CourtListener 10660985•People v. Kidd CA1/2
Texte intégral
Filed 8/26/25 P. v. Kidd CA1/2
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or
ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION TWO
THE PEOPLE,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
A171307
v.
WILLIAM EMIL KIDD, IV (Lake County
Super. Ct. No. CR966266A)
Defendant and Appellant.
Defendant William Emil Kidd appeals from a judgment after a jury
convicted him of second degree burglary (count 1; Pen. Code, § 4591) and
receipt of stolen property (count 2; § 496, subdivision (a)). His appointed
counsel filed a brief pursuant to People v. Wende (1979) 25 Cal.3d 436. Kidd
was informed of his right to file a supplemental brief, but he did not do so.
Our independent review of the record revealed a potentially arguable issue
about Kidd’s sentencing, and we ordered the parties to submit supplemental
briefs, which they did. Both parties conclude there was no sentencing error,
and we agree. We find no errors or other issues requiring further briefing.
Accordingly, we affirm.
1 All statutory references are to the Penal Code.
1
BACKGROUND
Kidd was charged in a first amended information with first degree
burglary (§ 459) and receipt of stolen property (§ 496, subd. (a)), felonies. As
to the burglary, it was alleged that on or about December 21, 2022, Kidd
entered an inhabited dwelling house and trailer coach and inhabited portion
of a building occupied by Robert and Ann Harper. As to the receipt of stolen
property, it was alleged that on or about the same day he bought or received
property exceeding $950 in value from Robert Harper, Ann Harper, Rodney
Harper, and Walter White “specifically, tools, saddle and other property,
which had been stolen and obtained by extortion, knowing the property to be
stolen and obtained.” The information alleged various aggravating factors
and that Kidd was not eligible for probation.
Kidd was tried before a jury over the course of two days. On the first
day, each counsel gave an opening statement, the prosecution put on its case,
the defense put on its case and rested, and the prosecutor indicated there
would be no rebuttal evidence.
Prosecution Case
Walter White is an in-law of Robert and Ann Harper and their son
Rodney, and a sergeant in the Lake County Sheriff’s Office. White is familiar
with the Harpers’ property, a 40-acre parcel on Cantwell Ranch Road known
as the Ranch, which includes a main residence, and various outbuildings
including a shop and barn. For the most part there is a fence around the
property, and only one method of ingress, with a gate; the main residence is
about two miles down a private road and is enclosed by a fence and gates.
Ann and Robert Harper are elderly and have various ailments; they lived at
the Ranch and also in a home down the road. The house is a “hoarder’s
paradise” with lots of items collected over the years from other family
2
members and brought to the property. Family members also kept horses at
the property.
In November 2022 White became concerned about other people being
on the property; some of the hoods of the vehicles were found open (there
were more than 70 vehicles on the property), a sliding glass door on one of the
sheds was open and things appeared to be moved around. But no one noticed
anything missing at that time. In response, the family started locking the
gate on the property. On December 15, White discovered the locked gate to
the property was unhinged and a vehicle had run over the gate. An
outbuilding had been broken into and items were missing. On December 20,
2022, White found the front door of the house was wide open with signs of
forced entry. White could tell someone had been in the house; “contents were
moved around, stuff dumped out of drawers, . . . [d]rawers were left open on
dressers, desks.” He did an inventory of his property and determined chains,
binders, a winch bar, and straps were missing from an equipment trailer. He
contacted law enforcement to let them know there had been a break-in.
Before leaving he tried to secure the house as best he could.
The next night, December 21, a neighbor told the Harpers about a
white Chevy Express van leaving the Ranch property with “horse saddles and
stuff being seen through the back window.” White went to the property to
check on his horse trailer and equipment trailer and found two saddles and
tack were missing.
That same evening Lake County Sheriff’s deputies investigated the
burglaries at the Ranch. Their investigation led them to a property about
two miles away on Spruce Grove Road, where they found a flatbed truck, a
white Chevy van, and a utility trailer with suspected stolen property inside.
3
Defendant Kidd was located in the house at Spruce Grove Road. The
owner of the house gave law enforcement permission to enter. Kidd was in
the shower stall hiding behind a shower curtain, fully clothed and wearing
shoes. In his pockets were a chain and some rings identified by Ann Harper
as hers, and a key to the locked utility trailer that held a black powder rifle
that Rodney had recognized was his. At trial it was stipulated that the white
Chevy van located on the Spruce Grove Road property on December 21
belonged to Kidd. Kidd told one of the sheriff’s deputies that he bought many
of the items seized earlier in the day in Clearlake.
Various Harper family members arrived at the scene on Spruce Grove
Road and identified suspected stolen items from inside the white Chevy van,
and the utility trailer.
Defense Case
Kidd called his mother, an acquaintance, and a friend and former
landlord who testified that various items were his. Kidd’s mother identified
the flat bed truck as belonging to Kidd.
On the next day of trial, the court permitted defense counsel to re-open
its case for Kidd’s mother to testify about per capita payments she and Kidd
received from the Cherokee nation. The prosecution did not object.
The jury was then instructed on the law. Each side gave closing
arguments and the jury, with additional instruction, was excused to
deliberate.
The jury returned a verdict the same day. Kidd was found guilty of
second degree burglary (count 1) and receiving stolen property valued at over
$950 (count 2). Kidd then waived his right to a jury trial on the
circumstances in aggravation (Cal. Rules of Court, rule 4.421) that were
alleged in the first amended information and agreed that the court could
4
decide the allegations. The jury was excused. The prosecutor withdrew the
vulnerable victim allegation (rule 4.421(a)(3)). The court found the following
alleged aggravating circumstances were true beyond a reasonable doubt:
Kidd planned the burglary (rule 4.421(a)(8)); the crime involved a large
quantity of contraband (rule 4.421(a)(10)); Kidd’s prior convictions were
numerous or of increasing seriousness (rule 4.421(b)(2)); Kidd had served a
prior term in prison or county jail (rule 4.421(b)(3)); and his prior
performance on probation or parole was unsatisfactory (rule 4.421(b)(5)). The
court found not true the allegation that the crime involved taking or damage
of great monetary value (rule 4.421(a)(9)).
On August 27, 2024, the court sentenced Kidd to the aggravated term
of three years on count 1, and a concurrent three years on count 2, stayed
pursuant to section 654, to be served in Lake County Jail.2
2 At sentencing, in stating the circumstances in aggravation that
warranted imposition of the upper term, the trial court included among other
factors that the crime “involved a taking of great monetary value.” There
was no objection to this statement or any part of the sentence. It appears
from the record however that the court found this particular factor not proven
at the court trial after the jury reached its verdict. The court said at the
sentencing hearing that the “minutes aren’t clear. I don’t remember
specifically what findings I made. [¶] I remember there was a number of
them. Even if some of these findings I just made were not proven at the court
trial after the jury trial, the ones that were found are sufficient to impose the
aggravating term in this case, and I do find that the aggravating term is
appropriate based solely on the findings that I made at the court trial on the
aggravating factors. [¶] So I do find the aggravating factors outweigh the
mitigating factors, which were none, both in number and in weight and will
impose the upper term in this matter.”
5
DISCUSSION
I.
Kidd’s counsel filed a Wende brief identifying no error and asked us to
review the record for any arguable issues on appeal. We asked for
supplemental briefing on whether the trial court erred in sentencing
defendant to three years for count 1 (burglary) and three years for count 2
(receiving stolen property) with execution of the sentence for count 2 stayed
pursuant to section 654, rather than dismissing count 2. We asked the
question because, immediately after the jury returned its verdicts, defense
counsel inquired: “Your Honor, in light of the verdicts, there is some
overlapping case law but should—should not Count Two be dismissed now, or
it would just have to run concurrent as a matter of law?” The court
responded, “[L]et’s deal with that at sentencing, because I don’t know off the
top of my head.” The record does not reflect further discussion of the issue at
sentencing. The court is not aware of any pre-sentence briefing on the issue,
or any previous consideration of the issue in the record.
During sentencing, without expressly addressing the issue, the court
sentenced defendant on count 1 to three years in the “county jail prison,” and
on count 2 to three years in county jail prison. It found that section 654
applied, and “stay[ed] execution of the sentence on Count 2 pending
completion of the service of the sentence on Count 1, with the stay to become
permanent upon completion of that sentence.”
In response to our request for supplemental briefing, Kidd contends the
trial court did not err by imposing and staying the sentence on count 2,
rather than dismissing it, explaining the appropriate remedy where a
defendant is convicted of both burglary (§ 459) and receiving stolen property
(§ 496) is to stay execution on the receiving count, which satisfied both
6
section 954, which allows multiple convictions, and section 654, which bars
multiple punishments—exactly what the trial court did here. For this he
relies, appropriately, on People v. Allen (1999) 21 Cal.4th 846, 867) which
resolved a conflict of decisions and held that a “defendant may be convicted
both of burglary and of violating section 496 with respect to property he stole
in the burglary.” (Id. at p. 866.) In his respondent’s brief, the Attorney
General agrees that there was no error in the sentence, for the same reasons.
We agree that there was no sentencing error.
II.
Aside from this issue, our review of the record pursuant to Wende has
disclosed no reasonably arguable issues. Kidd was at all times represented
by competent counsel. The jury’s verdict is supported by substantial
evidence. No ruling by the trial court in admitting or denying evidence
amounted to an abuse of discretion. No improper instructions were given to
the jury. The sentence imposed is lawful. The fines, fees and assessment
appear to have been authorized by law.
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.
7
_________________________
Miller, J.
WE CONCUR:
_________________________
Richman, Acting P.J.
_________________________
Desautels, J.
A171307, People v. Kidd
8
Vous vous demandez comment ce texte s’applique à votre situation ?
Consultation gratuite, sans engagement
Décrivez votre situation. Notre équipe vous recontactera par e-mail pour votre consultation.
Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude
Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.