People v. Waln CA2/3

CourtListener 10847917Calctapp24 avr. 2026

Texte intégral

Filed 4/24/26 P. v. Waln CA2/3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION THREE

THE PEOPLE, B338799

Plaintiff and Respondent, Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No.
v. XSEVA158343

SCOTT WALN,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of
Los Angeles County, Andrew C. Kim, Judge. Affirmed.

Levine, Flier and Flier, Leonard B. Levine; Law Office
of Kiana Sloan-Hillier and Kiana Sloan-Hillier for Defendant
and Appellant.

Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters,
Chief Assistant Attorney General, Susan Sullivan Pithey,
Assistant Attorney General, Steven D. Matthews and Gary
A. Lieberman, Deputy Attorneys General, for Plaintiff
and Respondent.
_________________________
A jury convicted Scott Waln of committing a lewd act
and a forcible lewd act on two of his former sixth-grade students.
On appeal, Waln argues the trial court should have granted
his motion for a new trial based on the erroneous exclusion of
evidence, because he received ineffective assistance of counsel,
and because of the cumulative effect of the errors. We affirm.
FACTS AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
1. The charges and trial
In February 2023, the People filed an information charging
Waln with five offenses against three of his former sixth-grade
students, Briana A., Alexis L., and Mia G.1 The People alleged
Waln committed a lewd act on a child under age 14 against
Briana (Pen. Code, § 288, subd. (a))2, a forcible lewd act on a child
under age 14 against Alexis (id., subd. (b)(1)), and three lewd acts
on a child under age 14 against Mia (id., subd. (a)). The People
alleged a special circumstance that Waln committed the offenses
against multiple victims (§ 667.61, subds. (b), (e)(4)). They
also alleged aggravating circumstances that the victims were
particularly vulnerable (Cal. Rules of Court, rule 4.421(a)(3))
and Waln used a position of trust (id., rule 4.421(a)(11)).
a. The People’s evidence
The People tried the case to a jury in October and
November 2023. We briefly summarize the evidence related
to each victim. We discuss the evidence in more detail in other
sections of this opinion.

1 We refer to the named victims using their first names and
last initials to protect their privacy. (See Cal. Rules of Court,
rule 8.90(b)(4), (10).)
2 Undesignated statutory references are to the Penal Code.

2
i. Briana
Waln was Briana’s sixth-grade math and computer teacher
in 2017. Briana was failing both classes, and Waln had been
pressuring her to improve her grades. One day, Briana went
to Waln’s classroom to talk to him about her poor performance
on a recent test. Briana and Waln were alone in the classroom.
Waln walked over to the door and shut it. Without saying
a word, he walked over to Briana and grabbed her right breast
with his right hand. Briana was scared and left the room.
Briana told her friend about the incident later that day.
The friend asked Brent Parsonage—who was the school’s
physical education teacher—to talk to Briana. Briana told
Parsonage Waln was “acting weird” and “touching her.”
Parsonage asked if Waln touched her “where her bathing suit
covered.” Briana said yes and pointed to her breast. She
was crying.
After talking to Parsonage, Briana gave written statements
about the incident to the school’s principal and to law
enforcement. The school removed Briana from Waln’s classes,
but Waln continued teaching at the school.
ii. Alexis
Waln was Alexis’s sixth-grade science teacher in 2019.
Shortly before winter break in December, Alexis asked Waln if
there were ways she could improve her grade. Waln told Alexis
to talk to him after class. Alexis stayed in the classroom after
the class ended.
Once all the other students had left the classroom, Waln
closed the door and locked it. Waln sat in a chair near where
Alexis was seated. He told Alexis to unbutton his pants, which
she did. According to Alexis, Waln was wearing black pants

3
with three buttons, and there was a zipper behind the buttons.
Under his pants, Waln was wearing white and navy blue
checkered boxers. Waln took his penis out of the slit in the
boxers. Alexis had never seen a penis before.
Waln grabbed Alexis’s wrist and put her hand on his penis.
Alexis tried to move her hand away, but Waln forced her hand
to move up and down on his penis. Waln was moaning and
eventually ejaculated. The ejaculate landed on Waln’s pants
and Alexis’s hand. Waln moved closer to Alexis and put his hand
down her pants on top of her underwear. He moved his hand
from side to side on her genitals.
Waln told Alexis not to tell anyone what happened, and
he threatened to give her a failing grade. Waln told Alexis
no one would believe her and people would think she is crazy.
He directed Alexis to wash her hands in the classroom sink.
Alexis washed her hands and left the classroom. She
returned to Waln’s classroom after lunch to get her backpack.
She noticed Waln had changed his pants and shirt.
Alexis did not initially tell anyone about the incident
because she was ashamed, scared, and thought no one would
believe her. However, she wrote about the incident in her
journal.3
About two years after the incident, Alexis created a
TikTok video consisting of a collage of photographs of herself

3 Alexis and her mother searched for the journal but could
not find it. They thought it might have been lost when they
moved to another house.

4
at different ages.4 The audio—which Alexis took from another
TikTok user’s video—was a conversation between two people.
One person says, “What that man did to you in the bus has
nothing to do with your smile or your personality and it is
absolutely not your fault.” Alexis did not post the TikTok video
on the internet or send it to anyone.
In May 2022, Alexis’s mother discovered the video on
Alexis’s phone. Alexis’s mother was alarmed and asked Alexis
“where the video came from, the music, the lyrics.” Alexis said
she “got those lyrics from a song.” Alexis’s mother asked if
something bad happened. Alexis nodded her head affirmatively,
wrote “ ‘Scott Waln’ ” on a coloring book, and eventually told
her mother what happened. Alexis’s mother filed a police report
the next day.
iii. Mia
Waln was Mia’s sixth-grade teacher for two classes in 2021.
Waln made Mia feel uncomfortable in class by commenting on
the way she sat and asking her why she did not smile at him.
One time, Mia caught Waln looking at her breasts. Another time,
Waln reached over Mia’s shoulder to grab a piece of paper off her
desk, and his hand made contact with her breasts. A different
day, Mia bent over at the waist to pick up books off the floor
in Waln’s classroom. Waln walked behind her and bumped into
her buttocks twice. Mia could feel Waln’s penis against her
buttocks. The last incident occurred while Mia was standing

4 Alexis described TikTok as a smartphone application
“where people can post short videos that they make” using other
people’s material.

5
in line outside Waln’s classroom. Waln walked past Mia and
quickly grabbed her buttock.
Mia told her mother about the incidents. Mia’s mother
did not immediately report Waln because she was not certain he
acted inappropriately. However, she contacted the police after
learning Waln had been arrested in connection with Alexis’s
allegation.
b. The defense
Waln called seven witness in his defense, most of whom
testified to issues related to the incident with Alexis. We discuss
the defense evidence in more detail in other sections of this
opinion.
c. The verdict
The jury found Waln guilty of the offenses against Briana
and Alexis. It found true the aggravating circumstances and
the multiple victim special circumstance. The jury found Waln
not guilty of all three offenses against Mia.
2. Waln’s motion for a new trial
After the jury returned its verdicts, Waln filed a motion
for a new trial and a supplement to the motion. Waln argued
he was entitled to a new trial based on errors by the trial court
and defense counsel. Specifically, Waln argued the trial court
erroneously excluded evidence of Alexis’s school records and
precluded him from playing for the jury the original source of
the audio Alexis used in her TikTok video. Waln argued defense
counsel—who drafted the motion for a new trial5—erroneously
advised him not to testify, failed to call character witnesses, and
failed to present evidence that he chaperoned overnight student

5 Waln expressly waived his right to conflict-free counsel.

6
field trips without incident. Waln also argued defense counsel
should have obtained and presented more evidence showing there
was no sink in his classroom, Alexis’s description of his penis
was physically impossible, and a sheriff’s deputy claimed to have
made a mistake in a report that benefited the prosecution.
The trial court held a hearing to consider the motion,
and then issued a written order denying the motion. The court
concluded Waln received a fair trial and failed to show any error,
let alone prejudicial error.
3. The sentencing
Briana, Alexis, and Alexis’s parents gave victim impact
statements at the sentencing hearing. The court sentenced Waln
to two consecutive terms of 15 years to life. The court stated
each victim “is deserving of a separate and consecutive sentence.”
Waln timely appealed the judgment.6
DISCUSSION
1. The trial court properly denied the motion for
a new trial based on the exclusion of evidence
Waln argues the trial court abused its discretion by
denying his motion for a new trial on the grounds that the court

6 Waln separately appealed the trial court’s order denying
his motion for bail pending appeal. At Waln’s request, we
consolidated the two appeals. While the consolidated appeal
was pending, Waln filed a motion in this court seeking bail
pending appeal. We denied Waln’s motion without prejudice
in March 2025, explaining, “Waln has not demonstrated that the
trial court abused its discretion, unjustifiably denied his motion
for bail, or shown by clear and convincing evidence that he must
be granted bail on appeal.” Waln does not address the bail issue
in his opening brief on appeal, which he filed in May 2025.
Therefore, we do not discuss it.

7
improperly excluded relevant evidence. Waln contends the
trial court should have allowed him to question witnesses about
information contained in Alexis’s school records. He also
contends the court should have allowed him to play for the jury
video of two scenes from a television show that was the original
source of the audio in Alexis’s TikTok video.
a. Standard of review
“Except as otherwise provided by statute, no evidence
is admissible except relevant evidence. (Evid. Code, § 350.)
Relevant evidence is evidence ‘having any tendency in reason to
prove or disprove any disputed fact . . . .’ (Id., § 210.) The trial
court is vested with wide discretion in determining the relevance
of evidence. [Citation.] The court, however, has no discretion
to admit irrelevant evidence. [Citation.] ‘Speculative inferences
that are derived from evidence cannot be deemed to be relevant
to establish the speculatively inferred fact in light of Evidence
Code section 210, which requires that evidence offered to prove
or disprove a disputed fact must have a tendency in reason for
such purpose.’ ” (People v. Babbitt (1988) 45 Cal.3d 660, 681.)
We review a trial court’s exclusion of evidence—including
for lack of relevance—for an abuse of discretion. (See People
v. Holmes, McClain and Newborn (2022) 12 Cal.5th 719, 766.)
We may not disturb a trial court’s ruling “except on a showing
the trial court exercised its discretion in an arbitrary, capricious,
or patently absurd manner that resulted in a manifest
miscarriage of justice [citation].” (People v. Rodriguez (1999)
20 Cal.4th 1, 9–10 (Rodriguez).)
“ ‘A trial court has broad discretion in ruling on a motion
for a new trial, and there is a strong presumption that it properly
exercised that discretion. “ ‘The determination of a motion for a

8
new trial rests so completely within the court’s discretion that its
action will not be disturbed unless a manifest and unmistakable
abuse of discretion clearly appears.’ ” ’ ” (People v. Fuiava (2012)
53 Cal.4th 622, 729–730.)
b. Alexis’s school records
i. Background
Before trial, the prosecutor moved to exclude a document
from Alexis’s school records, which the parties refer to as the
“school logs.” The document consists of 12 log entries, the
substance of which we discuss below. The trial court ruled
defense counsel could not “unilateral[ly]” introduce the school
logs into evidence, but he could use them for impeachment or
rebuttal if relevant. Defense counsel agreed with the court’s
ruling.
During trial, Alexis’s mother testified that she noticed
changes in Alexis’s behavior in late February and early March
2020, before the school shut down for the pandemic. The
prosecutor asked if the “changes were due to the fact that
Mr. Waln had touched [Alexis] inappropriately.” The court
sustained defense counsel’s objection.
On cross-examination, the prosecutor objected when
defense counsel asked Alexis’s mother, “[W]ere you aware of . . .
contact that [Alexis] had had in school with the counselor’s office,
and other issues that were going on during that time period?”
During a sidebar, the prosecutor noted defense counsel’s question
implicated information contained in the school logs. Defense
counsel argued the logs impeached testimony that Alexis’s
behavior changed a few months after the incident with Waln.
Counsel asserted the logs also were relevant to show Alexis

9
had opportunities during “interventions” at school to disclose
Waln’s abuse, but she failed to do so.
The court sustained the prosecutor’s objection. The court
noted Alexis’s mother testified the behavioral changes occurred
in February or March 2020, yet many of the incidents counsel
wanted to question her about took place much later. The court
also stated Alexis’s mother was not the proper witness to
testify about opportunities to disclose the abuse to counselors
or therapists. The court agreed to revisit the issue during
Alexis’s testimony. After the sidebar, defense counsel did
not ask Alexis’s mother any questions about the school logs.
Defense counsel raised the issue again while cross-
examining Alexis. Counsel asked the court to allow him
to question Alexis about entries suggesting she had talked
to school counselors or that counselors were available to her.
Counsel argued “the jury has the right to know that . . . [Alexis]
had her own issues that she went to counselors about, unrelated
to this case, and that counselors were available there for her
to see and talk to if she had any complaints against Mr. Waln.”
The court ruled defense counsel could not question Alexis
about interactions with counselors “unless you can represent
to me that something in those logs indicated that she was given
the opportunity, or was asked, or there was some questioning
regarding the subject matter of inappropriateness by staff,
teachers, or by Mr. Waln, specifically.” Defense counsel did
not make an offer of proof and did not question Alexis about
the school logs.
In his motion for a new trial, Waln argued the trial court
should have allowed him to question witnesses about the school
logs. According to defense counsel, the logs were relevant to

10
explain Alexis’s mother’s testimony regarding Alexis’s change
in behavior.7 Counsel argued the logs also help to explain why
Alexis disclosed Waln’s abuse years after the incident.
The trial court discussed the relevant log entries in detail
in its order denying the motion for a new trial. The court
concluded it properly excluded the school logs from evidence.
ii. Analysis
On appeal, Waln argues the trial court should have
allowed him to question witnesses about log entries on four
topics: (1) Alexis’s access to counseling services; (2) Alexis’s
accusation that another student slapped and hugged her without
consent; (3) Alexis’s violation of the school’s phone policy; and
(4) Alexis’s participation in a video production class.8 Waln
contends the entries on these topics were relevant for a variety
of purposes, including to impeach Alexis’s preliminary hearing
testimony, explain her behavioral changes, show a motive to

7 Counsel argued specifically that the court should have
allowed him to question witnesses about a log entry from
January 2020 stating Alexis “ ‘wrote an inappropriate story
on GoogleDocs.’ ” Waln does not meaningfully address that
entry on appeal, so we do not discuss it.
8 To the extent Waln argues the court should have allowed
him to question witnesses about entries concerning other topics,
he forfeited the arguments by failing to support them with
meaningful analysis. (See People v. Stanley (1995) 10 Cal.4th
764, 793 [appellate courts need not consider general assertions
in briefs unsupported by specific argument and citation to
relevant authorities]; In re S.C. (2006) 138 Cal.App.4th 396, 408
[“When a point is asserted without argument and authority
for the proposition, ‘it is deemed to be without foundation and
requires no discussion by the reviewing court.’ ”].)

11
fabricate allegations, rebut the prosecution’s timeline, and
contextualize the TikTok video.9
Counseling services. Waln argues the trial court should
have allowed him to question witnesses about log entries
that showed Alexis received, or had access to, counseling
services. There are three log entries that address the issue.
A September 16, 2020 entry states, “Called home and talked to
dad first then to Alexis. She said she had talked to her parents
about her feelings of not belonging or of taking her life. She had
no plans but just had some feelings about it. I talked to dad
again and asked if we could provide counseling, he will come
on Monday to fill out paperwork (counseling through NLMUSD).”
A September 18, 2020 entry states, “referred to school counselor.”
A December 10, 2021 entry states, “Student was given counseling
and check-ins will be provided.”
Waln contends the entries are relevant because they
contradict Alexis’s testimony at the preliminary hearing.
Specifically, he points to Alexis’s testimony that she did not
tell anyone about Waln’s abuse for “about three” years. Defense
counsel asked, “[D]uring that whole time, did you ever speak

9 As Waln seems to acknowledge, he did not make most
of these arguments in the trial court, which forfeits the issues
on appeal. (See Evid. Code, § 354; People v. Ramos (1997) 15
Cal.4th 1133, 1178 [defendant’s failure to make offer of proof
in the trial court forfeited argument on appeal that the court
improperly excluded evidence].) Nevertheless, we will consider
the arguments on the merits given Waln’s contention—albeit
cursory—that defense counsel’s failure to make the arguments
below constitutes ineffective assistance of counsel.

12
to school counselors or therapists or anyone about other things?”
Alexis responded, “No.”
Contrary to Waln’s contentions, the log entries were
not admissible solely to impeach Alexis’s preliminary hearing
testimony. Alexis’s preliminary hearing testimony was not
in evidence at trial, and neither party sought to admit it. Nor
did Waln have the right to question Alexis on collateral matters
solely for the purpose of eliciting testimony to be contradicted.
(See People v. Contreras (2013) 58 Cal.4th 123, 154.)
There is no merit to Waln’s suggestion that the court
should have allowed him to use the entries to impeach testimony
concerning Alexis’s behavioral changes. As the trial court
repeatedly explained, Alexis’s mother testified that Alexis’s
behavior changed in February and March 2020. The counseling
log entries concerned incidents that took place in September 2020
and December 2021. Those entries do not impeach testimony
about behavioral changes in early 2020.
We also disagree with Waln to the extent he argues the
entries were relevant to show Alexis had opportunities to disclose
the abuse earlier. Alexis never claimed she failed to disclose
the abuse for lack of opportunity. Instead, she testified she was
ashamed and scared, and thought no one would believe her.
The fact that Alexis was in counseling for other issues does not
contradict that testimony.
Waln argues the trial court’s ruling was arbitrary because
the court did not restrict him from asking Mia about her
counseling sessions. We disagree. Mia’s counseling sessions
took place around the time of the alleged incidents and resulted
in the school transferring her out of Waln’s class. In contrast,
there is nothing even to suggest Alexis’s sessions concerned Waln

13
in any way. Given that distinction, the court’s ruling was not
“arbitrary, capricious, or patently absurd.” (Rodriguez, supra,
20 Cal.4th at pp. 9–10.) Accordingly, Waln has not shown the
trial court erred on this ground.
Incident with another student. Waln argues the trial court
should have allowed him to question witnesses about log entries
from December 2021 concerning an incident between Alexis
and another student. According to the entries, Alexis reported
that another student slapped her in the face and hugged her
“unwantedly and made her uncomfortable.” Alexis’s mother
reportedly told the school “her daughter is afraid of the student
and it has caused her to become ill and to have anxiety.” Another
entry states, “not able to find witnesses. Action: Student was
given counseling and check-ins will be provided.”
Waln argues these entries were relevant to show Alexis
had a “pattern of untruthfulness” in the month of December
and “lent credence to the defense argument that Alexis had
a propensity to fabricate accusations.” We disagree. The
entries do not state, or even suggest, that Alexis fabricated
the accusation against the other student. No reasonable juror
could have reached that conclusion had the court allowed Waln
to question witnesses about the log entries.
Nor is there merit to Waln’s suggestion that these entries
would have rebutted an inference that his abuse caused Alexis’s
behavioral changes. As we noted above, Alexis’s mother testified
that the behavioral changes occurred in early 2020. The incident
with the other student occurred in 2021. Thus, the incident
with the student could not have caused the behavioral changes.
Waln suggests the entries were relevant because of their
proximity to Alexis’s creation of the TikTok video. As best we

14
can tell, Waln’s contention is the jury could have found Alexis
created the TikTok video in response to the incident with the
student but concealed that fact by fabricating allegations against
Waln. His argument lacks merit. According to the log entries,
the assistant principal met with Alexis and her mother to discuss
the incident with the student around the time it occurred. It is
not clear, then, what motive Alexis would have had to hide from
her mother a connection between the incident and the TikTok
video. Waln suggests none. On this record, no reasonable juror
could have accepted Waln’s theory. Accordingly, he has not
shown the trial court erred on this ground.
Phone use during school. Waln argues the trial court
should have allowed him to question witnesses about three log
entries concerning Alexis’s use of a phone during school. An
August 2021 entry states, “student using phone during school
hours. First offense, warning.” A September 2021 entry states,
“Student was using the phone during school hours. 2nd offense.
Parent Pick up.” An October 2021 entry—entitled “Cell phone”—
states, “2nd offense, parent pick up.”
Waln argues the trial court should have allowed him to
ask Alexis’s mother whether the phone violations involved Alexis
accessing TikTok during school. He also suggests it is possible
Alexis was watching explicit sexual content on her phone. No
reasonable juror could have reached either conclusion based on
the log entries, which state only that Alexis was using a phone
during school hours. Waln’s assertions otherwise are pure
speculation. He has not shown the trial court erred on this
ground.
Video production class. Waln argues the trial court should
have allowed him to question witnesses about two log entries

15
referring to a video production class. An August 19, 2020
entry states, “Mom called and said Alexis did not want Video
Production Class.” An entry from the next day states, “[L]eft
a message for mom this morning regarding her concern over
Alexis being in the video production class.”
According to Waln, these entries are relevant because—
when considered with evidence that Alexis did not immediately
tell her mother about the source of the audio she used in her
TikTok video—they suggest Alexis “may not have been allowed
to make or view TikTok videos.” Once again, Waln’s argument
relies on baseless speculation. No reasonable juror could have
reached that conclusion based on the log entries, even when
considered with all the other evidence presented at trial. In
any event, Waln fails to explain why it would have been relevant
that Alexis was not allowed to make or view TikTok videos.
Accordingly, he has not shown the court erred on this ground.
c. The Sex Education video clips
i. Background
The original source of the audio in Alexis’s TikTok video
is a “British teen sex comedy-drama” television show called
Sex Education. The audio came from a scene in which a therapist
and a young woman discuss a sexual assault. The show depicted
the sexual assault in a separate scene. According to the trial
court, that scene showed a “young woman riding a crowded bus
being ejaculated on by a male passenger.” In the therapy scene,
the therapist says, “ ‘What that man did to you on the bus is
not your fault and has nothing to do with your smile or your

16
personality and it’s only about him and it is absolutely not your
fault.’ ”10
Before trial, the People asked the court to order the defense
not to mention the name Sex Education in front of the jury. The
prosecutor argued it would be prejudicial to mention the name
because the jury might believe Alexis watched a show related to
the allegations. Defense counsel said he planned to ask Alexis
general questions about the source of her TikTok video without
“going into Sex Education or anything.” Counsel said he “would
only ask to show her the actual video from the Sex Education
show if she denies this had anything to do with another video
or anything and that she just made this up herself, but I would
seek permission of the court first.” The court agreed with defense
counsel’s approach. The court noted that, if other issues with
the video were to arise at trial, it would hold a hearing to resolve
them if necessary.
During trial, the prosecutor asked Alexis to describe her
process of creating the TikTok video. Alexis said she “was on
TikTok, and [she] heard that sound from another video that
someone had posted.” The other video had photographs, but
Alexis could not remember what they were. Alexis “listened to
the lyrics” and decided to make her own video using the same
audio. Alexis included subtitles on her video, in which she
changed the word “bus” to “room.”
On cross-examination, Alexis denied seeing “that video that
had the word ‘bus’ on it.” She also denied seeing “any video at all

10 Alexis used an edited version of the audio from this scene
in her TikTok video. In Alexis’s video, the person says: “What
that man did to you in the bus has nothing to do with your smile
or your personality and it is absolutely not your fault.”

17
showing someone ejaculating on a bus onto a person.” Defense
counsel asked Alexis if she took the audio “from another video,
and just changed it by changing some of the words, and putting
your photos on it, as opposed to the photos that were on the video
you saw on TikTok.” Alexis replied yes and said she did not know
“where that [other] video came from.” Counsel did not mention
Sex Education or attempt to play for the jury any scenes from
the show.
In his motion for a new trial, Waln argued for the first time
that the court should have allowed him to play for the jury video
clips from Sex Education. Waln argued two scenes from the show
were relevant: (1) the therapy scene that was the original source
of the audio in Alexis’s TikTok video; and (2) the scene depicting
the sexual assault on the bus. According to defense counsel,
he realized only after the trial that “Alexis likely fabricated her
allegations against Waln after viewing” clips from the show.
Counsel asserted he did not explore the issue earlier given the
court’s pretrial ruling “disallowing such questioning unless
Alexis first admitted to having viewed” Sex Education.
The trial court concluded neither scene was admissible.
The court explained the videos were irrelevant because Alexis
testified she never saw the bus scene in Sex Education, and her
allegations against Waln were not sufficiently similar to the
sexual assault depicted in the show. The court noted the sexual
assault in the show occurred in public, the victim disclosed
the assault to a therapist, the perpetrator was a stranger
to the victim, and the perpetrator’s penis was never shown.
ii. Analysis
On appeal, Waln argues the trial court abused its
discretion to the extent it determined video clips from Sex

18
Education are irrelevant. He contends the court’s ruling “denied
the defense the opportunity to substantiate their argument that
these videos were a source of inspiration for Alexis’[s] own video.”
At the outset, Waln forfeited these arguments by failing
to make them during trial. Waln did not seek to play the videos
for the jury. Instead, he raised the issue for the first time in
his motion for a new trial, which was untimely. (See Evid. Code,
§ 354; People v. Lucas (1995) 12 Cal.4th 415, 462 [defendant
forfeited evidentiary issue raised for the first time in a motion
for a new trial].)
Even if we were to overlook the forfeiture, we would reject
Waln’s argument on the merits. Although it is undisputed that
Alexis used audio from the show Sex Education in her TikTok
video, she testified she had not seen the video that was the
original source of the audio. Alexis testified she got the audio
from another TikTok user’s video and did not know the source
of the audio in that video. Waln points to nothing in the record
even to suggest otherwise. Nor does Waln challenge the trial
court’s observation that the “only similarity between the [bus]
video . . . and Alexis’[s] sexual assault was that they both involve
an act of masturbation; in just about every other way, the two
are different.” Given the lack of similarities, no reasonable juror
could have inferred Alexis “derived her knowledge from the
Sex Education videos,” as Waln contends. The trial court did
not abuse its discretion when it denied the motion for a new trial
on this ground.
2. The trial court properly denied the motion for a
new trial based on ineffective assistance of counsel
Waln argues the trial court should have granted his motion
for a new trial because he received ineffective assistance of

19
counsel in violation of the Sixth Amendment to the United States
Constitution.11 According to Waln, his counsel’s performance
was constitutionally deficient in three respects: (1) counsel failed
to present evidence that a sheriff’s deputy admitted making
a mistake in a report; (2) counsel failed to present evidence
definitively proving he is circumcised; and (3) counsel failed
to present evidence proving there was no working sink in
Waln’s classroom. We address each issue in turn.
a. Standard of Review
While ineffective assistance is usually most appropriately
decided in a habeas corpus proceeding, a defendant may raise the
issue as a ground for a new trial. (People v. Hoyt (2020) 8 Cal.5th
892, 958 (Hoyt).) If the court can determine the effectiveness
issue on a new trial motion, it should rule to expedite justice.
(Ibid.)
“To make out a claim that counsel rendered constitutionally
ineffective assistance, ‘the defendant must first show counsel’s
performance was deficient, in that it fell below an objective
standard of reasonableness under prevailing professional norms.
Second, the defendant must show resulting prejudice, i.e.,
a reasonable probability that, but for counsel’s deficient
performance, the outcome of the proceeding would have been
different.’ [Citation.] To make out an ineffective assistance claim
on the basis of the trial record, the defendant must show ‘(1) the
record affirmatively discloses counsel had no rational tactical

11 In passing, Waln asserts defense counsel’s performance
also violated his “right to a fair trial, . . . to a reliable verdict and
to due process and fundamental fairness under the California
Constitution and the Sixth and Fourteenth Amendments to the
United States Constitution.”

20
purpose for the challenged act or omission, (2) counsel was asked
for a reason and failed to provide one, or (3) there simply could
be no satisfactory explanation. All other claims of ineffective
assistance are more appropriately resolved in a habeas corpus
proceeding.’ ” (Hoyt, supra, 8 Cal.5th at p. 958; see Strickland
v. Washington (1984) 466 U.S. 668, 687.)
The United States Supreme Court has cautioned that,
“[a]fter an adverse verdict at trial even the most experienced
counsel may find it difficult to resist asking whether a different
strategy might have been better, and, in the course of that
reflection, to magnify their own responsibility for an unfavorable
outcome. Strickland, however, calls for an inquiry into the
objective reasonableness of counsel’s performance, not counsel’s
subjective state of mind.” (Harrington v. Richter (2011) 562
U.S. 86, 109–110.)
b. Impeachment of Deputy Meredith
i. Background
A contested issue at trial was the accuracy of Alexis’s
description of Waln’s penis during her interviews with law
enforcement. Deputy Jacob Meredith—who was a patrol deputy
at the Norwalk sheriff’s station—conducted the first law
enforcement interview of Alexis concerning the incident with
Waln. In a report summarizing the interview, Deputy Meredith
wrote Alexis described Waln’s penis as follows: “seven inches,
uncircumcised, dirty blonde pubic hair and the head of his penis
was pink.”
Detective Larry Flores—who was the lead investigator
on the case—interviewed Alexis sometime after Deputy Meredith.
According to Detective Flores’s report of that interview, Alexis
said “there was skin covering [Waln’s penis], but when she had

21
her hand on it and moved her hand down (or towards his body)
the excess skin would move down as well exposing the tip of
his penis. When her hand moved in an upward movement,
the excess skin would cover the tip of his penis.”
Asked to describe Waln’s penis at the preliminary hearing,
Alexis said “it had like a—like, I don’t know the word—a hood or
something? Like, he was putting a hand up, just like something
covered the tip and it went down again.” On cross-examination,
she agreed that “when your hand moved in an upward
movement, the excess skin would cover the tip of his penis.”
Alexis said she did not know the difference between a circumcised
and uncircumcised penis.
At the preliminary hearing, Detective Flores testified
he viewed photographs of Waln’s penis taken while Waln was
in custody.12 Defense counsel asked Detective Flores, “And
in fact it was revealed that Mr. Waln has a circumcised penis,
is that correct?” Detective Flores responded, “That’s correct.”
Seven months later—while jury selection for the trial was
in progress—Detective Flores told the prosecutor he misspoke
at the preliminary hearing. He said, after viewing the
photographs of Waln’s penis, he believed Waln is uncircumcised.
The prosecutor informed defense counsel. At the parties’ request,
the trial court declared a mistrial to give the defense time to
get an expert opinion on whether Waln is circumcised.
A day or two before the start of the second trial, defense
counsel and the prosecutor met with Deputy Meredith to discuss

12 Detective Flores obtained a search warrant to take
photographs of Waln’s penis. Detective Flores was not personally
present when the photographs were taken.

22
his initial interview with Alexis. For the first time, Deputy
Meredith said Alexis described a circumcised penis during the
interview. He recalled her saying, “when she moved her hand
up and down, the skin did not cover the tip of the penis.” Deputy
Meredith said he made a mistake in his report when he wrote
that Alexis described an uncircumcised penis.
At trial, Alexis clarified the testimony she gave at the
preliminary hearing about Waln’s penis. According to Alexis,
when she said Waln’s penis had a “hood,” she was referring to
“the tip of it,” which was pink. Alexis said skin would “go up”
while she was stroking Waln’s penis, but it would not “cover”
the tip. The tip was always visible.
The defense presented expert testimony from a urologist
who examined Waln and concluded he is circumcised. Defense
counsel also called Detective Flores and Deputy Meredith
as defense witnesses. Counsel questioned Detective Flores
extensively about his preliminary hearing testimony and whether
he believed, based on the photographs of Waln’s penis, that Waln
is uncircumcised. Counsel questioned Deputy Meredith about
his initial interview of Alexis. However, counsel did not ask
Deputy Meredith about the “mistake” in his report or whether
Alexis described Waln’s penis as uncircumcised.
In the motion for a new trial, Waln argued defense counsel
committed error by not presenting to the jury evidence of Deputy
Meredith’s mistake. According to Waln, the evidence “would
have left the jury with two choices; either that [Deputy] Meredith
had intentionally changed his description of the evidence to
support the prosecution’s case, or it was just another incredibly
coincidental mistake by law enforcement as to the crucial issue
of the description by Alexis of her attacker’s penis.”

23
The court determined defense counsel’s failure to question
Deputy Meredith on the circumcision issue was not “ineffective,
or a mistake, or a failure,” and “would not have affected the
result in this case.” The court explained defense counsel achieved
the “ultimate objective” to impeach Alexis on her description of
Waln’s penis. The court noted the value of questioning Deputy
Meredith on the point was “negligible when compared to the . . .
greater effect of directly impeaching Alexis and her description
of Defendant’s penis.” The court also noted defense counsel
“conclusively proved”—through photographs and expert
testimony—that Waln’s penis is circumcised.13
ii. Analysis
On appeal, Waln argues defense counsel’s failure to present
evidence of Deputy Meredith’s mistake constituted ineffective
assistance of counsel. We disagree.
There are obvious tactical reasons why counsel might have
avoided questioning Deputy Meredith about his mistake. Deputy
Meredith wrote in his report that Alexis described Waln’s penis
as uncircumcised. That fact was helpful to the defense, as
it contradicted the undisputed evidence that Waln’s penis is
circumcised. If the jury learned Deputy Meredith claimed he
meant to write “circumcised,” there was a risk the jury would

13 The trial court later acknowledged that, at the time
it ruled on the motion for a new trial, it erroneously believed
evidence of Deputy Meredith’s mistake was before the jury. The
court thought Waln was arguing defense counsel was ineffective
for failing to question Deputy Meredith about that evidence, not
that he was ineffective for failing to introduce the evidence in the
first place. The court stated its position did not change knowing
evidence of Deputy Meredith’s mistake was not before the jury.

24
question whether Alexis had, in fact, described a circumcised
penis during the initial interview. If so, it would have undercut
one of the defense’s strongest arguments: that Alexis repeatedly
gave inaccurate descriptions of Waln’s penis. Counsel had to
weigh that possibility against the benefit of impeaching Deputy
Meredith. A reasonable attorney could have concluded the
benefit of questioning Deputy Meredith was not worth the risk
of undercutting one of the defense’s strongest attacks on Alexis’s
credibility. Indeed, we suspect the majority of experienced
trial attorneys would have made that choice.
Waln argues any tactical justifications for defense counsel’s
actions are irrelevant because counsel admitted he did not
make a strategic decision.14 Defense counsel submitted two
declarations under penalty of perjury in connection with the
motion for a new trial. Counsel did not address his failure to
question Deputy Meredith in either. Nevertheless, Waln points
to a sentence in a trial brief—which defense counsel drafted—
stating it “is not true” that counsel failed to question Deputy
Meredith for strategic reasons.15 Counsel also suggested during

14 Although the Strickland standard is objective, the
California Supreme Court has stated a defendant can “reasonably
expect that before counsel undertakes to act at all he will make
a rational and informed decision on strategy and tactics founded
on adequate investigation and preparation. [Citations.] If
counsel fails to make such a decision, his action—no matter
how unobjectionable in the abstract—is professionally deficient.”
(People v. Ledesma (1987) 43 Cal.3d 171, 215.)
15 In the motion for a new trial, defense counsel wrote
the decision not to question Deputy Meredith was error, but
he did not deny having a strategic reason for making the choice.
In opposition to the motion, the People argued counsel made

25
the hearing on the motion for a new trial that he did not question
Deputy Meredith because “it was so late in the proceedings” and
he “was so focused on the other points.”
Defense counsel’s assertion that he was not acting
strategically strains credulity. The fact that Alexis described
Waln’s penis as uncircumcised was central to Waln’s defense.
During his closing argument, defense counsel asserted the
circumcision issue “dwarfs all the others” in the case. Counsel
argued the “fact that [Alexis] says [Waln] was uncircumcised . . .
[b]ut . . . he is circumcised proves his innocence.” Counsel also
asserted the “assailant had an uncircumcised penis and [Waln]
does not. End of story.” Given the centrality of this issue to the
defense, we highly doubt counsel would have risked planting
any seeds of doubt in jurors’ minds on whether Alexis described
Waln’s penis as circumcised.
The manner in which defense counsel presented evidence
of Deputy Meredith’s report supports that conclusion. It is
clear from the trial record that counsel wanted the jury to know
Deputy Meredith wrote in his report that Alexis described
an uncircumcised penis. Indeed, counsel mentioned that fact
three times in his opening statement. However, counsel did
not present that evidence to the jury through Deputy Meredith,
which would have opened the door to testimony that he made
a mistake in his report. Instead, defense counsel presented the

a “calculated decision . . . to avoid having yet another witness,
another adult, admit to having used the word circumcised
and uncircumcised incorrectly.” In a motion to supplement the
motion for a new trial, counsel refuted that argument, writing,
“It would be easy for counsel to attribute the decision not to
question Meredith as defense strategy, but that is not true.”

26
evidence while questioning Detective Flores. Defense counsel
later called Deputy Meredith to testify as a defense witness and
questioned him extensively about Alexis’s interview, including
her description of the length of Waln’s penis and the fact that
it was erect. However, counsel did not ask Deputy Meredith
whether Alexis described Waln’s penis as uncircumcised. These
actions suggest defense counsel purposefully avoided the issue
of Deputy Meredith’s “mistake,” likely for the strategic reasons
we discussed above.
Even if we were to take defense counsel at his word, Waln
has not shown prejudice. Waln argues questioning Deputy
Meredith would have “effectively challenged the credibility of the
prosecution’s case” by suggesting law enforcement was willing
to fabricate evidence to benefit the prosecution. While that may
be true, defense counsel introduced other compelling evidence
on the issue. Specifically, counsel presented evidence that
Detective Flores—who was the investigating officer in charge
of the entire case—claimed to have given inaccurate testimony
while describing Waln’s penis at the preliminary hearing. There
was marginal benefit to showing Deputy Meredith—who was a
patrol officer with little involvement in the case—made a similar
mistake in his report. That is especially true given the case did
not turn on whether the jury believed law enforcement fabricated
evidence. Rather, it turned on whether the jury believed Alexis’s
testimony that Waln sexually assaulted her. On that issue,
questioning Deputy Meredith about a mistake in his report
could only hurt the defense’s case.
On this record, Waln has not shown a reasonable
probability that, but for counsel’s error, the result in the
proceeding would have been different. Nor does the error

27
otherwise undermine our confidence in the outcome of the trial.
Accordingly, Waln has not shown he received ineffective
assistance of counsel. (See Hoyt, supra, 8 Cal.5th at p. 958 [an
ineffective assistance of counsel claim requires the defendant
to show resulting prejudice].) The trial court did not abuse
its discretion when it denied the motion for a new trial on
this ground.
c. Circumcision evidence
i. Background
During her interviews with law enforcement,
Alexis described Waln’s penis in a way that suggested it is
uncircumcised. To impeach Alexis on that issue, Waln presented
expert testimony from a urologist, Dr. Justin Houman.
Dr. Houman examined Waln’s flaccid penis and concluded it is
circumcised.
The prosecutor did not deny that Waln’s penis is
circumcised. However, in her closing argument, the prosecutor
pointed to photographs of Waln’s flaccid penis that showed some
“wrinkled skin” and asked, “[I]s it unreasonable to believe that
what we see in the pictures . . . is exactly what Alexis saw? That
wrinkled skin on the penis, that wrinkled skin on the testicles,
and when that skin is pushed up, it actually, in fact, covers the
ridge of it[?]”
In his motion for a new trial, Waln argued defense counsel
should have presented “more precise evidence” concerning “the
state of [his] penis vis-a-vis circumcision, and whether or not,
during masturbation in its erect state, skin would cover the head
during upward movement, and then expose it during downward
movement.” In support, Waln submitted a sworn declaration
from his expert, Dr. Houman. Dr. Houman stated he examined

28
Waln a second time after trial “with the goal of discovering more
definitive evidence . . . regarding the issue of whether or not the
defendant was circumcised.” Based on the second examination—
this time in a partially erect state—Dr. Houman again concluded
Waln “is clearly circumcised.” Dr. Houman also concluded the
“physical state of [Waln’s] penis in the partially erect state does
not contain sufficient skin to cover the head as Alexis described;
or even close to that state. Even with a partial erection, there is
no skin that gets remotely close to the head of the penis to give
the impression of an uncircumcised penis.”
Waln also submitted a declaration from defense counsel
stating he should have originally instructed Dr. Houman to
examine Waln in an erect state. Counsel asserted the evidence
was necessary to rebut the prosecutor’s argument that, although
Waln is circumcised, he has some excess skin on his penis that
could account for Alexis’s description of “skin moving up and
down.” Counsel asserted he should have asked Dr. Houman
two questions: (1) is Waln circumcised; and (2) “[b]ecause of
[Waln’s] circumcision, would it be possible for the skin on his
penis to cover the entire head, in an erect state?”
The court did not address this issue in its written order
denying the motion for a new trial. However, at the hearing
on the motion, the court stated it read Dr. Houman’s declaration
and concluded it did not provide grounds for a new trial.
ii. Analysis
On appeal, Waln argues his counsel was ineffective for
failing to elicit testimony from Dr. Houman to eliminate “any
doubt about whether skin would cover or expose the head of
[Waln’s] erect penis during masturbation.” The record, however,
shows counsel did elicit testimony on that issue at trial. Defense

29
counsel asked Dr. Houman, “In the case of an uncircumcised
penis, if the evidence was that the hand was moving up, and skin,
as it moved up, covered the tip, and as the hand went down,
the skin went down and the tip was uncovered, would that be
a circumcised or uncircumcised penis?” Dr. Houman answered,
“If it covered the head—the only way it would—an uncircumcised
penis would fully cover the head. It’s always fully covered.”
Defense counsel asked, “And a circumcised penis would not?”
The doctor replied, “It would not.” Counsel asked if during
masturbation “the skin would cover the entire hood of the penis
. . . [w]ould that be a circumcised penis or an uncircumcised
[penis], in your opinion?” Dr. Houman replied, “That would be
an uncircumcised penis.”
Considering this testimony with Dr. Houman’s opinion
that Waln is circumcised, the jury would have understood that
the skin on Waln’s penis could not cover the entire head during
masturbation. Dr. Houman’s examination after trial simply
confirmed that fact. As such, it was cumulative and would not
have meaningfully affected the outcome of the case. Accordingly,
Waln has not shown the trial court erred when it rejected his
ineffective assistance of counsel claim on this ground. (See
People v. Padilla (1995) 11 Cal.4th 891, 960–961, overruled on
other grounds in People v. Hill (1998) 17 Cal.4th 800 [defense
counsel was not ineffective for failing to seek a new trial based
on newly discovered evidence that was cumulative].)
d. Classroom sink
i. Background
A contested issue at trial was whether there was a
portable sink in Waln’s classroom in 2019. The issue was
relevant to Alexis’s testimony that she washed her hands in a

30
sink at Waln’s direction after he ejaculated on her. She said the
sink was two feet wide, had handles, and could be moved around.
The People presented testimony from Detective Flores
that he visited the school during his investigation and found six
portable sinks. The sinks were not in Waln’s former classroom.
The court admitted a photograph of one of the sinks over defense
counsel’s objection. The court ruled the photograph was relevant
for the purpose of showing that portable sinks exist, a fact that
might not be common knowledge.
The People called Gerald Mitchell—who was the director
of maintenance and operations at the school—to testify on a
different issue. However, defense counsel asked Mitchell about
the sink issue during cross-examination. In response to counsel’s
questions, Mitchell testified he ordered portable handwashing
stations for the school in 2021 in response to the pandemic.
Mitchell had no knowledge of a sink ever being inside Waln’s
former classroom. On redirect, Mitchell testified that he visited
Waln’s former classroom in April 2023 and found “some type
of water dispenser . . . that said something to the effect of . . .
lab use H2O.” It could be used to fill “a cup, or a pail, or
something like that.” Mitchell did not know whether the
water dispenser was in Waln’s classroom in 2019.
The defense called two witnesses to testify on the sink
issue. Steve Fericean—who was the school district’s director
for purchasing and warehouse—searched the district’s records
for “evidence of any portable handwashing stations, or temporary
sinks, or sinks that were ever placed in any classrooms.”
Fericean found purchase orders for portable sinks, but the orders
were placed after the start of the pandemic in 2020.

31
The defense also called Paula Mayes, who was an assistant
principal at the school from 2014 through 2021. Mayes visited
Waln’s classroom every other week to observe him teaching.
According to Mayes, there was never a sink in his classroom.
Mayes said she was aware of a sink in a different classroom,
but it was not functional.
During her closing argument, the prosecutor acknowledged
she did not have a picture of a sink in Waln’s classroom, noting
the “evidence is what it is.” The prosecutor suggested the
jury should follow the instruction to “ ‘not automatically reject
the testimony just because of inconsistencies or conflicts,’ ”
especially when considering “the testimony of young ladies
who are remembering events that happened to them when
they were 11 and 12 years old in sixth grade.” The prosecutor
said people “sometimes honestly forget things or make mistakes;
it does not mean that they are lying.”
The prosecutor also noted Mitchell’s testimony about
the “lab use H2O” dispenser. The prosecutor did not argue
the dispenser was in Waln’s classroom. However, she stated,
“Obviously the teacher that had that classroom in April 2023,
when Mr. Mitchell went there, was resourceful enough to
find some way to dispense water, right, for the lab use.
So is it unreasonable to think that teachers can bring their own
materials?”
In connection with Waln’s motion for a new trial, defense
counsel asserted he discovered new evidence proving there was
no working sink in Waln’s classroom. Counsel attached to the
motion an affidavit from Mark Jackson, who was the school’s
head custodian. According to the affidavit, the school purchased
portable sinks “long before the Covid break,” but they “were

32
never operational” or filled with water. Jackson asserted there
was “no water source for the sinks other than the tank at the
bottom of the sink. Those tanks were never filled. In no way
were those sinks operational. There was never any water in
any of them.”
The court concluded counsel did not commit error in failing
to call Jackson or submit other evidence on the sink issue. The
court determined Jackson’s affidavit was “cumulative rather than
new.” The court noted defense counsel presented other evidence
at trial that “more than adequately addressed the lack of a
working sink in [Waln’s] classroom and achieved the objective
of impeaching Alexis’[s] testimony” on the issue.
ii. Analysis
On appeal, Waln contends defense counsel was ineffective
for realizing “[o]nly after the verdict . . . the necessity of
establishing the exact time period when a sink . . . was on the
school campus, including the relevant period between August
and December 2019.” This contention borders on the frivolous.
The record shows defense counsel conducted a thorough
investigation of the sink issue. To prepare for trial, defense
counsel interviewed and served subpoenas on three witnesses
who could testify for the defense on the sink issue. At trial,
counsel elicited helpful testimony while cross-examining Mitchell,
and called two witnesses to testify on the issue for the defense.
Mayes provided compelling direct evidence that there was no sink
—working or otherwise—in Waln’s classroom at the relevant
times. Fericean supported her testimony by suggesting the
school did not order portable sinks until 2020. This evidence
effectively impeached Alexis’s testimony that there was
a portable sink in the classroom in 2019. Indeed, as Waln

33
concedes on appeal, defense counsel “present[ed] compelling
evidence at trial that no such sink existed.” On this record,
Waln’s contention that his counsel did not realize the importance
of the sink issue is meritless.
Nor are we persuaded by Waln’s suggestion that defense
counsel was ineffective for failing to call Jackson as a witness
at trial. Waln contends Jackson’s testimony was critical because
it “established physical impossibility, a qualitative distinction
from the trial testimony, which merely suggested the sink likely
was not functional.” In making this argument, Waln completely
overlooks Mayes’s testimony that there was no sink in Waln’s
classroom. Indeed, it is physically impossible to wash one’s
hands in a sink that does not exist.
We also agree with the Attorney General that Jackson’s
affidavit is not wholly favorable to the defense. The prosecutor
presented evidence at trial showing there were portable sinks
at the school in 2023. However, aside from Alexis’s testimony,
the prosecutor did not present any evidence showing those
sinks were at the school in 2019. Defense counsel, in contrast,
presented evidence that the school did not order portable sinks
until 2020, which suggests there were no portable sinks on the
school’s campus before then. Jackson’s affidavit would have
undercut that evidence—and supported the prosecutor’s case—
by confirming there were portable sinks at the school “long before
the Covid break.” Although Jackson asserted those sinks were
“never” operational or filled with water, it is doubtful he had
personal knowledge of the operational state of every sink at all
times.
On this record, Waln has not shown counsel’s performance
was deficient or that he suffered any prejudice from it. (See Hoyt,

34
supra, 8 Cal.5th at p. 958.) Accordingly, the trial court properly
denied his motion for a new trial on this ground.
3. Cumulative error does not require reversal
Waln argues the trial court abused its discretion in
denying his motion for a new trial because of cumulative error.
“In examining a claim of cumulative error, the critical question
is whether defendant received due process and a fair trial.”
(People v. Sedillo (2015) 235 Cal.App.4th 1037, 1068.) We are
satisfied that Waln received a trial that was fair and comported
with due process.16

16 For the first time in his reply brief, Waln argues the trial
court should have granted his motion for a new trial based on
newly discovered evidence. Waln forfeited these issues by failing
to raise them in his opening brief on appeal. Accordingly, we
do not consider them. (See People v. Duff (2014) 58 Cal.4th 527,
550, fn. 9 [declining to consider argument raised for first time
in appellant’s reply brief].)

35
DISPOSITION
We affirm the judgment.

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

EGERTON, Acting P. J.

We concur:

ADAMS, J.

HANASONO, J.

36

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.