CourtListener 10806795•In re E.M. CA5
Texte intégral
Filed 3/10/26 In re E.M. CA5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIFTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
In re E.M., a Person Coming Under the Juvenile
Court Law.
MERCED COUNTY HUMAN SERVICES F090593
AGENCY,
(Super. Ct. No. 25JP-00002-A)
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v. OPINION
J.M.,
Defendant and Appellant.
THE COURT*
APPEAL from orders of the Superior Court of Merced County. Mark V.
Bacciarini, Judge.
Jamie A. Moran, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for Defendant and
Appellant.
Forrest W. Hansen, County Counsel, and Ann Hanson, Deputy County Counsel,
for Plaintiff and Respondent.
* Before Levy, Acting P. J., Peña, J. and Meehan, J.
-ooOoo-
Appellant, J.M. (mother), is the mother of now 14-year-old E.M. Mother appeals
from orders of the juvenile court finding that the Merced County Human Services
Agency (agency) complied with the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA) and related
California law and that ICWA did not apply to E.M. As her sole contention on appeal is
that the court and the agency failed to comply with ICWA, she requests the matter be
remanded with instructions for the court to ensure full compliance with ICWA inquiry
and notice provisions. The agency concedes a limited remand for the purpose of
compliance with ICWA is appropriate, and we agree. We conditionally reverse the
court’s orders and remand the matter for the limited purpose of compliance with ICWA.
Further, because the parties have submitted a stipulation indicating there are no other
appellate issues other than the ICWA compliance issue discussed herein and seek
immediate remittitur, remittitur shall issue immediately.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
On January 4, 2024, mother, while under the influence of alcohol, got into an
argument with then 13-year-old E.M., threatened her with a knife and a taser, and
threatened to kill her, stating, “ ‘I want you dead.’ ” E.M. fled to their neighbor’s
apartment in fear for her life but mother followed her and got into a verbal and physical
altercation with the neighbors. Mother was arrested.
On January 5, 2025, a social worker interviewed the police officer who responded
to the incident. The officer stated that after the incident E.M. eventually left with
confidential adult 1 (CA 1).1
E.M. reported to the social worker that during a prior incident, she and mother
were in the car when mother became angry and started punching her with a closed fist.
E.M. stated that when these types of incidents occurred, she would call her maternal
1 CA 1 is E.M.’s adult half sister.
2.
grandmother to pick her up because she was afraid of mother, and had stayed with her
maternal grandmother for an extended period of time after a prior incident in 2024. She
also reported incidents in which mother made statements to the effect that she wanted to
commit suicide and kill E.M. She stated mother would also drive under the influence of
alcohol and would swerve the car while saying she wanted to kill herself.
A social worker contacted CA 1. CA 1 stated she received a text message from
E.M. requesting to be picked up from mother’s home because of mother’s aggressive
behavior. CA 1 stated she arrived at the neighbor’s apartment where E.M. and mother
were, and that mother was engaged in a verbal and physical altercation with the
neighbors. CA 1 stated mother tossed her keys at her and began to chase her, stating she
was scared due to mother being under the influence of alcohol. CA 1 stated mother had
engaged in similar aggressive behavior towards her when she was a child and had waved
a knife at her, so mother lost custody of her. She stated E.M. had contacted her before
about mother’s aggression, but this was the first incident that also involved a taser and
knife. She stated that mother had also stabbed mattresses in the past and attempted
suicide by consuming over-the-counter pain medication, 13 years before the current
incident. CA 1 told a social worker that E.M.’s father had never been a part of E.M.’s
life and that she only knew his first name.
A social worker interviewed mother, who reported she drank alcohol daily due to
past trauma and that E.M. knew how to “push [her] buttons.” Mother stated her habit
was to buy three 24-ounce cans of beer and drink them all in one sitting every other day,
as well as consume one 5-liter box of wine within three days. Mother told the social
worker that E.M.’s alleged father, M.R. (father), was chronically homeless, in and out of
jail, abused drugs, had never provided regular care or support for E.M., and that his
3.
whereabouts were unknown.2 The report noted all efforts to locate him were
unsuccessful.
E.M. was detained pursuant to Welfare and Institutions Code section 3003 and
released to the agency for out-of-home placement. Mother, E.M. and CA 1 denied Indian
ancestry. Mother stated to a social worker that father also did not have Indian ancestry.
On January 7, 2025, the agency filed a juvenile dependency petition pursuant to
section 300, subdivisions (a), (b)(1), and (c).
On January 8, 2025, the juvenile court held a detention hearing at which mother
was present. The agency had made an ICWA inquiry as to mother, E.M., the maternal
grandmother, and CA 1. The court questioned mother regarding ICWA, asking her if she
or any member of her extended family were members of an Indian tribe or had received
benefits because of such membership, whether she had attended an Indian boarding
school, had been born on a reservation, had a certificate degree of Indian blood, was on
any roll or census of Indian tribal membership, spoke an Indian language, participated in
tribal political activities such as elections, or participated in tribal cultural activities such
as powwows. Mother answered in the negative to all of the court’s inquiries. After
questioning mother, the court found ICWA did not apply to her. Father was not present
at the hearing, and the court reserved the issue of paternity.
On February 5, 2025, the juvenile court held a jurisdiction hearing. The agency
filed an ICWA-020 form the same day. On the form, mother indicated that “none of the
above apply” in response to all inquiries about Indian ancestry. At the hearing, E.M.’s
maternal grandmother also denied she or any member of her extended family were
members of an Indian tribe or had received benefits of such membership. She also
2 M.R. was adjudicated the father of E.M. in Merced County Family Court case
No. 22FL-01963.
3 Further code references are to the Welfare and Institutions Code.
4.
denied attending an Indian boarding school, having been born on an Indian reservation,
having a certificate degree of Indian blood, being on any roll or census of Indian tribal
membership, speaking an Indian language, participating in tribal political activities such
as an election, or participating in tribal cultural activities such as a powwow. The court
found, based on E.M.’s maternal grandmother’s responses, that ICWA did not apply.
The minute order from the hearing stated, “[t]he [c]ourt finds ICWA does not apply to the
minor regarding the maternal grandmother.”
On March 18, 2025, the juvenile court held a jurisdiction hearing. Mother denied
the allegations of the petition, waived her right to a contested hearing, and submitted the
matter to the court. The court sustained the petition as alleged, declared E.M. a
dependent of the court, removed her from mother’s custody, and placed her in foster care.
On September 13, 2025, the agency submitted a declaration of due diligence
regarding its efforts to locate father as an attachment to its six-month review hearing
report. The agency indicated its search efforts for father were ongoing.
On September 24, 2025, the juvenile court granted mother’s request to set the
matter for a review hearing.
On October 14, 2025, the juvenile court held a contested six-month review
hearing. Mother waived her right to a contested hearing, objected to the agency’s
allegations, and submitted the matter to the court. The court found the agency provided
mother with reasonable reunification services and that the progress by mother to mitigate
or alleviate the causes necessitating E.M.’s removal from her home had been minimal.
The court extended family reunification services for mother to 12 months. The court
found the agency conducted a reasonably diligent search for father, whose whereabouts
remained unknown.
On October 14, 2025, mother timely filed a notice of appeal.
5.
DISCUSSION
Mother contends the agency failed to comply with ICWA’s inquiry and notice
provisions and requests that the matter be remanded with instructions for the juvenile
court to ensure full compliance with ICWA. Here, the parties agree, as do we, that
remand for compliance with ICWA inquiry requirements pursuant to
section 224.2, subdivision (b) is required. The parties have filed a joint application and
request for our court to order a stipulated conditional reversal and limited remand to the
court with directions to order the agency to comply with the inquiry and documentation
provisions set forth in section 224.2, subdivision (b), and California Rules of Court,
rule 5.481(a)(5). The parties stipulate that in all other respects, the court’s orders
extending family reunification services are affirmed.
The agency’s initial ICWA inquiry was made only of E.M., mother, E.M.’s
maternal grandmother, and CA 1. The record does not show whether the agency made
efforts to determine which other extended family members of whom the initial ICWA
inquiry must be made were available for inquiry and what efforts the agency made to
fulfill its duty to actually inquire of those people as to whether ICWA applied to E.M.
Congress enacted ICWA in 1978 to address concerns regarding the separation of
Indian children from their tribes through adoption or foster care placement with
non-Indian families. (In re Isaiah W. (2016) 1 Cal.5th 1, 7.) California adopted the main
provisions of ICWA into statutory law in 2006 and, more recently, amended its own
statutes to conform with additional federal regulations concerning ICWA issued in 2016.
(In re Autumn K. (2013) 221 Cal.App.4th 674, 703–704; In re A.W. (2019) 38
Cal.App.5th 655, 662; Assem. Bill No. 3176 (2017–2018 Reg. Sess.).)
In every dependency proceeding, the juvenile court and the agency have an
affirmative and continuing duty to determine whether ICWA applies. (In re W.B. (2012)
55 Cal.4th 30, 53; In re Gabriel G. (2012) 206 Cal.App.4th 1160, 1165; Cal. Rules of
Court, rule 5.481(a); § 224.2, subd. (a).)
6.
In In re H.V., the juvenile court explained,
“(1) Pursuant to ICWA, ‘[i]n any involuntary proceedings in a State
court, where the court knows or has reason to know that an Indian child is
involved, the party seeking … termination of parental rights to[] an Indian
child shall notify the parent or Indian custodian and the Indian child’s tribe’
of the pending proceedings and its right to intervene. [Citations.] ‘As the
Supreme Court recently explained, notice to Indian tribes is central to
effectuating ICWA’s purpose, enabling a tribe to determine whether the
child involved in a dependency proceeding is an Indian child and, if so,
whether to intervene in or exercise jurisdiction over the matter. [Citation.]’
[Citation.]
“(2) ‘ICWA defines an “Indian child” as “any unmarried person who
is under age eighteen and is either (a) a member of an Indian tribe or (b) is
eligible for membership in an Indian tribe and is the biological child of a
member of an Indian tribe.” [Citations.] The trial court and [agency] have
an affirmative and continuing duty in every dependency proceeding to
determine whether ICWA applies. [Citations.] In cases “where the court
knows or has reason to know that an Indian child is involved,” ICWA
requires the [agency], or other party seeking adoption or foster care
placement, to notify “the Indian child’s tribe, by registered mail with return
receipt requested, of the pending proceedings and of their right of
intervention.” [Citations.]
“(3) ‘Following changes to the federal regulations concerning ICWA
compliance, California made conforming amendments to its statutory
scheme regarding ICWA, effective in 2019. [Citation.] In [In re D.S.
(2020) 46 Cal.App.5th 1041], the court explained that the resulting
clarification of law, found in part in section 224.2, “creates three distinct
duties regarding ICWA in dependency proceedings. First, from the
[agency]’s initial contact with a minor and [her] family, the statute imposes
a duty of inquiry to ask all involved persons whether the child may be an
Indian child. (§ 224.2, subds. (a), (b).) Second, if that initial inquiry
creates a ‘reason to believe’ the child is an Indian child, then the [agency]
‘shall make further inquiry regarding the possible Indian status of the child,
and shall make that inquiry as soon as practicable.’ ([§ 224.2], subd. (e),
italics added.) Third, if that further inquiry results in a reason to know the
child is an Indian child, then the formal notice requirements of
section 224.3 apply. [Citations.]” [Citation.]
“ ‘At the first step, “[s]ection 224.2, subdivision (b) specifies that
once a child is placed into the temporary custody of a county welfare
7.
department, such as the [agency], the duty to inquire ‘includes, but is not
limited to, asking the child, parents, legal guardian, Indian custodian,
extended family members, others who have an interest in the child, and the
party reporting child abuse or neglect, whether the child is, or may be, an
Indian child.’ ” [Citation.]’ ” (In re H.V. (2022) 75 Cal.App.5th 433, 436–
437.)
The agency is required to make “a meaningful effort to locate and interview
extended family members to obtain whatever information they may have as to the child’s
possible Indian status.” (In re K.R. (2018) 20 Cal.App.5th 701, 709.) Pursuant to ICWA,
“ ‘extended family member’ shall be defined by the law or custom of the Indian child’s
tribe or, in the absence of such law or custom, shall be a person who has reached the age
of [18] and who is the Indian child’s grandparent, aunt or uncle, brother or sister,
brother-in-law or sister-in-law, niece or nephew, first or second cousin, or stepparent[.]”
(25 U.S.C. § 1903(2).)
“If a child welfare agency fails to obtain meaningful information or pursue
meaningful avenues of inquiry—by, for example, failing to discover that a parent was
adopted, or failing to inquire further after a parent identified an extended family member
with more information about the child’s potential Indian ancestry—those facts would be
relevant to whether the initial Cal-ICWA inquiry is adequate, not whether the inquiry is
prejudicial. The conditional reversal rule … clearly distinguishes between the separate
issues of whether an inquiry is adequate and whether inquiry error is harmless.” (In re
Dezi C. (2024) 16 Cal.5th 1112, 1151.)
Appeals from ICWA findings by the juvenile court are reviewed for substantial
evidence. (In re H.V., supra, 75 Cal.App.5th at pp. 437–438.) Substantial evidence
supporting the findings and orders must be “ ‘considerable in amount, value or the like;
firmly established, solidly based.’ [¶] … [¶] It must be reasonable in nature, credible,
and of solid value ….” (Estate of Teed (1952) 112 Cal.App.2d 638, 644.)
Here, as the agency concedes, the ICWA notices did not include all relevant
information available to the agency. E.M. was ultimately placed with her maternal aunt,
8.
A.C., and A.C.’s husband, C.C. However, as the record shows, the agency here was
aware of multiple relatives of E.M. who should have been the subject of the initial ICWA
inquiry, but who the agency did not contact. The record also does not show the agency
made any effort to locate E.M.’s paternal relatives, aside from father, and that its efforts
to locate father did not include asking E.M.’s other relatives that it had found where
father was or if any other paternal relatives were available for inquiry. Also, despite
father being adjudicated as E.M.’s father in Merced County and being involved in
15 previous referrals in Merced and Fresno counties, the identities of E.M. and adults
involved in the previous referrals were redacted as confidential in the agency’s reporting,
but the agency’s report does not state whether any of those people were people whom the
agency was required to contact for purposes of the instant ICWA inquiry. The agency’s
report also stated information about placing E.M. with a “maternal great[-]uncle and
maternal great[-]aunt,” but does not specify if this was a reference to A.C. and C.C., with
whom E.M. was placed, or some other unnamed relatives. The record also shows mother
told the social worker she had two sisters and two brothers, but the report does not name
them, nor show whether the agency made any attempt to make an ICWA inquiry of any
maternal aunt, uncle, great- aunt, or great-uncle who mother had mentioned. Further, the
agency’s report does not show it attempted to contact E.M.’s maternal grandfather, who it
was informed was still living, for ICWA inquiry purposes. Accordingly, as the record
does not show the agency complied with locating and notifying E.M.’s “grandparent,
aunt or uncle, brother or sister, brother-in-law or sister-in-law, niece or nephew, first or
second cousin, or stepparent,” the juvenile court did not know when it made its finding
regarding ICWA whether the agency’s ICWA inquiry was complete. (25 U.S.C.
§ 1903(2).)
In addition, we also agree with the parties that the agency did not fulfill its inquiry
obligations pursuant to section 224.2, subdivision (e) insofar as it did not make an
attempt to interview known family members regarding ICWA. (§ 224.2, subd. (e);
9.
§ 224.3, subd. (a)(5).) The record shows that even available relatives of E.M. were not
subject to the agency’s ICWA inquiry, as the record shows the inquiry only included
E.M., mother, E.M.’s maternal grandmother, and CA 1. The record also shows that the
agency only made an initial inquiry of CA 1 but did not report asking her about the
availability of other relatives of E.M. for whom it was required to make an initial ICWA
inquiry. This error also requires reversal. (See In re N.G. (2018) 27 Cal.App.5th 474,
481–482.)
The failure to include such information was prejudicial error requiring reversal.
(See § 224.3, subd. (a)(5)(C) [notice shall include names of all parents, grandparents, and
great-grandparents, if known]; In re A.G. (2012) 204 Cal.App.4th 1390, 1394–1395.)
As a final matter, the parties have submitted a stipulation indicating there are no
appellate issues other than ICWA compliance issues discussed herein and seek immediate
remittitur. Accordingly, remittitur shall issue immediately.
DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s orders finding the agency complied with ICWA inquiry and
notice requirements and that ICWA does not apply to E.M. are conditionally reversed and
the matter is remanded to the court with directions for the court to vacate its ICWA
finding with respect to E.M. and to direct the agency to complete inquiry and notice
provisions in compliance with ICWA. If, after the agency does so, the court finds E.M. is
an Indian child, the court shall proceed in conformity with ICWA. If the court finds E.M.
is not an Indian child, the orders shall be reinstated. Remittitur shall issue immediately.
10.
Vous vous demandez comment ce texte s’applique à votre situation ?
Consultation gratuite, sans engagement
Décrivez votre situation. Notre équipe vous recontactera par e-mail pour votre consultation.
Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude
Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.