CourtListener 10644525•People v. Hann CA3
Texte intégral
Filed 7/30/25 P. v. Hann CA3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
THIRD APPELLATE DISTRICT
(Sacramento)
----
THE PEOPLE, C100076
Plaintiff and Respondent, (Super. Ct. No. 22FE018981)
v.
EDWARD EVAN HANN,
Defendant and Appellant.
A jury found defendant Edward Evan Hann guilty of three counts of sexually
molesting victim. Defendant contends the trial court prejudicially erred by admitting
victim’s reports of the abuse to a friend and to her brother. Specifically, defendant
contends those reports exceeded the scope of fresh complaint evidence, were unduly
prejudicial, and denied defendant his constitutional right to a fair trial. We disagree and
affirm. But we do order the trial court to correct a clerical error in the abstract of
judgment.
1
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
In 2023, defendant was charged with three counts of lewd and lascivious acts upon
a child by means of force, violence, duress, menace, or fear of immediate and unlawful
bodily injury. (Pen. Code, § 288, subd. (b)(1).) The prosecution’s case consisted of
victim’s testimony, victim’s Special Assault and Forensic Evaluation (SAFE) interview,
the testimony of the lead detective involved in victim’s case, and the testimonies of
victim’s brother and one of her friends.
I
Victim’s Testimony
Defendant started living with victim’s family in 2020 when victim was about eight
years old. Victim’s family consisted of victim’s mom, sister, and brother. Defendant
would take victim clothes shopping, out to eat, and to the park. One time, defendant
bought victim a pair of red heels and a red dress even though victim wasn’t really into
dresses. She wore them on an outing with defendant but felt uncomfortable because the
dress was a little short and the heels were tight.
One night, victim and defendant were watching a movie while victim’s mom and
sister were asleep and brother was in his room. Defendant told victim to bend over the
couch. Victim thought he also told her “it wouldn’t hurt” and he would hurt her family if
she told anyone. Defendant then pulled down victim’s shorts and underwear, got up to
grab oil or Vaseline “or something,” put it on his private part, and then put his private part
in her bottom. Defendant breathed heavily. His body moved back and forth. Victim
thought she was crying and thought she told defendant it hurt. Victim was not entirely
sure, but she also thought she told him to stop. She didn’t call out for help because she
was scared defendant would do something to her family. Defendant told her to go to the
bathroom where victim noticed “cleary white stuff” running down her legs. Either she or
defendant wiped the stuff off, and defendant told her to throw away her shorts and
underwear, which were now wet.
2
The same thing happened the next night. Victim went to the living room to play a
video game with defendant. When asked why she would play a game with him after what
he did the night before, victim responded that she “was young and [her] mindset wasn’t
really like – [she] wasn’t really thinking around that age.” After playing the game,
defendant did the same thing to victim as the night before, except victim was lying flat on
her stomach. Victim was confused and thinking a lot about why defendant was doing this
to her. His private part was oily again and her bottom hurt with a sharp pain. Still scared
defendant would do something to her mom or brother, victim didn’t call out for help. She
thought she told defendant it was hurting and thought she asked him to stop, but he didn’t
say anything or stop. Defendant told her to go to the bathroom, where victim wiped
herself down because the “white gooey stuff” was on her legs again and then threw away
her underwear and shorts.
The third night victim was watching a movie with defendant in the living room
when defendant put the Vaseline or oil on his private part and put his private part in her
bottom. Defendant did the back-and-forth motion, and victim felt a sharp pain. Victim
thought she was crying, and she felt weird, confused, and “kind of sad and mad at the
same time.” When asked why she chose to watch a movie with defendant after the last
two nights, victim responded, “[b]ecause I was a little girl and . . . my mind wasn’t really
. . . as it is now.” When asked why she didn’t call out for help this third night, victim
responded that she was scared defendant would hurt her mom and brother. After the
incident, victim went to the bathroom to clean up the same “white stuff” on her legs. She
and defendant then threw away the now-wet clothes victim had been wearing.
Defendant continued to live with victim and her family. He continued to take
victim out to eat and to the park and she liked spending time with him. He never did the
same things to her, but he did slap her bottom or try to kiss her on the lips or the cheek
when no one was around.
3
Victim’s mom later kicked defendant out. Sometime after that, victim told three
friends what happened and then told her brother.
II
Friend’s and Brother’s Testimonies
The prosecution moved to admit victim’s disclosures to brother and one of her
friends (friend) under the fresh complaint doctrine. At the motion hearing, the
prosecution represented that victim (1) told friend and brother that defendant raped her
and (2) went “a little further” with friend to say that defendant touched victim’s butt.
Defense counsel objected and asked that the disclosures not be admitted or at least be
limited “only to what was told and not any detail.” Defense counsel argued that the
disclosures were more prejudicial than probative and were cumulative of each other. The
court granted the prosecution’s motion, concluding that multiple complaints were
admissible and finding victim’s reports, including their circumstances, highly probative
and unlikely to necessitate undue consumption of time.
A. Friend’s Testimony
In 2020 or 2021, victim asked friend to come over, insisting it was an emergency.
When friend arrived, victim “was crying a lot,” “was really shaky” and “looked like she
was really scared.” Victim told friend that defendant “was like touching her and she felt
really uncomfortable. She didn’t know what to do to. She didn’t know who to tell. She
was really scared to tell anybody.” Victim told friend that defendant touched her butt
three times. Friend hugged victim and told her to tell her mom. Friend also cried
because she didn’t like seeking victim like that and because she “felt really bad for her
and like she shouldn’t have to go through that.” Victim was scared and said she didn’t
think her mom would believe her because defendant told victim he would tell victim’s
mom that victim was lying.
4
Following friend’s testimony, the court instructed the jury that victim’s statements
to friend were admitted “for the limited purpose of corroborating [victim’s] testimony and
not to prove the actual occurrence of the crime.”
B. Brother’s Testimony
In May 2022, about four or five months after defendant left victim’s home, victim
called brother to their mom’s closet. Brother “knew something was up” by the face
victim made, which was tearing up. Victim “spit out three words . . . ‘Evan raped me.’ ”
Brother didn’t fully grasp what victim was telling him. He called their mom immediately
and told her to rush home.
The court then instructed the jury that victim’s statement “He raped me” was
“admitted for the limited purpose of corroborating [victim’s] testimony and not to prove
the actual occurrence of the crime.” The court also instructed that this statement was “not
admitted to prove the truth of the matter asserted” but to show that victim reported the
alleged crime and the circumstances of and context around the reporting.
Brother then continued his testimony. He explained that right after victim said
those words, “she just started crying, like bawling out crying.” And she “just kind of
kneeled down on the floor and she was crying.” Brother was shocked, angry, frustrated,
and devastated. He “couldn’t believe it. Like how we – how we seen him and how we
looked at him and like I couldn’t really believe – couldn’t put two and two together.” He
was devasted because “we were all so comfortable around him” that it was “like a slap in
the face.”
When asked if he learned what part of victim’s body defendant touched, brother
responded that he overheard from mom and victim talking that defendant had touched
“her butt area.” When asked if there was any specific part of victim’s butt, brother
responded, “[h]er anus. [⁋] . . . [⁋] That’s the only place that I heard about.” The court
interjected that its previous instruction regarding victim’s statements applied to that
statement as well, “that he overheard to the mom.”
5
III
Victim’s SAFE Interview
Victim’s SAFE interview took place in August 2022. In that interview, victim
stated that defendant “put his private part . . . in [her] bottom.” This happened “like three
nights in a row,” she thought. The first time, she thought defendant pulled down her
pants. He then told her it wouldn’t hurt. Defendant went to grab something like
Vaseline, put it on his private part, and then put his private part in her bottom. It hurt, and
she was “like kinda crying because [she] wanted him to stop, but he wouldn’t listen.” His
body was moving back and forth and he breathed heavily. According to victim,
defendant stopped after three to four minutes because he was scared brother might come
out of his room. Victim went to the bathroom and felt a white, slimy substance dripping
down her legs. Defendant went to get paper towels. Victim thought he said, “Don’t tell
your mom.” He also told victim to clean up and that he’d throw away her shorts if there
was something on them. Her body and bottom felt normal after.
The second and third times were basically the same. Defendant did the same thing
that he did the other night, using Vaseline, putting his private part in her bottom, and
throwing her clothes away after. “[L]ike, the second night or something,” defendant told
victim he would hurt her family if she told anyone.
After those three nights, defendant was nicer and tried to get closer to victim’s
friends. That’s also when he started to kiss victim on the lips and cheeks and put her on
his lap. Victim’s mom kicked defendant out months later because they didn’t get along
very well.
IV
Defense Case
Defense counsel cross-examined victim, friend, and brother. Victim could not
answer many of defense counsel’s questions because she couldn’t remember. She
explained that her brain was “a little foggy today” but it wasn’t foggy when she testified
6
the day before. Victim also admitted the following: (1) her room and brother’s room
weren’t that far from the couch where the incidents occurred; (2) victim could hear
people in the living room from her room; (3) brother would often come out of his room at
night for a snack or a drink; (4) on the first night, victim stood in the bent position
without shorts or underwear while defendant left to grab something; (5) her body felt
normal after the first night; and (6) she met with the prosecutor before coming to testify
and watched the SAFE interview, which helped her remember all the details she gave in
her testimony.
Brother agreed that memory fades over time and admitted he had reviewed his
previous statement before testifying, which helped refresh his memory. He confirmed
that he liked to play video games in his room late into the night and would randomly
come out for snacks and drinks. He also testified that the red dress defendant bought for
victim came down below the knees.
Friend admitted she had reviewed her previous statement before testifying, which
refreshed her memory.
Defense counsel also cross-examined the lead detective. The officer admitted the
following: (1) victim did not report the alleged abuse for almost a year; (2) the SAFE
interview did not occur until almost three months after law enforcement became aware of
the allegations; (3) not immediately presenting a child for a forensic interview might give
time for others to make suggestions to the child; (4) nine-year-olds can falsely report
sexual abuse or intentionally make up abuse for their own motives; (5) sexual abuse
memories can be suggested or implanted in a child’s memories; (6) during his
investigation, the detective heard about different dates that the incidents may have
happened; and (7) the detective never directly questioned victim, never tested how voices
carry through victim’s home, and never asked victim’s mom about missing shorts and
underwear.
7
V
Closing Argument and Verdict
In closing argument, defense counsel challenged victim’s credibility, questioning
whether her story made logical sense and pointing to inconsistencies between her
testimony and her SAFE interview and how often victim said “I think” during those
statements. Defense counsel argued the phrase “I think” meant victim was unsure, and
that gave the jury reason to find doubt and reason to return a not guilty verdict. He also
claimed the detective presented a “garbage” investigation.
In its instructions, the court repeated that victim’s statement about the alleged
offenses to friend and brother were admitted for the limited purpose of corroborating
victim’s testimony and not to prove the actual occurrences of the crimes.
The jury found defendant guilty of all three counts. The abstract of judgment
indicates he was convicted by plea. Defendant timely appealed.
DISCUSSION
Defendant contends the trial court prejudicially erred by admitting friend’s and
brother’s testimonies for three reasons: (1) the testimonies exceeded the permissible
scope of fresh complaint evidence; (2) the testimonies were unduly prejudicial under
Evidence Code section 352 (section 352); and (3) the testimonies were so prejudicial that
they denied defendant his constitutional right to a fair trial. We disagree.
Under the fresh complaint doctrine, a sexual assault victim’s out-of-court
disclosure of an alleged offense is admissible for the limited, nonhearsay purpose of
establishing “the fact of, and the circumstances surrounding, the victim’s disclosure of the
assault to others” to help the jury decide whether the offense occurred. (People v.
Brown (1994) 8 Cal.4th 746, 749-750 (Brown).) The jury may consider evidence
admitted under this rule “for the purpose of corroborating the victim’s testimony, but not
to prove the occurrence of the crime.” (People v. Ramirez (2006) 143 Cal.App.4th 1512,
1522 (Ramirez).) The fresh complaint evidence that may be offered for this purpose is
8
limited in scope. In general, only the fact that a complaint was made and the
circumstances surrounding its making are admissible. (Brown, supra, 8 Cal.4th at p. 760.)
That said, the evidence is not limited “to the bare fact that the victim ‘made a complaint’
as to an unspecified subject matter,” because such evidence “would be meaningless.”
(People v. Burton (1961) 55 Cal.2d 328, 351.) The nature of the offense and the identity
of the offender is proper. (Ibid.)
Fresh complaint evidence is also subject to exclusion under section 352 if the
court determines that its probative value is substantially outweighed by undue prejudice.
(Brown, supra, 8 Cal.4th at p. 763; Evid. Code, § 352.) We review a trial court’s
evidentiary ruling under section 352 for abuse of discretion and reverse only if the ruling
was arbitrary, whimsical, or capricious. (People v. Robertson (2012) 208 Cal.App.4th
965, 991.)
When a trial court erroneously admits evidence, we affirm the judgment unless it
is reasonably probable a different result would have occurred had the evidence been
excluded. (People v. Partida (2005) 37 Cal.4th 428, 439.) But if the admission results in
a due process violation by making the trial fundamentally unfair, we apply the more
stringent prejudice standard in Chapman v. California (1967) 386 U.S. 18. (People v.
Albarran (2007) 149 Cal.App.4th 214, 229.)
Here, defendant contends brother went beyond the scope of fresh complaint
evidence when he testified that he heard defendant had touched victim’s anus. He also
contends friend went beyond the scope of fresh complaint evidence when she testified as
to the following: (1) defendant was touching victim; (2) victim felt uncomfortable;
(3) victim didn’t know what to do or whom to tell; (4) victim was scared; (5) friend
hugged victim and told her to tell her mom; (6) defendant touched victim’s butt three
times; and (7) victim was scared to tell her mom because she didn’t think her mom would
believe her because defendant threatened to tell her mom victim was lying.
9
With one exception discussed below, we disagree with defendant. The statements
that defendant touched victim, specifically her butt or her anus, and that victim was
uncomfortable described the nature of the offense with fewer details than other cases
have allowed. (People v. Burton, supra, 55 Cal.2d at pp. 337, 351 [defendant “ ‘made me
play with his peter’ ”]; People v. Butler (1967) 249 Cal.App.2d 799, 804-805 [“ ‘He said
the man was sucking his thing’ ”]; People v. Cordray (1963) 221 Cal.App.2d 589, 594
[“ ‘She said he had pulled her pants down and he had kissed her between the legs’ ”].)
The statements that victim was scared, didn’t want to tell her mom, and didn’t know what
to do or whom to tell were admissible because they concerned the context and
circumstances surrounding the disclosure and why victim delayed telling anyone.
(Brown, supra, 8 Cal.4th at p. 764 [victim felt scared and was reluctant to tell her
mother].) And the statement that friend hugged victim and told her to tell her mom was
not an out-of-court statement by victim and helped explain why victim eventually
brought the incidents to her family’s attention who then went to law enforcement.
This leaves friend’s disclosure of the number of times defendant touched victim’s
butt. Although the People concede, and we agree, that the number of times went beyond
the scope of fresh complaint evidence, defendant did not object to that statement during
the trial, and his earlier, more general objection did not cover this specific statement.
(People v. Mattson (1990) 50 Cal.3d 826, 853-854 [a specific objection is required to
enable the court to make an informed ruling and to enable the party proffering the
evidence to cure the defect].)
Even if defendant did properly object, he fails to show a reasonable probability
that a different result would have occurred had that statement been excluded. Victim
offered her own testimony about the three incidents, giving the jury the opportunity to
hear directly from her and judge her credibility. (Ramirez, supra, 143 Cal.App.4th at
p. 1526.) The jury also heard victim’s SAFE interview, which largely tracked her trial
testimony. This means the jury “did not have to rely solely on secondhand statements
10
[victim] made to third parties” that were cumulative to her testimony and SAFE interview
at trial. (Ibid.) Moreover, the jury was specifically instructed as to the purpose for which
victim’s statements to brother and friend could be used, and there is no indication that the
jury was unable to follow those instructions. (People v. Jimenez (2019) 35 Cal.App.5th
373, 390 [prejudice “refers to the possibility of misuse of the evidence”]; People v.
Homick (2012) 55 Cal.4th 816, 867 [we presume jurors understand and follow
instructions].) For these reasons, it is not reasonably probable that defendant would have
fared better had the jury not heard friend state the number of times defendant touched
victim’s butt.
Although brother’s and friend’s statements were cumulative of victim’s testimony
and SAFE interview, we reject defendant’s contention that the court should have
excluded them as cumulative under section 352. The weighing of probative though
possibly cumulative evidence against its prejudicial nature is a matter entrusted to the
sound discretion of the trial court. (People v. Medina (1995) 11 Cal.4th 694, 749.) When
evidence arguably lacks credibility, other evidence that will bolster its credibility is
corroborating, not merely cumulative. (See People v. Bolin (1998) 18 Cal.4th 297, 319.)
Here, victim’s credibility was central to defendant’s case. As a result, the extrajudicial
statements provided through brother and friend were not merely cumulative of victim’s
testimony; rather, they served to corroborate her testimony and satisfied the purpose of
the fresh-complaint doctrine. (Brown, supra, 8 Cal.4th at p. 761 [“[w]hen the victim of
an alleged sexual offense did not make a prompt complaint but instead disclosed the
alleged incident only some time later, evidence of the fact and circumstances surrounding
the delayed complaint . . . may be relevant to the jury’s evaluation of the likelihood that
the offense did or did not occur”].)
Defendant’s three remaining prejudice contentions fare no better. First, he
contends that the improper fresh complaint statements tipped the section 352 balance
toward undue prejudice. We disagree. As we explained, a single statement – the number
11
of times defendant touched defendant’s butt – went beyond fresh complaint evidence.
We disagree that this single statement was more prejudicial than probative. It was no
more damaging than victim’s detailed testimony regarding the three incidents, and it was
accompanied by an instruction that it could be used only for the purpose of corroboration.
Moreover, defendant’s theory was that no lewd or lascivious acts occurred, not that the
number of acts was inaccurate.
Second, defendant contends that victim’s extrajudicial statement to brother that
defendant “raped” her was “emotionally charged” and likely to evoke a strong emotional
bias against defendant particularly because defendant was charged with committing a
lewd or lascivious act, not rape. But defendant failed to assert this contention during the
hearing on the prosecutor’s motion to admit this specific statement. (People v. Mattson,
50 Cal.3d at pp. 853-854.) And while this statement was certainly damaging to
defendant, “damaging” is not synonymous with “prejudice.” (People v. Jimenez, supra,
35 Cal.App.5th at p. 390.) We cannot conclude that victim’s extrajudicial statement to
brother that defendant raped her is more inflammatory than the direct trial testimony she
offered regarding defendant’s acts. (See ibid. [offense was described in detail through the
victim’s direct testimony].)
And third, defendant takes similar issue with friend’s and brother’s descriptions of
victim’s demeanor during the disclosures – i.e., victim was “bawling out crying” and
victim was “really shaky” – and of their reactions to those disclosures – i.e., brother was
angry, frustrated, and devastated and friend felt really bad for victim because she
shouldn’t have to go through that. Defendant contends these descriptions were
manifestly prejudicial, “emotionally charged,” and denied defendant his constitutional
right to a fundamentally fair trial. In his view, the prejudice was compounded by the
length of victim’s and friend’s testimonies that he claims spans 40 pages of the reporter’s
transcript and by the prosecutor’s repeated emphasis of victim’s extrajudicial statements
in closing argument.
12
Defendant’s account of the record is inaccurate. Victim’s direct testimony spans
around 70 pages while brother’s and friend’s direct testimony on victim’s disclosure span
around seven and 10 pages, respectively. In the prosecutor’s closing argument, which
spans around 22 pages, the prosecutor briefly mentioned victim’s disclosures to friend or
brother five times and spent just over two pages describing the disclosures and why they
corroborated victim’s testimony. We disagree with defendant’s characterization of the
prosecutor’s closing argument as “repeatedly referenc[ing] and emphasiz[ing]” the
extrajudicial statements.
Also, defendant did not object to the purportedly “emotionally charged”
statements during the trial, and his general objection to the admission of the disclosures
did not cover these specific statements. (See People v. Partida, supra, 37 Cal.4th at
pp. 433-434.) Even assuming defendant did properly object, friend’s and brother’s
descriptions provided the circumstances surrounding victim’s disclosures and were highly
probative of victim’s credibility. (Brown, supra, 8 Cal.4th at p. 762 [fresh complaint
evidence properly includes “the circumstances surrounding the making of the
complaint”].) The fact that friend’s and brother’s testimonies could have had a powerful
impact on the jury in assessing credibility does not mean they were overly prejudicial
under section 352 or created a fundamentally unfair trial. (See People v. Jimenez, supra,
35 Cal.App.5th at pp. 390-391.)
One final point: the abstract of judgment must be corrected to show conviction
was by jury rather than plea. (People v. Mitchell (2001) 26 Cal.4th 181, 185.)
13
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed. The trial court is directed to (1) prepare a corrected
abstract of judgment reflecting defendant’s conviction by jury, rather than by plea, and
(2) forward the corrected abstract to the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation.
/s/
MESIWALA, J.
We concur:
/s/
ROBIE, Acting P. J.
/s/
FEINBERG, J.
14
Vous vous demandez comment ce texte s’applique à votre situation ?
Consultation gratuite, sans engagement
Décrivez votre situation. Notre équipe vous recontactera par e-mail pour votre consultation.
Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude
Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.