Esquer v. Hong Holdings CA2/5

CourtListener 10587381Calctapp20 mai 2025

Texte intégral

Filed 5/20/25 Esquer v. Hong Holdings CA2/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on
opinions not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule
8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or ordered published for
purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION FIVE

RICARDO ESQUER, B339194

Plaintiff and Respondent, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No.
v. 24AVCV00130)

HONG HOLDINGS, LLC et al.,

Defendants and Appellants.

APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Stephen T. Morgan, Judge. Affirmed.
Pettit Kohn Ingrassia Lutz & Dolin, Ryan H. Nell, Alysha
R. Zapata, and Annie F. Fraser for Defendants and Appellants.
Sparrow Law Group, Joubin Hanassab, and Nikka Maleki
for Plaintiff and Respondent.
We consider whether the trial court erred in denying a
motion to compel arbitration filed by defendants and appellants1
based on the court’s finding that they did not carry their burden
to prove the existence of a valid arbitration agreement with
plaintiff and respondent Ricardo Esquer (plaintiff). The issue
comes down to whether the court’s doubts about the authenticity
of the purported agreement were justified.

I. BACKGROUND
Plaintiff, who began working as a truck driver at Conico in
2018, sued defendants after they terminated his employment in
2023. His operative complaint pleads eleven causes of action
including harassment, retaliation for making complaints about
harassment and for whistleblowing, wrongful termination,
various Labor Code violations, and other employment-related
torts.
Defendants moved to compel arbitration of the dispute.
They contended Esquer signed an agreement during his
onboarding process that mandated arbitration of all claims or
controversies arising out of his recruitment, employment, or
termination of employment. Defendants attached the purported
arbitration agreement to their motion, and the document bears
the handwritten, printed names of Ricardo Esquer and M.
Goldberg, signatures beneath those names, and handwritten
April 11, 2018, dates beneath the signatures.
Defendants also filed a declaration by Michael Goldberg in
support of their motion to compel arbitration. Goldberg declared

1
They are Hong Holdings dba Conico Wholesale, LLC
(Conico), Mike Goldberg (Goldberg), John Yu, and Larry Grand.
We shall refer to them collectively as “defendants.”

2
he was responsible for onboarding new drivers in 2018.
According to Goldberg, he “conducted the onboarding process
when Ricardo Esquer (“Plaintiff”) was hired at Conico on April
26, 2018 [sic] in the position of Class A Truck Driver.” Goldberg
averred that “[d]uring the in-person onboarding process, [he]
presented Plaintiff with approximately 25 pages of document[s]
overall, including various policies. The Arbitration Agreement
was presented in the packet of 25 documents [sic].” Goldberg
further declared that “Plaintiff hand-signed the Arbitration
Agreement during his onboarding process,” “[t]he purpose of the
Arbitration Agreement was verbally expressed to Plaintiff during
the onboarding process,” plaintiff did not ask any questions
during onboarding or after signing the arbitration agreement,
and plaintiff was given a copy of the Arbitration Agreement and
“was provided with the opportunity to review it with an
attorney.”
Plaintiff opposed defendants’ motion to compel arbitration.
He argued defendants had not established the existence of an
authentic agreement to arbitrate because plaintiff disputed he
signed such an agreement and Goldberg’s declaration did not
authenticate the purported arbitration agreement attached to
defendants’ motion to compel. Plaintiff emphasized Goldberg
necessarily lacked the requisite personal knowledge to
authenticate the document because his declaration stated the
onboarding process occurred on April 26 while the arbitration
agreement attached to defendants’ motion was dated two weeks
earlier, i.e., April 11. Relatedly, plaintiff argued Goldberg also
had no personal knowledge of whether an arbitration agreement
was included in a packet given to plaintiff during the onboarding

3
process, whether plaintiff signed it, or whether its purpose was
explained to plaintiff.
Plaintiff submitted a declaration in support of his
opposition. He declared that on April 11, 2018, he had a meeting
with Goldberg in which Goldberg verbally offered plaintiff the
position of truck driver for Conico. When plaintiff accepted the
offer, Goldberg presented him with a packet of pre-printed
documents and said something to the effect of, “sign these now
and you’re good.” Plaintiff attested there were immigration
verification and tax forms in the packet of documents, but he
averred he did not recall seeing or signing an arbitration
agreement. Plaintiff further declared that he had reviewed the
arbitration document attached to the motion to compel
arbitration and recognized neither the document nor the
signature on it that purported to be his (he explained it “d[id] not
look like [his] usual signature.”) Plaintiff also maintained he was
not provided with a copy of a signed arbitration agreement, either
in person or by email, and neither Goldberg nor anyone else ever
explained to plaintiff what arbitration was. According to
plaintiff, Goldberg told him he would start work at Conico on
April 26, 2018. Plaintiff did not receive or sign any additional
paperwork on that day, and Goldberg was not present when
plaintiff reported to work that day.
Defendants filed a reply to plaintiff’s opposition, but their
reply was not accompanied by any additional declarations or
evidence.
The trial court held a hearing on defendants’ motion to
compel arbitration in May 2024. There is no reporter’s transcript
of the hearing in the appellate record, but the trial court issued a
five-page “statement of decision” following that hearing

4
explaining its reasons for denying the motion to compel
arbitration.
The trial court found arbitration was not required because
there was no valid, authenticated arbitration agreement. In
particular, the court highlighted the contradiction between
Goldberg’s statement that plaintiff signed the arbitration
agreement when Goldberg “conducted the onboarding process
when [plaintiff] was hired at Conico on April 26, 2018” and the
document itself bearing signatures dated April 11, 2018.

II. DISCUSSION
The record supports the trial court’s finding that
defendants did not carry their burden to prove the existence of a
valid arbitration agreement. The trial court reasonably
determined that defendants’ evidence of the existence of such an
agreement (the document attached to their motion and the
Goldberg declaration) did not suffice even on its own, and
especially when considered against plaintiff’s countervailing
evidence. The proffered arbitration agreement was signed and
dated on April 11, 2018, which was inconsistent with Goldberg’s
declaration that plaintiff signed the agreement two weeks later
during a meeting where Goldberg purportedly explained
arbitration to him. (Indeed, when confronted with the
inconsistency by plaintiff’s opposition to the motion to compel
arbitration, defendants did not even attempt to explain it away in
a supplemental declaration.) Plaintiff, on the other hand,
without contradiction declared he did not recall receiving or
signing an arbitration agreement and the signature on the
purported agreement attached to defendants’ motion did not look
like his usual signature. That evidentiary picture fully justifies

5
the trial court’s finding that there was no valid agreement to
arbitrate.

A. Legal Background and Appellate Review
A “party seeking arbitration has the burden of proving the
existence of an arbitration agreement by a preponderance of the
evidence.” (Ramirez v. Golden Queen Mining Company, LLC
(2024) 102 Cal.App.5th 821, 829.) “Although the party seeking
arbitration bears the ultimate burden of proof as to the existence
of an arbitration agreement, the burden of producing evidence on
the issue may shift pursuant to a three-step process recognized
by California courts. [Citations.] The first step requires the
party seeking arbitration to carry the initial burden of presenting
prima facie evidence of a written agreement to arbitrate the
controversy. [Citations.] If that initial burden is met, the second
step requires the party opposing arbitration to carry the burden
of producing evidence to challenge the authenticity of the
agreement. [Citation.] If the opposing party meets the burden of
producing sufficient evidence, the third step requires the party
seeking arbitration to prove by a preponderance of the evidence
that the parties formed a valid contract to arbitrate their dispute.
[Citation.]” (Id. at 830.)
“There is no uniform standard of review for evaluating a
trial court’s order granting or denying a motion to compel
arbitration. [Citation.]” (Herzog v. Superior Court (2024) 101
Cal.App.5th 1280, 1294.) We ordinarily review an order denying
a petition to compel arbitration for abuse of discretion (absent a
pure question of law), but if an order turns on resolution of a
factual issue, we review for substantial evidence. (Espejo v.
Southern California Permanente Medical Group (2016) 246

6
Cal.App.4th 1047, 1056-1057; Robertson v. Health Net of
California, Inc. (2005) 132 Cal.App.4th 1419, 1425.)

B. The Trial Court Did Not Err in Finding No Valid
Agreement to Arbitrate
Defendants’ evidence of an agreement to arbitrate was
defective from the outset. The purported arbitration agreement
is dated April 11, 2018, but Goldberg’s declaration unequivocally
represents plaintiff agreed to arbitration by signing a document
on another date two weeks later. Here, verbatim, is what
Goldberg avers under penalty of perjury: “5. I conducted the
onboarding process when [plaintiff] was hired at Conico on April
26, 2018, in the position of Class A Truck Driver. [¶] 6. During
the in-person onboarding process, I presented [p]laintiff with
approximately 25 pages of document[s] overall, including various
policies. The Arbitration Agreement was presented in the packet
of 25 documents [sic]. The entire onboarding process took
approximately two hours. [¶] 7. Plaintiff hand-signed the
Arbitration Agreement during his onboarding process. A true
and correct copy of [p]laintiff’s signed Arbitration Agreement is
attached hereto as Exhibit 1. [Emphasis omitted] [¶] 8. The
purpose of the Arbitration Agreement was verbally expressed to
[p]laintiff during the onboarding process.” Because Goldberg
represents plaintiff signed an arbitration agreement during the
two-hour onboarding process on April 26, 2018, and the document
attached to his declaration as that agreement is dated two weeks
before that, even defendants’ own evidence does not establish the

7
proffered arbitration agreement was signed by plaintiff.2 And
that, of course, means there is no proof of a valid agreement that
justifies compelling arbitration. (AT&T Technologies, Inc. v.
Communications Workers of America (1986) 475 U.S. 643, 648
[“arbitration is a matter of contract and a party cannot be
required to submit to arbitration any dispute which he has not
agreed so to submit”]; Rosenthal v. Great Western Fin. Securities
Corp. (1996) 14 Cal.4th 394, 413.)
Considering the evidence submitted by plaintiff only
reinforces this conclusion. Plaintiff declared he did not recall
receiving or signing an arbitration agreement; he reviewed the
arbitration document attached to the motion to compel
arbitration and did not recognize it; and the signature near his
name on that document did not look like his usual signature.
Plaintiff also maintained he would not have left his prior
employment to work for Conico if he knew doing so would require
him to sign a document that rendered him unable to file a lawsuit
and have a jury trial. And plaintiff stated he did not receive any
additional paperwork or explanation about arbitration on his first
day of work, a day on which Goldberg was not present. That—
and the lack of any evidentiary response from defendants—only
confirms the trial court’s finding is well justified. (See, e.g.,

2
Defendants argue here, as they unsuccessfully argued in
the trial court, that Goldberg’s declaration is merely “unartfully
written” and does not say the onboarding occurred on April 26,
2018. That is wrong; we have reproduced what Goldberg says,
and he says he conducted the onboarding process “when” plaintiff
was hired “on” April 26, 2018. Defendants also do not explain
why, if it truly was merely a drafting issue, they never even
attempted to submit evidence clarifying or explaining the
“unartful writ[ing].”

8
Navas v. Fresh Venture Foods, LLC (2022) 85 Cal.App.5th 626,
631-632 [sufficient evidence supported trial court’s finding that
plaintiffs did not sign arbitration agreement where plaintiffs
averred they did not recall seeing the arbitration agreement
before and did not “recognize” the signature on the document as
their own].)

DISPOSITION
The order denying the motion to compel arbitration is
affirmed. Plaintiff is awarded costs on appeal.

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

BAKER, Acting P. J.

We concur:

MOOR, J.

KIM (D.), J.

9

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.