CourtListener 10793873•In re Amy V. CA2/1
Texte intégral
Filed 2/13/26 In re Amy V. CA2/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
In re AMY V. et al., Persons B346332
Coming Under the Juvenile (Los Angeles County
Court Law. Super. Ct. No. 24CCJP04038)
LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF
CHILDREN AND FAMILY
SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
J.G.,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from the dispositional order of the Superior Court
of Los Angeles County, Syna N. Dennis, Judge. Affirmed in part
and reversed in part.
Akila A. Shenoy, under appointment by the
Court of Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Jessica S. Mitchell, Principal
Deputy County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
____________________
In this appeal in a dependency case, mother (J.G.), who was
nonoffending, challenges only that part of the juvenile court’s
dispositional order requiring her to attend a support group for
domestic violence. We agree with mother that this requirement
constitutes an abuse of discretion. Although father perpetrated
domestic violence, mother and father ended their relationship a
decade before the dependency proceedings commenced.1 At the
time of the dependency proceedings before us, mother was not in
an abusive relationship. Additionally, the children were safe in
mother’s custody and remained there throughout the dependency
proceedings. Father’s abusive conduct against his partner, Y.L.,
also does not support an order requiring mother to attend a
domestic violence support group. Accordingly, we reverse that
requirement in the juvenile court’s disposition order and affirm
the court’s dispositional order in all other respects.
BACKGROUND
Mother and father ended their relationship in 2014. Father
has two sons with mother, Angel and Adrian, and two daughters,
Amy and Alexa. Father has four additional children with Y.L.,
who also has a child from a different relationship. In 2020, father
1 Father is not a party to this appeal.
2
was arrested for carrying a loaded gun, a charge that was later
dismissed. In 2024, father was arrested for child abuse and
possession of an assault weapon. The record does not show
whether he was charged with those crimes.
Throughout the dependency proceedings, the children
remained in mother’s custody. Mother worked as a medical
assistant.
1. Petition
In December 2024, the Los Angeles County Department of
Children and Family Services (DCFS) filed a petition naming
Angel (17 years), Amy (16 years), Adrian (14 years), and Alexa
(13 years) as dependents. As later sustained, the petition alleged
father sexually abused Amy and this sexual abuse placed Amy,
Alexa, and Adrian at risk of sexual abuse in the future. The
juvenile court struck Angel from the petition.
No allegation in the petition involved mother or alleged
domestic violence.
2. DCFS reports
It is undisputed that father sexually abused Amy. DCFS
reported in December 2024, mother took Amy to the hospital as
soon as Amy told mother about father’s sexual abuse. DCFS
described mother as “behav[ing] in a protective capacity by
taking Amy to be assessed at the hospital following her
disclosure.” When interviewed by a social worker, mother
reported father’s past domestic violence. Mother told the social
worker there was no physical violence since she and father ended
their relationship in 2014.
Amy told the social worker that over a two-year period,
father repeatedly touched her inner thigh and on some of those
3
occasions, Amy observed father having an erection. On one
occasion, father told Amy to “grab his dick” but she refused. Amy
wanted to continue living with mother and did not want to live
with or visit father. Amy reported that in the past, mother and
father had “an abusive relationship.” Amy stated, “ ‘[Father]
used to hit my mom all the time.’ ” Amy also observed father hit
Y.L. Amy reported father hit her with a belt on her leg.
Alexa told the social worker father “touched her thighs once
or twice.” Alexa also reported father touched her “ ‘inner thigh’ ”
but “ ‘[n]ot in a sexual way . . . .’ ” Father asked to look at Alexa’s
“butt.” Alexa further reported Amy was afraid to tell mother
about father’s conduct because father “had threatened mom
before” and Alexa warned Amy not to “ ‘put [mother] in danger.’ ”
In approximately 2014, Alexa saw father hit mother once. More
recently, Alexa saw father hit Y.L. Alexa told the social worker
she was scared of father.
Angel told a social worker that in approximately 2018, he
observed a physical fight between mother and father. Angel
did not observe father touch Amy in a sexual manner, but he
observed father hit Amy with a belt.
Adrian told the social worker he preferred to live with
father. Adrian did not believe father sexually abused his sisters.
3. Interviews with forensic evaluator
Amy told a forensic evaluator that father asked her, “ ‘Are
you posing like that to give me a boner? . . . While grabbing his
dick . . . Do you touch yourself? Show me how you touch yourself.
How many fingers do you use to masturbate?’ ” Amy also
reported father rubbed her back and upper inner thigh. On one
occasion in the car, father said he “was getting an erection and
told Amy to grab his dick.” Amy also reported to the forensic
4
evaluator father physically abused her when she dated a person
her father did not like and that mother saw bruises caused by
father. Amy recounted that father beat Y.L.
Alexa told the forensic evaluator she heard father ask Amy,
“ ‘Let me see how you do it? Do you want to touch it?’ ” Alexa
reported father asked her the same questions. On another
occasion, father asked to look at Alexa’s butt. Alexa also reported
being afraid of father because he hit her. Alexa said mother saw
a bruise after father hit her. Alexa saw father hit Amy.
4. Jurisdictional dispositional hearing
No witness testified at the jurisdictional and dispositional
hearing. With respect to disposition, mother’s counsel argued,
inter alia, a domestic violence support group was not necessary.
Counsel for DCFS responded: The “Department is asking for
domestic violence classes for mother and father because all the
minors except [one] recall domestic violence incidents between
mother and father. [¶] Amy and Alexa reported that father has
hit the stepmother . . . .”
The juvenile court found, “I do think that domestic violence
support group for victims would be appropriate in this case. I
understand that the allegations regarding domestic violence were
not pled in this petition and there was no allegation of domestic
violence sustained and the . . . last reported incident may have
been several years ago. [¶] But in the reports, the children do
report that domestic violence was going on, and they specifically
reported that they did not tell the mother about the sexual abuse
because they were afraid that the father would hurt the mother.
So there’s some issues going on here today concerning domestic
violence, and I am going to be including that on the mother’s case
plan.”
5
5. The court’s dispositional orders concerning mother
The court ordered mother to participate in individual
counseling to address case issues. The court also ordered mother
to attend sex abuse awareness counseling and to participate in
family preservation services. Finally, the court ordered mother
to attend a support group for victims of domestic violence, the
order mother challenges on appeal.
DISCUSSION
“ ‘The juvenile court has broad discretion to determine
what would best serve and protect the child’s interests and to
fashion a dispositional order accordingly. On appeal, this
determination cannot be reversed absent a clear abuse of
discretion.’ [Citation.]” (In re Briana V. (2015) 236 Cal.App.4th
297, 311.) The juvenile court’s discretion extends to order a
nonoffending parent attend programs. (Ibid.) Indeed, “the court
may make ‘all reasonable orders for the care, supervision,
custody, conduct, maintenance, and support of the child . . . .’
[Citation.]” (In re Jasmin C. (2003) 106 Cal.App.4th 177, 180.)
The court, however, may not order a class where the class
would benefit neither the parent nor the child. (In re Jasmin C.,
supra, 106 Cal.App.4th at pp. 178–179.) As the parties agree,
although “[j]uvenile courts should be mindful of the burdens their
disposition orders impose on parents already grappling with
difficult conditions and circumstances[,] . . . . the paramount
concern always must be the child’s best interests, and [the
reviewing court] cannot reverse a disposition order reasonably
fashioned to eliminate the conditions that led to dependency
jurisdiction, no matter how burdensome its requirements may
6
seem from the parent’s prospective.’ [Citations.]” (In re D.P.
(2020) 44 Cal.App.5th 1058, 1071–1072.)
The juvenile court abused its discretion in ordering mother
attend a domestic violence support group, and the order was
particularly burdensome to a nonoffending mother who took care
of four children, worked, and also was ordered to attend
individual counseling, sex abuse awareness training, and family
preservation services. Mother did not have an ongoing issue with
domestic violence. Her relationship with father ended in 2014
and there was no evidence, at least since 2018, that father
perpetrated domestic violence on mother. The fact that father
perpetrated domestic violence on Y.L. does not support the
conclusion that mother should attend a domestic violence
program. Further, the fact the children were afraid of father
does not support the order requiring mother to attend a domestic
violence support group. Although Alexa was afraid mother would
be in danger if Amy reported sexual abuse to mother, the record
shows that mother immediately took steps to investigate the
claim of sexual abuse once Amy reported it. Alexa’s fear of father
is not evidence that mother needed a domestic violence support
group. Although there was considerable evidence that father
needed to work on his violent tendencies, no evidence showed
that at the time of the jurisdictional hearing, mother needed a
domestic violence support group.
No evidence supported that a domestic violence support
group would ameliorate the conditions leading to dependency
jurisdiction. The petition did not allege jurisdiction based on
domestic violence. No evidence supported the juvenile court’s
finding that it was in the children’s best interest for mother to
attend a domestic violence support group when there was no
7
evidence father had committed violence against mother since at
least six years before commencement of the dependency
proceedings, and it was undisputed that mother had severed her
relationship with father over a decade before those proceedings
began. There was no evidence that the children would not be safe
in mother’s care, where they remained during the dependency
proceedings, absent her attending a domestic violence support
group. In short, because no evidence supported the juvenile
court’s order requiring mother attend a domestic violence support
group, that order constitutes an abuse of discretion.
DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s dispositional order is reversed insofar
as it requires mother to attend a domestic violence support group.
In all other respects, the juvenile court’s dispositional order is
affirmed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.
BENDIX, J.
We concur:
ROTHSCHILD, P. J.
M. KIM, J.
8
Vous vous demandez comment ce texte s’applique à votre situation ?
Consultation gratuite, sans engagement
Décrivez votre situation. Notre équipe vous recontactera par e-mail pour votre consultation.
Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude
Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.