CourtListener 10767616•People v. Day CA3
Texte intégral
Filed 12/31/25 P. v. Day CA3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
THIRD APPELLATE DISTRICT
(Nevada)
----
THE PEOPLE, C100539
Plaintiff and Respondent, (Super. Ct. No. CR0001679)
v.
JUSTIN SCOTT DAY,
Defendant and Appellant.
A jury found defendant Justin Scott Day guilty of three counts of willful infliction
of corporal injury resulting in a traumatic condition on a person, J. Doe, with whom he
had a dating relationship (Pen. Code, § 273.5, subd. (a)—counts 1, 3 & 5),1 two counts of
assault by means of force likely to produce great bodily injury (§ 245, subd. (a)(4)—
1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Penal Code.
1
counts 2 & 6), and one count of the lesser included offense of assault (§ 240—count 4).2
In a bifurcated proceeding, defendant admitted he had a prior strike conviction. (§§ 667,
subds. (b)-(i), 1170.12.)
The court sentenced defendant to an aggregate term of eight years in prison: four
years on count 1 (the low term of two years, doubled for the prior strike) and consecutive
two-year terms on counts 3 and 5 (one-third the middle term of three years, doubled).
The sentences on counts 2, 4, and 6 were stayed pursuant to section 654.
On appeal, defendant challenges the admission of evidence of: (1) his parole
status, (2) his methamphetamine use, and (3) his calls and text messages with Doe while
he was in jail. He further contends the cumulative effect of these alleged errors
necessitates reversal. Defendant also argues the trial court erred by failing to exercise its
discretion to strike his prior strike pursuant to section 1385. Additionally, defendant
asserts, and the People concede, that he is entitled to additional days of presentence
credit. We will accept the People’s concession and modify the judgment accordingly.
The judgment is otherwise affirmed.
I. BACKGROUND
On March 23, 2023, officers from the Grass Valley Police Department were
dispatched to Doe’s apartment. When they arrived, they could hear yelling from inside.
Doe opened the door. She appeared disheveled and her face, neck, and chest were red.
Her eye makeup was running down her cheek. There was redness and bruising in the
shape of handprints on her neck. The injuries to her skin were raised and swollen.
Initially, she said she was fine and that she had been in a yelling argument with
defendant. After officers separated Doe and defendant into different areas of her
apartment, she gestured for an officer to be quiet and then gestured that she had been
2 The jury found defendant not guilty of assault by means of force likely to produce great
bodily injury with respect to count 4.
2
choked. An officer took her out of the apartment and onto the front porch. There, she
said she found out defendant had been cheating on her and confronted him about it. He
became aggressive and started arguing. He grabbed her throat with both hands and
started to choke her. He headbutted her in the face several times while they were in the
bedroom. She freed herself and went to the kitchen, where he followed her, continued to
call her names, and then choked her again and pushed her against the kitchen window.
They went back into the bedroom where he pushed her onto the bed and placed her into a
headlock. She told officers she did not know how long the headlock lasted: “It could
have been five hours because she was kind of going in and out.” She said she did not
lose consciousness and her breath was not restricted. She was not asked if she was dizzy,
woozy, lightheaded, or faint, or if she had trouble swallowing or moving her neck. Doe
said defendant threw bottles at her. The officers did not find any thrown or broken bottles
or damage to the window.
Doe told officers she felt fine and did not need medical attention. She appeared
reluctant to answer these questions. She said she wanted an emergency protective order
and wanted it to require defendant to move out. When an officer returned to deliver the
protective order, Doe was holding an icepack to her forehead.
Initially, defendant told law enforcement his argument with Doe did not get
physical at all. When he was asked if there was any reason why Doe would have marks
on her, defendant said he “pulled her in for a hug,” and wrapped his arms around her back
and neck to calm her down while they were arguing.
Body camera footage from the officers who responded to the incident was played
for the jury.
A physician who testified as an expert on strangulation opined based on the police
report, the photos of Doe taken by law enforcement, the body camera footage, and her
statements at the preliminary hearing, that there was a very reasonable chance Doe was
unconscious at some point during the incident. The physician further concluded the
3
photographs of Doe taken by the officers was consistent with multiple episodes of
strangulation including chokehold strangulation and manual hand strangulation. He also
testified regarding the risks of strangulation.
While in custody, defendant called Doe in violation of the protective order. Two
days after his arrest, the couple discussed the incident in a series of four recorded calls
that were played for the jury. In the first call, defendant told Doe, “I’m sorry that this
happened,” and they had the following exchange:
“[Defendant] . . . I’m hoping you could just, you know what I mean, make a
statement in court saying that I didn’t hurt or hit or abuse you at all.
“[Doe]: I’m just kind of starting to get a black eye, [defendant].
“[Defendant]: What?
“[Doe]: I’m getting a black eye.
“[Defendant]: Are you serious?
“[Doe]: From when you had, when you headbutted me.
“[Defendant]: Oh my God. I don’t remember headbutting you.
“[Doe]: Yeah, you held me there, and you headbutted me.
“[Defendant]: No, I didn’t. I might have –
“[Doe]: You did.
“[Defendant]: – I might have like did that when you first woke me up. Baby, I’m
so sorry.” Shortly thereafter, Doe asked defendant, “why did this happen?” and “why did
you start doing meth again, you know?”
In the second call, Doe responded to defendant’s protestations that he did not
speak to another woman that night by saying, “you still freaked out on me on meth, you
know?”
In the third call, Doe said, “Everyone knows what you did. Everyone’s texting me
asking if I’m okay.” Defendant replied, “Well, I love you baby. It breaks my heart for
me to hear that.” Doe told defendant, “I love you, but I can’t be with you. It’s not safe.”
4
Doe told defendant that he held her down by the face, headbutted her, choked her, and
slammed her. He denied doing each of these things. He said, “I remember yelling at you
and getting mad at you, but that’s it.”
In the fourth call, defendant repeatedly promised to “make it right.”
The jury also heard additional telephone calls and text messages between
defendant and Doe that took place while defendant was in jail.
The People called Doe as a witness at trial and, on the advice of counsel, she
invoked her Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination as soon as she was asked
what happened on the night of March 23, 2023. Accordingly, the court found her
unavailable as a witness.
As part of defendant’s case, the jury was read portions of Doe’s testimony at his
preliminary hearing. In it, Doe testified that she lied to the officers because she was upset
with defendant and wanted him to leave. Doe testified that defendant had choked her
with her consent during sex. Her breathing was not restricted. She recalled some of her
statements to officers, but did not remember telling them that defendant wrapped her
head in a headlock and had her throat in his arms or that he grabbed her throat and pushed
her into the kitchen window. She also did not recall telling officers that defendant pushed
her on the bed and put her into a second headlock. She testified she told officers
defendant had headbutted her because they had bumped heads, and she was upset and
confused. Later, she testified that their heads had not touched, and she had misinterpreted
it when he was leaning in trying to talk to her.
On rebuttal, the prosecution called an investigator for the El Dorado County
District Attorney’s office to testify as an expert on intimate partner violence and the cycle
of violence. He explained the cycle of violence has three stages: the tension building
stage, the incident or acute violence stage, and the honeymoon or reconciliation stage.
He explained it is common for victims to change their story, recant, or deny that anything
has occurred. He explained there are different reasons victims could give inconsistent
5
statements including having a memory gap that is pieced together through talking to
others, a change in how they feel, or trying to protect the abuser.
II. DISCUSSION
A. Admission of Evidence of Defendant’s Parole Status
Defendant argues the trial court violated his due process right to a fair trial by
allowing the prosecution to introduce evidence of his parole status. He contends this
evidence should have been excluded under Evidence Code section 352 because his parole
status was not relevant to the issues of the case and its prejudicial effect was extremely
high. We disagree.
1. Trial Court Proceedings
Prior to trial, defendant filed a motion in limine seeking an order that no testifying
witness refer to the fact that he was on parole at the time of his arrest. He argued it was
more prejudicial than probative under Evidence Code section 352.
During the initial hearing on the motion, the prosecution opposed the motion and
explained that while it would not use defendant’s parole status in argument, defendant’s
parole status was “deeply intertwined in the statements of the victim” and mentioned on
the body camera footage. The prosecution also argued it was probative and true that
defendant was out of custody for a very limited period of time when the incident took
place, and their relationship started when he was in custody. The prosecution argued that
within a month or two of being out of custody, there were a number of incidents, which
proved a cycle of violence. Defense counsel argued the evidence was irrelevant and
prejudicial, and the body camera footage could be edited or stopped and restarted.
The prosecution submitted supplemental briefing that further argued defendant’s
parole status was probative of defendant’s case that Doe was angry with him for his
infidelities and used his status as a parolee to have him arrested. The prosecution
explained the evidence was offered for the limited purpose of providing the true context
of the facts, circumstances, and witness statements to the jury. Accordingly, the
6
prosecution explained the People would not be opposed to a limiting instruction that the
jury could not consider defendant’s parole status for purposes of determining guilt.
The court ruled that the body camera videos were admissible, and the jury would
be given a limiting instruction. The court ordered the prosecution to redact portions of
the footage where the officers elicited more detailed information from defendant about
his parole, but allowed Doe’s “incidental” statements about defendant’s parole status to
remain.
In the body camera footage from the incident played for the jury, Doe twice told
the responding officers that defendant was on parole: “You guys gotta take him, he’s on
parole”; and, “He got put on parole.”
In rebuttal and without defense objection, the prosecution introduced a jail text
message where defendant stated in, part, to Doe, “They can’t tell the jury that I’m on
parole.”
The jury was instructed that, “[d]uring the trial, you heard testimony regarding the
defendant’s custody status and testimony related to the defendant being on parole. You
are not to consider this evidence in determining his guilt.”
2. Analysis
“ ‘Relevant evidence’ means evidence, including evidence relevant to the
credibility of a witness or hearsay declarant, having any tendency in reason to prove or
disprove any disputed fact that is of consequence to the determination of the action.”
(Evid. Code, § 210.) The trial court may not admit irrelevant evidence, but it has broad
discretion in determining whether evidence is relevant. (People v. Babbitt (1988) 45
Cal.3d 660, 681.) It also has discretion to exclude even relevant evidence under
Evidence Code section 352 “if its probative value is substantially outweighed by the
probability that its admission will (a) necessitate undue consumption of time or (b) create
substantial danger of undue prejudice, of confusing the issues, or of misleading the jury.”
(Evid. Code, § 352.) “A trial court’s exercise of discretion in admitting or excluding
7
evidence is reviewable for abuse [citation] and will not be disturbed except on a showing
the trial court exercised its discretion in an arbitrary, capricious, or patently absurd
manner that resulted in a manifest miscarriage of justice [citation].” (People v. Rodriguez
(1999) 20 Cal.4th 1, 9-10.)
We cannot conclude the trial court abused its discretion in not requiring the
prosecution to edit out the portions of Doe’s initial statements to law enforcement that
mentioned defendant’s parole status. Doe was unavailable at trial and the credibility of
her previous conflicting statements was a focus of the trial. Doe’s statements that
defendant was on parole and that the officers had to take him because he was on parole
were part of her initial statements. Further, these statements were relevant to the jury’s
evaluation of Doe’s motivations and the veracity of her initial and subsequent version of
events. At the preliminary hearing on May 23, 2023, Doe testified she did not recall
telling officers that defendant was on parole and had to leave. She testified she did
remember telling officers she wanted them to take defendant to jail and that she did so
because she was angry with him. Hearing the actual statements Doe made to the officers
was relevant for understanding whether her later assertion that she had made these
statements only because she was angry with defendant was credible. Her statements
about his parole status demonstrated she had in mind the potential consequences to
defendant of her initial statements when she made them and were probative of their
veracity.
Defendant did not object to the admission of his own mention of his parole status
in his text messages to Doe. To the extent he argues on appeal that he had already
objected to the admission of his parole status generally and any further objection would
have been futile, it is not clear this was sufficient to preserve for appeal an objection that
this particular reference to his parole status should have been redacted for its relevance or
cumulative prejudicial effect. The trial court had analyzed other references to defendant’s
parole status separately and ordered them removed.
8
Regardless, we disagree with defendant’s assertion that any reference to his parole
status should have been excluded under Evidence Code section 352. The brief mentions
of his parole status that the jury heard took up little time, and were unlikely to confuse the
issues, or mislead the jury. The jury was not told why defendant was on parole. We
cannot conclude the mere mention that defendant was on parole “was inflammatory or
substantially likely to elicit an impermissible emotional response from the jury. Evidence
that defendant was on parole . . . was not so emotionally charged as to inhibit its logical
evaluation by the jury. Nor would the evidence, by virtue of its nature, have prompted
the jury to punish defendant. No abuse of discretion appears.” (People v. Mendoza
(2011) 52 Cal.4th 1056, 1092.) Likewise, we disagree with defendant’s assertion that the
trial court deprived him of his due process right to a fair trial by allowing the jury to hear
this evidence. “The admission of relevant evidence will not offend due process unless the
evidence is so prejudicial as to render the defendant’s trial fundamentally unfair.”
(People v. Falsetta (1999) 21 Cal.4th 903, 913.) This was not the case here.
B. Admission of Evidence of Defendant’s Methamphetamine Use
Defendant argues the trial court deprived him of his due process right to a fair trial
by allowing the prosecution to introduce evidence of his methamphetamine use. He
contends the trial court abused its discretion by not excluding this evidence under
Evidence Code section 352. We disagree.
1. Trial Court Proceedings
Prior to trial, defendant filed a motion in limine to prohibit Doe from opining that
defendant was under the influence of methamphetamine on March 23, 2023. Defendant
argued there was no other admissible evidence that he was under the influence other than
her opinion, and that the evidence was not relevant and should be excluded under
Evidence Code section 352. In response, the prosecution explained that defendant’s
methamphetamine use was admissible because it would be offered through his own
statements or adoptive admissions from the jail calls. Further, the evidence was relevant
9
because the statements were “in the context of his use or influence at the time that the
abuse occurred,” and it was relevant to prove the abuse occurred. The prosecution also
argued defendant’s methamphetamine use was relevant to Doe’s credibility because it
explained why he told Doe he did not remember doing specific acts that she accused him
of. The prosecution argued “it is well established that the use of substances involves the
numbing of the faculties as to affect the capacity to observe, to recollect or to
communicate.”
The trial court initially explained, “I think there are some admissions made or at
least arguable admissions made. It would go to the issue of credibility if nothing else.”
The court ruled the prosecution could not expand on the issue by introducing evidence
about the effects of methamphetamine. The prosecution asked if it could “comment on it
in closing arguments.” The court replied, “Of course. To the extent that the evidence
comes in that supports it, and as you indicated in your briefing I think we all have some
knowledge that substance use affects our abilities in certain ways. So as long as you
don’t go outside what the evidence is, that’s fine.”3 Later, the court explained its ruling
in more detail: “[Defendant] does make admissions about using meth. There is some
indication that I think could be an inference that he was using meth or had used meth that
day based on his own statement. I do think it goes to credibility. [¶] That is what I ruled
again tentatively pending receiving all of the briefing. I have received the briefings and I
haven’t changed my ruling. I did, however, deny [the prosecution]’s request to bring in
an expert about the effects of methamphetamine. I think that goes a step too far.” When
discussing whether Doe could be asked if defendant was under the influence of
3 Whether the prosecutor’s closing argument ultimately improperly used the evidence
that the trial court properly admitted is a separate issue that defendant did not properly
raise.
10
methamphetamine for purposes of impeachment,4 the court added: “Here’s the reason
why I still think it is more probative than prejudicial. Number one, it would go to
credibility because it also potentially explains some of his not remembering everything
that was going on that night. He does make the admission, so it’s not like [Doe] would be
testifying to something he didn’t already admit.”
2. Analysis
The trial court did not abuse its discretion in admitting references to defendant’s
methamphetamine use in the jail conversations between defendant and Doe. These
references, which made clear defendant was using methamphetamine at the time of the
charged crimes, were relevant to understanding their discussions. In the first jail call
played for the jury, shortly after confronting defendant with what he had done, Doe asked
him “why did this happen?” and “[w]hy did you start doing meth again, you know?” In
the second call, Doe said, “you . . . freaked out on me on meth” and “you were still doing
meth,” and defendant agreed: “I was. I’m sorry.” As the trial court explained, the
references to methamphetamine use were relevant to explaining why, when Doe
confronted defendant with her recollection of events, he at times stated he did not
remember what she described. Defendant argues that his inability to recall events was
not genuinely disputed. This point is debatable. Moreover, it misses the larger issue.
The jury was tasked with making sense of the various versions of events they were
presented with. In one exchange, Doe mentioned defendant headbutted her and he
responded, “Oh my god. I don’t remember headbutting you.” In another, he stated he
only remembered yelling and getting mad at her. Their references to his
methamphetamine use put it into context and explained their different version of events
and how defendant could assert he did not remember things that would otherwise seem to
4 During the preliminary hearing, Doe testified that defendant was not under the
influence of any substances at the time of the incident.
11
be very memorable. It was therefore relevant to the jury’s interpretation of their
discussions and the veracity of their statements.
The trial court did not abuse its discretion in concluding the probative value of the
evidence was not substantially outweighed by its prejudicial impact under Evidence Code
section 352. The references did not necessitate an undue consumption of time. Some of
the statements by Doe and defendant suggested that his methamphetamine use was a
source of conflict in their relationship and contributed to his actions on March 23, 2023.
Doe stated, “I wasn’t happy because you were on meth and, you know?” When
defendant promised he would not hurt her again, Doe expressed skepticism by stating,
“You’re gonna start using meth again.” Doe also told defendant, “I don’t know if that’s
how you are or if that was the drugs,” and “who you are when you’re high is completely
different than who you really are.” We disagree with defendant’s assertion that the
evidence prejudiced the jury against him because methamphetamine use carries
“particularly strong negative connotations in the public consciousness, associated with
violent and erratic behavior, addiction, and criminal activity” and “transforms the focus
from whether the alleged crimes occurred to whether [defendant] is the type of person
who would commit such crimes due to substance abuse.” The evidence of defendant’s
drug use at the time of the offense was less inflammatory than the evidence of the
charged crimes, and the trial court prohibited the prosecution from expanding on the issue
by introducing evidence about the effects of methamphetamine use generally. As such,
we cannot conclude the court abused its discretion in admitting it. We also disagree with
defendant’s assertion that the trial court deprived him of his due process right to a fair
trial by allowing the jury to hear this evidence. The evidence was not “so prejudicial as
to render the defendant’s trial fundamentally unfair.” (People v. Falsetta, supra, 21
Cal.4th at p. 913.)
12
C. Admission of Calls and Text Messages with Doe
Defendant argues the evidence of his jail calls and text messages with Doe should
have been excluded under the Sixth Amendment because it was testimonial, and he was
not given an opportunity to cross-examine her at trial. Even assuming without deciding
that this argument was not forfeited for failure to raise it in the trial court, it is unavailing
because the statements at issue are not testimonial.
“ ‘The Sixth Amendment bars the admission of testimonial hearsay from a witness
who did not appear at trial, unless the witness was unavailable to testify and the
defendant had a previous opportunity for cross-examination.’ [Citations.] The Sixth
Amendment is concerned only with those hearsay statements that qualify as ‘testimonial.’
[Citations.] ‘The high court has yet to state definitively just what facts conclusively
demonstrate that particular hearsay qualifies as testimonial. [Citation.] However, it has
never held a hearsay statement to be testimonial unless it was sufficiently formal and
made by or to a government agent during the course of a criminal investigation, for the
primary purpose of preserving evidence for trial.’ ([Citation]; see also Ohio v. Clark
(2015) 576 U.S. 237, 246 [‘Because at least some statements to individuals who are not
law enforcement officers could conceivably raise confrontation concerns, we decline to
adopt a categorical rule excluding them from the Sixth Amendment’s reach.
Nevertheless, such statements are much less likely to be testimonial than statements to
law enforcement officers’].)” (People v. Alvarez (2025) 18 Cal.5th 387, 461.) The
statements at issue here do not meet these criteria.
Defendant’s argument that the statements are testimonial relies on a court of
appeal decision, People v. Sisavath (2004) 118 Cal.App.4th 1396, that predated Davis v.
Washington (2006) 547 U.S. 813 and held that “[t]he pertinent question is whether an
objective observer would reasonably expect the statement to be available for use in a
prosecution.” (Sisavath, supra, at pp. 1402-1403.) Defendant argues an objective
observer would reasonably expect the statements at issue would be available for use in
13
prosecution because the jail calls in particular began with the warning that calls were
subject to recording and monitoring. Moreover, he asserts he and Doe were speaking and
texting using aliases because they understood their statements could be used against
them. “[I]n Davis the United States Supreme Court has since refined the definition of
testimonial statements.” (People v. Cage (2007) 40 Cal.4th 965, 989.) Indeed, “Davis
now confirms that the proper focus is not on the mere reasonable chance that an out-of-
court statement might later be used in a criminal trial.” (Id. at p. 984, fn. 14.) “Rather, a
critical consideration is the primary purpose of the police in eliciting the statements.”
(People v. Romero (2008) 44 Cal.4th 386, 422.)5 Additionally, “Sisavath is readily
distinguishable because there the ‘interview took place after a prosecution was initiated,
was attended by the prosecutor and the prosecutor’s investigator, and was conducted by a
person trained in forensic interviewing.’ ” (People v. Alvarez, supra, 18 Cal.5th at p.
463.) Defendant offers no other support for the suggestion that merely because the
government records a conversation, that conversation becomes testimonial. We reject his
assertion.
D. No Cumulative Error
Defendant contends his convictions must be reversed because of the cumulative
effect of his alleged errors. “There was, however, no error to cumulate.” (People v.
Phillips (2000) 22 Cal.4th 226, 244.)
5 “[I]n [Davis], the high court gave this explanation: ‘Statements are nontestimonial
when made in the course of police interrogation under circumstances objectively
indicating that the primary purpose of the interrogation is to enable police assistance to
meet an ongoing emergency. They are testimonial when the circumstances objectively
indicate that there is no such ongoing emergency, and that the primary purpose of the
interrogation is to establish or prove past events potentially relevant to later criminal
prosecution.’ ” (People v. Romero, supra, 44 Cal.4th at p. 421.)
14
E. Denial of Romero Motion
Defendant argues the trial court abused its discretion by denying his so-called
Romero motion to strike his prior strike conviction. We find no abuse of discretion.
Prior to his sentencing hearing, defendant filed a motion pursuant to People v.
Romero (1996) 13 Cal.4th 497 (Romero) asking the court to dismiss the prior strike
allegation in the furtherance of justice pursuant to section 1385. Defendant argued the
court should dismiss his prior strike because otherwise it would result in punishment
“disproportionate to the severity of the present offense” and because he “demonstrates a
willingness and ability to rehabilitate himself.”
The prosecution opposed the motion, noting that defendant “suffered the prior
strike a mere six weeks prior to committing the present offense and was on parole when
he committed the present offense,” has multiple recent felony convictions, and “failed to
rehabilitate despite grants of probation with a myriad of rehabilitative orders and
opportunities.” At the time he committed the prior strike offense, defendant was on
“multiple grants of mandatory community supervision or felony probation.” Further,
defendant has been assessed as a “high risk of violence.”
Defendant filed an amended Romero motion adding arguments that the court
should dismiss his prior strike in the interests of justice because the offense was
connected to mental illness and prior childhood trauma. (§ 1385, subd. (c)(2)(D)-(E).)
On appeal, defendant argues the current offenses were “not particularly serious”
because they “involved domestic violence with resulting bruising” and no weapons and
were “not the type of violent crimes that the Three Strikes law was primarily designed to
address.” Defendant similarly argues the prior strike “was not of the gravest nature”
because it did not involve great bodily injury or a firearm. In the first degree residential
burglary, defendant broke into a home and left with a decorative knife. Defendant argues
he demonstrated a willingness to rehabilitate by completing a four-hour domestic
violence class and submitting letters of support. Defendant contends he suffered
15
significant childhood trauma within the meaning of section 1385, subdivision (c)(2)(E).
He also argues mental health conditions made his youth difficult. Further, he “was only
24 years old and had no significant record of prior violent criminal offenses.” He also
asserts as a mitigating circumstance that Doe provoked him.
Subdivision (a) of section 1385 provides that a judge may, in furtherance of
justice, dismiss a criminal action. In Romero, our Supreme Court held that a trial court
may utilize this provision to strike or dismiss a prior strike conviction for purposes of
sentencing under the Three Strikes law. (Romero, supra, 13 Cal.4th at p. 504.) In ruling
on a Romero motion, the court considers “whether, in light of the nature and
circumstances of his present felonies and prior serious and/or violent felony convictions,
and the particulars of his background, character, and prospects, the defendant may be
deemed outside the scheme’s spirit, in whole or in part, and hence should be treated as
though he had not previously been convicted of one or more serious and/or violent
felonies.” (People v. Williams (1998) 17 Cal.4th 148, 161.)
We review a trial court’s denial of a Romero motion for abuse of discretion.
(People v. Carmony (2004) 33 Cal.4th 367, 374.) “This review is deferential. . . . [A]n
appellate court may not substitute its judgment about appropriate sentencing for that of
the trial court, but instead must give due regard to the discretion vested in that court.
[Citations.] The appellate court can find a reversible abuse of discretion only if it
concludes that no reasonable judge would have agreed with the trial court’s decision.
[Citations.] Unless that standard is met, the appellate court must affirm the decision,
even if it ‘might have ruled differently’ on the Romero motion ‘in the first instance.’ ”
(People v. Dain (2025) 18 Cal.5th 246, 258.) “Abuse of discretion in failing to strike a
prior conviction occurs in limited circumstances: where the trial court is not aware of its
discretion; where the trial court considers impermissible factors; or where applying the
Three Strikes law would produce an arbitrary, capricious, or patently absurd result under
the specific facts of a particular case. [Citation.] A reviewing court’s disagreement with
16
the trial court’s weighing of proper factors (as distinct from the trial court’s reliance on
improper factors in the weighing process) does not constitute an abuse of discretion.”
(People v. Dryden (2021) 60 Cal.App.5th 1007, 1029; see Carmony, supra, at pp. 378-
379.)
On this record, we cannot conclude the trial court abused its discretion.
Defendant’s suggestion that because the court set forth the reasons it decided not to strike
defendant’s prior strike, it did not consider all the circumstances and arguments in favor
of doing so is unpersuasive. The trial court was not required to give “great weight” to
any mitigating factors under section 1385, subdivision (c)(2). (See e.g. People v. Serrano
(2024) 100 Cal.App.5th 1324, 1338 [the Three Strikes law is an alternative sentencing
scheme not impacted by § 1385, subd. (c)].) The record reflects that the trial court
considered defendant’s mitigating evidence and arguments and nonetheless concluded
that defendant still “fit squarely within the [T]hree [S]trikes law for the following
reasons: [¶] [He] was on parole for his prior strike when this offense occurred, very
recently placed on parole. [¶] . . . [¶] His prior attempts at rehabilitation have failed
despite numerous grants of probation and mandatory supervision. He’s considered a high
risk to reoffend. [¶] And this is a very serious case that he was adjudicated guilty by a
jury. [¶] I just honestly think it would be an abuse of discretion for the Court to grant
this Romero motion in this case. I do not find that it would be in the interest of justice to
exercise the Court’s discretion, and I’m declining to strike the prior conviction.” We
cannot conclude this decision was “so irrational or arbitrary that no reasonable person
could agree with it.” (People v. Carmony, supra, 33 Cal.4th at p. 377.) Defendant
headbutted and strangled Doe repeatedly. Defendant’s attempts to downplay his present
crimes are not ones the trial court was required to find successful. Likewise, defendant’s
assertions that he demonstrated a willingness to rehabilitate were not conclusions the
court was required to come to based on this record. We discern no abuse of discretion.
17
F. Presentence Credit
Defendant contends, and the People concede, that the trial court incorrectly
awarded him 304 days of actual credit and 304 days of conduct credit for a total
presentence custody credit of 608 days instead of 310 days of actual credit and 310 days
of conduct credit for a total of 620 days. The miscalculation appears to be the result of
the trial court failing to include the fact defendant was in custody from his initial arrest on
March 23, 2023, until March 28, 2023, before being arrested again on April 19, 2023.
We accept the concession and order the judgment modified to reflect 620 days of
presentence credit. (People v. Guillen (1994) 25 Cal.App.4th 756, 764.)
III. DISPOSITION
The judgment is modified to reflect that defendant is awarded 310 days of actual
custody credit and 310 days of conduct credit, for a total of 620 days of presentence
credit. The trial court is ordered to prepare an amended abstract of judgment reflecting
this modification and further ordered to forward a certified copy of the amended abstract
of judgment to the Department of Corrections. In all other respects, the judgment is
affirmed.
/S/
RENNER, Acting P. J.
We concur:
/S/
BOULWARE EURIE, J.
/S/
FEINBERG, J.
18
Vous vous demandez comment ce texte s’applique à votre situation ?
Consultation gratuite, sans engagement
Décrivez votre situation. Notre équipe vous recontactera par e-mail pour votre consultation.
Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude
Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.