People v. Dean CA2/7

CourtListener 10775564Calctapp16 janv. 2026

Texte intégral

Filed 1/16/26 P. v. Dean CA2/7
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has
not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION SEVEN

THE PEOPLE, B335738

Plaintiff and Respondent, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. BA503211)
v.

EDDIE DEAN, JR.,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Ronald S. Coen, Judge. Affirmed.
Laini Millar Melnick, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief
Assistant Attorney General, Susan Sullivan Pithey, Senior
Assistant Attorney General, Wyatt E. Bloomfield, Supervising
Deputy Attorney General, and Chelsea Zaragoza, Deputy
Attorney General, for Plaintiff and Respondent.

_________________
Eddie Dean, Jr., appeals from a judgment entered after a
jury convicted him of the first degree murder of Stephawn Jouner
and the attempted premeditated murder of H.J.1 in a gang
shooting. The jury also found true the firearm enhancement
allegations on each count. On appeal, Dean contends the trial
court erred in allowing a gang detail police officer to identify
Dean as one of the shooters based on surveillance video of the
shooting. He also argues substantial evidence did not establish
Dean’s involvement in the shooting. Dean further contends the
gang evidence offered by the prosecution to show motive was
cumulative and unduly prejudicial, and the trial court abused its
discretion in admitting evidence of Dean’s possession of a firearm
and ammunition that were not linked to the shooting. We affirm.

FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

A. The Prosecution Case2
1. The shooting
At around 3:30 p.m. on January 8, 2021, H.J. and Jouner
(H.J.’s best friend) were standing and talking on the sidewalk on
East 75th Street near South Main Street in Los Angeles when six
men began shooting at them. Jouner was killed. H.R. ran from
the scene but sustained at least five gunshot wounds on his lower
body. First responders found H.J. in a nearby alley and
transported him to the hospital. H.J. testified that he did not see
the shooters and did not know who shot him; he had very little
recollection of the shooting.

1 H.J. was identified only by his initials at trial.
2 Dean was tried with codefendant Randy Walker. Walker
was acquitted on all charges and is not a party to this appeal.

2
Los Angeles Police Department officers responded to the
scene of the shooting between 3:30 and 4:00 p.m. on January 8
and found Jouner’s dead body lying between two parked vehicles
on 75th Street. An autopsy showed that Jouner sustained
23 gunshot wounds over his whole body. The forensic pathologist
testified that at least four of the wounds were fatal, including
bullet wounds that penetrated the skull, brain, heart, and lungs.
Los Angeles Police Department investigators recovered
62 spent shell casings from the scene, including thirty-two 9-
millimeter casings, four .40-caliber casings, eleven .45-caliber
casings, twelve 7.62-millimeter casings, and three casings of
unknown caliber stamped “WMA.” Two unfired .40-caliber
bullets were also recovered. Los Angeles Police Detective Patrick
Farmer testified that the varying calibers meant at least four
different guns had been fired.

2. The surveillance videos
Los Angeles Police Officer Thorsten Timmermans collected
surveillance video from four cameras mounted on a business at
the southeast corner of Main and 75th Streets. Collectively, the
videos captured nearly the entire shooting from multiple
perspectives, with some blind spots. Excerpts of the video played
for the jury showed that at about 3:23 p.m.3 on January 8, Jouner
and H.J. were standing together on 75th Street, socializing and
smoking. At about 3:24 p.m., a white, four-door sedan followed
by a black, four-door sedan traveled north on Main Street past

3 Officer Timmerman and other investigators synchronized
the time stamps in the surveillance videos to standard time, but
their calculations may have deviated from standard time by up to
a minute.

3
75th Street. After passing the intersection, both vehicles pulled
over for about 10 seconds, then continued driving.
Five minutes later, at about 3:29 p.m., the white car
returned and pulled to the curb at the northeast corner of the
intersection, and three men jumped out of the passenger side of
the car. Each man wore a dark hooded sweatshirt that obscured
his face and blue gloves. Immediately upon exiting the car, each
man raised his arms and began to repeatedly fire a handgun in
the direction of H.J. and Jouner. Two seconds later, the black car
pulled up to the southeast corner of the intersection, and three
more men emerged and began to fire handguns in the direction of
H.J. and Jouner. Two of the men wore hooded sweatshirts, and a
surgical face mask is visible on one. The third man who exited
the black car, later identified as Dean, wore a beanie-style hat
and a gray hooded sweatshirt, and he had a beard. His face can
be seen in the videos.
When the shooting began, H.J. and Jouner quickly dodged
between two parked cars, and then H.J. ran away from the
shooters and out of the frame. Four of the shooters ran partway
down 75th Street while continuing to fire their guns, and
Jouner’s body fell to the street. Dean did not run down 75th
Street with the others; rather, he remained at the southeast
corner of the intersection, and it appears from his gun’s recoil and
muzzle smoke that he fired at least 12 shots in the direction of
H.J. and Jouner. Twenty seconds after the shooting began, all
six shooters returned to the two vehicles, which drove north on
Main Street.
Police investigators also obtained surveillance video footage
from a building on the 7400 block of South Main Street. Excerpts
from the video played for the jury show that about five minutes
before the shooting, the white and black cars turned from

4
northbound Main Street onto 74th Street, where they were
slowed by traffic. As described by Los Angeles Police Detective
Jocelyn Harris, the black car appeared to have a red-and-white
paper-like rear license plate, similar to a temporary tag from a
car dealership. Immediately after the shooting, both vehicles
passed the camera as they traveled rapidly north on Main Street.

3. Dean’s identification and arrest
For three months after the shooting, the police
investigators were unable to identify any suspects. In April 2021
Detective Harris took over the case as the investigating officer.
She learned that H.J. was a member of the 7-Tray (or 73) Crips
criminal street gang, and the shooting occurred in an area that
was 7-Tray Crips territory under challenge from the rival Swan
Bloods criminal street gang. Detective Harris contacted Mitchell
Woods, a gang enforcement detail officer for the Los Angeles
Police Department southeast division and an expert on the Swan
Bloods gang, hoping he could make an identification.
Officer Woods viewed the surveillance video and “immediately”
identified Dean as the bearded shooter on the southeast corner
who exited the black car. Based on this identification, Detective
Harris obtained search warrants to search Dean’s social media
account and cell phone records. Dean was arrested on
February 17, 2022. During a search of Dean’s residence, police
officers found 177 live rounds of ammunition of varying calibers,
including several dozen .40-caliber and .22-caliber rounds, a
smaller number of 5.56-millimeter and .20-caliber rounds, one
unknown-caliber round stamped “WMA,” and a Glock cartridge
loaded with ten .40-caliber rounds from two manufacturers. No
firearms were found, nor did the police recover any of the clothing
seen in the surveillance video.

5
At trial, Officer Woods testified about his identification
from the surveillance video.4 He explained that as part of his
assignment to the gang enforcement detail, he had interacted
with Dean approximately 100 times, nearly every week for more
than four years. The interactions ranged from simple greetings
to 10-minute conversations. Officer Woods knew Dean was a
member of the Swan Bloods gang, but Officer Woods had never
arrested him, and their interactions were “positive” and
“friendly.” When Detective Harris approached Officer Woods
about making an identification, he had not been told anything
about the investigation.
Officer Woods reviewed the surveillance video entered as
People’s exhibit 91 (in which Dean was most visible) and six still
frames from the video that were also shown to the jury.
Referring to the still frames, Officer Woods explained, “[Dean]
has very unique physical features. He has this red beard that is
like a chin-strap cap. He often wears glasses, and he has a
unique walk or gait. . . . [Previously] he was the victim of a
shooting. He was hit in both his legs, and since then, he’s kind of
braced himself when he walks just to account for the injury, and I
observed that in this video.” Further, Officer Woods explained, in
the video of the shooting, Dean appeared to “step[] gingerly,”
shifting more weight onto his left leg than his right and lowering
his left arm. Officer Woods also observed a red beard that he
described as “like a chin-strap cap,” and he “believe[d]” he saw
glare from eyeglasses on Dean’s face. Officer Woods added, “[I]t’s
not one thing that causes me to believe that this is Eddie Dean.
It’s the totality of everything that I know about Eddie in my
opinion.”

4 Officer Woods also identified Dean in the courtroom.

6
Los Angeles Police Officer Steven Alaniz, who was Officer
Woods’s partner in the gang enforcement detail for the southeast
division, also identified Dean as the bearded shooter. Like
Officer Woods, Officer Alaniz had numerous contacts with Dean
over several years, interacting nearly every week, sometimes
conversing for 20 or 30 minutes. Officer Alaniz and Dean
developed a “very friendly” relationship. When Officer Woods
was unavailable to testify at the preliminary hearing, Detective
Harris approached Officer Alaniz and asked if he could identify
anyone in a surveillance video. Officer Alaniz immediately
recognized Dean in the video from the moment Dean climbed out
of the black car.
Officer Alaniz explained that Dean had “unique physical
attributes” that were unlike any other Black man with whom he
had interacted in his job. Dean was “particularly light-skinned,
and he has a beard that glows red in the light.” The beard was
usually kept short and thick. Dean almost always wore glasses
during their prior interactions. Officer Alaniz observed that
Dean’s gait changed after he had been shot, and Dean would
“brace[] his leg as he makes like exaggerated motions with his
body” when starting or stopping walking, or when changing
directions.
The prosecutor played the same surveillance video she had
shown to Officer Woods, and Officer Alaniz confirmed this was
the video he had first watched with Detective Harris and the
prosecutor before the preliminary hearing. Officer Alaniz
testified that when he first watched the video, he “immediately
recognized that to be Eddie Dean.” Officer Alaniz explained that
he had seen Dean on many occasions and in many contexts, “from
several streets away, to up close and personal, to sitting in a car,
wearing masks due to COVID,” and “in every situation I

7
recognized him immediately.” In an unrelated earlier incident (in
which Dean was a witness, not a suspect), Officer Alaniz
identified Dean from surveillance video that was not high quality.
With respect to the surveillance video from the shooting, Officer
Alaniz was able to see Dean’s beard and glasses, but what
“jumped out” was Dean’s demeanor and gait and how Dean
“braced his leg as he was turning around, as I know Eddie to do.”

4. The gang evidence
Officer Alaniz testified that Dean was a self-admitted
member of the 89 Family Swans, a set of the Swan Bloods gang.
The Swan Bloods have about 300 members and include sets
based around 77th, 79th, 80th, 84th, 89th, and 92nd Streets that
cooperate with each other in committing crimes. The Swan
Bloods are rivals with “almost every Crip gang,” including the 7-
Tray Crips. The location of the shooting—75th and Main
Streets—was claimed by the 7-Trays but was a “controversial
jurisdiction” that was “intertwined partially” with nearby Swans
gangs. The Swans and 7-Trays would “fight over that area” and,
in Officer Alaniz’s experience, when rivals “see each other on that
street” in a disputed area, “it could escalate from . . . an exchange
of words to homicide.”
Officer Alaniz testified the criteria used to determine
whether someone is a gang member—in addition to a self-
admission—included whether the person wore gang clothing, had
gang tattoos, frequented the gang’s territory, displayed gang
colors, and hung out with gang members. The prosecutor showed
Officer Alaniz nine photographs retrieved from Dean’s social
media account. Officer Alaniz explained how the photographs
showed Dean and his associates making different signs of the
Family Swans and their sets, wearing gang colors and clothing,

8
and associating with known Family Swan gang members. For
example, in one photograph, Dean made a hand sign referencing
the 80 Swans that he captioned “7892,” a reference to the Family
Swans’ territory between 78th and 92nd Streets. In another
image, Dean made a Swans gang sign and wrote, “892 I took an
oath for the gang. It ain’t no changing that.” Another
photograph with Dean and a companion making gang signs was
captioned, “Only the family” with a swan picture. Dean also
posted a photograph of his neck tattoo with an inverted San
Francisco Giants logo, an image adopted by the Family Swans to
represent the “S” and “F” in the gang’s name read backwards.
The photograph was captioned, “Family Swan on my neck. That
really mean something.”
The prosecutor also introduced a photograph from Dean’s
social media account that showed him sitting on a lawn chair
while holding a handgun with an extended magazine pointed at
the camera. The photograph was captioned with Dean’s social
media username and a swan emoji.5

5. The cell phone evidence
Federal Bureau of Investigation special agent Jeff Bennett
analyzed Dean’s cell phone records and cell tower data to track
the location of Dean’s phone on the day of the shooting. Agent
Bennett concluded that between 2:38 and 3:18 p.m. on January 8,
Dean’s phone moved from Compton (where Dean resided) to the
vicinity of the shooting and an hour later, at 4:20 p.m., the phone
traveled back toward Compton. At 3:24 p.m.—when the black car

5 The prosecutor introduced four more non-gang-related
photographs of Dean from his social media account through
Detective Harris, who discussed Dean’s beard and eyeglasses.

9
first passed the intersection of 75th and Main Streets—Dean’s
phone connected with a tower about 10 blocks south of the
shooting, even though there were two closer cell towers to the
north. Agent Bennett admitted on cross-examination that if
Dean’s phone were in the black car at 3:24 p.m. (the time stamp
on the surveillance video), Agent Bennett would have expected
the phone to connect to one of the closer towers.
Detective Harris testified that the day before the shooting,
someone with the username “es_gunna” sent Dean a direct
message on social media stating, “Don’t forget to take off that
paper plate.” Dean responded, “Yup.” Officer Alaniz testified
that a Family Swans member, Sylvonte Leverette, used the
moniker “Gunna.” Leverette appeared with Dean in three of the
social media photographs admitted at trial, and in one of the
photographs, Leverette was tagged “@es_gunna.” Dean and
Leverette also communicated on the night of the shooting about
meeting up; however, Dean never discussed the shooting in any
social media messages in the records Detective Harris reviewed.

B. The Defense Case
Stephen Buller, an analyst specializing in forensic video
enhancement, was retained by the defense to “enhance, clarify,
and enlarge” the surveillance videos from two of the cameras and
to extract clear still images from the videos. Buller testified
there “wasn’t a whole lot of room for enhancement” of the motion
video due to the quality of the original, but he applied software
filters that increased contrast and overall lightness. The
enhanced video, as well as a frame depicting the shooter
identified as Dean with his gun lowered to his torso, were shown
to the jury. On cross-examination, Buller admitted that applying

10
filters for contrast had the effect of making objects “a little bit
darker.”
Dean’s stepfather, Teron Shaw, testified that Dean was not
the shooter in the surveillance video. The enhanced video and
still frames prepared by Buller were played for Shaw, who
explained to the jury that the shooter moved in a way that Dean
was incapable of doing due to the gunshot injuries he had
previously sustained in both legs and his right elbow. In
particular, when the shooter first appeared in the frame of the
enhanced video, the shooter appeared to do an athletic “jump
stop” before firing his gun: “[H]e’s running up. Now he did a
little jump . . . and now he’s like sticking the landing and getting
ready to start shooting.” The shooter also used both hands to fire
his gun with his elbows “locked in,” but Dean suffered numbness
in his right arm and was unable to grip properly. Shaw did not
believe Dean would be physically able to hold and fire a gun in
the manner of the shooter. Shaw conceded that Dean had a
“reddish-orange beard” that was uncommon in Black men and
“stands out,” but Shaw did not see any red in the shooter’s beard
in the video. Contrary to Officer Woods’s and Officer Alaniz’s
testimony, Shaw did not see eyeglasses on the shooter. Shaw
also stated, contrary to the officers’ testimony, the shooter was
not bracing his leg; instead, it appeared the shooter was
“grabbing at his crotch area.” Shaw was “100 percent certain”
the shooter was not Dean.
On cross-examination, Shaw testified he was not aware
that the contrast in the enhanced video had been increased in a
manner that could make objects such as the shooter’s beard
darker. However, upon viewing the original, unenhanced video,
Shaw maintained that the shooter did not have a red beard or
eyeglasses. With respect to his testimony that Dean would be

11
unable to grip a gun because of his injured right arm, Shaw
testified he had never seen Dean handling a gun until he saw
social media photograph of Dean holding a semiautomatic
handgun introduced by the prosecutor at an earlier proceeding.
Forensic analysis Robert Aguerro examined Dean’s cell
phone and cell tower data and testified that at 3:24 p.m. on the
day of the shooting, Dean’s phone connected to a tower that was
farther from the scene than four other towers. Moreover, Dean’s
phone connected to the same tower at 3:18 p.m., which was south
of the shooting, and this would have been unlikely to occur if
Dean’s phone was inside the black car shown on the surveillance
videos moving north of the crime scene. Aguero confirmed Dean’s
call and text records did not show any contacts between Dean and
his codefendant.

C. The Verdict and Sentence
The jury found Dean guilty of first degree murder (Penal
Code,6 § 187, subd. (a); count 1) and attempted willful, deliberate,
and premeditated murder (§§ 187, subd. (a), 664; count 2). As to
count 1, the jury found true the allegation Dean personally used
a firearm in the commission of murder (§ 12022.5, subd. (a)), and
as to count 2, the jury found Dean personally used a firearm
(§ 12022.5, subd. (a)) and inflicted great bodily injury on H.J.
(§ 12022.7, subd (a)).
The trial court sentenced Dean to an aggregate state prison
term of life, plus 36 years to life. The court imposed a term of
25 years to life on count 1 for murder, plus the middle term of
four years for the firearm use enhancement. On count 2 for

6 Further undesignated statutory references are to the Penal
Code.

12
attempted premeditated murder, the court imposed a life term,
plus the middle term of four years for the firearm use
enhancement and three years for the great bodily injury
enhancement.
Dean timely appealed.

DISCUSSION

A. The Trial Court Did Not Abuse Its Discretion in Allowing
Officer Alaniz To Identify Dean in the Videos
Dean contends the trial court erred in allowing Officer
Alaniz to identify Dean as the bearded shooter in the surveillance
videos because the officer’s testimony was improper opinion
testimony, and the jury in viewing the video was “as capable as
Alaniz to determine whether [Dean] was one of the shooters.”
The court did not abuse its discretion.
A nonexpert witness may offer opinion testimony if it is
“[r]ationally based on the perception of the witness” and
“[h]elpful to a clear understanding of [the witness’s] testimony.”
(Evid. Code, § 800.) “‘[T]he identity of a person is a proper
subject of nonexpert opinion,’” and appellate courts have “long
upheld admission of testimony identifying defendants in
surveillance footage or photographs.” (People v. Leon (2015)
61 Cal.4th 569, 601 (Leon); see People v. Mixon (1982)
129 Cal.App.3d 118, 130-131 (Mixon) [officers’ identifications of
defendant from surveillance photograph was proper where they
had “ample prior contact” with defendant, they “identified him
unequivocally and without hesitation,” and the identification
aided the jury, because “the surveillance photograph was not a
clear depiction of the subject, and [defendant] had changed his
appearance before trial”]; People v. Perry (1976) 60 Cal.App.3d

13
608, 613 (Perry) [police officers’ identifications from surveillance
video were proper because they were based on officers’ “contacts
with the defendant, their awareness of physical characteristics on
the day of the robbery, and their perception of the film taken of
the events”].)7
Courts have generally considered “two predicates for the
admissibility of lay opinion testimony as to the identity of
persons depicted in surveillance [video]: (1) that the witness
testify from personal knowledge of the defendant’s appearance at
or before the time the [video] was taken; and (2) that the
testimony aid the trier of fact in determining the crucial identity
issue.” (Mixon, supra, 129 Cal.App.3d at p. 128.) The Supreme
Court in Leon extended the holdings in Mixon and Perry,
concluding a police officer need not be familiar with the
defendant prior to the crime to make an identification from
surveillance video; rather, “[q]uestions about the extent of [the
detective’s] familiarity with defendant’s appearance went to the
weight, not the admissibility, of [the detective’s] testimony.”
(Leon, supra, 61 Cal.4th at pp. 600-601.) We review a trial

7 We reject the People’s contention Dean forfeited his
objection to Officer Alaniz’s identification testimony by failing to
object at trial. At the Evidence Code section 402 hearing, the
trial court denied the motion by Dean’s codefendant (Randy
Walker) to preclude Detective Harris from identifying Walker in
the surveillance video, which Walker had argued was improper
opinion testimony under Leon, supra, 61 Cal.4th 579. We decline
to find forfeiture because Dean’s attorney may have concluded an
objection would have been futile given the court’s rejection of the
same argument made by Walker. (People v. Johnsen (2021)
10 Cal.5th 1116, 1164 [“failure to object would not forfeit
[defendant’s] claim when doing so would have been futile”].)

14
court’s decision to admit a lay identification opinion for abuse of
discretion. (Id. at p. 600; accord, Mixon, at p. 127.)
Dean contends Officer Alaniz’s opinion was not helpful to
the jury because the jurors could have drawn their own
conclusions whether Dean was the shooter from watching the
videos and seeing Dean in court and in photographs admitted
into evidence, in contrast to Perry, supra, 60 Cal.App.3d at
page 613 (as well as in Leon, supra, 61 Cal.4th at page 601 and
Mixon, supra, 129 Cal.App.3d at page 125), in which the
defendants changed their appearances before trial. However, the
courts in Perry, Leon, and Mixon did not hold, nor is there any
authority for the proposition, that identification testimony is
admissible only where the defendant changes his appearance.
Moreover, Officer Alaniz had information from his
extensive interactions with Dean that would not have been
apparent from observing Dean in court, including his familiarity
with Dean’s gait and distinctive movement patterns. Based on
this experience, Officer Alaniz was far better equipped than the
jurors to recognize Dean in the videos, which had poor resolution
and showed Dean in motion at a distance. As Officer Alaniz
explained, he recognized Dean the moment Dean emerged from
the black car, and what “jumped out” was Dean’s demeanor, gait,
and how he “braced his leg as he was turning around, as [he
knew] Eddie to do.” (See People v. Larkins (2011)
199 Cal.App.4th 1059, 1067 [loss prevention officer was properly
allowed to identify defendant in a surveillance video because the
officer had watched 20 to 30 other videos showing the defendant,
“during which time [the officer] could observe such distinguishing
characteristics as defendant’s posture, gait and body
movements”].)

15
B. Substantial Evidence Supported a Finding Dean Was One
of the Shooters
Dean contends there was insufficient evidence to support
his conviction because no physical evidence connected him to the
shooting, and the identifications by Officers Woods and Alaniz
were unreliable. There was substantial evidence.
“‘When considering a challenge to the sufficiency of the
evidence to support a conviction, we review the entire record in
the light most favorable to the judgment to determine whether it
contains substantial evidence—that is, evidence that is
reasonable, credible, and of solid value—from which a reasonable
trier of fact could find the defendant guilty beyond a reasonable
doubt.’” (People v. Cardenas (2025) 18 Cal.5th 797, 821; accord,
People v. Lindberg (2008) 45 Cal.4th 1, 27.) “‘“‘Conflicts and even
testimony [that] is subject to justifiable suspicion do not justify
the reversal of a judgment, for it is the exclusive province of the
trial judge or jury to determine the credibility of a witness and
the truth or falsity of the facts upon which a determination
depends. [Citation.] We resolve neither credibility issues nor
evidentiary conflicts; we look for substantial evidence.’”’” (People
v. Beck and Cruz (2019) 8 Cal.5th 548, 627; accord, People v.
Frias (2024) 98 Cal.App.5th 999, 1015.) “‘“The standard of review
is the same in cases in which the prosecution relies mainly on
circumstantial evidence.”’” (People v. Vargas (2020) 9 Cal.5th
793, 820; accord, Frias, at p. 1015; see People v. Westerfield (2019)
6 Cal.5th 632, 713 [“‘If the circumstances reasonably justify the
trier of fact’s findings, reversal of the judgment is not warranted
simply because the circumstances might also reasonably be
reconciled with a contrary finding.’”].)
Officers Woods and Alaniz both testified they
“immediately” recognized Dean as the bearded shooter when they

16
first viewed the video marked as People’s exhibit 91. As
discussed, both officers had extensive interactions with Dean over
several years, and they were familiar with his distinctive
appearance, demeanor, and pattern of movement after his
shooting injury. Both officers described to the jury with
specificity what they perceived as they watched the video that
made it clear to them Dean was the shooter, and the video is
substantially consistent with their observations. The video has
poor resolution, but it is apparent in viewing the video that the
shooter had a “short and thick” chin-strap beard, was wearing
eyeglasses (as seen in People’s exhibit 91 at timestamp 04:29:16
that shows the glare from the glasses), and had a distinctive gait.
Further, as the prosecutor noted in her closing argument, unlike
the other shooters, Dean did not run after the victims, suggesting
a physical limitation. Although it is difficult to discern from the
video whether the shooter’s beard was red or reddish, the jurors
were able to watch the video and make a determination whether
they found credible the officers’ descriptions of the beard.
Dean focuses his argument on the circumstances
surrounding the officers’ initial identifications of Dean. With
respect to Officer Woods, Dean questions whether Officer Woods
was the officer who made the initial identification, pointing to
Detective Harris’s testimony at the preliminary hearing that
when she first showed the video to Officer Woods, “[h]e then took
the video back to his station and showed the other gang experts
the video to see if they identified anyone on that surveillance
video.” However, Detective Harris at trial testified that Officer
Woods made the initial identification upon first viewing the video
in her office. And Officer Woods consistently testified, when
cross-examined by defense counsel, that he recognized Dean the
first time he viewed the video.

17
Defense counsel also asked Officer Alaniz about Detective
Harris’s preliminary hearing testimony in which she answered
affirmatively to defense counsel’s inquiry whether, at the time of
Officer Alaniz’s initial identification, he “already knew . . . that
the person that [he] was going to be asked to testify against was
Eddie Dean.” Officer Alaniz disagreed with Detective Harris’s
characterization, stating he knew only that he was being asked to
make an identification in a case in which Dean was a defendant.
As discussed, it was for the jury to evaluate which testimony it
found more credible, not for this court to decide on appeal. (See
People v. Beck and Cruz, supra, 8 Cal.5th at p. 627.)
There was significant other evidence that Dean was
involved in the shooting. The day before the shooting, Dean’s
fellow gang member Leverette sent a message to Dean: “Don’t
forget to take off that paper plate.” Surveillance video from five
minutes before the shooting showed the black car had instead of
a rear license plate what appeared to be a printed paper license
plate. In addition, the cell tower analysis showed that Dean’s cell
phone moved from his residence in Compton to the vicinity of the
shooting—connecting to a tower 10 blocks from the shooting—in
the hour before the shooting, and his cell phone returned to
Compton in the hour after the shooting. Although special agent
Bennett conceded the evidence that Dean’s phone was at the
crime scene at the time of the shooting was equivocal because
there were two closer towers with which the phone did not
connect, the jury could have inferred Dean did not have his phone
on his person while he was carrying out the shooting.
The People also introduced Dean’s social media posts that
showed he was an active and committed member of the Family
Swans who associated with and supported Swan sets that
claimed territory near the scene of the shooting. This evidence

18
showed Dean’s motive and intent in carrying out the shooting
against rival gang members. The evidence the shooting was
gang-related was compelling: Officer Alaniz testified that the
intersection of 75th and Main Streets was at the heart of a
territorial dispute between the Swans and the 7-Tray Crips (in
which H.J. was a member), and the presence of rival gang
members loitering on the disputed street could have escalated to
murder. Further, the surveillance video showed a coordinated
and premeditated attack involving six gloved gunman in two cars
who fired at least 62 bullets at a known 7-Tray Crips gang
member.

C. The Trial Court Did Not Abuse Its Discretion in Admitting
Gang Evidence from Dean’s Social Media Account
1. The trial court proceeding
The prosecutor filed a motion in limine to introduce gang
evidence to show motive, intent, and identity. Dean filed a
motion in limine to exclude, in relevant part, the “[u]se of gang
pictures or videos,” noting Dean and his codefendant were not
charged with any gang crimes or enhancements. At the Evidence
Code section 402 hearing on both motions, the prosecutor stated
her intent to introduce photographs from Dean’s social media
account “of his gang tattoo, him throwing gang signs, him
associated with known gang members,” and to present testimony
from gang officers about Dean’s membership in the Swan Bloods
and the gang’s rivalry with the 7-Tray Crips. The prosecutor
agreed not to use a gang hypothetical, introduce evidence of
predicate offenses, or present testimony the shooting was for the
benefit of a criminal street gang. The trial court ruled the
proposed evidence was admissible and not overly prejudicial.

19
2. Governing law
“Although evidence of gang membership carries the
potential for prejudice, it ‘“is often relevant to, and admissible
regarding, the charged offense. Evidence of the defendant’s gang
affiliation—including evidence of the gang’s territory,
membership, signs, symbols, beliefs and practices, criminal
enterprises, rivalries, and the like—can help prove identity,
motive, modus operandi, specific intent, means of applying force
or fear, or other issues pertinent to guilt of the charged crime.”’”
(People v. Holmes, McClain and Newborn (2022) 12 Cal.5th 719,
772; accord, People v. Ramirez (2022) 13 Cal.5th 997, 1095 [gang
evidence “is admissible even when a gang enhancement is not
charged, provided the probative value of the evidence is not
substantially outweighed by its prejudicial effect”]; People v.
Chhoun (2021) 11 Cal.5th 1, 31 [“The People are generally
entitled to introduce evidence of a defendant’s gang affiliation
and activity if it is relevant to the charged offense.”].) However,
“‘courts should carefully scrutinize evidence of a defendant’s gang
membership because such evidence “creates a risk the jury will
improperly infer the defendant has a criminal disposition and is
therefore guilty of the offense charged.”’” (Chhoun, at p. 31;
accord, People v. Melendez (2016) 2 Cal.5th 1, 28-29.)
Even where evidence is relevant, under Evidence Code
section 352 the trial court “‘in its discretion may exclude evidence
if its probative value is substantially outweighed by the
probability that its admission will (a) necessitate undue
consumption of time or (b) create substantial danger of undue
prejudice, of confusing the issues, or of misleading the jury.’”
(People v. Hardy (2018) 5 Cal.5th 56, 87; accord, People v. Bell
(2019) 7 Cal.5th 70, 105.) “‘[T]he prejudice which exclusion of
evidence under Evidence Code section 352 is designed to avoid is

20
not the prejudice or damage to a defense that naturally flows
from relevant, highly probative evidence. . . . “[It] applies to
evidence which uniquely tends to evoke an emotional bias against
the defendant as an individual and which has very little effect on
the issues.”’” (People v. Jones (2017) 3 Cal.5th 583, 610; accord,
Bell, at p. 105.)
We review a trial court’s ruling on the admissibility of gang
evidence, including whether the evidence was unduly prejudicial,
for an abuse of discretion. (People v. Ramirez, supra, 13 Cal.5th
at p. 1095; see People v. Chhoun, supra, 11 Cal.5th at p. 33
[“‘“The admission of gang evidence over an Evidence Code
section 352 objection will not be disturbed on appeal unless the
trial court’s decision exceeds the bounds of reason.”’”].)

3. Dean’s social media photographs were highly relevant
to prove the charged offenses and not unduly
prejudicial
Dean contends the trial court abused its discretion in
allowing the prosecution to introduce 14 gang-related
photographs to establish his alleged motive for the shooting. He
argues his motive to commit the shooting was established by the
officers’ undisputed testimony that Dean was a self-admitted
member of the Family Swans, coupled with the officers’ testimony
about the gang and its deadly territorial rivalry. Thus, Dean
argues, there was no need to introduce the photographs to show
he was a Swan member, and the photographs were cumulative
and highly prejudicial. We are not persuaded.
As discussed, Officer Alaniz testified about nine of Dean’s
social media photographs, identifying the gang signs, colors,
clothing, and gang members in the photographs. Detective
Harris testified about five additional photographs, including a

21
photograph (which we address separately) of Dean holding a
handgun captioned with a swan emoji. The images showed that
Dean not only self-identified as a member of the Family Swans,
but he was deeply committed to and involved in the gang. He
captioned one photograph with a companion making gang signs,
“892 I took an oath for the gang. It ain’t no changing that.”
Another photograph with Dean and a companion making gang
signs was captioned, “Only the family” with a swan picture.
Dean was proud to demonstrate his allegiance, posting a
photograph of his neck tattoo with the caption, “family Swan on
my neck. That really means something.” Several of the
photographs included references to different Swan sets and
showed Dean socializing with prominent Swan gang members.
This evidence was relevant to show Dean’s motive to carry out a
territorial gang shooting with other Swan gang members to kill
rival gang members.
Many of the photographs were also relevant to Dean’s
appearance around the time of the shooting. Four of the
photographs were not connected to his gang membership and
were instead relied on by the officers to discuss the styling of
Dean’s beard and the eyeglasses he wore. Three photographs
showed Dean with Leverette and were offered to show Leverette
was a committed Family Swan gang member and that Leverette’s
message to Dean the day before the shooting to remove the paper
plate evidenced Dean’s involvement in planning the crime.
Relying primarily on People v. Cardenas (1982) 31 Cal.3d
897, Dean argues the multiple gang photographs were
cumulative and unduly prejudicial because they created a risk
the jury would infer Dean had a “criminal disposition.” Cardenas
is distinguishable. In that case, eyewitnesses to a convenience
store robbery that resulted in the store manager’s murder gave

22
“sharply conflicting” testimony about the identification of
Cardenas as the perpetrator, and the defense presented several
alibi witnesses. (Id. at pp. 901-903.) The prosecutor attacked the
credibility of the alibi witnesses by eliciting admissions that they
and Cardenas were all members of the same gang, and the
prosecutor asked numerous questions about their gang affiliation
and gang practices. (Id. at pp. 903-905.) The Supreme Court
reversed Cardenas’s conviction, holding the gang-related
evidence was unduly prejudicial and cumulative under Evidence
Code section 352 because it was offered only to show the alibi
witnesses’ bias, and other evidence already showed the witnesses’
ties with Cardenas; further, the prosecutor suggested in his
questioning that the robbery could be gang-related, creating a
“near certainty that the jury viewed [Cardenas] as more likely to
have committed the violent offenses charged against him because
of his membership in the Flores gang.” (Id. at pp. 905-906.)
Here, as discussed, the photographic evidence came from
Dean’s own social media account and was relevant to prove
crimes that were indisputably gang-related. Moreover, although
the gang officers testified that Dean was a self-admitted Family
Swan, the photographic evidence was not cumulative because it
was introduced for multiple purposes other than Dean’s gang
affiliation.

D. The Trial Court Abused Its Discretion in Admitting
Evidence of Ammunition Found in Dean’s Home But Not
the Gun Photograph; the Error Was Harmless
Dean contends the trial court erred in admitting evidence
of the ammunition found during the search of his home and the
social media photograph of him holding a semiautomatic
handgun (the gun photograph) because they were irrelevant and

23
highly prejudicial under Evidence Code section 352. Dean’s
contention has merit as to the ammunition but not the gun
photograph. However, the error was harmless.

1. The gun photograph
At the pretrial hearing on the admission of evidence, the
prosecutor acknowledged as to the gun photograph that she
would not be able to prove the handgun in the photograph was
the murder weapon. However, she stated it “could be” the
murder weapon. On the first day of trial, the trial court ruled the
prosecutor could use the gun photograph based on the
prosecutor’s confirmation that the gun “is of the type that could
have been used based on the evidence at the crime scene.”
Detective Harris opined at trial that in the gun photograph Dean
was holding what appeared to be a semi-automatic gun that could
use 9-millimeter, .40- or .45-caliber bullets (for which casings
were found at the scene), but she could not say with certainty
what caliber bullet the gun could use.
The trial court did not abuse its discretion in admitting the
gun photograph. Dean is correct that “[w]hen the prosecution
relies . . . on a specific type of weapon, it is error to admit
evidence that other weapons were found in his possession, for
such evidence tends to show, not that he committed the crime,
but only that he is the sort of person who carries deadly
weapons.” (People v. Riser (1956) 47 Cal.2d 566, 577, overruled
on other grounds by People v. Morse (1964) 60 Cal.2d 631; accord,
People v. Barnwell (2007) 41 Cal.4th 1038, 1056.) However,
“[w]hen the specific type of weapon used to commit a homicide is
not known, it may be permissible to admit into evidence weapons
found in the defendant’s possession . . . that could have been the
weapons employed. There need be no conclusive demonstration

24
that the weapon in defendant’s possession was the murder
weapon.” (Riser, at p. 577, italics added [.38 bullet shells found
in defendant’s car were admissible where resembled .38 bullets
found at scene and could have come from murder weapon;
.22 bullet shells and Colt weapon not admissible where excluded
as murder weapon or bullets from murder weapon]; see People v.
Neely (1993) 6 Cal.4th 877, 896 [“the weapon and the
ammunition located in defendant’s truck were found by deputy
sheriffs at the crime scene, shortly after commission of the
crimes, and there was no direct evidence as to the fatal shooting
that would render this evidence irrelevant to establish facts
material to proof of the charged offenses”].)
In this case, the bullet casings found at the crime scene
were of four different calibers, but none of the weapons was
recovered. Because the gun in the photograph could have been
used by Dean in the shooting (that is, it could hold 9-millimeter,
.40-caliber, or .45-caliber bullets), the photograph was not
inadmissible under Riser.
Moreover, the gun photograph, captioned with a swan
emoji, was relevant as gang evidence, which as discussed, was
probative of identity, motive, and intent. (See People v. Cox
(2003) 30 Cal.4th 916, 956 [“when weapons are otherwise
relevant to the crime’s commission, but are not the actual murder
weapon, they may still be admissible”], disapproved on other
grounds in People v. Doolin (2009) 45 Cal.4th 390, 421, fn. 22.)
The probative value of the gun photograph outweighed any
undue prejudice from the inference Dean was a violent person (in
showing he had access to a gun), and the trial court did not abuse
its discretion in admitting the gun photograph.

25
2. The ammunition found in Dean’s home
We agree with Dean that the trial court abused its
discretion in admitting evidence of the significant amount of
ammunition found in his home. There was no evidence to match
this ammunition to the type of shell casings found at the crime
scene,8 and the search of Dean’s home occurred more than a year
after the shooting. The ammunition was therefore not relevant to
prove that Dean was one of the shooters. Further, the
prosecutor’s suggestion in her closing argument that the stockpile
of ammunition meant Dean must have had “matching weapons”
(absent any evidence) asked the jury to draw an improper and
prejudicial inference “that he is the sort of person who carries
deadly weapons.” (People v. Riser, supra, 47 Cal.2d at p. 577;
accord, People v. Barnwell, supra, 41 Cal.4th at p. 1056.)
Although admission of the ammunition evidence was error,
the error was harmless. “[T]he application of ordinary rules of
evidence like Evidence Code section 352 does not implicate the
federal Constitution, and thus we review allegations of error
under the ‘reasonable probability’ standard” of People v. Watson
(1956) 46 Cal.2d 818. (People v. Marks (2003) 31 Cal.4th 197,
226-227; accord, People v. Thomas (2023) 14 Cal.5th 327, 373-374
[applying Watson to alleged error under Evid. Code, § 352 in
admitting cumulative and inflammatory photographs].) “‘Under
the Watson standard, the erroneous admission of [unduly

8 Although some of the ammunition was of the same caliber
as shell casings found at the crime scene, there was no expert
testimony tying the bullets in Dean’s home to the specific type of
shell casings found in the parking lot. The Attorney General does
not contend the similarity of the caliber of bullets supported
admission of the evidence.

26
prejudicial evidence] warrants reversal of a conviction only if the
appellate court concludes that it is reasonably probable the jury
would have reached a different result had the photograph been
excluded.’” (Thomas, at p. 374.)
There is no reasonable probability the jury would have
found Dean not guilty had the ammunition evidence been
excluded. Counsel for both parties made clear during their
opening statements and closing arguments that the central issue
was identification. The jury watched the video footage of the
shooting, and it was undisputed that this was a violent murder of
a rival gang member. In finding Dean guilty, the jury necessarily
believed the identification testimony, thus finding it was Dean
who stood on a street corner in broad daylight and fired at least
12 shots in rapid succession from a semiautomatic handgun at
H.J. and Jouner. It is not reasonably probable had the jury not
found the identification testimony credible that the jury would
have convicted Dean on the basis he was a violent man who
stored ammunition in his home, especially in light of the fact no
evidence was presented tying the ammunition to the shooting.

27
DISPOSITION

The judgment is affirmed.

FEUER, J.
We concur:

MARTINEZ, P. J.

STONE, J.

28

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.