CourtListener 10838311•Gonzalez v. Juarez CA2/5
Texte intégral
Filed 4/6/26 Gonzalez v. Juarez CA2/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION FIVE
JUAN CARLOS GONZALEZ, B346174
Plaintiff and Respondent, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct.
v. No. 24STRO02139)
AMY JUAREZ,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of
Los Angeles County, Latrice A.G. Byrdsong, Judge. Affirmed.
Amy Juarez, in pro. per., for Defendant and Appellant.
No appearance for Plaintiff and Respondent.
——————————
Defendant and appellant Amy Juarez appeals the trial
court’s April 14, 2025 order under Family Code section 6345,
subdivision (a),1 renewing, for a period of five years, a one-year
domestic violence restraining order (DVRO) protecting plaintiff
and respondent Juan Carlos Gonzalez. Juarez contends the trial
court erred in believing what Juarez claims were Gonzalez’s false
allegations against her. We affirm.
FACTS AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A. Background and Overview
Gonzalez and Juarez previously worked together and for
some time were engaged in a dating or sexual relationship, which
ended sometime before October 2023.2 In April 2024, the trial
court entered a one-year DVRO protecting Gonzalez and his
relatives from Juarez. Juarez appealed, and this court affirmed.
(Juarez v. Gonzalez (Nov. 7, 2025, B343323) [nonpub. opn.].)
While Juarez’s appeal of the April 2024 DVRO was pending,
Gonzalez requested a renewal of the DVRO. After a contested
hearing, the trial court renewed Gonzalez’s DVRO for a period of
five years. Juarez now appeals that renewal order.
1 All further statutory references are to the Family Code
unless otherwise stated.
2 Portions of our recitation of facts and procedure are taken
from our prior opinion in Juarez v. Gonzalez (Nov. 7, 2025,
B343323) [nonpub. opn.]) and the underlying record on appeal.
(Evid. Code, § 452, subd. (d).)
2
B. Initial DVRO
On March 26, 2024, plaintiff Gonzalez filed a request for a
domestic violence restraining order (DVRO), accusing Juarez of
stalking him, disturbing his peace, and vandalizing his car. On
March 28, 2024, Juarez filed her own request for a DVRO,
accusing Gonzalez of physically abusing her in April 2023,
harassing her in August 2023, and attacking her and her brother
in March 2024.3 After a hearing on April 17, 2024, to consider
both DVRO requests, the trial court granted Gonzalez’s DVRO
request for a period of one year, expiring April 17, 2025. The
court denied Juarez’s DVRO request.
Juarez appealed the DVRO against her. In the fall of 2025,
this court invited the parties to address the status of the
appealed order and explain why we should not dismiss the appeal
as moot. Juarez filed a response asking us to reach the merits of
her appeal because the DVRO caused her mental stress and
financial hardship; she also alluded to a new court case for a five-
year extension. Ultimately, this court addressed the merits of
the appeal, and we affirmed the April 2024 DVRO. (Juarez v.
Gonzalez (Nov. 7, 2025, B343323) [nonpub. opn.].)
3 Nowhere in her appellate briefing did Juarez contend the
court erred in denying her DVRO request.
3
C. DVRO Renewal
1. Request for Renewal
On March 21, 2025, Gonzalez filed a request to renew the
April 17, 2024 one-year restraining order for a period of five
years. Gonzalez wrote in his request that he sought the renewal
because he was afraid or worried Juarez might abuse him in the
future based on two incidents, on June 4 and June 11, 2024.
Gonzalez characterized both incidents as violations of the
restraining order. Gonzalez’s written narrative in support of his
renewal request stated that the officer who arrested Juarez on
June 11, 2024 told him that “they found weapons like a taser,
pepper spray, and a knife past the legal length in her possession.”
Attached to the request were copies of the prior DVRO and police
reports for June 4 and June 11, 2024.
2. June 4, 2024 Encounter
In the very early morning of June 4, 2024, Gonzalez was
sleeping in his parked car near his workplace in the City of
Alhambra, before his work shift was due to start at 2:00 a.m. He
saw a car parked behind him that he believed belonged to Juarez,
and he took photos of the car before it drove away. He later saw
the same car drive past him and past the police station. He
reported to the police that Juarez was violating the restraining
order, but by then the car had left the area. An officer told
Gonzalez that if he saw Juarez’s car again, he should not
approach the car, but instead report its location to the police.
4
3. June 11, 2024 Arrest
Around 1:30 a.m. on June 11, 2024, Gonzalez saw Juarez’s
car parked about two blocks away from his workplace. Gonzalez
called the police and reported he had a restraining order against
Juarez, and she was parked near his workplace. Gonzalez
provided police with the location and a description of Juarez’s
car. When police located her car, Juarez was driving. Police
conducted a traffic stop and questioned Juarez about her
presence in Alhambra. She explained she had gotten off work
and had stopped to talk to a friend on the phone. Juarez
confirmed to the officer that she was aware of the restraining
order and she knew Gonzalez was scheduled to start work, but
denied coming to Alhambra to look for Gonzalez. After the officer
confirmed the restraining order with dispatch, he called
Gonzalez, who advised the officer that Juarez being in Alhambra
when he starts work has been an ongoing issue, and that seeing
Juarez’s car disturbs his peace. Gonzalez stated he was worried
that Juarez would follow him and possibly vandalize his car,
because she previously vandalized his car when it was parked at
his home. Based on his investigation, the officer determined that
Juarez had violated the restraining order by driving and parking
near Gonzalez’s workplace and disturbing Gonzalez’s peace and
emotional calm. Juarez was arrested and booked for violation of
Penal Code section 166(a)(4) [willful disobedience of a court
order], and her car was towed. Ultimately, the district attorney
chose not to pursue the charges against her.
5
4. Renewal Hearing
On April 14, 2025, the trial court conducted a hearing on
the renewal request.4 After a brief discussion about what
additional evidence the parties had beyond the renewal request,
the court first heard testimony from Gonzalez about the two
incidents on June 4 and 11, 2024. Gonzalez also explained to the
court that he was seeking the renewal because he feared that
once the current order expired Juarez would resume harassing
him, affecting his work and making him fear for his life, his
mental and physical health, and his finances, based on her
vandalizing his vehicle.
The court asked Juarez about her presence near Gonzalez’s
work on the two dates at issue. Juarez denied being near
Gonzalez’s workplace on June 4, 2024, explaining that she had
seen other vehicles like hers in Alhambra, and she was not there.
Regarding the incident on June 11, 2024, Juarez explained that
she got out of work in El Monte at 1 a.m., and she sometimes
stops in Alhambra to go to her gym (Planet Fitness) or to the 7-
Eleven store there. Juarez had parked on the street, one block
from the 7-Eleven, and was talking on the phone with a friend
when she noticed a strange car near her own for a long time.
Juarez couldn’t see the license plate, and then the other car drove
off as she was walking back to her own car. She thought
Gonzalez might have done something to her car, but it looked
4 Responding to questioning from the trial court, Gonzalez
admitted he had forgotten to have the sheriff serve Juarez with
his renewal request. Juarez was present at the hearing and
waived the defective service.
6
fine. When she started driving, she noticed she was being
followed very closely by a vehicle that turned out to be the police,
who pulled her over and started questioning her. Juarez
explained—to the court and to the police—that she was not there
to see Gonzalez, but that she frequents the 7-Eleven and the gym
nearby.
During her testimony, Juarez also claimed that Gonzalez
chose her birthday to “do this to me,” meaning Juarez believed
Gonzalez was tracking her car and sought to have police detain
her on her birthday. When the judge asked Gonzalez to clarify
whether he was already there or saw Juarez’s car that morning
after it was parked, Gonzalez said he saw her car when he was
driving to work, but also explained that he was paranoid because
his car had been vandalized in the nighttime, implying that
Juarez and her brother were carrying out the vandalism. Juarez
responded that she works from 4:30 until 1 a.m. in the morning,
and she had the shift times to prove it. She denied vandalizing
Gonzalez’s car, and started referring to her efforts to present
evidence on that issue during the original DVRO hearing in April
2024. The court responded that it was not going to relitigate the
facts and circumstances of the prior DVRO. The court clarified
that for the current hearing, Juarez had not presented any
request for a restraining order against Gonzalez or any of his
family members, so it would be “evaluating the information to
determine whether or not [Gonzalez] has good cause to request
this renewal based on his reasonable belief that there’s still a
need for the restraining order. And to be clear, [Gonzalez] does
not need to prove any future abuse or that acts have actually
occurred but that [he has] a reasonable apprehension of future
abuse.”
7
The court asked about a police document Juarez had
identified earlier, and upon reviewing the document, the court
described it as indicating that the district attorney chose not to
file an accusatory pleading within 25 days of Juarez’s arrest, but
that the letter did not preclude further investigation or a
subsequent filing.5 Juarez noted that where she parked was a
half-mile from Gonzalez’s workplace. Juarez also clarified to the
court that her testimony and photos of Gonzalez’s family
members was being offered not to ask for a restraining order
against him, but to clarify that it didn’t make sense for Gonzalez
to be claiming Juarez was harassing him, when he was sending
his family members to harass her and her family. Finally Juarez
pointed out that while Gonzalez claimed in his request that
Juarez had weapons in her vehicle, the police report did not
include any such information.
The court gave Gonzalez an opportunity to respond, and he
emphasized that since Juarez worked in El Monte, there was no
plausible reason why she needed to go to a 7-Eleven in Alhambra
so close to his work. He also pointed out that because his job is
parking enforcement, his work could require him to be anywhere
in Alhambra between 2 a.m. and 4 a.m. He noted that Juarez did
not need to exit the freeway to make a phone call, and said he
had a map showing the relative distances between the freeway,
the police station, the 7-Eleven, and the Planet Fitness. He also
stated that the security guard for the parking lot near the Planet
Fitness calls the police station to tow away vehicles that are
5 On March 26, 2026, Juarez filed in this court a motion to
augment, seeking to add to the appellate record this document
and several others that were not included in the clerk’s
transcript. The motion is denied.
8
parked overnight, noting that he responds to that area
frequently.
The trial court found Gonzalez’s testimony to be credible,
and that he had proven by a preponderance of the evidence that
he “entertains a reasonable apprehension of future abuse,” noting
the police report that the June 11, 2024, incident disturbed
Gonzalez’s emotional well-being and therefore violated the
existing restraining order. The court stated it did not find
Juarez’s reasons for being in the area to be credible, and did not
believe Juarez’s testimony about the June 4, 2024, incident.
5. Renewal Order and Appeal
The court granted the renewal request, and Juarez filed a
timely appeal.
DISCUSSION
Gonzalez has not filed a respondent’s brief on appeal, but
Juarez still bears the burden to show reversible error. (Jameson
v. Desta (2018) 5 Cal.5th 594, 609 [appellant must demonstrate
error justifying reversal].)
A. Restraining Order Renewals
Family Code section 6345, subdivision (a) authorizes a
court to extend the term of an existing DVRO “upon the request
of a party, either for five or more years, or permanently, at the
discretion of the court, without a showing of further abuse since
9
the issuance of the original order.”6 (Navarro v. Cervera (2025)
108 Cal.App.5th 229, 237 (Navarro); G.G. v. G.S. (2024) 102
Cal.App.5th 413, 421.)
“The legal standard for renewal of a DVRO is whether the
protected party entertains a reasonable apprehension of future
abuse. (Ritchie v. Konrad (2004) 115 Cal.App.4th 1275, 1290
(Ritchie).) ‘[T]his does not mean the court must find it is more
likely than not that abuse will occur if the protective order is not
renewed. It only means the evidence demonstrates it is more
probable than not there is a sufficient risk of future abuse to find
the protected party’s apprehension genuine and reasonable.’
(Ibid.) An imminent and present danger of abuse is not required;
there must only be a reasonable apprehension that ‘abuse will
occur at some time in the future if the protective order is allowed
6 The full text of the subdivision provides: “(a) In the
discretion of the court, the personal conduct, stay-away, and
residence exclusion orders contained in a court order issued after
notice and a hearing under this article may have a duration of
not more than five years, subject to termination or modification
by further order of the court either on written stipulation filed
with the court or on the motion of a party. These orders may be
renewed, upon the request of a party, either for five or more
years, or permanently, at the discretion of the court, without a
showing of further abuse since the issuance of the original order.
Renewals and subsequent renewals shall be subject to
termination, modification, or subsequent renewal by further
order of the court either on written stipulation filed with the
court or on the motion of a party. The request for renewal may
be brought at any time within the three months before the
expiration of the orders.” (§ 6345, subd. (a).)
10
to expire.’ (Id. at p. 1288.)” (Michael M. v. Robin J. (2023) 92
Cal.App.5th 170, 179 (Michael M.).)
A court ruling on a renewal request considers three factors
to assess whether the requesting party has a reasonable
apprehension of future abuse: (1) “the evidence and findings on
which the initial DVRO was based” (Michael M., supra, 92
Cal.App.5th at p. 180; Ritchie, supra, 115 Cal.App.4th at p. 1290);
(2) changes in the circumstances surrounding the events
justifying the initial DVRO (Michael M., at p. 180; Ritchie, at
p. 1291); and (3) “ ‘the seriousness and degree of risk, such as
whether it involves potential physical abuse, and the burdens the
protective order imposes on the restrained person, such as
interference with job opportunities’ ” (Michael M., at p. 180;
Ritchie, at p. 1291).
“[S]ection 6345 makes it unnecessary for the protected
party to introduce or the court to consider actual acts of abuse the
restrained party committed after the original order went into
effect. It would be anomalous to require the protected party to
prove further abuse occurred in order to justify renewal of that
original order. If this were the standard, the protected party
would have to demonstrate the initial order had proved
ineffectual in halting the restrained party’s abusive conduct just
to obtain an extension of that ineffectual order.” (Ritchie, supra,
115 Cal.App.4th at p. 1284; accord In re Marriage of Brubaker &
Strum (2021) 73 Cal.App.5th 525, 536.)
“In challenging a renewal order, the restrained party is not
permitted ‘to challenge the truth of the evidence and findings
underlying the initial order.’ ” (Lister v. Bowen (2013) 215
Cal.App.4th 319, 333; see also Ritchie, supra, 115 Cal.App.4th at
p. 1290.)
11
B. Standard Of Review
A trial court’s order granting or denying a request for
renewal of a DVRO is reviewed for abuse of discretion. (Navarro,
supra, 108 Cal.App.5th at p. 238.) If it is necessary to review
factual findings, we refrain from reweighing evidence and
consider whether the findings are supported by substantial
evidence. (In re Harris (2024) 16 Cal.5th 292, 319 [reviewing
court prohibited from reweighing facts in assessing whether
substantial evidence exists]; Navarro, at p. 238 [factual findings
in DVRO renewal reviewed for substantial evidence]; M.S. v. A.S.
(2022) 76 Cal.App.5th 1139, 1145 [reviewing court declines to
reweigh evidence in determining propriety of DVRO].)
“ ‘A court abuses its discretion if it acts “in an arbitrary,
capricious, or patently absurd manner” ’ [citation] or ‘when its
ruling “falls outside the bounds of reason” ’ [citation].” (People v.
Thomas (2023) 14 Cal.5th 327, 399.) The California Supreme
Court has emphasized: “ ‘ “The appropriate test for abuse of
discretion is whether the trial court exceeded the bounds of
reason. When two or more inferences can reasonably be deduced
from the facts, the reviewing court has no authority to substitute
its decision for that of the trial court.” ’ [Citations.]” (In re
Stephanie M. (1994) 7 Cal.4th 295, 318–319.) Nevertheless, “[i]f
the court’s decision to deny a renewal request is influenced by an
erroneous understanding of the law, the court has not properly
exercised its discretion under the law. [Citation.]” (Michael M.,
supra, 92 Cal.App.5th at p. 178.)
12
C. Analysis
Juarez contends on appeal that the trial court incorrectly rejected
the following arguments she presented during the hearing: (1)
Gonzalez’s factual assertions regarding the incidents on June 4
and 11, 2024, were fabricated; (2) because she had an alternate
reason for being in the vicinity of Gonzalez’s workplace and
denied purposely coming within 100 yards of Gonzalez, she did
not violate the initial DVRO; and (3) Gonzalez’s claimed fear of
further abuse was belied by her evidence that his younger
siblings had vandalized her car and home. Juarez also
challenges the court’s credibility determination, accusing the
court of bias.
None of Juarez’s arguments demonstrate that the trial
court abused its discretion when it determined that Gonzalez had
a reasonable apprehension of future abuse. Juarez’s argument
that Gonzalez’s statements of fear were either fabricated or
unreasonable are simply irrelevant to whether the court
committed legal error in granting the renewal. Keeping in mind
that Gonzalez did not need to show a violation of the prior DVRO
in order to show reasonable apprehension of future abuse
(Michael M., supra, 92 Cal.App.5th at p. 179), it bears
emphasizing that the court did find such a violation, based upon
the totality of the evidence and the relative credibility of
Gonzalez and Juarez’s testimony. Juarez’s arguments boil down
to dissatisfaction with the trial court’s credibility determination,
a determination that we have no occasion to second-guess. (See
Curcio v. Pels (2020) 47 Cal.App.5th 1, 12 [a reviewing court
“must accept as true all evidence supporting the trial court’s
findings” and will “not determine credibility or reweigh the
13
evidence”].) Finally, Juarez’s claims that the court was biased
against her reflect nothing beyond Juarez’s dissatisfaction with
the court’s credibility determinations and findings of fact; we
have reviewed the transcript of the hearing and conclude Juarez’s
claims of trial court bias are unfounded.
The court had before it the two police reports attached to
Gonzalez’s renewal request. The police reports corroborated his
testimony about seeing Juarez’s car parked near his workplace
close to the time he would be coming to work. Juarez admitted to
the police she knew what time Gonzalez came into work. Given
that the initial DVRO was at least partly based upon a
determination that Juarez had vandalized Gonzalez’s car,
Gonzalez’s testimony at the renewal hearing, combined with the
June 11, 2024 police report, was ample evidence to support the
trial court’s finding that Gonzalez had a reasonable apprehension
that, if the restrictions of the initial DVRO were no longer in
place, Juarez would resume her abusive acts towards him.
(Compare Cueto v. Dozier (2015) 241 Cal.App.4th 550, 561–562
[focus is on evidence to support finding that applicant’s fear of
future abuse is reasonable].)
14
DISPOSITION
The court’s April 14, 2025 restraining order is affirmed. In
the interests of justice, each party to bear their own costs on
appeal.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.
MOOR, J.
WE CONCUR:
HOFFSTADT, P. J.
KIM (D.), J.
15
Vous vous demandez comment ce texte s’applique à votre situation ?
Consultation gratuite, sans engagement
Décrivez votre situation. Notre équipe vous recontactera par e-mail pour votre consultation.
Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude
Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.