Shamiryan v. City of Glendale CA2/7

CourtListener 10857739Calctapp12 mai 2026

Texte intégral

Filed 5/12/26 Shamiryan v. City of Glendale CA2/7
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION SEVEN

NORA SHAMIRYAN, B340724

Plaintiff and Appellant, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No.
v. 23GDCV00069)

CITY OF GLENDALE,

Defendant and
Respondent.

APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of
Los Angeles County, Ashfaq G. Chowdhury, Judge. Affirmed.
Beloryan & Manukyan, Haik Beloryan and Vahe
Shakhgeldyan for Plaintiff and Appellant.
Michael J. Garcia, City Attorney, Ann M. Maurer, Chief
Assistant City Attorney, and Carl B. Arias, Principal Assistant
City Attorney, for Defendant and Respondent.

_______________________________
Nora Shamiryan tripped and fell due to a sidewalk fault
that measured 1.5 inches or less. She sued the City of Glendale.
Glendale moved for summary judgment. The trial court found
there was no triable issue of material fact on the lack of notice
and the fault was trivial as a matter of law. We affirm.

FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

A. The Underlying Incident and the Complaint
Nora Shamiryan has lived in her Glendale neighborhood
since approximately 2002 and was familiar with the area.
Shamiryan “would walk around 20 minutes to 30 minutes every
day,” taking varying routes. On the afternoon of May 24, 2022,
Shamiryan left her home to go for a walk. It was a sunny and
clear day, and she was “looking straight ahead just in a normal
fashion.” About 2:30 p.m. or 3:00 p.m., Shamiryan’s left foot
struck a raised portion of the sidewalk near 600 South Street.
This caused her to trip and fall forward onto the ground.
Shamiryan testified during a deposition that there were “dry
leaves” and “dry branches fallen, scattered around.” During the
same deposition, Shamiryan testified that there was nothing
obstructing her view of the raised sidewalk at the time of the
accident and there were no shadows covering the raised sidewalk.
In January 2023 Shamiryan filed a complaint alleging
negligence and premises liability under Government Code
sections 815, subdivision (a), 815.2, and 835 et seq.

B. Glendale’s Motion for Summary Judgment
After answering the complaint, Glendale moved for
summary judgment on the grounds that (1) the offset was too

2
trivial to constitute a dangerous condition and (2) Glendale had
no notice of the dangerous condition. In support of its motion,
Glendale submitted the declarations of Jesus Valencia, a cement
worker finisher, and Matthew Binder, a street crew supervisor,
both of whom work for Glendale’s Public Works Maintenance
Services Section, which is responsible for maintaining and
repairing Glendale streets and sidewalks. Binder oversees the
concrete operations department, in which Valencia works, and
both assist in investigating claims for damages presented to
Glendale.
Valencia stated that in November 2022 he visited the
sidewalk location where Shamiryan fell. He “identified the offset
in that area” and noted that it “did not have any jagged edges or
broken pieces.” Valencia measured “the offset at its highest
point,” which he recorded as “1 and 1/8 (1.125) of an inch,” and
took photographs. That same day, Glendale employees “applied a
patch of asphalt to the offset sidewalk to make it sloped.”
Binder also assisted in investigating Shamiryan’s claim.
Upon a request from the city attorney’s office, he reviewed
Glendale’s records in December 2022. Based on this review,
Binder found there had been no complaints, service requests,
reports of defects, or accidents relating to the sidewalk at or near
600 South Street prior to Shamiryan’s May 24, 2022 accident.

C. Shamiryan’s Evidence in Opposition to Glendale’s Motion
In opposition to Glendale’s motion, Shamiryan presented
declarations from Philip Rosescu (a forensic engineer),
photographs and measurements of the incident scene, excerpts
from two depositions of Binder, and excerpts from her deposition.
Rosescu, who was retained by Shamiryan as a “safety and
liability expert for purposes of forensically investigating” the

3
incident, conducted a site inspection of the sidewalk where
Shamiryan fell. Rosescu signed a declaration that included
photographs of the accident location after the asphalt patch was
applied. Photographs of a ruler next to the offset on top of the
asphalt patch show the height differential at three-fourths of an
inch. Photographs recording Rosescu’s attempt to measure the
maximum height differential without the asphalt patch show one
and one-half inches, approximately four to six inches from the
edge of the upraised sidewalk.
Rosescu stated that the sidewalk uplift that caused
Shamiryan’s fall presents “an abrupt height differential of 1-1/2
inch.” Rosescu cited human ambulation studies that have shown
“the minimum toe clearance of a pedestrian during normal
walking stride is approximately 0.50 to 0.60 inches.” He
explained one study correlated an “unseen one-inch (1”) height
differential to a trip occurring on almost every stride . . . .
Therefore, an abrupt height differential of 1-1/2 inch magnitude
is not trivial as it poses significant risk of causing a pedestrian to
trip and fall or misstep if the height differential is not
conspicuous and readily observable in advance.” Rosescu stated
the “subject sidewalk offset would not be readily apparent to
approaching pedestrians and given that the magnitude of the
defect was much higher than the average minimum toe clearance
of pedestrians during normal ambulation . . . could therefore
easily cause a trip event.”
Regarding the issue of notice, Shamiryan submitted a
Google Street View image of the accident location from
November 2017. Rosescu’s declaration stated: “Google Street
views show the subject height differential existed in some
capacity within the subject area at least as far back as November

4
of 2017.” The resolution of the image was limited, and there was
no evidence of the size of the differential or whether it was more
than trivial in 2017. Shamiryan also provided evidence about a
“safe routes to schools improvements project” from around
November 2017. The project included “[s]elective removal and
replacement of damaged sidewalks” and reconstruction of the
ADA ramps “in the general area” of Shamiryan’s accident.

D. The Trial Court’s Ruling
The trial court granted summary judgment for Glendale.
The court concluded that even accepting Rosescu’s measurement
of a 1.5-inch defect, the offset was trivial as a matter of law. The
court also concluded that Shamiryan had failed to show there is a
triable issue of fact on the notice requirement. The court entered
judgment, and Shamiryan appealed.

DISCUSSION

Shamiryan makes two main arguments: (1) the trial court
erred in finding no triable issue of fact regarding the lack of
constructive notice; and (2) the trial court erred in determining
that the sidewalk defect was trivial.

A. Standard of Review
“A court may grant a motion for summary judgment ‘“only
when ‘all the papers submitted show that there is no triable issue
as to any material fact and that the moving party is entitled to a
judgment as a matter of law.””” (Fajardo v. Dailey (2022)
85 Cal.App.5th 221, 225 (Fajardo); see Code Civ. Proc., § 437c,
subd. (c); Regents of University of California v. Superior Court
(2018) 4 Cal.5th 607, 618.) A defendant moving for summary
judgment on a claim on which the plaintiff bears the burden of

5
proof may satisfy its initial burden by showing that “[o]ne or
more elements of the cause of action cannot be separately
established” by the plaintiff. (Code Civ. Proc., § 437c,
subd. (o)(2).) “In other words, all that the defendant need do is to
show that the plaintiff cannot establish at least one element of
the cause of action—for example, that the plaintiff cannot prove
element X.” (Aguilar v. Atlantic Richfield Co. (2001) 25 Cal.4th
826, 853.) “‘Once the defendant . . . has met that burden, the
burden shifts to the plaintiff . . . to show that a triable issue of
one or more material facts exists as to that cause of action . . . .
The plaintiff . . . may not rely upon the mere allegations or
denials’ of his ‘pleadings to show that a triable issue of material
fact exists but, instead,’ must ‘set forth the specific facts showing
that a triable issue of material fact exists as to that cause of
action . . . .’” (Id. at p. 849.)
“‘We review a grant of summary judgment de novo and
decide independently whether the facts not subject to triable
dispute warrant judgment for the moving party as a matter of
law.’” (Doe v. Roman Catholic Archbishop of Los Angeles (2021)
70 Cal.App.5th 657, 669.) ‘“In performing our de novo review, we
view the evidence in the light most favorable to plaintiff[ ]’
[citation], and we “liberally construe” plaintiff’s evidence and
‘strictly scrutinize’ that of defendant ‘in order to resolve any
evidentiary doubts or ambiguities in [plaintiff’s] favor.’”
(O’Riordan v. Federal Kemper Life Assurance Co. (2005)
36 Cal.4th 281, 284.)

B. Glendale Did Not Have Notice of a Dangerous Condition
To establish liability, a plaintiff must show the public
entity had actual or constructive notice of the dangerous
condition. (Maksimow v. City of South Lake Tahoe (2024)
106 Cal.App.5th 514, 523-524.) Actual notice requires evidence

6
that the entity “had actual knowledge of the existence of the
condition and knew or should have known of its dangerous
character.” (Gov. Code, § 835.2, subd. (a).) The entity has
constructive notice “only if the plaintiff establishes that the
condition had existed for such a period of time and was of such an
obvious nature that the public entity, in the exercise of due care,
should have discovered the condition and its dangerous
character.” (Gov. Code, § 835.2, subd. (b).) The adequacy of the
entity’s inspection system and the length of time the condition
existed are relevant factors. (Gov. Code, § 835.2, subd. (b)(1).)
Shamiryan failed to raise a triable issue on actual or
constructive notice. Glendale presented uncontroverted evidence
that it had no prior complaints, service requests, or reports of
accidents at the location dating back to 2013. Shamiryan raised
evidentiary issues with the evidence in the trial court but does
not argue Glendale had actual notice.
Regarding constructive notice, Glendale provided evidence
of its inspection and maintenance practices, including its
response to service requests and employee reporting policies.
With this, in combination with the evidence that there were no
prior complaints, service requests, or accident reports for the
location, Glendale met its burden of showing a lack of evidence
about the amount of time the condition existed and its
obviousness.
To meet her burden to show a triable issue, Shamiryan
presented a Google Street View image of the same sidewalk
location from 2017, and her expert opined that the image shows
the sidewalk defect existed in 2017 “in some capacity.”1

1 Glendale objected to Shamiryan’s evidence on constructive
notice. The trial court sustained the objection but stated, “even if
the Court credited and admitted the Plaintiff’s evidence on

7
Shamiryan argues that “the Google Street View picture of the
pertinent site from November 2017 shows that the 1.5 inch rise
in the sidewalk existed at least 4.5 years prior to Shamiryan’s
trip and fall.” Only it doesn’t. While the image perhaps shows
some discontinuity in the sidewalk, the image is relatively poor
quality and does not show the size of any height differential.
There are no measurements or calculations. The image does not
show a discontinuity that is more than trivial.
In addition, Shamiryan provided evidence of a 2017
sidewalk improvement project in the same area. Shamiryan
argues that the Google Street View image shows the sidewalk
condition, and the project should have notified Glendale of the
allegedly dangerous condition. This argument fails for the same
reason as the Google Street View image alone—there is no
evidence that a non-trivial defect existed in 2017. And Glendale
is under no obligation to repair an offset if it is only a trivial
defect. (See Ursino v. Big Boy Restaurants (1987) 192 Cal.App.3d
394, 398 [“The duty of care imposed on a property owner, even
one with actual notice, does not require the repair of minor
defects.”].)
Heskel v. City of San Diego (2014) 227 Cal.App.4th 313 is
instructive. The plaintiff tripped and fell over a hollow metal
post cemented into the sidewalk. (Id. at p. 315.) The defendant
city moved for summary judgment for lack of constructive notice,
providing evidence of how it becomes aware of dangerous

constructive notice, the Court would nevertheless grant
Defendant’s motion on this issue, given the amorphous, nebulous,
and speculative nature of Plaintiff’s constructive-notice
argument.” Because the court considered the evidence and
neither side briefed the admissibility issue of the constructive
notice evidence, we need not address it here.

8
conditions, receives complaints, responds to such situations, and
maintains a database of the information. In addition, the city
provided evidence that the database had no report of any
dangerous conditions at the accident site. (Id. at p. 319.) This
met the defendant’s burden to show a lack of constructive notice.
In response, the plaintiff provided evidence that the post was
present for two years, including pictures of the post. (Id. at
pp. 320-321.) The court noted that the pictures were poor quality
and did not show that the condition was obvious or its size. The
court concluded that the evidence failed to create a reasonable
inference that the condition was obvious and affirmed summary
judgment. (Ibid.)
Similarly, Glendale moved for summary judgment for lack
of constructive notice, providing evidence of how the city becomes
aware of dangerous conditions, receives complaints, responds to
such situations, and maintains a database of the information. In
addition, Glendale provided evidence that the database had no
report of any dangerous conditions at the accident site. This met
Glendale’s initial burden for summary judgment. In response,
Shamiryan provided the Google Street View image and the
sidewalk improvement evidence from 2017, but neither was
sufficient to create a reasonable inference that the defect existed
in 2017 and that Glendale had constructive notice. There was no
triable issue of fact on constructive notice, and the trial court
properly granted summary judgment on the issue.2

2 Shamiryan also argues the trial court erred in determining
that the sidewalk defect was trivial. Because our ruling upholds
the judgment on the notice issue, we do not reach the trial court’s
alternative basis for summary judgment.

9
DISPOSITION

The judgment is affirmed. Glendale shall recover its costs
on appeal.

GIZA, J.*
We concur:

SEGAL, Acting P. J.

STONE, J.

* Judge of the Los Angeles County Superior Court, assigned
by the Chief Justice pursuant to article VI, section 6 of the
California Constitution.

10

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.