Scott v. Kaiuum

CourtListener 4348784Calctapp14 févr. 2017

Texte intégral

Filed 1/4/17

CERTIFIED FOR PUBLICATION

IN THE APPELLATE DIVISION OF THE SUPERIOR COURT

STATE OF CALIFORNIA, COUNTY OF FRESNO

CANDY SCOTT, ) Sup. Ct. Appeal No. 2574
)
Defendant and Appellant, ) Sup. Ct. No. 15CECL09273
)
v. )
)
SHEIKH KAIUUM, )
)
Plaintiff and Respondent. )
)
)
)
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of Fresno

County, Lisa Gamoian, Judge. Reversed.1

Attorneys and Law Firms

Central California Legal Services, Inc., Marcos Seguro, for

Defendant and Appellant.

Law Offices of Daniel A. Bruce, Daniel A. Bruce, for

Plaintiff and Respondent.

Opinion

GARY D. HOFF, J.

1
This opinion was originally issued by the court on December 7, 2016. It was
certified for publication on January ___, 2017, which is within the time that
the appellate division retained jurisdiction. This opinion has been certified
for publication in the Official Reports. It is being sent to the Fifth District
Court of Appeal to assist the Court of Appeal in deciding whether to order the
case transferred to the court on the court‟s own motion under Rules 8-1000 –
8.1018.
I.

Introduction

In this appeal from an unlawful detainer judgment, appellant

Candy Scott (hereinafter “appellant”) contends that the trial

court erroneously granted judgment in favor of respondent Sheikh

Kaiuum (hereinafter “respondent”). She argues that the respondent

was not allowed to evict her for failure to pay the full amount

due under her rental contract because she was the beneficiary of

subsidized rental payments under 42 U.S.C.A. 1937f, Section 8.

She contends that the Fresno County Housing Authority had ceased

making Section 8 payments on her behalf due to the respondent‟s

failure to maintain the property in a habitable condition, and

thus respondent should not have been allowed to declare her in

breach of the rental agreement.

We agree that it was respondent‟s conduct, not appellant‟s,

that caused the Housing Authority to cease making Section 8

payments, and that respondent was not permitted by law to recover

the unpaid amounts from appellant, or to declare her to be in
breach of the lease when she failed to make the full payments.

Therefore, we will reverse the trial court‟s judgment.

II.

Facts

On January 14, 2015, appellant and respondent entered into a

one-year residential rental agreement with rent set at the market

rate of $700 per month. However, a portion of appellant‟s rent
was subsidized through the Federal Section 8 program. In

accordance with Section 8 regulations, respondent and the Fresno

-2-
County Housing Authority entered into a Housing Assistance

Payment Contract (“HAP contract”), which required the Housing

Authority to pay respondent $684 of appellant‟s $700 per month

rent each month starting on September 1, 2015. The HAP contract

prohibited respondent from charging appellant more than $16 per

month.
On October 27, 2015, the Housing Authority sent respondent
and appellant a letter stating that the property had failed a
recent inspection, and listing multiple violations of the federal
habitability standards, all but one of which were deemed to be
caused by the owner. The letter warned that there would be
another inspection on November 17, 2015, and that, if the defects
were not cured by the time of that inspection, the Housing
Authority would abate all further Section 8 payments effective
December 1, 2015, and the HAP contract would be canceled
effective December 17, 2015.
On November 18, 2015, the Housing Authority sent respondent
another letter, stating that the property had failed the second
inspection, that the Housing Authority would abate Section 8
payments to respondent effective December 1, 2015, and that the
HAP contract would be canceled on December 17, 2015 unless
repairs were made before the cancelation date. There was an
inspection report attached to the letter that listed multiple
separate violations in appellant‟s unit and the common areas of
the complex, all of which were all determined to be the
responsibility of respondent owner. The letter also informed the
respondent that it was “not permitted to recover monies from the
resident.”
Nevertheless, when rent came due on December 1, 2015,

respondent demanded that appellant pay the entirety of the $700

-3-
rent under the rental agreement. When rent became past due on

December 4, 2015, respondent served appellant with a three-day

notice to pay or quit, again demanding the full $700 rental

payment.

When appellant did not pay rent or leave the premises,

respondent filed his complaint for unlawful detainer on December

16, 2015. Appellant filed her answer on December 21, 2015,

raising defenses based on lack of habitability and violation of

the agreement with the Housing Authority. Trial was set for

January 12, 2016.

At the trial, Judge Lisa Gamoian found that respondent had

failed inspections due to substandard conditions at the unit, and

that the Housing Authority had given notice that Section 8 rent

would not be paid to respondent if the violations were not cured.

However, the court found that, because the deficiencies were not

cured by the deadline, the Section 8 contract had terminated and

thus appellant was required to pay the full amount of rent under

the rental agreement. Therefore, the court granted the unlawful
detainer judgment in favor of respondent and against appellant.

The court also ordered appellant to pay past due rent and

holdover damages of $1,242.96. Appellant then filed the present

timely appeal.

III.

Discussion

Standard of Review: There are no disputed issues of fact,

so we apply the de novo standard of review to the trial court‟s
construction of the relevant statutes and ordinances, as well as

to the court‟s determination that the complaint states a cause of

-4-
action. (Naylor v. Superior Court (2015) 236 Cal.App.4th Supp.

1, 6.)

Principles of Unlawful Detainer and Section 8 Law: Under

Code of Civil Procedure section 1161, “A tenant for a term less

than life is guilty of unlawful detainer by continuing in

possession without the landlord's permission after default in the

payment of rent pursuant to the lease or rental agreement, and

after a three-days' written notice stating the amount due and

requiring the payment or possession of the property, has been

served on the tenant and subtenant, if any. (Code Civ. Proc., §

1161, subd. (2).)” (Smith-Chavez, Stratton & Trembath, Cal.

Practice Real Property Litigation (2016) § 18:9.)

Also, “Section 1161 of the Code of Civil Procedure requires

that the three-day notice must state „the amount which is due.‟

It is settled law that this section incorporates the common law

view that in order to work a forfeiture of a lease for nonpayment

of rent the landlord must demand the precise sum due, and that a

demand in excess of the judgment will not support the judgment.”
(Werner v. Sargeant (1953) 121 Cal.App.2d 833, 837.)

In addition, since appellant was renting the unit under the

federal Section 8 program, the respondent had to comply with

federal statutes and regulations related to Section 8 before it

could evict appellant. “[T]ermination proceedings under Section

8's existing housing program are left by Congress and HUD to

state law” and “the landlord can institute unlawful detainer

proceedings in state court.” (Gallman v. Pierce, 639 F.Supp.
472, 478 (N.D.Cal.1986).) The regulations regarding termination

of a Section 8 lease agreement provide that tenancy may be

-5-
terminated for serious violation of the terms of the lease,

“including but not limited to failure to pay rent.” (24 C.F.R. §

982.310(a).)
However, under the HUD regulations, “The owner must
maintain the unit in accordance with HQS [Housing Quality
Standards].” (24 C.F.R. § 982.404, subd. (a)(1).) “If the owner
fails to maintain the dwelling unit in accordance with HQS, the
PHA [Public Housing Authority] must take prompt and vigorous
action to enforce the owner obligations. PHA remedies for such
breach of the HQS include termination, suspension or reduction of
housing assistance payments and termination of the HAP contract.”
(24 C.F.R. § 982.404, subd. (a)(2); see also 24 C.F.R. § 982.453,
subd. (b).)
“The PHA must not make any housing assistance payments for a
dwelling unit that fails to meet the HQS, unless the owner
corrects the defect within the period specified by the PHA and
the PHA verifies the correction.” (24 C.F.R. § 982.404, subd.
(a)(3).)
Also, “Any of the following actions by the owner... is a
breach of the HAP contract by the owner: (1) If the owner has
violated any obligation under the HAP contract for the dwelling
unit, including the owner's obligation to maintain the unit in
accordance with the HQS.” (24 C.F.R. § 982.453, subd. (a)(1).)
Moreover, “The family is not responsible for payment of the
portion of the rent to owner covered by the housing assistance
payment under the HAP contract between the owner and the PHA.”
(24 C.F.R. § 982.310, subd. (b)(1), emphasis added.)
Furthermore, “The PHA[„s] failure to pay the housing

assistance payment to the owner is not a violation of the lease

-6-
between the tenant and the owner. During the term of the lease

the owner may not terminate the tenancy of the family for

nonpayment of the PHA housing assistance payment.” (24 C.F.R. §

982.310, subd. (b)(2), emphasis added.)

Application: We find that the trial court‟s decision to

grant judgment in favor of respondent and evict appellant was in

error. First of all, under the HAP contract and HUD regulations,

appellant was only obligated to pay $16 per month of rent, not

the full $700 market rate rent pursuant to the rental agreement.

Thus, to the extent that the three-day notice sought to recover

the full $700 in rent from appellant, the notice greatly

overstated the amount of rent due. As a result, the three-day

notice was inaccurate and could not form the basis of a valid

unlawful detainer claim, nor could it properly support any

subsequent unlawful detainer judgment. (Werner v. Sargeant,

supra, 121 Cal.App.2d at p. 837.)

Also, the judgment was in violation of the HUD regulations

that prohibit the owner from collecting the unpaid rental subsidy
from the resident when the Housing Authority abates the subsidy

payment due to habitability standard violations by the owner.

“The family is not responsible for payment of the portion of the

rent to owner covered by the housing assistance payment under the

HAP contract between the owner and the PHA.” (24 C.F.R. §

982.310, subd. (b)(1), emphasis added.) “The PHA failure to pay

the housing assistance payment to the owner is not a violation of

the lease between the tenant and the owner. During the term of
the lease the owner may not terminate the tenancy of the family

-7-
for nonpayment of the PHA housing assistance payment.” (24

C.F.R. § 982.310, subd. (b)(2), emphasis added.)

Yet here, the owner served a three-day notice to pay rent or

quit after the Housing Authority abated Section 8 subsidy

payments to the owner due to the owner‟s violation of the

habitability standards under Section 8. There is no dispute that

the abatement was due to multiple violations of the habitability

standards, or that the violations were solely caused by the

owner, rather than the tenant. Under these circumstances, the

owner was not allowed to recover the unpaid amount of rent from

the resident, and the Housing Authority‟s letter clearly stated

as much. Thus, the trial court should not have found the tenant

to be in violation of the lease terms or granted judgment in

favor of the owner. Nor should the trial court have found the

tenant liable for the unpaid rental amounts, which were based on

the full market rate rather than the remaining balance of $16

that was the tenant‟s responsibility.

It appears that the trial court believed that it was the
responsibility of both the owner and the tenant to cure the

defects in the unit, and that, since the HAP contract was

terminated for failure to cure the defects, therefore the tenant

was liable for the full amount of rent under the rental

agreement. However, as discussed above, the Housing Authority

found that the violations were solely caused by the owner, not

the tenant. As such, the owner had no right to seek the balance

of the unpaid subsidy payment from the tenant.
In addition, the November 18, 2015 letter from the Housing

Authority made it clear that, while the Section 8 payments would

-8-
be abated effective December 1, 2015, the HAP contract would not

be canceled until December 17, 2015. Thus, the HAP contract had

not yet been canceled at the time the three-day notice was served

on December 4, 2015, or even when the unlawful detainer complaint

was filed on December 16, 2015. As a result, even assuming that

the owner could have properly recovered the full market rate rent

from the tenant after the HAP contract was canceled, which it

could not, here the three-day notice and complaint were filed

before the contract had been canceled. Consequently, the owner

was not entitled to recover the full market rate rent of $700 per

month from the tenant, and the court should not have granted

judgment based on the failure to pay the full rental amount.

Allowing the owner to recover the unpaid balance of the

Section 8 subsidy from the tenant when the Housing Authority had

canceled the payments due to the owner‟s failure to cure the

habitability violations would also be inconsistent with the

intent of Section 8, which is to make it possible for low-income

tenants to obtain affordable, safe, and decent housing. (See 42
U.S.C. 1937f, subd. (a).) Permitting a landlord to evict a

tenant for failure to pay the full market amount of rent because

the landlord failed to remedy basic violations of the

habitability standards of Section 8 would reward the landlord for

its bad behavior, and perhaps even create an incentive for

landlords to refuse to correct defects with their properties.

There is a dearth of California authorities addressing this

issue, but we note that other states have consistently held that
an owner who refuses to correct violations of habitability

standards are not allowed to then either collect the full amount

-9-
of rent from their tenants, or evict them if they fail to pay

full market rate rents. For example, in 1212 Grand Concourse LLC

v. Ynguil, 2010 WL 183762, 894 N.Y.S.2d 713, 27 Misc. 3d 205, a

New York court found that the landlords could not evict their

Section 8 tenants when it was the landlords‟ failure to cure the

defective conditions of the premises that had caused the HAP

contracts to be terminated. (1212 Grand Concourse, supra, 27

Misc. 3d at pp. 212 – 213; see also Sunflower Park Apartments v.

Denise Johnson (1997) 23 Kan. App. 2d 862; Soliman v. Cepeda

(1993) 269 N.J. Super. 151, 636 A.2d 1057.)

While this court is not bound by the decisions of courts in

other jurisdictions, we agree with their reasoning that it would

defeat the intent of Section 8 and the HUD regulations to allow

the respondent landlord to demand full rent payments from the

appellant when it was the respondent who allowed the property to

fall into such disrepair that it fell below minimum standards of

habitability under federal law. It would give the landlord no

incentive to correct such unsafe and unsanitary conditions if the
landlord could simply demand full rental payments from the tenant

when the Housing Authority cuts off the Section 8 subsidy

payments. In fact, it would reward the landlord for its own bad

conduct to allow unlawful detainer actions to proceed in such

circumstances.

Furthermore, the respondent was also not entitled to demand

payment of rent under California Law because the conditions of

the rental unit violated Civil Code section 1941.1. Under Civil
Code section 1942.4,

-10-
(a) A landlord of a dwelling may not demand rent, collect
rent, issue a notice of a rent increase, or issue a three-
day notice to pay rent or quit pursuant to subdivision (2)
of Section 1161 of the Code of Civil Procedure, if all of
the following conditions exist prior to the landlord's
demand or notice:

(1) The dwelling substantially lacks any of the affirmative
standard characteristics listed in Section 1941.1...

(2) A public officer or employee who is responsible for the
enforcement of any housing law, after inspecting the
premises, has notified the landlord or the landlord's agent
in writing of his or her obligations to abate the nuisance
or repair the substandard conditions.

(3) The conditions have existed and have not been abated 35
days beyond the date of service of the notice specified in
paragraph (2) and the delay is without good cause...

(4) The conditions were not caused by an act or omission of
the tenant or lessee in violation of Section 1929 or 1941.2.

(Civ. Code, § 1942.4.)

Also, under Civil Code section 1941.1,

(a) A dwelling shall be deemed untenantable for purposes of
Section 1941 if it substantially lacks any of the following
affirmative standard characteristics or is a residential
unit described in Section 17920.3 or 17920.10 of the Health
and Safety Code:

(1) Effective waterproofing and weather protection of roof
and exterior walls, including unbroken windows and doors.

(2) Plumbing or gas facilities that conformed to applicable
law in effect at the time of installation, maintained in
good working order.

...

(6) Building, grounds, and appurtenances at the time of the
commencement of the lease or rental agreement, and all areas
under control of the landlord, kept in every part clean,
sanitary, and free from all accumulations of debris, filth,
rubbish, garbage, rodents, and vermin.

-11-
...

(8) Floors, stairways, and railings maintained in good
repair. (Civ. Code, § 1941.1.)

Here, the conditions of the unit as described in the notice

of abatement served on respondent showed that the unit fell below

the standards of section 1941.1. The abatement letter contains a

list of violations present in the unit that respondent failed to

rectify, including exterior doors with missing trim, loose shower

head, improperly installed water heater, roach infestation,

garbage and debris in the common areas, hanging barbed wire on

the carports, protruding nails on boarded up units, damaged

stairs, and various other health and safety violations. The

Housing Authority served respondent with notice of the violations

on October 27, 2015, and warned respondent to fix the violations

or Section 8 payments would be suspended and the HAP contract

terminated. Respondent refused to repair the conditions despite

having more than 35 days in which to do so. Finally, the letter

from the Housing Authority clearly states that the conditions

were caused by respondent, not the tenant.

Respondent did not deny any of these facts at trial, nor has

respondent filed any opposition to appellant‟s brief on appeal,

so respondent apparently concedes that the unsafe conditions

existed, that they were caused by respondent, that it had notice

of the violations, and that it failed to correct them.

Therefore, because respondent failed to remedy the unsafe
conditions at the unit after receiving notice of the violations,

respondent had no right to collect any rent from appellant during

-12-
the period in which the violations went uncorrected. (Civil Code

§ 1942.4.)

As a result, the trial court‟s order granting the unlawful

detainer judgment against appellant and awarding damages against

her based on unpaid rent was erroneous.

IV.

Disposition

Accordingly, the judgment is hereby reversed, and the matter

is remanded to the trial court with instructions to enter a new

judgment denying all relief to respondent. It is so ordered.

Dated this __ day of January, 2017

_____________________________________
Hon. Gary D. Hoff, Judge

WE CONCUR:

_____________________________________
Hon. Donald S. Black, Presiding Judge
Appellate Division of Fresno Superior
Court

_____________________________________
Hon. Rosemary McGuire, Judge

-13-
-14-

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.