CourtListener 10371483•Inglett v. Inglett CA2/8
Texte intégral
Filed 4/2/25 Inglett v. Inglett CA2/8
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION EIGHT
SRI INGLETT, B335210
Plaintiff and Appellant, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. 21AVRO00702)
v.
BILLY INGLETT,
Defendant and Respondent.
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County. Valerie L. Skeba, Temporary Judge. (Pursuant
to Cal. Const., art. VI, § 21.) Affirmed.
Paul Hastings, Ben Nicholson, Nicole Tackabery and
Colton J. Walker for Plaintiff and Appellant.
Law Office of Sabrina L. Roque, Sabrina Roque; Parmar
Law and Ravi Parmar for Defendant and Respondent.
**********
Plaintiff Sri Inglett, also known as Sara, and defendant
Billy Inglett were married in July 2017. In 2021, plaintiff filed
an application for a domestic violence restraining order (DVRO)
against defendant pursuant to the Domestic Violence Prevention
Act (Fam. Code, § 6200 et seq.; Act) based on two acts of alleged
physical abuse. Several weeks later, defendant filed an action for
dissolution of their marriage and also sought a DVRO against
plaintiff based on alleged cyber abuse. Following a joint
evidentiary hearing on both DVRO applications, the court denied
plaintiff’s application and granted defendant’s.
Plaintiff now appeals, contending the trial court applied the
incorrect legal standard in denying her application and made
arbitrary credibility findings in rejecting her evidence of abuse.
Plaintiff also purports to challenge the court’s order granting a
DVRO in favor of defendant.
We reject plaintiff’s contentions and affirm the denial of her
application. With respect to the order granting defendant’s
DVRO application in the dissolution action, we conclude plaintiff
failed to perfect an appeal.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
Plaintiff emigrated to this country from Indonesia as a
teenager in 2003. She and defendant met in 2014 through an
online dating service, and she eventually moved into defendant’s
home in Lancaster. The two married in July 2017.
In June 2021, plaintiff filed an application for a DVRO
against defendant based on two incidents of physical abuse
(Super. Ct. L.A. County, No. 21AVRO00702). Plaintiff’s
supporting declaration described an incident in January 2017,
before the parties were married, where defendant strangled her,
sat on her neck, “smashed” her to the ground “many, many
times,” and locked her out of the house in cold weather. The
second incident occurred on May 30, 2021. On that date, plaintiff
2
said defendant pushed her, sat on her legs to prevent her from
escaping their home, and blocked both of her hands. Plaintiff
reported she was left with “lots of bruises and tenderness” on
both legs and “tenderness” on her arms.
Thereafter, defendant filed a separate action seeking a
dissolution of their marriage (Super. Ct. L.A. County,
No. 21AVFL00593). In that action, defendant requested a DVRO
against plaintiff based on claims she was engaging in cyber abuse
and harassment. In his supporting declaration, defendant said
plaintiff was routinely controlling and distrustful, which he tried
to excuse, believing it was due “to the trauma she suffered
throughout her life.” Defendant eventually grew tired of
plaintiff’s behavior and on May 15, 2021, he told her he wanted a
divorce. On June 7, 2021, plaintiff began “cyber attacks” against
him, including logging into his e-mails and digital accounts
without permission and creating false social media accounts in
his name.
1. Joint Evidentiary Hearing
The parties agreed to a joint evidentiary hearing on both
applications. The two actions remained separate and were not
consolidated. The joint hearing took place over eight days spread
out over several months. Both plaintiff and defendant testified.
Defendant called four witnesses, including an expert. Plaintiff
did not call any witnesses.
Plaintiff testified in greater detail about the two incidents
of physical abuse stated in her declaration. She said the abusive
conduct in January 2017 included defendant grabbing her by the
neck, chasing her around the house, picking her up and
slamming her to the ground, kneeling on her, cursing at her,
pulling her hair, punching her in the face, dragging her outside,
3
kicking her in the stomach and locking her outside in the cold
with no coat or shoes.
Plaintiff identified several pictures of bruises and a scratch
that she said she suffered in the incident. She also testified that
defendant told her not to testify against him and made her go to
Florida to stay with his parents so the prosecutor could not find
her.
As for the incident on May 30, 2021, plaintiff said
defendant was drunk and raped her, which he had done on
numerous other occasions. Afterward, she locked the bedroom
door and stayed there for some time because she was scared
before eventually calling the police. Plaintiff said she did not tell
the police that defendant had raped her because she was
embarrassed. She identified pictures showing bruising on both
legs that she said happened during the rape.
Defendant denied plaintiff’s allegations of abuse. He said
the January 2017 incident occurred during a visit from his
childhood friend, David Dehart. Plaintiff woke up from a nap
and wanted to watch a movie and became angry with defendant
because he was watching music videos with Mr. Dehart.
Defendant said Mr. Dehart tried to play “mediator” to help
resolve the disagreement, but plaintiff “lunged” at defendant and
slapped him in the face. He put his arms up to try to defend
himself. Plaintiff was very upset and “flailing” at him, so
defendant grabbed her arms to try to block her. He was knocked
off balance and they both fell to the floor. Defendant admitted he
struggled with plaintiff for a while until she eventually stopped
fighting with him. Defendant said he was angry and told
plaintiff to leave the house. Defendant assumed plaintiff called a
friend to pick her up.
4
Defendant testified it was plaintiff’s idea to go stay with his
father in Florida so she could avoid testifying. The charges
against him were ultimately dismissed.
Defendant denied ever raping plaintiff. He said the
incident on May 30, 2021 began with plaintiff repeatedly banging
on his bedroom door while he was sleeping. By that time,
defendant had already told plaintiff he wanted a divorce, and he
had moved into the guest bedroom. Plaintiff was upset and
accused him of blocking her from their bank account. Defendant
said he had not done anything to the account, but he accessed the
account online, changed the password and gave her the new
password so she could use the account. Later in the day,
defendant found plaintiff in her room, talking to 911 and telling
the operator he was going to hurt her and to send the police.
Defendant waited outside for the police to arrive. He was
arrested but the charges were ultimately dismissed.
Defendant conceded that he and plaintiff did sometimes
drink and get drunk, but he denied that drinking caused him to
act violently toward plaintiff. Defendant explained that in the
spring of 2021, plaintiff often complained of feeling dizzy or
having panic attacks. She reported to him several times that she
had fallen and suffered bruises. Text messages between plaintiff
and defendant during this time showed plaintiff telling defendant
that her leg and backside hurt from falling down the stairs.
Copies of other text messages showed plaintiff asking defendant
to come home from work and take her to the doctor because she
had fallen and lost consciousness.
David Dehart testified about the January 2017 incident.
Mr. Dehart said that he and defendant were drinking and
watching music videos while plaintiff took a nap. When she
5
awoke, plaintiff became upset because she wanted to watch a
movie instead of music videos. Plaintiff and defendant began to
argue, with plaintiff raising her voice and defendant following
suit. Mr. Dehart said they began to argue “above [his] comfort
level” so he tried to “deescalate” the situation. Mr. Dehart told
them to sit down and try talking things out more calmly.
Mr. Dehart said that at some point, plaintiff jumped up,
“rushed” at defendant and slapped him in the face two or three
times. Defendant stood up and raised his arms, palms facing out,
blocking plaintiff’s efforts to hit him. Plaintiff then started to
kick defendant. Defendant grabbed her arms and eventually
they both fell to the floor, sort of wrestling with one another.
Defendant was yelling at plaintiff to stop. Defendant told
plaintiff she should leave, and she did. Later that night, the
police arrived and arrested defendant. Mr. Dehart said he
decided to cut his vacation short and go back home because he
was upset by plaintiff’s behavior and did not want to be at the
house with her.
Susan Marfleet testified that she met plaintiff sometime in
2020 through another friend. At the time of the hearing, they
were no longer friends. They had gotten into a disagreement over
plaintiff contacting Ms. Marfleet’s former boyfriend on social
media. After their falling out, Ms. Marfleet said plaintiff
harassed her online. Ms. Marfleet said her opinion of plaintiff
changed over time because she caught plaintiff “lying about
things” and found her to be “extremely manipulative.”
Ms. Marfleet said plaintiff talked about defendant a lot but
she only recalled plaintiff mentioning one physical altercation
with defendant and it only involved him pushing her. Plaintiff
said that she had gotten into a verbal argument with defendant
6
after he returned from a trip to Oklahoma, and she confronted
him about “cutting off” her credit card. Plaintiff said defendant
“pushed her” during that argument, that plaintiff called the
police, and defendant was arrested. Ms. Marfleet said plaintiff
was “very, very angry” about the incident.
Ms. Marfleet also recounted a Fourth of July weekend
when plaintiff stayed over at her beach house. She said plaintiff
spent a lot of time on her laptop “checking what [defendant] was
up to that weekend.” Plaintiff showed Ms. Marfleet she had
access to defendant’s e-mails and various digital accounts,
including Google, and had discovered that defendant had
purchased concert tickets. Plaintiff told her she wanted to get
somebody “to go spy” on defendant. Plaintiff also told her she
wanted someone to follow defendant and get a picture of him
drinking because she believed she could get defendant fired from
his job with the federal government.
David Richman rented a room from defendant and plaintiff
for most of 2021. He testified they seemed to have a typical
marriage with ordinary disagreements, but he never saw any
physical violence or loud shouting.
On May 30, 2021, Mr. Richman said the house was very
quiet when he came home from work. He did not see defendant
or plaintiff. After he had been home for a while, Mr. Richman
received a text from plaintiff asking him to call 911. She said she
was hiding in the bedroom because she was scared of defendant.
He had no idea what would have caused plaintiff to be scared.
He was aware the police did arrive later and arrested defendant.
Mr. Richman later moved out of the Lancaster house at plaintiff’s
request.
7
Robert Beegle testified as an expert in digital forensics in
support of defendant’s allegations that plaintiff had engaged in
online harassment and cyber abuse.
2. The Trial Court’s Oral and Written Rulings
a. The oral ruling
On October 5, 2023, after closing arguments, the court
issued an oral ruling from the bench as to both applications.
In denying plaintiff’s application, the court said it was
“striking” that plaintiff answered so many questions with “I don’t
know” or “I don’t recall,” estimating that it was over 90 times.
The court found plaintiff to be evasive and questioned her general
veracity. The court believed plaintiff had fabricated parts of her
testimony about what had happened with defendant, including
being raped in May 2021, in order to appear more sympathetic.
The court also believed plaintiff had lied to the court about
scheduling issues. The court said it did not credit every aspect of
defendant’s testimony, but the court did not believe plaintiff’s
testimony “at all.”
The court also said it found both Ms. Marfleet and
Mr. Beegle generally to be credible, both of whom bolstered and
corroborated aspects of defendant’s testimony.
The court granted defendant’s application for a DVRO,
explaining defendant had established by a preponderance of the
evidence that plaintiff “broke into [defendant’s] computer, that
she was surveilling him, canceling accounts, ordering things and
masquerading as [defendant]” online.”
8
b. The statement of decision
On November 6, 2023, the court issued a written decision
denying plaintiff’s application in case No. 21AVRO00702.
The court said it found plaintiff lacked credibility and
referenced its oral findings of October 5, 2023. The court said it
had previously “outlined the general concerns about [plaintiff’s]
truthfulness and listed 11 examples of statements by [plaintiff]
that the Court found to be deceptive, including an outright lie to
the Court about her reason for missing a court date. The Court
also commented on her general evasiveness—noting over
90 times she responded that she didn’t remember, or she didn’t
know to questions asked of her.”
The court explained it had “carefully reviewed” plaintiff’s
testimony and the exhibits “several times in order to determine if
there were any statements of [plaintiff’s] that would allow the
Court to have confidence in their truthfulness.” But ultimately
the court found plaintiff’s testimony to be “so evasive and
deceptive, that the Court was not able to believe anything that
she had testified to.”
As for defendant’s testimony, the court said it did not
believe everything defendant said but nonetheless found him to
be more credible than plaintiff, and his testimony was “bolstered
by other witnesses such as Mr. Beegle and Ms. Marfleet.”
The court emphasized it “had ample opportunity to see and
hear all of the witnesses testify concerning their observations of
the parties, their statements in their declarations, as well as
numerous exhibits.” Further, “the Court heard [plaintiff] testify
for 3 days and [defendant] for 4 days. They were extensively
questioned about their declarations and exhibits and subjected to
intensive cross-examination. These isolated screenshots and
9
other exhibits do not outweigh the probative value of this type of
in-person testimony. The ultimate outcome in this rests
primarily on the credibility of the parties while they were
testifying in court, along with the testimony of the two other
witnesses which the Court found to be credible and reliable—
Ms. Marfleet and Mr. Beegle.” The court also noted that
plaintiff’s actions after the May 2021 incident were not consistent
with her testimony that she feared defendant.
This appeal followed.
DISCUSSION
1. Plaintiff’s DVRO Application
a. Standard of review
We review the grant or denial of a request for a DVRO
under the deferential abuse of discretion standard. (In re
Marriage of Davila & Mejia (2018) 29 Cal.App.5th 220, 226.)
“ ‘ “To the extent that we are called upon to review the trial
court’s factual findings, we apply a substantial evidence standard
of review.” ’ ” (Ibid.; accord, In re Marriage of F.M. & M.M.
(2021) 65 Cal.App.5th 106, 116.)
In denying plaintiff’s DVRO application, the trial court
made explicit credibility findings adverse to plaintiff. “Of course,
‘ “[c]redibility determinations . . . are subject to extremely
deferential review” ’ [citation], and ‘ “[a] trier of fact is free to
disbelieve a witness . . . if there is any rational ground for doing
so.” ’ ” (Vinson v. Kinsey (2023) 93 Cal.App.5th 1166, 1176
(Vinson).) As a reviewing court, it is not our role to judge the
credibility of witnesses or reweigh the evidence. (Jennifer K. v.
Shane K. (2020) 47 Cal.App.5th 558, 578-579.)
Plaintiff, citing Vinson, attempts to avoid the application of
these well-established principles by urging us to find the trial
10
court committed legal error by applying an incorrect legal
standard in exercising its discretion under the Act and that our
review is therefore de novo. She contends Vinson held it was
error for a trial court to deny a DVRO based on post-abuse
actions by the victim, and to require the victim to prove fear of
bodily harm. She says the same legal errors were made by the
trial court in denying her application.
Plaintiff’s argument is without merit. Vinson did not hold
that a court may not consider post-abuse conduct in ruling on a
DVRO application. Vinson concluded the trial court abused its
discretion because it denied the plaintiff’s application without
consideration of the totality of the circumstances required by
Family Code section 6301, subdivision (d). (Vinson, supra, 93
Cal.App.5th at p. 1180.) Vinson explained it was compelled to so
conclude because the trial court had focused too narrowly on only
one incident of the defendant’s threatening behavior, had
“indicated the threat [the plaintiff] described did not warrant a
protective order because the court did not believe [she] took this
threat seriously, and gave no indication it considered the
evidence [she] submitted of additional threats and repeated
verbal and physical abuse.” (Ibid.) Vinson did not say or imply
that post-abuse conduct by the parties is irrelevant to the totality
of circumstances analysis.
b. Analysis
Giving due deference to the trial court’s explicit credibility
findings, we find no abuse of discretion in the court’s denial of
plaintiff’s application.
The court heard testimony from plaintiff, defendant, and
four witnesses over the course of seven days. In addition to the
testimony and multiple exhibits presented during the evidentiary
11
hearing, the court also reviewed the parties’ written declarations
and filings. The court emphasized it had “carefully reviewed”
plaintiff’s testimony and exhibits “several times” before reaching
its decision. Nothing in the record suggests the court took lightly
its obligation to carefully consider all of the evidence. After
engaging in such review, the court said it found the testimony of
the parties to have the most probative value and ultimately came
to the conclusion that defendant’s testimony, corroborated in
many aspects by the testimony of Ms. Marfleet and Mr. Beegle,
was more credible than plaintiff’s. The court’s oral and written
rulings reflect that it considered the totality of the circumstances
in reaching its decision as required by Family Code section 6301,
subdivision (d).
Plaintiff makes too much of the court’s statement at the
end of its written decision that plaintiff’s application for a DVRO
“appears to have been triggered by [defendant’s] decision to file
for divorce, rather [than] fear of him.” The court was not
imposing a “fear” requirement not contained in the statute. The
statement appears to be nothing more than a reflection of the
court’s credibility findings.
Defendant had testified, both in his declaration and during
the hearing, that he told plaintiff by May 15, 2021, that he
wanted a divorce, and that he moved out of their master bedroom
and into the guest bedroom before the incident of May 30, 2021.
The court noted that plaintiff made overtures to defendant after
May 30 that seemed inconsistent with her claims of abuse,
ultimately filing her application on June 10, 2021. That the court
had doubts about plaintiff’s motivation for filing her application
is consistent with the court’s overall credibility findings and does
not undermine the court’s decision. We also reject plaintiff’s
12
argument the court’s credibility findings were arbitrary and
without evidentiary support.
2. Defendant’s DVRO
In her briefs to this court, plaintiff challenges the propriety
of the DVRO granted in favor of defendant. However, nothing in
the record demonstrates that plaintiff perfected an appeal as to
that order which was issued in case No. 21AVFL00593.
Plaintiff began the superior court proceedings below by
filing an application for a DVRO against defendant, and the
action was assigned case No. 21AVRO00702. Two weeks later,
defendant filed a separate action seeking a dissolution of their
marriage and also requesting his own DVRO against plaintiff.
The dissolution action was assigned case No. 21AVFL00593. The
parties agreed to a joint evidentiary hearing on their respective
DVRO applications, but nothing in the record or briefing
indicates the two separate cases were ever consolidated.
On October 5, 2023, the last day of the joint hearing, the
court orally announced its decision on both matters, denying
plaintiff’s DVRO and granting defendant’s. On November 6,
2023, the court issued a written decision denying plaintiff’s
application. The written decision was issued only in case
No. 21AVRO00702 and addressed only the denial of plaintiff’s
application. Plaintiff timely filed a notice of appeal challenging
the denial of her application, and the only case number stated in
the notice of appeal filed with this court is case No.
21AVRO00702. Plaintiff’s notice of appeal does not include any
reference to case No. 21AVFL00593, nor is there any record of
plaintiff filing a separate notice of appeal under that case
number.
13
Notices of appeal are ordinarily liberally construed. But
“ ‘ “[o]ur jurisdiction on appeal is limited in scope to the notice of
appeal and the judgment or order appealed from.” [Citation.] We
have no jurisdiction over an order not mentioned in the notice of
appeal.’ ” (In re J.F. (2019) 39 Cal.App.5th 70, 75.)
Plaintiff says her notice of appeal references the court’s oral
decision of October 5, 2023, in which the court made rulings on
both DVRO applications. She contends her notice of appeal
therefore should be liberally construed to apply to the DVRO
rulings in both cases even though the notice identifies only case
No. 21AVRO00702. We do not agree.
Plaintiff’s case and defendant’s separate dissolution action
were never consolidated. Plaintiff fails to explain how the notice
she drafted and filed with only her case number gave fair notice
that she intended to appeal the court’s order in defendant’s
separate action as well. While plaintiff timely gave notice and
perfected an appeal of the court’s ruling denying her DVRO
application in case No. 21AVRO00702, we conclude we have no
jurisdiction to consider her contentions regarding the court’s
ruling on defendant’s DVRO in case No. 21AVFL00593.
3. Plaintiff’s Motion to Augment
Plaintiff filed a motion to augment the appellate record to
include the exhibits defendant submitted in support of his DVRO
application in case No. 21AVFL00593—the case over which we
have concluded we have no appellate jurisdiction. Plaintiff’s
motion to augment was filed on December 23, 2024, 12 months
after plaintiff’s notice of appeal was filed, and after briefing was
complete. Counsel’s brief declaration in support of the motion
states that on September 11, 2023, while representing plaintiff in
this case, he moved to a new law firm and it was “[n]ot until
14
December 2024” when he was able to obtain all but one of the
exhibits.
As we explained above, plaintiff did not timely perfect an
appeal from the court’s decision to grant defendant’s DVRO in
case No. 21AVFL00593, and the motion fails to articulate any
reason why defendant’s exhibits, many of which pertained to his
DVRO application for cyber abuse, are useful or necessary to this
appeal.
Furthermore, there is nothing in counsel’s one-page
declaration that explains what caused the delay in obtaining
copies of all of the exhibits, or the delay of over a year in filing
the motion. In September 2023 when counsel said he transferred
to a new law firm, he was involved in the joint evidentiary
hearing in this case, including an appearance on September 29,
2023, when testimony was received from defendant, and again on
October 5, 2023, when the parties made closing arguments to the
court. Counsel offers no explanation for why he did not have
access to or the ability to make copies of the exhibits at that time,
nor any explanation for what hampered his ability to obtain
copies over the course of the year after the hearing concluded.
California Rules of Court, rule 8.155, provides that a
motion to augment may be made at any time. However, whether
a motion to augment “is made within a reasonable time” is a
relevant factor the reviewing court may consider in ruling on the
motion. (Ibid., Advisory Com. com.) Plaintiff has failed to make
any showing that the motion to augment was made within a
reasonable time.
15
DISPOSITION
The order denying plaintiff and appellant Sri Inglett’s
application for a domestic violence restraining order is affirmed.
Plaintiff’s motion to augment the appellate record is denied.
Defendant and respondent Billy Inglett shall recover costs
of appeal.
GRIMES, J.
WE CONCUR:
STRATTON, P. J.
VIRAMONTES, J.
16
Vous vous demandez comment ce texte s’applique à votre situation ?
Consultation gratuite, sans engagement
Décrivez votre situation. Notre équipe vous recontactera par e-mail pour votre consultation.
Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude
Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.