Adoption of J.S. CA4/3

CourtListener 10326954Calctapp4 févr. 2025

Texte intégral

Filed 2/4/25 Adoption of J.S. CA4/3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION THREE

Adoption of J.S., a Minor.

ALMA V.,

Plaintiff and Appellant, G064354

v. (Super. Ct. No. 22AD000252)

JAMIE F., OPINION

Defendant and Respondent.

Appeal from an order of the Superior Court of Orange County,
Mary Kreber Varipapa, Judge. Affirmed.
Baron Legal and Brian W. Baron, for Plaintiff and Appellant.
Brent Riggs, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for
Defendant and Respondent.

* * *
Alma V. (the grandmother) appeals from an order denying her
petition for freedom from parental control and custody (the petition) as to her
granddaughter, J.S. J.S.’s mother, Jaime F., had left J.S. in the
grandmother’s custody for approximately three years, since J.S. was
approximately 21 months old, under a temporary guardianship. The probate
court denied the petition.
The grandmother argues the court should have granted her
petition. The grandmother fails to set forth all of the pertinent facts under
the relevant standard of review and misapplies that standard of review. We
conclude there was substantial evidence to support the court’s decision to
deny the petition, and therefore we affirm the order.
STATEMENT OF FACTS AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY
J.S. was born in November 2017. She was released to Alma1 from
the hospital due to the mother’s substance abuse. Jaime asked Alma to take
custody of J.S. because Jaime did not want J.S. to be in the juvenile
dependency system.
Alma was granted guardianship in December 2017. Visitation for
Jaime was at Alma’s discretion.
Jaime filed a petition to terminate the guardianship in
September 2022, which the court denied. The court ruled that termination
was premature due to inconsistent contact between Jaime and J.S. The
parties were ordered to mediation pursuant to their agreement in order to
establish a plan for Jaime and J.S. to maintain contact. Mediation resulted in

1 Alma’s son, A.S., is J.S.’s father. He did not object to Alma’s

petition and is not part of this appeal. He was incarcerated at the time J.S.
was born.

2
an agreement with respect to contact. Pursuant to that agreement, Jaime
was permitted four hours of visits per week and daily phone calls. Alma, A.S.,
and Jaime agreed to drug test, with a urinalysis for Alma and follicle tests for
both parents.
In December 2022, Alma filed the instant petition. The grounds
for the petition were Family Code section 7822, alleging abandonment, and
Probate Code section 1516.5.2 She also filed a notice of pending adoption
proceedings, and a request to consolidate the guardianship and adoption
petitions and stay the guardianship proceedings. She had not, at that point,
filed an adoption request or initiated a home study.3
Both Alma and Jaime spoke to an investigator from Family Court
Services in connection with the petition. The report the investigator produced
was dated December 2022.
Alma reported that she worked full time as a caregiver, typically
from 10 p.m. to 6 a.m. During that time, childcare was provided by J.S.’s
paternal uncle or Alma’s 80-year-old mother. She was currently unmarried
and had five adult children. She denied any substance abuse, child abuse,
domestic violence, or criminal activity. She reported Jaime had not visited
J.S. since 2019. She denied that the father, A.S., resided in her home. She
believed the father was currently sober, but he had not complied with the
mediation agreement to complete a follicle test. She stated this was due to
“‘lack of an order and time.’”

2 Subsequent statutory references are to the Probate Code unless

otherwise indicated.
3 Alma filed an adoption petition much later, in January 2024.

3
According to Alma, J.S. had anxiety, but she was unable to
provide a diagnosis or the name of J.S.’s treating physician. When asked
again for that information, she stated there was “‘no official diagnosis’” but
said J.S. had been prescribed medication. She could not recall the name of it.
J.S. also had an unspecified eating or gastroenterological
disorder. Alma stated she had a specialist at St. Joseph Hospital, but was
unable to provide the doctor’s name.
Alma stated J.S. did not attend preschool or other extracurricular
activities, but went to church and played with other children. She described
J.S. as having “‘extreme separation anxiety’” but also being “‘very
independent.’”
With respect to visits as agreed to at mediation, Alma claimed
she had not agreed to it. She did not claim she had complied with the
mediation agreement with respect to contact.
When first asked, Alma stated she had not made any long-term
plans for J.S. in the event she was no longer able to care for her. When asked
the same question later, she said her daughter, a single parent, would take
her, or her son would take her.
J.S. could not be interviewed. The investigator’s report stated:
“[T]he child was briefly observed in the presence of [Alma]. It is unknown if
the child prefers to live with [Alma], . . . . It was apparent the child looked to
[Alma] for direction and only responded to the undersigned when instructed.
When asked direct questions by the undersigned the child, shrugged, spoke
inaudible or looked to [Alma]. [Alma] was observed making leading
statements and questions to the child about her name, songs and making
videos. Of concern to the undersigned was the child’s reported continued use
of a pull-up at the age of five, her non-enrollment in pre-school or

4
Kindergarten for socialization and the inability for the petitioner to provide
the undersigned with the name and telephone numbers of her healthcare
providers who are treating her alleged digestive and anxiety issues.”
Jaime was interviewed. She admitted being “‘under the
influence’” at the time of J.S.’s birth. She voluntarily placed J.S. in Alma’s
care. Jaime reported she had been sober since May 2020, the date she
entered a four-month residential rehab program. She completed the program
successfully. She had a substance abuse sponsor who she spoke to on a
regular basis. She had been employed at a grocery store for approximately
two years, working a full-time, variable schedule. She was not in a
relationship and had lived in the same apartment in Indio for two years with
her two other children, a 15-year-old, A., and a three-year-old, D. Pursuant to
the mediation agreement, she had submitted to a hair follicle test and was
awaiting the results. She denied any history of domestic violence or mental
health concerns. She attended therapy, anger management, and parenting
classes as part of her recovery. She acknowledged a conviction for receiving
stolen property and stated she was on formal probation until 2023. She was
compliant and in good standing.
Jaime admitted a juvenile dependency case as to her younger
child, D., who was born in January 2020 with positive toxicology. Both A. and
D. had ultimately been placed in foster care as a result. The case was closed
with exit orders. The dependency termination report, dated 2021, stated the
risk to the children, if dependency was terminated, “‘is low.’” Currently, she
had shared physical custody of D. with D.’s father and sole custody of A.
Jaime showed the investigator a timeline of visits using dated
photographs from her cell phone. She visited seven times each in 2018 and
2019. She had two video visits in 2020. In 2020, the dependency case occurred

5
involving her two other children, and she entered substance abuse treatment.
Thereafter, she reported Alma closed her social media account, ending
Jamie’s ability to communicate with her or J.S., leading to no visits in 2021 or
2022. In July 2022, she unsuccessfully petitioned to dissolve the
guardianship.
Acknowledging the existence of a child support order, Jaime
stated she had started paying in 2022.
Jaime believed Alma provided the father access to J.S., which
Jaime found concerning. She “expressed serious concern for the child’s safety
and well-being while under his supervision and care.” She did not believe the
father was currently sober, and alleged that family members had observed
him buying drugs. She also expressed serious concern about J.S.’s eating
disorder and that she was not attending school at five years old. Alma did not
allow Jaime to attend doctor’s visits, nor did she supply her with doctors’
names or telephone numbers before the mediation process. With respect to
visits, Jaime stated that Alma had not complied with the agreement at all,
stating Alma had not allowed her any visits. Documentation gathered by the
investigator supported Jaime’s claims.
Jaime was aware that the court “‘was not just going to give [J.S.]
right back. I just want a chance to develop a relationship. She has sisters.
This is supposed to be what’s best for her [J.S.] not for me or [Alma]. I just
want a chance to be her mom.’”
The investigator’s report stated: “[Alma] believes it is in the
minors’ best interests to be freed from the natural mother’s parental custody
and control. Throughout her interview, [she] expressed serious concern
regarding the natural mother’s history of substance abuse, her contact with
the Riverside County Juvenile Dependency Court, her ability to care for the

6
child while ensuring her safety and this Court’s ability to protect the child.
The child has been in her care since birth and she maintained the natural
mother has had no contact with the child since 08/27/2019.”
Jaime, the report noted, was “strongly opposed to the petition
and any adoption request. She plans to attend the hearing scheduled for
12/19/2022. [She] denied abandoning the child at any time and provided a
picture timeline of visits between 2017 and 2019. She acknowledged her last
visit occurred with the child in 2019, however maintained it was a result of
her entering treatment and [Alma] abusing her discretion with regard to
visitation. She maintained [Alma] unilaterally suspended all visits and
communication between her and the child, which brought her to the probate
court to request a dissolution of the guardianship. This resulted in the
probate court ordering its own investigation and sending the parties to
mediation, which she attended.
“[Jamie] appears to be stabilized at this point, . . . documentation
was provided that supports her employment, substance abuse treatment and
successful completion of her juvenile dependency matter. She reported her
sobriety date as 05/17/2020 and recently submitted to a hair follicle analysis
per the Probate Court mediation agreement. The natural mother expressed a
desire to reintroduce herself, resume contact with the child and cultivate her
maternal role. She is aware the process cannot happen all at once and is
prepared to accept a step-up plan.”
The evaluator opined: “Mitigating factors such as the mother’s in-
patient substance treatment, dependency case and [Alma]’s gatekeeping,
have limited and/or eliminated her ability to exercise frequent and continuing
contact with the child. [Alma]’s non-compliance with the mediation
agreement filed on 11/10/2022, and subsequent filing of this petition on

7
11/18/2022, was noted in addition to the last dependency report that noted
the return of the child’s siblings to the natural mother as a ‘. . . low-risk at
this time.’ Of concern to the undersigned is [Alma]’s open disdain and
disbelief that the natural mother is sober or capable of any change. [Alma]
appeared fixated on the natural mother’s history of poor choices, and
potentially dangerous behaviors, understandable; however it also appears she
has used them to delay or withhold visitation.
“In view of the foregoing, this investigator has concluded it is
premature and not in the best interest of the minor . . . to be freed from the
parental custody and control of the natural mother . . . ; however the Court
may wish to take additional testimony from all parties prior to making its
final decision in addition to appointing minor’s counsel.”
The hearing on Alma’s petition proceeded in April 2024. The
evaluation report was admitted into evidence. With regard to the testimony
at this hearing, we touch only upon relevant matters that were not previously
mentioned.
Alma testified extensively as to A.S.’s contacts with the child. As
relevant here, she stated that she had encouraged A.S. to have more contact.
As to Jaime, she testified that she had visited three times in 2017, six times
in 2018, and twice in 2019, with no visits thereafter.
As to J.S., Alma testified that she provided for her medical needs
and that the child had started school in August 2023. Somewhat in conflict
with what she had told the evaluator, she testified that J.S. had no “unusual”
health issues after she was four months old.
Alma acknowledged participating in some visits between J.S. and
Jaime’s other children. The last visit was in approximately 2021. Alma

8
stopped the visits after the dependency case involving the other children
ended.
Alma had changed her cell phone number more than once since
J.S. had been in her custody. She closed her social media account in 2019.
With respect to mediation, Alma acknowledged that she had
attended, but denied that an agreement for visitation had been reached. She
acknowledged that she signed something, but claimed she was “threatened”
into signing it, but she later stated she signed the agreement “voluntarily,”
before asserting she was “pressured into it.” She verified her signature was
on the agreement. Alma testified that she did not allow Jaime to start visits
after the mediation because she had not seen drug test results. Alma said she
communicated with Jaime for about a week after the mediation, and stopped
once she retained counsel.
Alma testified that as of the date of the hearing, she had no
intention of allowing Jaime to ever see J.S., and no intention of allowing
sibling contact until J.S. turned 18.
Jaime also testified. Her testimony was largely consistent with
her statements to the evaluator. When J.S. was born, she was addicted to
heroin and methamphetamine. She entered into the guardianship believing
Alma would return J.S. to her once she was able to care for the child. She also
believed the guardianship was necessary to prevent J.S. from entering into
foster care. She visited J.S. occasionally in 2018 and 2019 while still suffering
from her addiction.
Jaime had been sober since May 2020. She went from a rehab
facility to a sober living location. By then, she was working. Both her other
children had been in foster care, and she successfully reunited with them. At

9
the time of the hearing, she lived with both daughters and supported them by
working at a grocery store.
In late 2021, Jamie sought contact with J.S. She waited until
then based on the advice of a social worker who told her it would be better to
wait until she regained custody of her other daughters and the child
protective services case was closed. Alma did not respond, and Jaime
subsequently sought to terminate the guardianship. Mediation took place
thereafter, and as mentioned previously, Alma refused to abide by the terms
she agreed to.
Jaime was opposed to Alma’s adoption petition because she
believed she deserved to be a part of her daughter’s life. She had a full-time
job, was able to support herself, and had custody of J.S.’s siblings. She lived
in a two-bedroom apartment and had the space and a bed for J.S.
After hearing from Alma, Jaime, and other witnesses, the court
reached its decision. The court ruled: “The court finds that pursuant to . . .
Section 1516.5 that the parents, in fact, do not have custody of the minor
child and have not had custody for a period of over two years; however, the
court finds that there is insufficient evidence that the minor child would
benefit from being adopted by the guardian at this time. Additionally, the
court notes under [Family Code section] 7822 that, yes, there was a period of
time where [Jaime] did not communicate with the minor child; however, the
court makes a specific finding at this time that that period of time, that
presumption of evidence that was presented based on the period of time was
overcome.
“The court finds that [Jaime] has overcome that presumption,
and that she did not intend to abandon the child during that time frame. She

10
was unable to have contact with the child during that time frame.” The court
expressly found that Alma had “block[ed]” Jaime’s efforts to contact J.S.
“The court finds at this time under [sections] 7800 and 7801 of
the Family Code that the child’s best interests would not be served or
protected by granting this petition.
“The court finds that the best interest of the child is served by
denying the petition at this time.
“And with that, the court finds that [Alma] has not met her
burden by clear and convincing evidence, not under [section] 1516, not under
[Family Code section] 7822 (a)(2) and not under [Family Code section] 7822
(a)(3).”
DISCUSSION
I.
RELEVANT STATUTORY FRAMEWORK AND STANDARD OF REVIEW
Section 1516.5 governs Alma’s petition. Subdivision (a) states a
proceeding to free a child from parental custody and control may be granted if
all of the following requirements are satisfied:
“(1) One or both parents do not have the legal custody of the
child.
“(2) The child has been in the physical custody of the guardian for
a period of not less than two years.
“(3) The court finds that the child would benefit from being
adopted by his or her guardian. In making this determination, the court shall
consider all factors relating to the best interest of the child, including, but not
limited to, the nature and extent of the relationship between all of the
following:
“(A) The child and the birth parent.

11
“(B) The child and the guardian, including family members of the
guardian.
“(C) The child and any siblings or half siblings.”
Further, the court is required to “appoint a court investigator or
other qualified professional to investigate all factors enumerated in
subdivision (a)” and produce a written report. (§ 1516.5, subd. (b).)
Case law has shed further light on these requirements. “Although
the finding required by section 1516.5, subdivision (a)(3) is simply that ‘the
child would benefit from being adopted by his or her guardian,’ there is no
doubt that this requires a determination of the child’s best interest. It would
be absurd for the court to conclude that any benefit from adoption would be
sufficient, regardless of competing considerations. ‘Benefit’ in this context
means that adoption would be the best alternative for the child, as is clear
from the Legislature’s specification that ‘[i]n making this determination, the
court shall consider all factors relating to the best interest of the child . . . .’”
(Guardianship of Ann S. (2009) 45 Cal.4th 1110, 1128, fn.10 (Ann S.).) All
factors relating to the child’s best interest “would include the circumstances
leading to guardianship, the parent’s efforts to maintain contact with the
child, any exigencies that might hamper those efforts, and other evidence of
commitment to parental responsibilities.” (Id. at p. 1132.)
In the probate court, the burden is on the petitioner to
demonstrate that the facts support granting the petition under the clear and
convincing evidence standard. (Ann S., supra, 45 Cal.4th at p. 1127, fn. 9.) On
appeal, we examine the record for substantial evidence to support the court’s
order. “When determining whether substantial evidence is present, we do not
resolve conflicts in the evidence, pass on the credibility of witnesses, or
determine where the preponderance of the evidence lies. [Citation.] We

12
merely determine if there is any substantial evidence, contradicted or not,
which will support the conclusion of the trier of fact. [Citation.] Substantial
evidence is ‘reasonable, credible evidence of solid value such that a
reasonable trier of fact could make the findings challenged. . . .’ [Citation.]
The appellant must show the evidence is insufficient to support the trial
court’s findings.” (Adoption of Myah M. (2011) 201 Cal.App.4th 1518, 1539.)
Alma only contests the probate court’s findings under section
1516.5, and does not argue any findings under Family Code section 7822. We
therefore limit our discussion to the Probate Code.
II.
THE PROBATE COURT EXAMINED THE PROPER FACTORS
Alma’s first contention is that the probate court improperly
considered Jaime’s fitness as a mother. She does not cite any authority for
her argument that this is an inappropriate consideration. “‘[T]he court shall
consider all factors relating to the best interest of the child . . . .’” (Ann S.,
supra, 45 Cal.4th at p. 1128, fn.10.) The record reflects that the court briefly
considered Jaime’s fitness in the context of her successful drug recovery.
Indeed, the court expressly stated the “case does not revolve around that” and
the focus was on Alma rather than Jaime. We find the court’s brief reference
to Jaime’s recovery does not constitute an inappropriate inquiry in the
context of the statutory scheme.
Next, Alma takes issue with the court discussing the lack of an
adoption report, complaining that the court appeared to consider whether she
was suitable as a prospective adoptive parent. Again, this is something the
court referenced only briefly, noting that an adoption petition had not been
filed until January 2024 when the termination matter had been pending for
over a year. The court noted the lack of a report left the court without the

13
opportunity to consider whether an adoption would be appropriate, but
expressly stated this was “not evidence in itself” but merely a “lack of
information.” Whether the termination of Jaime’s parental rights would
eventually lead to adoption was an appropriate consideration within the
larger inquiry into J.S.’s best interest. Accordingly, we find no error.
Overall, we find the court considered the proper factors in
reaching its decision to deny the petition. The court’s review of the factors set
forth in section 1516.5, subd. (a)(3) was extensive and thorough.
III.
SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE TO SUPPORT THE COURT’S ORDER
Alma attempts to turn the standard of review on its head,
seemingly arguing there was substantial evidence to support her desired
outcome. But that is not how substantial evidence review works in the
appellate court—the only question before us is whether there was substantial
evidence to support the court’s decision, not whether substantial evidence
would have supported the opposite conclusion. (Pope v. Babick (2014) 229
Cal.App.4th 1238, 1245.)
Alma complains the court focused on her stability, rather than
the child’s stability in her care. But the stability of a caregiver is certainly a
legitimate inquiry in the overall consideration of a child’s best interest. She
does not contend the court did not have substantial evidence to support its
ruling on this point.
Among other things, the court noted Alma had “given some very
inaccurate information, and it may some [sic] small details, but those small
details have been very cumulative.” She had given the facts “a slant all the
way through” the case. Thus, in addition to other facts, the court found her to
be an inaccurate reporter. She had also “block[ed]” communication between

14
J.S. and Jaime and prevented J.S. from seeing her siblings. While she had
the attitude of wanting to do the right thing, the court was “not sure that
she’s been able to do the right thing in many circumstances.” The court found
some of her testimony “evasive,” as well as “inconsistent.” “It was continually
inaccurate and in embellishing [sic] fashion to justify certain actions, and,
again, it provided the court some very contradictory information going
forward.”
The court specifically found that it was “very difficult to say that
this particular situation in and of itself is, in fact, stable.” Contrary to Alma’s
argument, the court examined both J.S.’s stability in the home and the
general stability of the situation. These were proper concerns in the larger
context of J.S.’s best interest.
Alma also contends it could not be in the child’s best interest “to
upset [the] stability and continuity of care and introduce [Jaime], a complete
stranger” into her life. She apparently ignores that Jaime’s lack of presence
in the child’s life was due to the deliberate decision Alma made to exclude
her, despite an agreement to the contrary in 2022. The court found “an
extensive pattern of blocking” Jaime’s efforts “at every single opportunity.”
Allowing Alma to use her own intransigence to justify her desired outcome
would violate both the letter and the spirit of the statute, and would ignore
the child’s best interest.
Alma’s opening brief offers no further arguments to support a
claim that the probate court’s order was not supported by substantial
evidence. We conclude that it was. The court found that J.S.’s situation was
not stable. “I have concerns about the family in and out [sic] various stages of
sobriety, who’s looking after the child, who’s going to look after the child.
There’s no real plan in place as far as what if something happened to [Alma].

15
This court’s fear is that if this petition was granted, I could be making this
child an orphan . . . .” Accordingly, the court found that Alma had not met her
burden to establish by clear and convincing evidence that J.S.’s best interest
would be furthered by granting the petition. We agree this decision was
supported by substantial evidence.
DISPOSITION
The order is affirmed. Jaime is entitled to her costs on appeal.

MOORE, ACTING P. J.

WE CONCUR:

DELANEY, J.

GOODING, J.

16

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.