CourtListener 10326176•In re S.C. CA2/1
Texte intégral
Filed 1/31/25 In re S.C. CA2/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
In re S.C., et al., Persons Coming B335690
Under Juvenile Court Law.
LOS ANGELES COUNTY (Los Angeles County
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN Super. Ct. No. 23CCJP04405)
AND FAMILY SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
CARLOS C.,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from orders of the Superior Court of Los Angeles
County, Daniel Zeke Zeidler, Judge. Affirmed.
Jamie A. Moran, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Navid Nakhjavani, Principal
Deputy County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
_______________________________
Appellant Carlos C. (Father) appeals from the jurisdictional
and dispositional orders of the juvenile court in dependency
proceedings regarding his daughter S.C. (born January 2018) and
his son C.C. (born April 2020). Father challenges the sufficiency
of the evidence to support the court’s jurisdictional finding under
Welfare and Institutions Code section 300, subdivision (b)1 that
his use of marijuana and alcohol placed the children at risk. He
further contends the court abused its discretion by ordering him
to participate in a full substance abuse program as part of his
case plan. We affirm.
FACTS AND PROCEEDINGS BELOW
A. Petition Underlying Dependency Proceedings
On December 22, 2023, the Los Angeles County
Department of Children and Family Services (DCFS) filed a
section 300 petition alleging that S.C. and C.C. came under the
jurisdiction of the juvenile court based on allegations that Father
and the children’s mother, Stephanie B. (Mother), had a history
of engaging in domestic violence in the presence of the children,
and on a specific instance of domestic violence on December 10,
2023. On February 20, 2024, DCFS filed a first amended
petition alleging, inter alia: “[Father] has a history of substance
1 All further statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code.
2
abuse and is a recent abuser of alcohol and marijuana
which renders . . . [F]ather unable to provide regular care and
supervision of the children. On or about July 2023, . . . [F]ather
was under the influence of marijuana and alcohol while the
children were in . . . [F]ather’s care and supervision. On or about
August 2023, . . . [F]ather was under the influence of alcohol
while he engaged in a verbal and physical altercation with . . .
[M]other, and while in the presence of the children. On
12/10/2023, . . . [F]ather was under the influence of alcohol and
marijuana while he engaged in a violent altercation with . . .
[M]other and while in the presence of the children.”
B. Key Evidence Presented at
Jurisdiction/Disposition Hearing
The evidence before the court at the March 7, 2024 hearing
on the amended petition included the following:
1. Mother’s Statements and Videos on
Mother’s Phone
During interviews with DCFS, Mother reported that she
had been in a relationship with Father for 10 years. Father had
been physically abusive to her several times over the preceding
approximately five years, including hitting her on the head
with the gun he kept in the home and strangling her. During the
December 10, 2023 incident, Father kicked, punched, and choked
her, and threatened to kill her, chop up her body, and bury it in
the desert.
During her first interview with DCFS, “Mother denied
[F]ather was under the influence of any substances the day of
the [December 10, 2023] incident, but reported [F]ather uses
marijuana and alcohol.” In subsequent interviews, however,
3
Mother stated he was “ ‘drunk and aggressive that day’ ” and
under the influence of both marijuana and alcohol to such an
extent he “ ‘couldn’t walk straight.’ ”
Two videos Mother recorded on December 9 depict Father
drinking in the family kitchen while holding a gun. In the
first, Father “is shown consuming alcohol in the kitchen while
talking to . . . [M]other. Father is visibly holding a firearm while
threatening [to] shoot . . . [M]other while the children are heard
in another room. [¶] In a second clip, [M]other is standing in the
kitchen while [F]ather continues to talk to her while consuming
alcohol. Father has his gun on the kitchen counter while [C.C.]
is also sitting on the kitchen counter. During the video, [F]ather
is seen picking up the gun in the presence of . . . [M]other and
[C.C.]”
Mother further told the social worker that Father had
used marijuana daily “since he was in middle school,” that
he did not do so in the children’s presence, and that she cared
for the children when he was under the influence. According
to Mother, since July 2023, Father also drank one to six beers
daily. Mother suspected Father used other drugs “based on his
paranoid and aggressive behaviors” such as “grind[ing] his teeth,
[being unable to] keep still,” making “comments that someone
was following him,” and repeatedly checking the locks on the
doors and windows of the home in the middle of the night.
2. Father’s Statements and Driving Under
the Influence Arrest
During DCFS interviews, Father denied having any
substance abuse or mental health issues. He reported having
started using marijuana approximately eight years ago, at the
age of 21, and that he used marijuana two or three days per week
4
to help him sleep. Father said he stored the marijuana in a
safe and Mother took care of the children when he was under
the influence. Father started drinking at the age of 21, initially
drinking a six pack of beer once a week or every other week.
He now occasionally consumes a six pack of beer at family
gatherings. Father denied his alcohol and marijuana use ever
“created problems.”
Father further reported, however, that he had been
arrested for driving under the influence (DUI) in 2019. Father
had two outstanding warrants, one associated with the DUI
and one for driving without a valid license. A police incident
report provides further detail about his “DUI combined alcohol
and drug” arrest. (Capitalization & boldface omitted.) Police
responding to a report of a crash found Father in the driver’s
seat with a bong in his lap and jars of marijuana and empty
bottles of beer strewn in the car. Police described Father
as “extremely disorientated” and “unable to stand on his
feet without assistance.” Father’s blood alcohol level was
.229 percent and he had cannabinoids in his system.
On February 2, 2024, Father told the dependency
investigator he was “open” to an on-demand drug/alcohol test
that same day. The dependency investigator then called and
texted Father to inform him that an on-demand drug/alcohol
test was approved at Father’s preferred location, but Father
never responded or tested that day.
3. Children’s Statements
During an interview with a DCFS investigator, S.C. (then
six years old) reported seeing Father hit and push Mother. She
reported not feeling safe with Father and stated: “He will hurt
us. He is gonna go to jail because he drinks beer and hurts my
5
mommy.” S.C. said Father had a gun, and that she had seen it.
S.C. stated Father hit her and her brother with a belt, causing
injuries, and that this occurred “10 times.” S.C. also reported
that Father “ ‘always smokes. I see it. He says—Get out. . . .
The smoke was brown and white. He loves beer a lot.’ ”
C.C. (then three years old) reported that he has seen
Father “push[ ] [Mother]. Locked the door on mom. Daddy
threw a toy at my face.”
4. Statements of Other Relatives
Maternal aunt N.N. told DCFS in an initial interview
that she had seen Father drink alcohol and become intoxicated,
and that when he was intoxicated he was “not the best person.”
“She stated [F]ather drinks and drives and has driven with the
children while under the influence. [She] stated when [F]ather
drinks and drives, he ‘gets in the zone when he’s mad’ and will
speed with no regard for others. She stated she stopped going to
visit [M]other in Palm Desert because of how . . . [F]ather gets.”
In a subsequent interview, she further informed DCFS that
Father “ ‘drinks a lot of beer and liquor. He smokes marijuana.
The car smelled like weed with the kids in the car.’ ”
Several maternal and paternal extended relatives told
DCFS they were unaware of problems in the parents’ relationship
until the December 10 incident and denied any knowledge of
Father using drugs or using inappropriate discipline with the
children.
6
C. Challenged Orders Regarding Jurisdiction
and Disposition
The juvenile court struck the allegation of Father’s arrest
for DUI as a basis for jurisdiction, but otherwise sustained the
allegations of the amended petition.
The court declared the children dependents of the court,
removed them from Father, and placed them with Mother
under a plan of family maintenance. The court ordered DCFS
to provide Father with enhancement services that included a full
drug and alcohol treatment program with aftercare. In so doing,
the court rejected Father’s argument that a full substance abuse
program was not “necessary at [the] time” and his related request
that he be instead referred for drug treatment only after testing
positive, or that he first be assessed to determine whether such
services were necessary. Father also requested that DCFS
“actively work with . . . Father to identify remote programs”
for all of his services, because of his work schedule.
Father filed a timely appeal.
DISCUSSION
On appeal, Father challenges the sufficiency of the
evidence to support the jurisdictional finding based on his
substance abuse. He also challenges the requirement that he
complete a full drug and alcohol program with aftercare. We
find no error and affirm.
A. Substantial Evidence Supports the
Jurisdictional Finding Regarding
Father’s Substance Abuse
As a preliminary matter, DCFS contends that Father’s
challenge to the jurisdictional order is moot. Specifically, DCFS
argues (and Father concedes) that because Father challenges
7
only one of several jurisdictional bases sustained in the petition,
even if we reverse the challenged jurisdictional finding as Father
requests, the juvenile court would still have correctly asserted
jurisdiction over the children. (See In re Alexis E. (2009) 171
Cal.App.4th 438, 451.) Father, however, asks that we exercise
our discretion to nevertheless reach the merits of his appeal. We
choose to do so because the finding Father challenges serves as
the basis for the dispositional order he also challenges on appeal.
(See In re D.M. (2015) 242 Cal.App.4th 634, 638–639.)
The court sustained the challenged jurisdictional finding
under section 300, subdivision (b), which requires “ ‘evidence
indicating that the child is exposed to a substantial risk of
serious physical harm or illness. [Citation.]’ ” (In re David M.
(2005) 134 Cal.App.4th 822, 829.) This risk must exist as of
the time of the jurisdictional hearing (In re Katrina C. (1988)
201 Cal.App.3d 540, 547), but may be based on a parent’s past
conduct, so long as the evidence suggests that past conduct is
likely to reoccur or otherwise establishes a current risk. (In re
Nicholas B. (2001) 88 Cal.App.4th 1126, 1135; In re Rocco M.
(1991) 1 Cal.App.4th 814.) We review jurisdictional findings
for substantial evidence, meaning “we draw all reasonable
inferences in support of the findings, view the record favorably
to the juvenile court’s order and affirm the order even if other
evidence supports a contrary finding.” (In re James R. (2009) 176
Cal.App.4th 129, 135; In re Savannah M. (2005) 131 Cal.App.4th
1387, 1393–1394.)
8
Father argues the evidence supports only that he uses
legal2 substances (alcohol and marijuana), not that he uses
these substances while caring for the children or in a manner
that places the children at risk. He points to Mother’s
statements that she watches the children while he is under the
influence. He characterizes maternal aunt’s statements to the
contrary as mere speculation, because maternal aunt admitted
she did not spend very much time with Father or in the family
home.
Mother’s statement that she watches the children
when Father is under the influence is belied by other evidence.
According to S.C., Father drank and smoked marijuana in her
presence, and Father “hurt mommy” when he did so. Moreover,
the videos on Mother’s phone depict Father not only drinking
alcohol with the children nearby, but engaging in dangerous and
threatening behavior while doing so. Namely, in these videos,
Father is drinking alcohol, holding a gun, and threatening
Mother, all while, in one instance, the children are heard in the
background, and in the other instance, C.C. is within reach of the
weapon.
And regardless of how many opportunities maternal aunt
had to observe Father, during the opportunities she did have,
she saw him drive recklessly while under the influence with the
children in the car, and on one occasion smelled marijuana in his
car while the children were in it.
2 Father argues we should disregard Mother’s statements
that he might be using illegal drugs as mere speculation. We
need not determine whether Mother’s statements to this effect
would support the challenged finding, because we depend on
other evidence to support the finding.
9
B. The Court Did Not Abuse Its Discretion in
Ordering Father to Participate in a Full
Substance Abuse Program
We review the case plan requirements in a dispositional
order for an abuse of discretion. (In re Christopher H. (1996)
50 Cal.App.4th 1001, 1006 (Christopher H.).) The court may
make “all reasonable orders for the care, supervision, custody,
conduct, maintenance, and support of the child” (§ 362, subd. (a)),
including “any reasonable orders [directed] to the parents or
guardians of the child . . . as the court deems necessary and
proper to carry out this section . . . . The program in which a
parent or guardian is required to participate shall be designed
to eliminate those conditions that led to the court’s finding
that the child is a person described by [s]ection 300.” (§ 362,
subd. (d).) Proper dispositional orders are thus designed
to address potential obstacles to family reunification
(Christopher H., supra, at p. 1006), as determined by the court’s
review of the entire record. (See In re Briana V. (2015) 236
Cal.App.4th 297, 311.)
Although it is not entirely clear from the briefing, Father
appears to be arguing that the evidence does not support—
and the petition does not even allege—that, as of the date of
the jurisdictional hearing, he was addicted to drugs or alcohol,
or that he generally struggled with substance abuse issues to
such an extent that ordering him to complete a full substance
abuse treatment program with aftercare was “tailored to
eliminate legitimate protective issues.” He argues that, instead,
the evidence supports at most that he has in the past used
marijuana and alcohol. According to Father, only having a more
serious substance abuse problem or being addicted—not mere
10
historical substance use—can justify ordering a full substance
abuse treatment program.
We do not agree that this distinction is significant here,
because the issue is not whether Father’s substance abuse
reached some unspecified level he deems sufficient to require
a full treatment program. Rather, we must consider whether
the court could reasonably conclude that requiring Father
to complete a full substance abuse program would help to
“eliminate those conditions that led to the court’s finding” that
the children were at risk of harm without juvenile court oversight
(§ 362, subd. (d)), and/or eliminate obstacles to reunification.
(Christopher H., supra, 50 Cal.App.4th at p. 1006.) As we
conclude above, substantial evidence supports the jurisdictional
allegations that, on multiple occasions, the children were at risk
of harm when Father engaged in violent and dangerous behavior
that coincided with alcohol and/or marijuana use. The videos
on Mother’s phone support this. Further, according to Mother’s
statements, when Father assaulted her on December 10—
with the children in the home—he was under the influence of
marijuana and alcohol to such an extent that he could not walk
straight. Thus, whether or not Father had a substance abuse
“problem” by Father’s preferred definition of the term, or was
addicted to alcohol or marijuana, the connections between his use
of these substances and the behavior placing the children at risk
rendered it within the bounds of the court’s discretion to require
Father to participate in a program to address his use of those
substances.
Father’s reliance on In re Jasmine C. (2003) 106
Cal.App.4th 177, 179, for the proposition that a court may not
require a nonoffending parent to attend a parenting class when
11
there is no substantial evidence that the parent or the children
will benefit from such services is thus of no assistance to Father.
To the contrary, Jasmine C. underscores that a court can
properly order an offending parent (like Father) to participate
in a program when the evidence shows (as it does here) that the
parent would benefit from the program.
Finally, Father points out that completing a full
drug program with aftercare “placed unnecessary stress on
[F]ather” because “[F]ather worked long hours.” Although we
sympathize with the temporal difficulties an order for extensive
programming may impose on a parent, this is not a sufficient
basis for concluding that the court abused its discretion in
crafting Father’s case plan.
DISPOSITION
The orders are affirmed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.
ROTHSCHILD, P. J.
We concur:
BENDIX, J.
M. KIM, J.
12
Vous vous demandez comment ce texte s’applique à votre situation ?
Consultation gratuite, sans engagement
Décrivez votre situation. Notre équipe vous recontactera par e-mail pour votre consultation.
Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude
Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.