CourtListener 9502532•People v. Ortega CA4/1
Texte intégral
Filed 5/14/24 P. v. Ortega CA4/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for publication or
ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or ordered published for
purposes of rule 8.1115.
COURT OF APPEAL, FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
THE PEOPLE, D081407
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v. (Super. Ct. No. SCE404782)
ALFREDO ORTEGA,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of San Diego County,
John M. Thompson, Judge. Affirmed.
Aurora Elizabeth Bewicke, under appointment by the Court of Appeal,
for Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief Assistant
Attorney General, Charles C. Ragland, Assistant Attorney General, Steve
Oetting and Evan Stele, Deputy Attorneys General, for Plaintiff and
Respondent.
A jury convicted Alfredo Ortega of several crimes related to the abuse
of his girlfriend: assault with a deadly weapon (a car) (Pen. Code, § 245,
subd. (a)(1)1), hit and run with injury (Veh. Code, § 20001, subd. (a)),
corporal injury to a significant other (§ 273.5, subd. (a)), assault by means of
force likely to produce great bodily injury (§ 245, subd. (a)(4)), and stalking
(§ 646.9, subd. (a)). Before its deliberation, however, the jury was
inadvertently provided a copy of the PowerPoint presentation used by the
District Attorney during her closing argument.
On appeal, Ortega asserts this mistake violated his due process and
fair trial rights, requiring reversal of the jury’s verdict. In response, the
Attorney General concedes the trial court’s mistake was error, but argues the
error was not prejudicial. Because the presentation contained only
information that was already before the jury, we agree with the Attorney
General that the error was harmless and affirm the convictions.
Ortega also filed a petition for writ of habeas corpus (In re Ortega
(D082136)), which we ordered considered with this appeal. We deny the
petition by separate order.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A. September 14, 2020 Incident
Ortega and the victim, C.K., began a romantic relationship in February
2020, but had been friends for many years before. On September 14, 2020,
C.K. was at Ortega’s house. She needed to pick up prescriptions from CVS,
and told Ortega she wanted to go alone. This angered Ortega. C.K. left in
her pickup truck, and as she was leaving she saw Ortega get into a white
Audi station wagon.
C.K. headed east on Interstate 8. While driving in the fast lane on the
freeway, C.K. saw the white Audi behind her approaching at a high rate of
speed. The Audi moved to the middle lane of the three-lane freeway and
1 Subsequent undesignated statutory references are to the Penal Code.
2
pulled up next to her. C.K. decided she should exit the freeway, and merged
into the middle lane. Ortega then merged into the exit lane next to her,
preventing her from merging into that lane. C.K. told the lead investigating
California Highway Patrol (CHP) officer, Erick Parra, that she made several
attempts to speed up and slow down to get into the exit lane, but Ortega
matched her speed changes and prevented her from changing lanes.
C.K. feared that Ortega was going to ram her truck with his car. C.K.
also reported to Parra that during the pursuit, Ortega repeatedly called her
phone. After C.K. missed two exit attempts, she was finally able to merge
into the exit lane. C.K. then heard a car accelerating behind her and felt the
car make impact with her truck. The impact caused C.K. to lose control of
the truck, which rolled over before landing in the embankment next to the
freeway exit.
After her truck came to a stop, C.K. thought she heard Ortega’s voice.
Terrified, she got out of the truck and ran up the embankment towards
nearby homes. She saw an open garage and approached a man, M.L., who
was working out inside. M.L. saw that C.K. was injured and bleeding from a
large cut on her foot. She also had a golf ball sized lump on her head that
was bleeding. C.K. was scared and panicked, and she told M.L. that her
boyfriend was trying to kill her.
C.K. also asked M.L. to give her a ride. He told her he could not leave,
that he had three children inside the house, but that he would call 911. C.K.
begged him not to call the police. Over C.K.’s objection, M.L. called 911. As
M.L. described what was happening to the 911 operator, C.K. left the garage.
Shortly after, first responders located C.K. Parra spoke with C.K. and she
told him that Ortega had intentionally rammed her truck, and described the
3
terrifying interaction on the freeway. C.K. also gave Parra a description of
Ortega. C.K. was taken to the hospital and treated for her injuries.
When the responding officers arrived at the scene of the collision, they
found C.K.’s pickup truck with significant rollover damage down the
embankment next to the freeway exit. Other drivers were standing around
the scene. Two witnesses told Parra that they saw the collision. Their
statements to the CHP officers were consistent with C.K.’s account and one of
the witnesses saw the white car drive away after the collision.
In addition, the first CHP officer who responded to the scene, Justin
Cardec, saw a man matching C.K’s description of Ortega standing close to the
flipped truck. When Cardec called to the man, he fled. Cardec testified the
man looked sweaty and since the man was not responding to his commands,
he thought the man might have been under the influence of drugs or alcohol.
Later that evening, Parra showed Cardec a picture of Ortega and Cardec
identified the individual he saw as Ortega.
Three days after the hit and run, C.K. met with Parra to give another
statement. In this second interview, she gave the same account of the
incident and provided additional details. The following day, an investigator
from the District Attorney’s office went to Ortega’s residence and saw a white
Audi station wagon parked on the street that matched C.K.’s description of
the car that hit her truck. The Audi had damage on its front left bumper that
was consistent with C.K.’s description of the accident.
B. March 2021 Incident
In 2021, C.K. was living with Ortega at his house in National City. In
March 2021, a neighbor, J.H., was washing his car when he saw a man drive
down the street, park, and meet a woman standing outside of the house next
door. J.H. saw the man grab the woman by the forearm and force her into
4
the house. Minutes later, J.H. heard yelling and what sounded like someone
being thrown against a wall. J.H. heard the voice of a woman yelling in a
way that made him think she was being hurt. J.H. called 911.
A National City police officer, Pamela Sosa, responded to the call and
met J.H. outside. J.H. told the officer where the yelling and banging sounds
were coming from. As Sosa approached Ortega’s house, she saw Ortega
leaving and asked him if he had been involved in a dispute with a woman.
Sosa noticed that Ortega had a scratch behind his ear that was bleeding.
Sosa then approached C.K., who had also come outside. Sosa testified
that C.K. was crying and visibly upset. C.K. told Sosa that she found a
dating app on Ortega’s phone, called him and the couple had an argument
over the phone. During the argument, Ortega told C.K. they would discuss it
once he was home. C.K. told Sosa that when Ortega arrived at the house, she
went outside to greet him and he grabbed her by the arm and forced her
inside. The argument continued and C.K. started to pack a bag to leave.
C.K. told Sosa that Ortega started throwing her things around the house and
he threw C.K. to the ground, straddled her, and began strangling her.
Sosa went inside and saw items strewn all over the house, including
C.K.’s bag. Sosa noted and photographed injuries to C.K.’s neck, head, elbow,
knee, and back. Sosa testified that she thought the injuries on C.K.’s neck
were consistent with C.K.’s report of strangulation.
C. June 2021 Incident
In May or June 2021, C.K. decided to leave Ortega. She went to stay
with a friend, C.H.2 C.H. had known both Ortega and C.K. for over 20 years.
2 C.H. testified that after the car crash, C.K. was hospitalized for several
days and then stayed with C.H. for two days after she was released from the
hospital. C.H. also told the jury that C.K. told her Ortega had chased her on
the freeway and caused the rollover.
5
C.K. stayed with C.H. on and off for several months. During this time, C.K.
was constantly changing her phone number and her phone because she
feared Ortega was using her phone to track her. While C.K. was staying with
C.H., Ortega would regularly show up uninvited. C.K. told C.H. she did not
want Ortega coming over.
In June 2021, C.K. went to another friend’s apartment in Lemon Grove
after an incident with Ortega earlier in the day. While at the apartment,
C.K. thought she saw Ortega and believed he was following her. C.K. was
afraid and thought Ortega was tracking her, so she locked herself in the
laundry room and called 911. A police officer responded, but did not find
Ortega.
Later that night, C.K. was at C.H.’s house with another friend, R.P.
C.K. told R.P. that her ex-boyfriend, Ortega, was stalking her. C.K. also told
R.P. that she needed to pick up one of her other cars that was parked at
someone else’s house. R.P. agreed to help her, and around midnight, C.K.
and R.P. left C.H.’s house to go pick up the car. When they got close to the
location, C.K., who was driving, saw Ortega in a white Mercedes and sped off.
Ortega followed C.K. and R.P. R.P. testified that C.K. appeared scared, and
ran multiple red lights to evade Ortega. According to R.P., Ortega chased
them at high speeds and Ortega and C.K. were both driving erratically.
Eventually, Ortega pulled in front of C.K. and started backing up towards
them. C.K. was able to speed off, but Ortega continued to pursue her.
During the chase, R.P. called 911. C.K. and R.P. eventually lost Ortega
and headed back towards C.H.’s house. C.K. drove onto a one-way street in
front of C.H.’s house. R.P. then saw Ortega’s car driving the wrong way down
the one-way street towards them. C.K. began reversing quickly, lost control,
and hit a curb, puncturing one of her car’s tires. C.K. and R.P. got out of the
6
car and headed towards C.H.’s house. Ortega also got out of his car; R.P.
testified that Ortega said he just wanted to talk. C.K. told Ortega she had
called the police and Ortega got back into his car and drove away.
Eventually, a police officer arrived and took statements from C.K. and R.P.
about the incident.
D. Additional Evidence & Defense Case
C.K. took the stand over two days. Her trial testimony was entirely
inconsistent with her prior statements to police. At the start of her direct
examination by the prosecutor, C.K. stated she had brain surgery just three
weeks before trial, which was impeding her memory. She could not recall
how long she had been with Ortega or the contours of their relationship, but
she knew she wanted to help him. C.K. testified that she suffered from post-
traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and other mental health disorders that
caused her to blame Ortega for acts she believed were actually perpetrated by
her ex-fiancé, J.M. C.K. ended her relationship with J.M. just before her
relationship with Ortega began.3 C.K. also testified that another ex-
boyfriend prior to J.M. had engaged in high-speed car chases with her, which
gave her PTSD that she believed caused her to hallucinate Ortega chasing
her.
C.K. testified that she had no memory of Ortega ever harming her,
except during consensual sex. She explained that she liked to be choked
during sex, which caused the injuries to her neck observed by Sosa in March
2021. C.K. also testified that the neck injuries were the result of a botched
plastic surgery procedure, and that her eyes appeared red in the pictures
taken by Sosa because of a hereditary condition. C.K.’s mental health
3 J.M. testified that he had hired a private investigator to follow C.K.
after he discovered Ortega in an apartment he rented for C.K. and to recover
a car C.K. had taken from him.
7
struggles, and inconsistent testimony, formed the basis for Ortega’s defense.
In addition to C.K.’s testimony, Ortega presented the testimony of a
psychiatrist who evaluated C.K. and diagnosed her with schizoaffective
disorder bipolar type, the symptoms of which included psychosis and
hallucinations.
The defense also relied on the testimony of two witnesses at the scene
of the rollover crash. One of those witnesses testified that he was behind
C.K.’s and Ortega’s vehicles and they appeared to be jockeying for position.
He thought it was an incident of road rage. He also testified that he thought
the rollover was caused by the truck changing lanes erratically, which caused
its driver to lose control. He did not know if the white SUV had struck the
truck, but he thought if it had, it was not intentional. The other witness, who
was driving next to the truck and SUV before the crash, testified he thought
the white SUV had caused the accident, not by hitting the truck, but by
cutting it off aggressively.
The defense also presented the testimony of a friend of Ortega’s, T.S.,
who was with Ortega the night of the car chase in June 2021. T.S. testified
that Ortega and C.K. had visited him at his home earlier in the day and had
arrived in separate cars. T.S. said Ortega and C.K. had left together in the
same car and left the other car parked in front of his home. Ortega then
returned later in the evening by himself. T.S. had security cameras that
recorded the front of his house and later that night the camera system
alerted him that someone was there. T.S. and Ortega saw someone near the
white car that C.K. and Ortega had left earlier in the day. T.S. said that
Ortega went outside, the white car left, and then Ortega left in his car.
8
E. Verdict & Sentencing
After the conclusion of the trial, the jury returned guilty verdicts on all
five charges against Ortega: assault with a deadly weapon resulting in great
bodily injury (count 1; § 245, subd. (a)(1), § 12022.7, subd. (e), Veh. Code,
§ 13351.5); hit and run with injury (count 2; Veh. Code, § 20001, subd. (a));
inflicting corporal injury on a significant other (count 3; § 273.5, subd. (a));
assault with force likely to produce great bodily injury (count 4; § 245,
subd. (a)(4)); and stalking (count 5; § 646.9, subd. (a)).
Ortega admitted he was out on bail when he committed counts 3, 4, and
5 (§ 12022.1, subd. (b)). Ortega also admitted aggravating factors under
California Rules of Court, rule 4.421(a)(1), (a)(3), (b)(1)–(3).
Thereafter, the trial court sentenced Ortega to a total term of seven
years and eight months in prison. On count 1, the trial court imposed the
midterm of three years and an additional four years for the section 12022.7
allegation. On count 2, the court imposed one-third of the midterm for eight
months to run consecutively to count 1. On count 3, the court imposed the
midterm of three years to run concurrently to count 1 and struck the section
12022.1 allegation for the purpose of sentencing. On count 4, the court
imposed the midterm of three years, but stayed it under section 654. On
count 5, the court imposed the midterm of two years to run concurrently to
counts 1 and 2 and struck the section 12022.1 allegation for sentencing. The
court also imposed $3,000 in restitution and various fines and fees. Ortega
timely appealed from the judgment of conviction.
DISCUSSION
Ortega’s sole contention on appeal is that the jury’s verdict must be
reversed because his fair trial and due process rights were violated by the
trial court inadvertently providing the jury with a copy of the district
9
attorney’s closing argument presentation. The Attorney General concedes
this mistake was error, but asserts that there was no prejudice because all of
the information in the presentation was already before the jury.
A
Additional Background
Before closing arguments, the court instructed counsel to exchange
copies of whatever materials they intended to use. The court also explained
that printouts of any presentation would be marked as court’s exhibits to
preserve them for the appellate record. After the conclusion of the trial, the
clerk inadvertently provided the jury a copy of the prosecutor’s PowerPoint
presentation that she had submitted for this purpose. The presentation
consisted of 40 slides containing jury instructions, definitions, photos that
had been entered into evidence, several witnesses’ names, and the relevant
dates connected to each count.
Slides 1 and 2 listed the charges in counts 1 through 5. Slides 3
through 12 related to the September 14, 2020 rollover incident. Slide 3
contained the date, “September 14, 2020,” followed by “Count 1, PC245(a)(1)”
and “Count 2, VC20001(a).” Slide 4 contained three photographs of the
damage to the truck and Audi involved in the incident. Slide 5 contained a
portion of the jury instructions given for count 1, assault with a deadly
weapon. Slides 6 and 7 contained language from the jury instructions that
defined deadly weapon and application of force. Slide 8 contained the great
bodily injury allegation and the definition of great bodily injury provided to
the jury. Slides 9 and 10 contained photos depicting C.K.’s injuries from the
day of rollover incident. Slide 11 contained language from the jury
instructions for count 2. Slide 12, also based on the jury instructions, stated,
“Does not matter who ‘caused’ the collision.”
10
Slides 13 through 26 related to the March 2021 incident. Slides 13 and
14 had the dates February 1, 2021 and February 16, 2021 and the word
“corroboration” under the dates. Slide 15 had the date of the strangulation,
March 9, 2021, and listed the two associated counts, counts 3 and 4. Slides
16, 17, 18, 19, 20, and 21 contained photos of C.K.’s injuries from the
strangulation, the house she shared with Ortega in National City, and
screenshots of the body worn camera of Sosa. Slide 18 also had the words
“fresh injuries” next to a photo of a red mark on C.K.’s forehead. Slides 22
and 23 contained language from the jury instructions for count 3 and a
definition for traumatic condition. Slide 24 contained language from the jury
instruction for count 4. Slide 25 contained additional photos of C.K.’s neck
showing injury from the strangulation. Slide 26 contained the names of two
witnesses, the medical professionals who treated C.K. and testified about the
strangulation.
Slide 27 listed the date range of “June 1, 2021” to “June 30, 2021” with
count 5 written underneath. Slides 28 and 29 contained two exhibits entered
into evidence, a screenshot of a text message sent to a victim advocate from a
phone number that belonged to C.K. and a map of the area where the car
chase occurred. Slide 30 contained language from the jury instruction for
count 5, stalking. Slide 31 provided the definition for harassment from the
jury instructions. Slides 32 and 33 provided the definition of a credible
threat from the jury instructions. Slide 34 contained the word
“corroboration.” Slide 35 contained the words “jail calls.” Slide 36 had the
heading “prior domestic violence evidence” and provided the relevant
standard of proof, preponderance of the evidence, and its definition, “more
likely than not.” The final slide stated, “lesser included offenses.” Three
other slides were blank.
11
After the jury reached its verdict, and before sentencing, the trial court
scheduled a status conference. At the conference, the court informed the
parties that a printout of the prosecutor’s presentation was inadvertently
provided to the jury during deliberation. The court indicated it had
researched the issue and reached a tentative ruling that under the guidance
of People v. Anderson (2018) 5 Cal.5th 372 (Anderson), the error did not
constitute jury misconduct and was subject to a harmless error analysis. The
court tentatively concluded that a new trial was not required because there
was not a reasonable probability of a more favorable result absent the error
since all of the information contained in the presentation was provided to the
jury and Ortega had not raised any objection to the closing presentation. The
court then set dates for Ortega to submit a motion for a new trial based on
the error.
Ortega presented his motion for a new trial and the district attorney
filed opposition to the motion. The court then heard argument from counsel.
Ortega’s attorney asserted that this was a case of first impression, and unlike
Anderson, which involved a single piece of unadmitted evidence inadvertently
allowed into the jury room, the document at issue here constituted a roadmap
to the prosecutor’s desired result. Ortega’s counsel also asserted that because
the jury deliberated for approximately 90 minutes, before a four-day break in
the middle, followed by another morning of deliberations before reaching the
guilty verdicts, it was likely the jury inappropriately used the presentation as
just such a roadmap to a guilty verdict. The prosecutor argued that the jury’s
consideration of the presentation was harmless error because it did not
contain any new information. The trial court agreed with the prosecutor and
denied Ortega’s new trial motion.
12
B
Legal Standards
When the jury gains access to evidence or exhibits that the trial court
did not intend to admit, the “situation is no different than if the same
evidence had been proffered at trial and a valid objection to its admittance
was erroneously overruled.” (People v. Gamache (2010) 48 Cal.4th 347,
396‒397 (Gamache).) “The situation is the same as any in which the court
erroneously admits evidence. ... There has been merely ‘an error of law ...
such as ... an incorrect evidentiary ruling.’ [Citation.] Such error is
reversible only if it is reasonably probable that a result more favorable to the
defendant would have been reached in the absence of the error.” (People v.
Cooper (1991) 53 Cal.3d 771, 836.)
The introduction of improper evidence against a defendant does not
amount to a violation of due process unless the evidence “is so extremely
unfair that its admission violates ‘fundamental conceptions of justice.’ ”
(Dowling v. United States (1990) 493 U.S. 342, 352.) “For the erroneous
admission of evidence to amount to a denial of due process, the evidence must
have been ‘ “sufficiently material to provide the basis for conviction or to
remove a reasonable doubt that would have existed on the record without
it.” ’ ” (People v. Dryden (2021) 60 Cal.App.5th 1007, 1025–1026.)
Without explanation, Ortega asserts that the mistake here was so
egregious that his due process and fair trial rights were violated, requiring
review under the standard of Chapman v. California (1967) 386 U.S. 18, 24.
Under this more rigorous standard, reversal is required unless the
prosecution shows the error is harmless beyond a reasonable doubt. (Ibid.)
Because all of the information in the document, with minimal exception
discussed infra, was already in the jury’s possession, we do not agree with
13
Ortega that this mistake was of constitutional significance. Accordingly, in
this situation, we ask “whether, in light of all the other evidence properly
admitted, the verdict this jury reached would have been the same absent
exposure to the” presentation. (Gamache, supra, 48 Cal.4th at p. 397.)
C
Analysis
As discussed, the printed copy of the PowerPoint presentation that the
jury inadvertently received contained only information that had already been
provided to the jury in the form of evidence, instructions, and the prosecutor’s
closing argument. Further, of the 37 slides with content, only seven
contained anything other than the charged counts, jury instructions, and the
dates of the offenses. Of those seven, two slides had dates associated with
uncharged domestic violence incidents plus the word “corroboration” under
the dates; another contained only the word “corroboration”; one had the
names of two medical professionals that testified in relation to counts 3 and
4; one had a heading, “Jail Calls,” generally referencing an exhibit; one stated
“lesser included offenses”; and the seventh had the words “fresh injuries”
next to a photo of C.K.’s forehead showing a scratch. With respect to this last
slide, the prosecutor argued that the photo showed the injury was recent,
supporting her assertion the injuries occurred during the March 2021
incident.
Nothing in the presentation was new or “a revelation for the jury.”
(Anderson, supra, 5 Cal.5th at p. 421.) Rather, it was information already
before the jury and it was provided in the exhibits and instructions given to
the jury. In light of these facts, we agree with the Attorney General that the
error did not create a reasonable probability that a more favorable outcome
14
would have resulted absent the error. Accordingly, the trial court’s denial of
Ortega’s motion for a new trial was not an abuse of its discretion.
Ortega argues that because the court clerk mistakenly believed the
presentation was received in evidence, the jury must have ignored
instructions that the arguments of counsel are not evidence and considered it
as such. Ortega also argues that because the jury filled out the verdict forms
for the lesser included offenses—acquitting him of those offenses after it was
instructed to leave the forms blank if it found Ortega guilty of the greater
offenses—the jury must have had difficulty following all instructions and
therefore viewed the presentation as evidence and used it as a “roadmap” to
find Ortega guilty. Finally, Ortega (taking a contrary approach to that of his
trial counsel) asserts the length of the jury’s deliberation shows that “at least
one juror was harboring a serious doubt on one or more of the counts,” which
he contends shows the error was prejudicial.
These arguments do not persuade us that a more favorable outcome
was likely in the absence of the error. Contrary to Ortega’s arguments, jurors
are presumed to understand jury instructions intelligently and with common
sense. (See Boyde v. California (1990) 494 U.S. 370, 381 [we assume jurors
employ a “commonsense understanding of the instructions” with “all that has
taken place at the trial likely to prevail over technical hairsplitting”].) The
jury’s failure to follow the court’s instructions on the lesser included offense
forms does not show its members did not understand or follow the instruction
that the arguments of counsel were not evidence. (See People v. Coddington
(2000) 23 Cal.4th 529, 594, overruled on other grounds in Price v. Superior
Court (2001) 25 Cal.4th 1046 [“We credit jurors with intelligence and common
sense ... and do not assume that these virtues will abandon them when
presented with a court’s instructions.”]; People v. Holt (1997) 15 Cal.4th 619,
15
662 [“Jurors are presumed to understand and follow the court’s
instructions.”].) The instruction on how to complete the forms was technical
and lengthy, and the jury’s unnecessary completion of the lesser included
offense forms does not show a general disregard for the jury instructions.
Further, as discussed, the presentation did not provide new
information and differed only minimally from the evidence and jury
instructions that were properly in the jury room. For this reason, we do not
agree with Ortega’s assertion that the presentation served as a “roadmap” to
his guilt. The prosecutor’s closing statement had already presented the jury
with her obvious argument that Ortega committed the crimes for which he
stood trial. The substance of the presentation offered nothing new to the jury
that addressed the credibility of the conflicting evidence.
Finally, the length of the jury’s deliberation has minimal, if any,
relevance to the question of prejudice. This point is illustrated by the fact
that Ortega’s trial counsel argued that the short length of the deliberations
showed the jury simply adopted the prosecutor’s closing argument
presentation, while on appeal his counsel asserts that if the evidence was
overwhelming, “the jury would not have needed an afternoon followed by a
full day to deliberate, reaching a decision a mere ten minutes before they
would have been required to stop deliberating on that second day.”
The length of the jury’s deliberation is of limited relevance in light of
the extensive testimony at trial, over the course of 11 days, recounting events
that occurred during a multiyear period, going to five counts stemming from
three separate incidents. Less than two days of deliberation in light of this
record is not so lengthy that it establishes the jury’s decision was a close one,
16
supporting a finding of prejudice as a result of the error.4 (See e.g., In re
Sassounian (1995) 9 Cal.4th 535, 548–549, fn. 10 [lengthy jury deliberations
and requests for rereading of testimony and clarification of instructions does
not establish the case was close, and may instead be attributable to factors
such as the extensiveness of the evidence].)
In sum, while it is unfortunate that the court’s clerk mistakenly
provided the jury with the prosecutor’s presentation, we cannot say in the
particular circumstance that Ortega was prejudiced by its presence in the
jury room.
DISPOSITION
The judgment of conviction is affirmed.
McCONNELL, P. J.
WE CONCUR:
DATO, J.
DO, J.
4 We also note that there is no indication in the record before this court
that Ortega’s trial counsel sought to contact or interview any of the jurors to
determine whether the presentation was used during deliberations.
17
Vous vous demandez comment ce texte s’applique à votre situation ?
Consultation gratuite, sans engagement
Décrivez votre situation. Notre équipe vous recontactera par e-mail pour votre consultation.
Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude
Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.