CourtListener 10829979•Singleton v. TKG Storage Mart Partners CA1/4
Singleton v. TKG Storage Mart Partners CA1/4
CourtListener 10829979Calctapp30 mars 2026
Texte intégral
Filed 3/30/26 Singleton v. TKG Storage Mart Partners CA1/4
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or
ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION FOUR
DUANE A. SINGLETON,
Plaintiff and Appellant, A174412
v.
TKG STORAGE MART PARTNERS, (Alameda County
Defendant and Respondent. Super. Ct. No. 24CV061018)
Plaintiff Duane A. Singleton, appearing without a lawyer, appeals the
judgment of dismissal entered in favor of defendant TKG Storage Mart Partners
(TKG) after the court sustained without leave to amend TKG’s demurrer to
Singleton’s third amended complaint for breach of contract, fraud, and unjust
enrichment. We affirm the order sustaining the demurrer because Singleton has
failed to meet his burden of demonstrating error on appeal, and we conclude that
the court did not abuse its discretion in denying Singleton leave to amend his
breach of contract and fraud claims. We conclude, however, that the court abused
its discretion in denying Singleton leave to amend his claim for unjust enrichment.
Accordingly, we reverse the judgment and remand for further proceedings.
BACKGROUND
In May 2018, Singleton filed a complaint in the Alameda County Superior
Court under case number RG18906180 against TKG for breach of contract, fraud,
and unjust enrichment arising out of damages to property he stored in units 3106
1
and 2279 of TKG’s facility. In June 2023, after several demurrers and motions to
strike, Singleton’s sixth amended complaint was dismissed with prejudice.
Singleton’s appeal of the judgment to this court was dismissed in October 2023
after Singleton failed to file an opening brief.
In January 2024, Singleton filed the present action against TKG alleging
causes of action for breach of contract, fraud and unjust enrichment based on
damage to property he stored in units 1112 and 1169 of TKG’s facility. The
complaint alleges that “each of my units has become over-ran [sic] with their on-
going [sic] rat infestation” and that unit 1169 “is also overwhelmed with black
mold.” He further alleges that TKG “maliciously charged” him with “vast sums of
unjustified charges” which he “adamantly do[es] refuse to pay.” He accuses TKG of
“getting away with unjustly causing harm” to “the most vulnerable people” with
“overwhelmingly one-sided” contracts which were “always viciously unreadable via
the font used.”
TKG demurred to the complaint on the ground that it failed to state a cause
of action and was barred by the doctrine of res judicata. The court overruled the
demurrer in part and sustained the demurrer in part with leave to file a first
amended complaint.
Singleton’s first amended complaint was filed in May 2024. The complaint
repeats the prior allegations and adds allegations that TKG continues to demand
payment for the storage units, “intentionally overwhelming” him and his ability to
pay; TKG’s contracts are part of an “on-going policy and practice designed to . . .
defraud[] their customers”; and TKG’s breach of contract is “[c]ompounded with the
fact that [TKG] refuse[s] to check for Hantavirus Pulmonary Syndrome via the
brown rat infestation.” As to the claim for unjust enrichment, the first amended
complaint alleges that TKG took his “monies without providing the safe services
that I contracted with them to pay for.” As to the fraud claim, Singleton alleges
2
that the claim is based on the “ ‘unconscionable contract,’ compounded with the
total extent of each and every intentional act/(s) from my contracting with them.”
As to the breach of contract claim, the amendment adds that TKG breached the
contract by “firmly refusing to provide a[] safe environment with a[] vast array of
deceitful actions.”
TKG demurred again arguing that the amended complaint was uncertain and
failed to allege a cause of action. The court sustained the demurrer with leave to
amend. The trial court’s order detailed what additional allegations were necessary
to overcome TKG’s demurrer. The court advised that the cause of action for unjust
enrichment failed to allege that Singleton “has conferred any benefit of any type on
TKG” and to the contrary, alleges “that he has refused to pay the storage fees
charged on his unit.” With respect to the fraud claim, the court explained that
Singleton had not alleged “the name of the person who made the allegedly
fraudulent representation, what that person said or wrote, when, and how the
representation was false and caused Plaintiff to suffer damages.” Finally, as to the
breach of contract claim, the court found that the complaint does not “identify
whether the contract on which this cause of action is based was written, oral, or
implied in fact” and does not “allege the material terms of the contract that
Defendant breached, and how.” The court instructed, “If the contract was written,
Plaintiff shall attach a copy of the contract as an exhibit to his Second Amended
Complaint. If the contract was oral or implied in fact, Plaintiff shall allege when
and how he formed the contract with TKG.”
In January 2025, when an amended complaint was not timely filed, the court
issued an order to show cause why the matter should not be dismissed. However,
after being informed by the court clerk that it erroneously rejected Singleton’s filing
of the second amended complaint, the court withdrew the order to show cause and
directed Singleton to refile the second amended complaint. At a subsequent
3
hearing, Singleton explained that he no longer had a copy of his second amended
complaint because the briefcase that held his legal documents was stolen.
Accordingly, the court granted Singleton permission to file a third amended
complaint.
Singleton thereafter filed his third amended complaint.1 The complaint
realleges the facts set forth above and added the relevant but contradictory new
allegation related to his unjust enrichment claim that TKG took “monies without
providing the safe services that I contracted with them and paid for.” TKG filed a
demurrer to the complaint arguing that all causes of action remain uncertain,
ambiguous, unintelligible, and do not state facts sufficient to constitute a cause of
action. Singleton opposed the demurrer, arguing that TKG is “intentionally
defraud[ing]” people and that the defendant’s demurrers are “just as viciously set
up to[] do harm as the defendant[’s] on-going unconscionable contracts are.” The
court sustained the demurrer without leave to amend. The court explained that
despite being given several opportunities to allege that he had conferred some
benefit on TKG for which restitution should be made, Singleton failed to do so. The
court added, “If Plaintiff did not pay TKG’s charges, there is no basis for a
restitution claim. If, on the other hand, Plaintiff paid TKG pursuant to the terms
of a contract, then Plaintiff cannot state a claim for restitution based on unjust
enrichment.” The court found further that Singleton had previously been granted
leave to amend to allege specific facts in support of a fraud claim but that, to date,
Singleton has not alleged any specific misrepresentations by TKG or any other
facts giving rise to a fraud claim. Finally, the court found that despite having been
given several opportunities, the complaint still fails to allege the terms of any
1 The document bears an apparently erroneous filed-endorsed stamp
date of March 24, 2024. From context we assume the date was March 24,
2025.
4
contract sufficient to support his claim for breach of contract. After ruling on the
demurrer, the court ordered the case dismissed.
DISCUSSION
“On an appeal from a judgment of dismissal entered after a demurrer has
been sustained, the issue is whether, assuming the truth of all well pleaded facts
and those subject to judicial notice, the complaint alleges facts sufficient to state a
cause of action.” (Nealy v. County of Orange (2020) 54 Cal.App.5th 594, 600.) “ ‘If
the complaint states a cause of action under any theory, regardless of the title
under which the factual basis for relief is stated, that aspect of the complaint is
good against a demurrer.’ ” (Denny v. Arntz (2020) 55 Cal.App.5th 914, 920.) When
the demurrer is sustained without leave to amend, we must further decide
“ ‘whether there is a reasonable possibility that the defect can be cured by
amendment: if it can be, the trial court has abused its discretion and we reverse.’ ”
(McKenney v. Purepac Pharmaceutical Co. (2008) 167 Cal.App.4th 72, 78.)
While our review of the sufficiency of the complaint is de novo, appellant still
bears the burden of demonstrating error. (Denny v. Arntz, supra, 55 Cal.App.5th at
p. 920.) “In order to demonstrate error, an appellant must supply the reviewing
court with some cogent argument supported by legal analysis and citation to the
record.” (City of Santa Maria v. Adam (2012) 211 Cal.App.4th 266, 286–287.)
Likewise, while we review the denial of leave to amend for an abuse of discretion,
the “burden of demonstrating a reasonable probability that the defect can be cured
by amendment ‘is squarely on the plaintiff.’ ” (McKenney v. Purepac
Pharmaceutical Co., supra, 167 Cal.App.4th at p. 78.)
I.
Before addressing the merits of the appeal, we note that Singleton’s opening
brief and “addendum” to the opening brief focus to a significant degree on
irrelevant issues. He contends that the court minutes from the hearing on the
5
order to show cause are “false” and seems to suggest that the court erred in
refusing to file his second amended complaint. Singleton was, however, permitted
to file a third amended complaint and the demurrer was subsequently sustained to
that complaint. Accordingly, Singleton was not prejudiced by any confusion
regarding the rejection of his second amended complaint.2
Citing pages 465 to 472 of the clerk’s transcript, he asserts without argument
that the trial court “firmly and consistently” waged “enormous prejudicial acts”
against him. The cited pages of the clerk’s transcript include Singleton’s notice of
appeal in which he makes the following additional arguments in support of his
appeal: First, the third amended complaint “was in fact only my second one that
the court was able to review because the court clerks never filed” the second
amended complaint. Second, because he has been litigating these claims for “a vast
number of years” against the same defendant, TKG is “very well aware of the
germane and material facts of this unconscionable contract case.” Third, the rat
infestation at TKG’s facility poses a considerable health hazard to him and the
general public. The notice of appeal is not the proper vehicle for raising arguments
on appeal. (See Cal. Rules of Court, rules 8.100, 8.200 and 8.204.) In any event, to
the extent relevant, we address these additional arguments below.
II.
Singleton’s opening brief makes no argument challenging the court’s ruling
on his breach of contract or fraud claims. Because Singleton has not met his
burden of demonstrating error, we affirm the order sustaining the demurrer to the
breach of contract and fraud causes of action. (City of Santa Maria v. Adam, supra,
211 Cal.App.4th at pp. 286–287; Golden Day Schools, Inc. v. Department of
2 Singleton also makes an argument about his complaint being assigned
an incorrect case number. We do not understand the argument and are
therefore unable to address it.
6
Education (1999) 69 Cal.App.4th 681, 695, fn. 9 [“An issue merely raised by a party
without any argument or authority is deemed to be without foundation and
requires no discussion”].)
While Singleton suggests in the notice of appeal that he should be allowed to
rely on TKG’s presumed knowledge of the relationship between the parties to allege
a cause of action for breach of contract or fraud, he has not alleged sufficient facts
in support of such reliance. (See Tarmann v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. (1991)
2 Cal.App.4th 153, 158 [specificity requirement may be “ ‘relaxed when the
allegations indicate that “the defendant must necessarily possess full information
concerning the facts of the controversy” [citations] or “when the facts lie more in the
knowledge of the [defendant]” ’ ”].) Nor has he explained what additional facts
might be alleged to cure the defects previously identified by the trial court.
Accordingly, the trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying Singleton leave
to amend these causes of action.
III.
Singleton’s opening brief asserts summarily that the court erred in
sustaining the demurer to his claim for unjust enrichment. As TKG notes, unjust
enrichment is not an independent cause of action. (Durell v. Sharp Healthcare
(2010) 183 Cal.App.4th 1350, 1370 (Durell).) The trial court, however, properly
considered the claim as one for restitution. (Ibid. [“Unjust enrichment is
synonymous with restitution”].) “ ‘Under the law of restitution, “[a]n individual is
required to make restitution if he or she is unjustly enriched at the expense of
another. [Citations.] A person is enriched if the person receives a benefit at
another’s expense. [ Citation.]” [Citation.] However, “[t]he fact that one person
benefits another is not, by itself, sufficient to require restitution. The person
receiving the benefit is required to make restitution only if the circumstances are
7
such that, as between the two individuals, it is unjust for the person to retain it.” ’ ”
(Ibid.)
Singleton argues that “the pleading for unjust enrichment survived a
demurrer” because TKG received a benefit and retained that benefit at the expense
of another. Although the third amended complaint alleges, as set forth above, that
TKG took “monies” from him for “services that he contracted with them and paid
for,” it appears to contradict the allegation earlier in the third amended complaint,
as well as in prior versions of his pleading, that he has refused to pay TKG’s
“unjustified charges.” (See, e.g., Holland v. Morse Diesel Internat., Inc. (2001)
86 Cal.App.4th 1443, 1447 [in ruling on demurrer, court need not accept the truth
of allegations that are contradicted or inconsistent with allegations made in earlier
pleadings].) As the trial court noted, if Singleton did not pay any unjustified
charges, there is no basis for a restitution claim. It is reasonably possible, however,
that additional allegations could remove the apparent inconsistency by clarifying
that, even though there are some charges that Singleton refused to pay, there are
other charges he did pay that TKG has unjustifiably retained. To avoid further
demurrer on this ground, Singleton must allege what amounts, if any, he has paid
TKG, the facts and circumstances surrounding any such payments, and why TKG’s
retention of those amounts is unjust.
In sustaining the demurrer to this cause of action, the trial court offered as
an alternative ground that, if Singleton “paid TKG pursuant to the terms of a
contract, then [he] cannot state a claim for restitution based on unjust enrichment.”
It is true that Singleton alleged that he performed under various contracts—
unidentified but alleged to be both oral and written—and that TKG breached those
contracts by, among other things, failing to maintain a safe environment free from
a rat infestation. But the trial court found those allegations were insufficient to
state a claim for breach of contract, and we explained above that Singleton has not
8
carried his burden to establish error in that decision. We do not think the court
could properly find that the contract was inadequately alleged for the purpose of
stating a cause of action for breach of contract but adequately alleged for the
purpose of defeating Singleton’s cause of action for restitution as a matter of law.
Moreover, in Durell, supra, 183 Cal.App.4th at page 1370, the court held that “an
unjust enrichment claim does not lie where the parties have an enforceable express
contract,” but acknowledged that “restitution may be awarded in lieu of breach of
contract damages when the parties had an express contract, but it was procured by
fraud or is unenforceable or ineffective for some reason.” (Italics added.) Here,
Singleton’s complaint alleges that the contracts are unreadable, “overwhelmingly
one sided,” and designed to defraud customers. In connection with his fraud claim,
he describes the contracts as “unconscionable.”
In sum, while Singleton has not yet supplied allegations sufficient to show
what he paid TKG and why TKG’s retention of that money is unjust, we do not find
that the references to one or more contracts in the complaint foreclose a restitution
cause of action if Singleton amends the complaint to supply the missing
information.
9
DISPOSITION
The judgment is reversed with directions to the court to enter a new order
sustaining TKG’s demurrer to the third amendment complaint, denying leave to
amend as to the breach of contract and fraud claims but granting leave to amend
the unjust enrichment claim. The parties shall bear their own costs on appeal.
(Cal. Rules of Court, rule 8.278(a)(5).)
GOLDMAN, J.
WE CONCUR:
STREETER, Acting P. J.
MOORMAN, J. *
*Judge of the Mendocino Superior Court, assigned by the Chief Justice
pursuant to article VI, section 6 of the California Constitution.
10
Vous vous demandez comment ce texte s’applique à votre situation ?
Consultation gratuite, sans engagement
Décrivez votre situation. Notre équipe vous recontactera par e-mail pour votre consultation.
Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude
Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.