CourtListener 10781907•In re E.P. CA4/3
Texte intégral
Filed 1/30/26 In re E.P. CA4/3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION THREE
In re E.P., a Person Coming Under
the Juvenile Court Law.
ORANGE COUNTY SOCIAL
SERVICES AGENCY,
G065726
Plaintiff and Respondent,
(Super. Ct. No. DP026891-002)
v.
OPINION
M.M.,
Defendant and Appellant.
Appeal from an order of the Superior Court of Orange County,
Adrianne E. Marshack, Judge. Affirmed in part, reversed in part, and
remanded with directions.
William D. Caldwell, under appointment by the Court of Appeal,
for Defendant and Appellant.
Leon J. Page, County Counsel, Debbie Torrez and Aurelio Torre,
Deputies County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
No appearance for the Minor.
* * *
Mother appeals after the juvenile court made jurisdictional
findings declaring her 13-year-old son (the minor) a dependent of the court
pursuant to Welfare and Institutions Code section 300, subdivisions (a),
(b)(1), (g) and (j), and ordered him removed from her and the minor’s father’s
custody with the provision of reunification services to her.1 She challenges
the sufficiency of the evidence to support the court’s jurisdictional findings.
We find insufficient evidence to support the findings made under subdivisions
(a), (g), and (j), as well as (b)(1) to the extent based on certain of the sustained
factual allegations. However, because we find substantial evidence supports
the finding of jurisdiction under subdivision (b)(1) based on other sustained
factual allegations, we conclude there was a valid ground for the court to
exercise jurisdiction over the minor. Accordingly, we affirm the order in part,
reverse the order in part, and remand the matter with directions to enter an
order striking an unsubstantiated factual allegation and vacating specified
erroneous jurisdictional findings.
FACTS
In early May 2025, the minor was taken into protective custody
by the Anaheim Police Department after a neighbor found him hiding under
stairs with observable bruises on his face and arms, as well as some cuts on
his legs. The neighbor conveyed the then 13-year-old said his aunt and uncle,
with whom he was living, had been physically abusing him, withholding food,
1 All further statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code.
2
and tying him to a bed so he could not leave. It was determined the minor
needed to be medically cleared, so officers transported him to a hospital
where the Orange County Social Services Agency (SSA) later made contact
with him. Although SSA initially thought the aunt and uncle were the
minor’s legal guardians, it determined within the next couple of days that
mother had only given the aunt a limited power of attorney regarding the
minor.
I.
DETENTION REPORT
Among other matters, SSA’s detention report detailed interviews
it conducted on the day the minor was taken into protective custody and the
two days thereafter, information about a 2015 juvenile dependency
proceeding involving the minor and his sister, and details of prior inquiries
by SSA into allegations of abuse against the minor by the aunt and uncle.
A. Interviews
SSA interviewed the minor at the hospital where he was being
evaluated. He appeared “bubbly, social, and friendly” with SSA, police
officers, and all medical staff. The minor explained he lived with the aunt and
uncle, their then four-year-old son (the cousin), and two of the uncle’s
brothers. He said he had frequent telephone contact with mother but had not
seen her in-person for two to three years. Regarding his father, the minor
said he “lives ‘on the streets’ and he last saw him when he was 3 years old.”
As for the situation at the aunt and uncle’s house, the minor said
they had been abusing him “for about 2.5 years and social workers have not
believed him in the past.” He relayed they hit him whenever they want and
do not care if he cries or bleeds. SSA observed bruises and marks on the
minor’s body, and he said they were caused by the aunt and uncle. He
3
explained they hit him using the metal part of a belt, a metal pole, or their
hands, and the aunt has hit him on the head with her phone. The minor also
reported the aunt and uncle “tie him up by the arms and neck every night on
the side of the bunk bed while he is standing,” making him sleep standing up
or on the floor. He related that the night before officers took him into
protective custody, the uncle “‘choked [him] with both his hands, . . . [the
minor] passed out[,] and when [he] woke up [his] nose and mouth [were]
bleeding.’”
Aside from the physical acts, the minor said the aunt and uncle
do not let him eat for a month if he does his chores incorrectly or too slowly.
The last such incident occurred a week prior, and he stated he had not been
allowed to eat since then. When the aunt and uncle found out he was eating
at school, they took him out of school for the remainder of the week.
When asked whether and to what extent he felt safe with his
aunt and uncle, he said he did not feel safe because they hurt him and his
uncle “‘hurts [him] with the metal part of the belt and leaves bruises.’” He did
not want to share any details about specific incidents.
SSA learned from the treating nurse that all the minor’s tests
“came back clear” so SSA took him to Orangewood Children and Family
Center (Orangewood). During the drive, the minor got tears in his eyes and
expressed happiness that he was “going to somewhere that he would be safe.”
He explained that while living with the aunt and uncle, “he would listen to
calming music as a coping mechanism and to stop him from feeling angry and
sad about his living situation and the abuse he endured.” The minor also
reiterated that the aunt and uncle withheld food from him as punishment; he
ate two sandwiches, three packs of goldfish crackers, and multiple juices
while at the hospital.
4
During mother’s initial interview, she told SSA she has full legal
and physical custody of the minor, and denied father having any contact or
visitation with him. She explained that she placed the minor in the aunt’s
care about two and a half to three years earlier “because there was a case in
San Bernardino County where the [minor] was claiming the mother ‘beat him
up’” and a different maternal aunt alleged she saw the minor “on top of his
sister . . . inappropriately.” Mother said she last saw the minor in person
about two weeks before, and she visits the minor at least three to four times a
month.
Regarding the circumstances at the aunt and uncle’s house,
mother stated she learned from the aunt that police reported the minor was
being tied to the bed and physically abused. Mother said the former was a
“‘lie,’” explaining she believed the minor “is manipulative and has a history of
being aggressive toward school staff and students.” Regarding physical
abuse, mother denied the minor ever telling her he was being abused.
Although she saw marks or bruises on him in the past, she conveyed he
harms himself by “‘hit[ting] himself with things like a table or scooter’” and
he “bruises easily.” However, when separately questioned about the aunt and
uncle’s method of discipline, mother said she believed the uncle disciplines
the minor “by hitting him on the buttocks with a “chancla” (sandal) or his
hand,” and the aunt “yell[s] or spank[s] him on the buttocks with an open
hand.”
Overall, mother expressed doubts about the allegations, saying
the aunt and uncle “would never do that.” Specifically regarding the aunt, she
stated she “kn[e]w [the aunt] wouldn’t do [those things] because she [was
mother’s] main support system.” Instead, mother “believe[d] the [minor was]
5
making false allegations because he does not get what he wants and because
he does not like rules.”
Separate from her comments about the allegations, mother
expressed concern about other behavior in which the minor was known to
engage. She said “he has a history of inserting objects into his anus” and, in
the past, took videos of himself doing so. Mother had him evaluated in the
past, but “he came[] back normal.” Because she does not know why he does it
and is concerned it might be because of some unknown past sexual abuse, she
wanted him to be evaluated.
As far as reunification, “mother stated she want[ed] the [minor]
back in her care, ‘but not until he gets better.’” She explained that past
efforts to get him services were unsuccessful because he was not cooperative.
She expressed interest in reunification services and felt the minor would be
“better off at Orangewood in the meantime.” With support and services in
place, she would be willing to have him back in her care.
SSA also spoke to the aunt and uncle on the day the minor was
taken into protective custody. They denied all the allegations, confirming the
minor and the cousin have enough food to eat and stating they do not use
physical discipline. Regarding the latter, they said they discipline by taking
away phones and screen time. However, when separately interviewed, each
admitted to hitting the minor one time, “over his clothing, on the buttocks.”
Specifically, when the aunt and uncle found out the minor stole
approximately $600 in cash from them the week prior, the aunt hit him with
her shoe and the uncle hit him with a belt. Neither knew if the minor
sustained any bruises or marks as a result.
When asked about the minor’s bruises, the aunt said the minor
refused to respond when she asked him about them. She shared he “ha[s] a
6
history of hitting himself and that he bangs his head when he is upset.” She
thought the behavior was “‘odd,’” so she previously tried to get him evaluated.
Regarding cause, the aunt expressed her belief that the bruises were
sustained at school because the minor “has a history of being bullied at his
school,” of which the school was aware, and he “is known to constantly
engage in fights.” When asked if she reported the bruises to the minor’s
doctor or school staff, she said she did not because “she did not know she was
expected to report [it].” Separately, the uncle said the minor was “always
observed arriving from school with marks and bruises.”
As for the allegations of tying the minor to a bed, the aunt and
uncle denied ever doing so. The uncle confirmed a scarf, which law
enforcement took as part of its investigation, was previously tied to a bed.
However, he explained it was tied there because the cousin liked to play with
it; he swung his toys on it.
Aside from addressing the allegations, the aunt and uncle
expressed concern about the minor possibly having been subjected in the past
to sexual abuse. The aunt was aware of the past instances described by mom
involving the minor inserting objects into his anus. She did not know it had
occurred since living at the aunt and uncle’s house until she found evidence
the night before of him doing so. After discussing what she found with
mother, they agreed the aunt would take the minor to Orangewood so he
could be enrolled in a program to address the behavior. The aunt intended to
do so on the morning of the day police ended up taking the minor into
protective custody.
When SSA spoke with the doctor who evaluated the minor, the
doctor explained that although the test results were all normal, “the [minor]
ha[d] a lot of injuries [(i.e. bruises and marks)] in a lot of protected areas that
7
would not be expected to be obtained by playing, such as in softer areas of
[his] thigh and belly.” Although he expressed “the [minor’s] injuries would be
consistent with inflicted injury, . . . there [was] no way for him to
differentiate whether the injuries were inflicted by the [aunt and uncle] or
peers at school, as reported by the [aunt and uncle].”
The following day, SSA spoke with a psychologist and a social
worker from the minor’s school. Both provided similar details of past
observations and circumstances at school. There were multiple occasions
where the minor arrived at school with unexplained bruises that caused them
concern. When asked about them, the minor sometimes would say he fell or
ran into something. On at least one occasion, he told the school psychologist
that “he has to ‘clean a lot or he cannot go to sleep,’” and he asked they not
tell his aunt because he “‘almost made it to the end of the month.’” The
psychologist did not inquire further. Being concerned about the situation, the
school made reports to the child abuse hotline. Neither the social worker nor
the psychologist was aware of any reported bullying of the minor or physical
altercations between him and other students.
SSA spoke with mother to advise her it was adding allegations of
general neglect and caretaker absence against her. Mother was upset and
expressed disagreement with the allegations, saying she did not neglect her
son by having him live with the aunt and uncle. When discussing the
dependency process and reunification services, mother conveyed, “‘[I]t’s not
that I don’t want him in my care, you guys [(i.e. SSA)] need to stand by
parents and offer us services.’ . . . ‘[Y]es I want that, I want reunification
services.’”
A day later, the day before the detention hearing, SSA tried
contacting father but was unable to reach him because he was incarcerated in
8
an Orange County jail and the jail informed SSA he was in court. SSA also
spoke with mother again. She conveyed a willingness to work with SSA for
the best interests of the minor, acknowledging the situation was stressful and
“she wants to ‘get this over with.’” Expressing concern about the minor
potentially harming her three daughters, mother suggested that maybe the
minor’s maternal grandmother could move into her home and supervise the
minor. She also suggested the minor receive services through a particular
behavioral program. When asked why she did not previously seek those
services for him if she was aware of them, mother said she had just recently
learned of them, she previously asked for services but was not provided any
guidance, and it was tough being a mother of four children.
A social worker who worked on a 2022 San Bernardino County
dependency case involving the minor and mother also spoke with SSA.
Consistent with mother’s statement, the social worker confirmed the prior
case involved allegations that the minor made videos of himself “‘playing with
his butt and touching [his sister].’” The investigation was closed after mother
voluntarily complied with a suggested safety plan which involved, inter alia,
sending the minor to live with the aunt.
B. 2015 juvenile dependency proceeding
According to the detention report, the minor and his younger
sister were declared dependents of the Orange County juvenile court as part
of a 2015 dependency proceeding. The minor was almost four, and they were
removed from mother’s care based on allegations that the sister sustained
multiple bruises and a lump on her head while in the care of the mother’s
then boyfriend. The sustained allegations also detailed a history of domestic
violence between mother and the minor’s father, which included father being
arrested and the issuance of more than one restraining order. The
9
dependency terminated in early 2017, with mother and father having joint
legal custody, mother being given primary physical custody, and father being
given four hours of visitation one time per month.
C. Past SSA inquiries into abuse against the minor
The detention report indicated that between February 2024 and
the May 2025, SSA was notified nine different times about potential abuse of
the minor based on statements made by the minor and/or observations of
bruises on his body. In response to the reports, SSA either documented
matters for “information only” or conducted an investigation which concluded
the physical abuse allegations were unfounded or, in one instance,
inconclusive.
On multiple occasions, SSA spoke with the minor, as well as the
aunt and uncle. The aunt and uncle consistently denied any physical abuse.
One time they conveyed he was “always getting bruised, so it [was] not out of
the ordinary for [him] to have a new bruise.” More than once, despite having
made statements about abuse which led to someone making a report, the
minor denied any physical abuse or discipline when speaking to SSA. On
those occasions, he said the bruises resulted either from a fall or something
else he did which caused his body to hit something. One time, however, the
minor confirmed to SSA that the uncle caused his nose to bleed by pinching
it. SSA ultimately determined the allegations were inconclusive because the
uncle, the aunt, and mother all denied any physical abuse.
D. SSA recommendation
Based on the overall circumstances, SSA recommended the minor
remain detained at Orangewood pending a jurisdiction and disposition
hearing. It further recommended four hours of weekly supervised visits for
10
mother and four hours a month of supervised visitation for father once he
was released from custody.
II.
DEPENDENCY PETITION
The same day SSA filed the detention report, it filed a
dependency petition. The petition alleged the minor fell within the juvenile
court’s jurisdiction for a variety of reasons. They included: the minor having
suffered serious, nonaccidental physical harm caused “by the [minor’s] parent
or guardian”; a failure and/or inability of mother and father to protect the
minor; the parents’ willful or negligent failure to adequately protect the
minor “from the conduct of the custodian with whom the [minor was] left”;
the parents’ willful or negligent failure to provide the minor with adequate
food, clothing, shelter, or medical treatment; an inability of the father to
provide the minor with regular care due to substance abuse; father’s inability
to provide for, or arrange appropriate care for, the minor due to father’s
incarceration; and the presence of a substantial risk the minor will be abused
or neglected based on neglect or abuse of his sibling.
Among the factual allegations were the statements made by the
minor to SSA about what the aunt and uncle had done to him, the aunt and
uncle’s admissions that they physically disciplined the minor the week before
he was taken into protective custody, mother’s belief the minor was lying
about the abuse, and mother’s desire for the minor to get better before she
takes him back in her care. Additional allegations included the following:
mother and father have a history of domestic violence, including acts in the
minor’s presence; father was found to have abused an unidentified minor in
2013; father may have an unresolved substance abuse problem; father has a
criminal history; father has not been involved in the minor’s life and is
11
incarcerated; and the minor and his younger sister were the subject of a
dependency proceeding initiated in 2015 and terminated in 2017.
III.
DETENTION HEARING
At the detention hearing, mother denied all allegations in the
petition and submitted on the issue of detention. While SSA requested the
court provide her with four hours of weekly supervised visitation, mother
requested eight hours weekly and the minor’s counsel was in agreement with
that amount. Since father had not been in the minor’s life for 10 years,
mother requested the court provide him with a maximum of two hours
supervised visitation per month, which she said was consistent with the
amount of visitation allowed to father under an existing court order entered
in 2017. The court ordered the minor to be detained pending future hearings,
with eight hours of weekly supervised visitation for mother and one hour of
monthly supervised visitation for father. It also ordered no contact between
the minor and the aunt and uncle.
IV.
JURISDICTION AND DISPOSITION REPORT
A jurisdiction and disposition report detailed SSA’s interviews
with mother and others, a visit with the minor, communications with the
minor’s school and Orangewood, and its attempts to contact father.
Regarding the latter, SSA said it made a couple of attempts to contact father,
but it was unsuccessful because he had been released from jail and his
whereabouts were unknown.
The minor’s school and Orangewood informed SSA that since the
detention hearing, the minor was involved in a few separate altercations with
students at school, involving at least three other students. On two occasions,
12
the minor yelled and used profanity toward other students, and on a different
occasion, he threatened he would get a knife. At least one incident involved a
student who was reported to have been bullying the minor “for an extended
period of time.” The school conveyed there were incidents in the past where
the minor was picked on and he would respond by defending himself.
When SSA visited the minor, he was playing with other children
and appeared easygoing and smiley. He did not want to talk about the
alleged matters involving the aunt and uncle. In response to questions about
the incidents at school, he explained there was a student in the same grade
who had been bullying and bothering him. He expressed wanting to live with
mother.
In the days after the detention hearing, mother expressed
concern to SSA about the minor returning to her home. She said she wanted
him to return to her care but, after consulting with her attorney, she felt “he
should first receive the help he needs.” “She emphasized that her priority is
for the [minor] to receive the help he needs and to protect all of her children
equally.” When asked whether she believed the minor’s statements about the
aunt and uncle, she replied: “‘I do have my doubts on both sides, and you
guys are making me pick between my kid and my family member. I do have
my doubts. I can’t be up against the wall.’”
A few days later, SSA questioned mother about the petition’s
allegations. She expressed frustration about the abuse allegations, saying she
did not think her sister (the aunt) would lie but she wanted to find out the
truth, and suggesting lie detector tests for everyone. She relayed the minor
“made similar allegations against [mother] in the past, which nearly resulted
in her arrest.” While she observed bruises on the minor, he never appeared
fearful and the aunt “would attribute the injuries to accidents” in which the
13
minor hit or bumped himself on something. As for father, mother explained
she had no contact with him, did not want to see him, and was fearful of him.
She believed the various drug, crime history, and incarceration allegations
concerning him. Overall, she “stated that having the [minor] under the
protection of [SSA] is a positive step, as she believed he [would] receive the
help he needs” instead of possibly “fall[ing] through the cracks.”
During SSA’s interviews with the aunt and the uncle, both
continued to deny the allegations and the aunt shared the minor had made
similar allegations in the past which were not true. At the same time, both
once again admitted to hitting the minor the week before he was taken from
them after he allegedly stole a significant amount of their rent money. In
addition, the aunt said that when the minor “was out of control,” she would
give him “a light spank with her hand or with Crocs (soft shoes), which she
believed were not harmful.” The uncle said he spent little time with the
minor because of his work schedule, but said the aunt had previously told
him the minor was being bullied at school. The aunt also identified bullying
as an issue, saying the minor told her about it and she brought it up with
school staff at a meeting. They “assured her they were addressing it.”
The minor’s stepfather, with whom the minor lived before mother
placed him in the care of the aunt and uncle, described his observations of the
minor over time. Starting in about fourth or fifth grade, the minor started
having trouble interacting appropriately with peers at school and in after
school programs. After the minor started living with the aunt and uncle, he
and mother would see the minor every other weekend for a couple of hours.
He noticed bruises, but said the minor “would laugh about it, saying that he
had fallen,” and in other instances, he said they were from school or from
slipping in the shower. The stepfather conveyed he never saw the minor show
14
fear or an abnormal reaction when responding to directions from the aunt,
and he “showed no signs of distress” during video calls from the aunt and
uncle’s house. As for potential placement, the stepfather shared that their
family is small and relatives are afraid to take responsibility for the minor
because they fear he may hurt someone.
In making a recommendation, SSA indicated mother had not
provided it with any information showing she was participating in
recommended services. It further expressed its belief mother had made no
progress toward alleviating or mitigating the matters which led to court
involvement, and stated “[v]oluntary [c]hild [p]rotective [s]ervices [were] not
an appropriate alternative to declaration of dependency.” It summarized:
“The Social Services Agency believes the family will benefit from ongoing
Juvenile Court supervision in order to ensure the parents follow through with
the recommended services, allowing the family to address any barriers that
could hinder their ability to adequately provide for the [minor’s] needs.”
V.
TRIAL COURT’S JURISDICTION AND DISPOSITION ORDER
After hearing from counsel for mother, the minor, and SSA, the
juvenile court found SSA met its burden of demonstrating the minor fell
within the scope of the court’s jurisdiction. It “sustain[ed] all of the
allegations in the petition with the exception of (b)(4) [of section 300],” which
concerned allegations of domestic violence between mother and father more
than 10 years prior. Based on the sustained allegations, it found jurisdiction
under section 300, subdivisions (a), (b)(1), (g), and (j). The court declared the
minor a dependent, ordered him removed from his parents’ custody and
continued his existing placement, ordered reunification services for mother,
15
and found pursuant to section 361.5, subd. (b)(1) that reunification services
did not need to be provided to father.
Mother timely appealed from the jurisdiction and disposition
order.
DISCUSSION
Mother challenges the juvenile court’s jurisdictional findings,
arguing there is insufficient evidence to support them. SSA argues mother
forfeited her ability to challenge the jurisdictional findings by agreeing below
to the minor’s custodial removal.2 Alternatively, it contends the court’s
jurisdictional findings are supported by substantial evidence. We find no
forfeiture under the circumstances, find there is insufficient evidence to
support some of the factual allegations sustained by the court, and conclude
the court erred in making certain of the jurisdictional findings. However,
because we find one jurisdictional basis is supported by substantial evidence,
the court did not err in assuming jurisdiction over the minor.
I.
FORFEITURE
“[A] reviewing court ordinarily will not consider a challenge to a
ruling if an objection could have been but was not made in the trial court.
[Citation.] The purpose of this rule is to encourage parties to bring errors to
the attention of the trial court, so that they may be corrected. [Citation.]” (In
re S.B. (2004) 32 Cal.4th 1287, 1293, footnote omitted.) This forfeiture rule
applies with equal force in dependency matters. (Ibid.)
2 SSA uses the term “moot.” However, it is clear from its analysis
that it is challenging issue preservation, which is more properly
characterized as an alleged forfeiture.
16
SSA argues mother forfeited her right to challenge the
jurisdictional findings because she “necessarily agreed to jurisdiction” when
she “outright agreed to an out-of-home disposition.” We disagree.
Generally, a parent who “submits” on a disposition
recommendation or expressly agrees with a proposed disposition forfeits their
right to contest a court’s dispositional order that adopts the recommendation.
(See Steve J. v. Superior Court (1995) 35 Cal.App.4th 798, 813; In re Richard
K. (1994) 25 Cal.App.4th 580, 589 (Richard K.).) But, mother is not
challenging the court’s dispositional determination. Rather, she is
challenging the jurisdictional findings it made before considering the
appropriate disposition. Contrary to SSA’s assertion, her acquiescence to
SSA’s proposed disposition is not an implicit concession of the
appropriateness of the court’s assumption of jurisdiction over the minor.
At the jurisdiction and disposition hearing, mother’s counsel told
the court mother did not agree with it finding true all of the allegations in the
petition. Her counsel then elaborated as to a few of them. In addition, even
when a parent does not contest the state of the evidence, their right to
challenge it as insufficient to support a court’s jurisdictional findings is
preserved. (See Richard K., supra, 25 Cal.App.4th at p. 589; In re Anthony G.
(2011) 194 Cal.App.4th 1060, 1064.) Accordingly, we find mother did not
forfeit the arguments she raises on appeal.
II.
RELEVANT LAW, GENERALLY, AND STANDARD OF REVIEW
The opening clause of section 300 provides: “A child who comes
within any of the following descriptions is within the jurisdiction of the
juvenile court which may adjudge that person to be a dependent child of the
court.” The subdivisions that follow describe children who may be adjudged
17
dependents of the court. Among them are the four categories pursuant to
which the petition’s allegations in this case were made—subdivisions (a), (b),
(g), and (j).
Subdivision (a) of section 300 concerns children who have
suffered, or are at a substantial risk of suffering, serious physical harm
caused nonaccidentally “by the child’s parent or guardian.” A critical
component of the showing required under this subdivision is that the harm or
risk of harm relates to actions of a parent or guardian.
Subdivision (b) of section 300 speaks to situations in which a
“child has suffered, or there is a substantial risk that the child will suffer,
serious physical harm or illness,” due to specified circumstances. Those
circumstances include, among others: (1) a parent’s failure or inability to
adequately supervise or protect the child; or (2) a parent’s inability to provide
regular care for the child due to the parent’s mental illness. (Id., subd.
(b)(1)(A) & (D).)
Subdivision (g) of section 300 is implicated, among other
circumstances, when a “child has been left without any provision for
support . . . [or] the child’s parent has been incarcerated or institutionalized
and cannot arrange for the care of the child.”
Subdivision (j) of section 300 concerns a child whose sibling has
been abused or neglected and there is a substantial risk the child will,
themselves, be abused or neglected.
In the juvenile court, SSA bears the burden of proving by a
preponderance of the evidence that a child is a person described by section
300. (§ 355, subd. (a); In re I.J. (2013) 56 Cal.4th 766, 773 (I.J.).) “‘[A]
jurisdictional finding good against one parent is good against both. More
accurately, the minor is a dependent if the actions of either parent bring [the
18
minor] within one of the statutory definitions of a dependent.’” (In re Briana
V. (2015) 236 Cal.App.4th 297, 308.)
On appeal, we review the juvenile court’s jurisdictional findings
for substantial evidence. (I.J., supra, 56 Cal.4th at p. 773.) That is, we look to
whether there is contradicted or uncontradicted evidence that is reasonable,
credible, and of solid value supporting the court’s findings. (In re R.V. (2012)
208 Cal.App.4th 837, 843.) “‘“In making this determination, we draw all
reasonable inferences from the evidence to support the findings and orders of
the [juvenile] court; we review the record in the light most favorable to the
court’s determinations; and we note that issues of fact and credibility are the
province of the [juvenile] court.” [Citation.] “We do not reweigh the evidence
or exercise independent judgment.”’” (I.J., at p. 773.)
Although one valid jurisdictional finding is enough to declare a
child a dependent (In re D.P. (2023) 14 Cal.5th 266, 283 (D.P.)), we may
exercise our discretion to review all challenged findings if, for example, the
findings “‘could be prejudicial to the appellant or could potentially impact the
current or future dependency proceedings,’ . . . “‘could have other
consequences for [the appellant], beyond jurisdiction,”’” or are “based on
particularly pernicious or stigmatizing conduct” (id. at pp. 285–286).
III.
ANALYSIS
A. Allegation a-1
Allegation a-1 of the petition alleged the minor “has been
physically abused by” the aunt and uncle. Notwithstanding the aunt and
uncle’s persistent denials of abuse, there is substantial evidence to support
the juvenile court’s true finding on this allegation. Nearly everyone with
whom SSA spoke said they noticed bruises on the minor during the time he
19
was living with the aunt and uncle. Although the minor had previously
denied the aunt and uncle as being the cause of the bruising on multiple
occasions, he later conveyed they were the cause. On the day he was taken
into protective custody by law enforcement, he said they would physically
discipline him with the metal part of a belt, a metal pole, their hands, or a
cell phone. The juvenile court, which is charged with making credibility
findings (I.J., supra, 56 Cal.4th at p. 773), believed him.
Even though there is substantial evidence to support factual
allegation a-1, it cannot justify the juvenile court’s finding of dependency
jurisdiction under subdivision (a) of section 300. Subdivision (a) relates to
serious physical harm or risk of such harm caused by a “parent or guardian.”
The statute expressly states “guardian” means a child’s legal guardian.
(§ 300.) As SSA admits, neither the aunt nor the uncle was the minor’s legal
guardian. Because this factual allegation was the sole basis offered by SSA
for a jurisdictional finding under subdivision (a) of the statute, the trial court
erred in finding jurisdiction pursuant to that subdivision.
B. Allegation b-1
Allegation b-1 of the petition was factually identical to allegation
a-1, but it was included as supporting jurisdiction under subdivision (b)(1) of
section 300. Like the juvenile court’s true finding on the latter, the juvenile
court’s true finding on the former is supported by substantial evidence. But,
for the same reason allegation a-1 was insufficient to justify dependency
jurisdiction, allegation b-1 is not a viable ground, alone, to justify jurisdiction.
Subdivision (b)(1) concerns serious physical harm or substantial risk thereof
caused by a specified failure or inability of a parent or guardian to do certain
things (e.g., supervise or protect them, provide them with adequate food or
shelter). By its plain language, the actions of someone other than a parent or
20
guardian cannot, alone, support such a jurisdictional finding. Though
allegation b-1 cannot be a sole basis for jurisdiction, we agree with SSA it
may be considered in conjunction with other sufficiently supported
allegations to determine whether the juvenile court’s jurisdictional finding
under subdivision (b)(1) was proper.
C. Allegation b-2
Allegation b-2 of the petition alleged mother failed to protect
minor by allowing him to live with the aunt and uncle after he disclosed
physical abuse at their hands. It further alleged the minor is at a substantial
risk of future harm because mother had observed marks and bruises on him,
but she continued to believe he was lying about what took place at the aunt
and uncle’s house.
There is no evidence in the record demonstrating mother was
actually aware of what allegedly took place at the aunt and uncle’s house
before the minor was taken into protective custody. This includes a lack of
evidence that the minor had previously told mother about the physical abuse.
The juvenile court’s findings in those respects are not supported by
substantial evidence.
Nevertheless, there is substantial evidence to support the court’s
jurisdictional finding based on mother’s failure to adequately supervise or
protect the minor. One of the circumstances in which subdivision (b)(1) of
section 300 applies is when a child has suffered serious physical harm due to
a parent’s negligent failure to adequately supervise or protect them “from the
conduct of the custodian with whom the child has been left.” (§ 300, subd.
(b)(1)(B).)
Mother said she saw the minor at least three to four times a
month during the more than two years he lived with the aunt and uncle. In
21
addition, she admitted she observed marks and bruises on him during that
time, and she believed the aunt and uncle would discipline the minor by
hitting him on the buttocks with a sandal or hand. However, mother’s only
inquiry into the bruises and marks were questions to the minor and the aunt.
She did nothing further when they both denied matters. Given the known use
of physical discipline and the persistent presence of bruises and marks, there
is sufficient evidence to support a finding that mother was negligent in
failing to adequately protect the minor from the aunt and uncle’s conduct.
And because there was evidence mother continued to disbelieve the minor’s
statements even after he was taken into protective custody and evaluated by
medical professionals, as well as evidence that mother did not believe
physical abuse allegations of another of her children in a prior dependency
proceeding, there is substantial evidence demonstrating a future risk of
mother not adequately responding to any abuse concerns which may arise.
D. Allegation b-3
Allegation b-3 of the petition alleged the minor “has been left
without a legal caregiver able to provide for [his] support and supervision.”
Mother argues on appeal that it was unnecessary for the juvenile court to
assert jurisdiction over the minor because she wants the minor to receive
services and is willing, for example, to send him to a “‘residential leadership
academy for teens’” so he can receive the care he needs. (Italics omitted.) The
question before us, however, is not whether the assumption of jurisdiction
was necessary, but whether it is supported by substantial evidence. We find
it is.
More than once, mother told SSA she was not willing to have the
minor in her home until he received services because she was concerned he
posed a danger to her other children. She suggested another potential
22
relative placement, and SSA contacted that individual and other family
members, but no one said they would take in the minor. Further, mother did
not suggest any residential program or show she had the means for placing
him in such a program or that he would otherwise be accepted. With father
uninvolved in the minor’s life, mother unable to have him live with her, and
no other identified placement, substantial evidence supports the court’s
assertion of jurisdiction under subdivision (b)(1) of section 300.
E. Allegations b-5, b-6, b-7, and b-8
Allegations b-5 through b-8 exclusively concerned father. They
alleged he abused a child in 2013, “may have unresolved substance abuse
problems,” “has a criminal history” involving arrests and/or convictions for a
variety of crimes, and was incarcerated at the time the petition was filed.
Irrespective of whether these allegations were supported by substantial
evidence, a matter on which we express no opinion, they do not provide a
basis for jurisdiction under the circumstances.
Subdivision (b)(1) of section 300, like other subdivisions of the
same statute, requires harm or a substantial risk of harm to a child based on
the alleged parental behavior or failure. Everyone SSA spoke to about father,
including mother and the minor, said father had not seen the minor in 10
years, and mother expressed wanting nothing to do with father. In addition,
there was no evidence father was in contact with, or had attempted to make
contact with, mother, the minor, or anyone with whom SSA spoke. Under
these circumstances, father’s alleged behavior, even if true, cannot have
harmed or posed a substantial risk of harm to the minor.
F. Allegation b-9
Allegation b-9 of the petition concerned the 2015 dependency
proceeding involving the minor and his younger sister. It set forth sustained
23
allegations from that proceeding which concerned three types of
circumstances: 1) injuries the minor’s sister sustained while in the care of
mother’s then boyfriend and a maternal aunt (not the aunt involved in the
present proceedings); 2) domestic violence between mother and father which
took place between 2011 and 2015, some of which took place in front of the
minor and his sister; and 3) father’s criminal history and 2013 perpetration of
child abuse.
SSA admits “[t]he facts underlying the prior dependency[,]
alone[,] were not sufficient for jurisdiction.” The abuse in that situation
involved a different child and different perpetrators, and the matter
terminated more than eight years before this one began. We agree with SSA,
however, the juvenile court could consider some of the sustained allegations
in making a risk determination in this case because of some of the
similarities. (See In re Kristin H. (1996) 46 Cal.App.4th 1635, 1650 [pattern
of behavior evidenced by various allegations, including past conduct, may aid
in forming basis for dependency jurisdiction].) Like the situation which led to
this dependency proceeding, the prior proceeding involved abuse of one of
mother’s children at the hands of one or more caregivers and mother did not
believe the caregivers harmed the minor despite numerous bruises and
“professional evidence.”
G. Allegation g-1
Allegation g-1 alleged father was in jail when the petition was
filed, he had no contact with the minor, and he was unable to provide or
arrange appropriate care for the minor. Based on the sustaining of this
allegation, the juvenile court found jurisdiction under section 300,
subdivision (g), which applies, in relevant part, when a “child’s parent has
24
been incarcerated or institutionalized and cannot arrange for the care of the
child.”
From a factual standpoint, the juvenile court erred in sustaining
allegation g-1 because SSA’s report stated father was released a few days
after the filing of the petition. In other words, he was not incarcerated at the
time of the jurisdictional hearing. (In re M.R. (2017) 7 Cal.App.5th 886, 897
[subdivision (g) of section 300 applies when, inter alia, parent is incarcerated
at time of jurisdictional hearing].) And, from a legal standpoint, father did
not have physical custody of the minor; he was only permitted a one-time,
four-hour visit per month. Nothing indicates the Legislature intended to
allow the juvenile court to exercise jurisdiction over a child under subdivision
(g) based on the former incarcerated status of a noncustodial parent who has
not been involved in the child’s life for a decade.
H. Allegation j-1
Allegation j-1 of the petition was factually identical to allegation
b-9, involving the 2015 dependency case which stemmed from alleged abuse
against the minor’s younger sister. The juvenile court’s reliance on the 2015
dependency to establish jurisdiction under section 300, subdivision (j) was
error. Subdivision (j) concerns a substantial risk of harm to a child based on
the fact the child’s sibling has been abused. (See In re Carlos T. (2009) 174
Cal.App.4th 795, 803.) The 2015 dependency does not establish such a risk to
the minor. The abuse on which that dependency proceeding was based took
place roughly eight years before any of the alleged abuse in this case, it was
done by different individuals, and there is no evidence those individuals are
involved in the minor’s life. As a result, there simply is insufficient evidence
to demonstrate a sufficient current risk to the minor based on such remote
prior abuse of his sibling.
25
I. Conclusion
Without sufficient evidentiary support for a finding of jurisdiction
under subdivisions (a), (g), or (j) of section 300, the juvenile court erred in
exercising jurisdiction over the minor pursuant thereto. However, because
only one valid basis is necessary to establish jurisdiction, the sufficiently
supported finding based on subdivision (b)(1) of the statute is enough to
uphold the court’s exercise of jurisdiction. (See D.P., supra, 14 Cal.5th at p.
283.) We remand the matter for entry of a new order to clarify the record for
current and future purposes.
DISPOSITION
The challenged order is affirmed in part and reversed in part. On
remand, the juvenile court shall issue an order: (1) striking allegation g-1;
(2) vacating its jurisdictional findings under section 300, subdivisions (a), (g),
and (j); and (3) vacating its jurisdictional finding under subdivision (b)(1) only
to the extent it was based on allegations b-1, b-5, b-6, b-7, b-8, and b-9.
DELANEY, J.
WE CONCUR:
SANCHEZ, ACTING P. J.
GOODING, J.
26
Vous vous demandez comment ce texte s’applique à votre situation ?
Consultation gratuite, sans engagement
Décrivez votre situation. Notre équipe vous recontactera par e-mail pour votre consultation.
Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude
Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.