Saenz v. Eurostar CA2/5

CourtListener 10581740Calctapp9 mai 2025

Texte intégral

Filed 5/9/25 Saenz v. Eurostar CA2/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION FIVE

JUDDY SAENZ, B333851

Plaintiff and Respondent, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No.
v. 22STCV39723)

EUROSTAR, INC.,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of
Los Angeles County, Theresa Traber, Judge. Affirmed.
Manatt, Phelps & Phillips, Andrew L. Satenberg, Ryan P.
Patterson and Benjamin G. Shatz for Defendant and Appellant.
Bartz Law Group and Aaron A. Bartz for Plaintiff and
Respondent.
________________________
Defendant and appellant Eurostar, Inc., (Eurostar) appeals
from an order denying a motion to compel arbitration entered in
favor of plaintiff and respondent Juddy Saenz in this
representative action for violation of wage and hour laws under
the Private Attorneys General Act of 2004 (PAGA; Labor Code,
§ 2698 et seq.). On appeal, Eurostar contends: (1) the trial court
erred by concluding Eurostar failed to meet its burden to show
the existence of an arbitration agreement by a preponderance of
the evidence, (2) the agreement was not unconscionable, and (3)
any unconscionable provisions should have been severed. We
conclude the record is inadequate to review Eurostar’s
contentions because it does not include a reporter’s transcript or
suitable substitute for the hearing on the motion to compel
arbitration. Even if we were to find the record adequate for
review, however, we would conclude substantial evidence
supports the trial court’s finding that Eurostar failed to show the
existence of an arbitration agreement by a preponderance of the
evidence, and therefore, we affirm.

FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND1

On January 14, 2022, Eurostar hired Saenz as an assistant
store manager. In or around February 2022, Saenz came into the
office and the store manager walked her through the new hire
process. The manager asked for Saenz’s contact information,

1 The facts are stated in the light most favorable to the
judgment in accordance with the standard of review. (Slone v. El
Centro Regional Medical Center (2024) 106 Cal.App.5th 1160,
1173.)

2
including her address, social security number, and other
identification. The manager entered the information into her
computer, which Saenz did not have access to. The new hire
process took approximately 30 minutes. The manager filled out
the documents for Saenz’s new hire, including a W-4 tax
withholding form. Saenz was never provided with any
documents to sign whatsoever. She does not remember the
manager mentioning or explaining an arbitration agreement, and
she does not recall signing an arbitration agreement. At no time
in the new hire process was it explained that she would be
waiving the right to pursue any claims in court. If she had been
made aware of the existence of an arbitration agreement and had
the provisions, including the waiver to bring claims in court, been
explained, Saenz would not have agreed to be subject to such an
agreement.
There was no opportunity to negotiate any terms of the new
hire documents that the manager had on her computer. None of
the documents were explained, and Saenz was given no time to
review or consider them. She was told that if she wanted to work
for Eurostar, she needed to agree to the documents. Saenz was
also never given copies of the documents that the manager filled
out during the new hire process and had on her computer. She
was never given information about the arbitration rules, or
provided with a copy of the rules or where to locate them.
Eurostar terminated Saenz’s employment on August 26,
2022. On December 21, 2022, Saenz filed an action against
Eurostar alleging a single PAGA claim for violation of wage and
hour laws, requesting a jury trial.
On May 22, 2023, Eurostar filed a motion to compel
arbitration. Eurostar submitted a three-page arbitration

3
agreement. A typewritten note appears at the bottom of page one
and two stating: “Signed by: Juddy Saenz, 02/02/0222.” On the
third page, at the end of the agreement, the typewritten
statement, “Juddy Saenz, 02/02/2022”, appears above the place
for the “Employee Signature”.
Eurostar submitted the declaration of Senior Director of
Human Resources Marie Lopez Mackay concerning Eurostar’s
pattern and practice, although Mackay did not have any personal
knowledge about whether Saenz signed the arbitration
agreement.
On September 26, 2023, Saenz opposed the motion to
compel arbitration. She argued that Eurostar could not show an
arbitration agreement existed, because Mackay had no personal
knowledge and merely concluded that Saenz executed the
agreement. There was no evidence that the printed “electronic
signature” was an act of Saenz. In addition, Saenz argued that
the arbitration agreement was procedurally and substantively
unconscionable, and the unconscionable provisions could not be
severed. Saenz submitted her declaration in support of the
opposition, attesting to the facts described above.
On October 2, 2023, Eurostar filed a reply. In the event the
trial court was inclined to deny the motion based on Saenz’s
version of the facts, Eurostar requested an evidentiary hearing.
Eurostar submitted the declaration of Human Resources
Information Systems Manager Desiree Macias in support of the
reply. Macias stated that Eurostar requires new employees to
consent to an arbitration agreement, which they review and sign
electronically through the human resources platform. To access
the arbitration agreement, an employee must register an account
on the human resources platform using their employee

4
identification number as their username and selecting a unique
password. No other employee or manager has access to, or can
change, an employee’s password for the platform. Macias did not
explain, however, whether any other employee or manager has
access to Saenz’s account.
Macias further declared that there was a new employee
checklist in the human resources platform. An employee must
click through each document in its entirety, and electronically
initial and sign the documents, including the arbitration
agreement. The human resources platform logs the date and
time of completion.
The human resources platform showed Saenz’s account was
registered on January 26, 2022, and thirteen new hire documents
were signed electronically between 4:33 p.m. and 4:43 p.m. that
day; the signed documents did not, however, include the
arbitration agreement. Seventeen remaining documents were
signed electronically on February 2, 2022, between 2:46 p.m. and
3:11 p.m., including the arbitration agreement, and the new hire
checklist was completed. Form I-9, as well as federal and state
withholding forms, were among the documents completed on
February 2, 2022.
Eurostar also submitted the declaration of store manager
Nieves Baltazar with its reply in support of the motion to compel
arbitration. Baltazar stated that Saenz came into the store on
January 26, 2022, for an onboarding meeting to integrate her as
a new employee. The meeting was held in the store’s back office
using the store’s on-site computer. Baltazar assisted Saenz in
registering her account on the human resources platform. Saenz
selected a password, which she did not disclose to Baltazar.
Baltazar guided her to the new hire checklist of onboarding

5
documents to electronically review and sign. Baltazar asked for
Saenz’s social security number and to see her driver’s license to
fill out the employer portion of the tax verification form.
Baltazar stated that she left the back office so Saenz could review
and sign the documents. There was a technical issue where
onboarding documents were not displaying as complete on the
human resources end. Baltazar ended the onboarding meeting
and informed Saenz that she would have to come back to
complete the onboarding. On February 2, 2022, Eurostar’s
service desk department contacted Baltazar to let her know the
technical issue was resolved, and human resources personnel
confirmed that onboarding documents signed on January 26,
2022, were showing as completed. Baltazar contacted Saenz, who
returned to the store, reviewed and signed the remaining
onboarding documents, and completed the new hire checklist.
Baltazar declared that Saenz personally reviewed and signed the
new hire onboarding documents. Baltazar did not review or sign
any of Saenz’s documents, nor has she ever done so for any
employee.
After a hearing on October 9, 2023, the trial court took the
matter under submission. No reporter’s transcript of the hearing
has been made part of the appellate record. On October 20, 2023,
the trial court issued an order denying the motion to compel
arbitration. The court found Mackay’s declaration offered no
basis to conclude the electronic signature on the arbitration
agreement was authentic. The court noted Macias described the
human resources platform and stated an employee creates a
unique password, and that no other employee or manager has
access to the password; but Macias did not state that no other
employee or manager has access to the employee’s account. The

6
court was not persuaded that Eurostar met its burden to
establish the existence of an arbitration agreement between the
parties.
The court stated, “Although [Eurostar] has provided
evidence that the arbitration agreement was signed using
[Saenz’s] account on February 2, 2022 with other employment
documents, [Eurostar] has not established that [Saenz] herself
signed the agreement. The only witnesses to the February 2,
2022 onboarding session were [Saenz] and Nieves Baltazar, and
the onboarding was conducted using a store computer that
[Saenz] did not have regular access to. Moreover, while [Saenz]
described the events of that onboarding session, the Baltazar
declaration only provides a vague statement that she signed the
remaining documents. Given the competing accounts and the
circumstances surrounding the completion of these materials, the
Court is not satisfied that [Eurostar] has properly authenticated
[Saenz’s] electronic signature. Therefore, [Eurostar] has not
established an arbitration agreement between the parties.”
In addition, even if Eurostar could show Saenz signed an
arbitration agreement, the trial court stated it would refuse to
enforce the agreement as unconscionable. The agreement was
procedurally unconscionable because it was a contract of
adhesion, buried as a surprise in a large group of documents, and
Eurostar failed to provide the arbitration rules. The court
identified multiple terms that the court found to be substantively
unconscionable as well. The court exercised its discretion to
refuse to sever the deficient terms. Based on these findings, the
court denied the motion to compel arbitration.
Eurostar filed a timely notice of appeal from the order
denying the motion to compel arbitration.

7
DISCUSSION

A. Standard of Review and Inadequacy of the Appellate
Record

In ruling on a motion to compel arbitration, the trial court
determines the facts. (Fleming v. Oliphant Financial, LLC
(2023) 88 Cal.App.5th 13, 18 (Fleming).) Where the material
facts are undisputed, we review the order de novo. (Ibid; Diaz v.
Sohnen Enterprises (2019) 34 Cal.App.5th 126, 129 (Diaz).) If the
facts are in dispute, however, we review the record to evaluate
whether substantial evidence supports the trial court’s order.
(Fleming, supra, 88 Cal.App.5th at p. 18.) “ ‘Under the
deferential substantial evidence standard of review, findings of
fact are liberally construed to support the judgment or order and
we consider the evidence in the light most favorable to the
prevailing party, drawing all reasonable inferences in support of
the findings. [Citation.] “A single witness’s testimony may
constitute substantial evidence to support a finding. [Citation.]
It is not our role as a reviewing court to reweigh the evidence or
to assess witness credibility. [Citation.]” ’ ” (Bruno v. Hopkins
(2022) 79 Cal.App.5th 801, 823.)
A judgment or order of the lower court is presumed to be
correct; the appellant has the burden of overcoming this
presumption by affirmatively showing error on appeal by an
adequate record. (Ketchum v. Moses (2001) 24 Cal.4th 1122,
1140–1141.) Under California Rules of Court, rule 8.120(b), “[i]f
an appellant intends to raise any issue that requires
consideration of the oral proceedings in the superior court, the

8
record on appeal must include a record of these oral proceedings
in the form of one of the following: [¶] (1) A reporter’s transcript
under rule 8.130; [¶] (2) An agreed statement under rule 8.134; or
[¶] (3) A settled statement under rule 8.137.”
“Without the proper record, we cannot evaluate issues
requiring a factual analysis. The evidence is presumed sufficient
to support the judgment.” (Pringle v. La Chapelle (1999) 73
Cal.App.4th 1000, 1003.) “Where no reporter’s transcript has
been provided and no error is apparent on the face of the existing
appellate record, the judgment must be conclusively presumed
correct as to all evidentiary matters. To put it another way, it is
presumed that the unreported trial testimony would demonstrate
the absence of error.” (Estate of Fain (1999) 75 Cal.App.4th 973,
992.)
In this case, without a reporter’s transcript of the
proceedings at the hearing on the motion to compel arbitration,
we cannot evaluate any evidence presented or offers of proof
made to the trial court, and we do not know what arguments,
objections, or concessions were made by the parties, including
any discussion bearing on whether a further evidentiary hearing
was necessary. We cannot presume the trial court erred. The
absence of a record of the hearing precludes a determination that
the court’s findings are not supported by substantial evidence.

B. Substantial Evidence

Even based on the limited record provided, which does not
reveal why an evidentiary hearing was not held, we conclude the
trial court’s findings are supported by substantial evidence.

9
“There is a strong public policy favoring contractual
arbitration, but that policy does not extend to parties who have
not agreed to arbitrate.” (Esparza v. Sand & Sea, Inc. (2016) 2
Cal.App.5th 781, 787.) General contract law principles determine
whether the parties have agreed to arbitration, and mutual
assent is an essential element. (Id. at pp. 787–788.) The moving
party bears the burden of proving the existence of an arbitration
agreement by a preponderance of the evidence. (Villareal v.
LAD-T, LLC (2022) 84 Cal.App.5th 446, 456.)
In this case, the parties presented conflicting evidence
about whether Saenz reviewed and signed an arbitration
agreement as part of the new hire process. The trial court found
Saenz’s declaration credible – specifically with respect to her
testimony that the store manager asked Saenz for information
and typed the entries in the computer for Saenz – while noting
that the manager’s contrary testimony was generalized and not
persuasive. Saenz unambiguously declared that she was not
provided with any documents to sign whatsoever, her manager
typed in the entries for the new hire forms, Saenz did not
remember the manager telling her about an arbitration
agreement, and Saenz would not have signed an arbitration
agreement if the manager had made her aware of it.
Eurostar’s own evidence supported Saenz’s version of
events. The store manager declared that she asked Saenz for
information to fill out the employer’s portion of the tax
verification form in January 2022, but Eurostar’s human
resources records show federal and state tax forms were
completed in February 2022, consistent with Saenz’s declaration
that she gave her manager the information to complete the tax
forms in February 2022. The store manager did not declare that

10
she told Saenz about the arbitration agreement, which was
consistent with Saenz’s declaration that she did not remember
being told about an arbitration agreement. There was
substantial evidence to support the trial court’s finding that no
arbitration agreement existed between the parties.
We need not consider Eurostar’s contentions about the
admissibility of statements by human resources director Mackay,
who was not present during Saenz’s new hire process, because
they would not affect the resolution of the substantial evidence
issue.

DISPOSITION

The October 20, 2023 order denying the motion to compel
arbitration is affirmed. Respondent Juddy Saenz is awarded her
costs on appeal.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.

MOOR, J.
WE CONCUR:

HOFFSTADT, P. J.

BAKER, J.

11

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.