People v. Olbert CA3

CourtListener 10294482Calctapp17 déc. 2024

Texte intégral

Filed 12/17/24 P. v. Olbert CA3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
THIRD APPELLATE DISTRICT
(Sacramento)
----

THE PEOPLE, C100375

Plaintiff and Respondent, (Super. Ct. No. 10F07539)

v.

ROBERT BRIAN OLBERT,

Defendant and Appellant.

In 2023, after defendant Robert Brian Olbert had served approximately 13 years of
his 20-year prison sentence, the Secretary of the Department of Corrections and
Rehabilitation (CDCR) sent a letter to the sentencing court recommending that the court
recall defendant’s sentence and resentence him. The sentencing court recalled
defendant’s sentence and reduced it to 19 years. The court declined to further reduce the

1
sentence by striking a five-year enhancement under Penal Code section 13851 because
the court found defendant posed a risk to public safety based on defendant violating
prison rules by attempting to bring a bottle of liquid soap back to his cell. The court
found, based on the court’s personal experience, that defendant could use the liquid soap
as a weapon.
We requested supplemental briefing addressing whether substantial evidence
supports the sentencing court’s finding that dismissing the five-year enhancement posed a
risk to public safety. The People argue that the sentencing court did not abuse its
discretion, but offer no evidentiary basis in the record for the court’s finding that
defendant could use a bottle of liquid soap as a weapon. The People do not assert that we
can consider the court’s personal experience as evidence, and we conclude we may not.
Finding no other evidence in the record to support this finding, we conclude that the
sentencing court abused its discretion by basing its decision on a finding unsupported by
substantial evidence. We will vacate defendant’s sentence and remand for resentencing.
The parties agree that the sentencing court should not have included certain
repealed fees as part of defendant’s sentence, so we will also direct the court not to
impose those fees on remand.
BACKGROUND
Defendant pleaded no contest to allegations that in 2010, he attempted a robbery
and then, in a second incident, committed a robbery using a knife, attempted an
additional robbery using a knife, unlawfully used personal identifying information,
unlawfully possessed access card information, possessed a completed check with the
intent to pass it fraudulently, and possessed stolen property. Defendant also admitted
having been previously convicted of robbery in 1992.

1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Penal Code.

2
In 2012, the sentencing court imposed a stipulated sentence of 25 years in state
prison. At the sentencing hearing, the court told defendant: “You make no excuse for
yourself. And that’s not something I see very often in this courtroom.” The court also
told defendant: “I think that you know methamphetamine and alcohol have been
absolutely devastating to you personally . . . but I also see that even while you’re
incarcerated, you are a positive influence on those around you . . . [a]nd I think that
speaks very, very well of you.”
In 2015, following the enactment of Proposition 47, the Safe Neighborhoods and
Schools Act (Gen. Elec. (Nov. 4, 2014), the sentencing court reduced defendant’s
sentence to 20 years in state prison. The sentence comprised: the upper term of five
years for robbery, doubled due to the prior serious felony conviction; a consecutive term
of one year four months for each count of attempted robbery; a consecutive term of one
year four months for unlawful use of personal identifying information; a one-year
enhancement for personal use of a dangerous or deadly weapon, pursuant to section
12022, subdivision (b)(1); and a five-year enhancement for the prior serious felony
conviction, pursuant to section 667, subdivision (a)(1).
In 2023, after defendant had served approximately 13 years of his sentence, the
Secretary of CDCR sent a letter to the sentencing court, recommending that the court
recall defendant’s sentence and resentence him. The Secretary indicated that the
Legislature had amended section 1385 to grant the sentencing court authority it had
previously lacked to strike the five-year enhancement for the prior serious felony
conviction. The Secretary included a report of defendant’s time in prison, which showed
consistent above-average grades from work supervisors since 2016; a number of
milestone completions, including job training and behavioral health programs;
completion of an Associate of Arts degree with nine A’s and seven B’s; and four rules
violation reports, with only one occurring since May 2014.

3
The report for defendant’s most recent rule violation in 2023 showed that a prison
official found defendant with a water bottle full of liquid cleaner attached to his waist.
Defendant admitted taking the bottle from the trash and pouring cleaner in it “ ‘to clean
our food area for the ‘Super Bowl’ game.’ ” Defendant called his decision “ ‘stupid’ ”
and apologized for his actions. The prison hearing official found defendant guilty of
possession of contraband, in violation of California Code of Regulations, title 15, section
3006, subdivision (c)(1), and imposed 20 hours of extra duty. The report indicated the
punishment was mitigated in the interest of justice. The report does not indicate concern
about defendant using the contraband as a weapon, nor did prison officials offer evidence
to that effect.
Based on the letter from the Secretary of CDCR, the sentencing court appointed
counsel for defendant and set a resentencing hearing. In briefing and at the hearing,
defense counsel argued the court should recall defendant’s sentence pursuant to section
1172.1, subdivision (a) and resentence defendant, dismissing the five-year enhancement
for the prior serious felony conviction and the one-year enhancement for using a
dangerous or deadly weapon. Defense counsel emphasized defendant’s excellent
behavior while incarcerated and argued that defendant had no intent to use the liquid soap
as a weapon.
The People agreed that the sentencing court should recall and resentence
defendant but asked the court to impose the same sentence. The People acknowledged
that under section 1385, subdivision (c)(2), the court must consider the age of defendant’s
prior serious felony conviction as a mitigating factor that weighs greatly in favor of
dismissing the five-year enhancement, unless the court found that dismissal of the
enhancement would endanger public safety. Nevertheless, the People contended the
court should impose the same 20-year sentence because “that term remains appropriate in
light of the applicable Judicial Council rules, traditional sentencing considerations and
new laws in effect today.”

4
At the first hearing, the sentencing court expressed concern about defendant’s
most recent rule violation, though the court was under the impression that defendant had
too many bars of soap and could use them as a weapon. The court explained: “I want to
be assured that [defendant] wasn’t doing something that would be considered being in
possession of a weapon, because I’ve been doing this job for 25 years and I think it’s very
well-known it is a ubiquitous thing in prisons that many times inmates will use what
appear to be innocuous items of everyday use, they can put them in socks and use them as
weapons, and because [defendant] is an individual who resorted to the use of weapons
during the course of his criminal activity, I am concerned about that.”
At the next hearing, when the sentencing court learned defendant only had liquid
soap, the court pivoted, explaining its new concern as: “I have been doing this job for 25
years, and before that, my entire career has been in the criminal justice system . . . I am
concerned about him being secretive, smuggling contraband out of a place that he was
working[,] and people thought he was doing a good job and they had trust and reliance on
him, and then I have to think to myself, is [defendant] an individual who continues to arm
himself and present a danger to the public? And obviously, we know in prison that
correctional officers get, for lack of a better term, gassed. They have fluids, liquids
thrown on them. Many times it is bodily fluids, but it can also be other liquids and fluids.
I have seen it run the gamut in my career.”
Defendant testified at the resentencing hearing, consistent with his testimony at the
rule violation hearing, that he intended to use the liquid soap to clean the floor of his cell
for a Super Bowl party because he and his cellmates would roll up their mattresses to
make room to cook burritos and they wanted to clean the area before they put their
mattresses back down to sleep. The court twice asked the People if they wanted to cross-
examine defendant, but they had no questions or concerns about the incident.
The sentencing court then found “that what [defendant] did, notwithstanding his
excuse and justification, that could have been used as a weapon. I am concerned for

5
public safety with respect to [defendant] because he keeps weapons in his waistband. We
know the best predictor of future behavior is past behavior, and I think an individual who
is so close to being paroled being found in possession of what he was found in possession
of is very disconcerting to me.” The court then expressed concern that “my sentences
appear to me to be mere suggestions to the Department of Corrections and
Rehabilitation” because CDCR gives prisoners credit for time served, before reiterating,
“I’ll make the finding that I believe he poses a risk to public safety because he is hiding
again in his waistband something that could be used as a weapon.”
DISCUSSION
Defendant contends, both in his initial briefing and in his supplemental brief that
the sentencing court erred under section 1172.1, subdivision (b)(2) because substantial
evidence does not support the court’s finding that defendant posed a danger to public
safety, on which the court based its decision not to dismiss the five-year enhancement.
Defendant focuses on the wrong statute. Section 1172.1, subdivision (b)(2) governs the
court’s decision to recall and resentence defendant, not the court’s decision to dismiss the
enhancement.
The People address the correct statute, section 1385, which governs the court’s
discretion to dismiss an enhancement. The People argue in supplemental briefing that the
sentencing court did not abuse its discretion, but offer no evidentiary basis for the court’s
determination that defendant could use a bottle of liquid soap as a weapon. Nor do the
People contend we can rely on the sentencing court’s personal experience as evidence.
When reviewing for abuse of discretion, “we ask whether the trial court’s findings
of fact are supported by substantial evidence, whether its rulings of law are correct, and
whether its application of the law to the facts was neither arbitrary nor capricious.”
(People v. Superior Court (Humberto S.) (2008) 43 Cal.4th 737, 746.) “[W]e must view
the evidence in the light most favorable to the People and must presume in support of the
judgment the existence of every fact the trier could reasonably deduce from the

6
evidence.” (People v. Jones (1990) 51 Cal.3d 294, 314.) “[W]e must ensure the
evidence is reasonable, credible, and of solid value.” (Ibid.)
“[A] court’s personal experience is not evidence.” (Abatti v. Imperial Irrigation
Dist. (2020) 52 Cal.App.5th 236, 286; see Evid. Code, § 140.) The sentencing court was
not competent to testify as to whether defendant could have used the liquid soap as a
weapon, was not under oath, and was not subject to cross-examination. (Evid. Code,
§§ 703, 710-711, 720.) Nor could the court take judicial notice of its personal
experiences unless they “are of such common knowledge within the territorial
jurisdiction of the court that they cannot reasonably be the subject of dispute.” (Evid.
Code, §§ 450, 452, subd. (g).) To the extent the court considered defendant could use the
liquid soap in the way bodily fluids or feces are used to “gas” correctional officers, we
see no evidentiary basis for the analogy. Bodily fluids and feces are perhaps commonly
known to cause illness or infection, but, if anything, the opposite is true of liquid soap.
Aside from the sentencing court’s personal experience, we see no evidence in the
record to support the finding that defendant could use the bottle of liquid soap as a
weapon. The disciplinary hearing records do not indicate concern about the liquid soap
being used as a weapon or any potential harmful effects on correctional officers.
Defendant was charged with possessing contraband (Cal. Code Regs., tit. 15, § 3006,
subd. (c)(1)), not possessing dangerous property (Cal. Code Regs., tit. 15, § 3006, subd.
(a)). Defendant testified that he was just going to clean his cell in connection with a
party, which was consistent with the evidence introduced at the disciplinary hearing. The
People introduced no evidence at the hearing and elected not to cross-examine defendant.
Because the sentencing court declined to dismiss the five-year enhancement based
on its finding that defendant could use the liquid soap as a weapon, we conclude the court
abused its discretion by basing its decision on a finding unsupported by substantial
evidence. We will vacate defendant’s sentence and remand for resentencing.

7
We also note that the parties agree that the sentencing court should not have
imposed the main jail booking fee of $287 or the main jail classification fee of $59
because the Legislature repealed these fees. (Assembly Bill No. 1869 (2019-2020 Reg.
Sess), (Stats. 2020, ch. 92, § 25); Gov. Code, § 6111.) On remand, the court should not
impose those fees.
DISPOSITION
Defendant’s sentence is vacated, and the case is remanded for resentencing
consistent with this opinion.

\s\ ,
Krause, J.

We concur:

\s\ ,
Robie, Acting P. J.

\s\ ,
Feinberg, J.

8

Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude

Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.