People v. Jordan CA2/2

CourtListener 10687798Calctapp2 oct. 2025

Texte intégral

Filed 10/2/25 P. v. Jordan CA2/2
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION TWO

THE PEOPLE, B340243
Plaintiff and Respondent, Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. 24IWCF00068
v.
TONY DONELLE JORDAN,
Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of
Los Angeles County, Altus W. Hudson, Judge. Reversed in part,
affirmed in part, and remanded with instructions.

Ryan Peabody, under appointment by the Court of Appeal,
for Defendant and Appellant.

Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief
Assistant Attorney General, Susan Sullivan Pithey, Assistant
Attorney General, Noah P. Hill and Deepti Vaadyala, Deputy
Attorneys General, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
_______________________________
Defendant Tony Donelle Jordan was convicted by a jury of
three felonies: assault with force likely to produce great bodily
injury (GBI assault; Pen. Code,1 § 245, subd. (a)(4); count 1);
vandalism causing $400 or more in damage (§ 594, subd. (b)(1);
count 3); and assault with a deadly weapon (§ 245, subd. (a)(1);
count 4). The trial court sentenced him to an aggregate term of
five years eight months in state prison, calculated as follows: four
years for assault with a deadly weapon; one year for GBI assault;
and eight months for vandalism. (See maj. opn., fn. 3, post.)
Jordan appeals his conviction for GBI assault on two
grounds: (1) that the evidence was insufficient to show he used
force likely to produce great bodily injury; and (2) the trial court
erred in failing to instruct the jury on the lesser included offense
of simple assault. We disagree with the former but agree with the
latter and give the People the option to retry Jordan subject to
proper instructions or accept a reduction in the conviction to
misdemeanor simple assault.
Jordan also asserts the trial court should have applied
section 654 to stay punishment for all but one of his convictions
because they were all committed in furtherance of a single
objective. We agree section 654 applies to the convictions for
assault with a deadly weapon and vandalism but disagree that it
also applies the conviction for GBI assault.

1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Penal Code.

2
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
The primary victim in this case is Jordan’s mother,
Yvonne B.,2 who was about 62 years old at the time of the
incident in question. She lives in a second-floor apartment in
Inglewood with her daughter Destiny B. and two of Jordan’s
children. At the time of the incident, Jordan was about 32 years
old and about six feet tall. He did not, and was not allowed to,
live at Yvonne’s apartment. He sometimes visited but his visits
did not always go “so great,” to the point that police had to be
called on occasion. His convictions stem from one such visit.
Around noon on January 26, 2024, Yvonne and
Destiny returned to the apartment from running errands and
found Jordan waiting nearby. Yvonne and Destiny tried to walk
into the apartment without communicating with him, but he
followed them up the stairs. Yvonne told him he could not come
inside. She and Destiny left him at the threshold and locked him
out. Jordan stayed outside and shouted to be let in. He
threatened to break down the door, break the window, and
“ ‘mess up the house,’ ” but did none of these things.
About an hour later, Yvonne passed Jordan a plate of hot
food through the door. He rejected it but demanded keys to a car
she no longer had—a Nissan that was recently involved in a
wreck. Yvonne responded she did not have those keys or any keys
that belonged to him, but he continued to insist she give him
keys. She retreated into the apartment to get dressed for her
shift as a security officer at a bank.

2 We refer to the victim and other witness in this case by
their first names and last initials only. (Cal. Rules of Court,
rule 8.90(b)(4) & (b)(10).)

3
Once dressed in her work uniform, Yvonne headed down to
the street where she had two cars parked: a Nissan she had
bought to replace her wrecked car; and a Toyota she had rented
from Enterprise after the wreck. Jordan was waiting by the
Toyota, continuing to ask her for keys to a car. She continued to
rebuff his requests.
As Yvonne was standing on the driver’s side of the Toyota
preparing to leave, Jordan picked up a landscaping brick from
the neighbor’s property and threw it through the Toyota’s front
passenger window. Yvonne implored him to stop. He ignored her
and, without saying another word, methodically broke every
window on the car (and some other parts) while Yvonne waved
her arms and cried for help. Destiny came outside to see what
was happening.
When Jordan threw a brick at the Toyota’s back window,
Yvonne was standing at the front of the car. The brick broke the
window then ricocheted over the top and towards Yvonne. She
ducked and it passed her without hitting her. She then called the
police.
After Jordan finished with the Toyota, he reapproached
Yvonne and again demanded car keys. She tucked them in her
pocket and said she had no keys. Jordan then grabbed her by the
arms trying to get the keys and they “started tussling.”
When Jordan first grabbed Yvonne “it didn’t hurt” and she
was not scared. She was “just angry,” “concerned,” and “shocked
[he was] doing this to [her].” She managed to hit him a few times.
As they continued to tussle, she felt he was “trying to throw [her]
down or push [her] or something.” She felt “a burning sensation
on [her] arm” as he was “tossing [her] back and forth.” She
managed to stay upright by “kind of turn[ing] or push[ing] away

4
from him.” She did not fall but at one point her left foot “kinda
lifted” off the ground.
All of the pushing and “tossing . . . back and forth” “moved”
Yvonne and pinned her against a metal fence. From Destiny’s
perspective, Jordan was trying to “sling” Yvonne on the ground
when she was pushed against the fence. With Yvonne against the
fence, Jordan tore her pants pockets open, took the keys, and
walked off. Police detained him soon thereafter a short distance
away. They had to use force to wrest the keys from his grip.
From being pushed into the fence, Yvonne sustained
scrapes on her elbows that hurt for “a day or two.” She was not
otherwise injured.
Jordan was charged with the three counts on which he was
convicted, as well as a fourth that was dismissed for insufficiency
of the evidence.
Jordan represented himself at trial. He did not request a
jury instruction on simple assault if the jury did not agree he
committed GBI assault. In his closing argument he suggested the
assault charges were baseless, going so far as to argue he “didn’t
touch” Yvonne. But at the same time, he invited jurors to “find
me guilty” and argued that “they” had not presented evidence he
“used force . . . to likely cause GBI.” After deliberating for about
two and a half hours, the jury found him guilty on all counts.
The trial court revoked Jordan’s propria persona status at
sentencing because he had refused to speak at a posttrial hearing
on his priors. His counsel failed to object to the proposed sentence
on the grounds that section 654 applied to one or more of his
convictions. She only asked that Jordan be placed on probation

5
instead of committed to prison. The court sentenced him to state
prison for each count as detailed, ante.3
This appeal followed.
DISCUSSION
I. Substantial Evidence Supports Jordan’s Conviction
for GBI Assault
The jury convicted Jordan of GBI assault (§ 245,
subd. (a)(4)) for manhandling Yvonne after he finished
vandalizing the Toyota. Jordan contends there was insufficient
evidence that the force he used was likely to produce great bodily
injury. We disagree.
A. Standard of Review
When evaluating a sufficiency of evidence claim, “ ‘we
review the whole record in the light most favorable to the
judgment to determine whether it discloses . . . evidence that is
reasonable, credible, and of solid value . . . from which a
reasonable trier of fact could find the defendant guilty beyond a
reasonable doubt.’ ” (People v. Cravens (2012) 53 Cal.4th 500,
507.) “The test for evaluating a sufficiency of evidence claim is
deferential.” (People v. Flores (2020) 9 Cal.5th 371, 411.) “We
must presume in support of the judgment the existence of every

3 Upon the prosecutor’s request for clarification, the trial
court stated the sentences for “count 1 and 3” “are consecutive for
a total of five years.” Count 1 (GBI assault) and count 3 (felony
vandalism) carried an aggregate sentence of one year eight
months, so it appears the court was referring to count 1 (GBI
assault) and count 4 (assault with a deadly weapon). The court
did not address different treatment for count 3 (felony
vandalism). The abstract of judgment reflects all sentences are to
be served consecutively with none stayed under section 654 for a
total of five years eight months.

6
fact that the trier of fact could reasonably deduce from the
evidence.” (People v. Medina (2009) 46 Cal.4th 913, 919.) “We
must also ‘accept logical inferences that the jury might have
drawn from the circumstantial evidence.’ ” (Flores, supra, at
p. 411.) “The conviction shall stand ‘unless it appears “that upon
no hypothesis whatever is there sufficient substantial evidence to
support [the conviction].” ’ ” (Cravens, supra, at p. 508.)
B. Force Likely to Produce Great Bodily Injury
“ ‘Great bodily injury is bodily injury which is significant or
substantial, not insignificant, trivial or moderate. [Citations.]’
[Citations.] In other words, it is significant or substantial
physical injury that is more than minor or moderate.” (People v.
Sandoval (2020) 50 Cal.App.5th 357, 361.)
In evaluating whether a defendant used force likely to
produce great bodily injury, the proper focus is on the force
actually used, not the force the defendant was capable of using.
(People v. Duke (1985) 174 Cal.App.3d 296, 303 (Duke).) But
“[a] person can be guilty of an aggravated assault despite causing
no injury so long as his actions made a serious injury likely.”
(People v. Drayton (2019) 42 Cal.App.5th 612, 617.)
C. Analysis
The People’s theory of great bodily injury risk was that
Jordan used enough force to throw Yvonne to the ground but she
avoided injury only through her resistance. It is well established
that throwing a person to the ground can create the risk of great
bodily injury from colliding with the ground or another hard
object. (See, e.g., People v. Conley (1952) 110 Cal.App.2d 731, 733
[the defendant “pushed or shoved [the victim] with such force
that he struck his head against the parking meter and fell to the
sidewalk”]; In re Nirran W. (1989) 207 Cal.App.3d 1157, 1161–

7
1162 [the defendant knocked victim to the ground with a single
blow]; see also People v. Clark (2011) 201 Cal.App.4th 235, 246
[applying § 273a, “it is common knowledge that falling to the
ground as the result of an unexpected tripping creates a
substantial danger of broken bones, torn ligaments or other
injuries”].)
We conclude substantial evidence supports the jury’s
findings. Specifically, there was evidence that Yvonne managed
to stay upright only by her defensive measures. She testified that
she “fe[lt] like [she] had to stop him physically from tossing [her]
down” and “tr[ied] to keep [her]self from going down” by “kind of
turn[ing] or push[ing] away from him.” In short, she “just tried to
stay upright.”
From this testimony, the jury could reasonably have found
Jordan’s force would have been sufficient to topple Yvonne but for
her defensive efforts. Our Supreme Court has made clear that
“an aggressor should not receive the benefit of a potential victim
fortuitously taking a defensive measure” in ascertaining whether
the aggressor’s conduct was likely to cause injury. (In re B.M.
(2018) 6 Cal.5th 528, 537 [applying § 245, subd. (a)(1)].)
Duke, on which Jordan primarily relies to show
insufficiency of the evidence, is distinguishable in this respect.
Duke committed a series of assaults, only one of which is relevant
here: he used “a headlock to hold his victim while he touched her
breast. The headlock made her feel ‘choked’ but did not cut off her
breathing. She could still scream, and she did get away. The
victim did not describe an attempt to choke or strangle her. [The
victim’s] only actual injury was a laceration to her ear lobe
caused by her earring being pushed against her ear. She felt that
his hold on her was ‘firm,’ but did not say that he tightened his

8
grip.” (Duke, supra, 174 Cal.App.3d at p. 302.) The Duke court
found this evidence insufficient to show force likely to produce
great bodily injury. But there was no testimony that the
perpetrator used significant force but that the victim, as Yvonne
did here, asserted a countervailing force against Duke’s grip to
protect herself from being seriously injured. (Ibid.) Duke
subjected his victim to a relatively unharmful headlock when
there was nothing to impede him from choking her.
Here, viewing the evidence most favorably to the verdict,
Yvonne fought to stay upright while Jordan tried to knock her to
the ground. Though Yvonne managed to stay upright, Jordan still
“moved” her against her will and ultimately pushed her into a
metal fence with enough force to cut her arms. The jury could
reasonably find that, if she had not struggled against Jordan’s
force, she would have fallen, subjecting her to the likelihood of
serious injuries.
II. The Trial Court Should Have Instructed the Jury on
Simple Assault and Jordan Was Prejudiced by Its
Omission
Even though substantial evidence supported Jordan’s
conviction for assault with force likely to produce great bodily
harm, Jordan argues the trial court erred in failing to instruct on
misdemeanor simple assault (§ 240). Simple assault is a lesser
included offense of the assault for which he was convicted (People
v. Rupert (1971) 20 Cal.App.3d 961, 968 (Rupert)), comprising all
the same elements but without force likely to produce great
bodily harm. We agree the trial court should have instructed the
jury on simple assault and that there was a reasonable
probability he would have been convicted only for the lesser
offense.

9
A. Standard of Review
We independently review whether an instruction on a
lesser included offense should have been given. (People v.
Manriquez (2005) 37 Cal.4th 547, 584.)
B. The Trial Court’s Obligation to Instruct on a
Lesser Included Offense
“In a criminal case, a trial court must instruct on general
principles of law relevant to the issues raised by the evidence,
even absent a request for such instruction from the parties.[4]
[Citation.] The obligation extends to instruction on lesser
included offenses when the evidence raises a question as to
whether all the elements of the charged offense were present, but
not when there is no evidence that the offense committed was
less than that charged.” (People v. Cruz (2008) 44 Cal.4th 636,
664.) Put another way, the trial court must instruct on the lesser
included offense if there is “ ‘ “evidence from which a jury
composed of reasonable [persons] could . . . conclude[]” ’ that the
lesser offense, but not the greater, was committed.” (Ibid.) “ ‘The
rule’s purpose is . . . to assure, in the interest of justice, the most
accurate possible verdict encompassed by the charge and
supported by the evidence.’ ” (People v. Shockley (2013) 58 Cal.4th
400, 403–404.)
C. Analysis
The trial court erred in failing to instruct on simple assault.
We have been cited no case in which a defendant was convicted of
GBI assault where the risk of great bodily injury arose from

4 Because the trial court is obligated to act sua sponte, the
People’s contention that Jordan waived this argument by failing
to raise it below is meritless. (People v. Brothers (2015)
236 Cal.App.4th 24, 33, fn. 6.)

10
pushing that might have, but did not actually cause, an ordinary
fall. In order to convict Jordan of felony assault for his tussle
with Yvonne, the jury had to infer that, but for Yvonne’s limited
defensive measures, the force he applied would have been enough
to knock her down, and, further, that if she were knocked down,
she was likely to sustain a serious injury. That a reasonable juror
might not have reached that conclusion on the evidence
presented required a simple assault instruction.
When Jordan initially started grabbing Yvonne, it did not
hurt. Yvonne was not scared by his actions, only concerned and
shocked that her son would behave that way towards her. At one
point, she felt a “burning” sensation on her arm—a description
more consistent with friction from a sliding or twisting grasp
than a shove. In the end, she sustained only scrapes from being
pushed into the fence. While actual injury is not necessary to
support a conviction for GBI assault, the absence of an injury
militates in favor of finding no such force was used. (See People v.
Muir (1966) 244 Cal.App.2d 598, 604 [“the results of an assault
are often highly probative of the amount of force used”].)
This is particularly true in this case. Jordan is a man in his
30’s, who jurors could observe was nearly six feet tall and
weighed 175 pounds. In contrast, Yvonne is a woman in her 60’s
and eight inches shorter. A juror could reasonably have concluded
that if Jordan wanted to knock her over, he would have. As
Jordan argued in his closing statement, “[i]f I wanted to slam her
down, I could have. That’s not my intention.”5 Moreover, the

5 Jordan’s closing arguments are relevant to our prejudice
analysis, which we turn to next. (People v. Larsen (2012)
205 Cal.App.4th 810, 831.)

11
record contained good reasons for him to avoid knocking her
down, with its attendant risk of serious injury. Yvonne is
Jordan’s mother and the caretaker for two of his children. Again,
Jordan argued this point, asking the jury “why would I put a
person responsible for my children that I love with all my heart
in a position to where she can’t tend for them?” A juror could
reasonably conclude he refrained from exerting dangerous force
against her because of these familial considerations.
Finally, a juror could reasonably conclude that, even if
Jordan used enough force to push, and successfully pushed,
Yvonne down, she was not likely to sustain serious injuries.
Although she was 62 years old, photographs in evidence do not
suggest any frailty. Indeed, the evidence is that she worked as a
security officer at a bank and was largely successful in managing
the force Jordan exerted against her.
Rupert illustrates the clarity of the error here. In that case,
Rupert was attacking the victim’s mother. The victim tried to
intervene. Rupert hit her with his hand (and possibly a coffee pot)
at least five times, knocking her to the bedroom floor. (Rupert,
supra, 20 Cal.App.3d at pp. 966, 968.) He continued to strike her
when she was on the floor. (Id. at p. 966.) She sustained a
concussion and multiple facial lacerations, including at least one
that left a permanent scar. (Ibid.) The jury convicted Rupert of
GBI assault but was not given the option to convict for simple
assault. The Court of Appeal found this was error and reversed
the felony conviction on that basis. (Id. at p. 969.) Since a simple
assault instruction was required in Rupert, despite the victim
actually being knocked down and actually sustaining material
injuries to her head and face, it was required here, where the

12
tussle did not cause Yvonne to fall and resulted in only scraped
elbows.
People v. Roth (1964) 228 Cal.App.2d 522 (Roth) is similarly
instructive as it involved a manual assault yielding no serious
injuries. Roth was charged with, among other offenses, GBI
assault on a man he and another defendant encountered sleeping
on a beach. Roth first “seiz[ed] [the victim] by the throat.” (Id. at
p. 524.) He also “hit[] and kick[ed] [the victim] [while] [he] was
down on the sand.” (Id. at p. 525.) The jury convicted Roth of GBI
assault, but the Court of Appeal reversed. It explained: “This case
is one in which an instruction on simple assault would have been
particularly appropriate. The assault . . . was with hands, fists,
and feet, and [the victim] suffered no bodily injury other than a
cut mouth and some bruises. It is of course unnecessary for the
prosecution to show that the victim actually received injuries in
order to support a conviction [citation], but the absence of serious
injuries is a factor which the jury might consider in determining
what kind of force was used.” (Id. at pp. 530–531.)
Our finding of error does not, however, end the inquiry. “In
a noncapital case, the error in failing to instruct on a lesser
included offense is reviewed for prejudice under People v. Watson
(1956) 46 Cal.2d 818[,] which requires reversal of the conviction
for the greater offense ‘if, “after an examination of the entire
cause, including the evidence” [citation], it appears “reasonably
probable” the defendant would have obtained a more favorable
outcome had the error not occurred.’ [Citation.] Probability under
Watson ‘does not mean more likely than not, but merely a
reasonable chance, more than an abstract possibility.’ ” (People v.
Racy (2007) 148 Cal.App.4th 1327, 1335 (Racy).) “[I]n assessing
prejudice, it does not matter that the jury chose to convict the

13
defendant of the greater offense over acquittal or that the
defendant was convicted of the greater offense on sufficient
evidence.” (Ibid.) We find Jordan was prejudiced.
The Rupert court did not explicitly address prejudice but
reversed the GBI assault conviction for failure to instruct on
simple assault. (Rupert, supra, 20 Cal.App.3d at p. 969.) The
Roth court found prejudice as follows: “It seems hardly probable
that a jury, after hearing all of the evidence . . . , would ever have
acquitted defendant, but it is not improbable that a jury would
have found the offense to be a simple assault if the instructions
had permitted it.” (Roth, supra, 228 Cal.App.2d at p. 531.) After
all, “it was purely a matter of inference whether the assault was
of the severity contemplated by . . . section 245, or the simple
misdemeanor referred to in section 240 . . . .” (Ibid.)
The more recent decision in Racy further supports our
finding of prejudice. Racy involved a conviction for felony elder
abuse (§ 368, subd. (b)(1)). (Racy, supra, 148 Cal.App.4th at
pp. 1331–1332.) Felony elder abuse is differentiated from the
lesser included offense of misdemeanor abuse by the requirement
that the defendant harmed the elder “under circumstances or
conditions likely to produce great bodily harm or death.”
(Compare § 368, subd. (b)(1) with § 368, subd. (c)(1); see also
Racy, supra, at pp. 1334–1335.) Notably, the “circumstances or
conditions likely to produce great bodily harm or death” element
in section 368, subdivision (b)(1) is similar to, but less stringent
than, the “force likely to produce great bodily injury” element of
felony assault in section 245, subdivision (a)(2). (See People v.
Clark (2011) 201 Cal.App.4th 235, 252 [“There is nothing
inconsistent about the jury determining the evidence of force
likely to cause great bodily injury was insufficient on the felony

14
assault count, but at the same time finding that the totality of
the circumstances and conditions were likely to produce great
bodily harm.”].)6
The Racy court found Racy was prejudiced by the trial
court’s failure to instruct on misdemeanor elder abuse under the
facts of an assault bearing significant parallels to those presented
here. The 25-year-old Racy attacked a 74-year-old victim—whose
knee condition prevented him from running—for his wallet. He
first “ ‘zapped’ [the victim] in the leg with a stun gun.” (Racy,
supra, 148 Cal.App.4th at p. 1330.) When the victim retreated to
a bedroom, Racy followed him so closely that he could not close
the door. Racy yanked the phone cord from the wall when the
victim tried to call for help, leaving the victim to cower on the bed
in a defensive position. “For the next 10 minutes, [Racy] asked
[the victim] for money while he ‘zapped’ the stun gun . . . ‘in the
air.’ [Racy] then ‘tip[ped] [the victim] over,’ exposing his wallet.
[The victim] tried unsuccessfully to fight off [the] defendant. The
struggle moved the bed approximately one foot away from the
wall. [Racy] grabbed [the victim’s] wallet, tearing [his] jeans
pocket. At some point during the struggle, [the victim] ‘tripped.’
[Racy] then ran out of the house.” (Id. at p. 1331.)
While the Racy court found substantial evidence supported
the jury’s conclusion that Racy was guilty of felony elder abuse, it
still concluded the trial court prejudicially erred in omitting an
instruction on misdemeanor elder abuse. It explained: “[The
victim] did not suffer great bodily harm during the incident, so

6 Clark involved a child abuse statute containing the same
“circumstances and conditions” element and after which the elder
abuse statute was modeled. (See Clark, supra, 201 Cal.App.4th at
p. 243, fn. 5.)

15
the jury was left to draw inferences about whether the
circumstances or conditions under which [Racy] inflicted physical
pain or mental suffering were likely to produce great bodily harm
or death. . . . [T]he evidence supporting the guilty verdict of
felony elder abuse was not so compelling that the jury instead
could have reasonably reached a guilty verdict of misdemeanor
elder abuse.” (Racy, supra, 148 Cal.App.4th at pp. 1335–1336,
citation omitted.)
The same can be said of the force Jordan used in assaulting
Yvonne here. Based on the evidence already discussed, the jury
was left to draw inferences about the degree and nature of the
force Jordan exerted. There is at least a “ ‘mere[] . . . reasonable
chance,’ ” and certainly more than an “ ‘abstract possibility’ ”
(Racy, supra, 148 Cal.App.4th at p. 1335), that at least one juror
would have voted to acquit Jordan of felony assault if offered
simple assault as an alternative. (See People v. Hendrix (2022)
13 Cal.5th 933, 947, fn. 6 [a hung jury is a “ ‘more favorable’ ”
outcome for purposes of harmless error review under Watson].)
III. Section 654 Applies to Jordan’s Convictions for
Assault with a Deadly Weapon and Vandalism
Jordan contends7 he was erroneously punished for each of
his three convictions because section 654 permits punishment for
just one. We conclude section 654 applies to two (assault with a
deadly weapon and vandalism), but not all three, of his
convictions.

7 That Jordan failed to raise this issue, too, below is no bar to
considering it on appeal. (People v. Rodriguez (2015)
235 Cal.App.4th 1000, 1004, fn. 2.)

16
A. Standard of Review
“Whether section 654 applies in a given case is a question
of fact for the trial court, which is vested with broad latitude in
making its determination. [Citations.] Its findings will not be
reversed on appeal if there is any substantial evidence to support
them. [Citations.] We review the trial court’s determination in
the light most favorable to the respondent and presume the
existence of every fact the trial court could reasonably deduce
from the evidence.” (People v. Jones (2002) 103 Cal.App.4th 1139,
1143.)
B. Section 654
By its terms, section 654 permits just one punishment for
“[a]n act or omission that is punishable in different ways by
different provisions of law.” (§ 654, subd. (a).) But “[b]ecause
‘[f]ew if any crimes . . . are the result of a single physical act,’
section 654 applies not just to a single ‘ “ ‘act’ in the ordinary
sense . . . but also where a course of conduct violate[s] more than
one statute . . . .” ’ [Citation.] ‘Whether a course of criminal
conduct is divisible and therefore gives rise to more than one act
within the meaning of section 654 depends on the intent and
objective of the actor. If all of the offenses were incident to one
objective, the defendant may be punished for any one of such
offenses but not for more than one.’ ” (People v. Mendoza (2022)
74 Cal.App.5th 843, 853–854.) “If, however, the defendant had
multiple or simultaneous objectives, independent of and not
merely incidental to each other, the defendant may be punished
for each violation committed in pursuit of each objective even
though the violations share common acts or were parts of an
otherwise indivisible course of conduct.” (People v. Cleveland
(2001) 87 Cal.App.4th 263, 267–268 (Cleveland).)

17
The proper procedure is to sentence the defendant for each
count but stay execution of the sentence on the lesser conviction
to which section 654 applies. (People v. Jones (2012) 54 Cal.4th
350, 353; see also People v. Beamon (1973) 8 Cal.3d 625, 639–640
[the defendant’s sentence on the lesser punishment to be stayed].)
C. Analysis
We conclude two of the counts here arise from a single
course of conduct, punishable by more than one statute. Jordan,
in a fit of rage, committed felony vandalism by throwing bricks at
the Toyota’s windows. When one of those bricks skipped off the
back window and flew past Yvonne’s head, he also committed
assault with a deadly weapon. However, there is no indication
that the brick which skipped off the window was intended to do
anything but damage the car. Despite having access to several
bricks, he never threw a brick directly at Yvonne. No facts
support punishing these offenses separately. On remand, the
trial court shall select just one permissible punishment for them.
But we reject Jordan’s contention that the subsequent
assault on Yvonne was part of the same conduct as the vandalism
of the vehicle, described by Jordan as all being acts in
furtherance of a solitary criminal plan to get the key from
Yvonne. Substantial evidence supports the implied finding that
Jordan’s vandalism and assault with a deadly weapon conduct
were perpetrated out of anger and to punish Yvonne, whereas his
GBI assault was motivated by an attempt to get the key. (See
Cleveland, supra, 87 Cal.App.4th at pp. 271–272 [evidence that
recent interactions with the victim had angered the defendant
supported finding of separate intents for attempted murder and
robbery].)

18
The argument that Jordan’s conduct in throwing bricks at
the car was incident to obtaining the key is speculative. Jordan
did not threaten to break the Toyota’s windows unless Yvonne
gave up the key, nor did he offer to stop breaking the windows if
she did. After being refused the key yet again, he simply started
breaking windows without saying another word. When Yvonne
implored him to stop, he ignored her. Only after he broke all of
the windows was his vandalistic rage quelled and he returned to
the topic of the keys.
The absence of any logical connection between the
vandalism and an effort to obtain the keys distinguishes this case
from People v. Chacon (1995) 37 Cal.App.4th 52. There, the
defendants, inmates at a California Youth Authority facility,
committed a series of offenses as part of a plot to escape. These
included assaults on a female staffer they had taken hostage
from ransom: a pickup truck to aid their escape. The Chacon
court found the assaults were a means of obtaining the truck.
(Id. at p. 66.) The defendants first “threatened to ‘kill the bitch’ if
the truck was not delivered.” (Id. at p. 58.) When staff members
tried to reason with them, one defendant applied pressure to the
victim’s neck until she passed out and the other stabbed her in
the stomach. They then reiterated their threat “to ‘kill the bitch’
if the truck was not delivered” while one held a shank to her eye
and started counting down from 10. (Ibid.) Staff members
promptly furnished the truck.
As the evidence does not compel the conclusion that
Jordan’s acts relative to the Toyota (vandalism and assault with
a deadly weapon) were part of an indivisible course of conduct
with the subsequent tussle for the key, Jordan’s conviction for
GBI assault is separately punishable from the others.

19
DISPOSITION
Jordan’s conviction for assault with force likely to produce
great bodily harm (§ 245, subd. (a)(4); count 1) is reversed for
failure to instruct on the lesser included offense of simple assault
(§ 240). If, after the filing of the remittitur in the trial court, the
People do not retry Jordan on count 1 within the time limit set
forth in section 1382, subdivision (a)(2)—60 days unless waived
by Jordan—the trial court shall treat the remittitur as a
modification of the judgment as to count 1 to reflect a conviction
for misdemeanor simple assault (§ 240), and resentence Jordan
accordingly. (People v. Woods (1992) 8 Cal.App.4th 1570, 1596.)
In addition, the trial court shall resentence Jordan for his
convictions for assault with a deadly weapon (§ 245, subd. (a)(1);
count 4) and felony vandalism (§ 594, subd. (b)(1); count 3),
staying execution of the lesser conviction (§ 654).

RICHARDSON, J.
I CONCUR:

GOORVITCH, J.

 Judge of the Los Angeles County Superior Court, assigned
by the Chief Justice pursuant to article VI, section 6 of the
California Constitution.

20
People v. Jordan
B340243

Chavez, Acting P. J., Concurring and dissenting

I respectfully dissent from the majority’s harmless error
analysis as to count 1 and its application of Penal Code section
654.1 I concur in all other respects.
I. Failure to instruct regarding the lesser included
offense, if error, was harmless
“In a noncapital case, the error in failing to instruct on a
lesser included offense is reviewed for prejudice under People v.
Watson (1956) 46 Cal.2d 818[,] which requires reversal of the
conviction for the greater offense ‘if, “after an examination of the
entire cause, including the evidence” [citation], it appears
“reasonably probable” the defendant would have obtained a more
favorable outcome had the error not occurred.’ [Citation.]
Probability under Watson ‘does not mean more likely than not,
but merely a reasonable chance, more than an abstract
possibility.’” (People v. Racy (2007) 148 Cal.App.4th 1327, 1335.)
The question posed here is whether it is reasonably
probable the jury could have found defendant committed only a
simple assault and not an assault with force likely to produce
great bodily injury (GBI). The answer is no; it is not reasonably
probable the jury would have reached a more favorable outcome.
First, the majority minimizes the size disparity between
defendant and Yvonne: defendant is a six-foot tall, 32-year-old
male, while 62-year-old Yvonne stood five feet three inches tall.

1 All further unattributed statutory references are to the
Penal Code.

1
Second, the majority fails to consider the escalating
tensions of the entire afternoon. Before he broke all the windows
of the Toyota, threw a brick that narrowly missed Yvonne’s head,
and physically assaulted her, defendant was initially angry
Yvonne would not let him in the house. He stood outside yelling,
“come open the door before I bang the door in” and “open the
door. I’m gonna break the window. Come open the door before I
mess up the house.”
Third, even after Destiny separated the pair, defendant
continued to “come at her . . . trying to get the keys.”
“[Defendant] stuck his hands in [Yvonne’s] pocket[s], ripped [the]
pockets,[2] took the keys, and proceeded to walk away.”
Defendant was angry and frustrated his mother would not
engage with him and/or give him the keys to a car. As Yvonne
continued to refuse his requests, defendant became angrier,
working to break each and every window of the Toyota as Yvonne
begged him to stop. To break the final window, he lobbed a five-
pound, foot-long landscaping brick in his mother’s direction,
which, the evidence suggests, would have hit her if she had not
ducked—the brick only missed her by four to six inches.
Defendant grew angrier still when Yvonne walked over to
the alley to get help and avoid further contact with him. He
grabbed her arms with two hands and tried to “sling her [to] the
ground.” But for her evasive movements, she would have been
thrown down to the concrete. There is little doubt that being

2 People’s exhibits 8A and 8B were published to the jury,
which showed defendant pulled Yvonne’s pants with great force.
While her belt was intact around her waist, her pants were
ripped on both sides from the waist down to her knees exposing
her tucked in shirt and her legs.

2
thrown down on concrete is likely to cause great bodily injury.
The fact that she was able to stay on her feet and was, instead,
only pushed into the metal gate and only sustained minor scrapes
is of no moment. (See People v. Drayton (2019) 42 Cal.App.5th
612, 617 [“[a] person can be guilty of an aggravated assault
despite causing no injury so long as his actions made a serious
injury likely”].)
The majority points to defendant’s professed “intention” as
evidence that “if [he] wanted to knock her over, he would have.”
This, the force he was capable of using, is not the standard. (See
People v. Duke (1985) 174 Cal.App.3d 296, 303 [the proper focus
is on the force actually used, not the force the defendant could
have used].) The force defendant “actually used” was enough to
slam Yvonne into the metal fence causing scrapes and broken
skin. This is enough force to have caused her to hit the concrete
hard enough to cause broken bones, head trauma or other serious
injury. That Yvonne was quick enough to twist and turn in a way
to instead be thrown into the fence does not turn this GBI assault
into a simple assault. (See People v. Wingo (1975) 14 Cal.3d 169,
176 [“since the statute focuses on force likely to produce harm, it
is immaterial that the force actually resulted in no harm
whatever”].)
Assuming, only for the sake of argument, there was
evidence “‘substantial enough to merit consideration’ by the jury,”
it is not reasonably probable the jury would have convicted
defendant of simple assault. (People v. Breverman (1998) 19
Cal.4th 142, 162, disapproved of on other grounds in People v.
Schuller (2023) 15 Cal.5th 237; see People v. Avila (2009) 46
Cal.4th 680, 705.) Therefore, any error in failing to instruct on
simple assault was harmless.

3
II. Application of section 654 to counts 3 and 4
The majority errs in applying section 654 because
defendant had multiple, simultaneous objectives. The law
requires application of section 654 “[i]f all of the offenses were
incident to one objective” (People v. Mendoza (2022) 74
Cal.App.5th 843, 853) but not if “the defendant had multiple or
simultaneous objectives, independent of and not merely
incidental to each other” (People v. Cleveland (2001) 87
Cal.App.4th 263, 267).
Defendant had multiple and simultaneous objectives when
he threw the final brick. As discussed, as the afternoon wore on,
defendant became angrier and more agitated. He was angry and
threatening to “bang the door in,” “break the window,” and “mess
up the house” because he was not allowed entry into the home;
when Yvonne came outside to leave for work, defendant took
bricks and “smashed” each of the windows of the Toyota because
she would not give him the keys to a car; and, before physically
assaulting her, defendant lobbed a brick in the direction of the
rear window and Yvonne. Based on the facts adduced at trial,
defendant had at least two objectives when he threw the brick: to
get the keys to a car and break the last window of the Toyota—
the car he believed to be Yvonne’s.3 Thus, “defendant may be
punished for each violation committed in pursuit of each objective
even though the violations share common acts or were parts of an

3 The evidence supports finding defendant also harbored a
desire to hurt Yvonne because he was angry with her. In his
interview with police, defendant said he was “fed up” and angry
Yvonne “d[id]n’t want [him] there” and, according to him, was
“keep[ing] all [his] things.” He believed she “stole [his] car” and
“owe[d] [him] money.”

4
otherwise indivisible course of conduct.” (People v. Cleveland,
supra, 87 Cal.App.4th at pp. 267–268.)

CHAVEZ, Acting P. J.

5

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.