In re Nav. B. CA4/2

CourtListener 10382790Calctapp23 avr. 2025

Texte intégral

Filed 4/23/25 In re Nav. B. CA4/2

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION TWO

In re Nav. B. et al., Persons Coming
Under the Juvenile Court Law.

SAN BERNARDINO COUNTY
CHILDREN AND FAMILY SERVICES, E084405

Plaintiff and Respondent, (Super.Ct.Nos. J299576-79)

v. OPINION

A.B. et al.,

Defendants and Appellants.

APPEAL from the Superior Court of San Bernardino County. Lynn M. Poncin,

Judge. Affirmed.

Jesse McGowan, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for Defendant and

Appellant, A.B.

Emily Uhre, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for Defendant and

Appellant, L.B.

1
Tom Bunton, County Counsel and Landon Villavaso, Deputy County Counsel, for

Plaintiff and Respondent.

L.B. (Mother) and A.B. (Father) challenge the order removing four of their minor

children from their care under subdivision (c)(1) of section 361 of the Welfare and

Institutions Code (§ 361(c)(1)). (Unlabeled statutory references are to this code.) With

respect to all four children, they contend that the juvenile court applied the wrong legal

standard in removing the children, because the court stated that the jurisdictional findings

were prima facie evidence to support removal even though the petitions contained no

allegations under subdivision (e) of section 300 (§ 300(e)). The parents also challenge

the sufficiency of the evidence supporting removal of two of the children. We affirm.

BACKGROUND

I. Family background

Mother and Father are married and have seven children: (1) Nav. B. (female, born

in May 2023); (2) Nia. B. (female, born in January 2021); (3) Nolan B. (male, born in

2017); (4) Nori B. (female, born in 2015); (5) Nala B. (female, born in 2008); (6) Niy. B.

(female, born in 2006); and (7) Anthony B. (male, born in 2003 or 2004). This appeal

involves only the four youngest children.

The parents have a history of domestic violence. Father was convicted of battery

in 2003 and spousal battery in 2008, and law enforcement responded to a report of

domestic violence in the home in 2014. In 2014, Mother reported that Father punched

her twice in the face and that she punched him in response. Father told San Bernardino

2
County Children and Family Services (CFS) that the last incident of domestic violence

occurred in 2003, after which he attended domestic violence classes.

II. Dependency history

The family has a recent dependency history. In March 2022, CFS responded to a

referral alleging that then-16-year-old Niy. and 13-year-old Nala reported that their 18-

year-old brother Anthony had sexually assaulted them. Nala told Mother that she

performed oral sex on Anthony one week ago at his request, and the same thing happened

when she was seven or eight years old. A law enforcement officer interviewed Nala and

Niy. Nala disclosed that Anthony had “forced her to have oral sex aggressively, by

pushing her head down and placing his hands down her shirt” and that it had happened

more than once. Nala showed the law enforcement officer text messages of Anthony

asking Nala to go to his room. Niy. reported that a sexual encounter with Anthony

occurred and the abuse “‘lasted a couple of years,’” but she also said that Anthony had

“not asked her to perform sexual acts, since 2012,” when she was five or six years old.

She denied having sexual intercourse with Anthony.

Mother told the law enforcement officer that the family preferred to handle the

matter privately and that Anthony denied the allegations. Mother reported that she was

aware of a previous sexual encounter between Anthony and Niy. in which a friend

showed Niy. pornography and Niy. “reenacted the same behaviors, by pleasing

[Anthony] orally when she returned home.” Mother believed that all of the children

involved in the incident were victims of sexual abuse.

3
A social worker met with both parents in March 2022, and they agreed to a safety

plan that required Anthony to live elsewhere temporarily. In 2024, CFS reported:

“Unbeknown to the department, it was later revealed that [Mother] picked up adult

sibling [Anthony] and placed him back in the home the same night, which breached the

safety plan agreement.” In April 2022, the parents told social workers that they were no

longer interested in CFS’s intervention and directed the social workers to leave their

home. Nala and Niy. did not attend scheduled forensic interviews. CFS took the children

into protective custody pursuant to a warrant.

The paternal grandmother spoke with a social worker in July 2022 and claimed

that Anthony lived with her in Las Vegas, Nevada. The parents reported that Anthony

was not allowed in the home. The following month, the juvenile court declared all five

minor children (Nav. was not yet born) dependents, sustaining allegations under

subdivisions (b), (d), and (j) of section 300 as to Nia., Nolan, and Nori and subdivisions

(b) and (d) of section 300 as to Niy. and Nala. The court issued a no-contact order

between Anthony and his siblings.

In December 2022, CFS recommended that the dependency case be dismissed on

the basis that “the parents appeared to be rehabilitated and abiding by the no contact court

order,” and the juvenile court dismissed the case. The children were returned to the

parents with the understanding that Anthony would not be living with the family.

4
III. Present investigation

In September 2023, CFS received two referrals concerning the family. One

alleged general neglect and physical abuse of all six of the minor children perpetrated by

the parents and Anthony, and one alleged that Anthony sexually abused Niy. Seventeen-

year-old Niy. had been placed on a section 5585 psychiatric hold by law enforcement

after an altercation at home between Niy. and Mother.1 During the hospital intake

process, Niy. reported that Father choked her two months earlier and that he spanked

two-year-old Nia. Niy. also disclosed “that her adult brother Anthony . . . has moved

back into the home and had oral sex with two (2) of her siblings (unknown names)” and

that she had “sexual intercourse” with Anthony between the ages of five and 13 years old.

Niy. said that Mother blamed her for the sexual abuse and that Mother claimed that Niy.

had initiated the incidents.

A social worker spoke on the phone with Mother about the referrals in December

2023. Mother denied that either she or Father physically abused the children, and she

attributed the reports of abuse to Niy.’s mental health crisis. Mother said that CFS was

not welcome at her home.

The paternal grandmother spoke to the social worker and expressed concern about

the children. She reported that the home was unsafe because of violence, emotional

abuse, and possible ongoing physical abuse of the older children. The paternal

1 The record mistakenly refers to Niy.’s hospitalization as a section 5150 hold, but
Niy. was a minor, so the hold was under section 5585.

5
grandmother reported that Anthony had never lived with her and that she previously lied

to the department because the parents asked her to.

A social worker contacted staff at the school attended by Nolan and Nori. The

staff person provided the social worker with a student profile form that the parents filled

out in August 2023 for the upcoming school year. The form stated that Anthony lived

with the family.

In December 2023, CFS discovered that the state welfare database listed Anthony

as living in the parents’ residence. In early October, Mother updated an application for

state welfare benefits, signed by both parents, that stated that the home was occupied by

three adults and six children. Anthony was listed as working at Del Taco. According to

notes entered in the state welfare database, Mother called the welfare department the

following week to report that the family’s income had changed as Anthony no longer

worked at Del Taco, where he was employed for about two weeks. In an application for

state welfare benefits signed by both parents the day after the August 2022 jurisdiction

and disposition hearing in the prior dependency case, the parents identified Anthony as an

adult living in the home. In late August 2022, Mother reported to a welfare eligibility

worker “that her 18-year-old son was visiting his grandparents for two (2) weeks but

when [Mother] spoke to the worker, it was taken as if he was out of the home.” (Italics

omitted.) Mother told the eligibility worker that Anthony then lived in the home.

6
CFS obtained a warrant in January 2024 to take all six minor children into

protective custody. Social workers took custody of nine-year-old Nori and six-year-old

Nolan at their school and immediately took them to forensic interviews. In those

interviews, both Nolan and Nori confirmed that Anthony was living with the family in a

bedroom directly across the hall from the bedroom shared by Niy. and Nala, which Nori

noted had a lock on the door. In describing the September 2023 altercation that led to

Niy.’s hospitalization, Nolan said that Anthony was present in the home and protecting

Mother. Both Nori and Nolan denied that their parents and Anthony were physically or

sexually abusing them.

Social workers attempted to take custody of Nala and Niy. at their high school, but

the school reported that both girls were in a home hospital program. The social workers

went to the family’s residence to serve the detention warrant and take custody of the

remaining children, but no one answered the door. Mother called one of the social

workers later that day. The social worker informed Mother of the detention warrant and

asked Mother to surrender the children to CFS. The social worker advised Mother that

the children were being detained because CFS had reliable information that Anthony was

living in the house. Mother denied the allegation.

IV. The allegations and the initial hearing

In January 2024, CFS filed dependency petitions as to all six minor children. The

record on appeal contains only the petitions pertaining to the four youngest children

(Nav., Nia., Nolan, and Nori). Those petitions contain jurisdictional allegations against

7
both parents under subdivisions (b)(1), (d), and (j) of section 300. With respect to Nia.,

the petition also contained an allegation against both parents under subdivision (a) of

section 300.

The court held a detention hearing in early January 2024, which both parents

attended. CFS noted in the detention report that the parents had not yet surrendered Nav.,

Nia., Nala, and Niy. to CFS’s custody. At the hearing, the juvenile court detained all six

children from both parents. The court ordered supervised visits for both parents and

ordered CFS to provide the parents with predisposition services to facilitate reunification.

V. Jurisdiction and disposition

The jurisdiction and disposition hearing was initially set for late January 2024, but

the contested jurisdiction and disposition hearings were held over the course of several

days in June and July 2024. Niy. turned 18 years old in February 2024. Between January

and June 2024, CFS filed numerous reports, including a jurisdiction and disposition

report in late January 2024 and eight additional information or addendum reports between

January and July. All of the reports were admitted at the jurisdiction and disposition

hearings.

A. Events between the initial hearing and the jurisdiction hearing

On the day of the detention hearing, the court issued a warrant for CFS to detain

15-year-old Nala, who remained at home. The parents let the social workers and a law

enforcement officer into the home, where Nala was locked in her bedroom. Nala refused

to leave or to talk to the social workers. Seventeen-year-old Niy. was taken into custody

8
after the detention hearing and stayed with Nav. and Nia. at CFS’s office for two days.

When Niy. learned that placement had been secured for Nav. and Nia. without her, Niy.

went AWOL. CFS filed a missing person report and contacted the parents, who

suspected that Niy. was with her boyfriend.

In the jurisdiction and disposition report, CFS reported that Nala and Niy.

remained at home and refused to be taken into CFS’s custody. Nori and Nolan were

placed together with a foster family, and Nav. and Nia. were placed together with a

different foster family.

Around mid-January 2024, a social worker separately interviewed both parents at

their home and also interviewed Nala while there. Both parents denied that Anthony

lived in the home or had lived there since the prior case. Nala said that she had not seen

Anthony for two years. The parents and Nala could not explain why Nolan and Nori

would say that Anthony lived at home when he did not. Nala did tell the social worker

that Niy. sometimes went into Nolan’s and Nori’s bedroom “and tells them to say

things.” Mother reported that when the prior case closed the social worker told them that

Anthony was allowed to be at the home for the holidays and special occasions. Mother

refused to say whether that had happened.

The social worker asked both parents to provide a timeline of where Anthony had

lived since the prior case closed in December 2022. Both parents said that Anthony lived

with the paternal grandmother in Las Vegas when the case closed. According to Father,

Anthony then moved back to southern California and lived with a friend in a mobile

9
home not far from the family until that friend moved to Arizona in September 2023.

Mother too said that Anthony moved back to southern California, but she said that he

lived in a trailer that the parents purchased for him but later sold because Anthony did not

get a job. Father said that Anthony worked at Del Taco for two weeks but had to go live

with a maternal great-uncle in another city. Both parents reported that Anthony at some

point lived with a friend who lived near a Circle K. Mother also said that she arranged

for Anthony to live with her uncle, whom CFS was unable to interview for the

jurisdiction and disposition report. Both parents said that Anthony was now living in the

One-Stop TAY Center in Yucca Valley, where Mother said that he had been for perhaps

a couple of weeks. Mother refused to give the social worker Anthony’s phone number.

Mother later sent the social worker internet bills addressed to either Anthony or

Father for July 2022 to April 2023. The bills were for service provided at the address in

California where Mother claimed Anthony was living in a mobile home park. CFS noted

that this new evidence contradicted Mother’s report in the prior case that Anthony lived

in Las Vegas.

With respect to Anthony’s inclusion on the applications for welfare benefits,

Mother explained that she included him because she was concerned that he would lose

medical benefits if she removed him from her case. She had recently learned that his

case could be transferred, so she discontinued him from her case on January 16, 2024.

As for Anthony’s inclusion as a household member in the August 2023 student profile at

Nori’s and Nala’s school, Mother claimed that she did not add him but just clicked

10
through the form quickly without updating it. She claimed that she had since removed

his name.

In addition to inquiring about Anthony’s whereabouts, the social worker asked

both parents if they believed Niy.’s and Nala’s disclosures that they were sexually abused

by Anthony. Father responded, “‘It’s tricky because I believe all my kids.’” He added

that Anthony claimed that “‘he didn’t do anything.’” Father complained that Anthony

had not received “due process” in the previous case. Mother responded that she “‘of

course’” believed Nala’s and Niy.’s disclosures. Mother also stated that she did not

believe that CFS investigated the allegations well, because no one spoke with Anthony.

She added that she believed that Niy., Nala, and Anthony “were being secretive because

she didn’t see any signs that the girls were being sexually abused.”

Nala denied that there had been any additional sexual abuse since the prior

dependency case. She reported that she “‘would probably feel a bit unsafe’” if her adult

siblings were around but also indicated that her parents were protective. Nala refused to

be taken into custody.

After interviewing both parents and Nala, two social workers walked through the

four-bedroom home, which had two hallways with two bedrooms accessible from each

hallway. Nala and Niy.’s shared bedroom was not on the same hallway as the parents’

bedroom. Mother reported that the other bedroom on Nala and Niy.’s hallway previously

belonged to Anthony but is now a game room. The room contained a pack-and-play and

11
a section of a couch placed in front of a television. There were clothes in the closet that

Father said belonged to Nala, who he said was attempting to claim the room as hers.

A social worker briefly spoke with Nolan and Nori in January 2024 after visiting

the parents’ home. The social worker asked both children who was living in their home

before they came to CFS’s office and were placed with their caregiver, and both

responded that all six other children, including Anthony, lived in the home, along with

both parents. Nori said that she celebrated the past Christmas with the entire family,

including Anthony. Asked to describe Anthony’s bedroom, Nori said that it had “LED

lights, a bed, and a X-box.” Nolan agreed and added that the room also contained a

dresser and Anthony’s clothes. Nolan denied that the home had any empty rooms or a

playroom.

Mother called CFS the day after she was interviewed and reported that Niy. had

returned home. The following week, a social worker urged Mother to encourage Nala

and Niy. to be taken into custody because it was ordered by the court. Mother said that

the girls had “minds of their own” and were unwilling. Mother sent the social worker

text messages with video recordings of both girls in which each explained why they did

not want to be taken into custody.

In an addendum report filed in late February 2024, CFS reported that Nala

remained at home and refused to be taken into custody. In early February, the caregiver

for Nolan and Nori gave a 30-day notice to change the children’s placement. The

caregiver was “no longer willing to care for the children due to concerns with the

12
parents.” During visits with the children in February, Mother reported that Nia. had a

scrape on her chin, Nolan and Nori wore the same shoes every day, and Nav. wore the

same clothes to visits. Mother learned that Nia. received a flu shot and informed CFS

that the parents did not approve of the children receiving flu shots.

In a report filed in late March 2024, CFS reported that Nori and Nala had been

placed with a different caregiver earlier that month. In early March, the caregiver of Nav.

and Nia. reported that law enforcement came to her home because Mother called them

and expressed concerns. The caregiver gave a 14-day notice to remove Nav. and Nia.

from her home. Mother told a social worker that the caregiver had provided Mother her

address, but Mother had no explanation for why the caregiver would do that. After

speaking with the social worker, Mother again called law enforcement to check on Nav.

and Nia., and they again went to the caregiver’s home. The following day, Nia. was

moved into a special needs home, and Nav., Nori, and Nala were moved together into a

different caregiver’s home.

During a supervised visit in March 2024, Nolan asked the parents, “‘[D]id

Anthony leave,’” and Mother responded, “‘[W]e are not going to talk about that.’” A

social worker informed Mother that there were safety concerns with the visits because

Mother had a caregiver’s address.

A mediation was held in mid-March 2024. Father said “that the social worker lied

in the prior case.” He called the lead social worker in the ongoing case “a liar.” The

parents refused to continue mediating after 15 minutes.

13
A social worker visited the parents’ home unannounced in March 2024 to check

on Nala. Father answered the door and got Nala, who came to the door. The social

worker asked Nala to put on shoes so that she could join the social worker outside. Nala

got her shoes and returned to the door, but Father told Nala that she did not have to go

outside. Fifteen-year-old Nala again refused to be taken into custody.

In February and March 2024, CFS reported that both parents refused to sign

consent forms to be referred to services. Mother previously indicated that she was

willing to go through her medical carrier to attend therapy, but CFS advised her that she

would still need to sign a consent form for CFS to communicate with the therapist.

CFS learned in March 2024 that Mother set up a GoFundMe page in January for

assistance with legal fees. The fundraiser contained a photograph of the four youngest

children. In the fundraiser, Mother said that CFS removed her children because they

were mad that they were returned in the prior case and that CFS removed the children

without following regulations. At a hearing in late March 2024, the court ordered Mother

to remove the GoFundMe page within 48 hours because of the confidentiality of the

proceedings and Mother’s inclusion of the photograph. The court warned Mother that

she could be found in contempt if she did not comply. At CFS’s request, the court

ordered visitation to be supervised by CFS at a specific CFS office.

In an additional information report filed in early April 2024, CFS informed the

court of Mother’s recent social media activity. CFS attached to the report several

printouts of posts that Mother made on various social media platforms about the

14
dependency proceeding. Mother posted photographs of the children along with

confidential information about the children and identified social workers working on the

case, accusing them of kidnapping and human trafficking. As of March 29, Mother had

not complied with the court’s order to remove the GoFundMe page. The court issued an

order to show cause regarding contempt and set a hearing in late April to address the

issue.

CFS filed an addendum report for the late April 2024 hearing. CFS reported that

Mother had removed most of the social media posts, except for the GoFundMe page and

a consent form that contained confidential information about Nav. In early April, social

workers and a law enforcement officer went to the family’s residence to serve the warrant

to apprehend Nala. Nala was grocery shopping with Mother. On a telephone call,

Mother disputed that CFS had a proper warrant and told the social worker to leave the

property.

During a visit with the children in mid-April 2024, Nori and Nolan told Mother

that the caregiver asked them to take the trash out. Mother interrupted and said, “‘[S]he

has you taking the trash out,’” after which both Nori and Nolan started crying. Mother

called law enforcement and reported that the caregiver was hitting the children, making

them go to bed early, and forcing them to take out the trash. As a result of Mother’s

concerns, Nav., Nia., and Nolan were not returned to the caregiver’s home and were

instead placed together in a respite home until placement could be found. At a hearing on

the order to show cause, Mother’s counsel claimed that Mother mistakenly believed that

15
she had removed the social media posts that contained identifying information about the

children. Counsel represented that Mother would remove the children’s photograph from

the GoFundMe page that day, which the court indicated was all that Mother needed to do.

CFS filed an addendum report in late May 2024 and reported that CFS submitted a

referral for services because the parents signed consent forms in late April. Less than two

weeks later, Mother told a social worker that she did not understand why she had to

attend individual therapy. The social worker started to explain why, but Mother ended

the telephone conversation. The following day, Mother sent the social worker an email

indicating that she was formally withdrawing her consent to attend therapy. Mother

believed that it would be “unjust” for her to attend therapy on the false premise that

Anthony lived in the home after the prior case.

During a visit with the children in mid-April 2024, a social worker noticed a pair

of sunglasses with a blinking light on a table. The social worker informed the parents

that they were not allowed to record visits, which the parents denied doing.

In late April 2024, Nav., Nolan, and Nori were placed together in a new foster

home. One month later, the caregiver submitted a 14-day notice asking to have the

children removed from her home because she felt as though “the ‘parents have a different

and new complaint/allegation each week.’”

Two days before a scheduled child and family team meeting in mid-April 2024,

Mother informed CFS that she would not participate. The meeting was held the

following month. The social workers explained to both parents that they were allowed to

16
participate in therapy with their preferred providers but that CFS would need to speak to

their therapists to ensure that the therapy addressed CFS’s concerns. Mother did not

agree with CFS’s concerns and denied that Anthony was in her home, but she agreed to

participate in therapy through a county-contracted provider. In an addendum report filed

the following month, CFS reported that both parents were participating in individual

therapy.

Niy. contacted a social worker in June 2024 and asked for her siblings to be placed

with her. Niy. was staying with a friend because her parents had kicked her out of the

house. She was upset that “she lost ‘all my rights to foster care because of them.’” Niy.

disclosed that “her parents are unfit but was unwilling to provide detail or testify before

the court.” The social worker explained to Niy. that she could not be considered for

placement because of her lack of housing and employment, among other reasons.

B. Contested jurisdiction hearing

The court held a contested jurisdiction hearing over the course of two days in June

2024. Both parents and four social workers testified.

Father testified that Anthony was 20 years old and lived in a residence provided

through Job Corps. Father denied that Anthony had lived with the family since March

2022 (when the referral in the prior case was made), visited in-person with his siblings, or

attended any family holiday gatherings. Asked what initiated the previous dependency

proceeding, Father responded, “We called for help. I was lied on.” Father explained that

the social workers had lied, and he said that no allegations were found true in the

17
previous case. CFS’s counsel specifically asked Father if he was “aware that the Court

previously found that Anthony Jr. sexually assaulted Nala,” and Father answered, “The

Court didn’t find that because it wasn’t true.”

Father repeatedly stated that he did not know whether Anthony sexually abused

any of his siblings. Father did not believe that Anthony would harm or sexually abuse

any of his siblings. Father denied that anyone other than Nala had accused Anthony of

sexually abusing them, but he then admitted that Niy. too had accused him. Father did

not believe that his daughters were given an opportunity “to speak the truth” during the

previous proceeding, so “the whole truth about this story” remained unknown.

After the first dependency case, the family implemented several safety

precautions, namely, door chimes, a lock “on the girls’ door,” and a security camera.

Niy. and Nala had not indicated that they were harmed in between the two dependency

cases. Father said that he “would report it” if any of his children were physically or

sexually abused.

Mother corroborated Father’s testimony that Anthony had not lived in the home

since March 2022, in compliance with the court’s orders in the previous dependency

case. Mother was not sure whether Anthony had any contact with Niy. and Nala since

March 2022, but Mother said that he had not had any contact with his four youngest

siblings.

18
Mother explained that the prior dependency case was initiated when Nala told her

that she had orally copulated Anthony, and Mother called wraparound services for

assistance. Mother understood that Niy. also disclosed to a wraparound service provider

that she had sexual contact with Anthony. Asked whether Mother believed that Anthony

had sexual contact with his sisters, Mother answered, “[Y]eah” and “I don’t know.”

Mother explained that she had “the full story of what happened between my kids,”

claiming that Niy. initiated oral sex with Anthony after a girl at a park showed Niy.

pornography depicting oral sex. With respect to Nala, Mother explained, “And then I

guess it got to Nala. Nala got involved with [Niy.], and then, I guess, some type of

way—they were all involved in it.” Mother clarified, “From [what] the girls have told

me, [Niy.] started the whole thing. She involved Nala. They were doing things together,

and the brother was involved, too, as well.” Mother believed that Niy. and Nala engaged

in sexual activity with each other. Asked whether she disclosed that to CFS, Mother

responded, “They never really tried to get the full story from us.”

Mother did not know who bore responsibility for the incident between Niy. and

Anthony, and she believed that “all three of them were victims.” Asked specifically

about whether Anthony bore any responsibility, Mother answered, “If they’re all kids,

why would he bear responsibility just by his self?” Asked whether Anthony posed a risk

to any of his siblings, Mother responded, “I don’t believe so. The girls—they still want

contact with their brother.” Mother denied the allegation that she had failed to protect her

children.

19
The social worker responsible for managing the current case testified that once she

had passed by a Del Taco while transporting Nori to a visit, and Nori commented “that

her brother used to work there, and he would bring her milk shakes.” The social worker

supervised more than five visits, during which Nolan once asked, “‘Did Anthony leave,’”

and “Nori asked if she can have his Play Station.” A social worker who worked on the

prior dependency case through dismissal testified that the parents were advised that

Anthony was not allowed to visit any of the other children or to be at the house when

they were there.

With respect to the four youngest children—Nav., Nia., Nolan, and Nori, the court

found true allegations against both parents under subdivisions (b)(1) and (j) of section

300. The court found under section 300, subdivision (b)(1), that Mother and Father

“allowed adult sibling [Anthony] to reside in the home despite being aware that he

sexually abused siblings [Nala and Niy.], thus placing [their] child[ren] [Nav., Nia.,

Nolan, and Nori] at risk of abuse.” With respect to Nia., Nolan, and Nori, the court

additionally found true an allegation under subdivisions (b)(1) and (j) of section 300 that

they were prior dependents of the court on the basis of the parents’ “negligent failure to

protect the children from sexual abuse.” As to Nav., the court found under subdivision (j)

of section 300 that all of her siblings except Anthony had previously been adjudged

dependents because of the parents’ failure to protect them from sexual abuse.

20
With respect to Nala, the court noted that there was a warrant to apprehend her, so

the court could not take jurisdiction over her. The court set a further in-progress

jurisdiction and disposition hearing.

C. Contested disposition hearing

The contested disposition hearing was held in late July 2024. The court received

into evidence an addendum report from CFS that was filed on the day of the hearing.

The court summarized evidence that it found relevant from the jurisdiction

hearing. The court found it “greatly disturb[ing]” that Father still denied the allegations

found true in the prior case and thus denied that Anthony sexually abused Niy. and Nala.

The court also described how Mother testified that she was unsure about whether the

sexual abuse occurred and believed that if it did happen then all three children—Niy.,

Nala, and Anthony—were victims and that all three children bore responsibility for any

sexual contact.

The court summarized the evidence that Anthony lived with the family after the

prior case was closed, and the court noted that with respect to the removal determination

it was “faced with allegations that were found true in which the [Mother and Father]

allowed Anthony to have contact with the children in this case, including the two girls

who said they were sexually assaulted, which put the children at risk.” The court

acknowledged that the standard of proof at the jurisdictional phase is preponderance of

the evidence, but the standard for removal is clear and convincing evidence. The court

then quoted the following passage from In re A.F. (2016) 3 Cal.App.5th 283 (A.F.):

21
“‘Jurisdictional findings in a dependency case are prima facie evidence that the children

cannot safely remain in the home.’” Relying again on A.F., the court reiterated that it had

to find by clear and convincing evidence that there was a substantial danger to the

physical health, safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of Nav., Nia.,

Nolan, and Nori if they were returned to their parents’ custody.

The court then discussed the evidence contained in the addendum report filed by

CFS that day. CFS recommended removal of the four youngest children and

reunification services for the parents. CFS expressed concern about whether the parents

were benefitting from services, the parents’ unwillingness to admit that Anthony was in

the home or around the children, and their continued denial of the sexual abuse.

CFS reported that Nala still lived with the parents and refused to be taken into

custody. The social worker spoke with both parents’ therapists. Mother’s therapist

believed that although Mother was “somewhat difficult” in the beginning, she appeared

to have progressed to the point of being willing to comply with CFS’s requests. But the

therapist reported that Mother did not admit that any sexual abuse occurred. The

therapist believed that Mother had a personality disorder and was strong-willed but not a

liar. The therapist planned to request additional services so that she could continue

working with Mother. Father had one session of therapy remaining, and his therapist did

not recommend additional sessions because he did not believe that Father would “‘budge’

regarding his stance on the Department’s involvement.” Father refused to acknowledge

22
CFS’s involvement and insisted that Anthony was never in the home. Father also told the

therapist that Anthony was never arrested or referred to services.

Social workers also met with both parents in late June 2024. They asked Mother

what she had learned from therapy, and she responded, “‘The counselor said he was

confused.’” Father interrupted the conversation and took Mother into another room to

talk; after the parents returned, no additional questions about therapy were asked.

After discussing the newly admitted evidence on the record, the court said:

“[W]hen reviewing some of the testimony, it does concern the Court that this is a second

case presently before the Court dealing with allegations of sexual abuse that the Court

previously found true in the first case, and yet [Father] still does not believe that any such

abuse occurred in the home. Mother and Father have testified they are going to

cooperate; however, their actions speak differently, based on the history of the first

removal, and the history of this case as well, based on the testimony that was presented,

and the reports that were received into evidence.”

The court found that there was clear and convincing evidence that “there is a

substantial danger to the physical health, safety, protection, physical or emotional well-

being of [Nav., Nia., Nolan, and Nori] or would be if the children were returned home.”

The court removed all four children from both parents and ordered reunification services

for both parents.

23
DISCUSSION

Both parents argue that the juvenile court applied an erroneous legal standard

when it stated that the jurisdictional findings are prima facie evidence to support removal

of the children from parental custody. Both parents also challenge the sufficiency of the

evidence supporting removal of Nolan and Nav. We find no prejudicial error.2

Section 361(c)(1) provides that in order to remove a child from their parents’

physical custody “the juvenile court must find by clear and convincing evidence that (1)

there ‘would be a substantial danger to the physical health, safety, protection, or physical

or emotional well-being’ of the child in the parents’ home, and (2) ‘there are no

reasonable means by which the [child’s] physical health can be protected without’

removal.” (In re Zoe H. (2024) 104 Cal.App.5th 58, 71 (Zoe H.), quoting § 361(c).)

We review the removal findings for substantial evidence, “taking into account the

level of confidence that the ‘clear and convincing evidence’ standard demands.” (Zoe H.,

supra, 104 Cal.App.5th at p. 71; Conservatorship of O.B. (2020) 9 Cal.5th 989, 995-996.)

In analyzing the sufficiency of the evidence, we “view the record in the light most

favorable to the prevailing party below and give appropriate deference to how the trier of

fact may have evaluated the credibility of witnesses, resolved conflicts in the evidence,

and drawn reasonable inferences from the evidence.” (Conservatorship of O.B., at

pp. 1011-1012.)

2 Mother also has filed a petition for writ of habeas corpus, In re L.B. (Mar. 25,
2025, E085771). We summarily deny the petition by separate order.

24
Ten days after the disposition hearing in the present case, we published Zoe H.

(Zoe H., supra, 104 Cal.App.5th at p. 58.) In that opinion, we explained that section

361(c)(1) provides that jurisdictional findings constitute prima facie evidence for removal

only “if jurisdiction was based on severe physical abuse of a child under age five” under

section 300(e). (Zoe H., at p. 72; § 361(c)(1) [“[t]he fact that a minor has been

adjudicated a dependent child of the court pursuant to subdivision (e) of Section 300 shall

constitute prima facie evidence that the minor cannot be safely left [in the home]”].) If

jurisdiction is “taken under other subdivisions of section 300 but not under section

300(e), the jurisdictional findings do not constitute prima facie evidence that the children

cannot safely remain in the home.” (Zoe H., at p. 72.) Contrary statements in A.F. and

similar cases are not supported by the statutory language. (Zoe H., at pp. 61-62, 72-73; In

re E.E. (2020) 49 Cal.App.5th 195, 218-219; In re M.V. (2022) 78 Cal.App.5th 944, 958.)

The juvenile court repeated A.F.’s misstatement of the law when it said that

“‘[j]urisdictional findings in a dependency case are prima facie evidence that the children

cannot safely remain in the home.’” But the court did not rely on the sustained

jurisdictional allegations as the sole basis for removing the children. Rather, the court

also found that removal was supported by clear and convincing evidence. Thus, although

the court mentioned the A.F. standard for removal, which is not supported by section

361(c)(1), the court also applied the correct standard. Assuming for the sake of argument

that the court’s reference to the A.F. standard constituted error, the error was harmless

25
unless it is reasonably probable that the parents would have achieved a more favorable

result absent the error. (In re Celine R. (2003) 31 Cal.4th 45, 60.)

Again, the record shows that the court independently found that removal was

supported by evidence other than the sustained jurisdictional allegations. At the

disposition hearing, the court did not merely rely on the existence of the jurisdictional

findings—that is, that the youngest four children were at risk of abuse because Anthony

lived in the home after the prior dependency case and that he had previously been found

to have sexually abused Nala and Niy. Instead, the court expressly based its findings on

the ample evidence that even now the parents do not believe that Anthony sexually

abused Niy. or Nala, or are equivocal about it, or believe that all of the children,

including Anthony, were victims. The court also considered newly admitted evidence

chronicling the parents’ behavior in the month following the jurisdiction hearing,

including reports from both parents’ therapists that they continued to deny that Anthony

sexually abused Niy. or Nala and that Father’s therapist did not believe there was any

value in continued therapy with Father, given Father’s stubbornness and denial of the

basis for CFS’s involvement (despite the sustained allegations).

Because the record shows that the court independently found removal supported

by clear and convincing evidence other than the sustained jurisdictional allegations, any

error in referring to the A.F. standard is harmless unless the removal findings were not

supported by substantial evidence. But the parents do not argue that removal findings as

to Nori and Nia. were not supported by substantial evidence. Because the parents have

26
not carried their burden of showing that the court’s legal error was prejudicial as to Nori

and Nia., we must affirm the disposition as to both of those children. (Conservatorship of

Farrant (2021) 67 Cal.App.5th 370, 378.)

Both parents do argue, however, that there is insufficient evidence to support the

removal findings as to Nav. and Nolan. (§ 361(c)(1).) Relying on In re I.J. (2013) 56

Cal.4th 766 (I.J.), the parents contend that Nav. and Nolan were differently situated from

Nori and Nia. because of Nav.’s age and Nolan’s gender. In particular, the parents argue

that there was no evidence that Nav. or Nolan was at any risk of sexual abuse by Anthony

because Nav. was so young that she would be under constant supervision and there was

no evidence that Anthony would target a male child. We are not persuaded.

With respect to both Nav. and Nolan, the court sustained allegations under

subdivision (b)(1) of section 300 that the parents placed Nav. and Nolan at risk of abuse

by allowing Anthony to reside in the home even though they knew that he sexually

abused Niy. and Nala. The court also found true that Nav. and Nolan were at risk of

abuse under subdivision (j) of section 300 because all of the children other than Nav. had

been adjudged dependents in the prior proceeding on account of the parents’ failure to

protect the children from sexual abuse. The parents do not challenge those sustained

allegations, so it is uncontested that Nav. and Nolan were at risk of abuse on those

grounds. Given the sustained allegations concerning the risk of abuse, we must reject the

parents’ argument that for purposes of removal Nav. and Nolan were not at risk of sexual

abuse by Anthony. Although the sustained allegations do not by themselves constitute

27
prima facie evidence to support removal (Zoe H., supra, 104 Cal.App.5th at p. 72), the

parents cannot challenge the removal findings by presupposing that the jurisdictional

allegations are false.

Moreover, Nav.’s age and Nolan’s gender notwithstanding, the magnitude of the

risk of sexual abuse to Nav. and Nolan is greater given the egregiousness of the known

abuse. (I.J., supra, 56 Cal.4th at p. 778 [“‘Some risks may be substantial even if they

carry a low degree of probability because the magnitude of the harm is potentially

great’”]; In re S.R. (2024) 104 Cal.App.5th 44, 53 [“In general, the more egregious the

abuse experienced by the sibling, ‘the more appropriate for the juvenile court to assume

jurisdiction over the siblings’ under section 300(j)”].) Niy.’s disclosures reveal that the

abuse may have started when she was as young as four years old and occurred over the

course of years. Nala’s disclosures reveal that the sexual abuse occurred more than once,

started when she was seven or eight years old, and involved the use of force. In addition,

much remains unknown about the abuse because the parents did not allow CFS to

conduct forensic interviews of either Niy. or Nala in the prior dependency case. (Cf.

S.R., at p. 50 [law enforcement conducted a forensic interview of the daughter concerning

the sexual abuse].) All of that evidence supports removal of both Nav. and Nolan from

the parents.

The juvenile court also could reasonably infer that Nav. was at greater risk

because she was only one year and four months old. Nav. would be unable to protect

herself from any abuse and unable to report any abuse.

28
The risk to either Nav. or Nolan is further exacerbated by the parents’ continued

denial and minimization of the sexual abuse and denial that Anthony even lived at the

home. The court could reasonably infer that the parents did not believe that Anthony

posed a risk to any of the children, and the court could likewise infer that the parents

consequently would not adequately protect Nav. and Nolan from any such risk.

Moreover, because Nala remained at home at the time of disposition, there existed a risk

that Nav. or Nolan might witness Anthony sexually abusing Nala. (See I.J., supra, 56

Cal.4th at p. 778 [the possibility that the child could have witnessed the sexual abuse of

the sibling is “relevant to the totality of the circumstances surrounding the sibling abuse,”

which the court should consider in determining whether the child is at risk].)

For all of these reasons, substantial evidence supported the juvenile court’s

removal findings as to Nav. and Nolan. Any error in citing an alternative standard for

removal therefore was harmless as to Nav. and Nolan, so the disposition as to both of

those children must be affirmed.

DISPOSITION

The dispositional findings and orders are affirmed.

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS

MENETREZ
J.
We concur:

FIELDS
Acting P. J.
RAPHAEL
J.

29

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.