People v. Henry CA5

CourtListener 10333762Calctapp14 févr. 2025

Texte intégral

Filed 2/14/25 P. v. Henry CA5

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIFTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

THE PEOPLE,
F088246
Plaintiff and Respondent,
(Super. Ct. No. F19901581)
v.

JERRY JERVON HENRY, OPINION
Defendant and Appellant.

THE COURT*
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of Fresno County. Noelle Pebet,
Commissioner.
Allan E. Junker, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for Defendant and
Appellant.
Office of the State Attorney General, Sacramento, California, for Plaintiff and
Respondent.
-ooOoo-

* Before Hill, P. J., Peña, J. and Snauffer, J.
INTRODUCTION
Appellant and defendant Jerry Jervon Henry (appellant) pleaded no contest to
two felony charges in a domestic violence case in exchange for the dismissal of
two felony charges, a prior strike conviction, two misdemeanor cases filed after he
violated the protective order, and no initial prison sentence. Prior to sentencing, appellant
moved to withdraw his plea because he was not advised that if he was placed on
probation, he could be ordered to serve up to one year in jail. The trial court denied his
motion to withdraw and found his allegations were refuted by the record of the plea
hearing and the provisions of the written plea agreement that he initialed and signed.
Appellant was placed on probation on condition of serving 270 days in jail.
On appeal, appellate counsel filed a brief that summarized the facts with citations
to the record, raised no issues, and asked this court to independently review the record.
(People v. Wende (1979) 25 Cal.3d 436.) Appellant filed a letter with this court,
requesting a new attorney to challenge the denial of his motion to withdraw because of
the Wende brief; we denied his request. After review of the record, we affirm the
judgment.
PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
On March 7, 2019, a complaint was filed in the Superior Court of Fresno County
charging appellant with committing the following offenses on or about February 24,
2019: counts 1 and 2, corporal injury to a spouse or cohabitant, Jane Doe (the victim),
resulting in a traumatic condition (Pen. Code,1 § 273.5, subd. (a)); count 3, possession of
a firearm, a handgun, by a felon (§ 29800, subd. (a)(1)); and count 4, possession of
ammunition by a felon (§ 30305, subd. (a)(1)), with one prior strike conviction for
robbery.

1 All further statutory citations are to the Penal Code.

2.
Violation of Protective Order
On March 8, 2019, the trial court personally served appellant with a domestic
violence criminal protective order only permitting peaceful contact with the victim.
On August 28, 2019, the trial court terminated the initial protective order, and filed
and served appellant with a modified domestic violence criminal protective order
prohibiting any contact with the victim.
Approximately one month later, appellant violated the no-contact order and was
charged with a misdemeanor. About six weeks after that, appellant again violated the
no-contact order, and he was charged with another misdemeanor.
Suppression Motion
On March 9, 2020, appellant, represented by privately retained counsel Lawson
Renge, filed a motion to suppress evidence pursuant to section 1538.5, based on a search
of his vehicle when it was parked at a hospital, during which police officers found the
handgun and ammunition inside it. The prosecution filed an opposition. However, the
suppression motion was not heard, and the preliminary hearing was continued because of
a possible resolution.
Plea Agreement
On July 20, 2022, appellant signed a “Felony Advisement, Waiver of Rights, and
Plea Form” that stated he would plead no contest to counts 1 and 3, the plea was being
entered pursuant to People v. West (1970) 3 Cal.3d 595, indicated the remaining
two counts, prior strike conviction, and the two new misdemeanor cases would be
dismissed, and there would be “no initial state prison.”
Appellant initialed each paragraph in the plea form, including that he understood
and waived his constitutional rights and he could face a maximum prison term of
three years for each count. He initialed the following paragraph, which stated in pertinent
part:

3.
“If I violate any of the terms or conditions of my parole or post
release community supervision, I can be sentenced to more time in custody
for each violation. If I should receive probation, it could be for a period of
up to 5 years and could include up to 1 year in custody as a condition of
probation. I understand that if I violate any terms or conditions of
probation I can be sentenced to state prison for the maximum term which
may exceed the maximum on my plea bargain.” (Italics added.)
Appellant also initialed paragraphs that stated, “[t]he matter of probation and
sentence is to be determined solely by the Court,” and he was entering his plea freely and
voluntarily.
Appellant signed the plea agreement under penalty of perjury, attesting that he had
read, understood, and initialed each paragraph. His counsel, Renge, signed the
“Attorney’s Statement” that declared he reviewed the plea form with appellant, explained
each of his rights and answered his questions about the plea, discussed the facts with
appellant and explained the consequences of his plea, the elements of the offense, and
possible defenses, and concurred with appellant’s decision to enter the plea.
Plea Hearing
Also on July 20, 2022, appellant appeared in the trial court with Renge, who
presented the plea agreement to the court. The court stated appellant would plead no
contest to counts 1 and 3, and the remaining two felony counts, the prior strike
conviction, and his misdemeanor cases would be dismissed.
The trial court advised appellant about the terms of the plea, that he would not
receive an initial prison sentence, he would be placed on probation, and he could still be
sent to prison if he violated probation. The court asked appellant if he understood the
terms and conditions stated in the plea form, initialed each paragraph, signed the plea
agreement, and discussed it with his attorney. Appellant said yes.
Appellant pleaded no contest to counts 1 and 3, and the parties stipulated to a
factual basis pursuant to West. The trial court granted the prosecution’s motion to
dismiss the remaining two felony counts, the prior strike conviction, and

4.
two misdemeanor cases pursuant to People v. Harvey (1979) 25 Cal.3d 754. The court
allowed appellant to continue to remain out of custody on bond and set the sentencing
hearing.
Continued Sentencing Hearing
On November 9, 2022, appellant appeared with Renge for the scheduled
sentencing hearing. Renge asked the trial court to order appellant to attend a batterer’s
treatment program instead of imposing additional time. The prosecutor agreed and said
he would not ask for additional time.
The trial court stated that it was necessary to find unusual circumstances to place
appellant on probation in this case. It was inclined to find those circumstances since the
prosecution was not asking for additional time even given the allegations in the case,
appellant’s prior criminal record, and his prior significant time in custody.
Renge asked the trial court how much custodial time it would impose if it decided
to do so. The court said the probation department’s recommendation was 365 days in jail
as a condition of probation. Renge said that would devastate and severely jeopardize
appellant’s employment. The court asked appellant if he agreed with Renge’s
representation, and appellant said yes. The court asked the parties to approach and
conducted a bench conference off the record.
The trial court granted appellant’s motion for a continuance because Renge wanted
“to follow up on some issues regarding different issues related to [the] sentence in this
case .…”
On January 18, 2023, the trial court again convened the scheduled sentencing
hearing. Appellant appeared with Renge, who moved for a continuance because
appellant wanted to retain another attorney.
Appellant addressed the trial court and stated his attorney did not go “to bat” for
him and the plea deal was for no jail time. Appellant also said Renge told him that he

5.
would move to withdraw the plea if the court tried to impose jail time, and appellant felt
“blindsided.” Renge declined to comment because of the attorney-client privilege.
The prosecutor stated the plea agreement was for no initial state prison time, but
for probation and up to 365 days in jail. Appellant again addressed the trial court and
said the plea agreement was for “no prison time whatsoever. There was to be no jail
time.” The court continued the sentencing hearing.
On September 20, 2023, after numerous continuances, appellant appeared with his
newly retained counsel, Brian Andritch, and the trial court granted his motion for another
continuance.
Motion to Withdraw
On December 13, 2023, appellant filed a motion to withdraw his plea, based on
the claim that the trial court and Renge did not advise him about a direct consequence of
the plea, that a felony probation sentence could include up to one year in jail.
In his supporting declaration, appellant stated Renge informed him the plea
agreement was for probation and he would not spend any more time in jail, Renge did not
advise him that probation meant getting up to one year of jail time, the trial court did not
advise him that he faced up to one year of jail time, and he thought he would be
sentenced to jail only if he violated probation.
On May 9, 2024, the prosecution filed an opposition and argued appellant failed to
show good cause because the record refuted his declaration. Appellant initialed and
signed the plea form that clearly advised him that he could face up to one year of jail time
if he was placed on probation. At the plea hearing, the trial court asked him if he had
enough time to review the plea form with his attorney, and appellant said yes.
The Trial Court’s Denial of the Motion to Withdraw
On May 15, 2024, the trial court conducted the hearing on appellant’s motion to
withdraw. Andritch acknowledged the plea form stated that appellant could receive up to
a year in jail if he was placed on probation but argued that language was not clear

6.
because it was part of a paragraph that addressed other issues about community
supervision and parole violations. Andritch argued that at the plea hearing, the court
should have orally advised appellant of the possibility of probation with jail time, and in
the absence of such an advisement, his plea was not knowing and voluntary. The
prosecutor submitted.
The trial court stated appellant was 44 years old, and he had a prior felony and
misdemeanor record that showed he was “not a stranger to the court process or [the]
court.” The court also noted this case began in March 2019, and appellant made
25 appearances for over three and one-half years before the plea agreement was entered.
The trial court denied appellant’s motion to withdraw and found the change of plea
form was appropriately filled out and appellant signed the document and initialed each
paragraph, including those that expressly stated he faced up to one year in jail if he was
placed on probation and the sentence was to be solely determined by the court. At the
plea hearing, the court went over the terms of the plea agreement, which included
dismissal of a prior strike conviction in this case and no initial prison sentence. Prior to
taking the plea, the court asked appellant if he had sufficient time to review the terms
with his attorney and understood those terms, and appellant said yes. After appellant
entered his plea, he was advised that he could remain out of custody until his sentencing
hearing.
The trial court further found appellant’s supporting declaration was not compelling
or persuasive because it directly contradicted the plea agreement that appellant initialed
and signed under penalty of perjury, and appellant never declared he would not have
taken the plea deal if he had known more time would be served.
Sentencing Hearing
On June 3, 2024, the trial court convened the sentencing hearing. Appellant
personally addressed the court, apologized for the incident with the victim, and accepted
responsibility.

7.
The trial court stated appellant had a criminal history that went back to 1996. In
1998, he was convicted of robbery with a firearm at an ATM and sentenced to 14 years in
prison. The robbery conviction was alleged as a strike in this case and dismissed as part
of the plea agreement. After appellant was released from prison on the robbery case, he
was charged with false impersonation and placed on probation in 2016. He had been off
probation for nine months when he committed the offenses in this case.
As to the instant case, the trial court stated the victim had to go to the hospital as
the result of appellant’s actions and physicality toward her. Appellant lied about the
incident when he spoke to law enforcement, claimed he did not know why the victim was
at the hospital, and lied about a loaded firearm being in his car. The court found the
victim had to “mouth to another individual for help” because appellant held her “hostage
between two locations as [he] moved her around to get the proof [he] wanted that she
wasn’t cheating.”
The trial court further noted that while appellant was on bail in this case, he
violated the domestic violence no-contact criminal protective order twice and picked up
two misdemeanor cases, and these cases were dismissed as part of the plea agreement.
The two misdemeanor cases showed that he repeatedly did what he wanted to, and he did
not care about the court’s orders.
The trial court found it difficult to continue with the plea agreement because of
“the fact that [appellant] received the benefit of striking the strike prior, [his] repeated lies
to law enforcement, the conduct that [he] had while out of custody[,] and [his] case was
pending” when he violated the no-contact order twice.
The trial court suspended imposition of sentence and placed appellant on formal
probation for three years pursuant to section 1203.097 and subject to specific terms and
conditions, including serving 270 days in jail with credit for four days and successful
completion of a batterer’s program.

8.
The trial court terminated the prior protective order, and issued and served
appellant with another criminal protective order prohibiting contact with the victim for
three years. Appellant was remanded into custody.
On June 21, 2024, appellant filed a timely notice of appeal; the trial court granted
his request for a certificate of probable cause as to the denial of his motion to withdraw
his plea.2
DISCUSSION
As noted above, appellate counsel filed a brief with this court pursuant to Wende.
The brief also included counsel’s declaration that appellant was advised he could file his
own brief with this court. On November 4, 2024, this court advised appellant by letter
that he could file a supplemental letter or brief raising any arguable issues.
In response, appellant filed a letter with this court that stated he wanted another
attorney because his appointed appellate counsel filed the Wende brief and failed to
challenge the denial of his motion to withdraw his plea. On November 15, 2024, this
court denied appellant’s request to substitute attorneys and advised appellant that his
letter brief was due by December 4, 2024.
Appellant was not entitled to appointment of substitute counsel, and an appellate
attorney does not commit ineffective assistance by filing a Wende brief because “the
appellate court … review[s] the entire record in order to determine whether there [is] any
arguable issue.” (People v. Kelly (2006) 40 Cal.4th 106, 118.)
A. Motion to Withdraw
Appellant did not file another letter brief, but we will review the denial of his
motion to withdraw his plea to the extent he sought to assert that issue in his letter.

2 On October 3, 2024, this court granted appellant’s motion to construe the notice of
appeal to be “from the judgment entered on June 3, 2024, and taken after a plea of guilty
or no contest and based on the sentence or other matters occurring after the plea that do
not affect the validity of the plea.”

9.
“At any time before judgment, or within six months after an order granting
probation if entry of judgment is suspended, a trial court may permit a defendant to
withdraw a guilty plea for ‘good cause shown.’ (§ 1018.) ‘Mistake, ignorance or any
other factor overcoming the exercise of free judgment is good cause for withdrawal of a
guilty plea’ under section 1018 [citation], and section 1018 states that its provisions ‘shall
be liberally construed … to promote justice.’ A defendant seeking to withdraw a guilty
plea on grounds of mistake or ignorance must present clear and convincing evidence in
support of the claim.” (People v. Patterson (2017) 2 Cal.5th 885, 894.) The defendant
must show prejudice in that he or she would not have accepted the plea bargain had it not
been for the mistake. (In re Moser (1993) 6 Cal.4th 342, 352; People v. Breslin (2012)
205 Cal.App.4th 1409, 1416.)
“[A] validly executed waiver form is a proper substitute for verbal admonishment
by the trial court. [Citation.] … ‘A sufficient waiver form can be a great aid to a
defendant in outlining [a defendant’s] rights. The defense attorney, who is already
subject to a duty to explain the constitutional rights outlined in a proper waiver form to
his client prior to the client’s entering a plea, may even find it desirable to refer to such a
form. Thus, a defendant who has signed a waiver form upon competent advice of his
attorney has little need to hear a ritual recitation of his rights by a trial judge. The judge
need only determine whether defendant had read and understood the contents of the form,
and had discussed them with his attorney.’ ” (People v. Ramirez (1999) 71 Cal.App.4th
519, 521–522.)
“A plea may not be withdrawn simply because the defendant has changed his [or
her] mind.” (People v. Nance (1991) 1 Cal.App.4th 1453, 1456.) “[A] defendant’s
self-serving statement … [regarding whether] with competent advice he or she would [or
would not] have accepted a proffered plea bargain, is insufficient in and of itself to
[support] the defendant’s burden of proof as to prejudice, and must be corroborated
independently by objective evidence. A contrary holding would lead to an unchecked

10.
flow of easily fabricated claims.” (In re Alvernaz (1992) 2 Cal.4th 924, 938; People v.
Breslin, supra, 205 Cal.App.4th at p. 1421.)
“A trial court’s decision whether to permit a defendant to withdraw a guilty plea
under section 1018 is reviewed for abuse of discretion.” (People v. Patterson, supra,
2 Cal.5th at p. 894.) “[A] reviewing court must adopt the trial court’s factual findings if
substantial evidence supports them.” (People v. Fairbank (1997) 16 Cal.4th 1223, 1254.)
B. Analysis
The trial court did not abuse its discretion when it denied appellant’s motion to
withdraw his plea. As noted by the court, appellant never stated in his supporting
declaration that, if he had known about the possibility of jail time, he would not have
entered into the plea agreement that provided for the dismissal of the other two felony
counts and the prior strike conviction in this case, dismissal of the two misdemeanor
cases that were filed when he twice violated the criminal protective order while this case
was pending, and no initial time in state prison.
At the hearing on his motion to withdraw, appellant argued he should be allowed
to withdraw his plea because the trial court failed to verbally advise him of possible jail
time at the plea hearing. As explained above, however, a defendant may not withdraw his
plea if the court confirmed at the plea hearing that he understood the language on the plea
agreement form regarding the terms and conditions of his plea. (People v. Ramirez,
supra, 71 Cal.App.4th at p. 523.) Appellant initialed the paragraphs in the plea
agreement that stated that if he was placed on probation, he could receive up to one year
in jail, and the matter of probation and sentence were solely for the court’s determination.
At the plea hearing, the court asked appellant if he understood the terms of the plea
agreement, had sufficient time to discuss and ask questions about the terms in the plea
form with his attorney, and initialed and signed the document, and appellant said yes.
In denying appellant’s motion to withdraw, the trial court reviewed the plea
transcript and properly found objective and independent evidence refuted appellant’s

11.
self-serving statements in his supporting declaration that he was never advised of the
possibility of jail time as a condition of probation. The court also found appellant failed
to declare that he would not have entered the plea if he had known about the possibility
of jail time. The record supports the court’s findings that appellant failed to meet his
burden and, for the same reason, refutes any claim of prejudice relative to an ineffective
assistance claim.
After independent review of the record, we find no reasonably arguable factual or
legal issues exist.
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.

12.

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.