CourtListener 10746870•Thomas v. HNJ Starfish CA2/8
Texte intégral
Filed 12/3/25 Thomas v. HNJ Starfish CA2/8
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION EIGHT
JAQUAY THOMAS, B333073
Plaintiff and Appellant, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. 20STCV01147)
v.
HNJ STARFISH,
Defendant and Respondent.
APPEAL from a post-trial order and judgment of the
Superior Court of Los Angeles County, Gregory Alarcon, Judge.
Affirmed.
Law Office of Peggy A. Farrell, Peggy A. Farrell; Hennig
Kramer Ruiz & Singh, Jennifer R. Kramer, Brandon K. Ruiz,
Sereena J. Singh, Ashley Cruz; Law Offices of Rob Henning and
Robert A. Hennig; Gusdorff Law and Janet Gusdorff for Plaintiff
and Appellant.
The Ruttenberg Law Firm and Mark A. O’Brien for
Defendant and Respondent.
_______________________
After securing a partial jury verdict of $330,000 in his
favor, plaintiff Jaquay Thomas appeals the trial court’s post-trial
decision not to award him and other employees of defendant HNJ
Starfish (HNJ) $5 million in penalties under the Private
Attorneys General Act of 2004 (PAGA). HNJ is the owner of the
restaurant that employed Thomas as a server. Thomas has failed
to supply us with necessary portions of the record to enable us to
evaluate the proceedings in the trial court. He has not carried
his burden of providing an adequate record. As a result, we
affirm.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
We do not have the operative complaint or any record of
proceedings, motions, or trial court rulings that may have
narrowed or eliminated causes of action in the complaint.
Nor do we have a reporter’s transcript of the evidence in
support of and against the cause or causes of action that were
presented to the jury. As a result, we cannot, with confidence,
recite the factual background upon which the trial court based its
rulings. We recite the facts as stated in plaintiff’s opening brief
for context only.
On July 11, 2017, plaintiff was hired as a server by
defendant’s restaurant Hot N’ Juicy Crawfish. On February 1,
2019, at around 10:00 p.m. while at work in the back of the
restaurant, Thomas heard loud screams, crashes and commotion.
He ran to the restaurant floor and saw a tall man standing
behind the register. The man threw one female employee up
against a wall, slapped her face and then began choking another
female employee. A male co-worker put the man in a momentary
chokehold until the man broke free and continued to act
2
violently, including yelling in plaintiff’s face and throwing
restaurant items at him and his co-workers.
Police arrived and ultimately subdued the man who was
taken out of the restaurant on a stretcher. After police cleared
the restaurant around 10:40 p.m., plaintiff’s manager told the
employees to “clear the checks” and offer anyone on the waitlist
food to go. As a result, plaintiff did not leave the restaurant until
after midnight. When he got home, he was so distraught at what
he had experienced that he emailed his manager that he would
need to take the next two days off. He told his manager he was
upset about the incident and also about the way management
had treated the employees after the attack—without empathy or
concern for their well-being. He did not get a response.
Plaintiff did not work his shifts for the next two days. As a
group several employees asked the restaurant to provide a
security guard to ensure employee safety in the restaurant. Two
days passed after the incident and the restaurant had not
responded, so several employees decided not to come to work at
their regularly scheduled start time. Management responded
with an email advising employees that “if anybody doesn’t show
up for their shift they will be written up.” In the meantime,
when plaintiff came back to work for his next scheduled shift on
February 6, 2019, he was fired because “you didn’t show up for
work on the 2nd or 3rd even though you weren’t physically
attacked during the incident. . . . Meanwhile other employees
who were physically attacked showed up for work.” Plaintiff was
the only employee to request a medical leave following the
incident and the only employee who was terminated.
We reiterate we do not know how many of these facts were
presented to the jury because we have no transcript of the jury
3
trial proceedings. And, as set out below, it is not our role to take
appellant’s word for it.
PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
According to the Register of Action, plaintiff filed a
complaint on January 10, 2020. A first amended complaint was
filed on August 3, 2020, and a second amended complaint was
filed on August 27, 2020. Plaintiff withdrew the second amended
complaint on November 30, 2020. A third (mislabeled fourth)
amended complaint was filed on March 19, 2021. Each complaint
spawned demurrers and motions to strike. Plaintiff filed a
motion for summary adjudication and a separate statement of
undisputed facts on April 5 and 6, 2021. Defendant answered the
third amended complaint on May 28, 2021.
In preparation for trial, the parties filed joint witness and
exhibit lists on October 15, 2021. Plaintiff filed a statement of
the case on the same date. Plaintiff filed motions in limine. Jury
trial began on November 1, 2021 and ended on November 9, 2021.
On March 14, 2022 the court started a non-jury trial—Phase 2—
on “remaining issues.” This included Plaintiff’s request for PAGA
penalties. A minute order dated May 31, 2023, sets out the trial
court’s ruling on Plaintiff’s request: “Following the bifurcated
trial on May 10, 2023, and after considering the extensive
briefing, the court denies all claims by Plaintiff under the Private
Attorney General’s Act (‘PAGA’), Lab. C. Sections 2699 et seq.
based on the exercise of the court’s discretion considering all the
facts of the case as well as the grounds stated in Defendant’s trial
brief of June 13, 2022 and supplemental trial brief on September
2, 2022.”
Judgment was entered on August 31, 2023. The judgment
stated: “Pursuant to jury verdict on November 9, 2021, Plaintiff
4
Jaquay Thomas, an individual (‘Plaintiff’), shall have and recover
from Defendant HNJ Starfish, dba Hot N’ Juicy Crawfish, a
California corporation (‘HNJ’), non-economic damages of
$330,00.00.
“Following the bifurcated bench trial on May 10, 2022, and
subsequent briefing, the Court now denies all claims by Plaintiff
under the Private Attorneys General Act (‘PAGA’), Lab. C.
§§ 2699 et seq.
“Except as included within the jury verdict, the Court
denies all other remaining causes of action or claims by Plaintiff,
including all remaining claims for damages or penalties.
“Any award of court costs and attorneys’ fees shall be
determined post-judgment via memorandum of costs or by the
Court on noticed motion. Given the mixed outcome in this case,
in which Plaintiff prevailed on a few of his many causes of action
but HNJ prevailed on the remainder, the Court leaves the issue
of which party prevailed to subsequent determination by motion.”
Both parties requested a statement of decision on the
PAGA penalties, which the court filed on July 20, 2023. The
statement of decision reads as follows:
“[O]n November 9, 2021, the jury found for Plaintiff on his
7th, 10th, and 11th claims under Labor Code §§ 98.6, 6404, and
6406 and awarded him $330,000 in compensatory damages. The
jury did not render a verdict as to Plaintiff’s 15th and 16th
Causes of Action involving Plaintiff’s claim that his employment
contract with HNJ contained illegal terms. Plaintiff expressly
dismissed his 15th and 16th Causes of Action when he filed his
supplemental PAGA Brief on September 22, 2022.” (Fns.
omitted.) At this point, the trial court also noted in two footnotes
“[t]he verdicts are special verdicts derived from 98.6, 6404, and
5
6406 for the 7th, 10th, and 11th Causes of Action. The jury
rendered no verdict under Lab. C. §§ 6400-6403” and “Plaintiff’s
17th Cause of Action involved Plaintiff’s claim under PAGA;
Plaintiff never prepared or submitted any jury verdict or
instructions regarding 15th, 16th, and 17th Causes of Actions.”
The trial court continued. “The court now finds that
Plaintiff did not prove by a preponderance of the evidence that
any other employees of HNJ faced the same Labor Code
violations that Plaintiff prevailed on at jury trial (i.e., Lab. C.
§§ 98.6, 6404, and 6406). Plaintiff did not prove that HNJ
retaliated against any other employee or that HNJ interfered
with or failed to provide a safe and healthful work environment
as to any other employee.
“Plaintiff prevailed before the jury based primarily on a
single act of random violence by a third party who, uninvited,
entered HNJ’s restaurant on February 1, 2019. When Plaintiff
failed to appear for his scheduled shift the next morning, HNJ
fired him. Plaintiff did not prove that this single act of random
violence and subsequent firing affected or was applied to any
other employee such that HNJ might have violated Lab. C.
§§ 98.6, 6500-04, and 6404 as to any other employee.
“Lab. C. § 98.6(b)(3) provides for a civil penalty not to
exceed $10,000 against an employer who violates section 98.6.
HNJ was entitled to a jury trial on all issues of damages or
penalties, except insofar as PAGA allows a court to award
penalties for proven violations of the Labor Code. See CCP
§ 631(f); Grossblatt v. Wright (1951) 108 Cal.App.2d 475, 486
(right to jury trial as to statutory penalties); LaFace v. Ralphs
Grocery Co. (2022) 75 Cal.App.5th 388, 402 (finding no right to
jury trial on PAGA claims for civil penalties).
6
“The court finds that, because Plaintiff never sought from
the jury any penalties for himself under Lab. C. § 98.6(b)(3), he
cannot recover them post-jury verdict, either for himself or, under
PAGA, on behalf of other employees of HNJ.
“Lab. C. §§ 6400-04 and 6404 do not provide for any civil
penalties. PAGA only provides for a private right of action, as an
alternative to enforcement by the Labor and Workforce
Development Agency (‘LWDA’), when the Labor Code provision at
issue ‘provides for a civil penalty to be assessed and collected by
the [LWDA].’ Lab. C. § 2699(a); Sargent v. Board of Trustees of
Calif. St. Univ., 61 Cal.App.5th 658, 674-75 (2021) (‘PAGA
penalties cannot be sustained on Sargent’s claims premised on
statutory provisions that do not themselves provide for
penalties’). [(Fn. omitted.)]
“The court further finds that Plaintiff did not prove at trial
that he exhausted his administrative remedies with the LWDA
before filing suit. See Lab. C. § 2699.3(a) & (b); Caliber
Bodyworks, Inc. v. Super. Ct. (2005) 134 Cal.App.4th 365, 376.
Plaintiff attempted to show that he had exhausted his
administrative remedies, via a May 24, 2022, post-trial
declaration from his counsel, but both sides had already rested on
May 10, 2022 and Plaintiff did not seek to re-open the evidence at
trial.
“Before filing suit, Plaintiff obtained a citation from Cal-
OSHA in response to his claims under Lab. C. §§ 6400-06. The
court finds that Plaintiff’s PAGA claims based on the same
statutory sections therefore are barred. See Lab. C.
§ 2699.3(b)(2) (‘if the division issues a citation, the employee may
not commence an action pursuant to Section 2699’).
7
“Although Plaintiff did not sue third-party Heo Bo, LLC
(‘Heo Bo’), in Fountain Valley, CA, or amend his complaint to add
Heo Bo as a defendant, Plaintiff also sought in the bench trial, on
behalf of Heo Bo’s employees, PAGA penalties against Heo Bo.
By Ruling and Minute Order dated March 20, 2023, the court
denied all PAGA penalties against Heo Bo. Heo Bo did not
employ Plaintiff and Plaintiff did not prove that HNJ and Heo Bo
were so interlinked that they were substantially one employer or
a common enterprise.
“The court also finds that, under Lab. C. § 2699(e)(1), it has
the same discretion that the LWDA would have whether to assess
a civil penalty. Under Lab. C. § 2699(e)(2), the court has the
discretion to award less than the maximum civil penalty when
doing otherwise would be unjust, arbitrary and oppressive, or
confiscatory.
“Based on the foregoing factual and legal determinations,
and in the exercise of the Court’s discretion, the court therefore
denies all claims by Plaintiff under PAGA.
“To wrap up one other post-trial matter, the court also will
address Plaintiff’s claim for non-PAGA civil penalties on his
twelfth and thirteenth causes of action under Lab. C. §§ 226(c)
and 1198.5 (based on HNJ’s alleged failure to timely provide
Plaintiff his personnel file and wage records after termination).
Plaintiff’s pre-trial motion for summary adjudication of his
twelfth and thirteenth cause of action did not seek adjudication of
any penalties. Plaintiff likewise failed to submit to the jury any
evidence or claim for penalties on his 12th and 13th Causes of
Action. The court therefore denies any penalties on Plaintiff’s
12th and 13th Causes of Action under Lab. C. §§ 226(c) and
1198.5.”
8
This appeal followed.
DISCUSSION
We presume an appealed judgment is correct. (Jameson v
Desta (2018) 5 Cal.5th 594, 609 (Jameson).) To overcome this
presumption, the appellant must affirmatively demonstrate error
and provide an adequate record on all issues. (Ibid.) In the
absence of a contrary showing in the record, we will make all
presumptions in favor of the trial court ruling. (Ibid.) If any
evidence, argument, or other matters could have been presented
to the trial court that would have justified the challenged ruling,
we will presume those matters were presented. (Ibid.) It follows
from this rule that if the record is inadequate for meaningful
review, the appellant defaults, and we will affirm the trial court’s
ruling. (Ibid.) It is therefore appellant’s burden to provide an
adequate record and failure to do so requires the reviewing court
to resolve the appeal against appellant.
The complete record of an appeal consists of the record of
any oral proceedings; record of documents filed or lodged in the
trial court; and original exhibits received in evidence or rejected
by the trial court. (Cal Rules of Court, rules 8.120, 8.122(a)(3),
8.224.)
Here, the appellate record includes three reporter’s
transcripts of a post-verdict evidentiary hearing on whether the
trial court should impose PAGA penalties. The record also
includes Appellant’s Appendix. This Appendix includes the
following:
• A minute order setting out the special verdict questions
and the jury’s answers to those questions.
• Two minute orders setting out the names of the
witnesses and exhibits presented at the post-verdict
9
PAGA penalty hearings on March 14, 2022 and May 10,
2022.
• Plaintiff’s post-hearing trial brief in support of his
request for PAGA penalties, including exhibits
presented and not presented at the hearing, the court’s
ruling on plaintiff’s motion for summary adjudication,
an employee rules manual.
• An order and notice of ruling granting plaintiff’s ex
parte application to file documents under seal.
• Defendant’s trial brief re plaintiff’s request for PAGA
penalties, also including exhibits and a reporter’s partial
transcript of a hearing on November 5, 2021.
• Minute order dated July 22, 2022 asking for
supplemental briefing on the PAGA penalty request.
• Defendant’s supplemental trial brief re request for
PAGA penalties.
• Plaintiff’s supplemental trial brief re request for PAGA
penalties.
• Plaintiff’s trial brief re proposed trial plan, trifurcation
of issues, claims and damages, including exhibits and a
partial reporter’s transcripts of proceedings on
November 1, 2021 and 2, 2021.
• Declaration of counsel in support of plaintiff’s
supplemental trial brief, including timelines and emails
between counsel.
• Defendant’s Timeline of PAGA claims.
• Minute order dated September 26, 2022 stating the trial
court has received the briefing and is taking the PAGA
penalty request under submission.
10
• Plaintiff’s trial brief, exhibits, and Declaration of Peggy
A. Farrell in support of the judgment against HNJ.
• Defendant’s objections to evidence filed in support of
plaintiff’s request for PAGA judgment.
• Defendant’s trial brief and request for judicial notice,
including a partial reporter’s transcript of November 8,
2021 re plaintiff’s request for PAGA judgment.
• Plaintiff’s Reply to defendant’s trial brief.
• Ruling on plaintiff’s Request for PAGA judgment
against HNJ and Heo Bo as alter egos.
• Ruling on defendant’s objections to evidence filed in
support of plaintiff’s request for PGA judgment.
• Defendant’s trial brief re plaintiff’s lack of entitlement to
PAGA penalties.
• Plaintiff’s amended reply trial brief in support of award
of PAGA penalties, including prior pleadings and
exhibits.
• Minute order dated May 31, 2023, denying PAGA
penalty relief.
• Minute order dated July 20, 2023, re: Statement of
Decision on PAGA penalties.
• Judgment filed August 31, 2023.
• Notice of Appeal.
• Register of Actions.
Apparently, to explain the absence of the operative
complaint and the Reporter’s Transcripts of the jury trial,
Plaintiff states in his Opening Brief that the “underlying facts of
the incident which led the jury to conclude that Mr. Thomas’s
termination violated various provisions of the California Labor
Code are not a subject of this appeal except insofar as they shed
11
light on the question of the trial court’s denial of an award of any
PAGA penalties. The relevant facts, set forth below, are taken
from the factual summary contained in Plaintiff’s PAGA Claim
Notice that was filed with the [Labor Workforce Development
Agency] on September 19, 2019, and attached to Thomas’s PAGA
Trial Brief.” We decline to accept a PAGA Claim Notice as the
basis for facts upon which we evaluate a trial court’s post-jury
trial rulings.
Appellant’s failure to include a complete record dooms his
appeal. First, it is apparent from the trial court’s extensive and
complex statement of decision that it referred to and relied on
what was and was not argued and presented at the evidentiary
hearing and jury trial and pretrial proceedings to support its
rulings. In the minute order on the post-verdict evidentiary
hearing, the court expressly stated that its exercise of discretion
to deny the request for PAGA penalties was based on “all the
facts of the case.” Although plaintiff provided us with the
Reporter’s Transcripts of the two-day bench trial on the post-
verdict request for PAGA penalties, those transcripts paint an
incomplete picture of everything the trial court considered in
making its findings of fact and conclusions of law.
Second, plaintiff contends the court abused its discretion
and erred as a matter of law in making its rulings. We cannot
evaluate whether the court correctly exercised its discretion and
applied and interpreted applicable law in its denial of PAGA
penalties unless we can evaluate the record to determine whether
the trial court’s factual bases actually exist. (Nelson v. Anderson
(1999) 72 Cal.App.4th 111, 136 [exercise of discretion will not be
disturbed on appeal where appellant fails to provide a record
sufficient to determine whether the result would have been
12
different in the absence of the alleged trial court error].) And we
decline to accept without corroboration plaintiff’s rendition of the
operative facts. It is not our role to blithely accept what we are
told. An appellant must “[s]upport any reference to a matter in
the record by a citation to the volume and page number of the
record where the matter appears.” (Cal. Rules of Court, rule
8.204(a)(1)(C).) If a party fails to support an argument with the
necessary citations to the record, the argument will be deemed to
have been waived. (Nwosu v. Uba (2004) 122 Cal.App.4th
1229, 1246; United Grand Corp. v. Malibu Hillbillies, LLC (2019)
36 Cal.App.5th 142, 156.)
“[L]ack of a verbatim record of [trial court proceedings] will
frequently be fatal to a litigant’s ability to have his or her claims
of trial court error resolved on the merits by an appellate court.”
(Jameson, supra, 5 Cal.5th at p. 608.) That is the case here.
DISPOSITION
The order and judgment are affirmed. Respondent HNJ
Starfish shall recover its costs on appeal.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
STRATTON, P. J.
We concur:
WILEY, J. VIRAMONTES, J.
13
Vous vous demandez comment ce texte s’applique à votre situation ?
Consultation gratuite, sans engagement
Décrivez votre situation. Notre équipe vous recontactera par e-mail pour votre consultation.
Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude
Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.