Shallbetter v. Nono CA2/8

CourtListener 10304139Calctapp24 déc. 2024

Texte intégral

Filed 12/24/24 Shallbetter v. Nono CA2/8
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION EIGHT

ALETHEA SHALLBETTER, B331998

Petitioner and Respondent, Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. 22PSRO02202
v.

GHASSAN NONO,

Respondent and Appellant.

B335372
GHASSAN NONO,
Los Angeles County
Petitioner and Appellant,
Super. Ct. No. 23STRO06116
v.

ALETHEA SHALLBETTER,

Respondent.
APPEAL from orders of the Superior Court of Los Angeles
County, Lisa R. Washington and Melissa C. Lyons, Judges.
Affirmed.
Ghassan Nono, in pro per., for Respondent and Appellant.
Kendall Gkikas & Mitchell and Brian Mitchell for
Petitioner and Respondent Alethea Shallbetter.
____________________
These two appeals arise from an ongoing dispute between
neighbors Ghassan Nono and Alethea Shallbetter. In B331998,
Nono appealed the trial court’s January 2023 order granting
Shallbetter’s request for a five-year civil harassment restraining
order against him. In B335372, Nono appealed the trial court’s
October 2023 order denying his request for a civil harassment
restraining order against Shallbetter. We consolidated the
appeals and we affirm. Statutory citations refer to the Code of
Civil Procedure.
I
The clash escalated after the dog kept barking.
A
In 2020, Nono and his elderly mother moved into the house
next to Shallbetter, a woman in her sixties who lived alone.
Initially, Nono and Shallbetter enjoyed a cordial relationship.
Then the parties sought civil harassment restraining orders
against each other.
Nono’s pets include a parrot, rescue cats, and a young dog
named Bobey. Nono described Bobey as “our main source of
emotional support in our home.”
According to Shallbetter, Bobey barked incessantly while
Nono was away for work. As a flight attendant, Nono could be
gone for days at a time. Shallbetter would notify Nono whenever

2
she heard Bobey barking, and he would thank her for letting him
know.
In June 2022, Shallbetter texted Nono that Bobey “has
been barking for [two and a half hours] . . . he’s punched out part
of the screen in front of your house because both front windows
are open! Please send someone over to help him since he is
totally stressed out and he could get out if he gets through that
window.”
This time, unlike before, Nono responded: “You keep
harassing me and my family about my animals….don’t ever text
here . . . .” Nono told Shallbetter to “fuck off.”
In July 2022, Shallbetter went to Nono’s home to ask if he
wanted any of her leftover lattice for his garden, as Nono had
previously asked her for this lattice via text message. Nono
declined the lattice and asked Shallbetter to leave him and his
family alone. He followed up with this text message: “Don’t ever
knock on my door again. We do not want you in [our] property at
all . . . .”
Shallbetter responded: “I do not know why you are so
angry with me for almost 2 months now when I was just trying to
help [Bobey] . . . .”
Nono wrote back: “I hate people who don’t tell the truth.
Bobey never barked for 3 hrs. I asked all the neighbors and all
said 30 minutes was the max and they were fine with it. You lied
and played dumb about it. . . am very upset that you lied . . . .”
He also accused Shallbetter of having “no morals” and again, told
her to “fuck off.”
Shallbetter continued to hear Bobey barking, but did not
contact Nono because he had asked her to leave him alone.

3
Instead, she contacted the animal control services agency about
Bobey’s barking.
A few months later, on November 15, 2022, Shallbetter was
talking with her pool contractor Clint Raina on speakerphone
while she was driving home. She arrived home at about 5:30
p.m., pulled into her driveway, and stayed in her car to continue
the conversation.
Nono, his mother, and a neighbor named Linda Zych were
in front of Nono’s home when Shallbetter arrived. When he saw
Shallbetter, Nono came to the passenger side window of
Shallbetter’s car. Shallbetter rolled down the window, and Nono,
a 175-pound man in his forties, began to yell at her and
repeatedly called her a “fucking bitch.” Nono demanded that
Shallbetter remove a potted palm tree from his property.
Shallbetter remained in her car because she was frightened by
Nono’s behavior. Nono then rotated the potted palm tree himself,
and returned to Shallbetter’s car, where he continued to scream
obscenities at her, including calling her a “fucking bitch” and a
“slut.”
Raina, who was still on speakerphone, could hear Nono
shouting at Shallbetter. Raina described the yelling as “just kind
of alarming, kind of vulgar.” Raina asked Shallbetter if she
wanted him to call the cops, but Shallbetter said no, she only
wanted him to stay on the phone with her. She told Raina that it
was her neighbor yelling at her. Raina was concerned for
Shallbetter’s safety because of Nono’s angry tone and words.
Raina heard Nono yelling at Shallbetter for about five minutes.
Zych and a few other neighbors approached Nono and tried
to calm him down. Zych told Nono to go inside his house, and
walked him to his door.

4
When she saw that Nono had gone inside his house,
Shallbetter left her car and went inside her house. By now,
Shallbetter was “shaking inside” and concerned for her personal
safety.
Two days later, Shallbetter filed a report of this incident
with the local police department. She also installed security
cameras on her property.
Shallbetter then filed a request for a civil harassment
restraining order. On the same day that Shallbetter filed the
request, the court granted her a temporary restraining order.
In January 2023, the court held a hearing on Shallbetter’s
request. Nono, Shallbetter, Zych, and Raina testified. The court
granted Shallbetter’s request and issued an order of protection
for Shallbetter for a five-year period. The court ordered that
Nono remain at least five yards from Shallbetter, her property,
her workplace, and her car.
B
In June 2023, Nono filed a notice of intent to move for a
new trial. He argued Shallbetter’s evidence was insufficient to
show “a knowing and willful course of conduct” that would “cause
a reasonable person to suffer substantial emotional distress” as
required by section 527.6, subsection (b). This evidence consisted
of hostile text messages in June and July 2022, and the
November 15, 2022 incident of Nono yelling at Shallbetter in her
driveway.
In July 2023, the court heard and denied Nono’s motion.
Citing Russell v. Douvan (2003) 112 Cal.App.4th 399, 400
(Russell) and Harris v. Stampolis (2016) 248 Cal.App.4th 484,
487 (Harris), the court ruled it was within its discretion to issue
the restraining order based on “a single act of unlawful violence

5
or a single credible threat of violence . . . where there is a
likelihood of recurrence.” The court found Nono’s conduct on
November 15, 2022—yelling, cursing, approaching Shallbetter’s
car multiple times, and moving her personal property—to
constitute a credible threat of violence that would place any
reasonable person in fear of their safety. The court observed
that, because Nono and Shallbetter were neighbors, there was a
likelihood of future harm.
The court said “it was a solid ruling. It will remain. And
the court is denying the request for a new trial as there is no
basis for a new trial.”
Nono filed his first notice of appeal.
C
In March 2023, Shallbetter parked her car by the sidewalk
in front of Nono’s house. Nono called the police department to
express his fear that Shallbetter had parked close to his home to
induce him to violate the restraining order. A police officer told
Nono he would speak to Shallbetter “in order to keep the peace
and sustain a civil agreement.”
Shallbetter told the police officer she had parked on the
street in front of Nono’s house because she had workers at her
property, who had parked in her driveway and in front of her
house. She agreed to avoid parking in front of Nono’s home
“where and when possible without sacrificing convenience.”
Then, on two occasions in September 2023, Shallbetter’s
pool workers parked in front of Nono’s driveway.
The first time, Nono claimed the workers’ truck blocked his
driveway, preventing him from leaving for work. When Nono
asked the workers to move the truck, the worker declined to do

6
so. Nono admitted, however, that he did not know if Shallbetter
had directed the workers to park the truck this way.
On the second occasion, the pool workers parked a large
truck in front of Nono’s driveway. Nono was not home at this
time, but his mother called him to tell him his sister was unable
to come into their home because of the truck. Nono believed
Shallbetter was trying to intimidate him, but admitted he did not
know whether Shallbetter had instructed the workers not to
move the truck and block his driveway.
Nono filed a request for a civil harassment restraining
order the day after the second occasion involving Shallbetter’s
construction workers. The court declined to issue a temporary
restraining order for Nono against Shallbetter, but set the
request for hearing in October 2023. After Nono testified, the
court found he did not sustain his burden of proof and denied his
request for a restraining order.
Nono filed his second notice of appeal.
II
We affirm across the board. Nono has not demonstrated
trial court error. (See Jameson v. Desta (2018) 5 Cal.5th 594,
608–609 (Jameson).)
As Shallbetter points out, Nono mostly failed to comply
with the basic rules of appellate procedure, which require that he
present argument with citations to applicable law and to
pertinent portions of the record. (Jameson, supra, at pp. 608–
609.) Self-represented litigants are bound to the same rules as
any other party appearing before us. (See L.O. v. Kilrain (2023)
96 Cal.App.5th 616, 620.)
We discern two cognizable arguments in Nono’s briefing.
The first is the contention the trial court erred in finding his

7
conduct towards Shallbetter justified granting Shallbetter’s
request for a restraining order. The second is that the trial court
erred in denying his request for a restraining order against
Shallbetter.
Nono’s first argument faults the trial court (1) for finding
his conduct constituted a “credible threat of violence” within the
meaning of section 527.6 and (2) for denying his motion for a new
trial. The second order is not separately appealable but is
subsumed in our review of the January 2023 order. (See
Quantum Cooking Concepts, Inc. v. LV Associates, Inc. (2011) 197
Cal.App.4th 927, 930, fn. 4.)
We deferentially review the trial court’s decision to grant a
restraining order under section 527.6 and will affirm if
substantial evidence supports this decision. (Harris, supra, 248
Cal.App.4th at p. 497.)
Substantial evidence supports the trial court’s finding that
Nono’s conduct amounted to a “credible threat of violence” under
section 527.6, subsection (b)(2). We defer to the trial court’s
finding that Shallbetter was a credible witness. (See
Conservatorship of O.B. (2020) 9 Cal.5th 989, 1011–1012.)
Shallbetter, corroborated by Zych, Raina, and Nono himself,
testified that Nono approached her and yelled vulgar insults at
her for several minutes. This is sufficient for a finding under
section 527.6, subsection (b)(2). (See Harris, 248 Cal.App.4th at
p. 498 [“there is sufficient evidence to conclude that Stampolis's
gestures and actions that day–such as placing his hands close to
Harris, raising his voice, pointing and gesturing, and walking
back and forth toward her–as a whole constituted a credible
threat of violence”].) Objectively, a woman in her sixties living
alone would reasonably entertain fear of a 175-pound man in his

8
forties who sent vulgar text messages, verbally assaulted her,
and physically approached her in a state of rage. The fact that
Nono and Shallbetter own homes next to each other supports the
court’s finding that Nono was likely to harass Shallbetter again
in the absence of a court order. (See Russell, supra, 112
Cal.App.4th at p. 404 [a court may find circumstances justify the
issuance of a restraining order even if there was only one
instance of unlawful violence].) We therefore affirm the court’s
decision to grant Shallbetter’s request and deny Nono’s motion.
Nono’s second argument attacks the trial court’s October
2023 order denying his request for a restraining order against
Shallbetter. The denial of a request for a restraining order under
section 527.6 turns on a failure of proof. (See § 527.6, subd. (i).)
When reviewing these orders, the question on appeal becomes
whether the evidence compels a finding in favor of the appellant
as a matter of law. (See, e.g., In re Luis H. (2017) 14 Cal.App.5th
1223, 1227.) Reversing this order would require us to find Nono’s
evidence to be “uncontroverted and unimpeached” and “of such a
character and weight as to leave no room for a judicial
determination that it was insufficient to support a finding.” (See
ibid.)
Nono’s evidence does not compel a finding in his favor. He
testified that Shallbetter parked in front of his home on one
occasion, and that her workers twice blocked his driveway for no
longer than a few hours. This conduct would not cause “a
reasonable person to suffer substantial emotional distress,” as
required by section 527.6. (See Schild v. Rubin (1991) 232
Cal.App.3d 755, 763 [“A reasonable person must expect to suffer
and submit to some inconveniences and annoyances from the

9
reasonable use of property by neighbors”].) The court did not err
in denying Nono’s request.
DISPOSITION
We affirm the trial court orders and award costs to
Shallbetter.

WILEY, J.
We concur:

STRATTON, P. J.

VIRAMONTES, J.

10

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.