CourtListener 10863460•In re Isaac G. CA2/1
Texte intégral
Filed 5/22/26 In re Isaac G. CA2/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
In re ISAAC G., a Person B349677
Coming Under Juvenile Court
Law. (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. 25CCJP00309)
LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF
CHILDREN AND FAMILY
SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
LUCAS C.,
Defendant and
Appellant.
APPEAL from orders of the Superior Court of Los Angeles
County, Gabriela H. Shapiro, Judge Pro Tempore. Affirmed.
Megan Turkat Schirn, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Navid Nakhjavani, Deputy
County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
__________________________________
After the juvenile court found true allegations that
appellant-father Lucas C. sexually abused minor Jennifer G.
(born Feb. 2008)—the daughter of his then-girlfriend, S.G.—the
court assumed jurisdiction over both Jennifer and Father’s son,
Isaac G. (born Oct. 2021). 1 The court then removed Isaac from
his custody. On appeal, Father contends: (1) substantial evidence
does not support the court’s assumption of jurisdiction; and (2)
because the court should not have assumed jurisdiction, its
dispositional order was also erroneous. We find substantial
evidence supports the court’s assumption of jurisdiction and
therefore affirm.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A. DCFS Investigates a Referral
In early January 2025, respondent Los Angeles
Department of Children and Family Services (DCFS) received a
referral alleging Father had raped Jennifer in 2021 when Mother
was at work, had continued sexually abusing her since Jennifer
and Mother had moved into the same apartment complex where
1 S.G. is the mother of both Isaac and Jennifer, but Father
is not Jennifer’s father. Jennifer’s father is deceased. Mother is
not a party to this appeal.
2
Father lived five months ago, and had threatened Jennifer over
telling anyone about the abuse.
A children’s social worker (CSW) called Mother and
informed her “that a report had been generated alleging concerns
for the safety and wellbeing of her children.” Mother responded
that “her children were fine and there are no issues in her home.”
Mother said she was currently out with the children but would
return home soon.
1. Jennifer
After Mother informed the CSW she had returned home,
the CSW went to the family home and spoke with Jennifer. Upon
being asked, Jennifer stated she knew the CSW had come
because of what Jennifer disclosed to her maternal aunt (MA).
Jennifer told the CSW, “I would like to stop the case,” saying she
did not want to discuss “the incident” and did not want to get
anyone in trouble. The CSW “validated” Jennifer’s statement but
also “provided words of encouragement in addition to education
regarding the cycle of abuse, noting that if no one speaks up
about the abuse, the abuse will likely continue with possible
additional victims.” Jennifer then told the CSW that Mother and
Father met five years ago, when Jennifer was 11 years old. She
continued that, “around 2021 or 2022, when she was 14 years old,
she and a male friend her age, were hanging out in the room,”
and Father “came home to find her and her friend in the room.”
Father asked the friend to leave and, after he did, told Jennifer,
“'Do as I say and I won’t tell your mom.” Father “then began
touching her over and under her clothes.” Jennifer said, “He
touched my breast and front private (vagina) under the clothes
with his hand.” No one else was home at the time of the incident
as Mother was working, and nothing else happened.
3
Jennifer reported a second incident occurred in November
2024, before Thanksgiving. Mother had taken her phone away
and given it to Father to store. At the time, Father paid half of
her phone bill. When Mother was not home, Father asked
Jennifer to go downstairs to his apartment, and she did. 2 After
she arrived, Father told her: “Your phone is here, but stay here
with me for a little while.” Jennifer said, “He then started
kissing my neck and started touching me under my clothes on my
breast and vagina. He started kissing me on my mouth. I closed
my mouth and he kept trying to kiss my mouth. I pushed him
away, I came upstairs, showered, and started crying.” Jennifer
recounted that the incident occurred in the bedroom of Father’s
biological children, “while his two younger children ‘the girl and
the 4 year old were sleeping on the bed.’ ” Jennifer said Father
was “[g]rabbing me and pulling me towards the bed (where his
children were sleeping) and I was trying to push him away.”
Toward the end of 2024, Jennifer said she came home from
school, and Father came upstairs to her apartment (Mother was
working). Father asked if he could “get a hug” and “used that to
start taking advantage.” Jennifer told him she did not want
“this” (referring to the sexual abuse) to “keep happening” and she
did not care about the consequences. Father responded he would
“give her time to think about it” and left. He returned soon after,
and Jennifer repeated herself. Father said, “fine” and returned
her phone.
2 Jennifer and Mother lived in the same apartment complex
as Father, with their apartment upstairs from his. Jennifer
explained that, in her apartment, she shared a room with Mother
and Isaac, and Father’s adult son Rudy occupied the second
bedroom.
4
Jennifer explained she did not tell Mother about any of this
because she was scared what Mother would think of her. After
Mother had received the CSW’s phone call, she had asked
Jennifer if everything was okay. Jennifer told her that, ever
since Mother took her phone away, Father had been
“manoceandome” (fondling me). Mother seemed sad and scared.
Jennifer said she felt safe with Mother and MA but was afraid of
Father. Law enforcement then arrived to speak with Jennifer. 3
2. Mother
Before the police officers interviewed Jennifer, they
informed the CSW they had already spoken with Mother, who
3 DCFS later obtained the police report from this interview.
Jennifer had disclosed two incidents to the officers. The first
incident “occurred on an unknown date in 2022” when Mother
was not home. Father saw Jennifer had a male friend over and
told him to leave. After the friend left, Father told Jennifer, “If
you don’t do what [I] tell you I will tell your mom about your
friend.” Father then told Jennifer to sit on the bed, after which
he “placed his hand under her shirt touching her breasts. The
victim stated the suspect then pulled down her pants and began
to fondle her vaginal area with his hand for approximately 20–25
minutes. The victim stated there was no penetration.” The
second incident occurred in November 2024 after Mother had
given Jennifer’s cellphone to Father. Father told Jennifer if she
wanted her phone back, she needed to go to his apartment. After
she did, Father took Jennifer to his room and “began to take the
victim[’]s clothes off. The suspect then started to touch the
victim’s breast and fondle her vaginal area with his hands for
approximately 20 minutes. After the 20 minutes, the suspect
gave the victim her cellphone back. . . . The victim stated there
was no penetration in this incident either.”
5
denied Jennifer was ever alone with Father, or that Father had a
key to their apartment.
When asked about Jennifer’s allegations, Mother said
Father “doesn’t really come here” so she did not know when the
incidents happened, and she did not believe Jennifer’s
statements. Mother said she thought Jennifer was lying because
she did not like living in the apartment. Mother said she would
continue her romantic relationship with Father, opining that “he
is a good person and good to the kids.” Mother had been laid off
from work a few months ago, and Father had been “providing for
her and the family.” Mother agreed to temporarily move to a
relative’s house and prevent contact between Father and the
children.
3. Maternal Aunt
The CSW spoke with MA, who reported that “for some
time,” Jennifer had been sad, withdrawn, and without appetite,
and had said she hated Father. On January 2, 2025, Jennifer
disclosed the sexual abuse to MA, saying that the first incident
occurred in 2021, and that Father had threatened her over
disclosing the abuse to anyone. MA claimed Father isolated
Mother from the maternal family.
4. Father
Another CSW, investigating a “companion referral”
regarding Father’s biological children (Isaac’s half siblings),
asked Father about the allegations regarding Jennifer. Father
6
denied the allegations and accused Jennifer of falsely reporting
an uncle had sexually abused her “a few years back.” 4
5. Wendy
Ten days later, a CSW spoke with Mother’s cousin Wendy,
who described herself as a “distant aunt” to Jennifer. Wendy
lived in Los Angeles until 2022 and remembered Jennifer to be a
“friendly person.” However, when Wendy visited during the
holidays, she “observed a drastic change in Jennifer’s demeanor.
She noted the minor appeared withdrawn/depressed and her eyes
looked sad, leading her to believe that that minor Jennifer was
not doing well.” Based on her own past experiences, Wendy grew
concerned that Jennifer was being sexually abused. After Wendy
disclosed her prior experience as a victim of sexual abuse to
Jennifer and asked if anyone was hurting her, Jennifer began
crying and saying she was scared. Eventually, Jennifer reported
that on one occasion, Mother took her cellphone away and gave it
to Father to store. Father told Jennifer he would return her
phone “in exchange for him touching her.” When Wendy asked if
Father had abused her “completely, sexually,” Jennifer “affirmed,
verbalizing that ‘in the past he had.’ ” Wendy clarified Jennifer
never used the word “penetration,” but that was what Wendy
understood.
On January 30, 2025, the court issued an order removing
Isaac from Father. DCFS released him to Mother.
4 Mother later confirmed the maternal family no longer had
contact with this uncle after Jennifer’s allegations.
7
B. DCFS Files a Petition
In early February 2025, DCFS filed a petition on behalf of
Jennifer under Welfare and Institutions Code section 300,
subdivisions (b)(1) and (d), and on behalf of Isaac under
subdivisions (b)(1) and (j). 5 Counts b-1, d-1, and j-1 all identically
alleged Father sexually abused Jennifer on three occasions: once
in 2021 or 2022, once in November 2024 (while two of Father’s
biological children were in the room), and once in December 2024.
The petition also alleged that Father had threatened Jennifer not
to tell anyone of his abuse, and that Mother did not believe
Jennifer when informed of the abuse and failed to protect her.
DCFS claimed these acts endangered both children.
In mid-February 2025, Jennifer underwent a forensic
interview. A CSW in attendance summarized that Jennifer
reported two incidents of Father “touching her on her breast area
over clothes. During one of the incidents[,] he also touched her
buttocks area. She reported that during one of the incidents, he
put his hand under her shirt and rubbed her back with his hand.
She reported one of the incidents took place while in his bedroom
where his two young children were sleeping.” Jennifer also said
Father threatened her both with telling Mother that she had a
male friend in the home and with withholding her cellphone.
Jennifer stated Mother sometimes asked Father to deliver food to
her home when she was working and Jennifer was home alone.
At the mid-February 2025 initial hearing, the court found a
prima facie case for detaining Isaac from Father. Isaac remained
released to Mother.
5 Undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code.
8
C. DCFS Continues to Investigate
A dependency investigator (DI) spoke with several people
about the case.
1. Jennifer
After a DI read the petition’s allegations to her, Jennifer
stated it was untrue that Mother had not believed her, saying
Mother was just in shock when Jennifer told her. Jennifer also
said she wanted to clarify that Father “was trying to push under
my clothes, but I stopped him. . . . He started touching me over
my clothes because I had put a stop to more.” Jennifer denied
Father had ever taken off her clothes. Jennifer also said Father
had tried to kiss her and touch her buttocks, but she had backed
up and prevented him from doing so. While Father did touch her
breast, he did not touch her vagina, “just close like my thighs.”
She also confirmed that the “November [incident] was in his
apartment” and “the kids were sleeping.”
2. Mother
Mother explained it was not that she did not believe
Jennifer, she was just surprised because Jennifer had never said
anything before. Mother added she used to be out of the home for
work from around 10:00 a.m. to 5:00 or 5:30 p.m. and had never
observed anything concerning about Father’s interactions with
Jennifer.
3. Father
In late March 2025, a different DI investigating another
case involving Father spoke with him about the allegations in
this case. After being read the petition, Father told this DI:
“ ‘Nunca pasa. Todo es mentira.’ (This never happened.
9
Everything is a lie.)” When asked his opinion on why Jennifer
made these accusations, he stated his belief that Jennifer was
influenced by unnamed maternal uncles who did not approve of
his relationship with Mother—Father claimed these maternal
uncles had previously “engaged in physical and emotional
altercations against” Mother. Father asserted he had never lived
with Mother, Jennifer, and Isaac, and was now not even in a
relationship with Mother because of the DCFS investigation.
Father said he had never been alone with Jennifer and had only
“brief contact” with her once or twice weekly.
Father spoke with the DI from this case in early April 2025.
Father again denied all allegations of sexual abuse. When asked
about his relationship with Jennifer, he stated, “There was no
relationship. I knew her, say hi but I did not ask her anything
like how her days was, etc. No relationship like a father and
daughter. No hugs, just say hi.” He admitted they each had the
other’s phone number but claimed they “did not talk or
anything.” Father “denied ever bringing Jennifer food or ha[ving]
her eat at his apartment.”
4. Maternal Aunt
MA stated Jennifer had reported that Father had told
Jennifer she could trust him, and that it was okay if she had a
boyfriend—Father would be on her side as he knew Mother was
“really strict.” Jennifer claimed Father was the one who told her
to invite a male friend over, only to later tell her he would inform
Mother about the friend unless Jennifer complied with his
requests. MA opined Mother blamed her (MA) for the open DCFS
case. MA also disclosed an incident the previous year where she
and others were concerned about Jennifer and went to the family
10
home to speak with her, but Father “said it was his house” and
claimed they had no right to be there.
MA told the DI of text messages Father sent Jennifer,
calling her “love” and “mami,” which MA said she had. MA
provided the DI with screenshots showing someone addressed by
Father’s middle name 6 texting with someone addressed as
“Jenny” or “Jeni.” Father called Jennifer “[h]ermosa” (beautiful),
“mami” (mommy), “amor” (love), “preciosa” (precious or
beautiful), “bebé” (baby), and “darling.” He also called her “mija”
(a contraction of “mi hija” or “my daughter”) and told her
“medeves mi abraso dela navidad [sic]” (you owe me my hug from
Christmas). He once texted her “ven acomer [sic]” (come eat).
Father also told Jennifer he was at “la soto” (presumably a store)
and asked if she wanted anything. After he sent her some views
of landscapes, and she commented that the view was “bonita”
(pretty), he responded “Están. Bonitos [sic] los lugares pero tu
estas más hermosa” (the places are pretty but you are even more
beautiful).
5. Wendy
The DI spoke with Wendy, who reiterated the statements
she made to the CSW during the initial investigation. She added
that it was Father who told Mother to take Jennifer’s phone
away, claiming she was misbehaving.
6. Father’s Children
In May 2025, in response to a question from law
enforcement, a DI stated that one of Father’s sons Brandon C.
6 Mother had previously stated she would refer to Father by
his middle name.
11
(born Aug. 2008) denied Father ever abused him and asserted the
allegations against Father were false. Another adult daughter
also claimed the allegations were false.
D. The Court Removes Isaac From Father
At the August 2025 adjudication hearing, Father’s counsel
called both Jennifer and Mother as witnesses. Jennifer testified
she was not afraid of Father, and that Father had never
threatened her. Mother testified that, when she and Father lived
in the same apartment complex, neither had a key to the other’s
apartment.
DCFS’s counsel argued the court should sustain the
petition as to both Jennifer and Isaac, citing the evidence that
Father had sexually abused Jennifer multiple times, once when
his biological children were sleeping in the same room. Counsel
also contended Father was a member of Jennifer’s household,
pointing out that he frequented the homes where Jennifer lived,
was in a romantic relationship and shared a child with Mother,
and financially supported the family.
Jennifer’s counsel also asked the court to sustain the
petition, citing other evidence about Father’s abuse of Jennifer
and pointing out that he was frequently found in Jennifer’s home.
Counsel also asserted the text messages Father exchanged with
Jennifer contradicted his claim that he never communicated with
her. Counsel characterized the text messages as “classic
grooming behavior.”
Isaac’s counsel also asked the court to sustain the petition,
arguing the evidence showed Father sexually abused Jennifer,
which placed Isaac at risk even though he was Father’s biological
child and of a different gender than Jennifer.
12
Mother’s counsel asked the court to sustain the petition
against Father but strike the allegations against her, arguing the
evidence demonstrated she neither knew nor should have known
about the abuse.
Father’s counsel asked the court to dismiss all the
allegations against him, arguing both that the abuse never
happened and that, even if it did, Isaac was differently situated
and was not at risk from Father. Counsel pointed out the
inconsistencies in some of Jennifer’s statements and Father’s
inability to enter Jennifer’s apartment unless someone there let
him in. He also argued Father was not a member of Jennifer’s
household.
The court struck from the petition a sentence that Father
took Jennifer’s clothes off and tried to push her on to a bed, as
well as a sentence that Father threatened Jennifer over telling
anyone about the abuse. The court additionally added “over her
clothing” to the allegations that Father fondled Jennifer. As
amended, the court sustained the petition. The court found
Jennifer’s statements consistent and credible, and concluded the
abuse she described did occur. The court also found that Father
had continual and frequent contact with Jennifer’s household and
sent Jennifer inappropriate text messages. The court expressly
found Isaac to be at risk, citing evidence that two of Father’s
young, biological children were sleeping in a room when one of
the incidents of abuse occurred.
Turning to disposition, the court indicated its intention to
remove Isaac from Father and release him to Mother. Counsel
for Jennifer, Isaac, and Mother each agreed with the court’s
intention. Father’s counsel objected, again arguing Isaac was
differently situated. The court removed Isaac from Father and
13
released him to Mother, granting Father monitored visits with
Isaac and ordering Father to have no contact with Jennifer.
Father timely appealed.
DISCUSSION
In his opening brief, Father contends “there was
insufficient evidence to sustain jurisdiction as to Isaac as there
was no current risk of serious physical harm or sexual abuse by
father based on the sustained allegations.” However, he also
argues “the jurisdictional findings that he sexually abused
Jennifer M. should be reversed for insufficient evidence that the
alleged abuse placed his son Isaac at risk of sexual abuse of
serious physical harm as defined under section 300, subdivisions
(b) and (d).” And in his reply brief, he states that he “challenges
the juvenile court’s findings that he sexually abused the daughter
of Isaac’s mother, the minor Jennifer.”
Because it is unclear whether Father argues only that
substantial evidence does not support finding that his sexual
abuse of Jennifer placed Isaac at substantial risk of harm, or if he
is also arguing that substantial evidence does not support a
finding that he sexually abused Jennifer, we address both issues.
A. The Appeal Is Justiciable
Father contends the juvenile court erred when it “sustained
jurisdiction under section 300, subdivisions (b) and (d) as to
Isaac.” DCFS contends that “[b]ecause the assumption of
jurisdiction under section 300, subdivision (j), is unchallenged
and will remain despite father’s argument as to the remaining
counts, his appeal should be dismissed as non-justiciable.”
Initially, we note Father’s assertion is factually incorrect—
DCFS filed a petition on behalf of Isaac under section 300,
14
subdivisions (b)(1) and (j), not (d). Therefore, the court sustained
the petition as to Isaac under subdivisions (b)(1) and (j), not (d).
In any case, section 300, subdivision (j) provides for
jurisdiction if “[t]he child’s sibling has been abused or neglected,
as defined in subdivision (a), (b), (d), (e), or (i), and there is a
substantial risk that the child will be abused or neglected, as
defined in those subdivisions.” Thus, while Father does not
explicitly state he is challenging the court’s finding of jurisdiction
over Isaac under subdivision (j), he implicitly does so by arguing
that there is no risk Isaac will be abused or neglected as defined
in subdivisions (b)(1) and (d). We reach the merits of his appeal.
B. Substantial Evidence Supports the Court’s
Finding That Father Sexually Abused Jennifer
We review jurisdictional findings for substantial evidence.
(In re T.W. (2013) 214 Cal.App.4th 1154, 1161–1162.) “In a
challenge to the sufficiency of the evidence to support a
jurisdictional finding, the issue is whether there is evidence,
contradicted or uncontradicted, to support the finding. In making
that determination, the reviewing court reviews the record in the
light most favorable to the challenged order, resolving conflicts in
the evidence in favor of that order, and giving the evidence
reasonable inferences. Weighing evidence, assessing credibility,
and resolving conflicts in evidence and in the inferences to be
drawn from evidence are the domain of the trial court, not the
reviewing court. Evidence from a single witness, even a party,
can be sufficient to support the trial court’s findings.” (In re
Alexis E. (2009) 171 Cal.App.4th 438, 450–451.)
Here, Jennifer’s statements to the CSW, to the DI, to the
forensic examiner, as well as the statements she reportedly made
to MA and to Wendy, all support the trial court’s findings. As
15
Father himself admits, “[t]he court found the statements of
Jennifer M. to be credible, which was sufficient evidence to find
the allegations to be true.”
C. Substantial Evidence Supports the Court’s
Findings That Father’s Abuse Endangered Isaac
Father contends the court erred in assuming jurisdiction
over Isaac because Father’s “alleged sexual abuse of an unrelated
teenage minor was not dispositive that his son Isaac (age 4) was
at substantial risk of similar harm.”
In In re I.J. (2013) 56 Cal.4th 766, our Supreme Court
considered the question of “whether a father’s sexual abuse of his
daughter supports a determination that his sons are juvenile
court dependents when there is no evidence the father sexually
abused or otherwise mistreated the boys, and they were unaware
of their sister’s abuse before this proceeding began.” (Id. at p.
770.) Our high court concluded that “a father’s prolonged and
egregious sexual abuse of his own child may provide substantial
evidence to support a finding that all his children are juvenile
court dependents,” including his sons, even “when there is no
evidence the father sexually abused or otherwise mistreated the
boys,” the boys “had not witnessed any of the sexual abuse and
were unaware of it before this proceeding began,” and “[t]he boys
said they felt safe in the home and liked living with their
parents.” (Id. at pp. 770–771.)
In affirming the juvenile court’s jurisdictional findings, our
Supreme Court also considered “the violation of trust shown by
sexually abusing one child while the other children were living in
the same home and could easily have learned of or even
interrupted the abuse.” (In re I.J., supra, 56 Cal.4th at p. 778.)
The court stated that “[s]exual or other serious physical abuse of
16
a child by an adult constitutes a fundamental betrayal of the
appropriate relationship between the generations. . . . When a
parent abuses his or her own child, . . . the parent also abandons
and contravenes the parental role.” (Ibid.) Our high court
concluded that “[t]he serious and prolonged nature of father’s
sexual abuse of his daughter under these circumstances supports
the juvenile court’s finding that the risk of abuse was substantial
as to all the children.” (Ibid.)
The Court of Appeal in In re Andy G. (2010) 183
Cal.App.4th 1405 rejected arguments similar to those Father
makes now. In Andy G., the court removed two-year-old Andy
from his biological father after finding the father had sexually
abused Andy’s 12- and 14-year-old half sisters (who were not the
father’s children). (Id. at p. 1407.) On appeal, the father argued
“that the evidence showing he sexually abused Andy’s half sisters
was not sufficient to show that Andy was at substantial risk of
sexual abuse, since there was no evidence ‘of suspicious contact
between [Andy’s father] and his son Andy or between [Andy’s
father] and any juvenile or adult male.’ ” (Id. at p. 1411.) The
appellate court disagreed, finding that “ ‘aberrant sexual
behavior by a parent places the victim’s siblings who remain in
the home at risk of aberrant sexual behavior.’ ” (Id. at p. 1414,
quoting In re P.A. (2006) 144 Cal.App.4th 1339, 1347 [affirming
juvenile court order removing two sons from father who sexually
abused his daughter].) The court also found significant that the
father exposed himself to Andy’s half sister “while Andy was in
the same room (albeit apparently facing in the other direction)”
and “the court could infer, as the Department suggests, that
[father] used Andy to get [half sister] Janet to approach him so he
could expose himself to her, by asking her to take Andy to the
17
store and holding out the money to do so. This evinces, at best, a
total lack of concern for whether Andy might observe his aberrant
sexual behavior.” (Andy G., at p. 1414; see also In re D.C. (2015)
243 Cal.App.4th 41, 54 [“ ‘Also relevant to the totality of the
circumstances surrounding the sibling abuse is the violation of
trust shown by sexually abusing one child while the other
children were living in the same home and could easily have
learned of or even interrupted the abuse’ ”], quoting In re I.J.,
supra, 56 Cal.4th at p. 778.)
Here, while Jennifer was not Father’s biological child,
ample evidence in the record supports a conclusion that he acted
at least partially in a parental role. 7 He and Jennifer’s mother
were in a romantic relationship and shared a child who lived with
Jennifer. He brought food for Jennifer when Mother was working
late. He directed Mother to confiscate Jennifer’s phone when she
was allegedly “misbehaving” and was both the person who kept
the phone and the person who ostensibly decided when to return
it. And he financially provided for the family when Mother was
out of work.
Moreover, Father lied to DCFS about the extent of his
relationship with Jennifer—claiming he barely spoke with her,
when he had texted her several times, calling her “hermosa,”
7 Thus, Father’s citation to In re B.T. (2011) 193
Cal.App.4th 685 is inapposite. First, regardless of the holding of
B.T., In re I.J., issued by our Supreme Court two years later,
supersedes any contrary holding in B.T. Regardless, B.T.
concerned a mother who had a sexual relationship with a willing
15-year-old boy who lived next door, where there was no evidence
the mother treated the boy like a son. (Id. at p. 688.) Here,
Father was sexually abusing a teenaged girl with whom he acted
at least partially in a parental role.
18
“preciosa,” “amor,” and “mija” among other terms of endearment.
He also steadfastly refused to admit his abuse of her. “One
cannot correct a problem one fails to acknowledge.” (In re Gabriel
K. (2012) 203 Cal.App.4th 188, 197.) And one of the incidents of
sexual abuse occurred in the presence of two of Father’s biological
children who were sleeping in the same room and could have
woken up to see the abuse.
Father argues that his biological children denied any
sexual abuse and thus “there is no evidence that he ever behaved
in a sexually aberrant manner with his children.” But, in I.J.,
there was also no evidence that the father had behaved in a
sexually aberrant manner with his children. A court may find
jurisdiction over a minor even if the offending parent has done
nothing inappropriate to that child. (In re D.G. (2012) 208
Cal.App.4th 1562, 1573 [where father was found to have sexually
molested D.G., who was not his biological daughter, finding of
jurisdiction over L.C. was affirmed, though L.C. was his
biological daughter, and “he did nothing inappropriate to L.C.”].)
Furthermore, while the denials of his biological children may
have constituted evidence supporting a conclusion that Isaac was
not at substantial risk, “ ‘ “ ‘[w]hen two or more inferences can
reasonably be deduced from the facts,’ either deduction will be
supported by substantial evidence, and a ‘reviewing court is
without power to substitute its deductions for those of the trial
court.’ ” ’ ” (In re Misako R. (1991) 2 Cal.App.4th 538, 545.)
On this record, we conclude substantial evidence supports
the court’s finding that Isaac was at substantial risk of harm, and
thus the court did not err in assuming jurisdiction over him.
Because Father’s only argument that the court’s dispositional
order removing Isaac was erroneous is that “the jurisdictional
19
findings should be reversed for insufficient evidence,” his
challenge to the dispositional order fails as well.
DISPOSITION
The court’s orders are affirmed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED
M. KIM, J.
We concur:
BENDIX, Acting P. J.
WEINGART, J.
20
Vous vous demandez comment ce texte s’applique à votre situation ?
Consultation gratuite, sans engagement
Décrivez votre situation. Notre équipe vous recontactera par e-mail pour votre consultation.
Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude
Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.