEEN MINING COMPANY, LLC, AND GRANTING
PUBLICATION REQUEST
Defendant and Appellant. [NO CHANGE IN JUDGMENT]
THE COURT:
As the nonpublished opinion filed on May 15, 2024, in the above entitled matter
hereby meets the standards for publication specified in the California Rules of Court, rule
8.1105(c), it is ordered that the opinion be certified, in its entirety, for publication in the
Official Reports with the following modifications:
1. On page 2, first full paragraph, second sentence, the phrase “review den.
Apr. 26, 2023, S278817” is added immediately following the short cite “(Iyere)” so the
citation now reads: “(Cf. Iyere v. Wise Auto Group (2023) 87 Cal.App.5th 747, 757–758
(Iyere) review den. Apr. 26, 2023, S278817 ….”
2. On page 3, last paragraph of the “FACTS”, the word “below” of the last
sentence is deleted and replaced with “in part I.A.2. of this opinion”, so the sentence now
reads:
“The documents allegedly provided to Ramirez are described in part I.A.2.
of this opinion.”
3. On page 3, the paragraph under the heading “Motion to Compel” the word
“a” following “(1)” is deleted and replaced with the words “an unsigned” so the sentence
now reads:
“Marshall attached as exhibits to her declaration copies of (1) an unsigned
two-page arbitration agreement ….”
4. On page 5, the first sentence of the first paragraph, the word “inaccurate” is
added in between the words “the” and “statement”, so the sentence now reads:
“Ramirez’s opposition papers also included evidentiary objections to
the inaccurate statement in Marshall’s declaration that he “signed an
‘Arbitration Agreement’ on or about March 28, 2019.”
5. On page 14, footnote 3 is added after the citation “(Prostek, supra, at p.
1114.)” at the end of the paragraph beginning “Consequently, in Iyere,” which will
require renumbering of all subsequent footnotes:
In Garcia v. Stoneledge Furniture LLC (May 17, 2024, A166785)
2024 Cal. App. LEXIS 314, at page 17*, the First District, Division Three,
stated it “join[ed] the legion of courts that have concluded a denial of
signing an arbitration agreement is sufficient to shift the burden” to the
party seeking arbitration. The court cited Gamboa and referred to the cases
collected therein. Because Garcia involved an arbitration agreement
purportedly containing the plaintiff’s electronic signature, we do not
interpret it as impliedly rejecting Iyere’s conclusion about the evidence
needed to create a factual dispute about the authenticity of a handwritten
signature.
There is no change in judgment.
2.
FRANSON, J.
WE CONCUR:
LEVY, Acting P. J.
POOCHIGIAN, J.
3.
Vous vous demandez comment ce texte s’applique à votre situation ?
Consultation gratuite, sans engagement
Décrivez votre situation. Notre équipe vous recontactera par e-mail pour votre consultation.
Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude
Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.