In re J.K. CA4/1

CourtListener 10761926Calctapp19 déc. 2025

Texte intégral

Filed 12/19/25 In re J.K. CA4/1

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

COURT OF APPEAL, FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION ONE

STATE OF CALIFORNIA

In re J.K., a Person Coming Under
the Juvenile Court Law.
D085898
SAN DIEGO COUNTY HEALTH
AND HUMAN SERVICES
AGENCY, (Super. Ct. No. J520720)

Plaintiff and Respondent,

v.

C.A.,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of San Diego County,
Daniela A. Reali, Judge. Affirmed.
Diana W. Prince, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for
Defendant and Appellant.
David J. Smith, Acting County Counsel, Lisa M. Maldonado, Chief
Deputy County Counsel, and Natasha C. Edwards, Deputy County Counsel,
for Plaintiff and Respondent.
C.A. (Mother) appeals an order renewing a domestic violence
restraining order which prohibits her from contacting J.K. The original
three-year restraining order was issued by the juvenile court in 2021 when,
based on allegations of years of physical, emotional, and sexual abuse, the

court found jurisdiction of minor J.K. under Welfare and Institutions Code1
section 300, subdivision (a). In 2024, J.K., then a teenager with a permanent
plan of foster care, asked to renew the restraining order citing Mother’s long
history of abuse, his ongoing mental health treatment, and his fear that
Mother would harm him without a restraining order in place.
Mother contends there was insufficient evidence to support a finding
that J.K. had a reasonable apprehension of future abuse. Mother further
argues that the negative burdens of the restraining order on Mother’s ability
to obtain housing and employment outweigh the benefits of such an order.
We disagree and affirm the order.
BACKGROUND
A. Initiation of Dependency Proceeding
On April 19, 2021, J.K. arrived at a friend’s house “disheveled” and
upset. He said Mother beat him, choked him, and threatened him with a
knife before he ran out of his house without shoes. He had a red mark on his
neck that dissipated before law enforcement arrived.
J.K. told his friend’s mother and a responding officer about Mother’s
long history of hitting him, slapping his face, hitting him with a belt, and
choking him. A few weeks earlier, Mother burned J.K. by pressing a hot pan
on his hand during an argument. On another occasion, Mother entered the
bathroom while he was bathing and pushed his head under water for several

1 Further undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code.

2
seconds. J.K. “broke down crying” while describing Mother’s current and past
abuse saying he did not know why she did these things to him.
J.K. said Mother also abused his sister, who was now an adult and in
college. They tried to report Mother once, but nothing happened because
Mother knew the responding social worker. Mother told the children no one
would believe them.
The Agency filed a petition on behalf of J.K. pursuant to section 300,
subdivision (a) alleging J.K. suffered or was at substantial risk of suffering
serious physical harm inflicted non-accidentally by Mother.
In a forensic interview, J.K. detailed years of physical and verbal abuse
that occurred every week. Mother would scream at him and tell him he was
“a terrible kid.” She hit him with the metal part of a belt, choked him, held
his head underwater, hit him with a ruler to the point of bleeding, burned his
hand with a hot pan, and threatened him with a knife. She also touched his
private areas.
When J.K. met with the social worker in May 2021, he again recounted
a consistent history of abuse. He said he was hit “too many [times] to count”
and mother screamed at him, calling him names like “stupid” and “idiot.”
J.K. worried about the abuse he would suffer if he returned to Mother. He
did not want visits or phone calls with her, instead he wanted a restraining
order.
J.K.’s sister corroborated J.K.’s reports saying she also suffered abuse
throughout her childhood. She believed Mother started beating J.K. more
often when the sister left for college. The sister said J.K. was “absolutely not”
safe with Mother because Mother could not control her anger.

3
B. Restraining Order
J.K.’s attorney requested a restraining order to protect J.K. from
Mother. The application detailed the extensive physical abuse Mother
inflicted on J.K. and his fear of Mother. The application stated a restraining
order was necessary to protect J.K.’s physical safety and emotional
well-being.
At the scheduled jurisdictional and dispositional hearing, Mother
requested a trial on the issues of jurisdiction, disposition, and case plan. The
court issued a temporary restraining order and added the restraining order
request as a trial issue.
C. Jurisdictional Review Period
Throughout the jurisdictional review period, J.K. consistently said he
did not want visits or contact with Mother. He did not want her to be his
educational rights holder and he did not want her to know where he attended
school.
J.K.’s therapist diagnosed him with posttraumatic stress disorder
(PTSD). The therapist created a crisis plan with J.K. to address his fear of
returning to Mother’s care.
Another therapist determined J.K.’s PTSD was “a very severe case” as
evidenced by excessive sadness, crying, nightmares, flashbacks, and
struggling to fall asleep. J.K. became visibly anxious and upset whenever
they talked about Mother. He adamantly declined any communication or
visits with mother. The therapist did not observe any triggers for J.K.’s
anxiety other than the topic of Mother or court.
Mother did not participate in services and did not communicate with
the Agency before the contested jurisdiction and disposition hearing.

4
D. Contested Adjudication, Disposition, and Permanency Hearings
On November 19, 2021, after a two-day contested adjudication and
disposition hearing, the court sustained the petition and made a true finding
that J.K. was a child defined by section 300, subdivision (a). The court placed
J.K. out of the home. The court bypassed reunification services for Mother
under section 361.5, subdivision (b)(6) and set a section 366.26 hearing.
The court issued a restraining order protecting J.K. from Mother for
three years. It prohibited mother from any contact with J.K. and required
her to stay 100 yards away from him, his home, and his school.
At the section 366.26 hearing in April 2022, the court ordered a
permanent plan of foster care for J.K. J.K. still did not want contact with
Mother. Mother did not stay in touch with the Agency or ask about J.K.
E. Postpermanency Period
J.K. did well over the next few years at a residential education
program. He excelled in school, had a job at his residential home, and
participated in extracurricular activities. He also participated in therapy.
He asked to attend a more challenging school and requested accommodations
for study time and space at the residential home.
Mother did not maintain contact with the Agency. She attended the
postpermanency hearings virtually. In April 2023, she asked her attorney to
raise concerns about J.K.’s SAT preparation and his medical needs. In
August 2023, she opposed J.K.’s request to attend a different school, as well
as the appointment of counsel to help J.K. advocate for his educational needs.
F. Restraining Order Renewal
Shortly before the restraining order was set to expire in November
2024, J.K. filed a request to renew the restraining order. J.K. said he was

5
afraid of Mother and that she would harm him if the restraining order was
not renewed. He cited the history of excessive physical discipline and
emotional abuse he suffered at Mother’s hands, which led to posttraumatic
stress, and the fact that Mother had not participated in any child abuse or
parenting classes.
Mother objected to renewing the restraining order. At the restraining
order hearing in January 2025, J.K. asked the court to make the restraining
order permanent because he still feared Mother and he did not want contact
with her. His counsel argued the restraining order could and should be
renewed under Family Code section 6345, subdivision (a) without the need
for a showing of further abuse.
Mother objected to a permanent restraining order and her counsel
argued the restraining order should not be renewed because it was
unnecessary and imposed an undue hardship on Mother’s ability to secure
employment and housing. Counsel argued there was no evidence of
continued risk requiring protection since there had been no incidents or
violations in the past three years. Additionally, counsel argued the
restraining order, which is a public record, had a negative impact on Mother’s
housing and employment opportunities and penalized her for her past
behaviors.
The court asked why a permanent restraining order was necessary
considering J.K. would soon be an adult. J.K.’s counsel explained J.K. felt a
permanent restraining order would be best for his mental health given the
extreme abuse he endured from Mother.
The court denied the request for a permanent restraining order, but
renewed the restraining order for five years. The court, after considering the
totality of the circumstances, based the renewal on the fact that J.K. was a

6
minor dependent on the juvenile court, J.K.’s fear of Mother, and his medical
treatment. Mother appealed.
DISCUSSION
A. General Legal Principles
During a dependency proceeding, the juvenile court has exclusive
jurisdiction to issue a restraining order prohibiting any person from
“molesting, attacking, striking, stalking, threatening, sexually assaulting,
battering, harassing, telephoning, . . ., contacting, . . ., or disturbing the
peace” of the dependent child. (§ 213.5, subd. (a).) When related to domestic
violence, such restraining orders are issued in the manner provided by the
Family Code for a domestic violence restraining order (DVRO). (Ibid; In re
A.P. (2024) 103 Cal.App.5th 1137, 1145.)
Neither a showing of prior physical abuse nor “ ‘a reasonable
apprehension of future physical abuse’ is required” for the initial issuance of
a restraining order under section 213.5, subdivision (a). (In re Lilianna C.
(2024) 99 Cal.App.5th 638, 644 citing In re B.S. (2009) 172 Cal.App.4th 183,
193–194.) Since the purpose of dependency proceedings is to determine and
protect the best interests of the child, the court may issue a restraining order
enjoining a person, including a parent, from contacting a child “if such
contact would jeopardize the child’s safety” including “emotional and
psychological safety.” (In re A.M. (2019) 37 Cal.App.5th 614, 619 (A.M.).)
The juvenile court may extend a restraining order on the motion of any
party under section 213.5, subdivision (d)(1). A court may also renew a
DVRO under Family Code section 6345, subdivision (a), “upon the request of
a party, either for five or more years, or permanently, at the discretion of the
court, without a showing of further abuse since the issuance of the original
order. . . .” Under this statute, the “legal standard for renewal . . . is whether

7
the protected party entertains a reasonable apprehension of future abuse.
[Citation.] ‘[T]his does not mean the court must find it is more likely than not
that abuse will occur if the protective order is not renewed. It only means the
evidence demonstrates it is more probable than not there is a sufficient risk
of future abuse to find the protected party’s apprehension genuine and
reasonable.’ ” (Michael M. v. Robin J. (2023) 92 Cal.App.5th 170, 179
(Michael M.).)
We review orders granting or denying a request to review a restraining
order for abuse of discretion, deferring to the trial court’s factual
determinations. (Lister v. Bowen (2013) 215 Cal.App.4th 319, 333.) “To the
extent that we are called upon to review the trial court’s factual findings, we
apply a substantial evidence standard of review.” (Loeffler v. Medina (2009)
174 Cal.App.4th 1495, 1505.)
B. Application
No published cases address the standard the juvenile court must apply
to extend or renew a restraining order in a dependency action under section
213, subdivision (d)(1). The parties analyze the renewal under the
reasonable apprehension standard for renewing a DVRO under Family Code
section 6345. This standard for renewal of a restraining order protecting a
child in a dependency case could be viewed as a higher standard than is
required for an initial restraining order under section 213.5. However, we
need not decide this issue because substantial evidence supported the
juvenile court’s decision to renew the restraining order based either upon a
finding that J.K. had a reasonable apprehension of future abuse or a finding
that failing to renew the restraining order would jeopardize J.K.’s safety.
In evaluating a reasonable apprehension of future abuse for renewing a
DVRO, the court may consider relevant factors such as (1) the findings and

8
facts underlying the original restraining order, (2) any significant changes in
the circumstances that justified the original protective order, and (3) any
burdens imposed on the restrained party by the protective order. (Ritchie v.
Konrad (2004) 115 Cal.App.4th 1275, 1291 (Ritchie).)
1. Facts Underlying the Original Restraining Order Support Renewal
For the first factor, the juvenile court declared J.K. a dependent of the
court and issued the initial restraining order based an extensive and serious
history of Mother’s physical, verbal, and sexual abuse of J.K. since a tender
age. Shortly before detention, Mother threatened J.K. with a knife,
intentionally burned his hand with a hot pan, pushed his head under water,
choked him, and beat him. The court bypassed reunification services for
Mother based on a finding of severe abuse under section 361.5, subdivision
(b)(6).
Mother’s opening brief minimizes the incident that gave rise to
detention by saying the “initial physical abuse perpetrated by Mother was a
result of the circumstances at that time” arising from Mother working long
hours, lack of parental financial support for J.K., and “difficulty” between
Mother and J.K. about his grades, school, household chores, and being
distracted by his phone while water was running in the sink. “Mother felt
she ‘just couldn’t handle it anymore.’ ” She said she was trying to set up
counseling services when J.K. left for his friend’s house.
Even if the court found Mother’s account of the incident credible, this
was not the first incident of abuse. Both J.K. and his sister reported serious
forms of mistreatment throughout their childhood beginning in elementary
school. It is reasonable to expect such severe and prolonged instances of
physical and emotional abuse could “give rise to a long-lasting fear of the
perpetrator that could continue for many years.” (Michael M., supra, 92

9
Cal.App.5th at p. 181.) Indeed, J.K.’s therapists diagnosed severe PTSD from
Mother’s abuse. J.K. became visibly anxious and upset whenever they
discussed Mother, the possibility of visits with Mother, or the possibility of
returning to her care. No other triggers elicited this response. Thus, the
findings and facts supporting the initial restraining order are sufficient to
establish a reasonable apprehension risk of future abuse. (Ritchie, supra,
115 Cal.App.4th at p. 1291.)
Mother contends there was no evidence to support a reasonable fear
she would or could physically abuse J.K. in the future. This argument is
unavailing. “For a DVRO renewal, the protected party need not show a
reasonable apprehension of future physical abuse. [Citation.] The statute
defines ‘abuse’ broadly to include any behavior that could be enjoined under
Family Code section 6320, such as harassing or disturbing the peace of the
other party. [Citations.] This definition encompasses ‘a multitude of
behaviors’ that do ‘not involve any physical injury or assaultive acts.’
[Citation.] Thus, ‘there is no requirement that the party requesting a renewal
have a fear of physical abuse.’ ” (Michael M., supra, 92 Cal.App.5th at
p. 179.) Minor’s renewal application stated Mother’s excessive physical
discipline caused “emotional suffering” and led PTSD. J.K. said he was
fearful Mother would cause further psychological harm if Mother were
permitted to contact him. This is sufficient.
2. Circumstances Have Not Changed Significantly
For the second factor, Mother contends circumstances for both J.K. and
her have changed so the “opportunity and likelihood of future abuse has
diminished to the degree they no longer support a renewal of the order.” She
points to J.K.’s progress since placement at his residential education
program, including his ability to advocate for his desires and needs. She

10
contends there is no evidence he discussed Mother or his fear of her with his
social worker, CASA, or therapist once he was placed at the residential
school. She also states he “moved about freely on his own and with his CASA
without expressing fear . . . that Mother might be tracking or searching for
him.”
First, under Family Code section 6345, it “ ‘would be anomalous to
require the protected party to prove further abuse occurred in order to justify
renewal of that original order. If this were the standard, the protected party
would have to demonstrate the initial order had proved ineffectual in halting
the restrained party’s abusive conduct just to obtain an extension of that
ineffectual order.’ ” (Michael M., supra, 92 Cal.App.5th at pp. 179–180.)
Similarly, there can be no requirement for a protected party to prove that the
restrained party was tracking or searching for the protected party, which
would likely be a violation of the very order meant to protect the party.
Second, a child’s resilience does not mean a restraining order is not
necessary. This is particularly true where, as here, there was evidence that
any contact with the restrained parent would jeopardize the child’s emotional
and psychological safety. (A.M., supra, 37 Cal.App.5th at p. 619.)
J.K. explained he wanted the restraining order renewed to protect his
mental health. Without a restraining order, he was not confident Mother
“would not contact him” and “would not subject him to further harm
psychologically.” The court renewed the restraining order based, in part, on
J.K.’s mental health treatment.
There were several instances over the years where J.K. lost his temper
and was involved in verbal or physical altercations with other students or
staff members. In therapy sessions, J.K. was working on improving stress
management skills, conflict resolution skills, and emotional regulation

11
strategies, particularly in scenarios he perceives as confrontational or when
he feels slighted.
Although the status reports do not indicate specific discussions about
Mother in therapy sessions, it is reasonable to conclude J.K.’s issues with
conflict, emotional regulation, and stress are related to the trauma he
suffered from Mother’s abuse. For example, after J.K.’s forensic interview, he
became defiant and began spiraling and acting out. Mother’s counsel
acknowledged J.K. has “issues when it comes to his mental health concerning
his fear of the mother.”
Finally, Mother’s abuse over the years frequently related to arguments
about school and grades. During the dependency proceedings, Mother raised
questions about and objected to the schools he wanted to attend. She also
questioned J.K.’s preparation for standardized tests. Based on the history of
abuse as well as the questions Mother raised, it is reasonable for J.K. to fear
that without a restraining order Mother would contact him to exert influence
about school choice, educational performance, or career plans. This could
open old wounds which would result in emotional or psychological harm and
set back his mental health treatment.
Mother also contends her circumstances have changed so a restraining
order is not necessary. She says she “exited” J.K.’s life after he was detained
by not engaging with the social worker, not participating in her case plan,
and not attempting to contact or find J.K. She also points to her desire to
make telephonic court appearances in the dependency proceedings. This does
not indicate Mother has moved on with her life to the point that the
opportunity and likelihood of future abuse has diminished. To the contrary,
it indicates she has not engaged in services to address the concerns giving
rise to the DVRO.

12
Mother’s compliance with the restraining order by not trying to contact
J.K. does not mean a restraining order is not necessary. (Michael M., supra,
92 Cal.App.5th at p. 180.) Instead, the fact “that the initial restraining order
‘proved effective [was] a good reason for seeking its renewal.’ ” (Cueto v.
Dozier (2015) 241 Cal.App.4th 550, 562 quoting Ritchie, supra, 115
Cal.App.4th at p. 1284.)
The record indicates Mother wished to appear by video conference or
telephonically due to “personal issues” that included her “strong desire not to
be in the same room as the minor, as well as other triggering feelings which
court brings upon her.” This statement focused on her own comfort and
preferences rather than what was best for J.K.
Mother also claims a restraining order is not necessary because there is
no evidence she attempted to contact J.K.’s adult sister “[o]nce the older
sister cut off contact with Mother.” The phrasing of this argument is
interesting because the sister apparently cut off contact after Mother tracked
her at college and sent security and a residential assistant to her room as a
means of control. Around the time of the sister’s 18th birthday, Mother
became angry over the sister’s courseload and called her demeaning names.
When the sister said she would not take this from Mother anymore, Mother
sent the police to her room. Mother reported that the sister stopped speaking
to Mother in October 2020, but they apparently argued again in early 2021
about the sister’s college grades and attendance. J.K. said Mother was mad
during the April 2021 incident because she contacted the sister who told
Mother that Mother was abusive. The record is largely opaque about
Mother’s interaction or lack thereof with the sister after these events, but
this lack of information does not support a conclusion that Mother would

13
continue to stay away from J.K. without a restraining order. Indeed, the
sister told the social worker Mother was “dangerous.”
As J.K. pointed out in the renewal application, there is no evidence that
Mother has engaged in services to address the issues that led to detention
such as parenting or child abuse classes. There is no indication Mother made
any progress toward gaining insight about how her behavior harms J.K. or
what was in his best interests. (Cueto v. Dozier, supra, 241 Cal.App.4th at p.
562.) Thus, the evidence supported the juvenile court’s finding that Mother’s
circumstances had not changed to the point that renewal of the restraining
order was unnecessary.
3. The Risks of Harm Outweigh Any Negative Implications for Mother
As to the third factor, Mother’s counsel argued during the hearing that
the restraining order had a negative impact on Mother’s employment and
housing options. There is no evidence to support this statement. As of the
renewal hearing date, Mother lived in the same apartment as she did since
the inception of the case. Mother did not stay in contact with the Agency, but
there is no evidence she lost her job or suffered adverse employment actions
because of the restraining order. Additionally, Mother faced criminal
charges, which likely would overshadow any negative implications from a
restraining order.
The juvenile court was well within its discretion to determine the risk
of harm to J.K. from not renewing the restraining order outweighed any
negative impacts Mother might experience from the restraining order.

14
DISPOSITION
The order is affirmed.

RUBIN, J.

WE CONCUR:

KELETY, Acting P. J.

CASTILLO, J.

15

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.