CourtListener 10354104•People v. White CA4/1
Texte intégral
Filed 3/11/25 P. v. White CA4/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for publication or
ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or ordered published for
purposes of rule 8.1115.
COURT OF APPEAL, FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
THE PEOPLE, D082503
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v. (Super. Ct. No. SCD293806)
COLUMBUS WHITE,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of San Diego County,
Aaron H. Katz, Judge. Affirmed.
Johanna Pirko, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for
Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief Assistant
Attorney General, Charles C. Ragland, Assistant Attorney General,
Melissa Mandel and Seth M. Friedman, Deputy Attorneys General, for
Plaintiff and Respondent.
I. INTRODUCTION
Columbus White appeals from his convictions for human trafficking,
pimping, and pandering. White claims that text messages between the
prostitutes and him were inadmissible hearsay, and the People’s expert
improperly relied on the truth of those texts. Finding the texts admissible
under hearsay exceptions, we disagree and affirm the conviction.
II. BACKGROUND
In 2023, the Office of the San Diego District Attorney charged White
with human trafficking, pimping, and pandering of minor Maria S. between
January 23, 2022, and January 31, 2022 (Pen. Code, §§ 236.1, subd. (c)(1),
266h, subds. (a) & (b)(1), 266i, subds. (a)(1) & (b)(1); counts 1–3); pimping and
pandering of Gabriella J. between January 8, 2022, and February 21, 2022
(id., §§ 266h, subd. (a), 266i, subd. (a)(1); counts 4–5); pimping and pandering
of Juanica L. between February 2, 2022, and February 22, 2022 (id., §§ 266h,
subd. (a), 266i, subd. (a)(1); counts 6–7); and pimping and pandering of
Marketta G. between February 17, 2022, and February 21, 2022 (id., §§ 266h,
subd. (a), 266i, subd. (a)(1); counts 8–9).
At White’s trial, the trial court admitted text messages between White
and the four prostitutes as operative facts.1 The trial court instructed the
jury that the texts may not be considered “as evidence for the truth they
disclose.” The trial court explained that instead the jury may consider the
texts only to provide context for White’s statements and to determine
whether the texts “are part of the practice of engaging in the” charged
offenses.
1 “Written or spoken words offered as original evidence rather than for
their truth are generally referred to as ‘operative facts,’ ” (People v. Smith
(2009) 179 Cal.App.4th 986, 1003) or “verbal acts” (People v. Dell (1991)
232 Cal.App.3d 248, 262 (Dell)).
2
The following are examples of the admitted texts:2
From January 28, 2022:
Maria: Love you daddi
White: Call me with some money bitch or
don’t fuck with me at all
[¶] . . . [¶]
Maria: I only caught one date
White: Ok what exactly street you are on
White: If you can catch another one that’ll be
fine
White: Ask somebody what street you on
White: Finish the first date
Maria: I’m trying that trick from earlier said
he gots a friend
From January 28, 2022:
White: If he trying to have you do some extra
with that stripper pole have him pay
you more
Gabriella: Okay and yeah he already asking for
more time
White: Ok Make sure you get more money
Gabriella: I got you
Gabriella: I got 500
White: Nice
Gabriella: He want till 6[:]40
Gabriella: 6[:]30
Gabriella: But imma try n get em hom faster
White: Remember every condo you use that’s
more money
Gabriella: I know and i got another 120
White: Nice
2 Over 100 pages of texts were admitted, but White only cites to those
recited by Detective Daniel Dierdorff when he testified. We therefore limit
our analysis to those texts.
3
From February 18, 2022:
Gabriella: What i said was Someone wants a
date for 120 at that address I don’t
know if you want to go there or not for
that
Gabriella: He got it in cash so
Gabriella: App
White: Cash app
Gabriella: Yeah
White: OK give him my cash app to cash app
me
Gabriella: What you mean she gon have to give it
to him ain’t no one finna send the
money before she even shows up
White: Text me his number and I’m here
already
[¶] . . . [¶]
White: Tell him she’s getting dropped off by a
Uber at the gate
Gabriella: Tell her to go in the gate
Gabriella: She needs to go he keeps calling
White: [Sends Marketta a photo of his Cash
App account.]
White: U ok [to Marketta]
White: Got it [to Gabriella]
Gabriella: K
White: Set up some more good job [to
Gabriella]
White: Got it [to Marketta]
From February 19, 2022:
Juanica: 100$
Juanica: And the room was 104 Didn’t eat at all
yesterday And then today I did one
date hand jb quick lasted 6 min
for 80$
White: I’m still sick laying down but I’m going
to get up
Juanica: And I’ll be putting the money up but
won’t call till it’s more that
4
White: Ok good job keep it up I’m a keep
posting you to the top
Dierdorff testified as an expert in human trafficking and pimping,
defining the terminology used in the text messages. He explained that
prostitutes commonly call their pimps “daddy,” a “date” is the time a
prostitute spends with a sex buyer, a “trick” is a sex buyer, and “condo” refers
to condom.
Dierdorff opined that the texts were consistent with a pimp and
prostitute relationship. As Dierdorff described, pimps provide prostitutes
protection, staying in the area of the dates and communicating by text.
Pimps also control their prostitutes, using various methods such as not
letting them eat, and they provide their prostitutes with a specific number of
condoms as a tracking mechanism for how much money should have been
made.
Payment for sexual services, according to Dierdorff, is commonly made
through mobile applications such as Cash App and Venmo. White’s Cash
App records showed that a “Gabby” sent White approximately $2,700 and
White sent her approximately $1,000 around the time of White’s offenses in
this case. Some of those transactions had trophy emojis, which, according to
Dierdorff, indicate that a sex act occurred. Gabriella also texted White a
screenshot of a transfer she received through Venmo. During the February
18, 2022 text exchange quoted above, after White sent Marketta his Cash
App information and before he texted “[g]ot it,” White received $120 to his
Cash App account.
Dierdorff also testified that prostitutes use escort advertisements, such
as the website Megapersonals, to attract clients. Dierdorff discovered
postings on Megapersonals for Gabriella, Juanica, and Marketta. Each
contained the exact same language advertising prostitution services. White
5
had a screenshot of Marketta’s Megapersonals add on his phone. White also
had pictures of Juanica and Gabriela’s driver’s licenses on his phone, which is
significant because proper identification is required to post adds on
Megapersonals. When White wrote, “I’m a keep posting you to the top” in the
February 19, 2022, text to Juanica quoted above, Dierdorff found it
significant because escort ads are often reposted to increase their visibility.
The trial court also admitted numerous videos of White with Maria and
Gabriella containing references to pimping. For example, one of the videos
depicted White and Maria singing along to a song about pimping while
money emojis fell across the screen. In another, White tells Gabriella
“[s]taying down for my crown,” which means remaining loyal to a pimp.
Additional evidence against White included several officers’
observations of White, Maria, and Gabriella. On January 26, 2022, police
observed Maria and Gabriella standing outside the Main Street Motel in
Barrio Logan, which is a common area for prostitution. Maria and Gabriella
were wearing revealing clothing and waiving at passing cars, as prostitutes
often do. Maria had condoms in her possession. Gabriella had a tattoo of
“Mac $mooth” on her chest. Mac $mooth is White’s nickname. Prostitutes
frequently tattoo their pimp’s name on their bodies.
White was parked nearby, and after the police contacted Maria and
Gabriella, he appeared to record the incident. White then drove into the
parking lot where officers were detaining Maria and Gabriella.
On January 31, 2022, officers observed Maria in the same general area
about a block away. Maria was standing in the roadway waiving at cars as
they passed by, and officers detained her on suspicion of loitering to commit
prostitution. White was parked approximately 50 feet away, and he drove by
6
and observed Maria’s detention. Records from Maria’s phone showed that
she and White called each other 247 times between January 23 and 31, 2022.
White rested without presenting any affirmative evidence, and the jury
convicted him of all nine counts. The trial court sentenced White to 24 years
in prison.3 White timely appealed.
III. DISCUSSION
White argues the trial court abused its discretion in admitting the text
messages and allowing Dierdorff to provide his opinion based on those texts.
He claims the texts were inadmissible hearsay, and their truth was critical to
the prosecution’s case. White contends Dierdorff improperly relied on the
texts’ truth, and the trial court’s limiting instruction did not prevent the jury
from considering the texts as true.
White bases his arguments on People v. Sanchez (2016) 63 Cal.4th
665, 682, where the California Supreme Court held, “[w]hen an expert relies
on hearsay to provide case-specific facts, considers the statements as true,
and relates them to the jury as a reliable basis for the expert’s opinion, it
cannot logically be asserted that the hearsay content is not offered for its
truth.” The court determined that “the jury must consider expert basis
testimony for its truth in order to evaluate the expert’s opinion,” and hearsay
“problems cannot be avoided by giving a limiting instruction that such
testimony should not be considered for its truth.” (Id. at p. 684.)
3 White’s sentence consisted of 16 years for count 1, plus two years and
eight months for each of counts 4, 6, and 8. The trial court stayed White’s
sentence on counts 2, 3, 5, 7, and 9.
7
A. Standard of Review
We review a trial court’s rulings on admissibility of evidence for abuse
of discretion. (People v. Zavala (2013) 216 Cal.App.4th 242, 249.) However,
“we review the trial court’s ruling, ‘not the court’s reasoning and, if the ruling
was correct on any ground, we affirm.’ ” (People v. Camacho (2022)
14 Cal.5th 77, 123–124.)
B. Analysis
A prostitute’s statements may be admitted as operative facts to prove
pimping and pandering charges. (Dell, supra, 232 Cal.App.3d at p. 262.) “In
these types of situations, . . . the significance is in the fact the words were
uttered at all.” (Ibid.) For example, Maria’s text referring to White as
“daddi” was not admitted to prove that White was Maria’s father. Nor was it
necessary to prove that Juanica actually received $80 for the “date” she
described on February 19, 2022. These texts were relevant because the
declarants were using common prostitution terminology, and their
communications provided direct evidence of a prostitution/pimp relationship.
Consequently, the truth of these texts was not essential to the prosecution’s
case, and the texts were admissible as operative facts.
Dierdorff did not definitively state whether he considered the
statements in the text messages as true when rendering his opinion. Without
directly addressing the messages’ truth, Dierdorff generally described certain
terminology and opined that the text messages were consistent with a pimp
and prostitute relationship. Nonetheless, even if we assume Dierdorff
accepted the texts as true, and that the jury did as well, we see no error.
As explained in Sanchez, experts may rely on “hearsay properly
admitted under a statutory hearsay exception.” (People v. Sanchez,
supra, 63 Cal.4th at p. 685.) White’s statements in the text messages meet
8
the party statement exception to the hearsay rule in Evidence Code4
section 1220, under which “[a] defendant’s own hearsay statements are
admissible.” (People v. Davis (2005) 36 Cal.4th 510, 535.)
The prostitutes’ statements were also admissible using the
coconspirator exception in section 1223, which allows admission of
statements “made by the declarant while participating in a conspiracy to
commit a crime or civil wrong and in furtherance of the objective of that
conspiracy” if “made prior to or during the time that the party was
participating in that conspiracy.” (§ 1223, subds. (a) & (b).) White effectively
concedes this exception applies except for a narrow issue regarding Maria.5
In response to the People’s reliance on section 1223, White only argues
the coconspirator exception is inapplicable to Maria because she was a minor.
White claims Maria was statutorily immune from prosecution for prostitution
based on a 2016 amendment to Penal Code section 647; therefore, she could
not have participated in a conspiracy related to that offense. However, even
when prostitutes are immune from being charged as coconspirators, they may
nonetheless be treated as uncharged coconspirators acting with their pimp.
(People v. Brown, supra, 14 Cal.App.5th at p. 335.) In these circumstances,
4 All undesignated section references are to the Evidence Code.
5 In any event, we have no trouble finding the coconspirator exception’s
requirements are satisfied. Prostitutes may be treated as uncharged
coconspirators with their pimp. (People v. Brown (2017) 14 Cal.App.5th
320, 335.) The officers’ observations of Maria, Gabriella, and White; White’s
statements in the texts; the photos and videos on White’s phone; White’s
Cash App transactions; the Megapersonals advertisements; and the
numerous calls between White and Maria provide “independent evidence to
establish the prima facie existence of a conspiracy.” (People v. Calhoun
(2019) 38 Cal.App.5th 275, 319.) Further, the texts were between White and
the four prostitutes while White was pimping them, and they were in
furtherance of pimping and prostitution.
9
“it does not matter whether or not an uncharged coconspirator is
prosecutable, or instead enjoys immunity, in determining the application of
the coconspirator [hearsay] exception.” (Id. at pp. 332–333.) Accordingly,
immunity for prostitutes or human trafficking victims “does not preclude
treating them as uncharged coconspirators for purposes of the coconspirator
exception to the hearsay rule.” (Id. at p. 335.) White’s only defense to the
coconspirator hearsay exception therefore lacks merit, and we find the
prostitutes’ texts admissible under that exception.
In sum, in addition to being operative facts, the text messages were
also admissible under statutory hearsay exceptions. Consequently, both
Dierdorff and the jury were permitted to consider the texts for their truth,
and White has failed to show that reversal is warranted.
IV. DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.
RUBIN, J.
WE CONCUR:
HUFFMAN, Acting P. J.
KELETY, J.
10
Vous vous demandez comment ce texte s’applique à votre situation ?
Consultation gratuite, sans engagement
Décrivez votre situation. Notre équipe vous recontactera par e-mail pour votre consultation.
Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude
Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.