CourtListener 10587429•People v. Thomas CA4/1
Texte intégral
Filed 5/20/25 P. v. Thomas CA4/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
COURT OF APPEAL, FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
THE PEOPLE, D082842
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v. (Super. Ct. No. SCD291326)
ADAM THOMAS,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of San Diego County,
Carlos O. Armour, Judge. Affirmed.
Mark A. Hart, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for
Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief Assistant
Attorney General, Charles C. Ragland, Assistant Attorney General,
Robin Urbanski and Laura Baggett, Deputy Attorneys General, for Plaintiff
and Respondent.
A jury convicted Adam Thomas of the first-degree murder (Pen. Code,
§ 187, subd. (a))1 of his brother, Trenton Thomas. The jury also found true
the allegation that Adam had personally used a dangerous and deadly
weapon—a crossbow—in the commission of the murder (§ 12022, subd.
(b)(1)). The trial court sentenced Adam to 25 years to life in state prison.
Adam contends on appeal that the trial court prejudicially erred when
it permitted the prosecution to impeach his trial testimony with inconsistent
statements he made about his brother’s death in an interview with law
enforcement officers after his arrest. Before making these statements during
the interrogation, Adam repeatedly requested assistance of counsel when
advised of his rights, but then he ultimately agreed to speak to the detectives
without an attorney. He argues that the statements were the product of
coercion by the detectives and therefore should have been excluded at trial.
After reviewing the video recorded interviews, we conclude that Adam’s
statements were voluntary and thus admissible at trial for purposes of
impeachment. We therefore affirm the judgment.2
1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Penal Code.
2 In Adam’s opening brief on appeal, he also argued the trial court erred
by modifying the then-current version of CALCRIM No. 510, which explains
the law relating to excusable homicide. On reply, however, Adam notes that
the Judicial Council Advisory Committee on Criminal Jury Instructions
revised CALCRIM No. 510 in September 2024 such that the instruction is
now substantially similar to the instruction used at his trial. Accordingly, he
no longer contends the trial court erred by modifying the 2022 version of the
instruction.
2
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A. The Prosecution’s Case
Adam grew up in Sacramento with his parents, Andrew and Tina, his
older sister, Chay, and his two older brothers, Beau and Trenton. Trenton
started using drugs when he was in high school and soon developed a
substance abuse issue. His substance abuse placed a lot of stress on his
family.
In the summer of 2021, Tina and Chay drove Trenton down to a sober
living facility in San Diego. In July 2021, Adam purchased a crossbow,
arrows, and hunting broadheads from Amazon. In August 2021, Adam told
his parents he was going to San Diego to visit colleges and visit Trenton.
Adam asked his mother to go with him, but she did not want to go.
Adam texted with Trenton before he arrived in San Diego on August 9,
2021. In text messages on August 8 and 9, Trenton initially told Adam not to
come visit him, but the two eventually agreed to meet for dinner the night of
August 9.
Later that night, Adam was captured on residential video surveillance
with another person in an alley near a skate park in San Diego. In the video,
a white vehicle, later confirmed to appear consistent with the color of and
markings on Adam’s car, is seen entering the alley. The video then shows
Adam walking back and forth between the front of his car, where the second
person was located, and the trunk of his car. He eventually retrieved an item
from the trunk.
After Adam walked back toward the front of his car, a sound consistent
with the firing of a crossbow can be heard on the video. The crossbow is not
visible. The second person then ran into the park eastbound. Immediately
afterwards, Adam can be seen on the video placing an object back into the
3
trunk of his car, getting into his car, and rapidly accelerating in reverse out of
the alley.
On August 10, 2021, a security guard found Trenton’s body in the skate
park and called police. Trenton appeared to have sustained traumatic
injuries, and his face was covered in blood. There was a 188-foot-long trail of
blood from the alley where Adam’s car had been seen on the surveillance
video to the location where Trenton’s body was found. The blood trail led to
larger pools of blood and a Headhunter-brand crossbow bolt and arrow, which
was found along the blood trail leading to the alley. The tip of the bolt was
missing. Police also found a blue bandana tied in a knot, as if it had been
used as a face covering or blindfold, in the alley.
On August 13, a park ranger recovered a crossbow in a tree at the end
of a trail into a canyon. The same park ranger also found a box of arrows and
a hat in a bag with the word “Sacramento” on it. The items were discovered
less than one mile from where Trenton’s body was found.
A medical examiner performed an autopsy of Trenton and found he had
an entry wound in front of his right ear and an exit wound through his left
ear canal. An arrow appeared to have traveled from right to left in a
horizontal pattern and slightly backwards from the front of the body towards
the back of the body. The medical examiner opined that the injuries were
“possibly” consistent with a bladed arrowhead being pulled back out of
Trenton’s head. The cause of death was a perforating crossbow arrow wound
to the head, which caused Trenton to experience significant blood loss and
heart failure. The medical examiner opined that the manner of death was
homicide, meaning that another person was involved in the death.
Police officers searched Adam’s apartment in Sacramento and
recovered a box for a crossbow and two boxes of broadheads—one of which
4
had been opened and was missing four out of the five heads—in his bedroom.
They also searched Adam’s car and found a Barnett-brand container used to
hold crossbow bolts behind the driver’s seat and a handwritten note with
directions from the crime scene to a location in Escondido. Police later
discovered that Adam had paid for a stay at an Airbnb in Escondido between
August 9 and August 10, 2021.
An archery shop owner with 20 years of experience testified about
crossbows and other types of bows. A crossbow is a very accurate and easy
weapon to shoot. Bolts, rather than arrows, are fired from crossbows. Bolts
have a bigger diameter and shorter length than arrows, and they come with
tips for target practice. Broadheads, on the other hand, are used for hunting.
They are essentially razorblades, and they are made for inflicting damage.
Crossbows are not allowed on public park ranges in San Diego County
because they are too hazardous due to their velocity and penetration.
The crossbow in this case appeared to require 165 pounds of pull. Once
the bolt is pulled all the way back, it goes into an automatic safety mode and
cannot be fired until the safety switch is moved into the fire position. The
safety mechanism is labeled green for safe and red for fire. It does not
require much force to move from safe mode to fire mode—the force of only one
finger would be sufficient. To fire, a person would have to step through the
bottom stirrup, hook the cocking device on each side of the rail, pull back
with both arms until they hear it click—meaning it is locked into safety
mode—then slowly let off tension from the trigger pull, load a bolt, bring the
crossbow to their shoulder, acquire the target, push the safety mechanism
into fire mode, and squeeze the trigger.
5
B. The Defense
Adam’s parents, sister, and brother testified in his defense. His
parents stated that he is not a violent person and would not have
intentionally killed Trenton. Adam’s father believed that what happened to
Trenton must have been an accident. He testified that Adam was a loving
and caring person not capable of murdering Trenton.
Adam also testified in his own defense. He purchased the crossbow for
Trenton as a birthday gift because he thought Trenton would think it was
cool and he liked to shoot things. He also purchased the hunting broadheads
because he wanted the arrows to look “really cool.” While Adam was still at
home, he opened the crossbow, put the pieces together, and shot it twice in
his backyard.
Before Adam left for San Diego to visit his brother, he placed the
cocked crossbow in the trunk with the bolts next to it. After arriving in
San Diego, Adam picked up his brother and they went to dinner. After
dinner, they walked down to the beach, where Adam told Trenton he had a
present for him that he wanted to show him at a skate park.
After they arrived at the park, Adam asked Trenton to put on a
blindfold before receiving his present, and the two continued having a casual
conversation. Trenton smoked a vape pen while Adam went to his trunk to
load the crossbow. He wanted to load it so that it would be ready for Trenton
to shoot it.
Adam recalled that Trenton was in a “baseball catcher” position,
squatting down, smoking, and looking at his phone when Adam walked back
to his trunk to get the crossbow. Adam put the bolt in the crossbow and
accidently flipped the safety switch off the crossbow. He explained: “[T]he
safety is green and the fire is red, which I completely messed up. . . . I
6
pictured safe as stop and as -- go as green. And as I was pulling it out of the
trunk, I flipped the -- I flipped the switch to -- to red, but I thought that was
flipping it to stop.” As Adam walked around his car, he tripped and fumbled
the crossbow, and as he grabbed it, his finger grabbed the trigger barrel
rather than the pistol grip, and the crossbow fired. Trenton fell to the
ground, and Adam “just lost it” and “freaked out.” Adam stood over his
brother for a second, and then Trenton got back up, which scared Adam.
Adam did not know what was happening and did not know what to do, so he
threw the crossbow in his car and left as quickly as possible. He did not
attempt to help his brother.
At some point after Adam started driving away, he hit a dead-end, took
the crossbow out and threw it “as hard as he could.” He drove back to the
Airbnb in Escondido and then ultimately drove back to his parents’ home in
Sacramento. He did not tell his family what had happened because he was
too scared and thought they would not understand. Adam testified that he
did not buy the crossbow or plan the trip to San Diego with the intent to
murder Trenton, did not have any reason to murder Trenton, and loved
Trenton more than anything in the world. He said Trenton’s death was an
accident, which he told police multiple times.
On cross-examination, the prosecutor asked Adam about statements he
made to detectives after his arrest that were inconsistent with his trial
testimony. The prosecutor played for the jury two video recordings of Adam’s
interview with detectives. During the interview, Adam told the detectives he
pointed the crossbow as if he was going to fire it before it went off. He told
the detectives that he was going to tap Trenton on the shoulder while
Trenton was facing away from Adam, removed his hand because it was in the
trigger chamber, and accidentally pulled the trigger with his finger as he did
7
so. Adam did not tell the detectives that he had tripped, and he agreed with
the prosecutor that the surveillance video did not show him tripping. Adam
also did not tell the detectives that Trenton had been in a crouching position,
as he had testified to on direct examination. On cross-examination, he
testified that Trenton had been crouching but moved to standing position as
Adam approached him. After driving away, Adam took the crossbow, arrows,
hat, and bag out of his car and threw them into a canyon. He admitted that
he had lied to his mom several times after the incident to “try and cover
[him]self up.”
C. The Prosecution’s Rebuttal
On rebuttal, the prosecutor called several witnesses to testify to Adam’s
reputation in the community. Adam’s two roommates, one of whom was his
former restaurant coworker, testified that Adam had a reputation for being a
violent and angry person. One roommate was scared for her safety living
with Adam, and the other personally believed Adam to be violent based on
the way Adam disciplined his dog. Adam’s restaurant manager also believed
Adam had a violent reputation for the last two months of his employment,
and he was concerned that Adam would hurt other coworkers.
D. Jury Verdict and Sentencing
The jury found Adam guilty of first-degree murder and found the use of
a weapon allegation true. The trial court denied Adam’s motion to reduce the
verdict to second-degree murder. The court struck the weapon enhancement
and sentenced Adam to prison for 25 years to life.
DISCUSSION
Adam contends the trial court erred by allowing the prosecutor to
impeach his trial testimony using statements he made to detectives during
custodial interrogation after he repeatedly requested the assistance of
8
counsel. Based on our independent review, we conclude that these
statements were voluntarily made and therefore admissible for purposes of
impeachment.
A. Additional Factual Background
San Diego Police Detectives Wade Irwin and Steven Choy interviewed
Adam in Sacramento after his arrest on August 14, 2021. The interview was
recorded on video. After asking Adam basic informational questions,
Detective Irwin showed Adam photographs of the crime scene where Trenton
was killed and stated that police had recovered a crossbow they believed was
used to kill Trenton. Detective Irwin told Adam: “I’ve been a police officer 14
years. Um, what I’ve learned over my career is that people make mistakes.
And when they make mistakes, the best thing to do is to admit your mistake
and ask for forgiveness. [Because] this is all gonna come out in court. We
have a lot of evidence. That’s why we’re here talking to you. And your family
is gonna have to go to court. Your parents are gonna have to go to court.
Something happened. I don’t know why. But I’d like to talk to you and find
out what’s going on, okay. So, let me read you your rights.”
Detective Irwin then read Adam his rights under Miranda v. Arizona
(1966) 384 U.S. 436 (Miranda rights) and the two had the following
exchange: “Irwin: Yes? Having in mind and understanding your rights as I’ve
told you, are you willing to talk to me? [¶] [Adam]: I’d like to have a ret -- a
attorney present. [¶] Irwin: Okay, that is your right. Um, just so you know,
you’re gonna be -- you’re gonna be booked in for murder of your brother
Trenton. So, you will be going to jail today. [¶] [Adam]: Oh, okay. [¶]
Irwin: Um, and we’ll call your parents and let you kn -- let them know all
that. But, uh, I’m gonna leave you my card. I don’t -- I’m sure you have a
property -- I’ll leave it in your property bag, in case you change your mind
9
and you want to talk to me, we’ve been in contact with your attorney and all
that stuff. [¶] [Adam]: Is talking to you the way that, like, the steps to get
out of jail, or is that usually after trial and stuff like that? [¶] Irwin: I can’t
give you legal advice. But, um, if you want -- at this time, if you want to tell
me your side of the story -- [¶] [Adam]: I’ll tell you. I’ll tell you. [¶]
Irwin: W -- well hold on. I need to -- I need to -- I need to be clear here, okay.
[¶] [Adam]: Yeah. [¶] Irwin: Okay. So, I’m gonna read you your rights
again, and if you want to tell me your side of the story, we can do that.
[Adam]: Okay.”
Detective Irwin then advised Adam of his Miranda rights a second time
and asked: “Having in mind and understanding your rights as I’ve told you,
do you want to talk to me? [¶] [Adam]: I’m sorry. I’m very nervous. I think
I -- I’d still like the attorney. [¶] Irwin: Okay. Um, like I said, if you want to
tell me your side of the story -- because I wasn’t there, right. All I’m going off
of is evidence that we have. [¶] [Adam]: Yeah. [¶] Irwin: If you want to tell
me your side of the story, I need to hear it from you. [¶] [Adam]: Yeah. [¶]
Irwin: I can’t hear it from anybody else. So, this is your chance to tell me
that. [¶] [Adam]: I think I’d like to talk to my attorney first. [¶] Irwin:
Okay. Alright, that’s fine. If you want to change your mind before we go to
jail, you can do that. [¶] [Adam]: Okay. [¶] Irwin: Okay. [¶] [Adam]: Okay.
[¶] Irwin: Alright. I’m gonna leave you my card here. It might go in your
property bag, but, um -- [¶] [Adam]: So -- so, I’m going to be going to jail and
then just waiting for my attorney there, and -- [¶] Irwin: You’re gonna be
going to the jail, and then you’ll go through the legal process of, um, going
back to San Diego, extradition, all that stuff. [¶] [Adam]: I -- am I going to
jail in San Diego? [¶] Irwin: You’re going to jail here today, and eventually,
you’ll be brought back to San Diego [because] that’s where the crime
10
occurred. [¶] [Adam]: Okay. [¶] Irwin: Okay? Like I said, um, I want you to
think about this because, uh, your family deserves some closure to figure
out -- and the -- and, you know, the -- you might have a good reason why this
happened. But right now there’s a lot of unanswered questions, but we have
enough evidence to put you in. Something happened, but I need to know your
side of the story. And I’m sure you’re wanting your side of the story out
there. Maybe you had a good reason for all this but -- unless we hear it from
you, then we’re never gonna know, right. That’s not fair. You’re -- you’re 20
years old, right? [¶] [Adam]: Yeah. [¶] Irwin: You have your whole rest of
your life, you know. Obviously, you made a big mistake, but it’s not the end
of the world. But you need the -- like I said, the best thing to do sometimes is
when you (unintelligible) you’ve heard that all your life. When you’re a kid,
like, ‘Hey, if you make a mistake, just admit it and just ask for forgiveness.’
Okay. So think about that stuff. Alright? [¶] [Adam]: Yeah. [¶] Irwin:
Alright. [¶] [Adam]: Um, I mean, I guess -- I guess you can read me my
rights one last time and then I’ll tell you. [¶] Irwin: Okay. Okay. You have
the right to remain silent. If you give up the right to remain silent, anything
you say can and will be used in court against you. You have the right to
speak with an attorney of your choice before questioning and to have the
attorney present during questioning. If you cannot afford an attorney, one
will be appointed for you by the court prior to any questioning if you so
desire. The attorney will not cost you anything. The services are free. Do
you understand each of these rights that I explained to you? [¶] [Adam]:
Yes. [¶] Irwin: Having in mind and understanding your rights as I have told
you, are you willing to talk to me? [¶] [Adam]: Yes.”
Adam then told the detectives his version of the events leading up to
Trenton’s death.
11
Before trial, Adam moved to suppress his statements to the detectives,
arguing that (1) they were obtained in violation of his Miranda rights
because the detectives failed to honor his repeated requests for counsel, and
(2) they were obtained by coercive methods. In response, the prosecutor
argued that the Miranda issue was moot because she did not intend to
introduce Adam’s statements in the People’s case-in-chief, but she should be
permitted to use the statements for impeachment because they were not
coerced or involuntary.
After reviewing the video recorded interrogation, the trial court agreed
that Adam’s statements were voluntary, and the prosecutor could therefore
use them for impeachment purposes if Adam testified. The court found that
there was no coercive police conduct, and Adam was merely debating in his
own mind whether he wanted an attorney after being given his Miranda
warnings and having them repeated twice more. The detective was honest
with Adam when he said they had enough to charge him with murder, and he
was going to be charged, taken into custody, and transported to San Diego.
The detectives made no express or implied threats either to him or his family,
and the discussion was not confrontational. The court considered Adam’s age
and his condition during the interview, finding that he did not appear
distraught, he was not crying, he was not deprived of food or sleep, the
interview was short, and it did not take place immediately after he found out
his brother was dead, but several days later. The detectives did not threaten
any increased punishment or promise any leniency. Although the detectives
encouraged Adam to tell the truth and commented on the realities of his
situation, the court found that these statements were not coercive.
The prosecution did not use Adam’s statements to the detectives in its
case-in-chief. As described above, however, the prosecutor on cross-
12
examination impeached Adam with several of these statements, which were
inconsistent with his trial testimony.
B. Analysis
Involuntary statements obtained by coercion by law enforcement from a
criminal suspect are inadmissible under the federal Constitution and
California Constitution. (People v. Peoples (2016) 62 Cal.4th 718, 740
(Peoples).) To determine the voluntariness of a statement made during
custodial interrogation, the key question is whether the defendant’s choice to
make the statement “was not ‘ “ ‘essentially free’ ” ’ because his will was
overborne by the coercive practices of his interrogator.” (People v. Spencer
(2018) 5 Cal.5th 642, 672 (Spencer); see also Peoples, at p. 740.) This
determination does not turn on any specific fact, but rather on the totality of
the circumstances. (Peoples, at p. 740.) Courts consider “several factors,
including any element of police coercion, the length of the interrogation and
its location and continuity, and the defendant’s maturity, education, and
physical and mental health.” (Ibid.; see also People v. Caro (2019) 7 Cal.5th
463, 492 (Caro).) Where, as here, the interview was recorded and the facts
surrounding the giving of the statements are undisputed, we independently
review the trial court’s determination of voluntariness. (Peoples, at p. 740.)
Statements taken by law enforcement in violation of Miranda are
inadmissible in the prosecutor’s case-in-chief, but they can still be used for
impeachment purposes if the defendant testifies, so long as the statements
were voluntary. (Caro, supra, 7 Cal.5th at p. 492; see also People v. Coffman
and Marlow (2004) 34 Cal.4th 1, 55 [“Although a statement obtained in
violation of Miranda may not be introduced by the prosecution in its case-in-
chief, Miranda was not intended to grant the suspect license to lie in his or
her testimony at trial, and thus if an ensuing statement obtained in violation
13
of Miranda is voluntary, the statement nonetheless may be admitted to
impeach a defendant who testifies differently at trial.”].)
Adam contends the trial court erred in finding his statements
voluntary because the detectives questioning him used coercive tactics both
to secure a waiver of his Miranda rights and to continue eliciting admissions
from him throughout the interrogation. Specifically, Adam argues that his
statements were involuntary because the detectives continued urging him to
talk after he invoked his right to counsel three times, did not conduct the
interview in a calm manner, used aggressive tones and subtle psychological
tactics, implied that lack of cooperation would result in harsh punishment,
implied that he would not have assistance of counsel, wore him down to the
point of feeling helpless, and suggested that he write apology letters to his
brother and other family members.
We have independently reviewed the video and transcripts of Adam’s
interview with the detectives, and we conclude that the detectives’ interview
tactics do not rise to the level of coercion required to find that Adam’s will
was overborne. First, although the detectives repeatedly urged Adam to tell
the truth and tell his “side of the story,” it was not coercive for them to do so.
The Supreme Court has held that “when law enforcement officers describe
the moral or psychological advantages to the accused of telling the truth, no
implication of leniency or favorable treatment at the hands of the authorities
arises.” (People v. Carrington (2009) 47 Cal.4th 145, 172 [defendant’s
statements were voluntary]; see also People v. Linton (2013) 56 Cal.4th 1146,
1178 [nothing coercive in police officers urging defendant to tell the truth and
informing him that the sooner he told the truth, the sooner the interview
would finish].)
14
We also disagree with Adam’s contention that the detectives
“threatened him” during the interrogation. The detectives did not engage in
any abusive tactics, “[n]or was the tone of the questioning . . . particularly
harsh or accusatory,” contrary to Adam’s assertion. (See People v. Jablonski
(2006) 37 Cal.4th 774, 816.) As in Peoples, supra, 62 Cal.4th 718, where the
Supreme Court also concluded the defendant’s statements were voluntary,
“[t]he detectives asked defendant questions designed to build rapport but
never offered him leniency for his confession and never threatened a harsher
penalty if he remained silent.” (Peoples, at p. 741.) The detectives here also
did not “threaten” Adam with jail, as he argued to the trial court. Rather,
they made clear they had enough evidence to take him into custody and that
Adam would be going to jail that day regardless of whether he agreed to
speak to the detectives.
As to the other relevant factors courts consider when determining
voluntariness, we agree with the trial court’s factual findings. Neither the
length nor physical circumstances of Adam’s interview appear to have been
coercive. The interview was short. From the time the detectives entered the
room until the time they stopped the interrogation, offered Adam a bathroom
break, and left the room, less than 90 minutes elapsed. And although Adam
was only 20 years old at the time of the interrogation, there is nothing about
his age, education, or physical or mental health that appear to warrant a
finding of involuntariness. He “gave coherent, responsive answers” during
the interrogation and, while he stated he was very nervous, he “did not
appear excessively fearful or distressed.” (Spencer, supra, 5 Cal.5th at p. 673;
id. at p. 674 [concluding that complained-of interrogation tactics, which
included “ ‘repeated expressions that appellant was lying, an implication that
the death penalty would be imposed, fabricated evidence against appellant,
15
and implied promises of leniency,’ ” did not amount to coercion].) There were
no threats of harsh punishment or promises of leniency, and the detectives
clearly communicated that they were willing to honor Adam’s decision if he
wished to remain silent.
Based on these facts, and our independent review of the video recording
of Adam’s statements to the detectives, we conclude that the trial court did
not err in admitting Adam’s statements as impeachment evidence.
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.
BUCHANAN, J.
WE CONCUR:
IRION, Acting P. J.
RUBIN, J.
16
Vous vous demandez comment ce texte s’applique à votre situation ?
Consultation gratuite, sans engagement
Décrivez votre situation. Notre équipe vous recontactera par e-mail pour votre consultation.
Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude
Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.