CourtListener 10804988•In re Jaydan G. CA1/5
Texte intégral
Filed 3/6/26 In re Jaydan G. CA1/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or
ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION FIVE
In re JAYDAN G. et al., Persons
Coming Under the Juvenile Court
Law.
SAN FRANCISCO HUMAN
SERVICES AGENCY, A174463
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v. (City & County of San Francisco
ASHANTI G., Super. Ct. Nos.
JD24-3150, JD24-3150A)
Defendant and Appellant.
This is an appeal from the denial of the petition of Ashanti G., mother
of two-year-old twins (mother) Jaydan G. and Kaydan G. (minors), to modify
a juvenile court order ending reunification services and terminating her
parental rights over minors based on alleged changed circumstances (Welf. &
Inst. Code, §§ 388, 366.26).1 We affirm.
FACTUAL AND PRCEDURAL BACKGROUND
On September 11, 2024, plaintiff, San Francisco Human Services
Agency (agency), filed a juvenile petition pursuant to section 300,
1 All statutory citations herein are to the Welfare and Institutions
Code.
1
subdivisions (b)(1), (c), and (g), seeking to detain minors due to serious
domestic violence involving mother in minors’ presence, mother’s substance
abuse and mental health issues, and mother’s inability to provide for their
basic needs.
According to the detention report, a mandated reporting party reported
on August 12, 2024, that mother’s boyfriend of eight months had, in front of
minors, punched mother on the shoulder, kicked her in the face, choked her,
and threatened to kill her. When the police responded, they found minors
and mother, but the boyfriend had fled. Mother needed medical attention
and was taken to the hospital. An emergency protective order was issued,
and a family safety plan was immediately developed with mother’s support
network. However, mother thereafter failed to follow up with the agency for
several weeks. Mother missed scheduled meetings, and when the agency
called her, she was evasive and angry with staff. The agency resorted to a
police welfare check on August 23, 2024, during which the police found
minors sleeping on a gym mat on the floor, as well as garbage and clutter
strewn throughout the home. As a result, another child welfare referral was
generated.
A second domestic violence incident was reported on September 7,
2024, despite the fact that mother was working with the agency to develop a
family safety plan. After mother sought refuge at her godmother’s house, she
told the agency’s program director, Ronda Johnson, that the boyfriend kicked
her in the face. The police issued another emergency protective order
protecting mother and minors from the boyfriend. Mother subsequently
reported that, on September 7, the boyfriend appeared in her home using the
back door and refused her demands to leave. Johnson advised mother that
minors would be removed from her care. Johnson explained that while
2
mother was a young, single mother recently emancipated from extended
foster care in 2022, mother required education and support regarding healthy
relationships and protective parenting. The agency was also concerned that
mother had untreated mental health issues and was using marijuana to
manage them. Minors missed their 9- and 12-month child wellness medical
exams and had not visited a doctor since they were six months old.
Minors were placed with a nonrelated, extended family member on
September 9, 2024. At a detention hearing held three days later, mother
appeared and submitted to the detention. The court ordered minors removed
and ordered a minimum of six hours per week of supervised visitation for
mother. Mother advised the court that the identity of the alleged father was
unknown.
On October 24, 2024, the agency filed a disposition report
recommending out-of-home placement. Mother had limited contact with the
agency. While mother mostly refused to discuss the incidents giving rise to
minors’ removal, she acknowledged past incidents of domestic violence
involving the boyfriend, including one wherein he once assaulted mother
while she was holding one minor in her arms. Mother also acknowledged the
boyfriend had assaulted other women, but she nonetheless engaged in a
relationship with him, allowed him to be around minors, and let him back in
her home after he assaulted her.
The agency also noted concerns about mother’s parenting skills.
Mother had neither childproofed her home nor taken responsibility for its
safety. Mother placed food on the floor for minors to eat. She had no
explanation for why minors were over six months behind on their medical
appointments and vaccinations. Further, during supervised visitation,
mother appeared preoccupied on her phone and took little interest in minors.
3
Once, one of the minors escaped the visit room while mother was on her
phone, prompting a social worker to collect him. Another time, mother, after
being told to put away her phone and engage with minors, left after
15 minutes of the visit. She did not say goodbye to minors. Further, on
another visit, mother, again on her phone, failed to console minors, who were
upset and crying.
The agency also reported mother was frequently angry and aggressive
toward supervising staff. She would yell, scream, curse, walk out of meetings
and visitation, or hang up the phone when told something she did not like.
Mother also reported regular marijuana use, which concerned the social
worker since mother was minors’ sole caregiver.
At the jurisdiction/disposition hearing on December 4, 2024, mother
submitted to a first amended petition.2 The court then declared minors
dependents and ordered out-of-home placement, finding reasonable efforts
were made to prevent the need for removal. The court also ordered mother to
participate in reunification services for domestic violence, parenting
education, individual therapy, substance abuse assessment, and drug testing.
A six-month review hearing was scheduled for May 13, 2025.
On April 24, 2025, the agency filed a status review report
recommending termination of mother’s reunification services. Mother
remained in a relationship with her violent boyfriend. Since removal, the
police had been called to her residence for domestic violence six times
between October 27, 2024, and March 16, 2025. Additionally, mother
reported a domestic violence incident occurring on March 16, 2025, wherein
2 A first amended petition was filed on December 4, 2024, which
omitted the allegation in the original petition of serious emotional damage
under section 300, subdivision (c), among other minor amendments not
relevant on appeal.
4
mother retrieved two knives to defend herself. When the police arrived, the
boyfriend reported that mother was trying to kill him. Both mother and the
boyfriend were arrested for domestic violence. During the same time period,
mother failed to engage after being referred for domestic violence services
and refused to go to a domestic violence shelter despite fearing for her life.
Mother also expressed no interest in receiving services to improve her
parenting skills or engaging in therapy.
Further, mother continued to display erratic, irritable, and aggressive
behavior toward the staff involved in her case, especially when she disagreed
with an instruction or request. On one occasion, mother called a social
worker 19 consecutive times. When the social worker, who was in court, was
unable to respond on her cell phone, mother sent her a threatening, expletive-
ridden text message. Mother routinely became enraged during visits, yelling
at the supervising staff and leaving without telling minors goodbye. She also
regularly became irritated with minors and appeared unable to supervise
both of them at the same time. A visit to mother’s home revealed unsafe
conditions and an absence of food. During another visit, the case manager for
a parenting program found two magazines of bullets in a kitchen drawer.
Mother was assessed for substance abuse, with no treatment
recommended. However, the agency remained concerned about mother’s
habitual marijuana use as the sole caregiver to minors.
Minors continued their placement with the “Maternal Great God
Mother,” who was committed to adoption should reunification fail. Minors,
who had been diagnosed with autism spectrum disorder and developmental
delays, needed additional support around their sleeping, daily routines, and
interactions with peers.
5
An addendum report filed on May 22, 2025, noted that during a recent
visit, mother, for the first time, sat down to color with minors and was able to
nurture them when they cried. However, as recently as May 19, 2025,
mother told a social worker that she did not see the benefit of services and
would not discuss domestic violence.
A contested six-month review hearing was held on May 27, 2025. The
agency concluded mother had made “limited to no progress” in addressing the
concerns that brought about the dependency. It recommended terminating
reunification services and selecting adoption as minors’ permanent plan.
Following the hearing, the court agreed with the agency and, thus,
terminated mother’s reunification services, reduced her visits to twice per
month, and scheduled a section 366.26 hearing.
A report filed in anticipation of the section 366.26 hearing noted the
agency remained concerned about the quality of mother’s visits with minors.
Mother continued to exhibit negative and irritable behavior toward staff at
the visits and in front of minors, prompting the service provider to inform the
agency that it would no longer supervise mother’s visits. As such, the agency
stepped in to oversee mother’s visits.
The agency also reported that although minors knew mother and
engaged in play with her, they did not rely on her for safety or emotional
regulation to the same degree they did with their caregiver. The agency
concluded minors were likely to be adopted within a reasonable time and that
adoption would meet their need for legal, physical, and emotional
permanency. Moreover, the caregiver, with whom minors had lived since
September 9, 2024, successfully completed the resource family approval
process. She was committed to adopting minors, understood their diagnoses
6
and needs, and believed she could provide them with the “love and stability
they deserve.”
On September 2, 2025, mother filed a section 388 petition requesting
reinstatement of reunification services on the grounds that her circumstances
had changed since services were terminated. In support of her petition,
mother offered a July 16, 2025, letter from Sister’s Circle Women’s Support
Network (Sister’s Circle) and several negative drug test results. On
September 17, 2025, the court ordered a combined evidentiary hearing on
mother’s section 388 petition and the agency’s permanent plan
recommendation.
A combined hearing under sections 388 and 366.26 was held on
September 24, 2025. Mother, in support of her petition, testified that, since
July 2025, she had participated with Sister’s Circle, which provided domestic
violence support, women’s recovery services, parenting classes, and weekly
random drug testing. She attended Sister’s Circle Monday through Thursday
from 10:00 a.m. to 2:00 p.m. She also attended weekly therapy addressing
domestic violence, anxiety, and depression. Mother drug tested weekly and
was beginning to understand her need to “stop smoking weed,” since using
marijuana was “not more important than [her] children.”
Mother further testified that she was enrolled in weekly parenting
classes and had completed 10 classes. There, she was learning skills for
responding to minors’ needs and comforting them when they were upset.
Mother understood she “messed up” by exposing minors to domestic violence
and not paying them enough attention.
Mother acknowledged that she last used marijuana on her birthday,
September 10, 2025. Mother had not spoken with the social worker and did
7
not wish to do so, but she would if services were reinstated. She was
requesting six more months of services.
The juvenile court denied mother’s section 388 petition, finding that
while mother’s circumstances were “changing” for the better, they had not yet
“changed” to the extent required for minors to safely return to her care.
As such, the court found that awarding mother further services at this late
juncture would not be in minors’ best interests.
The court then turned to the section 366.26 hearing. Cullen Ruiz, the
social worker assigned to the case since June 2025, testified that mother was
engaging in regular supervised visits twice monthly for three hours, with few
recent negative interactions with staff. The agency was supervising the
family’s visits due to earlier incidents of mother’s irritable outbursts toward
the staff of the previous supervising organization. Minors responded
positively to mother during visits and recognized her. However, according to
Ruiz, minors did not have a “strong bond” with mother and had not relied on
her for their needs for “quite some time . . . .” Minors’ caregiver, with whom
they had lived since September 7, 2024, was willing to adopt them and was a
strong advocate for their autism-related needs. Ruiz opined that terminating
parental rights and setting adoption as the permanent plan were in minors’
best interests.
After the hearing, the court found, by clear and convincing evidence,
that minors were adoptable and terminated parental rights. Mother then
timely appealed the court’s denial of her section 388 petition.
DISCUSSION
Mother contends the juvenile court applied the wrong legal standard in
denying her petition under section 388 for reinstatement of reunification
services. As such, mother contends the court’s denial, as well as its
8
subsequent findings and order terminating parental rights pursuant to
section 366.26, must be reversed. We disagree.
Section 388 permits a parent to petition the juvenile court to modify or
set aside a prior court order by demonstrating: (1) a change of circumstances
has occurred and (2) the requested modification is in the child’s best
interests. (§ 388, subd. (a); In re Casey D. (1999) 70 Cal.App.4th 38, 47.)
“[T]he thrust of the legislative scheme is to encourage parents to correct
earlier problems so as to reunite them with their children.” (In re Michael D.
(1996) 51 Cal.App.4th 1074, 1086.) Section 388 thus offers parents an
“ ‘escape mechanism’ ” from a flawed order relating to the parent–child
relationship that is “vital to the constitutionality of the dependency
scheme . . . .” (In re Kimberly F. (1997) 56 Cal.App.4th 519, 528, italics
omitted.)
On appeal, we review an order denying a parent’s petition under
section 388 for abuse of discretion. (In re Stephanie M. (1994) 7 Cal.4th 295,
318.) It is an abuse of discretion for the juvenile court to misapply governing
law. (Doe 2 v. Superior Court (2005) 132 Cal.App.4th 1504, 1517.)
Here, we find no abuse of discretion. In considering whether a parent
has made the necessary showing under section 388, “the juvenile court may
consider the entire factual and procedural history of the case,” including
“factors such as the seriousness of the reason leading to the child’s removal,
the reason the problem was not resolved, the passage of time since the child’s
removal, the relative strength of the bonds with the child, the nature of the
change of circumstance, and the reason the change was not made sooner.”
(In re Mickel O. (2011) 197 Cal.App.4th 586, 616 (Mickel O.).)
The juvenile court met this standard. After hearing mother’s testimony
and argument from counsel, the court summarized the facts of the case and
9
commended mother for her recent progress, stating that her positive actions
“take[] courage.” Nonetheless, the court denied the petition, finding that
mother’s recent engagement with Sister’s Circle and focus on therapy and
limiting her marijuana use constituted “changing” circumstances, not
changed circumstances, for the purposes of section 388. In particular, the
court noted that mother admitted she continued to use THC and was
unwilling to speak or engage with Social Worker Ruiz. She also failed to
provide proof of negative drug tests for September and August or information
from providers corroborating her testimony. And, the court noted, it had only
been a few months since she interacted with her abusive former boyfriend.
Thus, based on the record as a whole, the court found that reinstating
mother’s services would not be in minors’ best interests because it would not
promote their need for permanency and stability, particularly in light of their
autism diagnoses and developmental delays.
The juvenile court’s analysis and conclusions were well reasoned and
soundly based on evidence in the record. Accordingly, there is no basis for
finding the court abused its discretion in denying mother’s section 388
petition. (In re Stephanie M., supra, 7 Cal.4th at p. 318 [juvenile court’s
ruling should not be disturbed unless it is “clearly established” that the court
“ ‘ “exceeded the limits of legal discretion by making an arbitrary, capricious,
or patently absurd determination” ’ ”].)
In so holding, we reject mother’s claim that the court misapplied the
statutory framework by “requir[ing] fully changed circumstances,
discount[ing] recent improvement as insufficient as a matter of law, and
appl[ying] this mistaken view to both prongs of the analysis.” To begin,
mother’s argument disregards fundamental rules of appellate law: We
presume the juvenile court’s ruling is correct, and we resolve all conflicts in
10
favor of the ruling and indulge all legitimate inferences to uphold the court’s
determinations. (In re K.S. (2016) 244 Cal.App.4th 327, 337.) Under this
lens, the court did none of the things mother claims. Indeed, as the court
acknowledged at the hearing, “[its] goal was to promote the children’s best
interests, which at this point were permanency and stability . . . .” (Mickel O.,
supra, 197 Cal.App.4th at p. 617; see § 388 subd. (a).) The court did just that.
Mother’s lingering issues with using marijuana, her unwillingness to
cooperate with the agency in its efforts to provide her services, and her just
recent separation from an abusive former boyfriend supported the court’s
determination that minors’ adoption by a loving and capable caregiver
attentive to their special needs would best promote their primary interests in
permanency and stability.
DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s findings and order of September 24, 2025, are
affirmed.
Jackson, P. J.
WE CONCUR:
Simons, J.
Burns, J.
A174463/S.F. Human Services Agency v. Ashanti G.
11
Vous vous demandez comment ce texte s’applique à votre situation ?
Consultation gratuite, sans engagement
Décrivez votre situation. Notre équipe vous recontactera par e-mail pour votre consultation.
Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude
Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.