CourtListener 10291322•People v. Duran CA5
Texte intégral
Filed 12/10/24 P. v. Duran CA5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIFTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
THE PEOPLE,
F086881
Plaintiff and Respondent,
(Super. Ct. No. CR-20-007470)
v.
ALBERTO VELO DURAN, OPINION
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of Stanislaus County. Shawn D.
Bessey, Judge.
Martin Baker for Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief Assistant Attorney
General, Michael P. Farrell, Assistant Attorney General, Christopher J. Rench, and
Jessica A. Eros, Deputy Attorneys General, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
-ooOoo-
Alberto Velo Duran was convicted of multiple counts of sexual abuse of his
daughters that lasted for several years. The trial court sentenced him to 85 years to life.
On appeal, Duran contends a pretext call with his daughters was involuntary and
inadmissible due to coercion and promises of leniency. We reject this contention. Duran
further argues his confession during his interview with law enforcement was poisonous
“fruit” traceable back to the pretext call and improperly admitted. We also reject this
argument and affirm.
PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
On April 3, 2023, the Stanislaus County District Attorney filed an amended
information charging Duran with continuous sexual abuse of a child under 14, Jane
Doe 11 (Pen. Code, § 288.5, subd. (a); count 1);2 continuous sexual abuse of a child
under 14, Jane Doe 2 (§ 288.5, subd. (a); count 2); oral copulation or sexual penetration
of a child 10 or under, Jane Doe 1 (§ 288.7, subd. (b); count 3); sodomy of Jane Doe 1
(§ 286, subd. (c)(1); count 4); sexual acts with a child 10 or under, Jane Doe 2 (§ 288.7,
subd. (a); count 5); and oral copulation or sexual penetration of a child 10 or under,
Jane Doe 2 (§ 288.7, subd. (b); count 6). As to counts 1 and 2, the information further
alleged a multiple victim enhancement (§ 667.61, subds. (b), (e)(4)).
On March 30, 2023, Duran filed a motion to exclude a pretext phone call he had
with Jane Does 1 and 2 regarding the sexual abuse. After a hearing held on April 5,
2023, the trial court denied Duran’s motion.
On April 12, 2023, a jury convicted Duran as charged. The jury further found the
enhancements true as to counts 1 and 2.
On September 11, 2023, the trial court sentenced Duran to 85 years to life as
follows: four consecutive terms of 15 years to life on counts 1 through 3 and count 6,
plus a consecutive 25 years to life on count 5, plus an aggregate six years (the middle
term) on count 4 to run concurrently to the other terms.
1 The amended information refers to the victims as Confidential Victim #1 and
Confidential Victim #2; we will refer to them as Jane Doe 1 and Jane Doe 2.
2 All further undesignated statutory references are to the Penal Code unless
otherwise stated.
2.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
A. Sexual Assaults to Jane Doe 1
Jane Doe 1 was born on December 27, 1999. Jane Doe 1 is the older sister of Jane
Doe 2; Duran is their father. He first sexually assaulted Jane Doe 1 when she was six
years old. At that time, Jane Doe 1 went into her parents’ room at night because she was
afraid. She got into bed with her mother and father and laid next to her father. Jane
Doe 1’s back was towards Duran; there was no one on the other side of her. He began
touching her arms, then his hands traveled down her body and rubbed her vagina and
breasts. His hand did not go inside Jane Doe 1’s vagina at that time. While doing this,
Duran told Jane Doe 1, “It [is] okay, I [will] protect you.” She told him to “get off.”
While Jane Doe 1 was between the ages of six and 10 years old, Duran sexually
abused her once every six months. During these times, he would touch her vagina and
breasts, and sometimes he would put his fingers inside her vagina. When Jane Doe 1 was
11 years old, Duran began touching her breasts and vagina about once every month or
two months.
When Jane Doe 1 was 12 years old, she was home sick from school and Duran
stayed home with her; they were the only ones home. Duran offered to “massage” Jane
Doe 1 because he told her it would make her “feel better.” He began massaging her in
her parents’ bedroom on the bed. She laid on her stomach and Duran was on top of her.
After a few seconds of massaging, Duran then wrapped his arms around under her body
and started touching her vagina, breasts, and “butt.” Then, he took off Doe 1’s pants,
pulled down his own pants, and touched her “butt” with his penis. When Duran put his
penis inside her “butt,” she started crying because it hurt. He stopped after she said it
hurt, and he said, “I [am] sorry.”
While Jane Doe 1 was between the ages of 12 and 20, Duran inserted his penis
into her vagina about once or twice a year. Every time he sexually abused her, he told
her not to tell anyone. She was afraid to tell anyone. She did not think her mother would
3.
believe her. When she was about 14 years old, she mentioned the sexual abuse to Jane
Doe 2. Years later, Jane Doe 1 eventually told her boyfriend about the sexual abuse, and
then the police.
B. Sexual Assaults to Jane Doe 2
Jane Doe 2 was born on May 5, 2001. The first sexual encounter with Duran
happened when she was eight years old. She was asleep in her bedroom and awoke to
Duran behind her in the bed. He asked her if she was scared and she told him “no.” But
he said, “I [am] going to hug you anyway.” He laid down behind her and began to hug
her under the covers. He brought her closer to him so that her “butt” was touching his
penis. He put his hands in the front of her pajamas and rubbed her vagina. She tried to
push him away but he continued to rub her vagina for about two minutes.
Another time, when Jane Doe 2 was still eight years old, she and Duran were
alone on the couch in the living room. He put his penis in her vagina for about five
minutes.
When she was about ten or eleven years old, she got out of school early one day
because she got mud on her pants and took a shower. Duran entered her room after she
got out of the shower and was still in a towel. He asked her if she needed any help.
Then, he took off her towel and pressed Jane Doe 2 against her bed. He pulled his pants
down and inserted his penis into her “butt.” He pressed his hands against her back and
put her face into a pillow. She was unable to breathe.
While Jane Doe 2 was between the ages of 11 and 13, Duran sexually abused her
at least once a year. The last time Duran sexually abused her was when she was 13 years
old. He got on top of her and inserted his penis into her vagina. She did not tell anyone
about the sexual assaults because she did not think anyone would believe her and she was
embarrassed her father would do those things to her. She was about 19 years old when
she reported the sexual abuse to the police.
4.
C. The Pretext Call
Jane Does 1 and 2 agreed to place a pretext call to Duran. Detectives Brandon
Bertram and Paul Inderbitzen were present at the police department with Jane Does 1 and
2 during the call.
The pretext call began with Jane Doe 1 asking Duran whether he had sexually
abused their youngest sister. Duran denied abusing her. He also denied having sex or
inappropriately touching Jane Does 1 and 2. He told them he did not want to discuss this
over the phone and asked if they were alone or if the call was being recorded. Jane Doe 1
said, “[I]f you tell me the truth … I [will not] say anything, but if you do [not], I [am]
[going to] go to the cops.” Duran replied, “Okay?”
Duran continued to ask where Jane Doe 1 was located. She said that she was in
the car with Jane Doe 2 alone. Jane Doe 1 asked, “But did you do it to us?” Duran said,
“Well .…”
Jane Doe 1 asked, “[D]id you put your penis in mine[?]” Duran admitted he had
put his penis in both of their “butts” and engaged in sexual intercourse with Jane Does 1
and 2 multiple times. Jane Doe 1 asked Duran why he put his penis in their “butts” when
they were six and eight years old. He said, “Because I [am] an ass, I [am] a dumb
person.” He admitted that he had sex with them when they “let” him. He said he touched
Jane Does 1 and 2 “everywhere” and again confirmed he had sex with Jane Doe 1 “a lot
of times.”
Jane Doe 2 said that she was still in elementary school when Duran had sex with
her and put his penis in her “butt.” After some back and forth Duran said, “you know it, I
[am] sorry. I [am] a bad person.” He denied that he had sex with them while they were
asleep. He said, “You would ask me to massage you and I would just massage you. And
then it just kept going.” He told them that he was sorry for having sex with them.
Jane Doe 2 asked Duran if he was going to tell their mother. He said, “Whatever
you guys want to do.” He also said, “If you guys [want to] report me, it [is] fine.” Jane
5.
Doe 1 asked, “[I]f we tell the cops, are you [going to] tell the cops that you did it?”
Duran replied, “[I]f you guys are going to, yeah, I have to. I have to go to jail.”
D. Bertram’s Interview with Duran
Later that day, Bertram met Duran in front of his house and informed him he
needed to speak with him at the police department. Duran said he had a small idea of
what Bertram wanted to talk about.
A recording of the interview begins with Duran providing identifying information.
He was read his Miranda3 rights; he said he understood them and wanted to talk to law
enforcement. Duran told Bertram the girls would “lay down” next to him and he would
comfort and massage them. He initially only massaged their backs but then it started to
get “out [of] hand .…” Duran admitted to touching them “inappropriately.” During the
massages, he typically sat on top of the girls and straddled them like a saddle on a horse.
He said that he touched Jane Does 1 and 2’s “butts”, breasts, vaginas, and “private parts.”
Duran started having sexual intercourse with Jane Doe 1 when she was about eight
or nine years old, about once or twice a month, until she was about 17 years old.4 He
denied putting his penis in Jane Doe 1’s “butt.” He said he would begin by rubbing Jane
Doe 1’s back. Then, he moved to her “butt”, breasts, and vagina. Once Jane Doe 1
started moving a little bit, he became aroused and would have sexual intercourse with
her. The intercourse would last about five minutes each time because he would realize it
was wrong and stop. However, after a few weeks, he would do it again.
Duran told Bertram that when Jane Doe 1 was around 12 years old, she stayed
home from school because she was sick. His wife was at work, and no one else was
home. He wanted to comfort her because she was sick, so he began to massage her
3 Miranda v. Arizona (1966) 384 U.S. 436.
4 Later, Duran admitted having sexual intercourse with Jane Doe 1 until she was
19 years old.
6.
stomach. She moved and Duran said he “started to … feel good.” Duran said he
“maybe” tried to put his penis in her “butt” but Jane Doe 1 told him it was hurting her, so
he stopped.
Duran said he began touching Jane Doe 2 when she was around eight or nine years
old. He kissed her on the neck and tried to kiss her on the lips. He said he inserted his
penis into her vagina about 10 or 15 times. He claimed he did not remember putting his
penis inside Jane Doe 2’s “butt.” He stopped having sex with her when she was 13 years
old because she made him nervous by wanting to tell her mother.
Duran claimed Jane Doe 1 wanted to have sex with him when she had been about
13 years old. He said she moved “her buttocks against [his] penis to get [him] aroused.”
However, he then said he did not believe she would have been aroused by him. Duran
knew his daughters had not been old enough to give consent for him to have sex with
them. Bertram said, you “raped” your two children “[t]heir whole lives.” Duran
responded, “Yeah. There [is] not a way to describe it.”
E. Duran’s Testimony
Duran denied all allegations against him at trial. He testified about the pretext call
with Jane Does 1 and 2. He was unaware that the call was being recorded. He said he
changed his answers to their questions during the pretext call after Jane Doe 1 said she
would call the police if he did not tell the truth.
Duran also testified about the interview with Bertram. He claimed he admitted the
sexual assaults because he was scared. During his interview, Bertram never threatened
Duran or made any promises of leniency. Duran continued to talk to Bertram even after
Bertram told him he was going to jail. He also testified he chose to talk to Bertram after
being read his Miranda rights and felt comfortable denying certain allegations he did not
believe were true.
7.
DISCUSSION
I. The Court did not Err in Admitting the Pretext Call
Duran contends the court erred in failing to exclude the pretext call with Jane
Does 1 and 2. He further claims that since the pretext call should have been excluded, his
interview with Bertram is the unlawful “fruit” of the poisonous tree, and the admission of
both prejudiced his case. The People maintain Jane Does 1 and 2 were not acting as
agents of law enforcement and therefore it is irrelevant that they engaged in tactics that
may have been interpreted by Duran as coercive. The People further contend that Duran
waived his argument by conceding his interview with Bertram was admissible, and, even
reaching the merits, the interview was voluntary, and Duran suffered no prejudice. We
agree with the People.
A. Additional Background
a. The Pretext Call
Bertram and Inderbitzen spoke with Jane Does 1 and 2 about doing a pretext call
before it occurred. Bertram discussed tactics, such as trying to elicit a response from
Duran by telling him they were concerned for the safety of their youngest sister.
Inderbitzen told Jane Does 1 and 2 to make sure Duran knew they were alone so he
would feel comfortable talking to them about the allegations.
Bertram wrote notes to Jane Does 1 and 2 during the call. Inderbitzen told the
girls that if they “stall out” or get “nervous” to tell Duran that they will “call [him] right
back” and hang up the phone so that another “game plan” could be reached. Bertram and
Inderbitzen did not provide Jane Does 1 and 2 with a script. Bertram told them it was
important to act “normal” on the phone. To that end, Bertram said, “[Y]ou [are] [going
to] cry … [if you] [c]ry. You [are] [going to] cuss if you cuss … [b]e normal. Okay?”
8.
b. Defense Counsel and the Prosecutor’s Arguments
Before trial, Duran sought to exclude the pretext call with Jane Does 1 and 2. The
prosecution countered and moved to admit the evidence as an admissible statement of a
party opponent.
Defense counsel argued Duran’s statements in the pretext call were coerced. The
defense claimed that Jane Doe 1 threatened Duran when she told him, “ ‘[I]f you tell me
the truth, I will [not] say anything. If you do [not], I [am] going to go to the cops.’ ”
Also, Jane Doe 1 promised leniency when she told Duran, “ ‘It was wrong, but we
forgive you.’ ” Defense counsel further argued Jane Does 1 and 2 acted as agents of the
state during the pretext call because (1) they were at the police station; (2) Bertram
suggested the call to get Duran to admit the allegations, he told them what to say, and
directed the conversation with handwritten notes; and (3) the call was recorded.
The prosecution noted Duran was not under arrest or detained during the pretext
call and had no expectation of privacy. The prosecutor further argued that it would be
unreasonable to believe Jane Does 1 and 2 had the authority to offer leniency.
c. The Trial Court’s Ruling
The trial court denied Duran’s motion to exclude the pretext call. The court
reasoned:
“[W]hat we have here are two daughters talking to a father on a
phone. [Duran] is not in custody. He [is] nowhere on the premises. He is
not in handcuffs. He does [not] have police surrounding him. He has the
ability to hang up or not say anything and those are all circumstances that
would lean toward [a finding] that it [is] not coercion.
“And … [there is] not … a police officer talking to [Duran] and
making any claims of leniency in an official capacity, so that would not be
official coercion there.
“And then … [there is] not … any law enforcement threats .…
“[I]t was … Jane Doe [1] saying that if you do [not] tell us, we [are]
going to go to the cops … [I]s that designed to elicit a response[?] The
9.
answer is absolutely yes. But during this whole process … Jane Doe [1]
and … Jane Doe [2] are sometimes following directives and sometimes ad
libbing, so it [is] like a free-flowing conversation.
“So you can[not] really say … all questions and every statement is
attributed to law enforcement, [and] you have to be law enforcement that is
doing the threats, and … doing the promise for leniency. But that could be
done … [in] circumstances where … [it] is done through a police agent, but
in this case I do [not] think what … Jane Doe [1] specifically is saying is
attributed to … law enforcement. It does [not] appear to me that everything
said was directly related to police questioning. It was just the flow of the
conversation.
“These [girls] are not trained personnel. They are not trained in
interrogation. [The questions were] clearly … untrained persons asking
questions. And there [is] a lot of that in that conversation .…
“[Duran] is not in custody. He [is] free to leave. He [is] free to
terminate that call. He is not in a situation where he is surrounded by law
enforcement, detained in any way. And in no sense are the threats, I [am]
going to go to the police, especially when you take the whole conversation
… [Duran says] I do [not] care if you go to the police … it [is] … a flow of
conversation that is not perfect in any sense of the imagination related to
interrogation, but it [is] two young individuals talking to their dad, trying to
elicit a response no doubt. And they did.
“[I]t was give and take throughout the conversation. And I do [not]
find as a totality of the circumstances that was coercive in the sense that
[Duran] was not responding of his own free will .…
“And in that sense it [is] reliable … [given] the totality of the
circumstances, the request to keep this out or suppress that statement in any
way is denied.”
Further, the court ruled that Duran’s interview with law enforcement was
admissible as an admission of a party opponent. Defense counsel conceded the interview
was admissible. The court also noted Duran decided to discuss the allegations with
Bertram after he was given Miranda warnings.
B. Law
The due process clause of the Fourteenth Amendment prohibits the admission of
an involuntary confession by coercion. (People v. Neal (2003) 31 Cal.4th 63, 79.) “To
10.
determine the voluntariness of a confession, courts examine ‘ “whether a defendant’s will
was overborne’ by the circumstances surrounding the giving of a confession.” [Citation.]
In making this determination, courts apply a ‘totality of the circumstances’ test, looking
at the nature of the interrogation and the circumstances relating to the particular
defendant.” (People v. Dykes (2009) 46 Cal.4th 731, 752 (Dykes).) The due process
clause is a restriction on the state. (U.S. Const., 14th Amend. [“No State shall make or
enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United
States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due
process of law .…”].) Thus, “[t]he most outrageous behavior by a private party seeking
to secure evidence against a defendant does not make that evidence inadmissible under
the [d]ue [p]rocess [c]lause .…” absent state coercion. (Colorado v. Connelly (1986)
479 U.S. 157, 166 (Connelly); accord People v. Whitt (1984) 36 Cal.3d 724, 745 (Whitt)
[“ ‘[a]bsent evidence of complicity on the part of law enforcement officials, the
admissions or statements of a defendant to a private citizen infringe no constitutional
guarantees’ ”].)
We independently review the trial court’s legal conclusion as to the voluntariness
of Duran’s statement during the pretext call. (Dykes, supra, 46 Cal.4th at p. 751.) The
court’s factual findings, credibility determinations, and circumstances surrounding the
confession are upheld if supported by substantial evidence. (Ibid.)
C. Analysis
a. Admission of the Pretext Call
The trial court determined Jane Does 1 and 2 were not acting as agents of law
enforcement. The court further found not everything Jane Does 1 and 2 said was
attributable to law enforcement but improvised from a “free-flowing conversation.” The
court also found the things that Jane Does 1 and 2 did say were not coercive given the
totality of the circumstances.
11.
The court’s factual findings were supported by substantial evidence. The record
before us does not show that Bertram or Inderbitzen told Jane Does 1 and 2 to threaten
Duran. Similarly, there is no evidence that the detectives told Jane Does 1 and 2 to offer
leniency to Duran in exchange for information. There is no evidence of a script.5 In fact,
before the call Bertram encouraged Jane Does 1 and 2 to act “normal” and do what they
would normally do in a situation in which they were discussing the sexual abuse with
their father. The court also rightly pointed out that the Does questioning showed they
were unskilled and untrained. The questions the girls asked Duran were not entirely
straightforward or formulaic, but from two daughters who were trying to elicit a response
from their father.
Duran fails to offer contrary evidence. Instead, he argues that Jane Does 1 and 2
acted as agents of law enforcement because they performed under law enforcement’s
direction and supervision. He cites Raymond v. Superior Court (1971) 19 Cal.App.3d
321, 326 (Raymond) for the proposition that a private citizen can act as an agent of law
enforcement when police participation in the private citizen’s action is “obvious, heavy,
and undebatable.” There, the Third District considered the extent of police involvement
when a 12-year-old boy took a sample of drugs from his father’s bedroom and provided it
to law enforcement. (Id. at pp. 325–326.) The court held that even though the boy seized
the contraband, law enforcement determined the timing, location, supplied transportation,
described quantity needed, waited for the purloined drugs, and then made it a basis for a
search warrant. (Id. at p. 326.) In those circumstances, the court held that the level of
involvement by law enforcement was significant, which made the 12-year-old boy an
agent of law enforcement and subject to the same constitutional demands. (Ibid.)
5 While there is evidence Bertram wrote “notes” to the girls during the call, there
is no evidence that the girls specifically followed what was on the notes. There is also no
evidence that the notes from law enforcement told the girls what to say, or to threaten or
offer leniency to Duran.
12.
Other cases have also found an agency relationship when the private actor was
acting under instructions and at the direction of the government and the defendant was in
custody and engaged in conversation by a paid government informant acting under the
direction of law enforcement. (U.S. v. Henry (1980) 447 U.S. 264, 270.) Our Supreme
Court held that “[t]he critical inquiry is whether the state has created a situation likely to
provide it with incriminating statements from an accused.” (Whitt, supra, 36 Cal.3d at
p. 742.)
We are not persuaded by the cases which found an agency relationship between a
private actor and law enforcement. Here, Bertram and Inderbitzen did not instruct Jane
Does 1 and 2 specifically what to say or do. As set forth above, Does 1 and 2 were told
to act “normal”, and law enforcement did not tell the girls to threaten Duran or offer him
a promise of leniency. Unlike Raymond, supra, 19 Cal.App.3d at page 326, where law
enforcement controlled and directed nearly every condition, here, law enforcement only
provided guidance and support. There was no further “ ‘state action’ ” to support a
Fourteenth Amendment constitutional violation. (See, Connelly, supra, 479 U.S. at
p. 165.) On these facts it cannot be held that law enforcement had such a high level of
involvement or direction to hold Jane Does 1 and 2 in an agency relationship with them.
Duran further contends Jane Does 1 and 2 coerced the statements by promising
that they would not report him to the police if he explained the details of his sexual
interactions with them. He cites People v. Shelton (1957) 151 Cal.App.2d 587, 588 to
support his claim that when a police officer makes a promise that he will not arrest an
individual to induce a confession, and the individual confesses, the confession is
involuntary.
Duran’s claim fails because the alleged promises or threats Jane Does 1 and 2
made were not at the direction of law enforcement and they were not acting as agents of
law enforcement. Consequently, it is irrelevant whether Jane Does 1 and 2, both private
citizens, engaged in tactics that, if they had been done by a police officer, would have
13.
been impermissibly coercive under the due process clause. (See Connelly, supra,
479 U.S. at p. 166; c.f. People v. Benson (1990) 52 Cal.3d 754, 778–779 [an involuntary
confession is obtained when there is coercion or coercive activity on the part of the state
or its agents and such activity is the proximate cause of the statement in question, and not
merely a cause in fact].)
Duran has failed to show the trial court erred in determining the evidence did not
violate the due process clause.
b. Admission of Bertram’s Interview with Duran
Because we find the pretext call was properly admitted, we also reject Duran’s
claim that the trial court improperly admitted evidence traceable back to the pretext call
as “fruit of the poisonous tree.” (People v. Mickey (1991) 54 Cal.3d 612, 652 [“[b]ecause
the tree was not poisonous, its fruit was not tainted”].)6 Therefore, Duran’s subsequent
interview with law enforcement is also admissible.
c. Harmless Error
We evaluate error of a coerced confession under the federal constitutional standard
and determine whether admission was harmless beyond a reasonable doubt. (People v.
Cahill (1993) 5 Cal.4th 478, 510; Chapman v. California (1967) 386 U.S. 18, 23.) Even
if we concluded the trial court erred in admitting the pretext call and Duran’s interview
with law enforcement, any error was harmless.
Here, the evidence of Duran’s guilt is overwhelming. Jane Does 1 and 2’s crucial
testimony regarding the sexual abuse they underwent at the hands of their father is strong.
Jane Doe 1 testified Duran started sexually abusing her when she was about six years old
6 We note Duran did not object to the admission of the interview with Bertram in
the trial court as required by Evidence Code section 353, subdivision (a). Defense
counsel acknowledged the interview was admissible. (People v. Partida (2005)
37 Cal.4th 428, 434 [“ ‘the “defendant’s failure to make a timely and specific objection”
on the ground asserted on appeal makes that ground not cognizable’ ”].)
14.
and it lasted until she was about 20 years old. Jane Doe 2 testified the sexual abuse
began when she was eight, and lasted until she was 13 years old. Jane Does 1 and 2
testified to different specific instances, provided detailed accounts of the parts of the body
Duran touched, and gave the approximate number of times the sexual abuse occurred per
year. They also provided testimony of Duran putting his penis in their “butts” and
vaginas on different occasions. This testimony alone is sufficient to sustain Duran’s
convictions. (People v. Jones (1990) 51 Cal.3d 294, 314 [in a child molestation case,
nonspecific or generic testimony from a victim—e.g., an act of intercourse “once a month
for three years”—outlines a series of specific, albeit undifferentiated, incidents each of
which amounts to a separate offense, and each of which may be sufficiently substantial to
sustain a separate criminal conviction]; People v. Harlan (1990) 222 Cal.App.3d 439,
451–452 [uncorroborated testimony of a child victim may be considered substantial
evidence to support a conviction of child molestation].) The jury was also properly
instructed with the standard instruction regarding the testimony of a single witness, which
is sufficient to prove a fact. (CALCRIM 301; People v. Rincon-Pineda (1975) 14 Cal.3d
864, 884–885.)
Duran’s interview with law enforcement and confession obtained during the
pretext call was cumulative to the testimony provided by Jane Does 1 and 2. The jury
may have considered Duran’s extrajudicial statements regarding the sexual abuse of his
two daughters, but the jury was also able to consider the same evidence in greater detail
through the testimony of Jane Does 1 and 2. (See, People v. Cunningham (2001)
25 Cal.4th 926, 994 [if the defendant’s statements are cumulative to the other evidence
properly obtained, a reviewing court may find the error harmless beyond a reasonable
doubt].)
Further, Duran relied on the statements he made during the pretext call to support
his defense. Defense counsel relied on Duran’s denials regarding the sexual abuse during
the pretext call to show he was not guilty of the charged crimes. (See People v. Steskal
15.
(2021) 11 Cal.5th 332, 372–373 [any error in admitting challenged evidence was
harmless in part because defendant relied on that evidence to show he was not
dangerous].)
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.
FAIN, J.*
WE CONCUR:
HILL, P. J.
SNAUFFER, J.
* Judge of the Fresno Superior Court, assigned by the Chief Justice pursuant to
article VI, section 6 of the California Constitution.
16.
Vous vous demandez comment ce texte s’applique à votre situation ?
Consultation gratuite, sans engagement
Décrivez votre situation. Notre équipe vous recontactera par e-mail pour votre consultation.
Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude
Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.