Cielo v. Payne CA2/6

CourtListener 10598479Calctapp4 juin 2025

Texte intégral

Filed 6/4/25 Cielo v. Payne CA2/6

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION SIX

CHERINE CIELO, 2d Civ. No. B340404
(Super. Ct. No. 24CV-0158)
Petitioner and Appellant, (San Luis Obispo County)

v.

SHERRY VINCENT PAYNE,

Respondent.

Appellant Cherine Cielo petitioned for a civil harassment
restraining order against respondent Sherry Vincent Payne
under Code of Civil Procedure section 527.6.1 Respondent
answered the petition but did not cross-petition for an order
against appellant. At hearing, the trial court found their “mutual
pattern of ongoing harassment” warranted mutual restraining
orders. The parties agreed; the court entered the orders.

1 All further unmarked statutory references are to the Code

of Civil Procedure.
Appellant promptly moved to vacate, arguing the court
lacked authority to issue mutual orders because respondent did
not file a cross-petition. Doing so, she asserted, contravened
section 527.6 and violated her due process rights. The court
denied the motion to vacate.
We will affirm the orders.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
Appellant worked at a doctor’s office where respondent
received acupuncture treatment. Respondent alleges appellant
began a romantic relationship with her husband around January
of 2022. This led to respondent and her husband divorcing.
Appellant sought a restraining order against respondent in
March of 2024. Her petition alleged respondent harassed her by,
among other things, stalking her home, filing false police reports,
and leaving defamatory voicemails at the doctor’s office where
she worked. Respondent accused appellant of similar behaviors.
She submitted a responsive declaration and a 45-page
compendium of exhibits but did not cross-petition for her own
restraining order against appellant.
Trial took place on March 22, 2024. The court entered
mutual restraining orders “based upon the request and
agreement of both parties.” Appellant moved to vacate the
mutual restraining orders on April 3. She argued the court
lacked authority to issue an order against her because
respondent did not cross-petition for relief. The trial court set the
hearing on the motion to vacate for July 31. It denied appellant’s
request to advance the hearing to an earlier date.
Respondent filed her own section 527.6 petition against
appellant on April 12, 2024. Appellant opposed the motion and
filed a notice of related cases. The court decided to take no action

2
on respondent’s petition because the March 22 mutual orders
were already in place.2
The court denied appellant’s motion to vacate in a written
ruling on August 23. It found appellant received a fair
opportunity to address respondent’s contentions against her.
“While not a cross-petition,” the court wrote, “[r]espondent’s
contentions that served as the basis for the order were set forth
in her response to the petition. The parties had a full trial on
their issues.” Appellant “expressly agreed to the mutual orders”
on March 22 after the court told the parties that “the evidence for
both sides evidenced a mutual pattern of ongoing harassment.”
While respondent did not initially cross-petition for her own
order, she eventually did so. Appellant was “aware of the content
and allegations of [r]espondent’s petition, because she filed a
notice of related action, opposed the requested order and
requested attorney fees.”
DISCUSSION
A party seeking a civil harassment restraining order must
petition for relief under section 527.6. The responding party
“may file a response that explains, excuses, justifies, or denies
the alleged harassment, or may file a cross-petition under this
section.” (§ 527.6, subd. (h).) The court may issue the order if it
finds clear and convincing evidence of “unlawful violence, a

2 It is not clear if the trial court held a hearing on

respondent’s section 527.6 petition. Appellant’s appendix
contains no order or reporter’s transcript from the scheduled
hearing date, i.e., April 26, 2024. The procedural summary
contained in the court’s August 23 ruling states: “4/25/24 –
Miscellaneous minute order issued by the Court in 24CV-0224
that mutual restraining orders were previously granted in 24CV-
0158 [i.e., this case], so the Court would take no action.”

3
credible threat of violence, or a knowing and willful course of
conduct directed at a specific person that seriously alarms,
annoys, or harasses the person, and that serves no legitimate
purpose.” (Id., subds. (a)(1), (b)(3) & (i); Schraer v. Berkeley
Property Owners’ Assn. (1989) 207 Cal.App.3d 719, 730.) A party
may appeal the court’s ruling as an “order granting or dissolving
an injunction, or refusing to grant or dissolve an injunction.”
(Code Civ. Proc., § 904.1, subd. (a)(6).)
Appellant contends the court lacked authority to issue
mutual restraining orders at the March 22, 2024 trial because
respondent had not yet petitioned for an order against appellant.
She also contends this violated her due process rights by
depriving her of notice and an opportunity to be heard. We
review these questions of law de novo. (See Harris v. Stampolis
(2016) 248 Cal.App.4th 484, 497 [whether a restraining order
“passes constitutional muster” is a question of law reviewed de
novo].) We review the trial court’s findings in support of the
restraining order’s entry for substantial evidence. (Ibid.)
Two cases anchor appellant’s arguments: Kobey v. Morton
(1991) 228 Cal.App.3d 1055 (Kobey) and Nora v. Kaddo (2004)
116 Cal.App.4th 1026 (Nora). In both, the trial court issued
mutual restraining orders even though respondents had not
cross-petitioned for relief. The Courts of Appeal reversed. Nora
quoted Kobey as follows: “‘[S]ection 527.6 calls for the formality
of a cross-complaint before the court imposes on the plaintiff
“what approximates a permanent injunction.” The court’s
inherent power does not extend so far as to encompass an order
without a petition to serve as a vehicle for that order.’” (Nora, at
p. 1029, quoting Kobey, at p. 1060.) We agree with this premise
but will not apply it here for two reasons.

4
First, the petitioners in Nora and Kobey immediately
objected to the trial court issuing mutual orders. Here, appellant
concedes she agreed to them at the March 22 hearing. The record
does not include a reporter’s transcript or minute order from this
date. The August 23 motion to vacate ruling, however, states the
court “held a full trial [on March 22] with testimony from both
[parties] and found clear and convincing evidence to issue a
restraining order against both parties.” The court then “inquired
of the parties if they would consider mutual restraining orders
due to the ongoing issues and allegations between them, and both
sides agreed.”
Second, Nora and Kobey did not involve a respondent who
promptly filed a prophylactic section 527.6 petition. Respondent
did so here on April 12—only three weeks after the court entered
the mutual orders. Appellant opposed this petition, sought
judicial notice of the March 22 orders, and filed a notice of related
cases. Both petitions were before the court when it heard the
motion to vacate on July 31. The August 23 ruling states the
court considered the evidence supporting the “various petitions”
and found it duplicative of that introduced at the first hearing.
Appellant thus received ample notice of the allegations against
her and at least two evidentiary hearings at which she was fully
aware of respondent’s allegations against her. The petitioner in
Nora, in contrast, received no evidentiary hearing at all. (Nora,
supra, 116 Cal.App.4th at pp. 1028-1029.)
The procedural infirmities that prompted Nora and Kobey
to reverse and vacate mutual restraining orders are not present
here. We agree with the trial court that appellant was “aware of
the content and allegations of [r]espondent’s petition” and that “a
further evidentiary hearing would generate the same evidence

5
and allegations the Court has previously considered.” While the
parties’ testimony at hearing is not contained in the record, their
declarations and exhibits are sufficient to support a finding that
each party engaged in “a knowing and willful course of conduct
directed at [the other party] that seriously alarms, annoys, or
harasses the person, and that serves no legitimate purpose.”
(§ 527.6, subd. (b)(3).)
DISPOSITION
The mutual restraining orders are affirmed. Respondent
did not appear and shall not recover costs on appeal.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.

CODY, J.

We concur:

GILBERT, P. J.

BALTODANO, J.

6
Tana L. Coates, Judge
Superior Court County of San Luis Obispo
______________________________

Sanger Law Firm, Sarah S. Sanger and Miguel A. Avila, for
Petitioner and Appellant.
No appearance for Respondent.

7

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.