In re D.H. CA4/1

CourtListener 10668559Calctapp9 sept. 2025

Texte intégral

Filed 9/9/25 In re D.H. CA4/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

COURT OF APPEAL, FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION ONE

STATE OF CALIFORNIA

In re D.H., a Person Coming Under
the Juvenile Court Law.
D084995
THE PEOPLE,

Plaintiff and Respondent, (Super. Ct. No. J241912)

v.

D.H.,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of San Diego County,
Richard R. Monroy, Judge. Affirmed.
Ava R. Stralla, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for
Defendant and Appellant.
No appearance for Plaintiff and Respondent.
D.H. was charged in a juvenile court wardship petition with
committing a murder at the age of 16. He appeals from the juvenile court’s
order transferring him to the jurisdiction of adult criminal court under
Welfare and Institutions Code section 707.1 His appointed counsel filed a
brief raising no arguable issues and requesting that we exercise our
discretion to review the record for potential issues under People v. Wende
(1979) 25 Cal.3d 436 (Wende) and Anders v. California (1967) 386 U.S. 738
(Anders).
We have independently reviewed the record and find no arguable issue
that would result in a modification or reversal of the transfer order.
Accordingly, we affirm the order.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A. Family Background
D.H. was the youngest of seven children born into a dysfunctional
family in 2005. Not long after his birth, his father beat his mother so
severely that she had to be hospitalized. D.H.’s father left the family
permanently and D.H. and his siblings were placed in various foster homes.
D.H. had no further relationship with his father. D.H. and one of his
brothers were removed from their first foster home because of abuse or
neglect.
D.H.’s mother regained custody of the children after they had been in
foster care for about a year. She was an alcoholic and had mental health
issues. She constantly had different boyfriends and often left the seven
children alone without adult supervision for days. They sometimes had no
food. Over the years, there were numerous referrals to child protective
services for general neglect, emotional abuse, physical abuse, and sexual
abuse.

1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and Institutions
Code.
2
D.H.’s mother started dating a man named Carlos. He was physically
abusive to her in front of the children. D.H. and his brother A.H. were afraid
of Carlos and reported that he touched them inappropriately in the shower.
Carlos also tattooed two of D.H.’s older siblings with gang symbols. When
Carlos was eventually deported in 2009, D.H.’s mother went to Mexico with
him, leaving the children with their grandparents. D.H. was about four years
old. For about three years, the grandparents provided the only stable
household the children ever knew.
In 2012, D.H.’s mother returned from Mexico and took custody of her
children again. For a while, they all lived in a one-room garage in Oceanside.
D.H.’s mother continued to drink alcohol, leave the children without
supervision for days at a time, and have different men in and out of the
house. She became aggressive when intoxicated and hit the children. She hit
D.H. with her hands, a sandal, a belt, or a hanger. D.H. did not have a close
relationship with her. He also reported being physically abused and bullied
by older siblings.
B. Gang Involvement
At a young age, D.H. began spending unsupervised time in the streets
and staying with friends to escape his home situation. He had two older
brothers who were associated with gangs and were already in the juvenile
system. At age 9 or 10, D.H. began associating with gang members. He
joined the Vista Homeboys gang at age 12 and was “jumped in” on his 13th
birthday.
D.H. became entrenched in the gang lifestyle and committed multiple
gang-related crimes. He sold drugs and was involved in many acts of
violence, including robberies, muggings, shootings, and stabbings. He started
using alcohol and marijuana at age 9 and other drugs at age 13. He was

3
often in possession of a knife or gun. The gang became his “whole life” and
“identity.”
C. Juvenile Record
D.H. had behavioral issues at school, including threats, defiance,
physical aggression, fighting, and harassment. At age 12, D.H. started
attending school and receiving services at the Juvenile Court and Community
Schools (JCCS). In August 2019, at the age of 13, D.H. was declared a ward
of the court and placed in a group home for his involvement in two incidents:
(1) threatening to shoot JCCS staff; and (2) assaulting someone with a knife
in a gang-related confrontation. He was unusually entrenched in the gang
lifestyle for such a young child.
D.H. absconded from the group home after a physical altercation with
another youth and was placed at another group home in Michigan. After
another youth died there, D.H. was transferred back to the group home in
California in June 2020. He absconded again after a violent altercation with
another youth in July 2020. He was arrested the next month after being
stopped in a car with Vista Homeboys gang members in possession of
marijuana. In August 2020, at the age of 14, D.H. was committed to Urban
Camp for a maximum of 250 days. He was released on February 1, 2021 to
live with his mother in Tijuana.
On February 25, 2021, when D.H. was 15 years old, he and four other
gang members assaulted and robbed two people and attempted to take their
vehicle at a Vista skatepark. D.H. was armed with a baseball bat and used it
to smash the front window of the vehicle and strike one of the victims about
eight times. Three days later, D.H. was arrested again after being stopped in
a car with other gang members in possession of drug paraphernalia and
methamphetamine.

4
In July 2021, D.H. was committed to the Healing Opportunities for
Personal Empowerment (HOPE) program in a locked juvenile facility, where
he received a wide variety of services, treatment, and therapy. Over time,
D.H. became receptive to therapy and made progress during this HOPE
commitment. He was released into the community to reside with his mother
in Tijuana in March 2022.
Later the same month, D.H. violated probation by failing to reside with
his mother and associating with members of the Vista Homeboys. He was
committed to HOPE for another 60 days then released to his mother again on
June 3, 2022.
On June 8, 2022, when D.H. was 16 years old, he and two other Vista
Homeboys robbed a couple at gunpoint and took the man’s skateboard. D.H.
issued a gang challenge and struck the man in the face. In September 2022,
D.H. was committed to the HOPE program for a minimum of 365 days.
D. Charged Murder
Just after midnight on June 9, 2022 (before D.H. was arrested for the
skateboard robbery committed the previous day), Eleazar Herrera and two
other men were drinking and talking at the bottom of some stairs in
John Landes Park in Oceanside. The park was disputed territory between
the Vista Homeboys and two other gangs. The men heard someone at the top
of the stairs say, “Where you from?” and “Do you guys bang?” and “Vista
Homeboys Gang.” A person standing at the top of the stairs pulled out a gun
and fired a shot at them, hitting Herrera in the chest and killing him.
That afternoon, police saw D.H. leave the home of another Vista
Homeboys member who lived very close to the park. After a short vehicle
chase, D.H. tried to run from the police. Witnesses saw him holding a
firearm as he fled. Officers pursued him on foot and apprehended him. They

5
later found a loaded 9-millimeter semiautomatic firearm D.H. had abandoned
in a bush during flight. Ballistics testing determined that the gun had fired a
9-millimeter casing that was recovered by police near the top of the stairs
where the shooting occurred.
Two informants provided information to the police identifying D.H. as
the shooter. They both reported that D.H. told them he had shot someone in
the park. D.H. told them he saw three guys at the bottom of the stairs. He
shot once and the gun jammed so he was unable to shoot again.
In a 2022 interview with a psychologist, D.H. said he did not regret
committing the murder. He also told a probation officer he was upset and in
a “bad place” on the night of the murder because a friend or fellow gang
member had been killed in a car accident, and he was out looking to shoot
someone. He said it was horrible what had happened.
In February 2023, while D.H. was still committed to the HOPE
program for the skateboard robbery, the People filed another wardship
petition charging him with the Herrera murder and alleging he was not a fit
and proper subject to be dealt with under the juvenile court law.
E. In-Custody Behavior
D.H. had dozens of behavioral incidents while in custody in juvenile
facilities between 2019 and 2024. These included fights, assaults against
other youth and staff, disrespectful remarks, gang-related altercations,
threats against staff, and inciting other youth to fight or assault staff.
D.H.’s behavior improved significantly during his second 2022-2023
HOPE commitment. This was the only time he received intensive therapy for
such an extended period of time. From November 2022 through August 2023,
he had no documented behavioral incidents. But after D.H. completed the
365-day HOPE commitment and was transferred back to East Mesa Juvenile

6
Detention Facility (East Mesa) in September 2023, he no longer received the
same level of services and his behavior deteriorated again.
In March 2024, when D.H. was 18 years old, there was a story posted
on his Instagram account that was directed at one of the informants against
him in the murder. It said “dry snitching kinda told” and “snitch [n-word]
ima pop you too.” D.H. was in custody without access to Instagram at the
time, but he was in contact with his brother who had access to his Instagram
account. In an interview with a psychologist, D.H. did not deny making the
post and said he wanted to take responsibility for it and did not want it to be
anyone else’s problem.
D.H. was charged in adult court with felony intimidation of a witness
(Pen. Code, § 136.1) for making the Instagram threat. He was transferred
from East Mesa to county jail.
On September 13, 2024, three days before the beginning of the section
707 transfer hearing, D.H. assaulted another jail inmate who was designated
for protective custody.
F. Section 707 Transfer Hearing
The probation department prepared a 53-page report and
recommendation in advance of the section 707 transfer hearing. The
probation officer concluded D.H. was not appropriate for rehabilitation
through juvenile court and recommended he be transferred to adult criminal
court.
The juvenile court held an eight-day section 707 transfer hearing in
September and October 2024. Multiple witnesses testified at the hearing
regarding D.H.’s family background, juvenile record, gang involvement, prior
treatment and services, capacity for growth, amenability to rehabilitation,
and the charged murder.

7
The defense called 15 witnesses, including probation officers, clinicians,
and others who worked with D.H. in the juvenile system, a mentor who had
been meeting regularly with D.H. since he was 12 years old, a clinical
psychologist who evaluated and extensively interviewed him, and three of his
sisters.
Many of the clinicians who worked with D.H. in the juvenile system
and the psychologist who evaluated him reported that he was intelligent,
receptive to therapy, cooperative, and showed significant progress, especially
during his second HOPE commitment in 2022-2023. During this second
HOPE commitment, D.H. completed high school, began taking college
courses, developed constructive goals, became more open and engaged,
participated in individual and group therapy, encouraged other youth to
participate, developed greater insight, spoke about leaving the gang, served
as unit representative for meetings with probation, was selected as the first
youth to participate in a new work program, and received multiple
certificates for citizenship and achievement. He was one of the most
successful youths in the HOPE program. Multiple defense witnesses testified
that D.H. was amenable to rehabilitation in the juvenile system.
The probation officer who authored the transfer report testified for the
People. She explained the reasons for her opinion that D.H. should be
transferred to adult criminal court, including his criminal sophistication, the
lack of time to rehabilitate him within the juvenile court’s jurisdiction, his
history of crimes and violence, and his gang involvement.
G. Juvenile Court Ruling
After the hearing, the juvenile court granted the People’s transfer
request in a 12-page written order. The court found by clear and convincing
evidence that D.H. was not amenable to rehabilitation while under the

8
juvenile court jurisdiction. In reaching this conclusion, the court considered
and analyzed each of the five criteria listed in section 707, subdivision
(a)(3)(A)-(E).
With regard to the degree of criminal sophistication exhibited by D.H.,
the court acknowledged he had significant challenges due to his traumatic
childhood. The court nevertheless found that D.H. had engaged in an
“ongoing series of serious and increasingly sophisticated criminal conduct.”
The court noted that D.H.’s behavior in custody had resulted in new adult
charges for “solicitation for murder on a witness to his pending murder case,”
which “demonstrates the growing level of [D.H.]’s criminal sophistication.”
The court also noted that D.H. had “attacked a protected custody witness,
without provocation, just one week prior to the commencement” of the
transfer hearing.
With regard to D.H.’s previous delinquent history, the court concluded
that his “significant and extensive delinquent history carried on up to and
beyond the alleged murder occurring in June of 2022.” The court considered
this delinquent history “in light of [D.H.]’s traumatic family and community
environment.” The court concluded that the mitigating facts were
“insufficient given the severity of [D.H.’]s crimes particularly the charged
707(b) offense of murder.”
With regard to previous attempts to rehabilitate D.H., the court found
that “[D.H.] was offered every rehabilitative tool the Juvenile Justice system
was allowed to provide [D.H.] given the nature of his past offenses,” including
an Urban Camp commitment, out-of-home placement, and two separate
HOPE commitments. After two lengthy custodial commitments and an
extensive out-of-home placement, “[D.H.] then committed a murder and a
separate serious robbery. [D.H.] was taken back into custody, but after a

9
change in his custodial setting, [D.H.] reverted to misconduct ultimately
committing a new adult offense.” Thus, the court found that “previous
attempts by the Juvenile Justice system to rehabilitate [D.H.] were
unsuccessful.”
With regard to the circumstances and gravity of the offense alleged in
the petition, the court found that “[D.H.] committed the murder after he
armed himself with a firearm and went looking for rival gang members to
kill. [D.H.] issued a gang challenge and [D.H.] fired a weapon into three
unarmed males. The facts support that [D.H.] would have fired additional
rounds if the weapon hadn’t malfunctioned.” The court concluded that this
factor supported a finding of unfitness.
Finally, the court concluded that D.H. could not be rehabilitated within
the juvenile system in the six years remaining before he turned 25 and its
jurisdiction expired. The court found that D.H. had no bond with his
biological family, his chosen family members were in custody, and some were
still gang members. The court also found that although D.H. was able to
make progress in therapeutic settings, he “picks and chooses when he wants
to implement those skills.” The court described D.H.’s recent assault on
another jail inmate as “an unprovoked attack on a protected status witness”
committed as an adult “for the benefit of a perceived criminal family.”
DISCUSSION
Appointed appellate counsel filed a brief summarizing the facts and
proceedings below, arguing no specific contentions as grounds for relief, and
asking this court to review the entire record for error as mandated by Wende,
supra, 25 Cal.3d. 436. To assist the court in its review, and in compliance
with Anders, supra, 386 U.S. 738, counsel identified the following possible
but not arguable issues: Whether the court properly found by clear and

10
convincing evidence that the prosecution had met its burden and that D.H. is
not amenable to rehabilitation while under the jurisdiction of the juvenile
court, and whether the juvenile court properly granted the motion to transfer
D.H. to the jurisdiction of the adult criminal court. (§ 707, subd. (a)(3); Cal.
Rules of Court, rule 5.770(b).) We invited D.H. to file a supplemental brief
raising any additional contentions, but he did not do so.
We have considered the potential issues identified by D.H.’s appellate
counsel and conducted an independent review of the record for other arguable
issues under Wende and Anders. Based on our review, we conclude there is
no arguable issue that would result in a modification or reversal of the
transfer order. D.H. is competently represented in this appeal. Accordingly,
we affirm the order. (Wende, supra, 25 Cal.3d at pp. 441–442.)
DISPOSITION
The transfer order is affirmed.

BUCHANAN, J.

WE CONCUR:

O’ROURKE, Acting P. J.

CASTILLO, J.

11

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.