CourtListener 10804507•In re M.C. CA2/6
Texte intégral
Filed 3/5/26 In re M.C. CA2/6
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION SIX
In re M.C., a Person Coming 2d Juv. No. B348066
Under the Juvenile Court (Super. Ct. Nos. 23JV00430,
Law. 23JV00430A, 23JV00430B,
23JV00430C)
(Santa Barbara County)
THE PEOPLE,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
M.C.,
Defendant and Appellant.
M.C. was charged in four separate juvenile petitions with
various offenses, including first degree murder, committed when
he was 17 years old. He appeals from the juvenile court’s order
transferring him to a court of criminal jurisdiction pursuant to
Welfare and Institutions Code section 707.1 He contends the
juvenile court abused its discretion by failing to properly evaluate
the criterion as required by section 707, subdivision (a). We
affirm.
Facts of the Alleged Offenses
On December 9, 2023, at approximately 2:26 p.m., police
responded to reports of shots fired at Oakley Park in Santa
Maria. Upon arrival, officers located 15-year-old Jesus Cabrera
lying face down on the ground, covered in blood, and suffering
multiple gunshot wounds. Cabrera was transported to the
hospital where he was declared deceased. An autopsy revealed
he had been shot once in the back and the bullet exited through
his left cheek.
Police interviewed several witnesses who reported hearing
two to three gunshots and seeing several vehicles leaving the
scene immediately after the shooting. Police obtained
surveillance video from the area, which showed several vehicles
parked south of the pathway near where Cabrera was walking.
Cabrera paused briefly before running away as the first gunshot
was heard. Approximately two seconds later, a second gunshot
was heard, and Cabrera collapsed. After the shooting, an
individual wearing dark clothing was observed bending down and
retrieving an item believed to be a spent shell casing before
fleeing. Police later retrieved a nine-millimeter shell casing from
the scene.
Investigators identified the three vehicles from the
surveillance video, including a black Chevrolet Impala, which
was registered to appellant’s mother. Officers conducted a search
1All further undesignated statutory references are to the
Welfare and Institutions Code.
2
of appellant’s residence and recovered a black, non-serialized
semiautomatic handgun concealed inside a jacket. A nine-
millimeter shell casing was also recovered from inside the
Chevrolet Impala. Appellant was taken into custody and booked
at the Juvenile Justice Center (JJC).
Ballistics testing linked the firearm recovered from
appellant’s residence to the Oakley Park shooting as well as
several other shootings that had occurred in the area.
Investigators also linked the Chevrolet Impala to other cases and
reviewed surveillance video showing the vehicle in an area
claimed by the West Park criminal street gang.
Other Shooting Incidents
On December 11, 2023, officers responded to a shooting at a
Santa Maria motel. Surveillance video showed an individual
entering and exiting the motel multiple times before pointing and
firing a handgun at an occupied room. Ballistics evidence
recovered from the scene tied the firearm used in the motel
shooting to the firearm recovered from appellant’s residence.
In January 2024, investigators reviewing various social
media accounts discovered a group chat related to a prior
shooting incident from August 6, 2023. In the group chat, several
individuals conspired to rob the victim of his firearm. Appellant
also discussed destroying evidence by taking the firearm used in
the shooting to an unknown individual to replace the barrel,
slide, fire pin, and ejector, which would create a new ballistic
profile and prevent law enforcement from linking the firearm to
other cases.
On September 29, 2023, officers responded to reports of
shots fired. The victim, M.M., reported that several juveniles had
challenged him to a fight, and one exposed a handgun. The
3
group of juveniles continued walking, when the suspect with the
handgun fired a shot in M.M.’s direction. M.M. believed he was
targeted due to his perceived affiliation with the Northwest
Criminal Street gang, a rival of West Park. M.M. described the
juveniles as members of “Step Team,” a crew from West Park,
who had been tagging in M.M.’s alley.
Investigators concluded that appellant was involved in the
shooting based on descriptions, social media posts, group chats,
and appellant’s school absence records.
Section 602 Petitions
Case No. 23JV00430
In December 2023, the People filed a section 602 petition
alleging appellant committed first degree murder (Pen. Code, §
187, subd. (a)(1), count 1), with special allegations of street
terrorism (Pen. Code, § 186.22, subd. (b)(1)(C)), and a principal’s
intentional discharge of a firearm causing great bodily injury and
death (Pen. Code, § 12022.53, subds. (b)-(e)(1)). The People
requested a hearing to determine whether appellant should be
transferred to the jurisdiction of the criminal court pursuant to
section 707. Appellant was ordered detained in juvenile hall.
Case No. 23JV00430-A
In March 2024, the People filed a second section 602
petition, alleging appellant committed assault with a firearm
(Pen. Code, § 245, subd. (a)(2), count 1), shooting at an inhabited
dwelling (Pen. Code, § 246, count 2), and having a concealed,
unregistered firearm (Pen. Code, § 25400, subd. (a)(2)). As to
counts 1 and 2, it was alleged that appellant committed the
offenses for the benefit of or at the direction of or in association
with a criminal street gang (Pen. Code, § 186.22, subd. (b)(1)(B)).
4
Case No. 23JV00430-B
In April 2024, the People filed a third section 602 petition
alleging appellant committed accessory after the fact to the crime
of attempted robbery (Pen. Code, § 32, count 1), with the special
allegation of street terrorism (Pen. Code, § 186.22, subd. b)(1)(a)).
The petition also alleged two counts of possession of firearm by a
minor (Pen. Code, § 29610, subd. (c), counts 2 & 3), with a gang
enhancement (Pen. Code, § 186.22, subd. (d)).
Case No. 23JV00430-C
In June 2024, the People filed a fourth section 602 petition
alleging appellant committed assault with a firearm (Pen. Code, §
245, subd. (a)(2), count 1) and conspiracy to commit assault with
a firearm (Pen. Code, § 182, subd. (a)(1)), with special allegations
of street terrorism as to each count (Pen. Code, § 186.22, subd.
(b)(1)).
The People requested a hearing as to each of the
subsequently filed petitions to determine whether appellant
should be transferred to the jurisdiction of the criminal court
pursuant to section 707.
Transfer Hearing
The juvenile court conducted a contested transfer hearing.
The People presented witness testimony and documentary
evidence, including police reports, appellant’s juvenile records, a
gang enhancement report, the transfer evaluation report, and
various other documents.
Probation Officer Brianna Cantero
Santa Barbara Probation Officer Brianna Cantero prepared
the fitness/transfer report recommending appellant be
transferred to a court of criminal jurisdiction. In preparing her
report, Cantero interviewed appellant, his parents, the
5
detectives, and attended a treatment team meeting. She
examined appellant’s social history, including his relationship
with his parents and appellant’s disclosure of sexual abuse by a
babysitter when he was eight years old. Cantero testified that
appellant was not amenable to rehabilitation while under the
jurisdiction of the juvenile court based primarily on the
sophistication of the crime, the length of services that would be
offered to him at JJC, and the gravity of the offense.
Probation Officer Daniel Nava
Daniel Nava worked as a probation officer at JJC and was
in charge of the Arise and PEAK programs, which counseled
youths to leave gangs. He testified that appellant did not ask for
help to facilitate dropping out of his gang.
Dr. Amy Watt
Dr. Amy Watt, a clinical psychologist, prepared the transfer
evaluation report, examined the five transfer criteria, and
concluded appellant did not meet the criteria to remain in the
juvenile court system. In preparing her evaluation, Dr. Watt
reviewed police reports and various school and juvenile records,
but did not interview appellant. Dr. Watt testified that appellant
did not suffer from any developmental issues, but noted a history
of varied school performance, behavioral difficulties, and low
grades.
In examining the sophistication criteria and the original
petition, Dr. Watt noted the shooting appeared to be gang-
related, involved planning, and knowledge about how to prevent
shell casings from being traced. She also noted that appellant
communicated with another gang member and advised him how
to get rid of the gun and change parts of the gun to prevent it
from being traced. When police searched his home, appellant
6
attempted to hide the firearm in his parents’ bedroom to avoid
taking responsibility for the offense. Dr. Watt found this
criterion applied.
As to appellant’s potential for rehabilitation, Dr. Watt
believed it was “unclear” whether this criterion was met. She
noted that appellant had a tendency to behave differently in
different settings with different people. For example, he
presented very well when interviewed by probation and his
therapist, and was described as respectful. But the juvenile
records indicated otherwise. Dr. Watt noted that appellant had
demonstrated improved behavior but expressed concern that such
improvement had been situational and influenced by the pending
transfer proceedings rather than sustained rehabilitation. She
opined that if appellant were put back with other gang members,
there might be behavior difficulties. As to this criterion, Dr. Watt
was neutral.
As to appellant’s delinquent history, Dr. Watt noted that
appellant had a number of police contacts for “minor offenses”
and he had not been arrested “a lot” before the offense in 2023.
However, Dr. Watt believed this criterion applied given
appellant’s strong association with the gang and his conduct in
juvenile hall.
As to appellant’s previous attempts to rehabilitate, Dr. Watt
noted that although appellant had never been on probation in the
community, the fact that he was arrested for the current shooting
incident in December 2023, indicated that any previous attempts
to rehabilitate were unsuccessful. Dr. Watt concluded this
criterion favored transfer.
As to the circumstances and gravity of the offense, Dr. Watt
found this criterion applied. She noted there were a number of
7
shootings that occurred over a short period of time, which
involved the same gun, were all gang related, and were
“extremely serious.”
Given appellant’s behavior in custody, including fighting,
defiance of authority, smoking marijuana, staging an escape
attempt, coordinating others to distract staff, and his ongoing,
strong focus on gang rivalry and violence, Dr. Watt believed
appellant should be transferred to adult court.
Detective Juan Rubio
Santa Barbara Police Detective Juan Rubio testified that
replacing the slide on a firearm completely replaces the ejector,
the firing pin, and the barrel, which is significant because such a
modification changes the ballistic profile of the firearm and
makes it difficult to link to other cases.
Detective Ruben Peinado
Detective Ruben Peinado works for the Santa Maria Gang
Suppression Team. He prepared the gang packet, which
contained numerous photos of appellant and other West Park
gang members making gang signs. Detective Peinado testified
that appellant was an active gang member in good standing with
the West Park criminal street gang.
Warden Raythel Fisher, Jr.
Warden Fisher, now retired, worked as the warden of Valley
State Prison in Chowchilla from 2014 to 2021. He testified that
the programs offered through juvenile hall were insufficient to
help gang members who are already entrenched in gangs to drop
out.
Defense counsel did not present any witnesses.
8
The Juvenile Court’s Ruling
In July 2025, the juvenile court granted the motion to
transfer appellant’s case to adult criminal court. In a detailed
ruling, the juvenile court acknowledged the People’s burden to
prove, by clear and convincing evidence, that appellant was not
amenable to rehabilitation while under the jurisdiction of the
juvenile court. The juvenile court analyzed each of the five
statutory factors set forth in section 707, considered the totality
of the evidence, explained how that evidence applied to each
statutory factor, and ultimately concluded appellant was not
amenable to rehabilitation under its jurisdiction.
Degree of Criminal Sophistication
The juvenile court found the offenses alleged in each
petition were committed with “criminal sophistication” and
“demonstrate[d] a pattern of intentional offenses” committed by
appellant for the benefit of his gang. The juvenile court cited
appellant’s age, his status as an active gang member, and noted
that the alleged offenses were not the result of “impetuosity” but
were committed with deliberation and purpose. As to the original
petition, appellant shot and killed a 15 year old as he ran away.
After the shooting, appellant or one of his companions picked up
the shell casings in an effort to conceal evidence and made no
effort to assist the victim.
As to Petition A, the juvenile court found the alleged
offense did not exhibit a high degree of sophistication but was
nonetheless deliberate and committed with the clear intent to
terrorize the victim. As to Petition B,2 the juvenile court found
2 The juvenile court noted that Petition B does not allege a
felony offense listed in section 707, subdivision (b), but
nevertheless considered the facts underlying the petition to
9
appellant demonstrated a “high level of knowledge and
sophistication” regarding altering a firearm to eliminate
evidence. As to Petition C, the juvenile court found the offense,
which consisted of shooting at a victim, his house, and vehicle on
multiple occasions, was done in attempt to intimidate the victim.
Additionally, the casings found at the scene matched the firearm
found in appellant’s home, and the victim was believed to be
affiliated with a rival gang.
The juvenile court acknowledged appellant’s past trauma
but found it did not mitigate against or explain his conduct. The
juvenile court further noted that there is no evidence that
appellant suffered from an intellectual disability, developmental
delays, or any notable mental health or emotional issues that
would explain or form the basis for his criminal behavior.
Instead, appellant had a “lengthy work history,” which showed
his ability to conform and engage in lawful activity. The juvenile
court found the only consistent factor and motivation underlying
appellant’s behavior is his gang affiliation.
The juvenile court also noted that appellant’s gang
involvement demonstrated criminal sophistication through his
use of social media to coordinate gang activities. His behavior in
custody further demonstrated his criminal sophistication,
including coordinating other youth in disruptive conduct, gang-
related fights, and disobedience. Appellant was seen as a leader
within his gang. Based on the totality of the evidence, the
juvenile court concluded this criterion weighed in favor of
transfer.
evaluate the “totality of the circumstances” in determining
whether to transfer appellant to adult criminal court. (Citing
Cal. Rules of Court, Rule 5.770, Advisory Committee Comment.)
10
Amenability to Rehabilitation Prior to Expiration of Juvenile
Jurisdiction
In analyzing this criterion, the juvenile court noted that
appellant had already been detained for approximately one year
and seven months. During the majority of that time, appellant
engaged in numerous instances of disruptive behavior, including
threatening staff, refusing to follow directions, engaging in gang-
related fights, flashing gang signs, and possession of contraband.
Appellant continued to deny any gang affiliation even though
many of the incidents were gang related. The juvenile court
acknowledged that appellant’s behavior had recently improved,
but attributed it to appellant’s concerns about a transfer to
criminal court rather than a sincere desire to rehabilitate. The
juvenile court concluded, “Based upon the evidence presented,
[the] court cannot find that sufficient time exists for
rehabilitation of the youth before expiration of juvenile
jurisdiction.”
Previous Delinquent History
The juvenile court noted appellant had two prior referrals
to juvenile probation for minor offenses. This criterion weighed
against transfer.
Success of Previous Attempts to Rehabilitate Minor
The juvenile court gave no weight to this criterion, noting
that appellant had only engaged in two prior informal diversion
programs.
Circumstances and Gravity of the Alleged Offenses
The juvenile court observed that the offense alleged in the
original petition involved the most serious and grave possible
harm, the loss of life. Appellant confronted a 15-year-old minor,
then “callously shot and killed him as he was running away” by
shooting him in the back. Appellant’s actions were not the
11
product of rage or impetuosity, but were deliberate and
intentional. The additional charges also involved violent and
calculated assaults with a firearm against other individuals. The
juvenile court found this criterion “weighs heavily for transfer.”
Discussion
Appellant contends the juvenile court abused its discretion
in three ways by: (1) failing to properly consider appellant’s
community environment and childhood trauma in evaluating the
degree of criminal sophistication; (2) improperly discounting
appellant’s recent positive behavior and relying on speculation
about his motives when evaluating his potential for
rehabilitation; and (3) failing to analyze how appellant’s trauma
affected his development when evaluating the gravity of the
offense. As we shall explain, we disagree.
We review the juvenile court’s determination to transfer a
minor to criminal court for abuse of discretion. (In re J.S. (2024)
105 Cal.App.5th 205, 211 (J.S).) “The court’s factual findings are
reviewed for substantial evidence, and its legal conclusions are
reviewed de novo. [Citation.] A decision based on insufficient
evidence or the court’s ‘“erroneous understanding of applicable
law’” is subject to reversal. [Citation.]” (Kevin P. v. Superior
Court (2020) 57 Cal.App.5th 173, 187.)
Section 707 provides that the People may move to transfer
to adult court any minor 16 years of age or older alleged to have
committed one of several enumerated offenses, including murder.
(Id., subds. (a)(1), (b)(1).) To prevail on this motion, the People
must establish, by clear and convincing evidence, that the minor
is “not amenable to rehabilitation while under the jurisdiction of
the juvenile court.” (Id., subd. (a)(3); In re S.S. (2023) 89 Cal.
12
App.5th 1277, 1288 [“‘amenab[ility] to rehabilitation’” is the
“ultimate determination”]; J.S., supra, 105 Cal.App.5th at p. 212
[same].)
In making this determination, the juvenile court must
consider five specific factors: (1) “[t]he degree of criminal
sophistication exhibited by the minor” (§ 707, subd. (a)(3)(A)(i));
(2) “[w]hether the minor can be rehabilitated prior to the
expiration of the juvenile court’s jurisdiction” (id., subd.
(a)(3)(B)(i)); (3) “[t]he minor’s previous delinquent history” (id.,
subd. (a)(3)(C)(i)); (4) “[s]uccess of previous attempts by the
juvenile court to rehabilitate the minor” (id., subd. (a)(3)(D)(i));
and (5) “[t]he circumstances and gravity of the offense alleged in
the petition to have been committed by the minor” (id., subd.
(a)(3)(E)(i)). “The weight to be given each of these factors is
within the court’s discretion.” (D.W. v. Superior Court (2019) 43
Cal.App.5th 109, 116.)
The statute also sets forth a nonexhaustive list of relevant
factors for the juvenile court to consider with respect to each of
the five criteria. (§ 707, subds. (a)(3)(A)(ii), (B)(ii), (C)(ii), (D)(ii),
(E)(ii).) If the juvenile court orders a transfer to criminal court, it
must “recite the basis for its decision in an order entered upon
the minutes, which shall include the reasons supporting the
court’s finding that the minor is not amenable to rehabilitation
while under the jurisdiction of the juvenile court.” (Id., subd.
(a)(3).)
Application of Section 707 Transfer Criteria
Degree of Criminal Sophistication
When evaluating the degree of criminal sophistication
exhibited by the minor, section 707 requires the juvenile court to
“give weight to any relevant factor, including, but not limited to,
13
the minor’s age, maturity, intellectual capacity, and physical,
mental, and emotional health at the time of the alleged offense;
the minor’s impetuosity or failure to appreciate risks and
consequences of criminal behavior; the effect of familial, adult, or
peer pressure on the minor’s actions; the effect of the minor’s
family and community environment; the existence of childhood
trauma; the minor’s involvement in the child welfare or foster
care system; and the status of the minor as a victim of human
trafficking, sexual abuse, or sexual battery on the minor’s
criminal sophistication.” (Id., subd. (a)(3)(A)(ii).)
Appellant contends the juvenile court misapplied the
criminal sophistication criterion by failing to consider his
community environment, including evidence of gang violence and
how that may have influenced his development and behavior as
required by section 707, subdivision (a)(3)(A).
While the juvenile court is required to give weight to “any
relevant factor,” including those identified under each criterion,
nothing in the statute obligates the juvenile court to exhaustively
detail how it assessed every such factor in its written ruling.
(See J.S., supra, 105 Cal.App.5th at pp. 213-214 [juvenile court’s
express consideration of the evidence, including reports, exhibits,
and witness testimony, necessarily included evidence of
appellant’s social, emotional, and intellectual history]; People v.
Myers (1999) 69 Cal.App.4th 305, 310 [“The court is presumed to
have considered all of the relevant factors”].) Accordingly, this
contention fails.
Appellant’s contention that the juvenile court “erroneously
dismissed” the relevance of his childhood trauma and sexual
abuse also fails. The juvenile court properly considered
appellant’s trauma, but concluded it did not mitigate or explain
14
his conduct. Indeed, Dr. Watt noted there was no documented
mental health issues requiring treatment or medication. The
juvenile court could reasonably find that appellant’s trauma was
not entitled to significant weight and was well within its
discretion to do so when considering all of the relevant factors
under this criterion.
Potential for Rehabilitation in Juvenile Justice System
Appellant contends the juvenile court erred in finding that
he could not be rehabilitated within the remaining six years in
the juvenile court’s jurisdiction. He claims his recent positive
behavior constitutes substantial evidence of rehabilitation
potential and the court’s reliance on speculation about his
motives was improper. We are not persuaded.
Here, the juvenile court noted that appellant had been in
custody for approximately 19 months. During the majority of
that time, he engaged in a pattern of behavior, much of it gang
related, which demonstrated a “lack of interest in programming
and rehabilitation.” The juvenile court acknowledged appellant’s
positive behavior, and commended him for it, but noted it was
“very recent.” The juvenile court did not rely on speculation, but
considered all of the evidence and information in making its
decision as to this criterion. Appellant may have weighed the
evidence differently, but that does not amount to error. (See
People v. Kraft (2000) 23 Cal.4th 978, 1054; People v. Thomas
(1992) 2 Cal.4th 489, 514.)
Circumstances and Gravity of the Offense
Appellant contends the juvenile court abused its discretion
because it failed to analyze how his trauma affected his
development when evaluating the gravity of the offense. This
contention fails. Regardless of appellant’s mindset, the charged
15
offenses were grave and serious, with murder being “one of the
most serious offenses.” (See Williams v. Superior Court (1983) 34
Cal.3d 584, 593.)
On this record, substantial evidence supports the juvenile
court’s finding that appellant is not amenable to rehabilitation
while under the jurisdiction of the juvenile court. It therefore
reasonably exercised its discretion to transfer appellant to adult
criminal court.
Disposition
The order is affirmed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.
YEGAN, Acting P. J.
We concur:
BALTODANO, J.
CODY, J.
16
Gustavo Lavayen, Judge
Superior Court County of Santa Barbara
______________________________
Laura Vavakin, under appointment by the Court of Appeal,
for Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Charles C. Ragland, Chief
Assistant Attorney General, Susan Sullivan Pithey, Senior
Assistant Attorney General, Scott A. Taryle, Supervising Deputy
Attorney General, and David A. Wildman, Deputy Attorney
General, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
Vous vous demandez comment ce texte s’applique à votre situation ?
Consultation gratuite, sans engagement
Décrivez votre situation. Notre équipe vous recontactera par e-mail pour votre consultation.
Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude
Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.