CourtListener 10872541•People v. Lewis CA4/1
Texte intégral
Filed 6/9/26 P. v. Lewis CA4/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
COURT OF APPEAL, FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
THE PEOPLE, D087168
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v. (Super. Ct. No. SWF2201442)
CAMERON HUNTER LEWIS,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of Riverside County,
Louis R. Hanoian and Frederick Paul Dickerson III,* Judges. Reversed with
instructions.
Matthew M. Johnson, under the appointment by the Court of Appeal,
for Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Chief Assistant Attorney General, Lance
E. Winters, Chief Assistant Attorney General, Charles C. Ragland, Assistant
Attorney General, Christopher P. Beesley and Namita Patel, for Plaintiff and
Respondent.
* Retired judges of the San Diego Superior Court assigned by the Chief
Justice pursuant to article VI, section 6 of the California Constitution.
Cameron Hunter Lewis left his car in the public parking lot of a
healthcare facility with its trunk ajar. Loose ammunition and shooting
targets, all legal, were visible inside its the locked passenger cabin. But a
security guard for the facility was sufficiently concerned that he called the
sheriff’s department. The sheriff’s deputy who responded to the call looked
inside the partially open trunk and could see a tactical vest commonly
associated with law enforcement and firearms. He opened the trunk, seized
the vest, and found a pistol and high-capacity magazines in its pockets.
Lewis pleaded guilty to several offenses stemming from this seizure,
but he now appeals the order denying his two-part motion to suppress
claiming there was no probable cause to open the trunk and seize the vest
because nothing incriminating about it could be seen until after it was taken
from the trunk. The trial judge who presided over the second hearing and
ultimately denied the renewed suppression motion disagreed. In his view,
the deputy provided credible testimony at the first hearing that he thought
he saw a gun in the vest before opening the trunk, and this was enough to
validate the search and seizure.
It is true the deputy initially testified that through the gap in the
partially open trunk he saw what “looked like the butt of a pistol in the
tactical vest.” However, on both cross and redirect examination across two
hearings, the deputy clarified that while he could see the vest through the
crack, he did not notice the butt of the gun until he opened the trunk.
Thereafter, two different prosecutors (at the first and second hearing) and the
trial court (at the first hearing) accepted that the deputy did not believe he
saw the butt of a pistol until after he fully opened the trunk. On this record,
the deputy’s initial-but-later-clarified testimony does not provide substantial
2
evidence that the butt of a pistol could be seen in plain view inside the
partially open trunk. Accordingly, we must reverse.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
After the court denied his motion to suppress, in May 2024 Lewis
pleaded guilty to gun- and drug-related charges stemming from the discovery
of an unsecured handgun, a loaded assault rifle, and four high-capacity rifles
magazines during a warrantless search of the trunk of his car.1 He was
sentenced to formal probation with the condition that he serve 180 days in
local custody.2
The weapons and rifle magazines were found while Lewis’s car was
parked in a lot outside a Temecula health care clinic in August 2022. Lewis
reverse parked his car into a corner spot adjacent to the building with no
other cars nearby. Between the spot and the building was a row of plants,
to the right of which were what appear to be utility boxes and to the left of
which were more plants. There was no sidewalk or other pedestrian path
between the parking spot and the building.
A clinic security guard noticed that the trunk of the car was partially
open and that shooting targets and loose ammunition were visible in its
1 The charges were: possession of an assault weapon (Pen. Code,
§ 30605, subd. (a)), carrying a concealed firearm within a vehicle under his
control (id., § 25400, subd. (a)), possession of four large-capacity magazines
(id., § 32310), being under the influence of a controlled substance while in
possession of a loaded firearm (Health & Saf. Code, § 11550, subd. (e)), being
under the influence of a controlled substance (id., subd. (a)), and possession
of an opium pipe (id., § 11364, subd. (a)).
2 This appeal following a guilty plea is expressly permitted by Penal
Code section 1538.5, subdivision (m).
3
passenger compartment. He called the Riverside County Sheriff’s
Department to investigate.
Deputy Gregory Eastwood was one of at least three deputies who
responded to the call. After seeing the targets and ammunition in the locked
passenger compartment of the car, Eastwood looked inside the trunk from the
side through the gap created by the partially open lid. He was able to see a
tactical vest like those worn by law enforcement officers.
Without obtaining a warrant, Eastwood opened the trunk and retrieved
the vest. He found a handgun and four high-capacity rifle magazines tucked
into its pockets. It was unlawful for Lewis to leave a firearm unsecured in
his unattended car (Pen. Code, § 25400, subd. (a)) or to possess high-capacity
magazines (id., § 32130, subd. (a)). Believing these discoveries authorized a
search of the trunk for more weapons, another deputy found a loaded assault
rifle—also illegal for Lewis to possess (id., § 30605)—in a rifle bag near where
the tactical vest had been lying.
Shortly thereafter, deputies confirmed that Lewis was the registered
owner of the car, identified him as a patient in the clinic, arrested him in
an examination room, and found drugs and drug paraphernalia in his car.
Before Lewis was arrested, deputies told him that they wanted to talk about
unspecified “objects” and “stuff” in his trunk, which caused him to become
visibly upset. They also found the key to the car in Lewis’s pocket during a
pat down search.
Shortly after the preliminary hearing, Lewis unsuccessfully moved to
suppress the evidence deputies gathered from his trunk and the fruits of that
allegedly illegal search. The motion was heard by Judge Louis R. Hanoian
and denied. After the People belatedly produced the footage from Eastwood’s
body worn camera (bodycam) and the case was set for trial, Lewis renewed
4
his suppression motion before the assigned trial judge, Judge F. Paul
Dickerson III. In denying Lewis’s renewed motion, the court acknowledged
that he had a reasonable expectation of privacy in the trunk of his car, but
found that the seizure of the vest and its contents were authorized under the
plain view doctrine. According to the court, Eastwood credibly testified that
he saw an unsecured gun in the vest while the trunk was only partially open.
DISCUSSION
Lewis claims that the record does not contain substantial evidence to
support the court’s finding that Eastwood credibly testified the gun was in
plain view while the trunk was only partially open. Thus, Lewis contends,
the deputy was not authorized to seize the vest and its contents without a
warrant, the first in what he believes was a series of illegal discoveries of
incriminating evidence. The People respond that even if Lewis had an
expectation of privacy in his partially open trunk, we must accept the trial
court’s challenged credibility finding and conclude that the search and
seizure was justified by the plain view doctrine.3 Alternatively, the People
contend that the warrantless seizure of the vest was a reasonable exercise of
the deputies’ community caretaking function to keep the public safe from
unsecured firearms.
In reviewing an order on a suppression motion, “we rely on the trial
court’s express and implied factual findings, provided they are supported by
substantial evidence, to independently determine whether the search was
constitutional.” (People v. Lee (2019) 40 Cal.App.5th 853, 860 (Lee).) “
3 The Attorney General does not argue that the entirely legal firearms-
related items concededly in plain view (targets, loose ammunition and the
tactical vest) created probable cause to believe an illegal weapon would be
found in the trunk.
5
‘Thus, while we ultimately exercise our independent judgment to determine
the constitutional propriety of a search or seizure, we do so within the context
of historical facts determined by the trial court’ ” construed in the light most
favorable to the court’s order. (Id. at pp. 860–861.) “It is the trial court’s role
to evaluate witness credibility, resolve conflicts in the testimony, weigh the
evidence, and draw factual inferences.” (Ibid.)
The Fourth Amendment to the United States Constitution, made
applicable to the states by the Fourteenth Amendment, prohibits the police
from conducting unreasonable searches and seizures of private property.
(People v. Ramirez (2007) 148 Cal.App.4th 1464, 1469.) A defendant
challenging the lawfulness of a warrantless search must establish a
reasonable expectation of privacy in the area searched or the things seized.
(People v. Nishi (2012) 207 Cal.App.4th 954, 960 (Nishi).) A successful
showing requires the government to respond by identifying an applicable
exception to the warrant requirement. (People v. Rogers (2009) 46 Cal.4th
1136, 1156.) If the government fails to do so, the court must apply “ ‘an
exclusionary rule that … forbids the use of improperly obtained evidence at
trial’ ” and must also preclude “ ‘[t]he introduction into evidence of materials
and testimony which are the products or indirect results of the illegal
search.’ ” (People v. Golden (2017) 19 Cal.App.5th 905, 911.)
A. Lewis’s Expectation of Privacy
The People first claim that Lewis lacked standing to challenge the
warrantless seizure of the vest. In their view, he could not have a reasonable
expectation of privacy in the unsecured partially open trunk of his car
because its contents were accessible to any passersby. A defendant’s
expectation of privacy must be both subjective and objectively reasonable.
(Nishi, supra, 207 Cal.App.4th at p. 960.) To meet this second prong of the
6
test, the expectation “ ‘must have a source outside of the Fourth Amendment,
either by reference to concepts of real or personal property law or to
understandings that are recognized and permitted by society.’ ” (Byrd v.
United States (2018) 584 U.S. 395, 405 (Byrd).)
The court’s determination that Lewis had a reasonable expectation of
privacy in the trunk of his car is supported by substantial evidence. At the
time of the search, the doors to Lewis’s car were locked and the key was in
his pocket. These facts are highly relevant to our inquiry because “ ‘[o]ne
of the main rights attaching to property is the right to exclude others,’ and, …
‘one who owns or lawfully possesses or controls property will in all likelihood
have a legitimate expectation of privacy by virtue of the right to exclude.’ ”
(Byrd, supra, 584 U.S. at p. 405.) Accordingly, “[o]ne who owns and possesses
a car, like one who owns and possesses a house, almost always has a
reasonable expectation of privacy in it.” (Id. at p. 404.)
To the People’s point, the facts indicate that Lewis took “ ‘precautions
customarily taken by those seeking privacy.’ ” (Cf. United States v.
Ramapuram (4th Cir. 1980) 632 F.2d 1149, 1156 [no expectation of privacy
in broken trunk of a junked car in an open field].) Lewis told deputies
that his key fob was broken and that he knew his trunk was open. When
considered in this context, Lewis’s decision to reverse park his car into a spot
that was away from other cars, had no walkway behind it, and was next to a
row of plants that abutted the clinic building are actions consistent with an
attempt to protect the privacy of his trunk.
B. Plain View Doctrine
It does not violate the Fourth Amendment for an officer to make a
warrantless seizure of an incriminating object in plain view if “(1) the officer
was lawfully in a place where the object could be viewed; (2) the officer had a
7
lawful right of access to the seized item; and (3) the item’s evidentiary value
was immediately apparent.” (People v. Caro (2019) 7 Cal.5th 463, 489.) This
third element requires that there be “probable cause to believe that the item
in question is evidence of a crime or contraband” before it was seized. (People
v. Stokes (1990) 224 Cal.App.3d 715, 719 (Stokes).)
Much of Judge Dickerson’s application of the plain view doctrine is
appropriately unchallenged on appeal. Lewis does not dispute that its first
two requirements are met. He instead argues the record does not support the
court’s finding that Eastwood saw the gun in the vest before he opened the
trunk. Thus, proper application of the plain view doctrine largely turns on
whether there is substantial evidence to support Judge Dickerson’s finding
that Eastwood credibly testified to seeing the gun in the vest before the trunk
was fully opened.
1. The First Hearing
Judge Hanoian conducted the hearing on Lewis’s initial motion in
October 2023. On direct examination, Eastwood began by describing his
arrival on the scene, where he found the car the security guard thought was
suspicious and saw a tactical vest in the partially open trunk.4 When asked
what he could see in the vest before opening the trunk, the deputy responded,
“It had some magazines, some – it looked like the butt of a pistol in the
tactical vest.” At that point, he testified, he opened the trunk and retrieved
the vest “in the interest of public safety,” specifically to secure the handgun to
prevent someone from taking it.
4 Certain persons may not own, possess, or maintain custody or control
over ammunition. (Pen. Code, § 30305, subd. (a)(1)–(b)(1).) It does not
appear that Lewis was such a prohibited person or that deputies thought
otherwise when they responded to the call.
8
That was the only time Eastwood testified to seeing a gun in the
tactical vest before he opened the trunk. He clarified on cross-examination:
“[Q:] Could you identify that there was a firearm from
when you first looked, before you opened—before you
opened the trunk?
“[A:] Before I opened the trunk?
“[Q:] Yes.
“[A:] No.”
A few moments later, Eastwood was asked to confirm whether he saw
the tactical vest before opening the trunk. the deputy answered in the
affirmative and then spontaneously added, “I didn’t see the handgun in the
[tactical vest] is what I remember.” He repeated that testimony on redirect
examination. Apparently satisfied with Eastwood’s clarifications, the
prosecutor accepted them as the truth when arguing against Lewis’s
suppression motion.
Judge Hanoian declined to suppress the evidence seized from the
trunk. He found that Lewis did not have a reasonable expectation of privacy
in the open trunk of his car but, even if he did, the warrantless seizure of the
vest and its contents was justified under either the plain view doctrine or the
exigent circumstances exception to the warrant requirement. The court
supported its latter rulings with findings that Eastwood saw the vest and
clips in the partially open trunk. But it also specifically found that “[h]e
didn’t see the gun until he opened it further.”
2. The Second Hearing
Lewis renewed his motion to suppress because footage from Eastwood’s
bodycam was provided to the defense after the previous hearing. Judge
Dickerson entertained Lewis’s renewed motion in May 2024. In addition to a
9
new judge, the People were represented at this hearing by a different
prosecutor. Before the hearing, the judge reviewed footage from Eastwood’s
and another deputy’s bodycams and the transcript of the earlier hearing, all
of which were admitted into evidence.
On direct examination, Eastwood set the scene as he did before, albeit
with more detail. He repeated his testimony that he could see the back of the
tactical vest in the partially open trunk. When combined with the loose
ammunition and targets in a car that was “backed into the corner of the
parking lot at a medical facility,” this led him to believe he could open the
trunk to address a potential active shooter situation.5 He went on to explain,
“I believe I picked up the vest, and that’s, I believe, when I saw the butt of a
handgun in the vest.” He also testified that he found the rifle magazines in
the vest after he removed it from the trunk and only then determined that
they were illegal to possess.
The footage from Eastwood’s bodycam corroborated his testimony about
seizing the vest and discovering its contents. He turned on the video capture
function after the trunk lid of Lewis’s car was already fully open. The video
depicts the vest lying in the trunk with neither the magazines nor the butt
of a gun visible. Eastwood switched on the audio capture function after he
picked up the vest but before he examined the magazines. The deputy
announced that the magazines were empty but did not mention that he
thought he saw a gun in the vest.
5 The court did not find Eastwood’s testimony about a potential active
shooter credible because the evidence showed that none of the deputies
exhibited the kind of urgency one would expect of a law enforcement officer
who genuinely thought a shooting might be imminent. We agree with this
finding and thus do not consider this testimony.
10
A few seconds after examining the magazines, Eastwood placed the
vest on the hood of Lewis’s car in an orientation where what turned out to be
the butt of the gun is visible. But rather than reach for the possible weapon
immediately, the deputy spent a few seconds poking at other compartments
of the vest. Evidently satisfied that they contained nothing of interest,
Eastwood then retrieved the pistol and exclaimed, “Oh boy!” The deputy
agreed that this exclamation indicated that the discovery took him by
“surprise,” as if “that’s the first time [he was] seeing it.”
Before playing Eastwood’s bodycam video, defense counsel referenced
his testimony from the first hearing that he could see the magazines and butt
of the pistol before he opened the trunk:
“[Q:] At the prior hearing, you testified that, when you
looked in the gap and you identified the tactical vest, and
you testified that you identified that there were magazines
and potentially the butt of a gun in it; correct?
“[A:] Yes.
“[Q:] At that point in time, prior to opening the trunk;
correct?
“[A:] Yes.
“[Q:] Okay. Is that your belief of what occurred?
“[A:] Well, I testified to that last time. But that’s—I
testified last time after I reviewed the body camera.
I haven’t reviewed the body camera in eight months.
So … .”6
6 Counsel did not follow up on whether Eastwood believed that he saw
the gun before opening the trunk.
11
Later on redirect examination, however, Eastwood confirmed that he also
previously testified that he did not “believe [he] noticed the butt of the gun
until after [he] opened” the trunk.
While arguing Lewis’s motion, the prosecutor—like his colleague
during the first hearing—characterized Eastwood as having testified that
that he did not see the gun until he took the vest out of the trunk. The court
asked the prosecutor to reconcile that interpretation with the deputy’s
testimony during the first hearing that he saw the handle of the pistol before
opening the trunk. In response, the prosecutor cited some of Eastwood’s
clarifying testimony withdrawing that assertion.
Like Judge Hanoian, Judge Dickerson also denied Lewis’s motion,
although he relied on a different rationale. According to Judge Dickerson,
Lewis had a reasonable expectation of privacy in his car because he was
arrested with its key in his pocket and there was paperwork in the car
belonging to him. But the court concluded that the warrantless seizure of
the vest and its contents were justified under the plain view doctrine because
Eastwood credibly testified during the first hearing that he could see a gun in
the vest before he opened the trunk. The seizure of the unsecured pistol and
high-capacity magazines, in turn, gave deputies probable cause to examine
the rifle bag that was also in the trunk.
The court explained its rationale for crediting Eastwood’s testimony
that he saw a gun before opening the trunk:
“I thought he did his very best. The inflection in his voice
was certain when he was certain. When he wasn’t sure, he
actually said to the Court, ‘I wasn’t sure.’ He admitted that
he made a couple of different inconsistent statements at the
prior hearing.
12
“But what he never did, Mr. Fox [prosecutor], was say he
didn’t see the butt of a pistol. What he said was—and this
was his first statement—as both of you know, having done
this work a long time, people can get confused; right?
You’ve got one attorney asking you questions, then another,
then the other attorney, then the other, then the other.
And you don't even know your name by the end of the
hearing. His first statement was—and you actually asked
him this, Mr. Donath [defense counsel]. ‘At the previous
hearing, you recall testifying that when you looked in the
trunk prior to opening the trunk in any way, you told the
Court that you can see the tactical vest with magazines and
what appeared to be the butt of a pistol?’
“His answer was unqualified, and I heard it in his voice,
‘Yes.’ He never qualified that to say, ‘I was mistaken.’
That was the sworn testimony, and the Court finds him
credible. Because the appellate Court, if it goes up, they
only have the transcript. I heard how he testified, and I
find him to be credible.
“As far as which statement to believe, this is what happens
in jury trials all the time. The trier of fact has to decide
which statement, if any, to believe.
“In the opinion of this Court, Mr. Fox [prosecutor], I believe
his initial statement was probably most accurate. He
looked in, he saw the vest, he saw what he believed to be
magazines and what appeared to be the butt of a gun. And
that’s corroborated. Because when he takes out the vest,
it has a gun in the vest, and there are magazines. It’s
corroborated. What he saw is what he saw, and there’s
evidence for it.”
3. The Trial Court’s Credibility Finding
Under the substantial evidence standard of review, we defer to a trial
court’s credibility finding that is supported by substantial evidence. (Lee,
supra, 40 Cal.App.5th at pp. 860–861.) Generally, this is “evidence which,
when viewed in light of the entire record, is of solid probative value,
13
maintains its credibility and inspires confidence that the ultimate fact it
addresses has been justly determined.” (People v. Conner (1983) 34 Cal.3d
141, 149.) Under this standard, we may reject testimony accepted as credible
by the trial court only if it is “ ‘ “wholly unacceptable to reasonable minds”
[or] “unbelievable per se” [citation] such that “no reasonable person could
believe the testimony.” ’ ” (In re S.A. (2010) 182 Cal.App.4th 1128, 1149.)
Credibility findings that fail to survive this scrutiny “are rare indeed.”
(DiQuisto v. County of Santa Clara (2010) 181 Cal.App.4th 236, 261 [“ ‘there
must exist either a physical impossibility that they are true, or [the
statements’] falsity must be apparent without resorting to inferences or
deductions’ ”].)
This case presents one of these rare occurrences. Eastwood testified
once, at the beginning of the first hearing, that he saw a gun in the vest
before he opened the trunk. Every other time the issue came up, however,
he clarified that he did not recall seeing the handgun in the vest until after
he opened the trunk. This clarification was fully consistent with the footage
from Eastwood’s bodycam, including his “Oh, boy!” exclamation he admitted
indicated surprise at the discovery of the gun. Indeed, the testimony that
Eastwood did not see the gun in the partially open trunk was so clear that
the prosecutors who handled both hearings accepted it as true. On this
record, we cannot accept the trial court’s finding that a snippet of testimony
Eastwood walked back several times was credible.
We are unpersuaded to read the record differently based on the trial
judge’s theories that Eastwood’s clarifications were the result of confusion or
that his one failure to spontaneously correct his initial testimony means that
he really did see the gun. Nothing in the deputy’s testimony indicates that
he failed to understand the questions he was being asked. Nor do we see why
14
yet another clarification of this point was necessary. And so while it is true,
as Judge Dickerson stated, that as the trier of fact he was to resolve
evidentiary conflicts and could take witness demeanor into account when
doing so, there was no confusion to address or contradiction to reconcile.
Rather, the deputy’s testimony about the gun as repeatedly clarified and
understood by all the advocates in the courtroom during both hearings was
consistent, not in conflict, with the other evidence.
Finally, the trial court’s rationale that Eastwood’s testimony about
seeing the gun in the vest before opening the trunk must have been true
because he later found a gun diminishes the protections of the Fourth
Amendment. Under the plain view doctrine, probable cause that an item of
interest to law enforcement is incriminating must exist before the object is
seized. (Stokes, supra, 224 Cal.App.3d at p. 719.) The trial court’s logic, by
contrast, suggests that this standard can be met by a mere hunch that
happens to pan out. That is not how the Fourth Amendment works. (People
v. Pitts (2004) 117 Cal.App.4th 881, 889 [“ ‘A hunch may provide the basis
for solid police work… . A hunch, however, is not a substitute for the
necessary specific, articulable facts required to justify a Fourth Amendment
intrusion’ ”].)
Having set aside the trial court’s finding that Eastwood credibly
testified he saw an unsecured gun in the trunk before he opened it, we must
15
conclude that the court erred in applying the plain view doctrine to deny
Lewis’s motion to suppress.7
C. Community Caretaking Function
In the alternative, the People contend that Eastwood’s warrantless
search of Lewis’s trunk was proper because protecting the public from
unsecured firearms falls under a law enforcement officer’s “community
caretaking functions.”8 Relying heavily on Cady v. Dombrowski (1973)
413 U.S. 433, 441 (Cady) and People v. Vodak (1980) 105 Cal.App.3rd 1014
(Vodak), the People contend that these functions include warrantless
searches of cars in public places to address concerns about weapons. In
the circumstances of this case, we disagree.
A law enforcement officer often performs functions that are “totally
divorced from the detection, investigation, or acquisition of evidence relating
to the violation of a criminal statute.” (Cady, supra, 413 U.S. at p. 441.)
As these so-called community caretaking functions relate to vehicles, they
7 Lewis argues that Eastwood could not have seen the magazines before
he opened the trunk and, even if he could, the deputy testified that he could
not have known they were illegal to possess until he seized them. Thus,
Lewis concludes, they could not provide probable cause to seize the vest.
The People concede this point, as they focus on Eastwood’s testimony about
the gun and only mention in passing the magazines he also claimed to see.
We therefore need not address this aspect of the deputy’s testimony.
8 The trial court did not rule that the community caretaking exception
applied. Accordingly, if there were potential merit to the People’s argument
and the underlying facts were disputed, a remand would be required so that
the trial court could address this issue in the first instance and make
appropriate factual findings. (See People v. Bowers (2004) 117 Cal.App.4th
1261, 1273 [case remanded for court to consider additional theories justifying
the search]; People v. LeBlanc (1997) 60 Cal.App.4th 157, 168 [same].) We
reach this issue here because there is no dispute as to the underlying facts.
16
include impounding them if they pose threats to public safety—for example,
because they are disabled, parked illegally, or blocking traffic or a sidewalk—
or stand at risk of theft or vandalism. (Lee, supra, 40 Cal.App.5th at p. 867.)
“ ‘When vehicles are impounded,’ ” that is, seized, “ ‘local police departments
generally follow a routine practice of securing and inventorying the
automobiles’ contents.’ ” (People v. Duong (2020) 10 Cal.5th 36, 52.) These
inventory searches are “a well-defined exception to the Fourth Amendment’s
warrant requirement.” (Lee, at p. 867.) Accordingly, under what is
sometimes referred to as the vehicle “community caretaking exception”
(People v. Ovieda (2019) 7 Cal.5th 1034, 1053 (Ovieda)), the government
may introduce evidence obtained from an inventory search of a lawfully
impounded vehicle. (Lee, at p. 867.)
We start with the fact that controlling precedent recognizes the vehicle
community caretaking exception applies only in the context of impound
procedures, which undisputedly were not used here. (Ovieda, supra, 7
Cal.5th at p. 1048 [“no published California case … has applied the concept
of community caretaking outside the context of a vehicle inventory”]; id. at
p. 1053 [the United States Supreme Court “has only recognized community
caretaking searches in the context of impound procedures”].) In Cady, the
high court rejected a challenge to a warrantless search for a gun in a car that
was in the police’s constructive custody, therefore it does not help the People’s
case. (Cady, supra, 413 U.S. at pp. 442–443, 447–448.) And neither does
Vodak despite that it bears some similarity to the facts here—officers found
loaded guns in the trunk of a car that had not been impounded after
observing loose shotgun shells in its passenger cabin. (Vodak, supra, 105
Cal.App.3d at pp. 1016–1018.) The warrantless search in Vodak was upheld
17
based on the existence of probable cause; there was no mention of the
community caretaking exception. (Ibid.)
The absence of established law supporting the People’s position does
not end our inquiry, however, because California courts have suggested they
might be open to expanding the vehicle community caretaking exception
beyond the impound context. For example, in People v. Madrid (2008) 168
Cal.App.4th 1050, 1057–1058, 1061, the Court of Appeal wrote, “[A]ssuming
that the community caretaking exception may justify the stop of a moving
vehicle, we conclude that given the facts[,] … a reasonable officer would not
have perceived a need to do so in this case.”
Turning to the People’s argument, we can imagine hypothetical
situations where a warrantless entry into the trunk of an unoccupied car in
a public lot would be reasonable under this exception, such as where police
credibly believe it contains a live explosive device. But reasonableness was
lacking for the warrantless search of Lewis’s trunk because there were
obvious and plainly less intrusive methods for addressing the deputy’s
concern that someone could gain access to firearms that might be located
there.9 The simplest solution to address this perceived danger, while also
protecting Lewis’s privacy interests, would have been for one of the three on-
scene deputies to watch the car while the others attempted to locate Lewis
inside the clinic so that he could be asked to secure the trunk. Indeed,
locating Lewis is precisely what the deputies successfully accomplished in
9 We likewise reject any suggestion that a search of Lewis’s trunk would
have been reasonable under the exigent circumstances exception to the
warrant requirement. Considering the presence of multiple deputies on the
scene, there was no risk that the car would be moved or that Lewis or
someone else would access the trunk and take a weapon officers thought it
might contain.
18
just a few minutes, but only after Eastwood opened the trunk and found the
firearms.
In short, even assuming that the community caretaking function might
in some circumstances permit a warrantless search for suspected firearms in
the unsecured trunk of an unoccupied car in a public place, the search here
was unreasonable because sheriff’s deputies made no attempt to first locate
the driver of the vehicle before opening the trunk.
DISPOSITION
The judgment is reversed. The matter is remanded with directions to
(1) vacate the order denying Lewis’s suppression motion and enter a new
order granting it; (2) permit Lewis to withdraw his guilty plea by appropriate
motion within 30 days after this opinion becomes final.
DATO, J.
I CONCUR:
KELETY, J.
19
O’Rourke, J., Dissenting.
I respectfully dissent. Sheriff’s deputies called to a public medical
facility parking lot came upon Lewis’s unoccupied, locked vehicle with a
partially open trunk lid. Shooting targets, high-powered assault rifle
ammunition, a knife and other shooting paraphernalia were in plain view on
the front passenger seat. One deputy peered into the trunk and saw a
tactical vest akin to those worn by police. Was the deputy’s decision to search
the open trunk without first obtaining a warrant reasonable under the
Fourth Amendment? In my view, the obvious answer is yes. This is so
because (1) Lewis had no expectation of privacy in the open trunk of his car
parked in a public lot; and (2) the search was justified by the automobile or
exigency exceptions to the warrant requirement. Reviewing courts may
affirm a suppression ruling if it is correct on any theory, even if the lower
court’s reasoning was incorrect. (People v. Perez (2026) 119 Cal.App.5th 345,
358; People v. Hall (2020) 57 Cal.App.5th 946, 952.) I cannot agree with the
majority’s approach, which elects to improperly reject the court’s reasoned
and carefully articulated credibility findings. Thus, I would affirm the order
denying Lewis’s motion to suppress on the grounds stated above.
A warrantless search of Lewis’s trunk “would violate the Fourth
Amendment only if [Lewis] manifested a subjective expectation of privacy in
[it] that society accepts as objectively reasonable.” (California v. Greenwood
(1988) 486 U.S. 35, 39 [addressing garbage bags left on the street].) Thus, to
invoke Fourth Amendment protection, Lewis “ ‘ “must demonstrate that he
personally has an expectation of privacy in the place searched, and that his
expectation is reasonable.” ’ [Citation.] ‘ “In other words, [he] must show
that he . . . had a subjective expectation of privacy that was objectively
1
reasonable.” ’ ” (People v. Cartwright (2024) 99 Cal.App.5th 98, 102, in part
quoting People v. Ayala (2000) 23 Cal.4th 225, 255; see also People v.
Hochanadel (2009) 176 Cal.App.4th 997, 1020.) “The ‘reasonableness of a
claimed expectation of privacy depends on the totality of circumstances
presented in each case.’ ” (Hochanadel, at p. 1020.) Lewis bears the burden
of showing he had a legitimate expectation of privacy in his vehicle trunk.
(Ibid.)
I cannot agree he met this burden, and would conclude the court’s
conclusion otherwise1 is unsupported by substantial evidence. The United
States Supreme Court has long held that individuals have a reduced
expectation of privacy with respect to vehicles: “ ‘[T]he expectation of privacy
with respect to one’s automobile is significantly less than that relating to
one’s home or office.’ ” (California v. Carney (1985) 471 U.S. 386, 391; see
also Terrence Byrd v. United States (2018) 584 U.S. 395, 403; Pennsylvania v.
Labron (1996) 518 U.S. 938, 940; People v. Schmitz (2012) 55 Cal.4th 909, 919
[“Homes and cars are afforded different levels of Fourth Amendment
protection”].) That Lewis left his car unattended in a public parking lot, with
the trunk lid unlocked and ajar, rendered any expectation of privacy he may
have had in the truck area objectively unreasonable. The majority points
out that Lewis otherwise locked the car, and backed it into plants, “actions
consistent with an attempt to protect the privacy of his trunk.” (Maj. opn.,
ante, at p. 7.) But this shows only that Lewis maintained a subjective
expectation of privacy; it does not demonstrate such an expectation is
1 The court’s ruling on this point was cursory and unreasoned: “[F]irst,
the Court has to find that Mr. Lewis had a legitimate expectation of privacy
in the car; otherwise, he doesn’t have standing, obviously. The Court finds he
did have standing.”
2
objectively reasonable. It is not. For this reason alone, the order denying
Lewis’s suppression motion should be affirmed.
But I would in any event hold the officer’s search of the trunk under
these circumstances was reasonable and did not violate the Fourth
Amendment. “ ‘The touchstone of the Fourth Amendment is reasonableness.’
[Citation.] ‘The Fourth Amendment does not proscribe all state-initiated
searches and seizures; it merely proscribes those which are unreasonable.’
[Citation.] When analyzing the reasonableness of a particular search or
seizure, ‘it is imperative that the facts be judged against an objective
standard.’ ” (People v. Ramirez (2024) 104 Cal.App.5th 315, 326, quoting
Florida v. Jimeno (1991) 500 U.S. 248, 250.) “ ‘Warrantless searches “are
per se unreasonable under the Fourth Amendment” ’ ” but that principle is
subject to “ ‘ “specifically established and well-delineated exceptions.” ’ ”
(Sellers v. Superior Court (2026) 19 Cal.5th 75, 89; People v. Lopez (2019) 8
Cal.5th 353, 359.) “ ‘Whether a particular kind of search is exempt from the
warrant requirement ordinarily depends on whether, under the relevant
circumstances, law enforcement’s need to search outweighs the invasion of
individual privacy.’ ” (Sellers, at p. 89.)
One such exception to the warrant requirement is the automobile
exception. Under that exception, “ ‘an officer may search a vehicle if the
officer has probable cause to believe that evidence of a crime will be found
inside.’ ” (People v. Sellers, supra, 19 Cal.5th at p. 89; see People v. Lopez,
supra, 8 Cal.5th at p. 372; People v. Lee (2019) 40 Cal.App.5th 853, 861.)
“The exception has been justified by ‘the ease with which an automobile
might be moved out of the jurisdiction before a warrant can be obtained.’ ”
3
(Sellers, at p. 89; Lee, at p. 861.)2 A court must assess the “totality of the
circumstances” to determine whether they give rise to probable cause.
(Sellers, supra, 19 Cal.5th at p. 89; People v. Leal (2023) 93 Cal.App.5th 1143,
1151.) “Our review is limited to the facts and circumstances known to the
searching officer. [Citation.] ‘[P]robable cause [to] search exists when an
officer is aware of facts that would lead a [person] of ordinary caution or
prudence to believe, and conscientiously to entertain, a strong suspicion that
the object of the search is in the particular place to be searched.’ ” (Leal, at
p. 1151.)3
The automobile exception generally justifies a warrantless search of a
vehicle trunk “in three categories of circumstances: (1) officers have probable
cause to believe contraband or evidence of a crime will be found specifically
2 The U.S. Supreme Court originally grounded this exception in the
“ready mobility” aspect of a vehicle. (Collins v. Virginia (2018) 584 U.S. 586,
591; California v. Carney, supra, 471 U.S. at p. 390; Pennsylvania v. Labron,
supra, 518 U.S. at p. 940 [“Our first cases establishing the automobile
exception to the Fourth Amendment’s warrant requirement were based on
the automobile’s ‘ready mobility,’ an exigency sufficient to excuse failure to
obtain a search warrant once probable cause to conduct the search is clear”].)
But the U.S. Supreme court has since articulated further justification for the
“less rigorous warrant requirements” based on the lessened expectation of
privacy with respect to vehicles. (Carney, at p. 391; see also Pennsylvania v.
Labron, at p. 940.) “Even in cases where an automobile was not immediately
mobile, the lesser expectation of privacy resulting from its use as a readily
mobile vehicle justified application of the vehicular exception.” (Carney, at
p. 391.)
3 “ ‘[W]here probable cause to search a vehicle under the automobile
exception exists, “ ‘a law enforcement officer may search the vehicle
“irrespective of whether [the offense] is an infraction and not an arrestable
offense.” ’ ” ’ [Citation.] Moreover, ‘[w]here the court finds that officers have
probable cause to search, the officer’s subjective intent in performing the
search is irrelevant.’ ” (In re Randy C. (2024) 101 Cal.App.5th 933, 937.)
4
in the trunk . . . ; (2) a search of the passenger compartment reveals
contraband or other evidence generating further probable cause to search
the trunk . . . or (3) probable cause exists as to the entire car (i.e., that the
contraband or evidence of a crime will be found somewhere in the car).”
(People v. Leal, supra, 93 Cal.App.5th at pp. 1151-1152.) The question is
whether the facts “ ‘warrant a prudent man in believing’ that a firearm or
any other contraband would be found in the trunk.” (Leal, at pp. 1153-1154;
see, e.g., People v. Vodak (1980) 105 Cal.App.3d 1014, 1017 [officers’ discovery
of shotgun shells on the floor of a vehicle car and an expended shotgun shell
under it “amply supports the conclusion that the police officer not only had
probable cause to believe that [stolen] shotguns . . . were in the trunk, but
that the weapons were loaded”].) In Leal, it was not enough that officers saw
an armed juvenile on searchable probation with a firearm restriction near the
trunk of a car, or that officers received reports of juveniles armed with
handguns around a vehicle, including its trunk. (Id. at pp. 1148, 1149-1150,
1152-1153.) “Being armed while standing near or around the trunk of a
vehicle, without more, does not create probable cause to believe the weapon
will be found in the trunk.” (Id. at p. 1153.)
The circumstances are very different here. Officers saw that Lewis’s
vehicle contained shooting paraphernalia, including a target, loose high-
powered rifle ammunition and a knife. One officer spotted a tactical vest
through the gap of the partially opened trunk. While in isolation, these items
may not have been unlawful to possess, the facts in my view “would lead a
man of ordinary caution or prudence to believe, and conscientiously to
entertain, a strong suspicion that the object of the search is in the particular
place to be searched” that is, such a man would strongly suspect that the
vehicle’s trunk contained a concealed weapon, a violation of Penal Code
5
section 24500.4 Though the circumstances here are not as obvious as those
in People v. Ramirez, supra, 104 Cal.App.5th 314, in which an officer’s plain
view observation of a firearm in a car constituted objective probable cause
that the driver was committing a violation of Penal Code section 24500 (id. at
p. 328), here, the presence of shooting target, ammunition and a tactical vest
all would strongly suggest to a reasonable officer that the vehicle likely
contained a concealed firearm. That there was a probability or substantial
chance of criminal activity is sufficient. (New York v. P.J. Video, Inc. (1986)
475 U.S. 868, 877 [“ ‘[P]robable cause requires only a probability or
substantial chance of criminal activity, not an actual showing of such
activity’ ”]; People v. Diaz (2023) 97 Cal.App.5th 1172, 1178 [same;
“[p]robable cause is not a high bar”].)
“ ‘If there is probable cause to believe a vehicle contains evidence of
criminal activity, United States v. Ross [(1982) 456 U.S. 798, 820-821]
authorizes a search of any area of the vehicle in which the evidence might be
found.’ ” (People v. Hochstraser (2009) 178 Cal.App.4th 883, 902.) I would
hold under the automobile exception, the officers’ search of Lewis’s trunk was
lawful.
Finally, I would hold the search was lawful under the exigent
circumstances doctrine. (People v. Oveida (2019) 7 Cal.5th 1034, 1041.) That
doctrine “describes ‘ “ ‘an emergency situation requiring swift action to
prevent imminent danger to life’ ” ’ ”and is measured by the facts known to
officers. (Ibid.; see also People v. Thompson (2006) 38 Cal.4th 811, 818
4 “Conviction under [Penal Code section 24500] requires proof that the
‘defendant carried within a vehicle a firearm capable of being concealed on
the person,’ the ‘defendant knew the firearm was in the vehicle,’ the ‘firearm
was substantially concealed,’ and the ‘vehicle was under the defendant’s
control or direction.’ ” (People v. Aguilar (2016) 245 Cal.App.4th 1010, 1017.)
6
[presumption of unreasonableness of a search can be overcome by the “risk of
danger to the police or to other persons”].) “[E]xigent circumstances may
exist where there is probable cause to believe a crime has been committed but
‘an emergency leaves police insufficient time to seek a warrant.’ ” (Ovieda, at
p. 1041.) “[T]he exigent circumstances exception applies to situations
requiring prompt police action.” (Id. at p. 1042.)
Such circumstances are present here, where, based on their view of the
contents of Lewis’s car and the tactical vest in his trunk, officers had
probable cause to believe concealed guns would be present in the unlocked
and open trunk of Lewis’s car. Any reasonable officer would conclude there
was an urgent and exigent need to open and search it to secure them from
access by Lewis or the public.
My conclusions eliminate the need to address the credibility of the
officer who peered into the trunk and whether he saw the butt of a firearm or
the magazines in the vest. This was a topic of the parties’ arguments, and
the court made a very carefully reasoned credibility finding based on its view
of the officer’s certainty when he initially testified. But the majority second
guesses this finding and replaces it with its own, contradicting settled law
that the trial court is the exclusive judge of credibility, requiring we give
deference to such findings. (People v. Elliott (2012) 53 Cal.4th 535, 585
[conflicting testimony or “even testimony which is subject to justifiable
suspicion” does not require reversal, “[u]nless it describes facts or events that
are physically impossible or inherently improbable”].) The court found
“unqualified” and “very credible” the officer’s initial sworn testimony that
he saw what appeared to be the butt of a gun and magazines in the vest,
and observed the officer never admitted he was mistaken on the point.
It expressly found the officer’s first statement was “most accurate” and
7
believable. It is not the province of this court to reach its own credibility
finding based on its review of the evidence, where the officer’s testimony is
not impossible or inherently incredible.
O’ROURKE, Acting P. J.
8
Vous vous demandez comment ce texte s’applique à votre situation ?
Consultation gratuite, sans engagement
Décrivez votre situation. Notre équipe vous recontactera par e-mail pour votre consultation.
Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude
Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.