In re M.M. CA4/2

CourtListener 10840453Calctapp9 avr. 2026

Texte intégral

Filed 4/9/26 In re M.M. CA4/2

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION TWO

In re M.M. et al., Persons Coming Under
the Juvenile Court Law.

RIVERSIDE COUNTY DEPARTMENT
OF PUBLIC SOCIAL SERVICES, E086494

Plaintiff and Respondent, (Super.Ct.No. DPSW2400130)

v. OPINION

MARKELLE M.,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from the Superior Court of Riverside County. Sean Crandell, Judge.

Reversed and remanded.

Suzanne Davidson, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for Defendant and

Appellant.

Minh C. Tran, County Counsel, Jamila T. Pernell and Prabhath Shettigar, Deputy

County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.

1
At the contested Welfare and Institutions Code1 section 366.21, subdivision (e),

six-month review hearing, the juvenile court terminated dependency jurisdiction over

M.M.2 Markelle M. (father) appeals, contending the court erred in accepting the

Riverside County Department of Public Social Services’ (the Department) changed

recommendation without giving him the opportunity to present any evidence to challenge

it. He argues the denial of his right to set a contested hearing and to present evidence

violated his due process rights. We agree and reverse.

I. PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND AND FACTS

Father and R.P. (mother) have four children: Ar.M. (born 2016), R.M.M. (born

2018), R.A.M. (born 2020) and M.M. (born 2022).3

A. Dependency proceedings in Los Angeles County

Mother, K.T-P., and V.V. came to the attention of the Los Angeles County Child

Protective Services (LACPS) in April 2016 due to a domestic violence incident between

mother and father (stepfather to K.T-P. and V.V.). The Los Angeles County Juvenile

Court ordered father to leave the family home, and the children were returned to mother’s

custody under family maintenance services. Subsequently, Ar.M., R.M.M., and R.A.M.

1 Further statutory references are to the Welfare and Institutions Code unless
otherwise indicated.

2 Initially, M.M. was identified as A.M.; however, on May 7, 2024, the juvenile
court acknowledged his legal name as M.M. We will do the same.

3 M.M. has two half siblings, mother’s older children K.T-P. (born 2010) and
V.V. (born 2012), who are not parties to this appeal.

2
(M.M.’s siblings) were born, added to the petition, and all the children were removed

from mother’s custody due to safety concerns surrounding an extensive history of

domestic violence involving mother and father. By 2021, the children were returned to

mother’s custody and family maintenance services were ordered. However, in September

2023, LACPS reported mother and her children’s whereabouts were unknown; warrants

were issued.

B. Dependency proceedings in Riverside County

1. Detention

On April 12, 2024, the Riverside County Department of Public Social Services

(the Department) received an immediate response referral regarding allegations of

general neglect as to M.M. M.M. resided with mother and his five siblings (who were

dependents of LACPS), and law enforcement served mother with an arrest warrant for

being on the run from LACPS. Mother had been living in Arizona for the past three years

and Los Angeles before then. She acknowledged domestic violence involving father,

claiming he was the aggressor who continued to violate the restraining order against him.

Mother questioned why LACPS had custody removal orders4 when she completed her

services and the children were returned to her care. Father was incarcerated in San

Bernardino County for robbery and intent to terrorize.

On April 16, 2024, the Department initiated dependency proceedings as to M.M.

(born 2022) alleging he came within the jurisdiction of the juvenile court under section

4 The custody removal orders were required because mother allowed father into
the home despite court/restraining orders.

3
300, subdivisions (b)(1) (failure to protect), (g) (no provision for support) and (j) (abuse

of siblings). Given the family’s flight risk, he was placed in protective custody. The

juvenile court detained M.M., ordered reunification services, supervised visitation for

both parents at a minimum of two times per week, separately due to their history of

domestic violence. Father was found to be presumed father of M.M.

2. Jurisdiction/Disposition

In its jurisdiction/disposition report filed May 2, 2024, the Department

recommended the juvenile court find the allegations in its petition true and order family

reunification services for the parents. The paternal grandmother was being assessed for

placement since M.M.’s siblings were placed with her. Father’s incarceration prevented

visitation; however, mother visited M.M. with some issues. Due to her history of

physically assaulting social services staff, the Department requested the presence of

special investigations unit officers. During her first visit, she refused to drug test,

snatched the child from the social worker’s hands, ran to the visitation room, slammed

the door, and would not let anyone enter the room.

Mother’s case plan included individual counseling, domestic violence, anger

management, parenting education, and substance abuse services. Father’s case plan

included individual counseling, domestic violence, anger management, parenting

education, and substance abuse services. Mother provided proof she completed a

parenting education class in August 2020, enrolled in an anger management class and

attended 30 classes as of June 2021, and completed 12 sessions of domestic violence for

4
survivors’ class in May 2022. On May 7, 2024, father’s counsel requested, and the

juvenile court set, a contested jurisdiction/disposition hearing.

According to the addendum report filed June 25, 2024, as of May 28th, mother’s

visits were supervised by M.M.’s caregiver. As there were no concerns about her

visitation, they progressed to two hours, twice a week, with the paternal grandmother and

M.M.’s siblings. The Department’s recommendations remained the same.

On July 1, 2024, at the contested jurisdiction/disposition hearing, the Department

submitted on its reports and recommendations; mother testified and provided exhibits for

consideration. The juvenile court denied the request to dismiss the petition, found the

allegations in the first amended petition true, and adjudged M.M. a dependent of the

court. Family reunification services were ordered; father was on a waitlist to participate

in programs available at his place of incarceration, and was authorized supervised

monthly visits as permitted at his facility. Mother appealed M.M.’s removal; however,

the appeal was dismissed after her attorney filed a brief pursuant to In re Sade C. (1996)

13 Cal.4th 952. (In re M.M. (Nov. 7, 2024, E084339).) On August 16, the court ordered

a psychological evaluation for mother and set a six-month review hearing.

3. Mother’s first section 388 petition

Mother filed a section 388 petition on September 20, 2024, requesting M.M. be

returned to her custody under a family maintenance plan or placed with the maternal

grandmother, an increase in visitation, and unsupervised community visits. In its

September 17, 2024, letter, Jenesse Center, Inc., a domestic violence program, stated that

she had participated in 25 domestic violence classes, 28 parenting classes, 22 anger

5
management classes, and four substance abuse classes. A hearing was set. The

Department opposed mother’s petition, expressing concerns about her temperament,

boundaries, ability to manage her moods, findings from her psychological evaluation, and

the legitimacy of the Jenesse programs. The Department was uncertain about the

legitimacy of Jenesse’s services and its effectiveness in addressing mother’s needs. Her

psychological evaluation recommended a comprehensive psychiatric evaluation to

confirm her diagnoses5 and to set a psychopharmaceutical regime.

On October 31, 2024, the juvenile court denied mother’s section 388 petition

without prejudice. It accepted the transfer of Ar.M., R.M.M., and R.A.M. only from Los

Angeles County.

4. Six-month review period

In the six-month status review report filed December 17, 2024, the Department

recommended continuation of family reunification services. Mother was gainfully

employed, enrolled in college, and living in a four-bedroom home; her support system

included maternal grandmother and two maternal aunts. She was diagnosed with PTSD,

anxiety, oppositional defiant disorder (ODD), and depression; she sees a psychiatrist

every 30 days. The social worker opined that she has demonstrated no discernible

benefits from the courses she has taken with Jenesse, she exhibits erratic mood swings,

5 Dr. Jaymer Jesser provided a probable diagnosis of adjustment disorder,
posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), cannabis use disorder, narcissistic personality
disorder, antisocial personality disorder, and paranoid personality with unspecified
personality disorder (negativistic) type.

6
and is confrontational, aggressive, and uncooperative, all to the detriment of her overall

progress.

Father remained incarcerated with a release date of December 17, 2024. The

Department sent him pictures, letters, and a copy of his case plan on four occasions;

however, his facility did not offer reunification services. Father received parenting

correspondence program materials, but had no visits due to his incarceration. Upon

release, he planned to reside in a halfway house while working on stabilizing his living

and employment situation. He expressed a strong desire to reunify with M.M.

Subsequently, the Department reported that mother had completed a domestic

violence and parenting education program in late 2024, and drug tested negative on all

tests, but continued using marijuana. Her unsupervised visit on December 24th went

well. An inspection of her home revealed appropriate provisions. She also demonstrated

she has benefited from the courses she completed through the Jenesse Center. The

Department recommended liberalized visits for father, and granted an extended holiday

visit between M.M. and his siblings at the paternal grandmother’s home; however,

mother objected to placing him with the paternal grandmother because she wanted the

children returned to her care.

On January 10, 2025, at mother’s request, the juvenile court set the six-month

status review hearing contested. It ordered the Department to provide father with housing

assistance, referrals, and supervised visitation a minimum of twice a week for one hour

each visit; both parents were to return on February 25th without further notice.

7
5. Mother’s second section 388 petition

In mother’s second section 388 petition, filed January 29, 2025, she sought

termination of dependency jurisdiction and assistance in obtaining a restraining order

against father. Regarding the change in circumstances, she had completed several

domestic violence classes, parenting education classes, anger management classes, life

skills classes, and substance abuse classes; she was attending monthly psychiatric

meetings and all scheduled visits. A hearing was set; the court clerk notified father of the

hearing at many addresses, including his JV-140 address. The court also accepted

transfer of mother’s two oldest children (K.T-P. and V.V.) from Los Angeles County.

In response to mother’s section 388 petition, the Department recommended

granting family maintenance services but denying termination of the dependency.

Mother had obtained stable housing, engaged in successful weekend and overnight visits,

and was progressing on her case plan. Father was referred for a psychological evaluation,

and parenting, anger management and domestic violence programs. The Department

provided him the service providers’ contact information on January 6, 2025; however, it

was unable to provide housing assistance due to the program’s requirements. On

February 15, it received a five-day investigative referral regarding father; it was

investigating the allegations with law enforcement. Thus, the Department recommended

a pause in his visits pending conclusion of the investigation. Mother filed a restraining

order against father, but it was later denied.

At the contested hearing, father was absent, but his counsel was present. The

juvenile court ordered an immediate referral for wraparound services for mother and

8
supervised visitation for father at the Department’s office, with the children’s wishes

taken into consideration. The contested hearing and mother’s section 388 petition were

continued to April 10, 2025.

6. Contested six-month review addendums and hearing

In its six-month status review report (regarding M.M.’s older siblings and half

siblings) filed March 27, 2025, the Department requested a continuance to complete its

investigation regarding the allegations against father. The children were doing well in

mother’s care; however, there were concerns with some of the children’s behaviors

(Ar.M., R.M.M., R.A.M. and M.M.). Ar.M., R.A.M. and R.M.M. were scheduled for

forensic interviews on April 2. Father was living in transitional housing, actively looking

for work, and was not on any medications. The Department provided him referrals for a

psychological evaluation, parenting, anger management, and domestic violence

programs, but the referrals for anger management and domestic violence were denied due

to confusion over his incarceration and residence outside the county. The referrals were

resubmitted on February 6. He had three visits in March; however, on March 12 two

children declined to attend. Mother complained that father’s visits were doing more harm

than good. He complained that mother manipulates the children and affects their visits.

The Department had concerns that mother may be influencing her children to refuse to

visit father.

On March 7, 2025, mother expressed her wish to terminate the case. The social

worker opined that while she has demonstrated her ability and willingness “to provide

care and stability to her children,” she “has exhibited erratic mood swings and has

9
frequently been confrontational with the Department, since the children returned to her

care.” Father’s visits were progressing, with the more recent ones being “productive, safe

and the children enjoyed spending time with [him]”; however, he needed to make more

progress on his services and realize his visitation time is mainly for him and his children.

By April 7, 2025, the Department requested a continuance to complete its

investigation of allegations of sexual abuse by father and physical abuse by the paternal

grandmother. It further requested a suspension of their visits until such investigation

concludes. Ar.M. made disclosures at the forensic interview of abuse by the father and

paternal grandmother. R.M.M. was “closed off and unwilling to answer,” and R.A.M.

said mother told her to say that the paternal grandmother and father abused her. On April

10, father informed the juvenile court that he was enrolled in, and was almost complete

with, a parenting class, he had yet to receive any referral for a domestic violence

program, and his insurance was no longer allowing him to see his current therapist. The

court continued the hearings on both the contested six-month review and section 388

petition to terminate the dependency; all parties were ordered to return on May 28, 2025.

Father was present to hear the court’s orders. The Department mailed notice of the

continued hearings to father on May 7, 2025, checking the box that it was recommending

a change in orders, placement, custody, or status and specified “Terminate dependency”;

however, it sent the notice to California Rehabilitation Center and High Desert Detention

Center. One notice of the continued hearing was sent to father’s JV-140 address;

however, it stated the Department recommended “No change in orders, services,

placement, custody, or status.”

10
In an addendum report filed May 22, 2025, the Department, for the first time,

recommended termination of the dependency, the children remain in mother’s care, sole

legal and physical custody of them be granted to her, and supervised visitation for father.

It further asked the juvenile court to deny mother’s section 388 petition due to it

“reaching an inconclusive decision on the recent allegations against the father . . . and the

paternal grandmother.” Since February 25, the children were in mother’s care on an

extended visit. Mother had enrolled in additional domestic violence and individual

counseling programs on May 17, and was consistent in ensuring that the children

received necessary education services.

The Department participated in the investigation concerning the allegations

against father and the paternal grandmother. Mother accused father of putting his mouth

on R.A.M.’s private parts; Ar.M. described him as a pedophile who placed his finger in

her private parts, and she did not want to have visits with him. At her forensic interview,

Ar.M. claimed he touched her inappropriately (rubbed her private area side to side with

his finger over her clothes) in a Red Lobster restroom while the family was celebrating

the paternal grandmother’s birthday. Ar.M. accused the paternal grandmother of hitting

her siblings with a hangar, leaving bruises. She later recanted and said mother told her to

say those things. R.M.M. told the police the paternal grandmother hit him with a black

hanger, leaving scars and scabs; however, at his forensic interview, he was unwilling to

answer questions. R.A.M. accused father of abusing her and paternal grandmother of

whooping her, but later recanted, saying mother coached her to say those things. The

Department provided copies of the children’s forensic medical exams. The only child

11
with signs of physical abuse was R.M.M. who had scars and abrasions in different

healing stages; however, he refused to disclose information about the marks.

Father denied all the allegations in the referral, asserting he “would never do

‘anything disgusting’ to his children.” He accused mother of coaching the children to

falsely accuse him of sexual misconduct; he recalled a similar incident in 2019 when

mother coached K.T-P. to report false allegations against him, but the maternal

grandmother intervened and advised the child to tell the truth. Similarly, the paternal

grandmother denied the allegations and maintained she never hit the children with any

object; however, she spanked R.M.M. one time on his bottom with an open hand. She

was willing to speak to law enforcement and suspected mother was coaching the children.

She said Ar.M. uses the restroom on her own and would not seek assistance from father.

Mother denied coaching the children. Based on the interviews and exams, the

Department found the allegations against father and paternal grandmother inconclusive.

Father’s visits included talking to and playing with the children. At times, he

failed to correctly redirect or handle their behaviors. He cancelled a few visits for lack of

transportation and blamed mother for sabotaging his visitation by seeking a restraining

order on the paternal grandmother, knowing she is his only transportation option. Her

temporary restraining order against the paternal grandmother was granted on May 12,

2025, pending a hearing on June 3.

The Department referred father to parenting education, anger management, and

domestic violence programs on February 6, 2025. As of April 16, father had not started

the domestic violence and anger management programs, but was attending individual

12
therapy sessions and parenting classes. The Department was unable to get progress

reports from his service providers. On May 7, the social worker spoke with father “about

[the Department’s] intention to close the case and how [the Department] referred him to

all services, but he was not benefiting from [them].” Regarding his referrals to service

providers, father failed to provide any verification or information about the services he

was enrolled in.

The Department reported that although mother is confrontational, frequently

disregards caseworker instructions, resists feedback, and avoids productive dialogue, she

has independently enrolled the children in services. It had no current safety concerns

about the children being in her care, as she has consistently provided for their medical,

dental, educational, and mental health needs since February 2025. As for father, the

Department reported that since it was unable to verify his participation in the required

programs, he has not demonstrated progress in his services.

At the contested six-month status review hearing on May 28, 2025, father failed to

appear. His counsel stated she received information from the Department that he wanted

to appear telephonically; her numerous attempts to call him that morning were

unsuccessful. Given the Department’s recommendation to terminate the dependency,

father’s counsel requested the matter be set for a contested hearing; she expressed

concerns regarding the addendum report because it appeared the Department was

unaware of the information and documentation regarding father’s progress in services.

Initially, no party objected to setting and continuing the hearing; however, mother noted

the case is eight years old, and her counsel said that if the only issue is visitation, mother

13
is agreeable to weekly supervised visits. The children’s counsel stated it is customary to

set the matter contested when the recommendation changes. After further discussion, the

juvenile court was able to establish telephonic communication with father.

Following a brief confidential conversation with father, his counsel objected to the

hearing moving forward because they did not have an adequate opportunity to talk. She

expressed concerns about “the investigation regarding the allegations the children made

against father” since “one of the children indicated that the mother was coaching them to

lie and to make up things about” him. She was concerned about the ability of the parents

“to set up any kind of visitation” since mother recently served the paternal grandmother

with a restraining order, which means she is unable to supervise visitation or transport

father to the visits. Referencing mother’s behavior (uncooperative and absconding with

the children) in Los Angeles County, counsel opined that father will be excluded from

any kind of visitation unless the court puts a specific plan in place. She conveyed father’s

objection that he did not have 12 months of reunification services due to his

incarceration, adding her belief that he was unable to complete some parenting and

therapy. If the case were to close over her objection, she asked that father maintain his

current visitation; she reiterated that her “three- to four-minute conversation with” him

left her unable to present any evidence that may make a difference with his visitation.

Mother’s counsel asked the juvenile court to follow the Department’s

recommendation and close the case because (1) mother had finished her case plan; (2) she

had gone above and beyond what was asked of her; (3) she was willing to allow father

supervised visits at his current schedule; (4) she was willing to have her mother supervise

14
the visits; and (5) if she interfered with his visitation, his recourse would lie in the family

law court. According to mother’s counsel, “[N]othing has been terminated from father.

He would just have to use a different avenue.” The Department submitted on its reports

and recommendations and asked the court to deny the section 388 petition as moot. The

children’s counsel also submitted on the visitation remaining the same, adding the

children want visits with father.

Acknowledging father’s objection, the juvenile court stated, “[T]here was ample

opportunity prior to today’s hearing for father to contact [his attorney] and discuss the

contents of the Department’s report, which was filed in advance of this hearing or make

himself available earlier in the day to speak about the matter. We didn’t call the matter

until after 11:30 which would have given [father] ample time to either be present in court

or make telephonic contact. He is present currently and did have an opportunity to speak

to counsel.” The court adopted the Department’s recommendations, except as to

visitation, which it allowed to continue at its current schedule of two hours a week

supervised by a person approved by mother or by a paid professional monitor at father’s

expense. The court terminated jurisdiction over father’s objection, granted mother sole

physical and legal custody “upon the filing of family law orders consistent with the

Department’s recommendation,” and denied the section 388 petition as moot.

II. DISCUSSION

Father contends the juvenile court erred in failing to continue the contested six-

month review/section 364 hearing to give him the opportunity to present evidence

challenging the Department’s recommendation to terminate dependency jurisdiction and

15
issue exit orders.6 He argues the denial of his right to present evidence violated his due

process rights. The Department asserts the six-month review hearing had already been

set as a contested hearing and mother’s section 388 petition requested termination of the

dependency, thus the court properly denied father’s request for a continuance. We

conclude father had a right to present evidence both to challenge dismissal of the

dependency action and the terms of visitation relevant to the exit order. The denial of an

evidentiary hearing on these issues deprived him of his due process right to present

evidence, and the error was not harmless.

A. Governing Law and Standard of Review

A court may grant a continuance in dependency proceedings so long as that

continuance is not “contrary to the interest of the minor” and the party requesting it

shows good cause. (§ 352, subd. (a)(1)-(2).) “We review the juvenile court’s decision to

deny a continuance for abuse of discretion. [Citation.] ‘Discretion is abused when a

decision is arbitrary, capricious or patently absurd and results in a manifest miscarriage of

justice.’” (In re D.Y. (2018) 26 Cal.App.5th 1044, 1056.)

“[W]hen dependency jurisdiction is terminated with the child in the custody of one

of his or her parents, section 362.4, subdivision (a), commits to the sound discretion of

the juvenile court the authority to make an order determining a noncustodial parent’s

6 Father contends section 364 is applicable since the juvenile court issued its
custody and visitation orders and terminated jurisdiction. The Department responds the
May 28, 2025, hearing was not a section 364 hearing, but a contested section 366.21,
subdivision (e), hearing. Regardless of how we label the hearing, the result is the same:
the juvenile court terminated dependency jurisdiction over father’s children and issued
exit orders.

16
visitation.” (In re C.S. (2022) 80 Cal.App.5th 631, 638; accord, In re Armando L. (2016)

1 Cal.App.5th 606, 616 (Armando L.) [“When a juvenile court terminates its jurisdiction

over a dependent child, it is empowered to make exit orders regarding custody and

visitation”].) “These orders become part of any family court proceeding concerning the

same child and will remain in effect until they are modified or terminated by the family

court.” (Armando L., at p. 616.)

“The power to determine the right and extent of visitation by a noncustodial parent

in a dependency case resides with the juvenile court and may not be delegated to

nonjudicial officials or private parties, including the parents themselves.” (Armando L.,

supra, 1 Cal.App.5th at p. 616.) “‘This rule of nondelegation applies to exit orders issued

when dependency jurisdiction is terminated.’” (In re A.C. (2011) 197 Cal.App.4th 796,

799; accord, In re T.H. (2010) 190 Cal.App.4th 1119, 1123 (T.H.).) While “[a] visitation

order may delegate to a third party the responsibility for managing the details of visits,

including their time, place and manner,” the juvenile court has “‘the ultimate supervision

and control over’” whether visitation will occur. (T.H., at p. 1123.)

“‘[T]he juvenile court has broad discretion to make custody [and visitation] orders

when it terminates jurisdiction in a dependency case (§ 362.4).’ [Citation.] We review

the juvenile court’s exit orders for an abuse of that discretion.” (In re J.M. (2023) 89

Cal.App.5th 95, 112-113.)

B. Analysis

Here, in refusing to continue the contested six-month review hearing, the juvenile

court found that father had “ample opportunity” to discuss the Department’s report. We

17
disagree. The initial six-month review report filed March 27, and the addendum report

filed April 7, 2025, recommended continuing dependency jurisdiction. The first notice

the Department was changing its recommendations to terminate jurisdiction and issue

custody and visitation orders came via the addendum report filed on May 22, 2025, six

days before the May 28th hearing. Father’s counsel informed the court that her brief

communication with father left her unable to present evidence that may make a difference

with his visitation. She expressed concerns about the ability of the parents “to set up any

kind of visitation” given mother’s uncooperative behavior toward social services and her

recent service of a restraining order on the paternal grandmother, father’s source of

transportation to visits. Also, due to his incarceration, father had insufficient time to

receive 12 months of services, making him unable to complete the parenting program and

therapy.

“Due process includes the right to be heard, adduce testimony from witnesses, and

to cross-examine and confront witnesses.” (Armando L., supra, 1 Cal.App.5th at p. 620;

see David B. v. Superior Court (2006) 140 Cal.App.4th 772, 777 [“[p]arents have a

fundamental liberty interest in the care, custody, and management of their children”].)

While it is possible that father may not have been able to offer evidence to prevent the

juvenile court from terminating the dependency, we cannot say the same about the court’s

visitation order. The record shows that mother frequently disregarded caseworker

instructions; she absconded from LACPS and took the children to Arizona for three years.

The Department acknowledged that she was less than cooperative in facilitating visitation

with father. She was diagnosed with ODD, demonstrated erratic mood swings, and is

18
confrontational. She made inaccurate statements regarding father and the paternal

grandmother abusing and/or neglecting the children and coached the children to lie about

both father’s and the paternal grandmother’s alleged abusive acts. Mother obtained a

restraining order against the paternal grandmother, knowing the paternal grandmother is

father’s only transportation option. And, she (mother) has resisted feedback and avoided

productive dialogue.

Notwithstanding the above, the juvenile court terminated jurisdiction and issued

an exit order that granted father visitation two hours a week supervised by a person

approved by mother or by a paid professional monitor at father’s expense. Father is

prejudiced by this order. If mother must approve the person who supervises his

visitation, she controls whether the visitation happens. He has stated that the paternal

grandmother is his means of transportation, but mother has a restraining order against her.

Even if the restraining order has expired, there is no indication mother will approve the

paternal grandmother as the visitation supervisor. If mother does not approve of any

family member supervising visits, then father has to pay for a professional monitor;

however, there is no indication how father will be able to pay for this (and the

reunification services programs he may be required to complete) when he is unemployed.

Thus, if mother wants to, she is empowered to prevent father from visiting his children

altogether.

19
Although father can seek to modify visitation in family law court, such court must

defer to the dependency court’s order concerning custody and visitation unless it finds a

significant change of circumstances. (Armando L., supra, 1 Cal.App.5th at pp. 619-621

[juvenile court abused discretion in denying evidentiary hearing on issues related to

jurisdiction and exit orders]; see also In re Michael W. (1997) 54 Cal.App.4th 190, 192,

196 [presuming prejudice, and holding that “when requested, an evidentiary hearing must

be held”]; Heidi S. v. David H. (2016) 1 Cal.App.5th 1150, 1164 [before modifying the

visitation schedule set forth in the exit order, the family court must find a significant

change of circumstances that warrants that modification].) According to the

Department’s reports, the circumstances are that mother is confrontational and

uncooperative with father regarding visitation. If this never changes, then there is no

“significant change of circumstances” to warrant changing the visitation order.

For the above reasons, we conclude the juvenile court abused its discretion when it

denied father’s request for a hearing to provide further evidence to challenge the

Department’s recommendations.

20
III. DISPOSITION

The juvenile court’s orders, filed June 9, 2025, are reversed and the matter

remanded for the court to conduct a contested hearing at which father may present

evidence concerning his present circumstances, including any issues affecting visitation

with his children.

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS

McKINSTER
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

J.

We concur:

RAMIREZ
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

P. J.

FIELDS
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

J.

21

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.