CourtListener 10865065•People v. Shumate CA1/2
Texte intégral
Filed 5/27/26 P. v. Shumate CA1/2
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or
ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION TWO
THE PEOPLE,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
A173335
v.
BENJAMIN THOMAS SHUMATE, (Sonoma County
Super. Ct. No. SCR-756294-1)
Defendant and Appellant.
Benjamin Thomas Shumate pleaded guilty to multiple sexual and other
offenses. His appointed appellate counsel has filed a brief pursuant to People
v. Wende (1979) 25 Cal.3d 436 (Wende), in which he raises no issue and asks
this court for an independent review of the record. Shumate has filed
a supplemental brief.
We have reviewed the issues raised in Shumate’s supplemental brief
and find none meritorious. Having examined the entire record in accordance
with Wende, we agree with counsel that there are no arguable issues
requiring further briefing. Accordingly, we affirm.
1
BACKGROUND
I.
Factual Background
In August 2022, Jane Doe 1 was 16 years old. She had been texting
with a man who contacted her through an “app” and he was pressuring her to
meet him because he wanted to have sex with her. She told him she was 16.
On the night of August 14, Shumate picked her up. They went to his
office, stopping on the way at a liquor store where he bought alcohol that
Doe 1 drank. At the office, Shumate took Doe 1’s clothes off, then took his
jeans off and “start[ed] to have sex with” her. When it ended, she tried to
leave but he stopped her, putting his hands on her throat, pushing her
against the wall and taking her phone away. She begged him to give it back
and when he did, she called the police. A police officer who responded to the
office location testified that Doe 1 told him she and Shumate met for the
purpose of engaging in sexual acts that she would be paid for.
Jane Doe 2 met Shumate in July 2022, when she was 15 years old. She
testified that she was struggling with drug addiction at the time, abusing any
drug she could obtain and communicating with random people on Snapchat
in order to get drugs. Someone who contacted Doe 2 told her she knew a
person who could get Doe 2 a free “vape,” and that the person needed to know
she was 18 years old or older. Doe 2 texted the number she was given and
had a conversation with the person. She told him she was 19 years old and in
junior college.
Shumate picked Doe 2 up near her house, drove to a nearby
neighborhood and parked. He kissed her, then pulled down his pants and she
sucked his penis. She got the vape in return and he drove her home. In
subsequent text messages, Doe 2 told Shumate she did not want to have sex
2
with him and he told her he needed “more than just head” in order for her to
get drugs from him. Doe 2 met Shumate seven or eight times in July and
August. These incidents were “all kind of the same”: He would pick her up
and drive her to his office, where he raped her on a couch. He raped her
approximately six times.
Doe 2 testified that Shumate took advantage of the fact that she was
struggling with drug addiction and bribed her with money or drugs; he gave
her “mostly weed” and gave her money for “harder drugs.” She felt “gross”
and two or three times had to stop and throw up, but she did what she had to
do to get the drugs. On one occasion Shumate forcibly orally copulated Doe 2,
holding her down on the couch with his hands on her thighs. The incidents
ended when her best friend told her mother, who told Doe 2’s mother; Doe 2’s
parents contacted the police and Doe 2 went to a psychiatric hospital.
II.
Procedural Background
An information filed on November 22, 2023, charged Shumate with a
total of 15 felony offenses committed against two victims. With regard to
Jane Doe 1, Shumate was charged with seven offenses: Trafficking a minor
for a sex act (Pen. Code,1 § 236.1, subd. (c)(1)) (count 1); assault by means
likely to produce great bodily injury (§ 245, subd. (a)(4)) (count 2); unlawful
sexual intercourse (§ 261.5, subd. (c)) (count 3); contact with a minor for a
sexual offense (§ 288.3, subd. (c)), with a prior conviction of section 288.3,
subd. (a)) (count 4); two counts of meeting a minor for lewd purposes (§ 288.4,
subd. (b)) (counts 5, 6); attempted using a minor for sex acts (§ 664/311.4,
subd. (c)) (count 7). Count 9 charged forcible oral copulation of a victim 14
1All further statutory references are to the Penal Code unless
otherwise indicated.
3
years of age or older (§ 287, subd. (c)(2)(C)) committed on or about August 7,
2022. With regard to Jane Doe 2, Shumate was charged with trafficking a
minor for a sex act (§ 236.1, subd. (c)(1)) (count 8); four counts of lewd act
upon a child (§ 288, subd. (c)(1)) (counts 10, 11, 12, 13); furnishing marijuana
to a minor over age 14 (Health & Saf. Code, § 11361, subd. (b)) (count 14);
and pandering by encouraging a minor under age 16 to become a prostitute
(§ 266i, subd. (b)(2)) (count 15). The information alleged nine aggravating
factors. (Cal. Rules of Court, rule 4.421(a)(1), (a)(3), (a)(6), (a)(7), (a)(8),
(b)(2)-(b)(5).)
Shumate pleaded not guilty and denied the allegations on
November 29, 2023. On January 24, 2024, he moved for dismissal of the
information pursuant to section 995.2 The motion was heard and denied on
March 13, 2024.
In September, October and November 2024, Shumate filed several
voluminous petitions for writ of habeas corpus, described by the trial court as
“nearly identical,” raising claims related to conditions of his confinement. He
later identified one of these as the petition he sought to proceed on and
withdrew the others. The court requested a response from county counsel on
behalf of the Sonoma County Sheriff. In an order filed on February 18, 2025,
the court addressed each of Shumate’s claims and denied the petition in its
entirety. The court subsequently reaffirmed its denial of the petition after
considering additional pleadings Shumate filed.
2Shumate argued there was insufficient evidence to charge him with
the counts related to Jane Doe 2 because her changing statements and
mental health challenges rendered her testimony unreliable, and that the
counts of human trafficking and pandering did not apply in the
circumstances of this case.
4
On March 28, 2025, Shumate pleaded guilty to counts 2, 3, 4, 9 and 14,
and admitted three aggravating factors. On April 25, 2025, he was sentenced
in accordance with the plea agreement to an aggregate term of 13 years,
consisting of the middle term of three years on count 2, concurrent middle
terms of two years on count 3, six years on count 4 and four years on
count 14, and, pursuant to section 667.6, a consecutive upper term of 10 years
on count 9. Shumate received 1,029 days of presentence custody credits.
Also on April 25, 2025, the court filed an order stating that all issues
raised in Shumate’s habeas petition had been considered and ruled on in
prior orders, specifically addressing an issue regarding alleged mail
tampering, and reiterating that Shumate had not stated a prima facie basis
for relief on any of the issues.
Shumate filed a timely notice of appeal and request for a certificate of
probable cause on May 2, 2025. The court denied the certificate of probable
cause on May 5, 2025.
DISCUSSION
I.
Wende Review
The denial of Shumate’s request for a certificate of probable cause
precludes him from arguing on appeal any issues affecting the validity of his
plea. (People v. Castelan (1995) 32 Cal.App.4th 1185, 1188; Cal. Rules of
Court, rule 8.304(b)(3).) He did not challenge the denial of his request for a
certificate of probable cause by petition for writ of mandate and may not do so
on direct appeal. (Castelan, at p. 1188.) As he was sentenced in accordance
with his plea agreement, a challenge to his sentence would constitute a
challenge to the validity of the plea. (People v. Shelton (2006) 37 Cal.4th 759,
766.)
5
Our review of the record reveals no arguable issues requiring further
briefing.
II.
Supplemental Brief
Shumate raises three claims in his supplemental brief. First, he argues
that his incoming and outgoing legal documents were lost, tampered with or
opened outside his presence while he was a pretrial detainee; his attorney
and the trial court did nothing to stop this abuse despite being notified of it
repeatedly; and as a result, he believed he could not get a fair trial and
therefore was coerced into accepting a plea agreement he did not want.
Second, he argues his convictions for the counts involving Jane Doe 2 are
invalid because they are based on Doe 2’s age, Doe 2 testified that she falsely
told Shumate she was an adult, his defense was genuine mistake as to age,
defense counsel falsely told him this was not a valid defense and, due to this
lie, Shumate was coerced into accepting the plea agreement. Third, Shumate
argues he received ineffective assistance of counsel in that, in addition to
deceiving him about his defense and refusing to address the mail tampering,
counsel refused to appeal from the denial of his section 995 motion following
the preliminary hearing, refused to assist with Shumate’s habeas petition,
told Shumate he was too busy with other trials to deal with Shumate’s case,
and urged Shumate to settle rather than go to trial by falsely representing
that Shumate’s good faith defense was not valid.
All of Shumate’s claims challenge the validity of his plea and, therefore,
are precluded by the denial of his request for a certificate of probable cause.
(People v. Castelan, supra, 32 Cal.App.4th at p. 1188.)
Nevertheless, we observe that the main premise underlying Shumate’s
challenges to the validity of his convictions and claim of ineffective assistance
6
of counsel brief is incorrect: Contrary to Shumate’s belief that he had a valid
defense to the offenses involving Doe 2 based on her representation that she
was an adult, mistake of fact as to the age of the victim is not a defense to
these crimes. (People v. Paz (2000) 80 Cal.App.4th 293, 301 [§ 288,
subd. (c)(1)]; People v. Middleton (2023) 91 Cal.App.5th 749, 766 [§ 236.1,
subd. (f)]; People v. Branch (2010) 184 Cal.App.4th 516, 518, 522 [§ 266i,
subd. (b)(2)]; People v. Lopez (1969) 271 Cal.App.2d 754, 760-762 [Health &
Saf. Code, § 11361, subd. (b)3].)
Shumate’s other main contention is based on alleged violations of his
constitutional rights with respect to confidentiality of his legal mail that he
asserted in his habeas petition but the trial court found he did not establish.
Shumate now maintains his plea was compelled by his belief that he could
not get a fair trial due to these violations, but he fails to address the trial
court’s reasons for concluding he did not show the underlying violations
occurred.
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.
3 When People v. Lopez was decided, the offense of furnishing
marijuana to a minor—currently Health and Safety Code section 11361,
subd. (b)—was defined in former Health and Safety Code section 11532.
(Lopez, supra, 271 Cal.App.2d at p. 760, fn. 1.)
7
STEWART, P. J.
We concur.
RICHMAN, J.
MILLER, J.
People v. Shumate (A173335)
8
Vous vous demandez comment ce texte s’applique à votre situation ?
Consultation gratuite, sans engagement
Décrivez votre situation. Notre équipe vous recontactera par e-mail pour votre consultation.
Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude
Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.