People v. Ronquillo CA6

CourtListener 10643755Calctapp29 juil. 2025

Texte intégral

Filed 7/29/25 P. v. Ronquillo CA6

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SIXTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

THE PEOPLE, H052316
(Santa Clara County
Plaintiff and Respondent, Super. Ct. No. C2016190)

v.

DENNIS DABU RONQUILLO,

Defendant and Appellant.

A jury convicted defendant Dennis Dabu Ronquillo of 19 sexual crimes
against two minor relatives. The trial court sentenced Ronquillo to 75 years
to life consecutive to 50 years in prison.
On appeal, Ronquillo contends the trial court erred by instructing the
jury on child sexual abuse accommodation syndrome (CSAAS) with
CALCRIM No. 1193 (CALCRIM 1193). Alternatively, Ronquillo claims that
his defense counsel was constitutionally ineffective for failing to object to
CALCRIM 1193.
For the reasons explained below, we affirm the judgment.
I. FACTS AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A. Procedural History
In June 2021, the Santa Clara County District Attorney filed an
information charging Ronquillo with 19 sexual crimes involving two minors,
Jane Doe 1 and Jane Doe 2.
Counts 1 through 7 of the information alleged crimes committed
against Jane Doe 1 at various times between December 1, 2018, and
December 2, 2020, namely six counts of a lewd or lascivious act on a child
under the age of 14 (Pen. Code,1 § 288, subd. (a); counts 1–4, 6 & 7) and one
count of a lewd or lascivious act by force or duress on a child under the age of
14 (§ 288, subd. (b)(1); count 5).
Counts 8 through 19 alleged crimes committed against Jane Doe 2 at
various times between February 27, 2011, and February 26, 2019, namely
four counts of oral copulation by force or duress with a minor 14 years old or
older (former § 288a, subd. (c)(2)(C) [renumbered as § 287, subd. (c)(2)(C)
(Stats. 2018, ch. 423, § 49, eff. Jan. 1, 2019)]; counts 8–11), four counts of a
lewd or lascivious act on a child under the age of 14 (§ 288, subd. (a); counts
12–15), two counts of rape by force or duress of a minor 14 years old or older
(§ 261, subd. (a)(2); counts 16–17), and two counts of sexual penetration by
force or duress on a minor 14 years old or older (§ 289, subd. (a)(1)(C); counts
18–19).
The information further alleged as to each count that Ronquillo
committed the charged offenses against more than one victim (§ 667.61,
subds. (b), (e), (j)(2)).
In December 2023, the jury found Ronquillo guilty as charged on all
counts and found true the multiple victim allegations attached to counts 1

1 All further unspecified statutory references are to the Penal Code.

2
through 7 and 12 through 15. The jury, however, found not true those
allegations attached to counts 8 through 11 and 16 through 19.
On May 6, 2024, the trial court imposed an aggregate sentence of 75
years to life consecutive to 50 years in prison, comprising 25 years to life on
counts 1 through 7 and 12 through 15 (with the terms on counts 1, 5, and 12
imposed consecutively), consecutive lower term sentences of six years on
counts 8–11, 18, and 19, and consecutive lower term sentences of seven years
on counts 16 and 17.
B. Evidence Presented at Trial
1. Prosecution Evidence
The prosecution presented evidence that Ronquillo sexually abused two
of his nieces, sisters Jane Doe 1 and Jane Doe 2, while he lived with their
family. Jane Doe 2 is seven years older than Jane Doe 1. Jane Doe 2 was 22
and Jane Doe 1 was 15 when they testified at Ronquillo’s trial in December
2023.
Jane Doe 2 told the jury that when she was in the fourth grade,
Ronquillo began entering her bedroom to talk to her. After a few such
interactions, Ronquillo started putting his hand on Jane Doe 2’s breast, at
first outside of her clothing and, later, underneath her shirt, directly touching
her breast. Ronquillo touched Jane Doe 2 in this manner multiple times
when she was in the fourth grade. Jane Doe 2 was “too scared” to say
anything to him. She, however, did mention some of Ronquillo’s abuse to her
friends around this time. She begged them not to say anything because she
feared what would happen.
When Jane Doe 2 was in the fifth or sixth grade, Ronquillo began
lowering his hand from Jane Doe 2’s breast to her vagina and rubbing it

3
outside of her clothing. Jane Doe 2 would freeze up and hope that Ronquillo
would stop.
When Jane Doe 2 was in the seventh grade, Ronquillo began to lift her
shirt and suck and bite her nipples. This happened on “[n]umerous
occasions.”
When Jane Doe 2 was in the eighth or ninth grade, Ronquillo placed his
hand under Jane Doe 2’s pants and tried to insert his fingers inside her
vagina, putting his finger between her labia. Between Jane Doe 2’s eighth or
ninth grade year and when she was 17, Ronquillo digitally penetrated Jane
Doe 2’s vagina in this way multiple times, testifying it was “too many to
count.” On rare occasions, Jane Doe 2 told Ronquillo that it hurt her when he
bit her nipples or rubbed her clitoris hard. Ronquillo responded, “ ‘No, it
doesn’t. You like it, don’t you?’ ”
When Jane Doe 2 was 15 or 16, Ronquillo began touching her breast,
fondling her, and then pulling her pants down and rubbing his penis inside
her labia. She would pretend to be asleep to discourage him and tried to keep
her legs together. Ronquillo attempted to pry her legs apart. This occurred
at least five times.
Beginning around when Jane Doe 2 was in the 10th grade, Ronquillo
made Jane Doe 2 orally copulate him. Ronquillo touched Jane Doe 2, told her
to suck his nipples, pressed her head down toward his penis, and told her to
suck it. Jane Doe 2 was scared to say no and she “felt gross.” She complied
because she feared Ronquillo would get angry, and she thought that if she
“just endured it a little more, he wouldn’t go after her [sister].” The oral
copulation occurred four or five times, until Jane Doe 2 was about 17.
The sexual abuse that Ronquillo perpetrated on Jane Doe 2 made her
“very, very depressed.” Her grades dropped significantly, which made her

4
mother mad. Jane Doe 2 usually coped with the abuse by “zon[ing] out.” She
also would “lose track of the time” or sometimes scratch herself. Jane Doe 2
did not warn her sister Jane Doe 1 about Ronquillo because Jane Doe 2 was
afraid Jane Doe 1 would tell their mother and arguments and fights would
ensue. Jane Doe 2 had arguments with her mother that “turned physical,”
and there were times her mother wrapped her hands around Jane Doe 2’s
neck.
In December 2019, Jane Doe 2 told her cousin that Ronquillo had
touched her in places she did not want to be touched.2 Jane Doe 2 begged her
cousin not to say anything.
Sometime in 2020, Jane Doe 2 moved out of the family house and into
her grandparents’ home.
Jane Doe 1 testified that when she was about 10 or 11 years old,
Ronquillo touched her on her bare arms and legs while she was sitting on his
bed watching a movie. It felt “a little awkward” and “really irritated” Jane
Doe 1.
Some weeks later, when Jane Doe 1 hid under the sheets on Ronquillo’s
bed while playing hide and seek with her brother, Ronquillo slid his hand
underneath and touched Jane Doe 1’s chest under her shirt. Jane Doe 1
“didn’t like it” and “[her] body was telling [her] to . . . get out,” but she stayed
where she was because her brother had not yet found her. Ronquillo told
Jane Doe 1 not to tell anyone what he was doing.
Another time, when Jane Doe 1 was still in elementary school and
returning from a party with her family in a van, Ronquillo placed his hands
under a blanket, unzipped Jane Doe 1’s jeans, put his hand under her

2 Jane Doe 2’s cousin provided corroborating testimony about this

conversation.
5
underwear, and rubbed her vagina. Jane Doe 1 was “grossed out,” but she
was afraid to say anything because she feared that her family would take
Ronquillo’s side against her.
Later, during the summer between the sixth and seventh grades (when
Jane Doe 1 turned 12 years old), Jane Doe 1 was awakened by Ronquillo
touching her. His “cold hand” was on Jane Doe 1’s vagina over her clothing,
and he was trying to rub it. She pushed his hand away and turned over; he
left the room.
Another time that summer, Jane Doe 1 was awakened by someone
lying down next to her in bed, putting a hand under her shirt, and rubbing
her chest area. Jane Doe 1 was not able to see who it was but believed it was
Ronquillo.
Once, when Jane Doe 1 was in Ronquillo’s bedroom, Ronquillo told her
to massage his chest and suck on his nipple. Jane Doe 1 complied because
she was told to respect her elders and do as they say. Ronquillo additionally
grabbed Jane Doe 1’s wrist, moved her hand under his underwear, and told
her to grab his penis “and go up and down.”
In the beginning of December 2020, while 12-year-old Jane Doe 1 was
sleeping on a couch, she felt Ronquillo brushing against her bare, upper arm,
towards her chest. She pushed his hand away.
Later that day, Jane Doe 1 told Jane Doe 2 about Ronquillo’s abusive
conduct because she “felt like it wasn’t right anymore” and was “tired of him
trying to touch [her] when [she was] sleeping.” Jane Doe 1 testified that she
disclosed the abuse to Jane Doe 2 first because their mother “is kind of scary”
and Jane Doe 1 did not have much interaction with her father. Their parents
also were “really strict,” and Jane Doe 1 was uncomfortable talking with

6
them because they “push[ed] [her] away.” She feared they would think she
was making up the abuse and she would get in trouble.
After Jane Doe 1 disclosed the abuse to Jane Doe 2, Jane Doe 2
informed their parents about it. Jane Doe 2 further told their mother about
the abuse Ronquillo had perpetrated on her because she feared Jane Doe 1
would not be believed.
Clinical psychologist Dr. Blake Carmichael testified as an expert on
CSAAS and the myths and misconceptions surrounding child sexual abuse.
Dr. Carmichael did not know the facts of this case and stated that he “would
not be able to provide” any opinion on whether someone was sexually abused.
Dr. Carmichael explained that CSAAS is an educational tool that helps
people understand myths and misconceptions about child sexual abuse. He
said CSAAS “helps explain why there’s such a variety of ways kids react to
and tell about their sexual abuse.” Dr. Carmichael added that there is no
“checklist to use to determine if someone has been abused” and “CSAAS
doesn’t tell you if a kid was abused or not.”
CSAAS has five components: secrecy; helplessness; entrapment and
accommodation; delayed, unconvincing, and conflicted disclosure; and
recanting or retraction. Dr. Carmichael explained that secrecy refers to the
context in which sexual abuse often occurs. He described reasons why child
victims may keep abuse a secret. Helplessness refers to the “power
differential” between the child and the perpetrator. Entrapment and
accommodation pertain to a child’s helplessness in stopping the abuse and
the ways children cope or deal with the abuse. Dr. Carmichael described
various behavioral, emotional, and cognitive mechanisms that children
employ to “manage the situation.” Delayed, unconvincing, and conflicted
disclosure encompass belated, inconsistent, and piecemeal revelations. Dr.

7
Carmichael explained how language, memory, and development may affect
disclosure and stated that a child’s demeanor with respect to disclosure is “a
dynamic situation.” Lastly, recantation and retraction refer to the
phenomenon in which a child victim discloses a valid claim of sexual abuse
and then repudiates it.
On cross-examination, Dr. Carmichael stated that “most people [agree,]
and the research agrees that not all kids who have been sexually abused will
have each of those [five] components [of CSAAS]. It’s really helping
understand why those things are not inconsistent for the kid that has been
abused.”
2. Defense Evidence
Ronquillo testified on his own behalf and was the only defense witness.
He told the jury that he did not molest Jane Doe 1 or Jane Doe 2 and had “a
typical . . . niece relationship” with them. He said he felt “[h]orrible” when
hearing their testimony and had no idea how they came up with their
allegations. The only reason Ronquillo could think of for their accusations is
that they wanted him out of the family’s house so their brother could get his
bedroom back.
Ronquillo moved in with Jane Doe 1’s and Jane Doe 2’s family in 2010.
From 2010 until 2012, Ronquillo worked for a company that manufactured
commercial refrigeration units. From 2012 until 2020, he worked at Tesla on
an assembly line. He often worked 12 hours a day, six days a week at Tesla.
In March 2016, Ronquillo sustained an injury that caused him to
“hav[e] a hard time” raising his right arm into “a high position” without
feeling pain in his shoulder and back. The injury also caused numbness and
tingling in his right arm and fingers and a loss of control of his fingers.
Additionally, in 2019, Ronquillo developed carpal tunnel syndrome in both

8
hands that required two surgeries. He had a “hard time” driving because he
could not “control the steering wheel” due to “pain” and his hands “freez[ing]
up” and “tingling.” He also “kept dropping” his phone and had a “hard time”
writing and brushing his teeth. Given that he did not “have control of [his]
right hand,” he had a hard time touching his girlfriend intimately, and he
could not masturbate.
Ronquillo recalled the time when Jane Doe 1 fell asleep while they were
riding in a van. He told the jury that he could not have opened Jane Doe 1’s
pants due, in part, to his hand problems.
On cross-examination, Ronquillo admitted that until 2020, he used a
lighter to light his cigarettes. He testified that he brushed his teeth twice a
day, and was able to drive to work, shave and trim his facial hair, and take
pictures with his cell phone. He further admitted that he buttoned the shirt,
tied the tie, and tied the laces of the shoes he was wearing during his trial
testimony.
II. DISCUSSION
Ronquillo contends that CALCRIM 1193 is legally erroneous because it
“instructed the jurors that they could use the expert CSAAS testimony to find
that the victims’ testimony was true since their conduct ‘was consistent with
the conduct of someone who has been abused.’ ” He asserts that the trial
court’s use of CALCRIM 1193 prejudicially violated his right to due process
and a fair trial and lessened the prosecution’s burden of proof.
The Attorney General responds that CALCRIM 1193 correctly states
the law and there is no reasonable likelihood that Ronquillo’s jury misapplied

9
the instruction. The Attorney General further asserts that the instruction
did not violate Ronquillo’s constitutional rights or prejudice him.3
A. Additional Background
Pretrial, the prosecutor moved to admit expert testimony regarding
CSAAS. The trial court granted the prosecutor’s in limine motion and stated
that it would instruct the jury with CALCRIM 1193.
In its final instructions, the trial court instructed the jurors as follows:
“1193. Testimony on child sexual abuse accommodation syndrome. [¶] You
have heard testimony from Blake Carmichael regarding child sexual abuse
accommodation syndrome. [¶] Child sexual abuse accommodation syndrome
relates to a pattern of behavior that may be present in child sexual abuse
cases. Testimony as to the accommodation syndrome is offered only to
explain certain behavior of an alleged victim of child sexual abuse. [¶] Blake
Carmichael’s testimony about child sexual abuse accommodation syndrome is
not evidence that the defendant committed any of the crimes charged against
him. [¶] You may consider this evidence only in deciding whether or not
[Jane] Doe’s 1 or [Jane] Doe 2’s conduct was consistent with the conduct of
someone who has been molested, and in evaluating the believability of her
testimony.” (Boldface & capitalization omitted.)

3 Notwithstanding Ronquillo’s failure to object to CALCRIM 1193 at

trial, the Attorney General does not assert forfeiture. Moreover, Ronquillo
contends that his appellate challenge to CALCRIM 1193 is cognizable
because that instruction is legally incorrect and affected his substantial
rights. Under these circumstances, we reach the merits of Ronquillo’s claim
of error. (See People v. Grandberry (2019) 35 Cal.App.5th 599, 604; People v.
Gomez (2018) 6 Cal.5th 243, 312; § 1259.) In turn, we need not consider
Ronquillo’s alternative ineffective assistance of counsel claim.
10
B. Legal Principles
“While CSAAS evidence is not relevant to prove the alleged sexual
abuse occurred,” California courts have long held such evidence admissible in
child sexual abuse cases to “disabuse jurors of five commonly held ‘myths’ or
misconceptions about child sexual abuse.” (People v. Lapenias (2021) 67
Cal.App.5th 162, 171 (Lapenias).) Such evidence is needed “ ‘to explain the
emotional antecedents of abused children’s seemingly self-impeaching
behavior.’ ” (People v. McAlpin (1991) 53 Cal.3d 1289, 1301; see also People v.
Gonzales (2017) 16 Cal.App.5th 494, 504 (Gonzales) [“The purpose of CSAAS
is to understand a child’s reactions when they have been abused.”]; People v.
Munch (2020) 52 Cal.App.5th 464, 468 (Munch) [“ ‘The expert is not allowed
to give an opinion on whether a witness is telling the truth.’ ”].)
“ ‘A claim of instructional error is reviewed de novo. [Citation.] An
appellate court reviews the wording of a jury instruction de novo and assesses
whether the instruction accurately states the law.’ ” (People v. Ramirez
(2023) 98 Cal.App.5th 175, 218 (Ramirez).) We consider the challenged
instruction “ ‘in the context of the instructions as a whole and the trial record
to determine whether there is a reasonable likelihood the jury applied the
instruction in an impermissible manner.’ ” (People v. Rivera (2019) 7 Cal.5th
306, 326; see also People v. Lemcke (2021) 11 Cal.5th 644, 655.) We assume
that jurors understand and follow the court’s instructions. (People v. Ortiz
(2023) 96 Cal.App.5th 768, 816 (Ortiz).)
C. Analysis
Relying principally on People v. Housley (1992) 6 Cal.App.4th 947
(Housley), Ronquillo argues that CALCRIM 1193 is defective because it does
not instruct that “ ‘the expert’s testimony is not intended and should not be

11
used to determine whether the victim’s molestation claim is true.’ ”4
Ronquillo further argues that the last sentence of the instruction provided to
his jury is improper because “CSAAS testimony has been strictly limited to
providing evidence that the victim’s behavior was not necessarily inconsistent
with that of an abused child.”5
We are not persuaded by Ronquillo’s contentions that the instruction
provided to his jury is erroneous. The trial court instructed the jurors that
Dr. Carmichael’s testimony about CSAAS was “offered only to explain certain
behavior of an alleged victim of child sexual abuse” and “is not evidence that
the defendant committed any of the crimes charged against him.” In the
same vein, Dr. Carmichael testified that there is no “checklist” for

4 The Court of Appeal in Housley concluded that a jury must be

instructed that CSAAS evidence “is admissible solely for the purpose of
showing the victim’s reactions as demonstrated by the evidence are not
inconsistent with having been molested; and [] the expert’s testimony is not
intended and should not be used to determine whether the victim’s
molestation claim is true.” (Housley, supra, 6 Cal.App.4th at p. 959; but see
People v. Mateo (2016) 243 Cal.App.4th 1063, 1074 [disagreeing with
Housley’s holding that a limiting instruction on CSAAS is required sua
sponte and explaining that when “the expert testifies regarding the behavior
of abused children as a class, there is little, if any, chance the jury will
misunderstand or misapply the evidence”].)
5 The last sentence of CALCRIM 1193 was modified in September 2022

(before Ronquillo’s 2023 trial) to state that CSAAS evidence may be
considered by jurors only in deciding whether or not the victim’s “conduct was
consistent with the conduct of someone who has been molested.” (CALCRIM
1193 (2023), italics added.) The prior version of CALCRIM 1193 provided:
“You may consider this evidence only in deciding whether or not [the victim’s]
conduct was not inconsistent with the conduct of someone who has been
molested.” (CALCRIM 1193 (2022), italics added.) Ronquillo acknowledges
that multiple Courts of Appeal endorsed the prior version of CALCRIM 1193
as accurately informing the jury of the limited use of CSAAS evidence. (See,
e.g., Lapenias, supra, 67 Cal.App.5th at pp. 175–176; Munch, supra, 52
Cal.App.5th at pp. 473–474; Gonzales, supra, 16 Cal.App.5th at pp. 503–504.)
12
determining abuse, “CSAAS doesn’t tell you if a kid was abused or not,” and
he could not opine on whether someone was sexually abused. On this record,
we discern no defect in the instant instruction that made it reasonably likely
the jurors understood the instruction to permit the use of CSAAS evidence as
affirmative proof that Jane Doe 1 and Jane Doe 2 were molested and
Ronquillo was guilty. (See Munch, supra, 52 Cal.App.5th at p. 474; Ortiz,
supra, 96 Cal.App.5th at p. 816; Ramirez, supra, 98 Cal.App.5th at pp. 219–
220.)
Regarding the last sentence of the instant instruction, we are satisfied
that even without the prior version’s double negative language about the
victim’s conduct being “not inconsistent” with that of someone who has been
molested, the instant instruction is semantically equivalent to the prior,
endorsed version of CALCRIM 1193. The instant instruction retains the
original version’s “whether or not” phrasing, still permitting the jurors to use
the CSAAS evidence only in deciding whether the alleged victims’ behavior
was either consistent or inconsistent with that of a molestation victim, but
not compelling “a conclusion that the victims’ conduct was consistent with
being a sexual abuse victim.” (Ortiz, supra, 96 Cal.App.5th at p. 816.)
Moreover, Dr. Carmichael stated during his testimony that CSAAS
helps people “understand why” the five components it describes “are not
inconsistent for the kid that has been abused.” Similarly, in his closing
argument, the prosecutor stated that the CSAAS evidence was “useful for []
describing that pattern of behavior that might seem kind of counterintuitive
but is not otherwise inconsistent with a child who’s been molested” and could
be used “in evaluating the credibility of [the victims’] testimony.” The
prosecutor also “reemphasize[d] . . . that this is not like a checklist, that
you’re not diagnosing anybody with having been abused.” Viewed in the

13
context of the complete record, there is no reasonable likelihood the jurors
applied the last sentence of the instruction to impermissibly extrapolate from
Jane Doe 1’s and Jane Doe 2’s behaviors that Ronquillo had in fact abused
them—rather than to decide only whether their behaviors were self-
impeaching.
For these reasons, we conclude the trial court did not err in using
CALCRIM 1193 and Ronquillo’s constitutional rights were not violated. (See
Ramirez, supra, 98 Cal.App.5th at p. 220; Ortiz, supra, 96 Cal.App.5th at
p. 816.)
Even assuming arguendo that CALCRIM 1193 is erroneous and that
error implicated Ronquillo’s constitutional rights, we conclude any such error
was harmless beyond a reasonable doubt. (See Chapman v. California (1967)
386 U.S. 18, 24.) As mentioned ante, the trial court expressly instructed that
Dr. Carmichael’s testimony on CSAAS is not evidence that Ronquillo
committed the charged crimes. The court also stated in other instructions
that the jurors “alone must judge the credibility or believability of the
witnesses” (CALCRIM No. 226) and the jurors were not required to accept an
expert’s opinion as true or correct. (CALCRIM No. 332.) Additionally, Dr.
Carmichael’s testimony and the prosecutor’s closing argument appropriately
conveyed the limitations on the jury’s consideration of the CSAAS evidence.
Although there was no physical evidence substantiating the sexual abuse
described by Jane Doe 1 and Jane Doe 2 and the issue of credibility was
paramount, their testimonies were consistent and corroborative of each other,
without proof of collusion. In contrast to the compelling evidence of guilt,
Ronquillo’s testimony was significantly impeached on his principal defense—
the effect that his work-related injuries had on his ability to engage in the

14
abusive conduct. On this record, we are convinced any error in CALCRIM
1193 was harmless beyond a reasonable doubt.
III. DISPOSITION

The judgment is affirmed.

15
______________________________________
Danner, Acting P. J.

WE CONCUR:

____________________________________
Wilson, J.

____________________________________
Bromberg, J.

H052316
People v. Ronquillo

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.