In re J.B. CA3

CourtListener 10859013Calctapp14 mai 2026

Texte intégral

Filed 5/14/26 In re J.B. CA3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
THIRD APPELLATE DISTRICT
(Placer)

In re J.B., a Person Coming Under the Juvenile Court C102939
Law.
(Super. Ct. No. 53005496)
PLACER COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH
AND HUMAN SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent,

v.

A.B.,
Defendant and Appellant.

Appellant A.B., mother of the minor J.B., appeals from the juvenile court’s order
denying her request for placement of the minor in her custody. (Welf. & Inst. Code,
§§ 361.2, 395.)1 Mother contends there was insufficient evidence to support the juvenile
court’s finding that placement of the minor with mother would result in substantial risk of
detriment to his physical or emotional well-being. The Placer County Department of
Health and Human Services (Department) argues mother’s claim was rendered moot by a
subsequent court ruling and, in any event, the claim lacks merit. We will dismiss
mother’s appeal as moot.

1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and Institutions Code.

1
BACKGROUND
Portions of the background are taken from our unpublished opinion filed in
mother’s previous appeal. (In re J.B. (Apr. 2, 2025, C100564) [nonpub. opn.].)
The then-12-year-old minor came to the attention of the Department in September
2023 when law enforcement executed a search warrant at the home where the minor lived
with his father and his paternal great-uncle Jason. The search revealed child pornography
and drug paraphernalia that was accessible to the minor, and the minor told law
enforcement that father used illegal substances. Father was arrested and the minor was
taken into protective custody. The extent of Jason’s involvement was also being
investigated. (In re J.B., supra, C100564.)
Dependency Petition
In October 2023, the Department filed a dependency petition on behalf of the
minor pursuant to section 300, subdivisions (b), (c), and (g). Mother was named only in
the section 300, subdivision (b) allegation, which stated the minor had been removed
from mother in September 2012 due to mother’s general neglect and emotional abuse and
was ultimately placed with father, who was awarded sole legal and physical custody.
Mother had supervised visitation rights. The minor told the social worker that mother
was homeless and had not visited for several months. He also stated she was pregnant
and had a boyfriend, Ethan, who was abusive to her. (In re J.B., supra, C100564.)
Mother wanted the minor to live with her or, alternatively, with the maternal
grandmother. However, due to mother’s child welfare history, the Department could not
place the minor with her without further assessment. (In re J.B., supra, C100564.) On
October 3, 2023, the juvenile court ordered the minor detained with twice weekly
supervised visitation between the minor and each of his parents. (In re J.B., supra,
C100564.)
According to the December 2023 jurisdiction/disposition report, the minor told the
social worker that mother had mental health issues that caused her to behave in an unsafe

2
manner, and that she had a mental breakdown after learning father had cheated on her.
The minor only saw mother about once a year, and she had not visited in some time due
to her pregnancy, which she was attempting to hide from father. The minor did not want
to stay with mother as he felt she was overprotective and was trying to separate him from
father, with whom he wanted to live. Father confirmed that mother seldom visited the
minor and did not have much of a relationship with him. When mother did visit the
minor, her boyfriend Ethan had inappropriate conversations with and made inappropriate
comments to the minor, which mother was unable to recognize or acknowledge when
pointed out. The Department wanted to provide mother with services to address those
and any other concerns prior to any possible placement of the minor in mother’s custody.
However, the social worker’s multiple attempts to meet with and interview mother to
obtain necessary information were thwarted by mother’s unavailability and failure to
participate. Due to mother’s child welfare history, her minimal contact with the minor
despite ample opportunity, and her current lack of availability, the Department
recommended that mother not be considered for placement. (In re J.B., supra, C100564.)
The Department’s January 2024 report stated mother was still not making herself
available to the social worker despite requesting placement of the minor. She was
inconsistent with scheduled visits, either failing to confirm the visit or not showing up at
all. Although mother presented well when she participated in video visits with the minor,
her boyfriend Ethan, who was also present, appeared to be intoxicated. Mother
continually tried to persuade the minor to live with the maternal grandmother despite the
minor telling her he did not want to and would be uncomfortable doing so. Mother
attended a November 2023 in-person visit with the maternal grandmother, who sat
quietly, and Ethan, who appeared intoxicated and made inappropriate comments about
father being a pedophile. Mother was eventually notified that she could not bring Ethan
to future visits due to his apparent intoxication and his inappropriate behavior. Although

3
mother’s interaction with the minor was reportedly positive, the minor referred to her by
her first name and kept her at a distance during video calls. (In re J.B., supra, C100564.)
Mother reported she was living at a shelter for unhoused families but was moving
into an apartment in several weeks and would be living with her daughter and Ethan, to
whom she was now engaged. The apartment could also accommodate the minor. Mother
reported that Ethan had struggled with alcohol in the past but was working on his
sobriety, attending AA meetings daily. She denied using alcohol or drugs herself except
for marijuana, which she used for anxiety and to sleep. She reported having received
mental health treatment and medication for her bipolar diagnosis for the past 10 years and
participating in counseling for new mothers of infants and children under three for the
past three months. She planned to find a parenting program to address parenting older
children (such as the minor). (In re J.B., supra, C100564.)
Mother reported that, prior to commencement of these proceedings, she last saw
the minor in July 2023 and blamed father for interfering with her attempts to see the
minor. She claimed some of the missed visits could be attributed to the minor mixing up
dates and times. The Department recommended that mother continue to engage in
services and requested that the juvenile court dismiss the section 300, subdivision (b)
allegation against her, sustain the petition as amended, adjudge the minor a dependent of
the court, and find that placement with mother would be detrimental to the safety and
well-being of the minor. (In re J.B., supra, C100564.)
Jurisdiction and Disposition Hearing
The contested jurisdiction/disposition hearing commenced on January 5, 2024.
Mother was not present but was represented by counsel. The juvenile court granted the
Department’s motion to dismiss the section 300, subdivision (b) allegation as to mother
(leaving her unnamed in the petition) and sustained the petition as amended. Regarding
disposition, the court admitted, without objection, mother’s declaration in lieu of her
testimony, as well as a memorandum from the County of San Mateo regarding mother’s

4
behavioral health and recovery services. Mother’s declaration stated among other things
that: she was living in a family shelter but was in the process of obtaining a two-
bedroom apartment; her boyfriend Ethan had a drinking problem but had been in
treatment for four weeks, did not drink around her children, and did not currently live
with her; Ethan had never been violent towards her; she experienced financial hardship
which impacted her ability to visit the minor in person; she knew smoking in the home
was unsafe for the minor and therefore no longer allowed smoking in the home; she was
unaware of the substance abuse and “other issue” occurring in father’s home leading to
the minor’s detention; she received treatment for her bipolar diagnosis for the past 10
years; and she did not pose a safety risk to the minor. (In re J.B., supra, C100564.)
Mother’s counsel argued that mother, as the (now) nonoffending, noncustodial
parent, was seeking placement of the minor pursuant to section 361.2, subdivision (a),
noting mother had found appropriate housing, was addressing her mental health needs,
had not had any additional contacts with law enforcement, and had maintained contact
with the minor over the years prior to his detention. Counsel argued that the minor’s
preference not to live with mother was outweighed by the long-term benefits he would
gain from becoming an integrated member of a family. (In re J.B., supra, C100564.)
The Department argued that, since mother lost custody of the minor in 2013, she
had been largely absent from the minor’s life except for sporadic visits. The minor had
not seen mother in many months and, as a result of her absence in his life, the two did not
share a strong bond. The Department expressed concern about mother’s inability or
unwillingness to protect the minor from Ethan’s alcohol abuse and his inappropriate
conduct during her visits with the minor, noting that she planned to live with Ethan in the
near future. For those reasons, the Department argued it would be detrimental to place
the minor with mother. Father joined in the Department’s arguments, emphasizing
mother’s poor judgment in allowing Ethan to be intoxicated during visits with the minor.
(In re J.B., supra, C100564.)

5
The minor also joined in the Department’s arguments and added that, given the
lack of relationship between the minor and mother, the minor’s age, and the minor’s
stated feelings towards his mother, it would be detrimental to force the minor to live with
a parent “who he does not know very well or feel comfortable with,” particularly when it
was unknown how much contact the minor would have with Ethan. (In re J.B., supra,
C100564.)
The juvenile court found placement of the minor with mother would be
detrimental to his safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being. The court
ordered the minor removed from father and continued in out-of-home placement, with
reunification services and visitation for both parents. (In re J.B., supra, C100564.)
Mother’s Prior Notice of Appeal
Mother filed a timely notice of appeal of the juvenile court’s January 5, 2024
orders. She claimed the disposition order was not supported by sufficient evidence that
placing the minor with her would be detrimental to the minor’s safety, protection or
physical or emotional well-being. This court disagreed and affirmed the juvenile court’s
order. (In re J.B., supra, C100564.)
Six-Month Review Hearing
In the meantime, the six-month review hearing commenced on June 26, 2024, at
which time the juvenile court found mother made no progress toward alleviating or
mitigating the causes necessitating the minor’s placement and father made minimal
progress. The juvenile court adopted the Department’s proposed findings and orders,
including continued reunification services for both parents.
In late-2024, the Department reported concerns regarding mother’s behaviors.
Kaitlyn Paris, mother’s former psychiatric nurse from Coastside Clinic, reported she had
significant concerns regarding mother’s insight into her life, life patterns, and current
relationship. Mother had reportedly been living in a family shelter and then, in May
2024, she moved to new housing (with Ethan) where she was receiving assistance with

6
case management and counseling. However, due to serious domestic violence
perpetrated against her, Ethan was banned from the shelter. Mother opted to leave the
shelter and sleep in her car with him. Ethan had previously been violent with mother,
including striking mother while she was pregnant, and had reneged on his promises to get
clean. Mother left him several times but then reconciled and was currently denying ever
being in danger while with him. Paris described mother as “childlike,” noting she did not
have great judgment and “she needs a lot of handholding.” Paris opined that mother
could not currently care for the 12-year-old minor and a newborn and she continued to
deny intimate partner violence by Ethan.
The Department also reported that mother demonstrated an inability to care for the
minor beginning when he was two years old due to her substance abuse, intimate partner
violence, codependency, lack of stability, and lack of insight in caring for the minor’s
basic needs. Mother was not engaged in and was resistant toward services despite ample
support from the Department. She avoided addressing concerns raised by the Department
and she was untruthful about her ongoing relationship with Ethan who previously
engaged in domestic violence against her. She consistently denied any danger to the
minor or that she was demonstrating any behaviors that could lead to domestic violence
or criminal arrest while at the same time maintaining a relationship with Ethan. Mother
stated she did not want to attend child and family team (CFT) meetings. She refused to
participate in court ordered parenting classes (completing just three of six online
sessions), individual therapy, or a psychological evaluation and she would not update a
release of information for her current therapist stating she did not plan to discuss the
minor during therapy. Mother’s visits with the minor were sporadic, inconsistent, and
“not in tune with” the minor, who preferred not to have video or telephone visits because
mother did not ask him questions and tended to use the time talking about her own life.
The Department recommended the court terminate the parents’ reunification services and
set the matter for a section 366.26 hearing.

7
Mother eventually submitted to a psychological evaluation conducted by Sidney
Nelson, Ph.D. Dr. Nelson noted mother had been diagnosed with bipolar disorder many
years ago but her psychological status had stabilized with the use of psychiatric
medication and she did not exhibit any symptoms suggestive of a major mental disorder.
Dr. Nelson opined that mother’s mental health condition should not be a barrier to her
benefiting from reunification services and recommended mother participate in a
minimum of 15 individual counseling sessions addressing anxiety management, parental
responsibility, and coping skills. Dr. Nelson also recommended mother participate in a
substance abuse evaluation regarding her use of marijuana.
Twelve-Month Review Hearing
At the 12-month review hearing on December 12, 2024, mother requested
placement of the minor in her custody and termination of the dependency or,
alternatively, six additional months of reunification services. Mother informed the
juvenile court she was no longer in a relationship with Ethan and he was no longer
residing in the home. She provided documentation showing her participation in therapy
and confirmed, via the psychological evaluation report, that she was consistent with her
medication management. Mother’s counsel argued the Department failed to include
domestic violence as a component of mother’s case plan or to provide mother with
domestic violence services despite identifying that issue as a barrier to the minor
returning to mother’s home and citing it as part of the reason for terminating mother’s
reunification services.
The Department argued it provided mother with reasonable services even in the
absence of a referral to domestic violence classes and mother’s minimal and belated
compliance in services did not cure the detriment associated with placing the minor in her
care, making particular note of mother’s inconsistent visitation. The Department further
argued there was not a substantial probability that the minor would be returned to mother

8
within the statutory 18-month reunification period. The court instructed the parties to
provide additional briefing on the issues and continued the matter.
At the continued hearing on January 8, 2025, mother reported she was enrolled in
two online parenting classes scheduled to begin later in the month and was provided with
a referral and contact information for an intimate partner violence service provider, and
she indicated she would be working on finding a virtual therapist specializing in women
with a history of intimate partner violence. The Department withdrew its objection to
extending mother’s reunification services. Regarding mother’s claim of unreasonable
services, the juvenile court explained that jurisdiction was established on a finding of
sexual abuse of the minor by or while in the care of father and not because of domestic
violence in mother’s home. The court stated, “Although [domestic violence] services
were not previously ordered and although mother previously denied any interest in such
services, the Court finds that such services should be made reasonably available to
mother prior to the cessation of reunification services ....” The court continued the minor
in out-of-home placement and ordered an additional six months of services for both
parents, including domestic violence services for mother.
Mother’s Second Notice of Appeal
Mother filed the notice of appeal in the instant case challenging the juvenile
court’s January 8, 2025 order.
Eighteen-Month Review Hearing
On September 16, 2025, after the initial appellate briefs were filed in this appeal,
the juvenile court held the 18-month review hearing, at which time the court found
mother made minimal progress toward alleviating or mitigating the causes necessitating
placement of the minor, that return of the minor to either parent would create a
substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being
of the minor, and the minor’s out-of-home placement was still necessary and appropriate.
The court terminated the parents’ reunification services and set the matter for a section

9
366.26 hearing. The court also advised the parents to seek an extraordinary writ by
filing, within seven days of the date of the hearing, a notice of intent to file a writ petition
and a petition for extraordinary writ in order to preserve their right to review the court’s
order.
Mother’s Notice of Intent to File Writ Petition
Mother filed a notice of intent to file a writ petition in the juvenile court on
September 17, 2025, which notice was received by this court on September 19, 2025, and
assigned case No. C104733.2 The juvenile writ record was filed on October 13, 2025,
and the parties were notified that any petition for extraordinary writ “must be served and
filed on or before October 23, 2025” or the case would be immediately closed. On
October 29, 2025, the clerk of this court sent a letter to the parties stating that, since
mother “has not presented a petition for filing within the time specified, the above case
has been closed.”
DISCUSSION
Mother contends the 12-month review order is not supported by sufficient
evidence that placing the minor with her would be detrimental to the minor’s safety,
protection or physical or emotional well-being.3 The Department argues the juvenile
court’s now final subsequent finding of detriment at the 18-month review hearing on
September 16, 2025, renders mother’s challenge to the previous detriment finding moot,
as the court cannot grant her any effective relief. As we explain, we agree that mother’s
claim is moot.

2 The Department’s request for judicial notice of this court’s case No. C104733 is hereby
granted. (Evid. Code, § 452, subds. (d), (h).)
3 To the extent mother claims she made an oral section 388 petition that was properly
before the juvenile court “by the consent of all parties,” we reject her claim due to her
failure to assert that specific request below.

10
As a preliminary matter, mother confusingly asserts that the juvenile court’s
“implicit detriment finding” in the 12-month review order that mother was unable to
provide adequate care for the minor was unauthorized and deprived her of due process of
law because the Department did not plead or prove such basis for jurisdiction. Mother
did not object to any “implicit” findings and instead seek express findings, nor did she
raise any due process violation concerns in the juvenile court. Thus, mother has forfeited
any such claims on appeal. (In re Dakota H. (2005) 132 Cal.App.4th 212, 221-222;
Kevin R. v. Superior Court (2010) 191 Cal.App.4th 676, 686 [A party may not assert
theories on appeal which were not raised in the trial court].) Mother asks us to exercise
our discretion to consider her claim despite her conceded failure to raise the argument
below. We do so briefly, only to note that mother’s claim is misguided. It is undisputed
that the court’s amendments striking allegations regarding mother in the dependency
petition rendered mother a nonoffending, noncustodial parent thereafter. As such, the
court applied section 361.2 to determine, at disposition and the 6-month, 12-month, and
18-month review hearings, whether to place the minor with mother. Section 361.2
provides in relevant part that the court “shall place the child with the parent [who desires
to assume custody of the child] unless it finds that placement with that parent would be
detrimental to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the child.”
(§ 361.2, subd. (a).) We can find nothing in that statute, and mother does not provide any
relevant authority, which requires that the Department first plead and prove any basis for
a detriment finding as a basis for jurisdiction.
We also reject mother’s misguided reliance on Cynthia D. v. Superior Court
(1993) 5 Cal.4th 242, 253 for the proposition that, over the entire period between
disposition and the section 366.26 hearing, each and every detriment finding “including
at disposition, as well as at each review hearing … is a precondition to terminating
parental rights” and, by implication, required to be upheld on the merits, despite
subsequent related detriment findings. Cynthia D. concluded that California’s

11
dependency system comports with due process requirements because, by the time
parental rights are terminated, the juvenile court has made multiple prior findings that the
parent was unfit. (Cynthia D., at pp. 254, 256.) It does not stand for the proposition that
any flaw in one of the juvenile court’s various detriment findings or any temporary return
of the minor to the parent, during the parent’s ongoing reunification efforts prohibits the
court from considering termination of parental rights. Moreover, this appeal is not one
from termination of parental rights. In any event, mother’s claim is moot.
“A case becomes moot when events ‘ “render[] it impossible for [a] court, if it
should decide the case in favor of plaintiff, to grant [her] any effect[ive] relief.” ’
[Citation.] For relief to be ‘effective,’ two requirements must be met. First, the plaintiff
must complain of an ongoing harm. Second, the harm must be redressable or capable of
being rectified by the outcome the plaintiff seeks. [Citation.] [¶] This rule applies in the
dependency context. (In re N.S. (2016) 245 Cal.App.4th 53, 60 [‘the critical factor in
considering whether a dependency appeal is moot is whether the appellate court can
provide any effective relief if it finds reversible error’].) A reviewing court must
‘ “decide on a case-by-case basis whether subsequent events in a juvenile dependency
matter make a case moot and whether [its] decision would affect the outcome in a
subsequent proceeding.” ’ [Citation.]” (In re D.P. (2023) 14 Cal.5th 266, 276.)
Here, mother challenges the juvenile court’s detriment finding made at the 12-
month review hearing. She seeks remand to the juvenile court with directions to place
the minor in her care and hold a hearing to determine whether to terminate jurisdiction or,
alternatively, remand with directions to reconsider whether to place the minor with her
under the current circumstances and to specify a factual basis for that determination.
“ ‘[W]hen a parent has demonstrated a specific legal or practical consequence that will be
averted upon reversal, the case is not moot, and merits review is required. When a parent
has not made such a showing, the case is moot, but the court has discretion to decide the
merits nevertheless.’ ” (In re S.R. (2025) 18 Cal.5th 1042, 1052, quoting In re D.P.,

12
supra, 14 Cal.5th at p. 283.) Mother’s requested relief fails to demonstrate what, if any,
consequence would be averted. Indeed, the juvenile court has already reconsidered
whether to place the minor with her. At the 18-month review hearing, the court made a
renewed finding, based on new, more current facts, that return of the minor to mother
would be detrimental. And, as the Department aptly notes, in order to set aside the 12-
month review findings and place the minor in mother’s care, the court would necessarily
have to set aside its findings and orders made at the 18-month review hearing. But,
because mother did not file a writ petition challenging the 18-month review orders, those
orders are final and not properly before the court. (In re Amber U. (1992) 3 Cal.App.4th
871, 881; Cal. Rules of Court, rule 8.490(b)(1)(A).) Therefore, no effective relief can be
granted, and mother’s claims are moot.
DISPOSITION
The appeal is dismissed.

/s/
BOULWARE EURIE, J.

We concur:

/s/
HULL, Acting P. J.

/s/
FEINBERG, J.

13

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.